❗️CORRECTION: 9:50 there is a small mistake in the sheet music. The “E” in the left hand should be a “C#” 🎵 Thanks to those who pointed it out 😀 Also, sorry for my awful pronunciation of Satie! 🇫🇷
Yes, but also melancholic and a little dissonant, as said in the video. Could it be the sadness of the people that lived in the village you're burning, maybe? :)
"Sweden" is a piece of music that I cannot listen to without going on a mind trip back to life in 2011. It is so surreal to listen to it that I actually stop myself even though I want to listen to it. It really is magical.
I feel like even though I wasn’t old enough to have nostalgia then, (I was born 1 year before it’s official release, give or take a few months), but it’s still feels nostalgic. Like I’m experiencing others people nostalgia, even reading the comments sometimes I see nostalgic ones.
I didn't even play it back then, but it still reminds me of alot the earlier days of playing mc It's such a simple and yet so good damn game, don't think it'll ever die
@@dcincco Wow I have the same feeling. I only started playing 3 years ago, and I only play on PvP servers without the music on. Yet, I feel a sense of nostalgia for something that I didn't personally experience.
Minecraft's is some of the most hauntingly beautiful music ever recorded. Much like Satie's Gymnopédie No.1, you will never hear it the same way no matter how many times you listen to it.
Junting but usually it’s just two channels about the same things (like two music channels or two Minecraft channels) but its when two youtubers you love that come from different fields that it’s impressive.
I am not even a native English speaker, but would distinguish them between each other blindfolded. Even if they had the same mics and voice processing. They have different manners of speech. Maybe it's because I have spent too much time watching MumboJumbo and can't confuse his voice with any other voice now
Another thing I absolutely love about Minecraft's music; it gives you a sense of loneliness. In single-player, you're trapped in an infinite world with nothing but yourself. Yeah, sure, there are villagers and pets, but there's no one really quite human. I've always felt like it adds to the feeling in the world and that's really what makes it really special :)
1:38 The key phrase here: "... a game like minecraft," is the important bit that sticks out to me. Minecraft is many games rolled into one. A game where ten different people can play it ten different ways, with ten different objectives, at ten different paces.
They have the same attack on their voices, their sustains are similar and the decay differs a lot. That's about it, it's really hard to separate their voices.
I listened to this without watching most of the video, and it took me a second to realize that it had actually switched from David talking to Mumbo talking.
@@Maodjrodnd the code is, of course, very significant. But though the code alone is good, the music definitely adds the needed depth and flavor to finalize it.
The music discs were always kind of mysterious. Some of them have obvious themes like "Mall" or "Cat," but some of them feel like they're telling a story that doesn't exist, like "Stal" or "Mellohi"
“Sweden” reminds me of my first time playing Minecraft,I mined down my first tree and made a set of wooden tools from it. And when I survived the very first night underground,”Wet hands” started to play right when I dug up to the surface. The memories made me teared up.
I am a person who's played Minecraft all these years almost entirely in singleplayer. Because of that, I love how the music feels curious yet lonely. The music's "slowness" and non-intrusiveness adds to the feeling of living and exploring in this huge world alone. I like to assume that this may be connected to how Minecraft used to be singleplayer only. I don't think I would enjoy the music as much if I played multiplayer more. I would have expected the music to behave like a character in itself in multiplayer.
@@DavidBennettPiano So I found the interview I was looking for. It was in the podcast The Shaft, episode 22, around 5 minutes in. C418 mentions that part of the reason the music is forlorn and isolated is because the tech demo he composed the music for was indeed singleplayer and only had the ability to place blocks. C418 also mentions that once the music was implemented around the time multiplayer was added, he wasn't happy because the music didn't fit anymore.
I play multiplayer all the time, I agree since I just put the music volume to 0 everytime I play bedwars. But the music still sits perfectly in an SMP.
when i play with my pals, I do notice the music a lot less, which is maybe because you dont feel the loneliness. but then when youre in a cave or something away from them or out exploring the music finds itself again eerily
that's so weird. whenever it rains, i always think it's a good time to play minecraft. part of that is that i know my friends are going to be inside when it rains so we could play online together, but this might be part of it too. it has good rain music.
I haven't played Minecraft in years but hearing these tracks immediately take me back. I associate Minecraft with a rough, dark period of my life because that's when I played it most. But hearing the music it reminded me of that calm feeling I would get that would help me forget about those problems, if only for an hour or two.
CreativeName GoesHere when he has a computer science background and he’s said he lost interest, I could something sparking a little bit which then maybe sits for a year after and lights a flame.
Im so obsessed with these tunes, it’s always envoked such a strong indescribable emotion in me it’s the perfect music for such a simplistically beautiful game
If I die someday, I want a tree in top of my grave instead of a gravestone and also a speaker that plays all the original c418 minecraft songs everyday.
I think something important to remember is that the music for Minecraft was composed way back when the game was in Alpha. Back then, there was no multiplayer, no biomes, significantly less content in the game and importantly, no villagers or any other sign of sentient life. When you take that into consideration, the music makes a whole lot more sense. It has a very lonely feel to it that really matched the feel of the game back then.
Never watched a video from David, but I subscribed to Mumbo a while ago, and the only thing that I can say... I SWEAR, when I closed my eyes, I couldn't distingush their voices Whatta a great video, btw. Love it
This was the most unexpected thing you could've possible uploaded Mumbo is one of my favourite hermits, i didn't know I needed this but I can't imagine life without it
Never watched one of your videos before, but I adore C418 and Lena Raine and the influence they have had on so many people, so here I am! I want to say two things: 1. This was a brilliant video. You smashed it. Primo background research. 2. Chuffed that you feel that was about the music, and that you were able to articulate it into words. Have a good one mate.
Finally a video diving in the **MUSIC THEORY** of Minecraft rather than "like dude i feel the **vibrations** on this one. Reminds me the time I was seven when I walked across the boat and came across the realms of the sea and the rivers flow across m"
Thank you, David, for making this video. Super awesome, I think a lot of people (including myself) would like more content like this. Keep it up, cheering you on as you grow.
Composing for sandbox games is super wonky; anything happens at any time. If you have a laid out storyline, you can compose to that story. But with a lack of story, such calls for music that can be used universally. Very good video!
I do wonder if it would be possible to make a dynamic soundtrack to a sandbox game if the game engine provided enough information. If there was some way to reliably weave themes and motifs in and out of the score as the things the motifs represent come into play. Essentially anything important gets a motif or motivic idea as part of their data, and that's used to compose music on the fly. It'd probably work better in an RPG generator than a sadbox game, something that generates a story on the fly and so making musical references makes sense, but it might work for sandboxes too.
@@timh.6872 the cool thing is that minecraft’s soundtrack is dependent of your dimension and your gamemode. The creative gamemode music has ambient music that is intended to inspire and help focus, as playing in creative is often related to searching for something or creating a design without survival limits. The nether music is also ambient music, but is oppressive to make you feel the stress the dimension should give the player(and ghast noises are hidden in the tracks, which is evil) Being submerged in water has its own music as well. Probably because movement is so different underwater. The game is basically designed to reflect the mood of the player. The player wanting a challenge in the nether will have intimidating music to put them in the mood. Wanting to create something, Aria Math plays, making you feel like making things grander. And just in survival, it lets you reflect on what you are doing. It’s just so great.
Now I want to see Mumbo build something with noteblocks and have David analyze and critique the music that gets produced. Kind of like the reverse of this collab if you will.
i've watched this video multiple times and have enjoyed it every single time. not many video essays actually go into detail about things like this one does-i feel like they're either a summary/documentary or a commentary, but this one actually gives me answers to the thoughts i had about minecraft's music. why is it so impactful? because of that dissonance/consonance, the ambience, the way that it comes in at the perfect times. why do i remember it? well, i've played minecraft so much that i've had beautiful moments with the music, and even if i don't remember the moments themselves anymore, the music sticks with me, forever. amazing video :)
12:09 My ears have never been this hurt in my life hearing this. This is truly tortureous for me who has played Minecraft for over 7 years and can't accept changes in the traditional soundtracks, that part hit me so hard. But no offence this analysis is great! David, you earned yourself a sub!
same, that caused a visceral discomfort deep in my brain. After 13 years that music is practically burned into my mind, any change to it no matter how small seriously sticks out like a sore thumb.
Minecraft music is so beautiful, the nostalgia it gives is something else. I always think ambient music is like adding a subtle spice to food. You know it's there, can't quite explain it, but it can add depth and richness to the experience.
Satie does heavily influence a lot of modern artists. There’s a very open, curious, but sometimes disconcerting feeling from Satie’s works... I played some Satie for my young daughter and she seemed fascinated by it.
I've watched quite a few different analyses on the minecraft music but this is by far the best one. It goes through every reason why it works so perfectly, thank you
I really appreciated your perspective and insight. I feel like I learned a lot about ambient music and the Minecraft soundtrack, as well as about major 7th chords. As always, I feel better than before I watched it.
I have never heard of Mumbo Jumbo, but I absolutely agree that you sound very similar to each other. And every video you post is always fascinating! I've never played Minecraft, but this was still very engrossing 🙂
You’d probably be surprised to hear that he’s got over 6 million followers and is a household name in Minecraft circles. Isn’t it crazy that there are so many different fandoms on TH-cam that you might never hear of without crossovers like this?
What Rosenfeld was saying about building a dirt hut with the music playing is so true, when I hear most tracks it reminds me of building my first house, and living mice specifically reminds me of boating through an ocean by a desert. The music pinned the memory to my brain.
Don't worry... the night before the invasion is planned the British government will pull off a signature U-turn 😉 g8fip1kplyr33r3krz5b97d1-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/GettyImages-472459584-1160x737.jpg
Really great observations. I really liked the concept of combining consonant and dissonant sounds. Also, Minecraft's soundtrack sets an example that the smallest changes of notes creates a huge experience in what we hear in music. You do not always have to make bold choices with notes for the piece to be a masterpiece. Really cool stuff! :)
I'm really glad you mentioned erik satie, this is probably the only Minecraft Music video that does mention him, I hope more folks will listen to his stuff
To me, Minecraft’s soundtrack sounds like pure nostalgia, it makes me feel really happy whenever it tunes into my survival world, and somehow gives a sort of melancholy vibe that I find so peaceful and comforting
I feel like the major seven chords in Minecraft's music add a sense of nostalgia. The happy normal melody makes you feel curious and adventurous, and the hint of melancholy just really brings out the emotions in the piece and in the game, no matter how much of a simple sandbox it might be.
I'll never forget my first time I really noticed the music in the game. It was during beta, I was digging out a digsite of sand behind my castle (which was actually smaller than a fort), then unbeknownst to me I just blew up without even knowing there was a creeper behind me even after I died. Then the "Mice on Venus" started playing as I was just staring at my deathscreen wondering what the fuck just happened. I even named this memory in my mind and I call it "Welcome to Minecraft".
This is helpful. Now i know why the nether soundtracks doesn't feel minecraft-y. That's because it's biome coded instead of just randomly played on the nether.
Thanks for that amazing video! For school I need to make a so called "VWA" about video game music and you made it easier to find sources etc. for me :)
I feel like I want to tell my opinions about which music feels what: Subwoofer Lullaby: It feels like the first music I heard in Minecraft. I was trying to explore the game, crafting system, the environment I spawned (a few chuck wide plains between a forest and an ocean, which is still my fav start). And I remember I heard this music Living Mice: When I started my first world, I realized that cobblestone was an interesting material to make a primitive/medieval 2 story house. Also, while making pickaxe with every material I discovered underground, I got tons of it. Cheaper than wood. I added flowers of all types in batches to decorate the surroundings of the house. A few block wide pool with lily pads. I remember that. I was also experimenting with a very primitive train station next to the house. Haggstorm: There's a kid or baby. It's sleeping time :) Not a music I can relate to the game. But the second part of the music feels like witches in the area. It may be a swamp passing by music. Minecraft: May be my least favorite music. Very repetitive. I feel like it starts in sunsets. Mice on Venus: The first part is one of my favorites. Everything is ok. I have a base. I finished making it. I have everything I need, etc. The second part is surely "A Witch Brewing Potions Theme" for me. A black cat is there regardless of black cats being in the game in that version. I would love if both parts were not in the same file. They are not very related, I think. Dry Hands: You're trying to do something but you're not progressing a single step. You're just staying where you are and spending effort on useless things. I feel this from the music trying to progress to some feelings but immediately falls back to the same mood as it started with. Tries to be Mice on Venus but it cannot. Very frustrating. But succeeds in making an ending and it is where it escapes from its chains. Wet Hands: Another sunset music. I have a relatively established home place. I'm watching the sunset on the roof of my house. It may be my favorite music in the game. It may compete with Alpha but they are clearly serving to different purposes. I also always skip credits. So Alpha never plays in the game for me. Clark: Having difficult times. Yeah, these happen in life. But what to do now? I'm just starting the game. I have very limited resources. Everything is scattered in a few chest. A crafting table and a bed is on the grass. This place will be where I build my house. But there's nothing now. It is a daytime music. Sweden: Almost the same as Living Mice. As in Clark, there are problems. But if there's a problem, there is also a solution :) Much more positive than Clark. Life is normal. Danny: Feels more Minecraft to me than Minecraft. May be partially because of how much I don't like Minecraft. But less Minecraft than Sweden and Living Mice. A bit like the last blueness of the sky after the sunset and the music continues at night. Turns into a night theme. It could've been one of the witch themes but doesn't go that way. Alpha: I had never finished the game in survival at the time I listened to this the first time. It was also not playing in the credits screen(probably and old bug that is fixed now). So I extracted this from game files. And I immediately fell in love with the beginning. As a whole, it is still very good. It competes with Wet Hands in being my fav Minecraft music. All parts have different beauties. -0:00 Minecraft ended. Everything that happened will live in memories and fill my heart with nostalgia everytime I remember them. -1:42, memories pass in front of my eyes one by one. I feel strong nostalgia. -2:23 hits that chord and the nostalgia intensifies with the chord. It continues to grow and -2:37 hits the climax. Then it calms down with the soft notes like the strong feelings that calmed down after crying. It starts a new mood. -3:00 is a new start after the end. Strong. The past is in the past. Let's live the future. Everything starts from the scratch. But the future builds up strong. -3:51 Beautiful horses run in plains. I would love to hear some horse neighs and running sounds with this. Then the screen slowly changes to a sunset. I'm watching my new beginning on top of a hill. -4:49 I don't have clear feelings that I can describe about this. -7:17 I'm making a decision. I will make promises. I'm sure that I will hold my promises. I will achieve it. -8:13 Everything is falling into the void one by one. Nothing else will remain. The world becomes empty slowly. Even the sound starts to go. Dead Voxel: I'm in a Nether Fortress and I'm discovering it. It has a system in itself. It runs on set rules. Moog City 2: All I know is I always find this very interesting. Concrete Halls: It is more of a Nether music than others. The others are more like fortress musics and Ballad of the Cats goes to an even more different direction. Mutation: A good Welcome to Minecraft. Haunt Muskie: A skyscraper era music. Not about what we think when someone says "Minecraft". A completely different gameplay style. May be the most suitable creative mode music. Well, I almost never play creative mode. MC Creative is not my game. I only use it for experimenting(especially in 1.7 where mods were there and not outdated by Minecraft. Mods sadly cannot keep up with Minecraft and they are now all in different lives). Warmth: Such a thing these Nether Fortresses are! They confuse the mind and lose me inside them. But the end of the piece makes sure that I'm in a fortress. Ballad of the Cats: Ghasts suffering from life at the distance. Feels like a captivity in a pirate ship. Ghasts may being tortured. It feels less nether than a pirate ship. The End: In the End. It clearly suits the purpose. Environment is vast. Void is there. It's like a dream where things are slightly distorted. Then it turns into a nightmare and ends up in void. Only sound is left in the world. Then starts a piece but I have no idea how it goes. I always ignore past the beginning of this 15 min file. Well, I never lived in the End so I guess that's the reason. I also want to say how unrelated Creative mode musics feel to the game. I listened them while playing Railcraft but not Minecraft. Creative mode may need different musics but I think current ones don't fit the game theme. Otherwise, I like some of them.
While I'm sure I would have naturally discovered Minecraft in my adulthood just by being online, I actually discovered it because I heard the music. Back in Beta 1.9, my teenage brother was playing the game in his room, and this music just sort of crept into my brain while I was reading. It was so pleasant, and I could have easily ignored it, but it was the first time I'd heard it so it caught my attention. And then I loved it so much, I had to go to my brother's room to see what it was, and there he was building a castle out of cobblestone, and I had never seen or heard of a sandbox game before, and I didn't play many games, so I was blown away by this 3d, open and totally manipulable landscape and the fantastic music. It certainly gives sometimes very mundane parts of survival gameplay an immersive, adventurous feel. And that new Nether Wastes music. Is. Phenomenal. I love the new biomes and exploring, but I'll be honest; I sometimes go to the nether just because I need to hear that music again.
@@DavidBennettPiano I can't believe there are only like 6 videos on this topic so far. When I questioned myself about the Minecraft Music for the first time I thought there were already at least 40 different videos about how genius it is, but then I searched it up and found nothing. It was 2017... Paying respects to all of these ~6 channels who made these videos since then including you lol
Once again David, you hit on a topic I didn't even know I wanted to learn about. I've played Minecraft for years and enjoyed the soundtrack. This just increases that enjoyment. Thank you for another great video. :D
I was painting and had this video in the background and it took me a while to notice Mumbo Jumbo's second appearance in the video because your guy's voices sound so similar.
David, all your videos are very interesting. You set a very high standard with your analysis. I loved yesterday. Keep up the great analysis. Your site has excellent content. Regards Peter.
I do think that one thing that Minecraft does that wasn't touched on and I think is very interesting, is managing to maintain the ambient music with random noises (ex. eerie noises) sound at randomized interval of time. The frequency is dependent on a "mood" variable, which changes on location, difficulty, biome, lighting, and more. In an example that I'm creating off of the top of my head, if you're in a cave and the blocks around you aren't lit at more then 4 darkness for a 17 cubed block radius around the player, the mood setting might be at a 70%, which means the chance of random eerie cave noises appearing is a lot higher then when the player is above ground, in the sunlight, with the mood setting at something like 2%. There are a number of other categories of ambient sounds, including ones for being underwater, which trigger if a player is submerged under water, with the possible frequency of noises increasing the longer a player is under and the deeper the water is, or if the player is in the warped forest, a specific biome within the Nether. This is a pretty large chunk of text, but I think that it's an interesting way to keep players engaged with the scenery and game play without having abrupt music changes like mentioned at 3:22 and beyond. Here's a link to the Minecraft Wiki for anyone interested in learning more about the "mood" function and how it fits into the ambient music of Minecraft! It also includes the algorithm for determining a player's "mood" at any given time, which is pretty neat. minecraft.gamepedia.com/Ambience
It's now been a month but I can't believe how much changed. This is the first time I heard of Mumbo but since then I have become absolutely obsessed with Hermitcraft. Thanks so much for opening my eyes to that beautiful community out there. Long live the Mycelium resistance!
❗️CORRECTION: 9:50 there is a small mistake in the sheet music. The “E” in the left hand should be a “C#” 🎵 Thanks to those who pointed it out 😀
Also, sorry for my awful pronunciation of Satie! 🇫🇷
Why are the previous comments deleted?
Kenji Gunawan I have no idea! I’ve only just noticed that! It must be a weird glitch
@@DavidBennettPiano Maybe check the "held for review" comments?
Perfect pitch gang!
Well, actually there's more mistake. Check the 10:20, it should be A - C# - E - A - C# - E, not A - C# - A - B - C# - E as is shown on the partiture.
Me: *_burns down village_*
Minecraft: Calm, Ambient music
Yes, but also melancholic and a little dissonant, as said in the video. Could it be the sadness of the people that lived in the village you're burning, maybe? :)
@Rylie Breaux-Collins nah, boffy would kill all the villagers with his bare hands.
Me: plants flowers
Minecraft: cave sounds
@@bucketofporknbeans2770 That's worse.
@@lukeedwardpanganiban7891 me: wakes up on my house
Game: plays Subwoofer *LULLABY*
Me playing Minecraft: this music is nice
The cave sounds: hello
Pigstep: Guten tag
Hallo
I read hello in the voice of the party kid in fnaf ugh that gave me chills wew
@@Aizelav balloon boy?
@@ohwni yeah
The best description of Minecraft's music that I've read (and I forgot where I read it), is that it sounds like a place you can never go back to.
That sums it up well 😊 Basically that warm/cold feeling of nostalgia
i remember going to a very old server, seeing my very old builds that i spent 10s of hours on, sweden kicks in, shit, i cried so hard i had a headache
@@DavidBennettPianoYeah I think this might be why a lot of people (me included) feel such a strong nostalgia for it.
Deep
That somehow makes so much sense
Is nobody talking about how we have never seen mumbo and David in the same place at the same time?
hmmm
@@user-ox3mu9mg4i baybayin characters, nice
they sound IDENTICAL
@@grassgrow030 personally i don't hear it but ok
xd i love this joke
Whoa, this was REALLY GOOD AND UNEXPECTED collab.
Thank you!
Bro yeah!
You say this was unexpected, but I remember him replying to a comment about him sounding like Mumbo on his 'only 12 notes in music' video.
Funny how I (and a few others) watch both channels :P
@@notafeesh4138 ye same
"Sweden" is a piece of music that I cannot listen to without going on a mind trip back to life in 2011. It is so surreal to listen to it that I actually stop myself even though I want to listen to it. It really is magical.
What happend to Minecraft calm 1
I feel like even though I wasn’t old enough to have nostalgia then, (I was born 1 year before it’s official release, give or take a few months), but it’s still feels nostalgic. Like I’m experiencing others people nostalgia, even reading the comments sometimes I see nostalgic ones.
I didn't even play it back then, but it still reminds me of alot the earlier days of playing mc
It's such a simple and yet so good damn game, don't think it'll ever die
@@dcincco Wow I have the same feeling. I only started playing 3 years ago, and I only play on PvP servers without the music on. Yet, I feel a sense of nostalgia for something that I didn't personally experience.
actually started playin at the age of 5 in 2013 so these musics are litterally all my childhood
Avengers: endgame is the most ambitious crossover ever
David: hold my piano
Me: breaks my back from holding that
Ambient-ious
How did that meme survive for so long?
Lazergurka - Smerlin it is dead but it’s kinda like STONKS, you use it regardless
Mumbo: hold my red stuff
Minecraft's is some of the most hauntingly beautiful music ever recorded.
Much like Satie's Gymnopédie No.1, you will never hear it the same way no matter how many times you listen to it.
I genuinely could not agree more with this comment
The crossover nobody expected but everybody wanted
Yeah. Reminds me of the crossover between 12tone and Religion for Breakfast.
Federico Savignano literally what everyone says under every collar vid...
theosib yep I remember that
Junting but usually it’s just two channels about the same things (like two music channels or two Minecraft channels) but its when two youtubers you love that come from different fields that it’s impressive.
spanish inquisition vibes
Plot Twist: David and Mumbo are actually the same person and we just don’t know it yet.
yeah lol
Everyone’s talking about the crossover, but even as a brit, if I wasn’t watching the screen I wouldn’t notice the speaker change 😂
I thought the creator is just Trolling and believe they are 1 just person.
I am not even a native English speaker, but would distinguish them between each other blindfolded. Even if they had the same mics and voice processing. They have different manners of speech. Maybe it's because I have spent too much time watching MumboJumbo and can't confuse his voice with any other voice now
Seangle flex much
@@HarryBakerSmith lol weird flex but yeah
Seangle weird flex but ok
Another thing I absolutely love about Minecraft's music; it gives you a sense of loneliness. In single-player, you're trapped in an infinite world with nothing but yourself. Yeah, sure, there are villagers and pets, but there's no one really quite human. I've always felt like it adds to the feeling in the world and that's really what makes it really special :)
Plot twist: They're actually the same person
I am honored to have the opportunity of being the 69th like
They sound the exact same
Ik this is a joke, but if u search up mumbo’s picture, they look entirely different
they do look faintly similar to me
@@wenhanli887 Mumbo's like 6.4 or something and has a literal block face, the Chaddiest of Chad's.
1:38 The key phrase here: "... a game like minecraft," is the important bit that sticks out to me.
Minecraft is many games rolled into one. A game where ten different people can play it ten different ways, with ten different objectives, at ten different paces.
It's almost everything to everyone
As an American, I could barely distinguish between your voices.
*Watches ending* glad I'm not the only one.
😂😂
13:40 The weird thing is when they talk their voices start sounding exacly the same and then they go in different ways
They have the same attack on their voices, their sustains are similar and the decay differs a lot. That's about it, it's really hard to separate their voices.
get good lol
@@mrpepero ok lol
I listened to this without watching most of the video, and it took me a second to realize that it had actually switched from David talking to Mumbo talking.
The music in Minecraft is so iconic, I honestly don’t believe Minecraft would be Minecraft without the music
Don’t get me wrong. I love the music but I think the code has a bit more significance
@@Maodjrodnd the code is, of course, very significant. But though the code alone is good, the music definitely adds the needed depth and flavor to finalize it.
turn down music to 0%, is it the same game?
Me, who plays on PE and have not downloaded the music pack AND plays on mute: *visible pain*
*Cries in Bedrock
I can't believe they stopped having C418 make their music.
C418 will still make minecraft music it's just that mojang wants to have different composer
@@monodia180 so C418 still works in Mojang?
@@juusomaenpaa7236 yes
@@monodia180 ok good
@@monodia180 okay now I'm more confused but... At least he's still there?
I also feel that Minecraft’s music discs also really interesting to look at since they’re nothing like the background music!
Which makes sense, as they're music you deliberately put on when you want to listen to them.
Yeah. My favorites are cat and wait
The music discs were always kind of mysterious. Some of them have obvious themes like "Mall" or "Cat," but some of them feel like they're telling a story that doesn't exist, like "Stal" or "Mellohi"
Pigstep: Now it's time to get funky!
What about the Nether and End music? I'm seriously disappointed.
“Sweden” reminds me of my first time playing Minecraft,I mined down my first tree and made a set of wooden tools from it. And when I survived the very first night underground,”Wet hands” started to play right when I dug up to the surface. The memories made me teared up.
I am a person who's played Minecraft all these years almost entirely in singleplayer. Because of that, I love how the music feels curious yet lonely. The music's "slowness" and non-intrusiveness adds to the feeling of living and exploring in this huge world alone. I like to assume that this may be connected to how Minecraft used to be singleplayer only. I don't think I would enjoy the music as much if I played multiplayer more. I would have expected the music to behave like a character in itself in multiplayer.
That’s a good point. The music was composed when the game was only single players so I do think you’re on to something here 😊
@@DavidBennettPiano i will go do my own research because i was so sure C418 mentioned as such at some point.
@@DavidBennettPiano So I found the interview I was looking for. It was in the podcast The Shaft, episode 22, around 5 minutes in. C418 mentions that part of the reason the music is forlorn and isolated is because the tech demo he composed the music for was indeed singleplayer and only had the ability to place blocks. C418 also mentions that once the music was implemented around the time multiplayer was added, he wasn't happy because the music didn't fit anymore.
I play multiplayer all the time, I agree since I just put the music volume to 0 everytime I play bedwars. But the music still sits perfectly in an SMP.
when i play with my pals, I do notice the music a lot less, which is maybe because you dont feel the loneliness. but then when youre in a cave or something away from them or out exploring the music finds itself again eerily
I will never forget the soundtrack - everytime I hear it, it gives me the chills.
True, Daniel Rosenfeld is up there with Bach, Chopin and Beethoven.
that's so weird. whenever it rains, i always think it's a good time to play minecraft. part of that is that i know my friends are going to be inside when it rains so we could play online together, but this might be part of it too. it has good rain music.
I haven't played Minecraft in years but hearing these tracks immediately take me back. I associate Minecraft with a rough, dark period of my life because that's when I played it most. But hearing the music it reminded me of that calm feeling I would get that would help me forget about those problems, if only for an hour or two.
subwoofer lullaby without the cmaj7 chord makes me uncomfortable
yeah. its cursed
I haven’t reached that part of the video, but the thought of it alone is making me cringe
Edit: I agree, it makes me very uncomfortable
sounds like a horror game's music.
I'm done that is the most accurate analogy I’ve ever heard
When I heard it, first thing I said was "That sounds wrong".
Mumbo and David have the exact same voice, and we didn’t see mumbo’s face in the video... I think we cracked who the REAL mumbo jumbo is
i can't unhear it, he's like the lite version of mumbo
The crossover I didn't know I needed
(Y) S ame
I was really really anticipating this, and I wasn't disappointed! I'm in love with the Minecraft soundtrack as a guitarist
Thanks! I’m glad you liked it 🙂🙂
Mumbo does redstone... Mumbo does building... Mumbo does cinematography... is Mumbo doing composition next, if so... I'm scared for my job!
Nah, everyone can coexist
@@masterpig5s no, everyone should be scared, soon we'll see mumbo doing programing
CreativeName GoesHere when he has a computer science background and he’s said he lost interest, I could something sparking a little bit which then maybe sits for a year after and lights a flame.
He made wonder wall in hermitcraft
Im so obsessed with these tunes, it’s always envoked such a strong indescribable emotion in me it’s the perfect music for such a simplistically beautiful game
okay what the hell, who was the person who said that you sound like mumbo jumbo? Cuz DAMN that person's right and I never noticed that until now
😂
@@DavidBennettPiano y
Everyone said that
When you watch both youtubers but you still notice this
It's because they're both British
If I die someday, I want a tree in top of my grave instead of a gravestone and also a speaker that plays all the original c418 minecraft songs everyday.
David : *uploads*
Title : (ft. Mumbo Jumbo)
Me:
Finally, something *EPIC* in 2020
Thanks!
epico
Mumbo Jumbo was a very chill guy..love him!
@@arcioko2142 porque respondes enespañol?
@@arcioko2142 why are you guys speaking spanish
wasn't expecting this to be reccomended but I'm so happy it was
I think something important to remember is that the music for Minecraft was composed way back when the game was in Alpha. Back then, there was no multiplayer, no biomes, significantly less content in the game and importantly, no villagers or any other sign of sentient life. When you take that into consideration, the music makes a whole lot more sense. It has a very lonely feel to it that really matched the feel of the game back then.
even with all the mobs, the game still feels lonely, and the music reinforces that feeling
Never watched a video from David, but I subscribed to Mumbo a while ago, and the only thing that I can say...
I SWEAR, when I closed my eyes, I couldn't distingush their voices
Whatta a great video, btw. Love it
This was the most unexpected thing you could've possible uploaded
Mumbo is one of my favourite hermits, i didn't know I needed this but I can't imagine life without it
Thanks so much! I’m glad you’re enjoying the video 😊
Wet hands is one of my favorite songs ever. Whenever I am sad, it lets me feel sad but hopeful at the same time.
Never watched one of your videos before, but I adore C418 and Lena Raine and the influence they have had on so many people, so here I am!
I want to say two things:
1. This was a brilliant video. You smashed it. Primo background research.
2. Chuffed that you feel that was about the music, and that you were able to articulate it into words.
Have a good one mate.
Thanks Liam! That means a lot 😃
All good mate! Showing appreciation where it’s due! 🤟🏽
Finally a video diving in the **MUSIC THEORY** of Minecraft rather than
"like dude i feel the **vibrations** on this one. Reminds me the time I was seven when I walked across the boat and came across the realms of the sea and the rivers flow across m"
Yes!
Yes, m is the best
I know exactly the video you're talking about too! What a waste of time it was
Wait, which one?
Thank you, David, for making this video. Super awesome, I think a lot of people (including myself) would like more content like this. Keep it up, cheering you on as you grow.
Composing for sandbox games is super wonky; anything happens at any time. If you have a laid out storyline, you can compose to that story. But with a lack of story, such calls for music that can be used universally. Very good video!
Thanks! Yeah, the freedom of sandbox games ironically present a challenge to composers.
Hi Emm Bee Sea
Silvagunner gang
I do wonder if it would be possible to make a dynamic soundtrack to a sandbox game if the game engine provided enough information. If there was some way to reliably weave themes and motifs in and out of the score as the things the motifs represent come into play. Essentially anything important gets a motif or motivic idea as part of their data, and that's used to compose music on the fly.
It'd probably work better in an RPG generator than a sadbox game, something that generates a story on the fly and so making musical references makes sense, but it might work for sandboxes too.
@@timh.6872 the cool thing is that minecraft’s soundtrack is dependent of your dimension and your gamemode.
The creative gamemode music has ambient music that is intended to inspire and help focus, as playing in creative is often related to searching for something or creating a design without survival limits.
The nether music is also ambient music, but is oppressive to make you feel the stress the dimension should give the player(and ghast noises are hidden in the tracks, which is evil)
Being submerged in water has its own music as well. Probably because movement is so different underwater.
The game is basically designed to reflect the mood of the player. The player wanting a challenge in the nether will have intimidating music to put them in the mood. Wanting to create something, Aria Math plays, making you feel like making things grander. And just in survival, it lets you reflect on what you are doing. It’s just so great.
Now I want to see Mumbo build something with noteblocks and have David analyze and critique the music that gets produced. Kind of like the reverse of this collab if you will.
a surprise, to be sure, but a welcome one
😁😁😁
i've watched this video multiple times and have enjoyed it every single time. not many video essays actually go into detail about things like this one does-i feel like they're either a summary/documentary or a commentary, but this one actually gives me answers to the thoughts i had about minecraft's music.
why is it so impactful? because of that dissonance/consonance, the ambience, the way that it comes in at the perfect times.
why do i remember it? well, i've played minecraft so much that i've had beautiful moments with the music, and even if i don't remember the moments themselves anymore, the music sticks with me, forever.
amazing video :)
12:09 My ears have never been this hurt in my life hearing this. This is truly tortureous for me who has played Minecraft for over 7 years and can't accept changes in the traditional soundtracks, that part hit me so hard. But no offence this analysis is great! David, you earned yourself a sub!
same, that caused a visceral discomfort deep in my brain. After 13 years that music is practically burned into my mind, any change to it no matter how small seriously sticks out like a sore thumb.
Same
the worst thing is he says "You see how that uneasy eeriness dissapears"
Minecraft music is so beautiful, the nostalgia it gives is something else. I always think ambient music is like adding a subtle spice to food. You know it's there, can't quite explain it, but it can add depth and richness to the experience.
lol this is one of the most unexpected collabs ever
great analysis, loved the video.
Thank you!
This is something that I didn't think needed until now. Great video.
Satie does heavily influence a lot of modern artists. There’s a very open, curious, but sometimes disconcerting feeling from Satie’s works... I played some Satie for my young daughter and she seemed fascinated by it.
How I like to describe Minecraft’s music is this - nostalgic, but you’re constantly experiencing that nostalgia for the first time
I've watched quite a few different analyses on the minecraft music but this is by far the best one. It goes through every reason why it works so perfectly, thank you
Thank you Ryan 😊 that means a lot
2:48 “The player has no objectives to achieve”
*cough cough* ender dragon
This appeared in my recommended and I wasn't prepared for the double whammy nostalgia hit of Minecraft's music and a MumboJumbo cameo
I personally play minecraft with no volume, but when I turn it on,
*oh boy*
I couldn’t finish this video without dying of nostalgia. I respawned so many times.
😃😂
Glad you ain’t playing hardcore
Great analysis and video
Thanks!
Well isn’t this a surprising collaboration
Really enjoyed this video. Really good
I really appreciated your perspective and insight. I feel like I learned a lot about ambient music and the Minecraft soundtrack, as well as about major 7th chords. As always, I feel better than before I watched it.
Thanks Troy! That means a lot 😃😃
Ever since I first started seeing your videos, I always thought you sounded a bit like Mumbo. This is the best possible video to confirm that haha
I have never heard of Mumbo Jumbo, but I absolutely agree that you sound very similar to each other. And every video you post is always fascinating! I've never played Minecraft, but this was still very engrossing 🙂
Thank you!
You’d probably be surprised to hear that he’s got over 6 million followers and is a household name in Minecraft circles. Isn’t it crazy that there are so many different fandoms on TH-cam that you might never hear of without crossovers like this?
*Casually getting mauled by zombies to "Wet Hands" by C418*
Mumbo and music theory all in the same video, what could be better
nothing
Thanks!
Mumbo, Grian, and music theory
What Rosenfeld was saying about building a dirt hut with the music playing is so true, when I hear most tracks it reminds me of building my first house, and living mice specifically reminds me of boating through an ocean by a desert. The music pinned the memory to my brain.
The british are getting too powerful...
Don't worry... the night before the invasion is planned the British government will pull off a signature U-turn 😉 g8fip1kplyr33r3krz5b97d1-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/GettyImages-472459584-1160x737.jpg
Rule Britannia Intensifies
I'm fine, as long as the invasion force includes platoons of G&S companies. :P
@@DavidBennettPiano I don't trust this domain (─.─||）
You should be glad we’re not allowed guns...
Really great observations. I really liked the concept of combining consonant and dissonant sounds. Also, Minecraft's soundtrack sets an example that the smallest changes of notes creates a huge experience in what we hear in music. You do not always have to make bold choices with notes for the piece to be a masterpiece. Really cool stuff! :)
Damnn 13:43 i thought the same guy was talking but it was really the other guy 😭
🤣🤣
It does sound a lot like him
What the hell. Never in my life expected this crossover. Nice collab.
the oof was the peak human editing performance
😂😂
I'm really glad you mentioned erik satie, this is probably the only Minecraft Music video that does mention him, I hope more folks will listen to his stuff
Trust me David, you don't know how much I need a nostalgia right now. Thanks for the video!
You're welcome Michael! Thanks
Amazing video!
ur one of the most interesting channels on youtube david! please keep it up!
Wow, thanks!
To me, Minecraft’s soundtrack sounds like pure nostalgia, it makes me feel really happy whenever it tunes into my survival world, and somehow gives a sort of melancholy vibe that I find so peaceful and comforting
One of my favorite music TH-camrs and one of my favorite Minecraft TH-camrs collabing? To quote Mumbo: “I’m chuffed to bits!”
I feel like the major seven chords in Minecraft's music add a sense of nostalgia. The happy normal melody makes you feel curious and adventurous, and the hint of melancholy just really brings out the emotions in the piece and in the game, no matter how much of a simple sandbox it might be.
I was so sold as soon as I read the title. And I wasn’t disappointed. Very inspiring video
Thank you 😃
I'll never forget my first time I really noticed the music in the game. It was during beta, I was digging out a digsite of sand behind my castle (which was actually smaller than a fort), then unbeknownst to me I just blew up without even knowing there was a creeper behind me even after I died. Then the "Mice on Venus" started playing as I was just staring at my deathscreen wondering what the fuck just happened. I even named this memory in my mind and I call it "Welcome to Minecraft".
This is helpful. Now i know why the nether soundtracks doesn't feel minecraft-y. That's because it's biome coded instead of just randomly played on the nether.
That's a good point! That's true of "The End" as well.
they feel minecrafty still, but different. that kinda embodies the nether update, it feels like Minecraft but different
@@equaius893 It definitely feels sandbox-y with a little minecraft feeling in there.
Thanks for that amazing video! For school I need to make a so called "VWA" about video game music and you made it easier to find sources etc. for me :)
David Bennet Piano: analyzing Minecraft's music
me: woah nice
.....ft Mumbo Jumbo
me: hol'up
*WHAT?*
hol up ring ding ring ding ding ding ding ding ding
Ring Ding Ring King Sing Pingpong
I feel like I want to tell my opinions about which music feels what:
Subwoofer Lullaby: It feels like the first music I heard in Minecraft. I was trying to explore the game, crafting system, the environment I spawned (a few chuck wide plains between a forest and an ocean, which is still my fav start). And I remember I heard this music
Living Mice: When I started my first world, I realized that cobblestone was an interesting material to make a primitive/medieval 2 story house. Also, while making pickaxe with every material I discovered underground, I got tons of it. Cheaper than wood. I added flowers of all types in batches to decorate the surroundings of the house. A few block wide pool with lily pads. I remember that. I was also experimenting with a very primitive train station next to the house.
Haggstorm: There's a kid or baby. It's sleeping time :) Not a music I can relate to the game. But the second part of the music feels like witches in the area. It may be a swamp passing by music.
Minecraft: May be my least favorite music. Very repetitive. I feel like it starts in sunsets.
Mice on Venus: The first part is one of my favorites. Everything is ok. I have a base. I finished making it. I have everything I need, etc. The second part is surely "A Witch Brewing Potions Theme" for me. A black cat is there regardless of black cats being in the game in that version. I would love if both parts were not in the same file. They are not very related, I think.
Dry Hands: You're trying to do something but you're not progressing a single step. You're just staying where you are and spending effort on useless things. I feel this from the music trying to progress to some feelings but immediately falls back to the same mood as it started with. Tries to be Mice on Venus but it cannot. Very frustrating. But succeeds in making an ending and it is where it escapes from its chains.
Wet Hands: Another sunset music. I have a relatively established home place. I'm watching the sunset on the roof of my house. It may be my favorite music in the game. It may compete with Alpha but they are clearly serving to different purposes. I also always skip credits. So Alpha never plays in the game for me.
Clark: Having difficult times. Yeah, these happen in life. But what to do now? I'm just starting the game. I have very limited resources. Everything is scattered in a few chest. A crafting table and a bed is on the grass. This place will be where I build my house. But there's nothing now. It is a daytime music.
Sweden: Almost the same as Living Mice. As in Clark, there are problems. But if there's a problem, there is also a solution :) Much more positive than Clark. Life is normal.
Danny: Feels more Minecraft to me than Minecraft. May be partially because of how much I don't like Minecraft. But less Minecraft than Sweden and Living Mice. A bit like the last blueness of the sky after the sunset and the music continues at night. Turns into a night theme. It could've been one of the witch themes but doesn't go that way.
Alpha: I had never finished the game in survival at the time I listened to this the first time. It was also not playing in the credits screen(probably and old bug that is fixed now). So I extracted this from game files. And I immediately fell in love with the beginning. As a whole, it is still very good. It competes with Wet Hands in being my fav Minecraft music. All parts have different beauties.
-0:00 Minecraft ended. Everything that happened will live in memories and fill my heart with nostalgia everytime I remember them.
-1:42, memories pass in front of my eyes one by one. I feel strong nostalgia.
-2:23 hits that chord and the nostalgia intensifies with the chord. It continues to grow and
-2:37 hits the climax. Then it calms down with the soft notes like the strong feelings that calmed down after crying.
It starts a new mood.
-3:00 is a new start after the end. Strong. The past is in the past. Let's live the future. Everything starts from the scratch. But the future builds up strong.
-3:51 Beautiful horses run in plains. I would love to hear some horse neighs and running sounds with this. Then the screen slowly changes to a sunset. I'm watching my new beginning on top of a hill.
-4:49 I don't have clear feelings that I can describe about this.
-7:17 I'm making a decision. I will make promises. I'm sure that I will hold my promises. I will achieve it.
-8:13 Everything is falling into the void one by one. Nothing else will remain. The world becomes empty slowly. Even the sound starts to go.
Dead Voxel: I'm in a Nether Fortress and I'm discovering it. It has a system in itself. It runs on set rules.
Moog City 2: All I know is I always find this very interesting.
Concrete Halls: It is more of a Nether music than others. The others are more like fortress musics and Ballad of the Cats goes to an even more different direction.
Mutation: A good Welcome to Minecraft.
Haunt Muskie: A skyscraper era music. Not about what we think when someone says "Minecraft". A completely different gameplay style. May be the most suitable creative mode music. Well, I almost never play creative mode. MC Creative is not my game. I only use it for experimenting(especially in 1.7 where mods were there and not outdated by Minecraft. Mods sadly cannot keep up with Minecraft and they are now all in different lives).
Warmth: Such a thing these Nether Fortresses are! They confuse the mind and lose me inside them. But the end of the piece makes sure that I'm in a fortress.
Ballad of the Cats: Ghasts suffering from life at the distance. Feels like a captivity in a pirate ship. Ghasts may being tortured. It feels less nether than a pirate ship.
The End: In the End. It clearly suits the purpose. Environment is vast. Void is there. It's like a dream where things are slightly distorted. Then it turns into a nightmare and ends up in void. Only sound is left in the world. Then starts a piece but I have no idea how it goes. I always ignore past the beginning of this 15 min file. Well, I never lived in the End so I guess that's the reason.
I also want to say how unrelated Creative mode musics feel to the game. I listened them while playing Railcraft but not Minecraft. Creative mode may need different musics but I think current ones don't fit the game theme. Otherwise, I like some of them.
While I'm sure I would have naturally discovered Minecraft in my adulthood just by being online, I actually discovered it because I heard the music. Back in Beta 1.9, my teenage brother was playing the game in his room, and this music just sort of crept into my brain while I was reading. It was so pleasant, and I could have easily ignored it, but it was the first time I'd heard it so it caught my attention. And then I loved it so much, I had to go to my brother's room to see what it was, and there he was building a castle out of cobblestone, and I had never seen or heard of a sandbox game before, and I didn't play many games, so I was blown away by this 3d, open and totally manipulable landscape and the fantastic music. It certainly gives sometimes very mundane parts of survival gameplay an immersive, adventurous feel.
And that new Nether Wastes music. Is. Phenomenal. I love the new biomes and exploring, but I'll be honest; I sometimes go to the nether just because I need to hear that music again.
I was literally telling myself yesterday that I needed a video like this, and youtube read my mind
David Bennett and Minecraft? Instant like.
Thanks!
@@DavidBennettPiano I can't believe there are only like 6 videos on this topic so far. When I questioned myself about the Minecraft Music for the first time I thought there were already at least 40 different videos about how genius it is, but then I searched it up and found nothing. It was 2017... Paying respects to all of these ~6 channels who made these videos since then including you lol
@@DavidBennettPiano btw Bennett why haven't you mentioned the End dimension ambient music? It *really* deserves some special attention to it.
Plus mumbo
You sound so alike that I thought Mumbo was talking in many moments, but it was actually you. Damn.
This is one of best videos on your channel sir.
Thanks!
I love your guitars in the back especially that sunburst strat!
Once again David, you hit on a topic I didn't even know I wanted to learn about. I've played Minecraft for years and enjoyed the soundtrack. This just increases that enjoyment. Thank you for another great video. :D
I was painting and had this video in the background and it took me a while to notice Mumbo Jumbo's second appearance in the video because your guy's voices sound so similar.
I'm loving this. Mumbo jumbo is in my to 3 favourite minecrafters on youtube. Thank you very much for this amazing video
Thanks!!
Whenever I hear the Calm 1, I get chills all over my body
Very interesting, thank you, David.
Thank you Peter 😊
David, all your videos are very interesting. You set a very high standard with your analysis. I loved yesterday. Keep up the great analysis. Your site has excellent content. Regards Peter.
Peter Dunphy thanks Peter! And don’t worry... I haven’t forgotten about Burt Bacharach!
@@DavidBennettPiano That's great news, David. Thank you again for all your excellent videos. Regards Peter.
Amazing collab
WTF LOL, this is the most ambitious crossover ever!
I do think that one thing that Minecraft does that wasn't touched on and I think is very interesting, is managing to maintain the ambient music with random noises (ex. eerie noises) sound at randomized interval of time. The frequency is dependent on a "mood" variable, which changes on location, difficulty, biome, lighting, and more. In an example that I'm creating off of the top of my head, if you're in a cave and the blocks around you aren't lit at more then 4 darkness for a 17 cubed block radius around the player, the mood setting might be at a 70%, which means the chance of random eerie cave noises appearing is a lot higher then when the player is above ground, in the sunlight, with the mood setting at something like 2%. There are a number of other categories of ambient sounds, including ones for being underwater, which trigger if a player is submerged under water, with the possible frequency of noises increasing the longer a player is under and the deeper the water is, or if the player is in the warped forest, a specific biome within the Nether.
This is a pretty large chunk of text, but I think that it's an interesting way to keep players engaged with the scenery and game play without having abrupt music changes like mentioned at 3:22 and beyond.
Here's a link to the Minecraft Wiki for anyone interested in learning more about the "mood" function and how it fits into the ambient music of Minecraft! It also includes the algorithm for determining a player's "mood" at any given time, which is pretty neat.
minecraft.gamepedia.com/Ambience
hmm, wonder how he will bake the beatles into this one...
It's now been a month but I can't believe how much changed. This is the first time I heard of Mumbo but since then I have become absolutely obsessed with Hermitcraft. Thanks so much for opening my eyes to that beautiful community out there. Long live the Mycelium resistance!