Sanjeev Sanyals erudition in ahistory of Bharath is so inspiring. I felt I am in my school(literally so). I am sharing with people who are in yhe same wavelength. I have down loaded to listen this with more Pride.
Instead of funding Harvard, Indian billionaires should consider supporting Indian scholars willing to translate original Indic works written on palm leaves in Sanskrit and never translated. As mentioned by Sanjiv Sanyal at end of video. What a way to obtain immortality for everyone involved!
Thwre is a non profit organisation in bengaluru named TARA PRAKASHANA that has the expertise in translating and preserving ancient palm leaves. The founder trustee, is Prif. P.R. MUKUND, Ph. D, professor emeritus at the Rochester Institute of Ttexhnology.
Alternatively, provide tax concession only to funds provided to Indian universities and research institutions, but tax funds sent to foreign universities. That should fix serious problems!
The best thing about this discussion is you are actually interested to listen to Sanyal ji. In this process you ask pertinent questions. Great discussion!
Transcribing manuscripts is the best call and hopefully new scientific interventions can come from that and India will regain its glory of knowledge light house. Hats off Sanjeevji
41:30 in fact, the phrase “the enemy of my enemy…” is attributed to Kautilya. It is from his theory of the Rajamandala in Sanskrit that the phrase travelled to become ‘amicus meus, inimicus inimici mei’ in Latin and then its modern English form in the 19th Century.
Its often the commentary of original text gets mis construed. Todays india is of a generation getting out of colonolial thinking. The future is definetly promising. But i think in this podcast its a good opportunity to understand (a) principle of any philosophy (b) the context in which the commentary (c ) the delta of time construct and relevance. Thank you for such a simple conversation and enticing podcast.
राजा का काम प्रजा का भरण पोषण करना होता है, इसीलिए जिन्हें सब राजाओं से बड़ा राजा माना गया है, वो खुद भगवान विष्णु हैं, जो स्वयम सुदर्शन चक्र धारण करते हैं। और पुराण ये बतातें हैं कि विष्णु को ये चक्र स्वयं भगवान महादेव से मिला था। इसीलिए प्राचीन भारत मे जितने भी महानतम चक्रवर्ती सम्राट हुए जिनमे राजा राम चन्द्र जी भी थे, वे सभी महान शिवभक्त थे।
Sanjivji, your explanation of Aśoka’s “greatness” seems very very logical. I also feel that Asoka was made great because, he denounced Santana Dharma and embraced Buddhism! So, excellent armor to beat down Santana Dharma
Also because of the Buddhist concept of Ahimsa which the British ascribed to Ashoka. As a result of this we've had to give up our territories 70 years ago. Historically though, none of the Buddhist, Jain or Ajivaka kings practiced ahimsa. It was meant only for the Bhikshu.
I really don't understand why Chanakya's Arthashastra is not included in the syllabus of Economics in UG and PG course. We study about Adam Smith, Keynes, etc.
@@pks2552 you just proved the point that he was labeled as great to divide the society. Anyway ...... continue blaming brahmins for everything u don't have or u can't do.
@@pks2552what Brahmins I am a OBC,Ashoka did not look far enough he somehow took Buddhism and it let to to some extent him diluting the army for ahims,but never considered ahimsa will come from outside.
So to conclude - " Ashoka the great" is as much as a hoax as " akbar the great" - both carefully minted constructs by motivated Leftist historians to suit their own socio-political ideology .
Hey Prakhar "I am currently in the states right now. It’s a great delight to watch your podcast, but just a request: if you are reading the comments, please bring some PhD professors in Sanskrit or experts who can elaborate on the matter regarding manuscripts yet to be translated. I believe it will spread awareness among a large section of society who will step up and we may uncover some lost knowledge or lost parts of history from those manuscripts.
Modis greatness is proper delegation of work responsibilities to his cabinet ministers. Sanyalji is one among them and is very close to Modi. He is so young and knows our history in detail and hence we can be rest assured that under NDA new amendments in our Constitution, laws etc will be in line with our past great philosophers and think tanks.
It's an absolute delight to listen to Sanjeev Sanyal sir talk about History..looking forward to more such conversations ... Thank you for this one ...😊😊
Lakhs of manuscripts.....left behind to be discovered and reawaken the glory of our cultural learning just sitting there to be discovered by our generations to come. What a fascinating call for people interested in doing such work. Can't wait to hold original manuscripts in my own hands and read it in Sanskrit. ❤️
@@TR-lb4om far better than congress mp 😂 because everyone of them are now in bjp it's doesn't matter 😂😂😂😂 pura party he kharid leya now we will scold them ab kaise bachoge first they use to blame each other now all are in one party we will take advantage Thai time fullfill our demands
Completely endorse Sanyal Ji's point about translating the manuscripts. I think despite all the destruction India has the highest number of manuscripts. I didn't learn Sanskrit, though I am trying. But it's imp that Sanskrit is taught in schools and in future we have scholars who bring all this hidden knowledge to light
Well, for us telugu people, this is what we are good at, we got so many historic and mythological films made that the same story or details that sir is telling about how kautilya and chandragupta and how he dealt with that loyal minister in nanda s empire...all that was mad einto a film beautiful well made film...chandragupta chanakya in 1977..... we knw that story its nice to hear and a lot of people didnt knew about this story btwn kautilya and that minister... you can watch it if any ones interested...
This conversation was so well done. Prakhar is doing justice to Sanjay sanyal. I hope sanjayji does more podcast with prakhar more than other idiot with bicep.
Chanakya/Kautilya has been one of the least understood personalities from our past. Also happy to see the myth of Ashoka being deconstructed. Archaeology/Linguistics departments at various universities need to take up longterm projects for transportation of manuscripts. It's not something individual researchers can do. Thanks for this engrossing podcast, subscribed.
The eastern side respected Knowledge and researched on it. That's why we see these cultures learning and growing together. Abrahamic Religion is kinda rigid, disrespects other cultures, and is very self-centered.
Knowledge is what is “known “, thus we must take time to understand what actually happened in the past. Look at the outstanding work done by Nilesh Nilkanth Oak who discovered the technology used by in ancient Indian texts “Ramayan “ and “Mahabharat “. We are now fairly certain abut the time of “Ravan Vadh” and Bhishma’s “Ichcha Mrityu “. Nilesh Oak’s theory is based on the position of stars Jupiter and Arundhati. Arundhati moves around Jupiter in about 28,000 years. The calculations presented by Nilesh bring the accuracy to probably one / two weeks. We must be thankful to Ashoka at least in one sense that he left inscriptions that give us the sense of his thoughts and the technology available in his time.
However Ashoka might as a person & King in general bt there's smthg we've to accept abt him that he spread culture influence & soft power of our country to most part of the world as we today like China, Japan all of south east asia & also in some parts of central asia as well as west asia.....
Before chandragupta, Ajatsatru too was great king ,his empire was largest before Ashoka . But he is not consudered great because of his heinous crime against his father the great Bimbisara other relatives ( so named Ajatsatru ...killed of his own relatives) & his own fate . Pushymitra sunga again protected Bharat from Greek ..
Fantastic! Amazing content. Suggestion- If you can please make it more engaging by like taking questions from the audience and asking them to Sanjeev sir. You could also give us short material we can read on as a follow up to this conversation like Think school does. It can become sort of a community interested in intellectual topics like Economics, History and Governance etc. if we take it further. You can also make a separate channel later on if you wish as there is so much material here. But do expand on this. It was a fascinating conversation
Lovely discussion! So happy to hear that Ashoka was indeed a chandashoka and not great in any good sense. Also that the wheel and the sthambha are the symbols of the sovereign, nothing to do with Ashoka or Buddhism/Jainism.
Amazing podcast brother. Just a suggestion, but, you could host J Sai Deepak next. Maybe talk about his "Bharat Trilogy" and carry on with this genre of podcast
നിങ്ങളുടെ ഓക്കേ യും നേതൃത്വം ഉപയോഗിച്ച് നമ്മുടെ ഭാരത സംസ്കാരത്തെ സംസ്കൃതിയെ ഇനിയും ഉയർത്തേണ്ടതുണ്ട് അതുകൊണ്ട് ആര് തന്നെ ഗ്രന്ഥം രചിച്ചാലും അത് പുനർ നിർമിക്കുന്ന നളന്ദ യിൽ വേണം ഹരേ കൃഷ്ണ
Respected brother agar yahi popular opinion wala narrative chalana tha tau kya zarurat thi New york jakar philosophy par gyan lene ki .....Our country needs to discuss real issues not a certain imposing ruling class ka narrative. Wahi sab beer biceps wala churan bechne lage aap bhi😞
you mean congress was not the ruling class and some one now who has risen from the grounds is a ruling class? do you mean the improvements in the lives of the poor in the last 10 years should not have happened? amreeka jayenge toh jo sahi hai woh galat ho jayega kya?
Bhai aap English me hi podcast bana rahe ho to majority hindi audiences wo kya karegi,ek hindi channel bhi banao jaha pe economic,historian,enterpunour ko invite karo Taki aam janta bhi samjh shake yr please
Historical revisionism is always interesting as is understanding the interests it serves. Here it makes one wonder how much knowledge is actually command over rhetoric and persuasion. Here we have 2 articulate incisive voices delivered by 2 handsome men - they set out the terms of an excellent line of inquiry.
Please open your own channel Sanjeev sir and open the discourse more scholarly and formally , going deep in to it and explaining things with deeper insight and supporting your viewpoint with scholarly literature and other available literature of that time with us . You coming to such shows where people hardly know about Chanakya and they having such a low level of understanding of political economy really is not worth watching as they can't really extract out anything much significant. Please launch a full series about political economy of Bharat in form of books , video lectures etc .
Prakhar you have so much reach, can you please find if there are any initiatives by government or so called new Hindu leaders on Creating more apps for Sanskrit stories and cartoons. We love learning the language but find less engaging due to lack of availability in the platforms that current generation uses. I am sure people are now watching movies and short movies in other languages due to dubbing and subtitles, so a similar start can bring more interest towards Sanskrit.
Before it becomes an Echo Chamber, you should ask Mr Sanyal 2 Basic Questions: 1) When would Modi govt improve India’s “Ease of doing Business” Ranking to Top 10 List. Now it’s in 60+ rankings slot 2) Improve current legal system that enforces written commercial contracts. Will there be special courts. History does not feed the 600Million+ people but businesses and employers do.
Who said businesses are not growing if you claim such things claim it and present it with facts, coz debate is all about exchange of facts not just word of mouth
Sanjeev sir should SERIOUSLY consider delivering a whole semester’s worth of lectures on TRUE Indian history and its relevance to our modern population. I am sorry to say that I am ASHAMED at the level of historical education imparted to us as students in school. This has to change.
Always a learning arc whenever I listen to your podcasts, prakhar. I never knew how we as a nation adopted the wheel in our flag and to be honest never cared too. But got to know now and it's all thanks to you and ofc Sanjeev Sanyal Sir. These podcasts are great, keep them coming!
The Host is either overconfident or lacks any of it. His body language is extremely inappropriate. The thinks of himself as Amitabh Bachchan from Agneepath. He is just backed by some of his good friends like the host of Dostcast. Other wise he is nothing. So calm down. Check your body language. And next time be a proper host.
Bhai aap apni videos or podcast both English and hindi main ku bnate ho.. Ek hi video main aap dono language bolte ho... Vese to apko hindi main hi videos or podcast banana chahiye kuki hum indians hai... Or syad aap indians ke liye hi videos banate ho... Keep improve your videos... Told as a friend..
Sanjay Sanyal informs Indians & the world about ancient Indian Philosopher like Kautilya who Was excellent at expounding how States should govern the lives of the People India does Not need to look elsewhere but in its own ancient rulers & traditions Sydney Desouza
Prakhar bhai, the sound quality of this podcast is not good. The voice is very low. Even after setting my laptop and youtube volume to high I had to take so much efforts to listen and understand what you both are speaking.
So I think the way to solve the problem of lack of translation/interpretation would be to give willing historians competitive salaries for their work. I'm talking about private entrepreneurs, not officials of national archives or whatever government bureaucratic institutions, the later would provide some oversight for responsible use of funding, of course.
The reason why neighbors are likely to be enemies as per chanakya is because countries of those time are ever expanding ..they didnt have hard borders today. So when your border stops somewhere it implies borders could not be expanded more than that because of resistance from the other side making them your likely enemies...its not a rule but its logic
bengali log kab Indian samjegi ... abhi bhi Bangladeshi samaste he ... bade bade bato to power me rahte kuch bhi bolte he... kitne log bangal me bahar se ghuse hue wo bhi batana chahiye
whyis so much importance given to written vs verbal utterances? written content maybe as wrong or right as verbal one? can we exploer this assumptions that has led to we Indians ourselves not believing our history
To Become a Social Genius, Click Here: amzn.eu/d/6tvr8jQ
i thaugh he was economic advisor but telling all past not future plans thats why india is behind china
Sanjeev Sanyals erudition in ahistory of Bharath is so inspiring. I felt I am in my school(literally so). I am sharing with people who are in yhe same wavelength. I have down loaded to listen this with more Pride.
Instead of funding Harvard, Indian billionaires should consider supporting Indian scholars willing to translate original Indic works written on palm leaves in Sanskrit and never translated. As mentioned by Sanjiv Sanyal at end of video. What a way to obtain immortality for everyone involved!
Yes brother 😊❤💪🇮🇳🕉️🥰
Totally agree with you
Thwre is a non profit organisation in bengaluru named TARA PRAKASHANA that has the expertise in translating and preserving ancient palm leaves. The founder trustee, is Prif. P.R. MUKUND, Ph. D, professor emeritus at the Rochester Institute of Ttexhnology.
Alternatively, provide tax concession only to funds provided to Indian universities and research institutions, but tax funds sent to foreign universities. That should fix serious problems!
Especially Mahindra guy
The best thing about this discussion is you are actually interested to listen to Sanyal ji. In this process you ask pertinent questions.
Great discussion!
यशस्वी भव🌻 कीर्तिमान भव। brilliant interview.
And the judges in India take 2 months of summer vacations like a school child while pending cases are piled up.
Transcribing manuscripts is the best call and hopefully new scientific interventions can come from that and India will regain its glory of knowledge light house. Hats off Sanjeevji
41:30 in fact, the phrase “the enemy of my enemy…” is attributed to Kautilya. It is from his theory of the Rajamandala in Sanskrit that the phrase travelled to become ‘amicus meus, inimicus inimici mei’ in Latin and then its modern English form in the 19th Century.
Very well composed thought process. Examined, analysed and explained in a very broad global framework
Great content 🚩
😮 Sanjiv sir
Its often the commentary of original text gets mis construed. Todays india is of a generation getting out of colonolial thinking. The future is definetly promising. But i think in this podcast its a good opportunity to understand (a) principle of any philosophy (b) the context in which the commentary (c ) the delta of time construct and relevance.
Thank you for such a simple conversation and enticing podcast.
Good one 👍
राजा का काम प्रजा का भरण पोषण करना होता है, इसीलिए जिन्हें सब राजाओं से बड़ा राजा माना गया है, वो खुद भगवान विष्णु हैं, जो स्वयम सुदर्शन चक्र धारण करते हैं। और पुराण ये बतातें हैं कि विष्णु को ये चक्र स्वयं भगवान महादेव से मिला था। इसीलिए प्राचीन भारत मे जितने भी महानतम चक्रवर्ती सम्राट हुए जिनमे राजा राम चन्द्र जी भी थे, वे सभी महान शिवभक्त थे।
It's also said by professors from.varanasa that it's only Chanakya who wrote kok shastra how to practice Sexual life
just think --- chanakya being modi ji and chandra gupta being yogi ji............ bhagwan hume ye dede toh bharat will have the golden age again
Does anyone know how old is the original manuscript of the Arthashastra? In what language and script is it written?
It is in sanskrit. Oldest copy is from 11th century...
So many podcasts. It’s like over supply
" a civilization waiting to be discovered " - what a phrase to conclude such a thought provoking discussion
Sanjivji, your explanation of Aśoka’s “greatness” seems very very logical. I also feel that Asoka was made great because, he denounced Santana Dharma and embraced Buddhism! So, excellent armor to beat down Santana Dharma
Also because of the Buddhist concept of Ahimsa which the British ascribed to Ashoka. As a result of this we've had to give up our territories 70 years ago. Historically though, none of the Buddhist, Jain or Ajivaka kings practiced ahimsa. It was meant only for the Bhikshu.
@@lajwantishahani1225 agreed. Non-violence concept of our dharmic philosophies were twisted and misused to make us weak.
I really don't understand why Chanakya's Arthashastra is not included in the syllabus of Economics in UG and PG course. We study about Adam Smith, Keynes, etc.
Because all this education is derived from Britishers and Congress, who never focused on their own country
an eye opener on Ashoka the so-called "great".
@@pks2552not Brahmins but the ones who read the real history and 2nd Chandragupta was the great
@@pks2552 Na India's golden period is during Gupta Dynasty..Mauryan Period will be second..
@@pks2552 you just proved the point that he was labeled as great to divide the society.
Anyway ...... continue blaming brahmins for everything u don't have or u can't do.
@@pks2552bruh. What bullshit.
@@pks2552what Brahmins I am a OBC,Ashoka did not look far enough he somehow took Buddhism and it let to to some extent him diluting the army for ahims,but never considered ahimsa will come from outside.
Sri Sanjeev Sanyal is always a pleasure to hear. 👍
So to conclude - " Ashoka the great" is as much as a hoax as " akbar the great" - both carefully minted constructs by motivated Leftist historians to suit their own socio-political ideology .
Yes
True, he's depth of knowledge economics & history👌, he's clear in opening his view's
Some people wouldn't know that he is the grandson of the famous freedom fighter Sachindra Nath Sanyal!
I know.
A great man, Chanakya, decoded by another great man, Sanjeev.
Hey Prakhar
"I am currently in the states right now. It’s a great delight to watch your podcast, but just a request: if you are reading the comments, please bring some PhD professors in Sanskrit or experts who can elaborate on the matter regarding manuscripts yet to be translated. I believe it will spread awareness among a large section of society who will step up and we may uncover some lost knowledge or lost parts of history from those manuscripts.
Not gonna happen till we reach 12 trillion dollar economy. A general Indian is still poor and rich wokes will do easy pusy PhDs on the rise of RSS.
yes exactly
i thaugh he was economic advisor but telling all past not future plans thats why india is behind china
Modis greatness is proper delegation of work responsibilities to his cabinet ministers. Sanyalji is one among them and is very close to Modi. He is so young and knows our history in detail and hence we can be rest assured that under NDA new amendments in our Constitution, laws etc will be in line with our past great philosophers and think tanks.
It's an absolute delight to listen to Sanjeev Sanyal sir talk about History..looking forward to more such conversations ... Thank you for this one ...😊😊
Lakhs of manuscripts.....left behind to be discovered and reawaken the glory of our cultural learning just sitting there to be discovered by our generations to come.
What a fascinating call for people interested in doing such work. Can't wait to hold original manuscripts in my own hands and read it in Sanskrit. ❤️
I vote 🗳️ BJP and Modi ji💪💪💪
Ok who is your MP
@@TR-lb4om far better than congress mp 😂 because everyone of them are now in bjp it's doesn't matter 😂😂😂😂 pura party he kharid leya now we will scold them ab kaise bachoge first they use to blame each other now all are in one party we will take advantage Thai time fullfill our demands
@@nature.951acha chiz nahi hai bhai . Local independent politicians ko bhi Lana chahiye . Sirf 3,4 parties hi sab power leke baithe hain
Nicely explained Sanjeev da, but Anchor is unbearable... Is he nervous? or trying to look smart?
There is another Jain philosopher somadeva who is a minister to a chalukyan king he wrote nitivakyamritam on arthashastra
Hm yes padhana shuru karo yr apni history pta chl jayega sone ki chidiya kyu tha bharat 😊
Completely endorse Sanyal Ji's point about translating the manuscripts. I think despite all the destruction India has the highest number of manuscripts.
I didn't learn Sanskrit, though I am trying. But it's imp that Sanskrit is taught in schools and in future we have scholars who bring all this hidden knowledge to light
Yes 😊❤
We have such set of manuscript which were preserved by my grandfather still with us in our temple room .. We call it ELLAI . 🙏
Sanskrit should be taught from kg ukg to 10 th standard
1:00:09 😮
What a coincidence. Right now I'm in kharvela park in bhubaneswar Odisha, watching this video.
Well, for us telugu people, this is what we are good at, we got so many historic and mythological films made that the same story or details that sir is telling about how kautilya and chandragupta and how he dealt with that loyal minister in nanda s empire...all that was mad einto a film beautiful well made film...chandragupta chanakya in 1977..... we knw that story its nice to hear and a lot of people didnt knew about this story btwn kautilya and that minister... you can watch it if any ones interested...
Kindly stop Britishers like mindset ..This all history not a myth. Kindly help others too about this
Sanjeev Sanyal Da is the kind of jewel we need more from upcoming generations..knowledge, clarity, vision.
This conversation was so well done. Prakhar is doing justice to Sanjay sanyal. I hope sanjayji does more podcast with prakhar more than other idiot with bicep.
😅
This is great. Excellent discussion.
Koi musalman hi hoga jo video dislike karega
Al Taqiyya karega
No, unk alava bhimtas bhi h 😂
Quality content, please continue such works🙌
We just needed another Chanakya and Chandragupta when The Brits Came 😢
Sanjeev Sanyal is a gem, really happy to see in the role of Economic Advisor to India.
Iam addicting of this man Sanjay Sanyal ❤❤
enforcement of law, economic policy, economic philosophy, cultural context.
Chanakya/Kautilya has been one of the least understood personalities from our past. Also happy to see the myth of Ashoka being deconstructed. Archaeology/Linguistics departments at various universities need to take up longterm projects for transportation of manuscripts. It's not something individual researchers can do. Thanks for this engrossing podcast, subscribed.
Sandeep maheshwari private his recent video about Acharya Prashant 😂
Really 😢
Do have downloaded that video, video is based on what topic,?😢
13:20 -13:29
One of the most amazing one liners from the podcast.
Btw thanks for liking my tweet bout this podcast.
Kind of sad.
We lost half of our land.
The eastern side respected Knowledge and researched on it. That's why we see these cultures learning and growing together. Abrahamic Religion is kinda rigid, disrespects other cultures, and is very self-centered.
48:14 Bindusara is not Chankaya's child but of Chandragupta Maurya.
This is the first time India praising its own economist
Don’t interrupt the recording in the middle to advertise. Do it at the start or end…
Knowledge is what is “known “, thus we must take time to understand what actually happened in the past.
Look at the outstanding work done by Nilesh Nilkanth Oak who discovered the technology used by in ancient Indian texts “Ramayan “ and “Mahabharat “. We are now fairly certain abut the time of “Ravan Vadh” and Bhishma’s “Ichcha Mrityu “.
Nilesh Oak’s theory is based on the position of stars Jupiter and Arundhati. Arundhati moves around Jupiter in about 28,000 years. The calculations presented by Nilesh bring the accuracy to probably one / two weeks.
We must be thankful to Ashoka at least in one sense that he left inscriptions that give us the sense of his thoughts and the technology available in his time.
Gupta emipre is alive😂😂😂 prakhar gupta...
Btw , loved the session... - thanx sanyal ji
However Ashoka might as a person & King in general bt there's smthg we've to accept abt him that he spread culture influence & soft power of our country to most part of the world as we today like China, Japan all of south east asia & also in some parts of central asia as well as west asia.....
Alexander invasion is a fantasy 😂created by British.... there is no reference to such invasion from any reference of taxasila University 😮
Just watched your last podcast with sanyal sir yesterday. Epic❤
Before chandragupta, Ajatsatru too was great king ,his empire was largest before Ashoka . But he is not consudered great because of his heinous crime against his father the great Bimbisara other relatives ( so named Ajatsatru ...killed of his own relatives) & his own fate .
Pushymitra sunga again protected Bharat from Greek ..
Sir, why is all this knowledge not there in our education system?
28:36 can we get a KautAIya (Kautilya AI)?
Fantastic! Amazing content.
Suggestion- If you can please make it more engaging by like taking questions from the audience and asking them to Sanjeev sir. You could also give us short material we can read on as a follow up to this conversation like Think school does. It can become sort of a community interested in intellectual topics like Economics, History and Governance etc. if we take it further. You can also make a separate channel later on if you wish as there is so much material here. But do expand on this. It was a fascinating conversation
Lovely discussion! So happy to hear that Ashoka was indeed a chandashoka and not great in any good sense. Also that the wheel and the sthambha are the symbols of the sovereign, nothing to do with Ashoka or Buddhism/Jainism.
The level of information I received in this podcast!!🦁
Amazing podcast brother. Just a suggestion, but, you could host J Sai Deepak next. Maybe talk about his "Bharat Trilogy" and carry on with this genre of podcast
Chanakya is a movie material. S. S Rajamouli can make a movie on chanakya ❤
Fantastic discussion. Thank you
Reminded me of a history class question in school - who is the greatest between Ashoka, Alexander and Napoleon?
Question kinda internalise the fact for naive kids that they all are great,
Alexander
@@shomikoto7558 after the death of the founder the empire also vanished. I don't called him great.
Does anyone have links and/or names of the authors to the Hindi and English translation of the book that Sanjeev shows at 17:01?
Prakhar you portrayed the wrong map of Mauryan empire, being a Mauryaphile , I am highly disturbed and perturbed
Do that head jiggle like Ranveer.... Nhi to maja nhi aa Raha hai....
നിങ്ങളുടെ ഓക്കേ യും നേതൃത്വം ഉപയോഗിച്ച് നമ്മുടെ ഭാരത സംസ്കാരത്തെ സംസ്കൃതിയെ ഇനിയും ഉയർത്തേണ്ടതുണ്ട് അതുകൊണ്ട് ആര് തന്നെ ഗ്രന്ഥം രചിച്ചാലും അത് പുനർ നിർമിക്കുന്ന നളന്ദ യിൽ വേണം ഹരേ കൃഷ്ണ
Respected brother agar yahi popular opinion wala narrative chalana tha tau kya zarurat thi New york jakar philosophy par gyan lene ki .....Our country needs to discuss real issues not a certain imposing ruling class ka narrative. Wahi sab beer biceps wala churan bechne lage aap bhi😞
you mean congress was not the ruling class and some one now who has risen from the grounds is a ruling class? do you mean the improvements in the lives of the poor in the last 10 years should not have happened? amreeka jayenge toh jo sahi hai woh galat ho jayega kya?
To kisne kha uska podcast dekhne k liye ??? Kyu aya h yhan??
Let the guest speak longer don't interrupt. Thanks for the podcast. Good job
Bhai aap English me hi podcast bana rahe ho to majority hindi audiences wo kya karegi,ek hindi channel bhi banao jaha pe economic,historian,enterpunour ko invite karo Taki aam janta bhi samjh shake yr please
Historical revisionism is always interesting as is understanding the interests it serves. Here it makes one wonder how much knowledge is actually command over rhetoric and persuasion. Here we have 2 articulate incisive voices delivered by 2 handsome men - they set out the terms of an excellent line of inquiry.
Please open your own channel Sanjeev sir and open the discourse more scholarly and formally , going deep in to it and explaining things with deeper insight and supporting your viewpoint with scholarly literature and other available literature of that time with us .
You coming to such shows where people hardly know about Chanakya and they having such a low level of understanding of political economy really is not worth watching as they can't really extract out anything much significant.
Please launch a full series about political economy of Bharat in form of books , video lectures etc .
Brilliant suggestion given the knowledge and experience he has and the position he holds in govt, it will certainly have a profound impact on society.
Prakhar you have so much reach, can you please find if there are any initiatives by government or so called new Hindu leaders on Creating more apps for Sanskrit stories and cartoons. We love learning the language but find less engaging due to lack of availability in the platforms that current generation uses. I am sure people are now watching movies and short movies in other languages due to dubbing and subtitles, so a similar start can bring more interest towards Sanskrit.
Persian emperor Cyrus had a very large empire
Sanjeev sir, you are educator who is my inspiration. I love you sir. ❤❤
@prakharkepravachan You resonated with the ideas and wisdom of the guest and it shows your homework and hardwork for the topic of discussion.
Very interesting, Mr sanyal's knowledge truly commendable ❤
Before it becomes an Echo Chamber, you should ask Mr Sanyal 2 Basic Questions:
1) When would Modi govt improve India’s “Ease of doing Business” Ranking to Top 10 List. Now it’s in 60+ rankings slot
2) Improve current legal system that enforces written commercial contracts. Will there be special courts.
History does not feed the 600Million+ people but businesses and employers do.
Who said businesses are not growing if you claim such things claim it and present it with facts, coz debate is all about exchange of facts not just word of mouth
Sanjeev sir should SERIOUSLY consider delivering a whole semester’s worth of lectures on TRUE Indian history and its relevance to our modern population. I am sorry to say that I am ASHAMED at the level of historical education imparted to us as students in school. This has to change.
Always a learning arc whenever I listen to your podcasts, prakhar.
I never knew how we as a nation adopted the wheel in our flag and to be honest never cared too.
But got to know now and it's all thanks to you and ofc Sanjeev Sanyal Sir.
These podcasts are great, keep them coming!
The Host is either overconfident or lacks any of it. His body language is extremely inappropriate. The thinks of himself as Amitabh Bachchan from Agneepath. He is just backed by some of his good friends like the host of Dostcast. Other wise he is nothing. So calm down. Check your body language. And next time be a proper host.
Bhai aap apni videos or podcast both English and hindi main ku bnate ho.. Ek hi video main aap dono language bolte ho... Vese to apko hindi main hi videos or podcast banana chahiye kuki hum indians hai... Or syad aap indians ke liye hi videos banate ho... Keep improve your videos... Told as a friend..
Sanjay Sanyal informs Indians & the world about ancient Indian Philosopher like Kautilya who Was excellent at expounding how States should govern the lives of the People
India does Not need to look elsewhere but in its own ancient rulers & traditions
Sydney Desouza
We need more discussion on philosophy of our great thinkers so that we can learn from there experience and be better prepared for future
Prakhar bhai, the sound quality of this podcast is not good. The voice is very low. Even after setting my laptop and youtube volume to high I had to take so much efforts to listen and understand what you both are speaking.
So I think the way to solve the problem of lack of translation/interpretation would be to give willing historians competitive salaries for their work. I'm talking about private entrepreneurs, not officials of national archives or whatever government bureaucratic institutions, the later would provide some oversight for responsible use of funding, of course.
The anchor should not feedback his words in the mouth of the speaker. Sanjeev Sanyal clearly does not need your anchoring in words, context, ideas.
Ikshvahu, Karikala and Vikramaditya supremacy 🎉🎉 10:35 (for empires we can't prove but all know about)
Prakhar if ur ass has dum then chanakya real ne tha ya uski koi book usne likhi thi ye sabit kr k batado👍🏻👍🏻😮😮
Btw good discussion
You look everywhere but at the guest speaker, shows your low confidence and knowledge. Try looking at the guest while asking them questions.
The reason why neighbors are likely to be enemies as per chanakya is because countries of those time are ever expanding ..they didnt have hard borders today. So when your border stops somewhere it implies borders could not be expanded more than that because of resistance from the other side making them your likely enemies...its not a rule but its logic
48:15 correction, Bindusara : Son of Chandragupta
bengali log kab Indian samjegi ... abhi bhi Bangladeshi samaste he ... bade bade bato to power me rahte kuch bhi bolte he... kitne log bangal me bahar se ghuse hue wo bhi batana chahiye
whyis so much importance given to written vs verbal utterances? written content maybe as wrong or right as verbal one? can we exploer this assumptions that has led to we Indians ourselves not believing our history
suggest you arrange a conversation with experts on the specific aspect of ruling as explained by Bhishma to Yudhistra
And once Super power!! Like in SAT YUG!! there will be fight between DEV n DAANT 😂😅
katae sexy lag rhe ho prakhar bhai suit mei