Actually Harley1597 Asch did in fact promise Natalia he would return right before he went off alone again. He said and I quote "Fine! I promise!" after she asked him to return. I too think it is Luke but the developers threw both those promises in to keep fans guessing. Ingenius. So really both of them kept their promise by both returning but it is clearly obvious that Luke is the controller of the combined body and is the only one now.
(Get ready for a long post) You know, people who think it's mainly Asch there in the ending based off of the sidequest that shows that the replica can combine with the original to spare the original tend to forget something. Luke has always been the exception in this game. Most replicas don't live; Luke did. Even fewer are perfect isofons; Luke was. He was supposed to die after getting rid of the miasma; he didn't. He wasn't supposed to be able to use a second-order hyperresonance; he did.
Just without all the theories behind replicas and all that... I think it was Luke because Tear started breaking down crying and Natalia was like, "oh that's nice." If it was Asch she'd be the one running out crying.
Ugh i wanted to know so many more things! Like the little things like Anise reforming the order, and what was really in Tear's locket that Legretta gave to her. Also i guess its both people? Luke and Asch. But idk people kept saying Tear was crying because its Luke. Well i think its more of Asch and that she was crying because it in fact wasnt Luke. Also she asked "Why're you here?" I dont think she would ask that to Luke, but more towards Asch. Idk i hate when games leave it open ended!
How could you hate emil? Emil is what everyone used to be. that shy new kid in town. And ratatosk is basically what you become when you change your "image." But everyone is entitled to their opinion. I personally think of emil as my second fav tales character. Asch being my first because thats how i usually am. Plus hes kinda luke but uses magic.
in my opinion bandai/namco made a brilliant work, creating two charcters capable of captive people making things like "asch team" and "luke team", because that this ambiguos ending... if you luke team dosnt matter what the people tell you, you ever will say "ITS FUCKING LUKE YOUR IDIOT!" if you are more "asch people" you will say he was asch in my case i totally captived for luke & tear for that i ever - doesnt matterwhat people tell me - SAY ITS FUCKING LUKE BITCHES, HES COME BACK!
OORRR [third post lol] Heres what i reaaally think =D That they're fused together but the main body person is Asch. Also people say that asch slicks his hair back, he only did that i think so there can be a difference between him and luke. but now theres no reason to be different if..your the same person. So its all poofy and adorable. And uhh i guess asch liked lukes clothes and wanted to wear it instead? D: confused
Its quite clearly luke's brain and consciousness in asche's body. Asche's consciousness died already, it would be wrong to bring someone back who has accepted death. Luke also made a promise that he would return asche never seemed to keep any promises throughout the story. Also why does asche give a fuck about tataroo valley?
well luke survived the Miasma by luck of the fact that he didnt know he had the Jewel if he didnt have the Jewel he would have definatly evaporated with the rest of the Replicas but alas Luke,Lloyd,and yuri are the Greatest Tales of Hero's in my Book i fuckin hate emil from ToS2
Ha....i'm soooooo bad. I watched it even though I don't even own it yet. lol But like all tales games, the endings are heartwarming and have bitter sweat endings.
you know what I think its not Luke or Asch but an entireley different being when they became one with lorelei it being the nice....ummmm thing that it is decided to give its scion an entireley new body containing both traits of luke and asch like luke's left handedness and aschs' hair color Notice tear didn't refer to him as either luke or Asch simply you ...
Also yea i think they Fused. So now its just Luke, not Luke & Asch. Or the real luke and replica luke. Im pretty sure *just guessing* that its not JUST luke because the scene before the credits, you can see Asch's hand/arm twitch/move. Bleh =[ i wish there was a more detailed ending that..well..told you more!
Actually Harley1597 Asch did in fact promise Natalia he would return right before he went off alone again. He said and I quote "Fine! I promise!" after she asked him to return. I too think it is Luke but the developers threw both those promises in to keep fans guessing. Ingenius. So really both of them kept their promise by both returning but it is clearly obvious that Luke is the controller of the combined body and is the only one now.
If you mean the one that Tear is singing I believe its called Fuka, or something with an F, it means love.
(Get ready for a long post)
You know, people who think it's mainly Asch there in the ending based off of the sidequest that shows that the replica can combine with the original to spare the original tend to forget something. Luke has always been the exception in this game. Most replicas don't live; Luke did. Even fewer are perfect isofons; Luke was. He was supposed to die after getting rid of the miasma; he didn't. He wasn't supposed to be able to use a second-order hyperresonance; he did.
Just without all the theories behind replicas and all that... I think it was Luke because Tear started breaking down crying and Natalia was like, "oh that's nice." If it was Asch she'd be the one running out crying.
Ugh i wanted to know so many more things! Like the little things like Anise reforming the order, and what was really in Tear's locket that Legretta gave to her.
Also i guess its both people? Luke and Asch. But idk people kept saying Tear was crying because its Luke.
Well i think its more of Asch and that she was crying because it in fact wasnt Luke.
Also she asked "Why're you here?"
I dont think she would ask that to Luke, but more towards Asch.
Idk i hate when games leave it open ended!
@jaakim You can get Luke to use magic too...
Asch slicks his hair back. You do the math.
How could you hate emil? Emil is what everyone used to be. that shy new kid in town. And ratatosk is basically what you become when you change your "image." But everyone is entitled to their opinion. I personally think of emil as my second fav tales character. Asch being my first because thats how i usually am. Plus hes kinda luke but uses magic.
in my opinion bandai/namco made a brilliant work, creating two charcters capable of captive people making things like "asch team" and "luke team", because that this ambiguos ending... if you luke team dosnt matter what the people tell you, you ever will say "ITS FUCKING LUKE YOUR IDIOT!" if you are more "asch people" you will say he was asch
in my case i totally captived for luke & tear for that i ever - doesnt matterwhat people tell me - SAY ITS FUCKING LUKE BITCHES, HES COME BACK!
Screw the hair and clothes and sword. THAT ENTITY IS A L.I.E.
ohsnap guys Luke is anime Jesus and he died for us all and then rose from the dead. 2 years later.
OORRR [third post lol]
Heres what i reaaally think =D
That they're fused together but the main body person is Asch. Also people say that asch slicks his hair back, he only did that i think so there can be a difference between him and luke. but now theres no reason to be different if..your the same person. So its all poofy and adorable.
And uhh i guess asch liked lukes clothes and wanted to wear it instead?
D: confused
i like the fonic hymn
Its quite clearly luke's brain and consciousness in asche's body. Asche's consciousness died already, it would be wrong to bring someone back who has accepted death. Luke also made a promise that he would return asche never seemed to keep any promises throughout the story. Also why does asche give a fuck about tataroo valley?
well luke survived the Miasma by luck of the fact that he didnt know he had the Jewel if he didnt have the Jewel he would have definatly evaporated with the rest of the Replicas but alas Luke,Lloyd,and yuri are the Greatest Tales of Hero's in my Book i fuckin hate emil from ToS2
Ha....i'm soooooo bad. I watched it even though I don't even own it yet. lol But like all tales games, the endings are heartwarming and have bitter sweat endings.
I subscribed
they proboly didnt its just because its so dark
It is Luke in Asch's body. End of story!
lol no i think it would still be luke since aschs real name is luke and lukes only name is luke
you know what I think its not Luke or Asch but an entireley different being when they became one with lorelei it being the nice....ummmm thing that it is decided to give its scion an entireley new body containing both traits of luke and asch like luke's left handedness and aschs' hair color Notice tear didn't refer to him as either luke or Asch simply you ...
luke and asch fused soo.... wouldn't they be lasch (lash)?
Also yea i think they Fused. So now its just Luke, not Luke & Asch. Or the real luke and replica luke.
Im pretty sure *just guessing* that its not JUST luke because the scene before the credits, you can see Asch's hand/arm twitch/move.
Bleh =[ i wish there was a more detailed ending that..well..told you more!
what is the name of the song at the end
hm......
@EvilTaco1994 LIES!!!! healing steel does not count >:-(
wow congratulations. you just ruined one of the best games ull ever play....i feel so sorry for you