Les Miserables Fantine comparison - I Dreamed A Dream
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- I put as many different portrayals here as I could. If a certain actor doesn't appear here I either couldn't find or didn't have audio/video of them singing the song, or they didn't perform the role until after the video was published.
Rose Laurens, Patti LuPone, Hiromi Iwasaki, Randy Graff, Debra Byrne, Maureen Moore, Elinore O'Connell, Sona MacDonald, Hollis Resnik, Jill Hayman, Christy Baron, Marina Prior, Pia Douwes, Ria Jones, Gema Castano, Rachel York, Claire Moore, Yuhko Ema, Catherine Hickland, Paige O'Hara, Ruthie Henshall, Cornelia Drese, Rebecca Storm, Laurie Beechman, Dianne Pilkington, Hilde Norga, Rachel Beck, Alice Ripley, Nancy Leach, Gunilla Backman, Elena Roger, Alejandra Desiderio, Thursday Farrar, Jenna Russell, Grania Renihan, Jacquelyn Piro, Lauren Kennedy, Carmen Cusack, Jayne Paterson, Yumiko Takahashi, Ann-Christin Elverum, Joanna Ampil, Linda Pierson Huff, Wiebke Woetzel, Kerry Ellis, Joan Almedilla, Jana Werner, Sophia Ragavelas, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Simone, Nikki Renee Daniels, Rona Figueroa, Judy Kuhn, Nurlaila Karim, Jessica Bogart, Melora Hardin, Allyson Brown, Genevieve Charest, Natalie Day, Madalena Alberto, Virginia Carmona, Edyta Krzemien, Lea Salonga, Betsy Morgan, Rhiannon Sarah Porter, Rebecca Seale, Cornelia Luna, Caroline Sheen, Sierra Boggess, Jessica Keenan Wynn, Anne Hathaway, Anna Sato, AJ Callaghan, Cho Jung-Eun, Charlotte Maltby, Bettina Moench, Genevieve Leclerc, Na-Young Jeon, Melanie Bright, Caissie Levy, Celinde Schoenmaker, Melissa O'Neil, Alison Blackwell, Megan Osterhaus, Elena Medina, Daniella Dalli, Erika Henningsen, Margaret Kelly, Rina Chinen, Patrice Tipoki, Kate Fahrner, Rachelle Ann Go, Paula Potosky
I love Ruthie's growl and Lea's clarity. They're still my favorite Fantine.
Agree.... I couldn't understand a word Edyta Krzemien was singing
mine too...
but why is nobody talking about caissie levy as fantine?? she leaves it ALL on the stage, she's so passionate and digs into the character, as well as having an extraordinary voice
i know right?
DUDE. She’s amazing as both Fantine and Elsa
SHES MY FAVE
Ava Pirie she’s my favorite fantine ever!
she is my favorite of all, she is just amazing
At least 4 disney princesses played Fantine then (Jasmine, Mulan, Belle and Pocahontas)
Leslie Elsa!
And Elsa
I was gonna say Elsa.. Making it 5
Ariel too!
@@yippedoodah Totally forgot the little mermaid happened on Broadway.. lol
I absolutely adore Ruthie Henshall's Fantine!
Fantastic Rose Laurens...
Everyone basically had to recreate everything Patti Lupone did in the original production. Shows become frozen and everyone following has to follow the character the originator created
Patti created the Fantine we all know. It's very hard to build a character from scratch. Very easy to add your flourishes to something that has already been built for you. Patti deserves credit from all.
But she sounds awful.
WHOA. Two Ariels, Cady, Elsa, AND Heather Chandler were all Fantine
And two Elphabas
And a Christine Daaé!
@@kp4692 that was an Ariel lol
and a Miss Honey
and a Jasmine.
Rose Laurens is amazing too! She set Fantine for everyone and she sounded AMAZING as Fantine. Everyone did as well!
Imo Ruthie Henshall by far the one who has sung this song the best.
Woah! Paige O' Hara (AKA the original voice of Belle) played Fantine on Broadway?!
I've been looking for audio of "Belle" as FANTINE everywhere!
Fun fact, Jana Werner (german voice of belle) played Fantine in Germany :D
Honestly, kind of perfect.
Jessica Keenan Wynn is positively the cutest fantine!
Patti LuPone, Ruthie Henshall, Lea Salonga, and Rachelle Ann Go❤💙💚💛💜
caissie Levy’s performance gives me chills each time I watch it
I *love* that "throbbing"quality in Randy Graff's voice. Rachel York is probably my other favorite (I saw her in the role in 1992).
Patti Lupone and Ruthie henshell are my favourite Fantine’s because they have amazing singing voices
Patti LuPone,Randy Graff, Elinore O'Connell, Christy Baron, Marina Prior,Rachel York, Claire Moore, Ruthie Henshall, Rachel Beck, Alice Ripley,Jacquelyn Piro,Carmen Cusack, Joanna Ampil, Joan Almedilla, Simone, Judy Kuhn, Nurlaila Karim, Madalena Alberto, Lea Salonga, Betsy Morgan, Sierra Boggess, Anne Hathaway, Anna Sato, Na-Young Jeon,Caissie Levy, Celinde Schoenmaker,Elena Medina, Patrice Tipoki and Rachelle Ann Go.
1. Ruthie Henshall 2. Lea Salonga 3. Rachelle Ann Go 4. Sierra Boggess.
Holy crap, this is amazing!! You have so many recordings!!! Wow! I love all of the foreign languages!
i love randy graff's version, the amount of emotion she puts really hits me
To moi....there is only one Fantine and she is Ruthie Henshall.
Pure raw talent that always leaves you wanting more.
Bravo Madame Ruthie ! ⭐️⭐️👏👏👏🇨🇦
Rose Laurens... wow.
Rachelle Ann Go is amazing :)
I saw her a eliza in Hamilton
Ruthie Henshall is the best, by a long way. She encompasses Fantine's soul and heartbreak, perfectly.
Sierra Boggess was very good, though.
I saw her play Fantine, in the West End and she was fucking amazing.
My favourite is Celinde Schoenmaker I was lucky to see her 4 times and she was amazing the first time and simply phenomenal the fourth, SHEER PERFEC TION. I DONT LOOK DOWN ON ANY OF THE OTHERS WHO HAVE PLAYED FANTINE BECAUSE TO BELT OUT THIS LES MIS CLASSIC YOU HAVE TO HAVE AN AWESOME VOICE.
Jessica Keenan Wynn was Fantine? Woah! Heather Chandler and Fantine are two very different roles yet she slayed both! Anne Hathaway was my fav tho😍😍😍
Still to this day one of my favorite songs! Thank you for this!
I love broadway and I always have, I've always loved this one especially, and *especially* this piece, but it fucking baffles me that anyone at all can listen to these one after the other and then still attempt to claim that Anne didn't do it justice in the movie. She honestly reinvented this piece, this entire character. She finally gave Fantine the actual emotion her character has written. This piece in particular. No one has brought the emotion as well as Anne has. Especially not the anger. Everyone is quick to mention Lea as the best, but she portrays Fantine as this forever hopefuly and bubbly character. Every time I have ever seen her or seen videos of her, she smiles through out this entire piece, and most of the show in general. Also tends to have those few pretty actress tears during this piece. Anne is the first to have finally brought that real rough and raw despair, and finally the anger Fantine allows herself to feel.
Vixey Lazer amen. Amen. Watching this video getting more and more annoyed with everyone’s lack of pain. Fantine is supposed to be *broken* .didn’t get that from anyone apart from Anne Hathaway
She was by far the best from an acting perspective (she's a great singer too), but I think a lot of people didn't like the film arrangement.
I agree but the film media allows this with the camera close up and all. It’s different on stage, live.
So many incredible actresses have played Fantine. Pretty much all of my favourite performers have been there at some point.
Of the all the Fantines listed, I've had the pleasure of seeing Joan Almedilla, Simone, and Charlotte Maltby. All three were breathtaking, but Simone and Charlotte were just so damn heartbreaking.
Do you know were I can find Simone's video?
Rose Laurens (first singer) CRUSHED IT HARD. So much emotion
Judy Kuhn: I hear Pocahontas at the end "seemed"!
I saw Rachelle Ann Go twice and she was sooo amazing!!
That Korean set! Holy crap! That was beautiful!
This must have been so hard to put together!!! Great job!
My only beef with this video, and indeed with videos comparing various Fantines, is that there is never audio of Kate Hathaway. I'm curious to know what Anne Hathaway's mother sounded like singing the role.
I know, right? Kate would have been fantastic!
That's literally why I listened to it tbh 😂!!
For my money Lea Salonga is the best one on here because of the sheer emotion she brings to it. She doesn't just sing it she acts it. But i have not been able to find Paige O Hara anywhere except on here and she sounds great too. But the sheer power and precision of Lea Salonga makes her the best for me.
I saw Patrice Tipoki (24:37) live and I teared up because she was so good omg
I saw her live as well and I was withholding tears from falling. so much passion
Caissie Levy and Rachelle Ann Go are my favesssss
I love Ruthie Henshall.
1:10 debra bryne is a perfect example that all vibrato is not good vibrato
my favorites
Ruthie Henshall : 5:28
Lea Salonga : 17:01
Sierra Boggess : 18:39
Anne Hathaway : 19:14
Erika Henningsen : 23:46
Rachelle Ann Go : 25:10
Rachelle Ann Go is amazing and she is definitley one of my favourites! But I absoloutley love Celinde Schoenmaker!!! I feel as though this video didn't represent her very well but she is honestly spectacular!!!
1. LEA SALONGA 2. Randy Graff 3. Rachelle Ann Go 4. Ruthie Henshall
man i love patti lupone but her fantine grinds my gears from the emotion she doesn't show
favourites are rachel york, ruthie henshall, rachelle ann go, gema castano, rachel beck, alice ripley, gunilla backman, elena roger, alejandra desiderio, betsy morgan, cornelia luna, cho jung-eun and celinde schoenmaker 👌
I was on vacation in Mexico City in 2003 and I had the great opportunity to enjoy Les MIserables. That night I saw Alejandra Desiderio playing Fantine, she was understudy, my GOd! what a power! what a feeling! what a voice! strong, passionate...one of the best that I ve ever seen in my life.
Debbie Byrne was Fantine in the Complete Symphonic Recording, it's a much better recording of her singing the song than what's here.
HOLY COW.... does anyone have a full clip of Simone's performance?? Those few seconds (13:31) were breathtaking! I had no idea Nina Simone's daughter had performed this role.
I'm trying to find it... She was amazing
My favorites are Kerry, Ruthie, Caissie, Anne, Simone, Sierra, Na-Young-Jean, Rachelle, Rose, Claire, and Yuhko. It’s a lot I know but these women are incredible
Rachelle Ann Go and Celinde Schoenmaker ❤️❤️❤️
Alison Blackwell is phenomenal, would love to see her full performance.
2:29
4:27
5:29
6:02
6:44
7:16
7:30
8:03
9:06
9:23
9:38
10:14
11:22
12:10
12:27
12:59
13:47
17:02
17:33
Ruthie Henshall hands down.
Thank you for this
Jan from The Office?? Guess her candle selling didn't work out.
Lea and Ruthie are the best for me and the new Fantine Rachelle 😁
ruth henshall lea salonga have made the soulful performance, but all of them were awesome.
they are the best...but Rachelle Ann Go is just amazing the new leading lady of cameron
im crying i didnt know judy kuhn played fantine too
but anyways i cried like 50 times watching this fantine deserves the WORLD
And Jessica Keenan Wynn!!! (Who originally played Heather Chandler in Heathers the musical!!)
Joan Almedilla, Lea Salonga, and Jessica Keenan Wynn❤❤❤
I love Judy Kuhn, Lea Salonga and Ruthie Henshall!
Go Rachelle Ann Go!!!
I just cried... that was so funny omg you made my day 😂🙆
Rose Laurens , Patti Lu Pone and Madelena Alberto. Hands down. The thing about these three is- They play fantine HARD SHES HARD bitter, angry, not romantic, thats cosettes role, a Fantine MUST BE HARD MUST BE ANGRY MUST BE BITTER.. These 3 in 30 years are the best.
My absolutely favorite performances on here. My Top 10: These are all Completely Different Interpretations that just vary from one another - Randi Graff, Judy Kuhn, Ruthie Henshall, Nikki Renee Daniels, Anne Hathaway , Cassie Levy, Jessica Bogart, Rachelle Anne Go, Kerri Ellis and Lea Salonga. Special shout-outs: Simone, and Maureen Moore.
Patti and Sierra are my favorites
Debra Byrne for me. She acts as well as just sings, great emotion, you feel her frustration
I’ve listened to Randy on the original cast recording so much she is Fantine to me but I saw it, 3xs on Broadway in the 90s and once in early 2000s that wasn’t my favorite.
This is the first ever Les miserables video where not everyone comments about Lea's gracefulness
Ruth Hanshell Ann Hathaway Randy Graff Sierra Boggess and Lea Salonga
Cho Jungeun is incredible!
Caisse Levy and Anne Hathaway
On another note, Patti LuPone got called a clod to her face, if you know what I'm talking about.
I'll go for LEA and RACHEL
I am very confused as to why there is no one talking about Rachel York, Shes freaking amazing!
I love Claire Moore, Ruthie Henshall, Jayne Paterson, Joana Ampil, Anne Hathaway, Rachel Ann Go, and Lea Salonga as Fantine
I actually think Anne H captures the hopelessness of Fantine quite well.
I know broadway or an official les mis but Susan Boyle gave one of the best renditions
Lea Salonga is the best. She played Fantine on the West End and on Broadway and not just in the 25th Anniversary Concert.
Easy one - Randy Graff - always will be - her phrasing is unmatched. Listen to Orig Brdwy Recording
Of this bunch, I've seen Betsy Morgan and Caissie Levy live
I love Ruthie's but Lea's singing and acting are undoubtedly phenomenal.
Trying to find out what soundtrack I used to have by listening to this
I just love Jenna Russell's voice. I think their were better Fantine's, but her voice is just so different from everyone else's and I love it.
Holy crap!!! Caissie Levy as Fantine is the best of the best she has the most amazing voice and she is so insanely talented hands down caissie you rule!
Love Celinde Schoenmaker and Jessica Keenan Wynn
Ruthie Henshall will always be the GOAT, no one else comes close, even the other greats are not on her level
I love Daphne in Rent but just..... no.
If they decided to switch the song around and make it more gritty like the movie (yes I know this was 06) Daphne’s version could have worked
Fun Fact: The "shame" was originally supposed to be sung as a flat note while only the orchestra went up. Patti LuPoune, who iconically originated the role, also chose to have the note go with the orchestra. Now everyone sings it like her lol. Musical Theatre History 101
Actually it was Rose who originated the role
Nice one! But you could have added Hiromi Itoh - Japan 1994, Marcia - Japan 2003 and Rumi Iryo - Japan 2003
Debra Byrne💗💗💗
I just dont get it... who let Daphine Rubin Vega be Fantine, dont get me wrong shes talented, but she aint Fantine
Ria Jones is the best followed by Ruthie Henshall, both musical theatre legends!!
16:30 Virginia Carmona is amazing!
Caissie Levy
Debra Byrne for me! Her acting of the song was far superior.
How I wish to find Simone's version, because she was amazing!
WHY IS NO ONE TALKING ABOUT KERRY FREAKING ELLIS !!!!
Nikki Renee Daniels and Betsy Morgan are easily the strongest Fantine's I have seen.
elinore o’connell
*looks at thumbnail
Oh cool, Walnut Street Theatre’s on here😊 (from PA)