Brock Purdy ranked outside of Top-10 QBs, Is he being disrespected? | NFL | THE CARTON SHOW
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- San Francisco 49ers Brock Purdy was ranked outside of the Top-10 QBs by executives, coaches and scouts. Craig Carton and crew weigh in on this list.
#TheCartonShow #NFL #BrockPurdy
SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from The Carton Show: sprtspod.fox/Su...
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4...
►Watch the latest content from The Carton Show: sprtspod.fox/Th...
▶First Things First's TH-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
►UNDISPUTED’s TH-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
►SPEAK's TH-cam channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
►The Skip Bayless Show TH-cam Channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
►What's Wright? with Nick Wright TH-cam Channel: sprtspod.fox/wh...
Follow The Carton Show on Twitter: / thecartonshow
Like The Carton Show on Facebook: / thecartonshowonfs1
Follow The Carton Show on Instagram: / thecartonshow
Follow The Carton Show on TikTok: / thecartonshow
About The Carton Show:
The Carton Show is a daily sports show live from New York City featuring Craig Carton, who will take on the day's breaking stories alongside a rotating group of co-hosts. Watch The Carton Show Monday-Friday at 7 AM ET on FS1.
Brock Purdy ranked outside of Top-10 QBs, Is he being disrespected? | NFL | THE CARTON SHOW
• Brock Purdy ranked out...
The Carton Show
/ thecartonshow
Subscribe to First Things First now: www.youtube.com/@FirstThingsFirst
Pure QB?! He led the league in almost every statistical category. Try again.
Game manager, system qb, not a pure natural qb. Pretty soon they’ll run out of dumb ways to discredit Purdy.
I know, it's insane. Highest QBR average for the entire season, and he's not even top 10?
lol and he doesn't take issue with a RB (Lamar) being 4th!
And he put that season together without a training camp! Remember he was recovering from elbow surgery and he missed all of training camp.
As far as passing is concerned Lamar Jackson is not a top 25 QB in the league. He just isn't.
Who ever says purdy doesnt make unscheduled plays is smoking rocks.
A video was just posted on Twitter this weekend with 2 minutes of his scrambling off-schedule plays & I just wish all of the haters would be forced to watch it lol
@vincenttalley5938 the disrespect is out of control. I can't believe dak Prescott is 10 that blows my mind. Choosing the bigger guy with the bigger arm and higher draft number so he can use all that ability to throw to the opposing team come playoffs
It’s all gravy baby. Brock will win mvp this year
They say it because they don’t watch him play
@@JC-hq7iu yessir🙌
He's not a pure Qb??? Hes one of the most pure qbs..all the other guys are just big arm guys.
Being an athlete at the QB position in today's game is required. Don't worry, we will erase that. Brady didn't have a big arm either. But winning SBs erased all of that BS. Brock has to win a SB.
@@marvingibson9431 Then why are we hyping up people like Lamar, Allen, Herbert, Dak?
He is a amazing system qb....but...he isnt the outlier on the team. That is the problem with brock
@marvingibson9431 Brady did have a strong arm, he just used it sparingly.
@@packers12to80 is Jared Goff a outlier on his team?
People forget Mahomes came in a great chiefs team with a great coach same situation as Purdy but they still can't give Purdy any credit!
Well, maybe because he must show he's a consistent winner, and actually win the game first before he can be considered Mahomes, to get the credit. But he did play well in the SB.
@@Esb906Facts my G. And I’m a Niner fan since 87. If Niners had any of those top 10 QB’s instead of Purdy we would’ve won the SB
Eh, Mahomes is in a league of his own, and the second best QB in the NFL is an injured Mahomes. And I'm a 49er fan, btw, not a Chiefs homer. He's just that good. And you could see it in college if you pay attention. It's unfortunate the 49ers passed on him twice (traded down from 2, still didn't take him at 3).
None of that means Brock isn't one of the best QBs, and he's on his way to being a great one. But no one is ever catching Mahomes unless he has a career injury or nosedives. Mahomes does all the improvisational stuff Brock does, except he has a stronger arm, and does even more amazing things. Sorry, but that's just the reality. Brock will never be as good as Mahomes. But that doesn't mean he can't reach the Hall of Fame. Just has to continue this trajectory.
He also said mahomes elevates players & has never had a decent WR, tyreek hill ring a bell
Exactly. Nobody seems to point that out or remember that. mahomes was handed the keys to the Ferrari after Alex Smith
Short answer, yes. All the people who say his team helps him win should rewatch the lions game last year, he beat the lions, not the 9ers.
Thank you
😂😂😂😂 🧢
Many things needed to happen in order for Brock to have thrived in that game. He did his thing, but it was a whole team effort!
Not impressive at all, goff outplayed him while going up against a top 3 defense meanwhile Purdy was struggling against a terrible lions defense ranked bottom 5 in the league , let that sink in
@@Elusivve guess you are feeling sad in detroit
Brock Purdy since he took over vs Miami, is first in wins, second in touchdowns, second in completion percentage, and first in passer rating. Only three QBs in NFL history had a higher DVOA rating than Brock’s 2023 season Peyton Manning in 2004/2006, Dan Marino in 1984, and Tom Brady in 2007. Brock also broke the record for adjusted yards per attempt in NFL history after tearing his UCL. He lead his team to two NFC championships and one SB, and possibly would have made two SBs in his first two seasons, despite the 49ers bottom 10 pass blocking unit. He’s beat Dak multiple times… once in the playoffs, he beat Stafford on the road, and he beat Goff in the playoffs. Purdy is easily a top 10 QB.
I have a feeling that once he breaks through and gets his first ring, he's gonna end up with a few more in a very short time.
Purdy disrespect continues with another stupid list. Burrow and Rodgers didn't even play last year. Herbert has done nothing. Dak chokes in the playoffs. Stroud has one year. Again Lamar and Allen lost in the playoffs.
Then swear up and down that if you put Purdy on any of those other teams, he outperforms those QBs. Go ahead.
Brock lost in the playoffs too to the same exact team Allen and Lamar lost to. Agree completely with Dak but I’m sorry, if you really think Brock is better than Aaron Rodgers because he tore his Achilles, you’re just delusional. Joe Burrow and Allen? Cmon man Brock hasn’t done enough to be considered better than those two by anyone serious
@@Joes35 Haven't done enough? There is only 4 QB's on that list that have had a better season then Purdy on that list.
@@Joes35 Lamar threw into triple coverage to send his team home. Jake Moody missed an extra point in the SB, which eventually sent it to OT. They are not the same.
Rodgers dak and justin H shouldn't be on it. Love and Brock deserve to be there.
Yes. Purdy is easily top 10. Brilliant QB.
Purdy showed in the playoffs he could make unscheduled plays, the o line broke down on him so many times, and I can make the argument his line is the worst out of all those qb’s you put over him and he still had better numbers
He's showed he can make unscheduled plays literally his entire career, and college too.
One defensive stop and we are world Champs. Blame the D, not Brock!
I love how people say Brock’s success is due to his teammates; and then they ignore Tampa’s receivers, Miami’s receivers, Seattle, Philly, Minnesota, Detroit, and how none of their quarterbacks can match Purdy’s numbers.
I agree bro!!
I agree too
Naturally Hurts won't match a lot of QBs #s being that he's a different kind of QB. A dual QB.
None of those teams are loaded on both sides of the ball, AND have an offensive genius leading them. Sorry Purdy is gifted and is gifted with a great team around him. Plus, how do you explain when the Niners went through key injuries in the middle of the season, the team's play took an IMMEDIATE DOWN TURN with three loses in a row! Purdy's play went down too?
@@michaelwallace2487 Do you actually remember those games? Cleveland we lost on a missed kick after Purdy drove down the field in the rain; in Minnesota Purdy threw for 272 yards but Cousins went crazy with 378 yards; then the Bengals game was Joe Burrow's only good game last year so he smoked us.
The point is Brock Purdy's had 2 bad games in his career, other than that he's been money. I'm not going to get carried away and say he's the best, but if he keeps playing like he has you won't be able to argue with it.
Purdy have more playoff wins than most of those guys .
Weird why they put Burrow and Rodger’s on the top 10 when they didn’t even play last season
Brock purdy took aiyuk into a big name. Aiyuk was nothing with jimmy g
OMG this is what I been saying for so long!!! If you look at Aiyuks numbers before 2023, the dude was not even a thousand yard receiver!! He was a bum!
Ehh... So by this logic, Jimmy G turned Deebo into a big name lol? I mean, Purdy is good no doubt, but the acquisition of CMC really helped free up some things in the passing game. Aiyuk was in the "doghouse" with Shanahan in 2021 but in 2022 he had over 1,000 yards with Jimmy G at the helm for over half of the season. Aiyuk was always ascending.
@@MJordanUX why would adding another running back be the reason Deebo began to have good numbers? QB is literally the one to throw the ball to the receivers so yea, there is a correlation.
@@Tackleqb I was talking about Aiyuk’s numbers for that part. But unlike other RBs, CMC is also a huge part of the passing game. He creates more spacing. Go look at WR “yards of separation” post-CMC. Deebo, Kittle & Aiyuk all had huge gains, Aiyuk with +.8 (aka wide open). Look at EPA/per play. And this was with Jimmy too. Defenses have more all-pro threats to worry about, the overall offense is more dangerous, Shanny can scheme crazy. While Purdy is obviously superior, Jimmy was also scoring more, gaining more, throwing less INTs & undefeated when CMC was fully integrated (also had top 3 passer rating lol).
Bro in the middle has no idea what a “Pure QB” is. Just saying a name Justin Herbert doesn’t describe a Pure QB. A Pure QB is Processing, Reading Pre-Snap and Post-Snap coverages, etc. which are called “intangibles.” Brock is elite in all of those so I really don’t get his point. Lol.
💯
He probably meant pure thrower, or ideal physical build for a QB.
@@eliteteamkiller319 I know you ain’t trying to argue like that, but isn’t a pure thrower at more pocket specific QB? If he meant physic than I’ll just got ahead and give him that lol
Literally what flaw does Herbert have other than team success he has great pocket presence, goes thru progressions, can extend plays with his feet, cannon of an arm, not turnover prone, amazing deep ball like what is it probably anticipation but that has a lot to do with play calling
@@mac9108 He overthrew Keenan Allen all last year it was super frustrating. Herbert has alot to prove still, having a cannon of an arm isn't everything.
Obviously, scouts still haven't watched tape of Brock Purdy
Well let's be fair here, no scouts thought he was worth drafting. I recall it being klay Kubiak who wanted to draft him and he had to convince Brian Griese he was woth it and with the help of Steve Slowik they pulled all the info together so Brian could make the case to Kyle. Kyle wanted to grab him as a free agent but Brian to him not to give Purdy a choice as a few other teams were also looking at him as a fa.
How come nobody acknowledging he made it to the superbowl in his first full season
Goff over Purdy 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😂😂😂😅😅😅😅😅
And who won? And who ran for 1st downs in the playoff game when needed?
@@emeraldphotography7363he laughing they put him over Goff g
They put Goff over purdy
@emeraldphotography7363 homie he's on Purdy's side lol
Guaranteed Brock will be a top three quarterback this year He gained 10 lb in muscle this year All you haters are going to hate it.
He was the best QB this past season
Preach it, guaranteed 😊
It's like they said, top hats didn't want to accept they slipped letting him through the cracks. I think he will only get his flowers once he wins the big dance. I also think he's actually one of few who comes every year showing how much talent he continues to create. Letttts go
red n gold
Purdy led in more passing categories than any quarterback in the league
Purdy is top in almost all statistics with a 28th ranked offensive line
I am sure Purdy doesn't care about these polls. He is about his team and their success. They just want him to do it again and again, yet some of those QBs on that list haven't done what Purdy has done in the postseason ever.
As a niner fan I'm hoping he cares. Hopefully when he heard the bs list, when went straight to the facility and started throwing angry dots
@@NYners718 as a fan, we hope he cares too, but the problem can be those around him that want him to be the center of attention not the team or someone else.
What's even worse is Dak over Purdy, Dak is not even close, Dak only beats bad teams, period! Plus Dak does not elevate players around him and he have so many weapons.
Prescott and Goff had to throw a hundred and fifty more passes to get to Purdy's stats and Purdy did it against one of the toughest schedules in football.
The disrespect is real for Purdy is insane
Brock Purdy is the second coming of Drew Brees.
@@therealist1103 lol! Now that is hilarious!
@@rldebro Nah your neck triple chin is😂😂😂
@@therealist1103 y'all are so senstive about an average QB that you resort to name calling! it is sad that y'all worship a guy to this level!! LOL
All Brock Purdy has to do is keep winning. It doesn't matter what other people think, success speaks for itself.
The guys who said Dak Prescott is literally insane. He would take a guy who can never get it done over a guy who gets it done ever year.
You have Stroud and Prescott on here. 😂 There's no way anyone should take that list serious.
@@forrestwalker603 stroud seriously? The dude that took a 3 win team to 10 wins and a playoff won?
@@rldebro purdy took over a team to the NFC championship with no first team reps his rookie season sit down
@@forrestwalker603 lol. Yall will make up more qualifiers to prop up Brcok! He is a good qb, nothing special! Look dude, Nfl executives and personnel people around the league said that loud and clear when they did not vote him as a top 10 qb!
@@rldebroeasy schedule, plus all these “ no name “ guys are first round picks😂
Purdy is easily top 7 QB 🤔
Herbert shouldn't even be on the list. Purdy is better than Herbert and Stafford.
Brock should be in the top 5 and CJ shouldn’t be on that list yet
I would agree. I mean at the very least Brock is top 6-7. You can’t logically place him higher on the list otherwise you just look foolish. The man lead almost every statistical QB Category!!
CJ Stroud took a 3 win to 10 wins and a playoff win. Trent is out 3 games and Brock loses all 3 games! That is why CJ Stroud is ranked higher!
@@rldebrohe didn’t take them…the team did and so did the head coach….that narrative of 3 games with one of the worst OLs in the league and defense wasn’t playing well being blamed on Purdy is hilarious
@@deciuswtasby CJ Stroud is a true difference maker! He doesn't need 4 all pros to win consistently. CJ Stroud took the Texans to the playoffs because he is the unquestioned best player on the Texans! Coaching defenitely was a major factor also. It is always an excuse! So we are supposed to praise Brock in wins but deflect blame in losses? We win the SB with CJ because the KC defenders would have actually respected our QB vs. having no fear like Sneed clearly told the world!
Gets the blame for a loss but gets discredited for the wins. Eagles vs 49ers NFC championship will tell you everything you need to know when the most important player goes out.
Stop slighting Brock Purdy for having a cast around him that are great players as well. STOP ITTTTTTTTTTTTT. None of these QB's would "potentially" have the same success outside of their own circumstances. Nobody will know because they're all on the same teams and those are their results currently. Not having Brock in the Top 3 to Top 5, you DO NOT WATCH TAPE!!!! Previous QB's have piloted the Niners offense and they have not navigated it even close to what Brock has done. Listening to an analyst say "based on Pure Quarterbacking"... lol. You are simply exposing yourself that you don't watch tape on Brock. It's as simple as that. Period.
Good analysis!
CJ plays in the same system as Tua and Purdy.
Cj may play in the same system but not with the same players.
People who are afraid to take Brock over 9 of those 10 people on the list are crazy. Brock Purdy made the most impressive throws of any quarterback last year. It's like they think that if he were on any other team that he would just forget how to throw.
Massive Massive Massive disrespect! Two quarterbacks threw over touchdowns last season. Dak and who?????? Exactly. Take Dak off there?!?!?! Rodgers is done!!!! Stafford is almost done. Herbert needs a bounce back. Dak is a great QB. But Purdy not on here?!?!?! Huh?
At the moment it's Mohomos and everyone else. If you think Brock isn't top 5, that's your opinion. If you watch him play he's way more efficient than any other QB.
Brock moved up from 262 to eleven in their minds. They are literally telling us how little they know about the subject. Leaving the guy out who leads in every meaningful category is straight up gaslighting.
Once again what is so special about Herbert? What is a big game he's played in that he proves he can be relied on? Lamar? Allen? Purdy had to put the team on his back twice and won major playoff games. What has Dak or even Goff actually done?
Brock beat Herbert and Dak
Goff and Dak
Wrong... The 49ers beat the Chargers and Cowboys which are not good franchises to the point they will forever have the easiest schedules in football...
Outside of Mahomes….he has arguably the best TE in NFL history and Tyreek Hill and Andy Reid
Brock is being underestimated. It's not smart, he will be in top 3 at the end of the season, and lead his team to #1 seed.
Lamar Jackson has had great wrs??? And he says we dont know ball if we think Purdy is mid lmaoooo
Lamar’s stats were garbage compared to Brock’s
I HAVE BEEN SAYING THIS FOR A YEAR THIS MAN IS SPITTING FACTS I LOVE THIS MAN
The amount of disrespect that Purdy gets because insiders didn't see his talent just shows how people's egos get in the way of seeing the truth. That truth is Purdy was massively underrated and has lifted the Niners to a Super Bowl caliber team.
Lamars stats last year were terrible
Finally, someone lays it out clearly that knocking Brock for the team he's on as a negative against him needs to stop. Carton's right 99% of great QBs have had great talent around them. The Jim Kelly example wo winning a Superbowl is a solid example; that Bills squad was stacked. They had to deal with the Cowboys in the 90s though the way every team now has to deal with Mahomes and the Chiefs.
Lets look at Playoff Records after all isnt that how we judge Winners?? : Lamar Jackson: 6 years in League 6 playoff games with a 2 and 4 record. 26 Sacks 6 interceptions and 6 tds 76 QB rating. Jalen Hurts: 4 years in league 5 playoff games with a 2-3 record. 9 sacks 5 tds and 2 interceptions. 88 QB rating. Joe Burrow: 4 years in league 7 playoff games with a 5-2 record. 29 sacks 9 tds 4 interceptions. 94 rating. Brock Purdy @2 years in the League ! : 6 playoff games 4-2 record. 8 Sacks 6 TD's and 1 Interception. 96 rating. Ask John Harbaugh if he wanted PURDY instead of Jackson in that KC playoff game last year? I think he says YES and they would have likely beat the Niners in SB as well.
Purdy gunna see this and go win 4 super bowls in a row with the help of his team of course
Purdy is a top 10 qb he will show it again this season
As a Niner fan IDC and I don't want Purdy throwing 50-60 yard bombs he throws a beautiful 30 yard ball that lets his guys Run. Purdy has been a Top 5 QB the last 2 years he also creates improv plays.
Purdy played behind the 26th best pass protection while delivering the NFL best passing efficiency...that is the definition of elevating the play of the offense around him.
Purdy was historically good with 62% completions on deep passes. Also, he led all passers with the most intermediate (20+) and long (40+) completions. That is not a function of the play calling and is beyond the control of great playmakers. It requires accurate passing.
Finally, prior to the current era, the previous GOATs at QB were Montana and Brady. Neither were first round picks because neither was 'prototypical'. Through a similar stage in their respective careers, Purdy is the better QB. He may be the best processor of the three. He might be the best off-schedule playmaker of the three.
It is a joke to compare Purdy to 10+ contemporaries. His only rival in the game now is Mahomes and otherwise he is competing with HOFs already.
Pure QB? Reading defenses, accuracy, elusiveness, audible at the line, makes every throw and throws further downfield than everyone else!
“Not a pure QB” is laughable lol, so you’re only a pure QB if you have a cannon? He’s accurate, he plays with high level anticipation, he’s a great processor, he’s mobile. Thats a really stupid take on why he’s not on this list
IT is so hard to understand why so many people hate this young man who took his team to the Super Bowl while only one of the ten they list made it. Purdy led the league in almost every category.
He gets his due by beating all these teams and winning the Super Bowl and yet some people will still say he is not that good.
Then how come Purdy looked so much better than Garoppolo and Lance with pretty much, the same team? Of course he helped make the team better!
My question is to the critics. If Brock’s face replaces Mahomes on this list, would you be surprised? Statistically, he’s already beat him. Mahomes won the last Bowl game by a hair. Against a rookie!
In overtime, when is the last time you’ve seen this?
@@chrisjohnmorse3892If you put any of the elite quarterbacks on the 49ers they are winning the Super Bowl
@@jakieresykes3644 That is a great point! They have a great team! But you can’t deny when that team saw Jimmy and Trey go down, Brock doing his thing certainly put some pep into their step! OMG it was ON!
He put pep into my step! The next day at work after that game was legendary!
He was 1 of the few who went to the Superbowl
The only qb id want other than purdy is mahomes or stroud
No. Not even a debate. Purdy plays on a loaded team. It's so clear as to be super-reality. We have evidence as well. When the Niners went through key injuries in the middle of the season, their play took an IMMEDIATE DOWN TURN! The Niners would be the biggest saps on the planet to pay Purdy 60 million! 40 to 50 million? Okay. The market is the market. But 60 million? That is dumb.
Prescott has to throw a hundred more passes to get to Purdy's stats.
I would take Herbert and Dak off this list and add Hurst and Purdy.
1.Mahomes
2.Allen
3.Jackson
4.Stafford
5.Stroud
6.Burrow
7.Rodgers
8.Purdy
9.Hurst
10.Goff
Agreed. I think the Herbert is so overrated
Thank you!!
Burrow 6th is delusional and blasphemous especially behind Lamar, Stafford and Stroud. C'mon. Shiesty will have you eating your words after he wins the Bayou Bowl. He is unequivocally a top 3 QB.
I dunno I would take Brock over Stroud, an old Rodgers, and Burrow. That would put him around 5-6. But that’s just me
@@allisondecker1918if he stays healthy. Which he can’t
Brock Purdy is one of the very few TRUE QBs in the past 2 decades! Get your facts straight.
How is Josh better than Lamar ? That’s insane
no way you asked this
do you watch the games
You can easily take Herbert, Goff, Prescott, and even Rogers off and put Purdy if your talking about going into this coming season. Buress definitely got it twisted with Purdy and Herbert. Purdy is definitely "The pure QB" especially when compared to Herbert who shined bright his first year, then has been on a declined since.
Herbert is a better player relax. I'll give you the other guys though but if the niners got offered Herbert for Purdy straight up they'd have a parade
@@thenorthernlowlight 😂 hypotheticals are good a fantasy, let's stick to reality.
@@texas.made.the.realist.5313 trust me I use my eyes I like purdy a lot but it's not really close
@@thenorthernlowlight that I agree with it's not close.
Michael Irving said it best. Purdy may not be the best QB in the NFL, but he is the best QB to run the 49er offense. He thinks no one can do it better than him, even Mahomes.
He’s not a pure QB cause he can’t make Justin Herbert caliber throws? This is why you don’t give dudes a microphone or platform.
So what Purdy is disrespected? WHO CARES? It doesn't matter on the field! People getting upset over other folk's opinions of Purdy is next level madness!
I can't stand the 9ers, but Purdy gets way too much disrespect. It's clearly dumb.
Their right Purdy is not a Top 10 QB, BUT is a Top 5 QB🤩🏈🏈🏈
Massive Massive Massive disrespect! Two quarterbacks threw over 30 touchdowns last season. Dak and who?????? Exactly. Take Dak off there?!?!?! Rodgers is done!!!! Stafford is almost done. Herbert needs a bounce back. Dak is a great QB. But Purdy not on here?!?!?! Huh?
He is def top 10 out of whos playing rite now. The other guys are only there bcuz of name recognition. He hasnt had a bad gm yet!!! Respect my boy!!!!
I don't even get upset over this no longer. It's because Purdy was drafted last in the 6th rd but furthermore Dak Prescott was drafted in the 4th round
I guess Brock Purdy is the only guy who ever played with good players around him.. it’s not like Montana, Brady, Manning, Warner, Mahomes, Young, Elway… shiiiii I’ll keep going… it ain’t like none of them we’re surrounded by talent or in good situations huh lol when people say it about Brock Purdy it automatically makes me know you don’t know how the sport of football works 😂
Brock purdy fan here san Francisco 49ers are coming back soon we hungry for it and got there just ain't get it done next time we will win Superbowl
Not surprising since these are the same people that didn't draft Brock Purdy. You're asking the wrong people. Ask the Fans!
4 Niners had over 1000 yards receiving. Same players. Different QB. Purdy elevated an already stacked team. His metrics were collectively better than everyone on the list. The lists have no merit or credibility. And, all these QBs benefit from their enviroments, even Mahomes.
Easiest answer of why the coaches and executives. They aren’t getting their moneys worth, like SF is getting out of Brock. Especially the Cowboys spending way too much on Dak.
The disrespect of Purdy is so stupid! This guy plays on a great team. But make no mistake he has made great plays to keep the offense alive! His stats are great his efficiency has been off the charts! He takes great care of the ball! In his second year he wins the NFC Championship and barely loses in the SuperBowl! And they put Dak at 10 ? C’mon!
Jared Goff being on the list destroys your reasoning for Purdy not being on the team…
Bro is the purest QB in the league..
My top 12 list would be:
01. Mahomes
02. Jackson
03. Burrow (Potential talent)
04. Stafford
05. Allen (Consistent winner)
06. Rodgers (Consistent winner)
07. Dak (Consistent winner)
08. Goff
09. Stroud (Potential only)
10. Herbert (Potential only)
11. Purdy (Loaded team; coach-offensive genius)
12. Love (Potential only; too small a sample size)
Thank you
Racism is a helluva drug
Stats Prove Brock Purdy is the Best & Most Promising Quarterback in the Entire NFL. Haters are Ignorant Fools!!!
No one wants to admit that they were wrong with evaluations . These are the same guys who had Zach Wilson and Trevor Lawrence as their top QBs on their boards. Just admit y’all were wrong on Brock.
The QB’s in question should be Goff, Burrow, and Herbert. Good arms, but mightily struggle without star talent as well.
best take so far
Look who Brock Purdy won with against the Jets. Jordan Mason and Jauan Jennings. The avengers were AWOL.
Burrow was getting glazed for having a bad o-line and getting it done even with all those great weapons he had. Purdy has the worst o-line apart from Trent Williams. And yet they keep saying he has a good line cause they look at Purdy sack numbers and see they aren’t that high and his accuracy. He just evades pressure well and even when it’s in his face still throws good balls so the numbers don’t reflect how shot his oline is but that man running for his life. Trade Purdys oline for Lamar’s, daks, goffa and his numbers improve significantly while I guarantee the others decrease significantly. Lamar mobile but his ability to read the field isn’t as good so his sack numbers will shoot up and he probably gets injured
Absolutely disrespectful. The man is easily top 2. So sick of these idiots.
The Niners o line sucks, with a much better o line Purdy would make a lot of average wrs look like beasts no doubt. I hope the Niners think about that for the future but I doubt it because Kyle thinks he’s the best football mind ever.
Let me put this argument to rest….
If you were having a draft today of only qbs
Look at it this way, separate the qb from
The team and then draft qbs
That should resolve your debate
By this talent logic, we take Herbert and Lawrence over Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Joe Montana, and John Elway. Mahomes plays with, and has played with great players, where did that lie come from?
Brock played better than stroud as a rookie. And last year 😂
No he did not! CJ doesn’t need a team full of all pros to win! KC defender said point blank they didn’t fear Brock! Brock is good but nothing special! We saw that in the games when Trent was out!
Not knowing Dak was drafted in the 4th round is crazy
Duh....none of them had Brock Purdy not even worthy to be drafted. None of these people have a clue what they were doing 😂
I guarantee if Burrow or Mahomes had the exact same numbers as Brock did this past season, they would be a lock for Top 10 no question. The Brock hate is real.
It’s fine. Keep disrespecting Brock. That will keep driving him to be the best. It’s his fuel. He is the perfect QB for the 49’ers.
No one is a bigger fan of Burrow than me, but he is a part time QB at the moment, so ranking a guy that plays 50% of the seasons in his career #2 is no bueno. Other than that the list is an opinion, so not worth getting all hot about it and fills up time ahead of the Magical Football season that is almost here!!
So how about ranking a guy that only played 4 snaps?
Shiesty is unequivocally a top 3 QB in this league regardless of playing time. He's missed 13 games behind one of the worse O line in football that has caused his freak injuries.
Any QB would have had their knee blown out behind that O line and the wrist was a byproduct of Clowney trapping Joe's wrist with his full body weight as he sacked him.
His 2 year playoff success to date is the greatest turnaround of any American sports team. Outside of Mahomes who was drafted to the perfect situation, Shiesty is the only player on this list besides Purdy that has advanced to a Super Bowl and AFCCG in back to back seasons and was the first #1 pick in NFL history to advance to a Super Bowl within his first 2 seasons.
Fingers crossed he doesn't have any more injuries for a few more seasons, but if he does than his place at the top of the QB list will no longer be justifiable, which breaks my heart.
@@allisondecker1918 Agree, I think one thing people take for granted is that bless his heart Ed Orgeron was not a good coach, and as a Dolphins fan we had Zac Taylor and I can tell you first hand he is not a good coach, yet Burrow made one a champion, and the other one a win away from being a Superbowl champion... The great Mahomes even had to have Reid to shine, this guy makes coaches shine in my opinion.
“He’s not a “pure” quarterback” “a pure natural quarterback “…. And you have Lamar at #4? 🥴
Purdy will be in the top 5 by the years end. He is fundimentally sound and makes his team better. Remember last year he was out recovering from major elbow surgery and couldn't throw a football untill right before the season and still crushed it. And as for the big QBs with the big arm means nothing if you can't process in game. Look at Danial Jones. Scouts miss QB evaluations a lot. Moneyball changed the way players are evaluated in basedall and all of a sudden smaller fundamentally sound players that get on base become more valuable than the rocked up arhlete that hits a 450 foot home run every once in a while but strikes out 35% of the time. On his trajectory Purdy is going to win multiple superbowls And as for his post season record the game against the eagles shouldn't count. He was injured less than 2 min into the game.