ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- G-EGG 課題曲チーム対抗フォトセット販売中！
official-goods...
#GEGG #GeggCteam #IdontCare #MV_Teaser
日本発！NEWプロジェクト
グローバルアイドル発掘 x リアル成長ストーリー「G-EGG」
Abemaビデオにてアーカイブ映像配信中！
abema.tv/video...
■公式サイト ：
■公式twitter ：@Gegg_yna
■公式instagram ： / gegg_yna
Can’t believe the company just decided to rip off everything from SHINee’s Our Page MV???
probably a tactic to get attention which is even more disgusting
Exactly, they even copied from the song that the members were having an extremely rough and hard time 😞 its an extremely special and important song to us yet the nerve of those producers to copy SHINee..
I heard the news and rushed here and disliked the mv they treated the mv which is dedicated to jonghyun like that I am so angry 😤
Vitória Arlene now that you’ve pointed it out, I can totally see it! This is terrible! They better apologise and take down this MV. Their company really set them up
Where is the tradition? The shooting locations are different, the words are different, the melody is different, the voices are different, the people are different, you just criticized for no reason
This so disrespectful, Our Page's stage is not only a decoration, that was a representation about what SHINee's was going trough after Jong's passed away. The lights aren't just a pretty thing, represents SHINee world and what meant to SHINee to get up and carry on and sing for us and Jjong, It's more than a stage, it was a special video for Jonghyun and his memory and the thing that you just only took that stage only for decoration makes me feel so angry....
EXACTLY IT IS DEDICATED TO JONGHYUN I AM SO ANGRY
Exactly...
@@parkhaejeong8364 criticize without reason? do you think we are people who are looking for trouble on purpose? you are very funny. we didn't mind the shooting location, language, melody, etc. because we know everything is different, it's just that we criticize why they plagiarized SHINee's MV on OUR PAGE and SHINee's clothes color? many other concepts appropriate to their song. we do not hate anyone, we only apologize from related parties for plagiarizing our SHINee. thank you
@@parkhaejeong8364 who the hell do you think you are? Our page was a song written specially for Member Jonghyun and this is an exact copy of that video. We "didn't criticize for no reason" this is the exact copy of SHINee's Our page music video, a sentimental one for us.
@@parkhaejeong8364 copy+ paste
The artists are not to blame, but really the company will have to take roles against the producer who decided to make the scenario similar to SHINee's "Our Page" MV.
Yes, im a shawol as well but we should blame the producers and the people behind this who thought copying was a great idea.. its not the boys' fault
@@expensivegurl1112 no one is hating the boys in the comment section also other platforms they only blame company
Thanks
For your kind word
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
@@dibidibidis119 i know, its the stans of these boys im worried about.. a lot of them are getting mad at us shawols saying we're attacking the boys but we're just mad at the producers and company 😞
Lol!! Kpop is also copying Jpop though. Twice copied Pink Champagne MV by E-girls. It's the Fancy MV.
no hate to the group, the producers should feel ashamed.
even jinkis toes have more sense than grown ass men
I hate this feeling. The feeling of wanting to protect SHINee and SHINee's hard work from those disrespectful people. (Not talking to this group but to the company) why do you need to do this. How many times will you (people who doesn't know how to respect and recognize SHINee's masterpiece) do this to us. How many times will you hurt our feelings. I can't do anything to protect SHINee, and it sucks 😭💔
I also hate this feeling ... that a group of idiots talk badly about people who were not guilty
@@strawberrygirl3998 I clearly stated myself that I am not attacking here the artist/group. I am referring to the company. If there's anyone who's idiot here, its you.
사천
If you really want to attack the program, go to Instagram .. not TH-cam
Where is the tradition? The shooting locations are different, the words are different, the melody is different, the voices are different, the people are different, you just criticized for no reason
@@parkhaejeong8364 criticize without reason? do you think we are people who are looking for trouble on purpose? you are very funny. we didn't mind the set, language, melody, etc. because we know everything is different, it's just that we criticize why they plagiarized SHINee's MV on our page and SHINee's clothes color? many other concepts appropriate to their song. we do not hate anyone, we only apologize from related parties for plagiarizing our SHINee. thank you
This is blatant plagiarism of SHINee’s music video for “Our Page”. Disgusting how you could copy a music video that is so personal and important to SHINee and SHINee fans.
Exactly, its not the layout we're mad about its the meaning behind it 😞
Well they clearly dont care
Please talk directly to SM 😭 They are not bad boys
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
You must send a email to company ..this is not fault of this boys...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program
Exactly!!!!
音源公開の時も同じようなコメントしたけど、とにかく翔平くんの声が良すぎて…。
曲的にはこれが1番聴いてて気持ちいいです。みんなカッコいい曲やりたかったみたいだけど、こういう楽曲は女心を掴むよー✨
あと、玄くんの表情すごくよかった。
白色チケットもらった理由がわかる気がする。
ヒョンスくんはもう完璧だし、冬威くん可愛いし、もう…もう……😇😇
あ、ヒドくんのウィンク何事ですかお風呂で見てて変な声でましたジェグではなるべく特定のお気に入り作りたくなかったのに好きになってしまいました責任とってください😇😇😇😇😇
こちらのファンとしても、件の内容に関しては驚きを隠せず、なにもわからない状況のため制作陣と運営の言葉を待つだけの状態となっております。本件にお怒りの方々のお気持ちお察ししますが、MV撮影時点に練習生段階である彼らには罪がありません。ここでは彼らへの批判はせず、説明を求めるコメントだけお願いしたいです。それでも煮えきらず責めたい場合には運営、制作陣側だけにお願いします。どうか彼らメンバーへの批判だけはご遠慮ください。
すいません
何があったんですか？
もひ SHINeeの『Our Page』というMVと衣装&雰囲気が似ていた？みたいです。それからテヨン(NCT)の『Long Flight』という曲と曲調が似てるため海外のファンがコメントに押し寄せてる感じです。
one wanna 様
教えてくださりありがとうございます。その２曲聴いてみました。 素人の感想ですが…
マービンゲイとエドシーラン程ではないような…権利関係って難しそうですね…どうなるのかなぁ
nao 正直、似てる部分はたしかにありました。ですが私自身この曲のおかげで日々の疲れを癒されたし、この曲が大好きです。その気持ちはこれからも変わりません
ヒド！この曲でヒド推しになりました。物憂げと幸福感が絶妙に混じったヒドの表現力がむちゃくちゃ生きてる。ヒドのダンスは、ドラマを感じさせるんだよね。
玄くん、分量多くないけど表情ダンス、職人技レベルに高めてるのが伝わる。何度も見ちゃう魅力につながってる。技術はもちろん、人格が愛される才能がある！
とういくん、全盛期のAKBのあっちゃんみたいな唯一無二のスター性感じます。さわやかだけど底知れない深さがあって、どんな表情をしてもドキッとするよ…！可能性ピカイチだと思う！
翔平くん、彼がいたからこの曲がただのかわいい系で終わらないアンセムソング級の存在感になったと思います。すべての曲を底上げする魅力。絶対メジャーで活躍できる！
ヒョンスはもうアイドル。
its not JUST SHINee’s our page, but also Taeyong’s Long Flight?????? Are you kidding me.
I really don't want this kindda thing happen but just why this is happen. So sad and mad
Really? OMG Our page and Long Flight? I did not want to see the full video
long flight?? really? i didn't watch the mv
about this taeyong thing, be careful because they may have used a sample
, and there are samples on the internet that you don't need permission to use or or you can buy
Where is the tradition? The shooting locations are different, the words are different, the melody is different, the voices are different, the people are different, you just criticized for no reason
The chorus sounds similar, no, exactly the same as Taeyong’s Long Flight. I also read comments about how it plagiarises SHINee’s Our Page. No hate to the boys but I believe the company to should apologise. Long Flight was a song Taeyong worked really hard on and even released it during his birthday month and Our Page being a very special song to both SHINee and Shawols.
This company omg... we need to e mail SM this is unacceptable
and stop DISLIKES please
This is so disgusting. Hope sm do something.
Where is the tradition? The shooting locations are different, the words are different, the melody is different, the voices are different, the people are different, you just criticized for no reason
@@parkhaejeong8364 copy+ paste
ヒドちゃんロス半端ない、、
まじでどうしちゃったんだろ
最近供給ないから元気かな？ってすごい心配だったけど、まさか辞退なんて思ってなかった
でもB.I.Gの活動があるから、絶対また戻ってくるよね
また元気な姿が見れたらいいな
やっぱ この曲は、透明感ある声のヒョンスが歌うのが正解👌 さすが ユナクさん🤩 ヒド翔平さすが✨ベテラン✨歌 めっちゃ上手👍👍 冬威くん 玄くん とにかく かわいい😊とにかく 何回も聞いていたい曲だね✨
When Shawols said ''Plagiarism is okay'' we meant it's okay *ONLY* for the SHINee members to do so with each other NOT any OTHERS. Having some similarities is okay but this looks TOO SIMILAR it isn't okay.
Too many similarities?
The disrespect towards Shinee...
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz Stop copying and pasting this comment on every shawols comments here. It doesn't matter if the members are apart in "Our Page" while the members are "together" on here. The background, the stage, the outfit, the hanging lights, it's all LITERALLY the SAME. It would've been okay if some things were similar but this is just TOO obvious already. Plus OUR PAGE song is such a personal song to us shawols. It's disrespectful asf to be copying such a sentimental mv
@@Diklazz Why are you copy and pasting your response to so many people and wasting your time on an MV you clearly don't know about? Are you really a shawol or not? Jesus christ... Did we watch the same MV? You need to rewatch Our Page again.
shinee plagiarizing each other is our inside joke too. it wasn't good either when that other group ripped jonghyun's instagram pictures withiut authorization too.
@@shineeingstars I'm copying because you all comment the same and refuse to actually watch the MV and see for yourself how different it is from our page.
And of course it matters if the members are together or separated... Both MVs have such different messages and stories.
オスワリクダサイ(•'-'•)❤︎❤︎❤︎❤︎
*めいめろ ヒドくんの"オスワリクダサイ"可愛すぎですよね♥️
その時のウインクでやられました…😂💓
ねぇなんで？ヒド………
どうしていなくなっちゃったの………
もう泣きすぎて死にそう😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
ヒドのいるNIKを追いたかった
ヒドのグッズを買いたかった
ヒド大好きだよ
ずっとずっと私の推したまだよ
冬威くん初々しい…かわいい…
可愛すぎてわたしはそろそろ変態になりそうです助けてください
あとヒドくんドアップで映すのやめてください心臓持ちません
(監督さんありがとうございますm)
IC,MC,RCまお まじでヒド君のウインクに、私の中の何かがギュンッ！！ってなる笑笑
冬威くん本当に可愛かったよ(>_
ヒドの辞退から毎日見てたこのMVに来れてなかったけど、、、やっぱり泣けちゃう😭くるしい。
ヒドくん １０月からオーディション番組にでますね！
あまりに尊すぎてコメント出来ず一晩考えたのですが、可愛いだけじゃなくて所々モテる男の余裕を感じて、めっちゃやられてます。
見ながら何度「ちょっと待って聞いてない…」と言った事か。ヒドペンなのでヒドくん文句なしにカッコ良かった最高でした。大好きです。ヒョンス見て努力が報われて良かったと思ったし、工藤くん妙に可愛いし、玄ちゃんもgegg出て良かった！と思いました。そして冬威くん！終盤ヒョンスとヒドくんと肩を並べて踊り最後センターでマンネなのに偉いぞ凄いぞよしよしとなってます。C team - “I don't Care”最高です！皆んな大好き！
ヒョンスとヒドのアイドル力の高さが素晴らしすぎる〜✨翔平君は存在感のある声はもちろん柔らかさと少しセクシーさのある表情がこの曲に合ってる。翔平君はここのチームで大正解！
This is so DISRESPECTFUL, plagiarism is never ok but of all songs, copying Our Page is the worst. It's such an important song for SHINee and Shawols. This is disgusting.
Your comment is disrespectful to Shinee
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz but that 40 seconds is the most meaningful part of the mv. If you can't understand our point, please just let us say our side. We're just trying to protect the most important mv to us and to SHINee.
@@Diklazz you are the one who's disrespectful for saying that. You don't know the meaning behind that 40s yet you have the guts to say "just" 40s??? Oh come on! You will never feel how we feel about this. This is beyond important to us. 😭
@@onyu_bit If Shinee recorded an entire 5:10 MV, those other 4:30 minutes obviously have a meaning as well. Jeez, look at the atmosphere of their entire MV.. I know the lonely mic is triggering, but look at the message of the entire MV
@@fayeallysamarienabarte8077 The entire MV should be important to you. As the members seem broken in the entire MV, I know how sad and triggering the lonely mic is, but the entire MV is sad. And different.
ヒョンスデビューおめでとう❣️
ここからデビューしたのヒョンスだけで悲しい😭😭
冬威くんにはNIKのマンネになってほしかった、、、
if you wanna rob shinee concepts. fine. shawols will still be mad. but why would you touch our page? WHY our page out of all songs and mvs that shinee has.... it rubs me the wrong way when g egg's copied song is called "i don't care". lmfaoo
Who do you think you are, please do not say such nonsense Everyone who makes bad comments should be silent. Who do you think you are, I love Team c
Uhm yk the mv have their director and it's not boys fault.
We should blame the producers and not the boys 🤧
I agree, im a shawol as well and seeing this brings me so much pain.. Out every MV they just had to choose SHINee's 'Our Page' in which holds the feelings of the members because of their fellow member, Jonghyun's passing 😞 they even copied the lights which represents our fandom/SHINee world.. this is so messed up
@@zaina3.al3ssa you dont understand, they copied off from SHINee's Our Page, a song in which the members expressed their extreme melancholy and sorrow and the period when they went through extreme hardship because of their fellow member's passing, Jonghyun 😞
I wouldnt care much if they copied off a different song but they just had to copy this one, this is a special song SHINee and us Shawols hold dear
You clearly don’t understand.
The level of disrespect is unbelievable. Our page is so important to us for various reasons and you go and plagiarize it as if it's nothing?? That's is so low
Not important enough for you obviously.
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
Lets e mail SM...
@@Diklazz there a thousands of way to change the look and lighting style of the stage, why make is sooooooo similar to our page,???? The light, the shape of the stage, the texture, the lights from above, the microphone, even the suits... Many things could have been changed ... But they decided not to...
@@Diklazz
I'm going to rebuff your argument that, because SHINee didn't spend the majority of Our Page on the stage set, it's therefore not as important to us with how the meaning of them being on the stage together outweighs the amount of time they spent on it. The fact that SHINee were together on the stage for such a small amount of time compared to the rest of the MV is that much more emphasised because they were together *at the end*. The symbolism of it is far more important than the time they took to stand on it. This makes this blatant copying of the stage layout that much more significant to us, because of the symbolic meaning of it. Your argument that, because SHINee don't spend that much time on the stage and therefore the stage isn't so important, is somewhat weak when you don't stop to consider the meaning behind *why* the time they spent on the stage is so short.
@@Diklazz its not the layout we're all mad about but the meaning behind the song. Its still heavily identical to SHINee's Our Page, Our Page isnt just a song but its a song where the members expressed their feelings and melancholy after the passing of their fellow member Jonghyun. They even copied the lights which represents our fandom "SHINee World/Fandom".. please know that this song is something very special to SHINee and to us Shawols.
なんでこんなに優勝してるのに再生回数1億じゃないの？？？？？
同じく😭
一億は吹いた
もっと色んな人に見てほしい
えぬたろう 様 共感します…。登録者数が約３万人…ここが桁違ってくると希望が見えるのかなぁ😢
この曲すごい癒されるし、大人っぽくておしゃれですよね。私も好きです。センスいいと思います。
ヒドのストーリー……….……
ねぇヒド…？何があったの……？
いなくなったりしないよね……？怖いよ………
ヒド……可愛い笑顔が見たいよ
ヒド君ウインクはズルい！可愛いよ！ラップだけじゃなく歌も上手い！ ヒョンスは歌もダンスも表情も良い！可愛い！ とうい君は爽やか青年って感じでいい！歌声も優しくて可愛らしい！ 玄は表情に気を使っててすごい！ 翔平くんは大人びた歌声が素敵！髪型前より似合ってる！ みんな可愛いコンセプトも似合ってるよ！最高！
It's grossly disrespectful to plagiarize SHINee's MV.
It's grossly disrespectful to forget 80% of the MV you are talking about
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz stfu.. and stop liking your own comment..
Its not about how much time spent..but rather them ripping of one of the most meaningful sets in SHINee'S MV
@@Diklazz its the meaning behind the song not the layout, its a song where they expressed their feelings and deepest melancholy because of their fellow member, Jonghyun's passing 😞
dharsh_kwon exactly. This person is dumb.
@@Diklazz hello pathetic bitch remember you were so scared to fight on twt and blocked me ❤️ i didn't forget how you talked trash about us and our connection with Jjong.
ヒョンス「もう限界だね。
黙って見てるなんて。」
ファン「はい限界ですね！開始20秒で一時停止押したファンが何人いるかな！黙ってられません可愛さ！いったん落ち着こか…！はぁぁぁぁ」
再生ポチッ
ヒョンス「誰にも渡したくない。」
ファン「ちょっと待って。まず私は貴方しか見てないから安心して？大好き。(お前には言ってねぇ) 」
……私もそろそろ限界オタクか、
(充分な程に限界突破)
触れたい
この ワンフレーズに
何回も、キューン♡
I don't care I love you Heedo ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
正直G-EGGに関してはヒョンスくんとユンソルくんしかよく知らなかったし、めちゃくちゃナメてました。こんな素敵な人たちがいたんですね、、、。
plagiarizing SHINee's our page which means so much to not only them but their fans as well,how low can the producer fall ? utterly disrespectful and disgusting.I hope SM takes action
Mobbing and accusing... Definitely SM fan.
Pad for Shinee... How You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz the evidence is there. stop being delusional
翔平くんの歌のうまさにびっくりしました。
とういくんは本当に可愛さと爽やかさが爆発してます。
玄くんは可愛い！！
ヒドさんはさすがって感じ！
ヒョンス君もさすがって感じだし、とにかく可愛い😍
盗作って、見に行ったけどそんなに似てるか？別にライト使ってても服が似てても曲は全然違うしそんな騒ぐ事かな。
あなたがSHINeeのファンでも同じことが言えるかどうかですよ。
@@kkkggg9730 むしろ普通のファンはそんなことで大騒ぎしないと思うけどね
一部の頭のおかしい人の声が大きいのはどこの世界でも一緒ですから
Kkk Ggg←この人どこにでもアンチコメ書く人なんで無視した方がいいですよ
もし騒ぐとしても、こういった所に書き込むのはタダの嫌がらせですよね。
感情的な行為がどれだけ推しのグループの品位を下げる行動か。
見境がないと、周囲から見下されるのがオチなのに・・・。
本当に問題だと感じればそのグループが法的に然るべき対応を取るはずなので、ファンはヒステリックにならずに見守るのが得策でしょうから。
ほんと意味分からないですよね。
曲の重要性は分かるけど、セットや衣装が似ているだけで、根本的な楽曲似てるなら理解も出来ますが。本当に大事なのはそこですから。
色々ありすぎてストレス溜まってたけどこのMV見たら忘れられそう。
ヒョンスくんってなんなの？？天使なの？？天使だよね()
their producers is just begging to be sued
first is shinee's mv stage and aesthetic but even Taeyong's Long Flight?
Ikr I'm so upset
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
You should send a email to company ..this is not fault of this boys...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
@@sarakimyayi4260 we're aware
honestly, what mission was it? pick a kpop mv and a song and make a new one out of it? and out of all mvs they could pick, they chose a tribute mv??
I don’t care、このメンバーで本当に良かったなと思います！
可愛さとカッコ良さと😭最高です😭😭
ヒドくん、ウインクはあかんよ…
みんな倒れてしまう…ありがとうございます…
本編では、その後のヒドのラップ人が違うくらいカッコよくて、心臓がもちません😭
本当に、素敵なものをありがとうございます！
stop plagiarising other people works, it’s highly offensive and disgusting moreover copying from SHINee’s tribute song to Jonghyun? & the long flight chorus??????
it's the company's fault
ヒドはオールラウンダーでかっこよくて最高だしウインク最高だし、ヒョンスはこんなに甘い声なのに本気出せばめちゃくちゃかっこいいダンスかましてくるし、翔平くんは絶対長髪より短髪の方が似合ってるし、大人っぽい声でこの歌が可愛すぎるだけじゃなくてちょっと大人っぽい感じにも聞こえるし、冬威くんはダンスカッコよすぎだし、玄くんは絶対こっちの歌になって正解だし、真面目で大好き。
まじで全員デビューしてくれ
ヒョンスの「君がいてコンプリート」のとこ大好き！
翔平くんの声も楽曲に深みが出ていい！
This is really blatant copying of an extremely personal and important MV by SHINee, Our Page, that was written in memory of one of their members.
It is not the performers’ fault, but why would the producers decide to plagiarize the appearance of such an MV for the sake of this song? At least change the color of the lighting or suits, alter the setup of the stage or the lights, ANYTHING. This MV feels so disrespectful and the similarities are incredibly unnecessary and unfair to the performers who worked hard to perform this song.
Our Page has dark lighting and atmosphere, with shinees colors, whereas here you have bright colors and atmosphere.
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz why would you tell a shawol that they forgot our page? hELLO??
**Dikla**이스라엘 FTI*SV*Li5ht This vid and Our Page have almost the exact same color lighting. Screenshots don’t lie.
@@NeuviletteYouDown I explained just that.
@@Diklazz the whole issue with this thing as much as I felt is the errie similarity between the two stages and as this mv has much more timeline on stage thus there goes this constant thing in ones my mind that I have seen this before and then u realize it's the stage from our page and thus goes the feeling of being betrayed somewhere I guess. And about the atmosphere as the two songs are totally in different genres and our page is typically in the form of a letter to one they miss and I don't care is on a more revolting type u will feel that the two colors being dark and light but if u get certain screenshots to compare then the similarity suddenly Sparks.
いきなりコメントが増えて驚かれているかもしれませんが、こちらのMVがSHINeeのOurPageという曲のMVに酷似しているとつい先日話題になりました。みんなが淡いスーツを着て沢山のライトの中で踊っている部分です。スタンドマイクを使った演出、ステージの構図、衣装、どれも似ています。
Our page is a very important song for SHINee and shawol, and even the way the MV was made and everything. I find it disrespectful, that they make a copy of something very significant for my fandom.
ヒドの オスワリクダサイ〜のあとの ウインク✨で やられた🤣 ホント 表情 魅せ方 上手👏🏻👏🏻
ちょっと前にコメしたばかりやんけど、ヒーリング・ミュージックとしての効果はモノホンの本物だと思う。観て聴いてると、自律神経が整うのすごくかんじる🐣みんなのうたで流してほしい。今流してほしい。無理だと知ってるけど。まさに今必要なヒトがたくさんいる。年齢問わないもの。
これメンバーは悪くないから………
デビュー楽しみにしてます…
This is plagiarism. This is clearly plagiarised from SHINee's Our Page MV. That MV is so special for SHINee and SHINee World. How could they do something like this??
How special is it if you downright ignore 80% of the MV?
You either forgot Our Page or haven't watched this MV, or both.
Our page is 80% the members being seperted from each other, and only together on the stage (and they are on the stage for ~40 seconds out of 5:10 minutes MV).
Whereas on this MV the members are together 95% of the time.
@@Diklazz yes, but the colour scheme of this mv is clearly the same as the one in our page and the idea with the light bulbs is also very clearly heavily inspired by SHINees our page
@@Diklazz and those small parts could easily be changed to something else. THOSE parts are the parts shawols are really upset by. Because it has a deep and personal meaning to us. I think you're being equally disrespectful right now, commenting these thoughtless things. You obviously have no idea what the meaning behind it all is. Which you should really read into first before commenting like this.
@@Diklazz That specific part of the MV is the crucial point if the video. That is the most meaningful part where SHINee members are finally together singing again with the microphone for J. And in this MV they used 5 guys to perform in a very very similar set-up. Imagine how triggering that is for us.
@@lativili9814 people did lightbulbs way before shinee but yea the layout is the same
0:57 ヒョンスペン無事死亡。
ヒドくんのお口の形ってすごく可愛くないですか？
The director of the MV should be ashamed. He should be ashamed to defame the name of a new group and copy a clip that SHINee fans value.
Thanks
For your kind word
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
@@sarakimyayi4260 I understand you and I feel sorry for this group. But I'm still angry as a SHINee fan because it's a song that's high in value and nothing has been done about it. I hope things will be okay soon..
Finally someone understands the point, it's not them it's their ignorant company..the boys are gearing up for their debut...it's gonna taint their reputation if this proceeds
最初のスモーク、確かにみんなのお顔見えにくいけど、私はわざとそういう演出にしてるんじゃないのかな？って思いました。歌詞の通り『ぼやける瞳のピントを僕に合わせてみてよ』と言われ合わせた結果、一番のサビからキラキラ輝いてる5人がハッキリ見えるようになったってことじゃないかなって思ったのは私だけでしょうか、、、、、そしたら『何色で僕が見えるの？』っていう歌詞にも繋がらないこともないですよね、？え、そうだとしたら深くないですか？考えすぎかな
ピ野
素晴らしい
Wanna One ありがとうございます😭 さすがにあのスモークの量はわざとだろうなって思って、、😂
ヒョンスもヒドも翔平くんも玄くんも冬威くんも男の子の可愛さとカッコ良さが混ざっていて、見ていて胸がきゅーってなる💕パステルのステージは、白い服の5人の夢なのかな。。。たくさんの人に見てもらいたいな☺️
We (Shawols) never try to be mad over things, we just try to support and love SHINee as much as we can without doing anything negative, but this is something very personal and intimate. It's 100% plagiarism and THAT is not okay. It feels very disrespectful to all of us. The similarities to ''OUR PAGE'' MV its way too much.
it is noooot copy i don't see a similarity between i don't care c and our page The concept, the dance, the movements and the words are completely different
Iraqi Girl Yes, but I didn’t mean that. We all know what was actually plagiarized.
@@omnvbjkoytjkmnl2130 the chorus is copied off from Taeyong's song, the MV is a plain ass copy from SHINee's our page.. us Shawols are usually calm but you dont understand that this song is something SHINee and us Shawols hold special because of its meanings and that this song is SHINee's way of expressing their melancholy because of Jonghyun's passing 😞 they basically copied the concept..
@@omnvbjkoytjkmnl2130 But the set is the same.
@@omnvbjkoytjkmnl2130 the chorus is the same of Long Flight by Taeyong, and the set is the same by Our Page, a meaningful song for Jonghyun. You don't understand, do you?
SHINeeのファン民度低って思われちゃうやんなにこのコメ欄…geggもシャイニも好きだから悲しい…でもヒドくんとういくん相変わらず可愛い😭💓
みんなかわいいー
ヒョンスさすが👏
ヒドくんの声好きだなー
翔平さん歌うま！！！！！
なに？ここに世界の可愛いがあつまってるの？
もうパステルキラキラの世界にやられて倒れるわぁ😆
お玄！ピンクでもう堪らん！
いやもう言葉では表せない😆😆
本当にG-EGGに出てくれてありがとう！
ユナクさん、G-EGG生みんなありがとう！！！
この曲が頭から離れません…笑
そしてヒョンス君とヒド君の沼に落ちてしまい頭から2人が離れません。
とりあえずCteamさいこーしん
ここ数日のコメント欄を見てはメンバー達を責め傷つける言葉たちにただただ涙が出ます… 私は初回放送からG-EGGを毎週楽しみにジェグ生達を応援してきました。そして特にこのCチームを応援しています。SHINeeというグループは知っていましたが今回のことで初めてその曲を知りMVを見ました。それがファンの方達にとってどれだけ大切で意味のある曲かも理解しました。運営、制作者さん達に説明を求めたい気持ちはわたしも同じです。確かに似通っていると感じた部分がありました。悲しみやお怒りの気持ちも十分に理解できます。…ですが、メンバーを責め傷つけることだけはやめていただきたいです。これまで切磋琢磨し努力し続ける姿を見てきたファンとしては、彼らを貶されることはとても胸が痛み悲しいことです。Cチームから何人デビューできるのかは分かりませんが、このままの状態でデビューメンバー発表、NIKデビュー日がきても誰も気持ち良くその日を迎えられません。早急に運営サイドには説明を求めます。
This is disgusting how you plagiarised Our Page a song and Mv that is a tribute to their bandmate. It's honestly sick. It's bad enough to plagirise but this mv.... do you know what those lights mean??? Those lights are pearl aqua to represent Shawols and how we are always by their side.
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
You must send a email to company ..this is not fault of this boys...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
@@sarakimyayi4260 I'm not mad at the guys in the mv, I know how they have limited control over the mv and how it's not their fault however I think it's important to point out why this mv is so important and that the mv means.
okay look here hater. this is not there fault so go complain to the company if not you can stfu thank you. the world doesnt need anymore toxic people as it is. so do me a solid if your here its to support this poor boys i know how you feel but they didnt do shit to you. it was the producer. so if you have a fucking problem go complain to the company. srsly so toxic.
@@yoongiturtle hater? Lmao
みんなかわいくて素敵なんですけど、翔平くんの大人の甘い歌声で、とっても素敵なオトナカワイイ曲に仕上がってると思います
サンタモニカ組推しだけど、翔平くんの美しい高音とハモりでグッと曲がグレートアップしてると思う、デビュー組に入って欲しい。
The amount of disrespect is disgusting. It's bad enough that y'all are plagiarizing another group's music video but to plagiarize Our Page, a song that's extremely special to Shawols and SHINee? The audacity to do this, I've cancelled the company❤
@SMEntertainment y'all better do something about this or we riot☺
Let's not cancell the group but cancel the company and directors please.. I'm a shawol myself but I'm not letting the group get the shit stuff when the company and the directors made the mistake
@@tokkichan8677 no one's cancelling the group 🙄 .. we're all aware the producers and company arent at fault, us shawols are giving them a chance ♡ we just want an apology from the company, we know the boys did nothing wrong
The company should actually be cancelled otherwise the group really didn't do anything, it's because of the company, the company lead them to make it how it is, let's not blame the boys 💞
シャヲルでG-eggもみていてこの曲が好きだったので、問題になり悲しいです…どのメンバーの負担にもならないことを願います…
何かあったんですか
ヒョンスはめちゃくちゃかわいい系の曲もできちゃうしふわふわした世界観似合いすぎて尊いし、
玄くんはピースかわいいしこの曲にめっちゃあってるし、
ヒドのお座りくださいウインクで心臓貫かれたし、
とーいサラストでさわやかだしかわいいし、
翔平くんのお陰でかわいいだけじゃない上品さもあるしやっぱりかわいいし、
このチーム強い
ヒョンスくんの綺麗な歌声と、ヒドくんの低くて聴き心地の良い歌とラップたまらない😭❤
冬威くんも玄くんもこの曲の雰囲気とかコンセプトにピッタリで素敵🥰🥰
翔平くんやっぱ歌上手いなあ、髪色もすごく合ってる！🥺
個人的Cチームが一番好きです🤍
Gosh this is downright plagiarism of the stage. I don't understand these companies doing all those things and then the artists have to face all the backlashes. And then again copying the concept of the stage of our page that is so much important to SHINee and Shawols is really really not done. They just could have changed the color of the stage and nothing like this would have happened.
Who do you think you are, please do not say such nonsense Everyone who makes bad comments should be silent. Who do you think you are, I love Team c
@@zaina3.al3ssa that's why u should read the whole thing properly. I don't think I'm someone obviously and I haven't said that the artist were wrong and I clearly stated it. And as much as I know I'm free to give an opinion and this comment does not disrespect the artists at all.
@@zaina3.al3ssa you're the one who clearly doesnt understand anything here lmao 😂
Shinee 's fan
G_egg is not a group
And this boy didnt debut yet too
This is just a survival show for debut new group
And this program hold by korea & jpan
And they allow for their mv from offical singer
Like as team b
That offical singer was a another person but he allow to this program that this boy sing his song
And for this mv too
I am sure sttaf from korea know rule too
And they ask for allow too
Stop lying and shut up. Nobody is hating the group, nobody is talking about the song stop defending this company and stop guilt tripping us. Have some shame will you?
@@eliana5000 not trying to defend any act of plagiarism but the commenter above ain't lying tho?
@@ktmrn Saying that that SM allow to use "our page" (Lights, stage, shot, clothes and background) is a lie. So I don't know what you mean.
well.. maybe at least this company can credit Our Page SHINee??
@@NoradilahAH and atleast give an apology and official statement, that's what we're all asking for 😞
I don'tcareチーム、このメンバーで大正解だよ。MV、パステルカラーで女子にはたまらなく幸せ空間💕こんなに幸せにしてくれてありがとうございます☺️
みんなの歌声も心地よい。
大好き😘
「この曲は○○が優勝」ってコメよりも「このメンバーでよかった」「Cteam最高」ってコメが多くて、とりあえずコメ欄ごとみんな抱きしめたい
ヒョンスってもうアイドルやん❤️
とうい君、可愛い❤️
玄ちゃんこの曲で良かった✨
ヒド君〜ラップが愛おしい❤️
翔平君の声ってどんな曲も素敵にしちゃう気がする❤️
ヒョンス〜！
リピ用！！
(ヒド推しの方へ)
1:40
3:27
みんなからこんなにウインクもらえて幸せです❤︎
ヒド 1:19 1:31 1:41 3:28
ヒョンス 2:29 3:17
玄 1:29 1:46
とういくん
ユナクさんに指摘されていた
姿勢が治ったら、ダンスのラインとか
表現 すごく良くなってる
短期期間でのgegg 生 みんなの努力と成長が
みんな、報われてほしいよ‼︎‼︎
冬威の亡霊です。。。
絶対アイドルデビューしような…そうじゃなかったらわし一般人のヲタクになっちゃう…
これを見てるのは女性が多いのかな〜？僕21歳の男ですけど、彼らに惚れました。男なのにドキドキするよ。😅
EXpert_No_09
どんな方もウェルカム！！
どんどん沼って下さい～👍
僕も男子です 未成年ですが…。
とてもかっこよかった
It's a joke? This is a plagiarism of SHINee's 'Our page'. They have done it on purpose to generate visits. 'Our page' is very important to shawol. I don't blame the guys, but I blame your company.
They even named it "i dont care", this is so disgusting and painful 😞
玄くんはI don't care
暸くんはsanta monica
が似合ってるなぁ
ユナクさんさすが
Santa Mónica y está canción me gustaron en especial
All of them say that this song is stolen, that it is a contest, and the company asked them to perform this way, and the results of the contest will appear soon. I mean, this is not stolen.
Stop saying that again
ヒョンスの可愛さにハマり、ヒドの低音ラップに釘付けになり、とい君の瞳に癒され、玄ちゃんの表情にニヤけ、翔くんの声に耳妊娠💕たまらん！
I can't believe the disrespect. Our page by SHINee wasn't just any other song it was a tribute to Jonghyun and the fact you plagiarized it like this is really disgusting
No hate to the group whatsoever, it's the company who did this.
ヒドくんのラップ、いい具合に肩の力を抜いてる感じがしてすごく聞きやすくて心地いい。本人不安だったらしいけど、表情も柔らかくてこのコンセプトに意外なほど似合ってる。ヒョンスはもうさすがとしか言いようがない(笑)。
「ｵｽﾜﾘｸﾀﾞｻｲ」の彼はデビューできると思ってたけど辞退したんだね。残念だ
THIS IS PLAGIARISM, THIS IS CLEARLY PLAGIARISED FROM SHINEE'S OUR PAGE ! Where is the respect for the group and for the Shawol ??
Plagiarism is bad enough on its own, but stealing the concept of a memorial song?? This is so disrespectful to SHINee and Jonghyun's memory. Have some class and take it down.
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
You should send a email to company ..this is not fault of this boys...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
玄くん好きだ、ヒョンス好きだ、冬威好きだ、ヒド好きだ、しょーへい好きだ
結論→I don’t Care大好きだ
個人的には、玄くんとヒドくんのコラボしてる、全ては君の為に で毎回特にキュンキュンします❤️
ヒド〜😢😢
Blatant plagiarism of SHINees Our page, SM ENTERTAINMENT SHOULD TAKE ACTION
ヒドとヒョンスのウィンク😉が次から次へと畳み掛けるように来てやられっぱなし😆💕ありがとー幸せです😂👍💕
結構みんな普段はふつうに男子なのに、どうしてこうもかわいいのもできるの…………？？？
玄ちゃん、歌声の透明感が優勝。エグい。ビジュも良くなって、子供っぽくはしゃいでるの一生見れるもん………かっこいいしかわいいね…………
翔平くん、一人だけ声がかなり深みのある声だからどうなるかなって思ったけど、杞憂でした。若干ハスキーで、すごく上手だから、スパイスにもベースにもなるっていう……最強じゃん
ヒドさ……、日曜の朝にコーヒーとクッキー食べてそうな声じゃない……？？ドユニのときに知って、お洒落で気取ったふうなラップにハマったんだよな～～今回もシャレオツ大放出で良かった 目キラキラで漫画のキャラクターみたい
とういくん、なにもしなくても若い 今どきの子の歌声って感じ もちろんダンスも、首が前になるの直っててすごいね～！！首コクコクするのは変わらなくてかわいい～～それでいい～～！！
ヒョンス ヒョンス……ヒョンス……………………………ヒョンスや………………………黒髪似合うね…………変わんなくてもかわいいよ…………………明るい色も好きだし、最近だとSSGのピンクとかもめちゃめちゃすきだけど……今の長さ最高だ……ちょっと切った………？？最高 もう歌もダンスもビジュも愛嬌も表情も立ち姿一挙手一投足すべてが愛おしい こんなにウィンクと指ハートが似合う23歳男性おる？？？ヒョンスは本当にアイドル～～～って感じ デビューしよ
結論：かわいい
なな 日曜の朝にコーヒーとクッキー食べてそうな声… 👍👍👍
翔平君の深い声いいあじでてますね。
بيقنينق'ز بليز:::
-ادري نبي ندعم هيدو وقلقانين ع نتيجته بالمسابقة
بس اول شيء اعتقد حتى لو هذا الامفي انحذف او اي شيء مارح ياثر على اعضاء الفريق لان جي اق تعرف هذا مو خطأهم.
-اتوقع جي اق حسموا النتايج فعلًا ومقررين من الاعضاء اللي رح يترسموا في فرقة NIK
اما نتايج الامفيات فترتيبها محسوم من زمان ومعروف
-ثالث شي واهم شي، مهما كانت اسبابنا والقلق على هيدو، غلط نتكلم بطريقة (استفزازية) مع فاندومز ثانيين الشاولز) لانه كذا رح يزيدوا بهجومهم ع عيالنا وبكذا احنا م نحمي عيالنا! بالعكس نعرضهم لكره زيادة
-الشاولز كثير منهم اسلوبهم بالتعليقات هنا محترم، قاعدين يوجهوا كلام حلو للاعضاء (يا ملائكة، قاتلوا واستمروا خلف احلامكم، انه ليس خطأكم انه خطأ المنتج، هجومنا ليس ضدكم..الخ) فيه حين ردود بعض البيقنينقز (نحن لا نهتم هذه الاغنية تعجبنا!!) وردود ثانية من نوع استفزازي
-بيقنينق'ز هذه مو مشكلتنا هذه مشكلة بين جي اق وبين (شايني/ الشاولز/ اس ام) فـ مو مطلوب مننا نسوي حرب هنا (اقولكم وشويشة باذانكم، لو سوينا هالحرب احنا اللي بنخسر)
بقولكم ليش؟ شايني اكثر فرقة في الحياة مرت بمعاناة و وقت صعب، المغني الرئيسي حقهم كان مكتئب (وتعرض لكلام قاسي) وانتحر، الاعضاء والفانز تأثروا كثير، اكتأبوا وتعالجوا نفسيًا حتى قدروا يرجعوا ولا زال لليوم هالجرح موجود، ورغم كذا الفرقة والفانز يحاولوا يستمروا بقوة في مجتمع الكيبوب التنافسي القاسي
امفي our page اللي فيه تشابه بينه وبين هذا ماكان امفي عادي كان يوصف حالة الاعضاء وهم يرجعوا للفانز، ما كان تمثيل كان حقيقة، الالوان والاضاءة لها معاني والامفي كله نوع من التعزيه لجونقهيون والأعضاء ومواساه لانفسهم وتشجيع للاستمرار!
فمن حقهم يدافعوا عنه!
في حين هالامفي I don’t care هو امفي لتمثيل الاغنية، واكيد يعني لنا بس ما يعني لنا كثر م يعني امفي شايني لهم، لان هذا عبارة عن جو للاغنية بس وليس (كلام عن معاناة حقيقة قاعدين يمروا فيها) وكانت جي اق ممكن تمثله بطريقة ثانية
-حتى لو ما اعجبكم امفي شايني، لا تتكلموا عنه بطريقة سلبية (لا اسمع احد يقول امفي هيدو احلى او اي كلام مسيئ!) بكذا انت رح تدخلوا انفسكم بمشكلة من نوع ثاني، وقتها احنا م رح نقدر نساعدكم!
بيقنينق'ز اقرروا😤
اخيرا شخص يفهم ...
بيقينينق'ز بليز اقروا و لا تكونوا سبب مشاكل و كره لفرقتنا!!
FLY HIGH B.I.G شكرًا ماريا
انا بجلس هادئة والشركات (G egg) و (sm) تتفاهم مع بعضها
@@roob.i.ginning50
حتى انا .. مانبي احد يتأذا بسبب سوأ فهم او مشاكل غبية زي ذي
خلوا المسؤلين يحلونها بدون مشاكل !
صح√
この鬱屈した今😷、大げさじゃなくて幸せ運ぶMVだよ✨✨
GEGG生まだ何人デビューするか決まってない中で、もっと認知度上げて関心集めて、より多くの子がデビューできるようにプロデューサーのユナクさんに届けたい💗
長く愛されるグループになってもらお！
I can understand they want attention but it's painful and sad to see a tribute video for our jjong and they convert it to like a happy song this not only a concept but that's emotion and sadness it has connected with Shawols and SHINee's feelings... I'm not angry on the boys No hate to the group but company did wrong at least mention SHINee name and give them credit with an apology if you really did this concept by mistake....
This is not a debut song
This is just a mission for a survival show ....
You should send a email to company ..this is not fault of this boys...they dont debut yet ...
This is a program for debut a new boy group
@lightning hunter they copy the stage and outfit and decoration lights you still think it's a coincidence??
@@sarakimyayi4260 I'm not blaming the boys... It's company fault
初見だけど、薄紫色の方のお顔と歌声がめちゃくちゃ好みで苦しい………
ドビー ヒョンスくんといいます。かわいいですよね💕よければAbema TVで本編も見てみてください😌
しとりくん 韓国の方なんですね！？すごく日本語がお上手………！この5人それぞれ可愛くて本当にこの曲にぴったり😭親切に教えて頂きありがとうございます！！すぐ観てみます！！
ドビー 即反応しちゃって恥ずかしいですが😅ヒョンスくん、geggが始まった時は全然日本語話せなかったみたいですよ。あと、第5話で家族のことを語るヒョンスくんにもらい泣きしちゃいました😌💕
しとりくん 今めっちゃ検索して色々調べてたので、情報教えてくださるの嬉しいです！この何ヶ月？の間にすごく努力なさったんでしょうね！！私、青少年たちが夢に向かって頑張る姿とか見ちゃうとすぐに涙出ちゃうんですよね…😭5話ですね！！絶対観ます！！！！！
ドビー まだデビュー前！一緒に推しましょー😉✨（私は長身のヒドくん推しです）
Yoo Heedo,,,,,,,,,,I don't care,,,,,,,,,
ヒョンスくんの歌声がかなり心地よすぎて脳内溶ける‥
毎日聴いてます‥
分かります🤤
良いですよね🥺
優しい歌声♪
ヒョンスの隣にヒドがいると、
なんか心地いい❤️
このチームにヒドは欠かせなかったなって思う。
ヒョンスってこんなに透明感ある歌声だったんだ。イントロから歌い出した時点でめっちゃ惹かれた。
ほんとに泣く、、個人的な事情なんだろうけど、ヒドくんずっと応援してた、、、