These are the highest quality “throwaways” I’ve seen since Kendrick dropped Untitled Unmastered. Tyler is a beast. His song writing is great, and his production is freaking amazing.
depends on what amazing means. hes basically amazing at beeing himself. but he so good at it that he is unable to hide it. so hes not what i would call a jack of all trades when it gets to producing....the things he does sound like him and no other. so no wonder justin bieber and other people dont want songs from tyler like earfquake or such. but regardless.....these are hq b side songs, by far not on the level of the kendrick untitled unmastered....but pretty damn solid
Genuinely one of the only b side records that I think are so good that they could've made the album. Tyler feels like he can do no wrong musically anymore
"Tyler feels like he can do no wrong musically anymore" you think HE feels this way, or you think he can do no wrong? What is he r@ped a chicken and then a puppy?
listen to What’s Your Pleasure: The Platinum Edition by Jessie Ware! I wish Melon talked more about those b-sides too - I know “Please” made his Top 50 Singles list
Listening to this made me realize how much Tyler has matured throughout the years especially on SORRY NOT SORRY. He was bold enough to realize and apologize to his family and friends that his work has gotten in the way of not being able to spend time with his loved ones, but at the same time not really feeling all that bad for where he is at right now. Tyler has evolved into this humble adult just living his life and hopefully will enter and take on a new era with us.
i do kinda have a similar mindset to him, through all the stupid shit i've done and the shit that's happened to me, i wouldn't change any of it cause i'm happy with where i am in this current moment in time, and i hope that'll be true years down the road, it's a comforting mentality to have.
@@isaacjones5687 one can be humble and brag at the same time. Tyler is humble in the sense that he knows why he's where he's at, what he can and can't do, and recognizes how important other people are to hid journey.
0:00 Introduction 0:52 STUNTMAN 1:39 WHAT A DAY 2:27 WHARF TALK 2:59 DOGTOOTH 3:29 HEAVEN TO ME 4:42 BOYFRIEND, GIRLFRIEND 5:28 SORRY NOT SORRY 6:55 Extra Comments for all you skippers out there ;)
I always roll my eyes when artists dropped B sides/deluxe albums but Tyler has changed how I feel about them completely. The songs could have been their own album but they add depth to it. Sorry Not Sorry is the true closer of the project
I also think the timing is good. Waiting a year or two seems a lot more interesting and likely to extend the life of the album than putting the deluxe out a month later
Yea usually I don’t care for deluxe editions as well but this was really a treat. Most artist throwaways are just that but this all could’ve easily been a part of main album and keep the vibes going. As a long time fan it all really shows how much he’s progressed especially with the music video’s corresponding to each song and the ever connecting story that’s weaved in for those who are familiar
I think most of these bonus songs are actually better than the tracks on the original album, especially HEAVEN TO ME, but obviously there's that thinking of "well they don't really fit anywhere" so I'm glad he decided to release them because think of how many amazing tracks out there just get left behind
I get that they’re meant to be leftovers, but it really feels like an EP that bookends the CMIYGL era with perspective and evolution that can only come with making some of the songs after the album’s success. It feels like a perfect set up for whatever he does next. I wish more deluxe editions were like this one.
"HEAVEN TO ME" uses a slowed down version of the instrumental from the 2006 John Legend Song "Heaven", which Kanye produced, just to avoid people's confusion. i'm sure Tyler got Kanye's approval, but Kanye didn't just recently create this beat for Tyler.
Honestly it’s so good and the last 6 years of Tyler has been so wonderful I purchased The Estate Sale vinyl even though I already have the non-deluxe version.
Personally, I do not believe "Sorry Not Sorry" is actually a leftover from the CMIYGL sessions. The self-reflection in the lyrics feels like it has to come after the most recent album cycle, and it's just too polished and too conceptually focused to be just a random track that didn't make it. Also, the 2 year delay since the album was released doesn't really make sense from a marketing standpoint if these songs had already been recorded - for reference, Kendrick released Untitled Unmastered only a year after TPAB, and that was a far more complete stand-alone project than The Estate Sale. I would guess that Sorry Not Sorry was recorded much more recently, but Tyler felt it wouldn't fit with his next project, and so he decided to package it with some other leftovers as a conclusion to this era of his catalogue.
sorry not sorry's music video also really highlights the song, showing how he was writing in the styles of his past personas and apologizing on their behalf and showing where he's going next
The deluxe version encouraged me to go back to this album. My first few listens I didn’t really enjoy it but this time around I actually enjoy it more. The new tracks I loved on my first listen
Amazing album, the songs are pretty much a perfect sequence to the original album. I loved the experience and personally think Tyler is one of the most unique and creative artists those days.
In my personal opinion sorry not sorry was the best song out of the CMIYGL era. I was honestly shocked he left that off the album initially, but maybe he knew the video would have more impact between eras!
I loved this project. There's a lot of vulnerability here, and cleverness, with great beats. There's a line where he says "white kids say I brag too much, black kids say it's inspiring, duality is tiring, my girl would kill me if she knew the things I was desiring, suppressing it, get it out the way, I put the sirens in" really hit me hard with the feels and the deep reflection
:) me too melon. A pleasant surprise, and I can’t get over the fact we’re STILL getting a new project. They did not listen to me about him 10+ years ago lol. The new tracks provide some wonderful context.
You could argue the first 6 tracks mirror his album styles Stuntman - Bastard +Goblin What a day - Wolf Warf talk - Cherry Bomb Dogtooth - Flower Boy Heaven to me - Igor Boyfriend, Girlfriend - CMIYGL With the final song, Sorry not sorry, serving to be the climax. It culminates with him literally killing his other persona's, which makes even more sense if you consider the 6 song 6 album theory.
@@ct1296 😂 But I do genuinely believe that theory Stuntman is very wonky with the beat, and in the more aggressive side, which is very reminisicnet of Tyler's early phase with Bastard and Goblin What a Day is very chill and laid back, but introspective. Giving it the vibe Wolf had on tracks like Lone, Slater, Bimer, and to some extent Answer Warf Talk just sounds like a mix of different production, half-hazardly thrown together in a similar function to Cherry Bomb Dogtooth is very uplfiiting but mellow, similar to most of Tyler's rapping on Flower Boy. Heaven to me has a sample that sounds like it would fit well with Igor's alignment Boyfriend, Girlfriend by process of elimination and order of the track arrangement has to be CMIFGL I wouldn't believe that theory outright, if not for the video for Sorry not sorry. Since it has all 6 of Tyler's sruido albums present (keeping in mind there are exactly 6 new songs added), and is thematically killing off those eras for good, we can assume that each song also ties into this concept. These kinda of concepts where Tyler has an ideal with the tracklisting for some of his albums, isn't new by any means.
I don't think this is actually "leftovers" or "less quality songs that didn't make the cut". It is just an addition 2 years later, that's why it's good.
idk if it's because my mood's different from the time when the album came out but i was instantly in love with all the new songs which didn't quite happen with the songs previously released, tho they were good too
All those tracks are fire, normally not much into rap but Tyler is something different. Enjoyed listening to them for the first time on Fantano's twitch
Might be my favorite “deluxe edition” album of all time. I played the deluxe songs way more often than the actual album when it first came out Side note: I had zero idea kanye would reduced heaven to me l, but the first two seconds when I heard that sig. sound I heard Kanye used, I knew he touched this somehow
Fantano a tank, I'll say that much. Saw him in Gmod shows back in like 2011. He voiced dudes in the show. Fantano if youre reading - youre a tank 😤 youre wise and...I respect you
At this point, I think he just doesn't want his album to be more than 14 tracks so he skims it but he knows he has pure fireeeee in his hard drive so he finished them after the release
As a young aspiring homeowner, I have to disagree on your take that the value of a 5% house loan at this age in the current market + monthly payments beats out renting. Honestly the intial cost and lack of stability make home ownership almost unattainable, even with a large sale of sorts. hope to see more sale style content!
“ It is a very groovy piece of bisexual pop-rap with a G-funk twist” is my favorite sentence of all time.
bro i thought u only making shit up until melon actually saying it and it's caught me off guard 💀
Read a book
@@pigchamp3627 read a book 🤓
what a crazy fucking sentence bro
😭
It’s pretty good. My favorite sentence is still “we’re a two-piece slam band called ‘kunt’”.
This "estate sale" was much better than the time my parents house got foreclosed on them in 2009.
omg the nostalgia! it's like we all lived the same childhood! 😍
Is that heaven to you?
@@ifirekirby7498 good quality joke
relatable
THANKS OBAMA
These are the highest quality “throwaways” I’ve seen since Kendrick dropped Untitled Unmastered. Tyler is a beast. His song writing is great, and his production is freaking amazing.
depends on what amazing means. hes basically amazing at beeing himself. but he so good at it that he is unable to hide it. so hes not what i would call a jack of all trades when it gets to producing....the things he does sound like him and no other. so no wonder justin bieber and other people dont want songs from tyler like earfquake or such. but regardless.....these are hq b side songs, by far not on the level of the kendrick untitled unmastered....but pretty damn solid
@@johnnyterra1309 All of those words just to say nothing
@@kingtulip9444 Untitled unmastered is better basically
@@kingtulip9444lmao 😂 that guy is the epitome of trying to be deep
dedicated side B exists
SORRY NOT SORRY has honestly become one of my favorite Tyler tracks of all time. Shit hits diff.
It’s wild how personal yet relatable it is.
@@remhawk73 I CANT SAVE NIGGAS IM NOT SUPER MAN but i could try. SOOOOO REALLLLL
@@remhawk73 it’s mad passionate
The "Fuck em" at the end is just too perfect
sorry not sorry is amazing, very excited to see his next era
era lol
@@xBINARYGODx yeah? the last 4 albums have all been wildly different, you could easily draw a line between eras based on his style and sound
@@xBINARYGODx hahahahahahahahahaha 🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵🫵
@@xBINARYGODx literally DJ dramas exact words
@@xBINARYGODx DJ drama literally said "I guarantee another era is upon us"💀
Genuinely one of the only b side records that I think are so good that they could've made the album. Tyler feels like he can do no wrong musically anymore
yup
"Tyler feels like he can do no wrong musically anymore" you think HE feels this way, or you think he can do no wrong?
What is he r@ped a chicken and then a puppy?
listen to What’s Your Pleasure: The Platinum Edition by Jessie Ware! I wish Melon talked more about those b-sides too - I know “Please” made his Top 50 Singles list
Tyler, Kendrick in recent memory. Who else?
Carly rae B Sides clears
This, Denzel Curry, and Baby Keems Deluxe albums are rare examples of the deluxe versions being worth it
Baby Keem’s Deluxe is so ass what you on about 💀
Don’t forget quadecas FMTY deluxe!
Baby keem? Loool
honestly I didn't think the baby keem deluxe was very good
Baby Keem not it
Listening to this made me realize how much Tyler has matured throughout the years especially on SORRY NOT SORRY. He was bold enough to realize and apologize to his family and friends that his work has gotten in the way of not being able to spend time with his loved ones, but at the same time not really feeling all that bad for where he is at right now. Tyler has evolved into this humble adult just living his life and hopefully will enter and take on a new era with us.
I wouldn’t say humble, because he’s really isnt, but he has matured
Get your tongue out his arse
i do kinda have a similar mindset to him, through all the stupid shit i've done and the shit that's happened to me, i wouldn't change any of it cause i'm happy with where i am in this current moment in time, and i hope that'll be true years down the road, it's a comforting mentality to have.
He def isn’t humble but he is self aware
@@isaacjones5687 one can be humble and brag at the same time. Tyler is humble in the sense that he knows why he's where he's at, what he can and can't do, and recognizes how important other people are to hid journey.
0:00 Introduction
0:52 STUNTMAN
1:39 WHAT A DAY
2:27 WHARF TALK
2:59 DOGTOOTH
3:29 HEAVEN TO ME
4:42 BOYFRIEND, GIRLFRIEND
5:28 SORRY NOT SORRY
6:55 Extra Comments
for all you skippers out there ;)
🐐🐐
daddy
@@joelcomer you gay
ZAMN!
I always roll my eyes when artists dropped B sides/deluxe albums but Tyler has changed how I feel about them completely. The songs could have been their own album but they add depth to it. Sorry Not Sorry is the true closer of the project
Emotion B Sides tho
@@Bedhead13 I was gonna say Carly's B-sides are immense
Fishtail is the true closer of the album, kinda weird it wasn’t included on this version
Denzel Curry dropped a nice Extender edition tho
what all album deluxes should be like
the goat
I also think the timing is good. Waiting a year or two seems a lot more interesting and likely to extend the life of the album than putting the deluxe out a month later
@monke yeah saw and edited lol
Yea usually I don’t care for deluxe editions as well but this was really a treat. Most artist throwaways are just that but this all could’ve easily been a part of main album and keep the vibes going. As a long time fan it all really shows how much he’s progressed especially with the music video’s corresponding to each song and the ever connecting story that’s weaved in for those who are familiar
Sorry Not Sorry is Tyler's Runaway ong
actual masterpiece
His masterpiece is 2seater
his masterpiece probably isnt even out yet
@@Alwljdbdbkd amazing song
@@Alwljdbdbkd okaga, ca better ngl
sorry not sorry honestly reminds me more of diand sonically
i loved rocky's verse on wharf talk. something abt how smooth and silky he delivers it just really grabbed my ears, but i wish it was a bit longer
I really thought we were gonna get the first official review for a deluxe album
congratulations on 100k my nigga 🤝
Does LUV vs the World 2, Brown Boy 2 and Neon Shark count?
@@clementinelives ty brooo
@@largegrainofsand I mean I guesssss, but those were all like 12+ extra
@@critiqueeverything3297 thank you man
bisexual pop rap with a G-funk twist might be the greatest genre title I've ever heard
IKR
I think most of these bonus songs are actually better than the tracks on the original album, especially HEAVEN TO ME, but obviously there's that thinking of "well they don't really fit anywhere" so I'm glad he decided to release them because think of how many amazing tracks out there just get left behind
I get that they’re meant to be leftovers, but it really feels like an EP that bookends the CMIYGL era with perspective and evolution that can only come with making some of the songs after the album’s success. It feels like a perfect set up for whatever he does next. I wish more deluxe editions were like this one.
totally agreed.
it reminds me of a longer version of how Best Interest felt when it dropped. kind of a late epilogue to the album
@@MINMOMINMOMINMO totally agreed
"HEAVEN TO ME" uses a slowed down version of the instrumental from the 2006 John Legend Song "Heaven", which Kanye produced, just to avoid people's confusion. i'm sure Tyler got Kanye's approval, but Kanye didn't just recently create this beat for Tyler.
Damnnnn, knowing the deep cuts.
Honestly it’s so good and the last 6 years of Tyler has been so wonderful I purchased The Estate Sale vinyl even though I already have the non-deluxe version.
i mean if you don’t want that non-deluxe i’ll take it off your hands
Tyler is actually a superhuman. Literally can't stop making awesome stuff
Personally, I do not believe "Sorry Not Sorry" is actually a leftover from the CMIYGL sessions. The self-reflection in the lyrics feels like it has to come after the most recent album cycle, and it's just too polished and too conceptually focused to be just a random track that didn't make it. Also, the 2 year delay since the album was released doesn't really make sense from a marketing standpoint if these songs had already been recorded - for reference, Kendrick released Untitled Unmastered only a year after TPAB, and that was a far more complete stand-alone project than The Estate Sale. I would guess that Sorry Not Sorry was recorded much more recently, but Tyler felt it wouldn't fit with his next project, and so he decided to package it with some other leftovers as a conclusion to this era of his catalogue.
We all know Call Me is his best album. Best vibe, best character, most entertaining, perfectly produced. Masterpiece
I think Igor is all of those thing cmifygl is super good tho easily second place to Igor (meat riding I know)
Nooooooo Tyler became a landlord 😭😭😭
Sorry not sorry will make melon’s top 50 songs of the year, I’m calling it right now. Amazing record.
You’re not wrong
sorry not sorry's music video also really highlights the song, showing how he was writing in the styles of his past personas and apologizing on their behalf and showing where he's going next
The deluxe version encouraged me to go back to this album. My first few listens I didn’t really enjoy it but this time around I actually enjoy it more. The new tracks I loved on my first listen
Amazing album, the songs are pretty much a perfect sequence to the original album. I loved the experience and personally think Tyler is one of the most unique and creative artists those days.
In my personal opinion sorry not sorry was the best song out of the CMIYGL era. I was honestly shocked he left that off the album initially, but maybe he knew the video would have more impact between eras!
I’ve literally been listening to these new tracks since Friday.
And they get better!
I could see almost any of these on the original album track list.
SORRY NOT SORRY is definitely Tyler's Magnum Opus.
I loved this project. There's a lot of vulnerability here, and cleverness, with great beats. There's a line where he says "white kids say I brag too much, black kids say it's inspiring, duality is tiring, my girl would kill me if she knew the things I was desiring, suppressing it, get it out the way, I put the sirens in" really hit me hard with the feels and the deep reflection
:) me too melon. A pleasant surprise, and I can’t get over the fact we’re STILL getting a new project. They did not listen to me about him 10+ years ago lol. The new tracks provide some wonderful context.
Fantano selling his house and moving in with Tyler? Never would've guessed
Tyler is undoubtedly one the best producers of our this generation. 🌟
5:05 BISEXUAL POP RAP 💀💀💀💀
1:02
I think it was a kooky beat
I just wanted to point out, "HEAVEN TO ME" has Ye sampled as a writer/producer due to his production on the original sample, Heaven by John Legend
Which again, samples another song lol
that "forever" at the end got me extra good this time 😭😭
but seriously what an album man, cannot wait for this years album. it's gonna go so fucking hard.
Call Me If You Get Lost was the soundtrack to summer 2021
It's super good but I still hope we get a new record from Tyler this year
Why was Sorry not Sorry not in the core album 😂 it‘s so good
sorry not sorry is one of the best songs made ever ever ever
Completely agree. Saved so much, the Walmart CEOs are amazing.
It’s an amazing EP attachment to the album.
You could argue the first 6 tracks mirror his album styles
Stuntman - Bastard +Goblin
What a day - Wolf
Warf talk - Cherry Bomb
Dogtooth - Flower Boy
Heaven to me - Igor
Boyfriend, Girlfriend - CMIYGL
With the final song, Sorry not sorry, serving to be the climax. It culminates with him literally killing his other persona's, which makes even more sense if you consider the 6 song 6 album theory.
bro I hope you did a substantial number of warm up exercises before deciding to reach like that
@@ct1296 😂 But I do genuinely believe that theory
Stuntman is very wonky with the beat, and in the more aggressive side, which is very reminisicnet of Tyler's early phase with Bastard and Goblin
What a Day is very chill and laid back, but introspective. Giving it the vibe Wolf had on tracks like Lone, Slater, Bimer, and to some extent Answer
Warf Talk just sounds like a mix of different production, half-hazardly thrown together in a similar function to Cherry Bomb
Dogtooth is very uplfiiting but mellow, similar to most of Tyler's rapping on Flower Boy.
Heaven to me has a sample that sounds like it would fit well with Igor's alignment
Boyfriend, Girlfriend by process of elimination and order of the track arrangement has to be CMIFGL
I wouldn't believe that theory outright, if not for the video for Sorry not sorry. Since it has all 6 of Tyler's sruido albums present (keeping in mind there are exactly 6 new songs added), and is thematically killing off those eras for good, we can assume that each song also ties into this concept. These kinda of concepts where Tyler has an ideal with the tracklisting for some of his albums, isn't new by any means.
sorry but most of these are crazy reachs that I cant see at all
@@Iegoshi I mean maybe 😂
Still not as crazy as Drake calling clb, honestly never mind, and her loss a trilogy lol
wharf talk has more the igor sound tbh
Melon broke out the yellow flannel😏
Sorry Not Sorry is one of my favorite songs of 2023 so far.
Love the talk around this. It’s a much more “traditional” deluxe but the way he did it was 150% better than the rest
Sorry Not Sorry is better than any song on the original. The Estate Sale is a tremendously good deluxe edition
RISE! And WILSHIRE don't exist?
Fantano, the heaven to me beat was made by ye all the way back in 2010 for John legend, Tyler just took the beat and used it in his song
Same for the madlib beat
I wasnt a massive fan of CMIYGL but this expansion is prob my favorite "album" of tyler so far
Bro same
These 7 songs are better than Igor and cmiygl and flower boy?
I normally don’t like deluxe albums and don’t listen to them but this one was SO GOODD I have all the songs added to my playlist 👍🏽👏🏽👏🏽
The fact that these almost just remained unreleased throwaways is crazy
tyler gotta drop a new album this year or he'll ruin the arithmetic progression.
Well he has 8 days left lol
Anthony at 4:33 going full Pops from regular show with his voice hit different
I don't think this is actually "leftovers" or "less quality songs that didn't make the cut". It is just an addition 2 years later, that's why it's good.
idk if it's because my mood's different from the time when the album came out but i was instantly in love with all the new songs which didn't quite happen with the songs previously released, tho they were good too
Happy late 10th birthday to Tyler’s Wolf album!
Such a w take my lord
GANGSTA BRAZILL: The Estate Sale.
Damn near died when I listened to WHAT A DAY. I fucking loooove that beat and I’m glad I can stream it now.
Madlib did an amazing job here (as one should expect from him)
All those tracks are fire, normally not much into rap but Tyler is something different. Enjoyed listening to them for the first time on Fantano's twitch
He forgot to mention the most important part of Heaven to me. “The Ice cream shoes and Mr.Krab watch”
Dogtooth might have the best beat on the album imo
plus what a dayyy
Melon, you cant just give it a 0 because the song isnt called "Melon To Me"
mom wake up new genre of music just dropped (bisexual pop-rap with a g-funk twist)
You should've given some of that love to The great escape but it's ok Anthony, just don't forget to close your windows tonight
you’re radiating bisexual light 9 vibes here
I feel like even if tylers new alblum is a miss we can all still forgive him because of how consistent hes been since 2017
You know what, Mr. Tony? Me too.
I wish he had put estate sale an ep by itself.. Its that good..
Ye so good that even after melon cancelled him he still had to mention the soul chops
bought the CD from Australia for $60 when the website went up. Just the first teasers looked amazing.
sorry not sorry is probably one of my favorite tyler tracks
Sorry not sorry is awesome
Might be my favorite “deluxe edition” album of all time. I played the deluxe songs way more often than the actual album when it first came out
Side note: I had zero idea kanye would reduced heaven to me l, but the first two seconds when I heard that sig. sound I heard Kanye used, I knew he touched this somehow
Heaven To Me gotta be like top 5 Tyler songs of all time
I really wish it was released as its own, like Untitled Unmastered, it could’ve stood on its own quite well
This may sound insane to say, but the estate sale is easily some of my favourite Tyler,
Your insane by Eminem of the album relapse
Tyler is about to release his own Mr Morale
Who would’ve thought the stereotypical artsy type would like Tyler’s expansion
What a day is an incredible song
I didn't initially listen to the album when it came out, so this edition feels well rounded and near perfect I'd say.
thanks melon, it's so important to praise music like this
The Melon Sale
i love it too, stainedthony shirtano
The door cracked slightly open in the background got me feeling uneasy like a nightshade's gonna pop out. Excellent review melon!
The estate sale da 🐐 no 🧢
Hahahaha
What a day is such a phenomenal track
Mafia/ Coke boss Tyler coming next 👀
i wonder if that yellow flannel is some super gucci custom made flannel that costs like 34372098 dollars like zuccs gray ass tshirts. funk melon flex
This estate sale really tickled my balls too Anthony.
Fantano a tank, I'll say that much.
Saw him in Gmod shows back in like 2011. He voiced dudes in the show.
Fantano if youre reading - youre a tank 😤 youre wise and...I respect you
I’m flummoxed, flabbergasted even that some of these weren’t on the album
At this point, I think he just doesn't want his album to be more than 14 tracks so he skims it but he knows he has pure fireeeee in his hard drive so he finished them after the release
He couldn’t miss if he tried. We’re witnessing one of the best runs oat
Wharf Talk’s a bop!
As a young aspiring homeowner, I have to disagree on your take that the value of a 5% house loan at this age in the current market + monthly payments beats out renting. Honestly the intial cost and lack of stability make home ownership almost unattainable, even with a large sale of sorts.
hope to see more sale style content!
Love the album and this deluxe made me love it even more. This is what a deluxe should be