There should be a limit on how many consecutive times one can listen to this version. After three, you are bordering on a state of despair that renders one useless for the remainder of the day.
I agree, somebody breaks up with you, or you break up with someone, not necessarily because you don't love them, but because you feel the relationship is not going anywhere. I speak from personal experience and the line "the dawn don't rescue me" rings true, you get up in the morning thinking things will get better, and you realize it is not getting better. Totally identify with his song. Rick pours all his emotions into it, such heatache, such perfection
Although Hudson is physically frail - he has reportedly been living in an assisted care facility since the death of his wife, Maud, in 2022 Garth is the sole survivor of The Band, I'm 70 and can only wish to live as long as Garth. They were a truly amazing band so special and light years ahead of their contemporaries.
Maybe it’s Garth’s memories that keep him going. A guy who might have ended as a music teacher in small town Ontario, instead was given the gift of sharing his instrumental legacy with the world. Without Garth, The Band would not have been.
Absolutely agree with you about their music being light years ahead 💜 I just turned 71 and listening to this song today, sounds so good, their sound has traveled well over the years
After Levon passed, my brother and I trekked to Woodstock to to show his daughter was giving at The Barn. An intimate musical performance I will never forget, bringing me to tears. Not a dry eye in the place. What a great band.
I cannot describe my sadness on the loss of Robbie Robertson- “and the rains fall down on my door- and the dawn don’t rescue me no more.” I’ve followed The Band for decades and have the clearest memories of listening to The Last Waltz over and over and over. These losses of great musicians are hitting me harder and harder and harder. Thank you Robbie.
love to you, Deborah.....I get it...and as I came here to watch Robbie.....then you see Rick and Levon....and then Garth comes out on the sax...the only one left. The music matters.
We made a tactical error, Deborah. We attached deeply to literally hundreds of musicians that were ten years or so older than us, and now they are dying almost daily. And the ones who wrote the insightful songs, and the challenging songs - the songs that pushed us into becoming deeper ... those are the ones, whose passing hits us the hardest. I think that, when Dylan dies, the country will just shut down for a week.
I listen to this one so much. This is my favorite song in The Last Waltz. Rick's vocals are crushing. Robbie's magical right hand shimmy shake during the solo. Garth on smooth sax. Sighhhhh. They are so young and beautiful and talented here. Time Flies. Rest well, Robbie. You've got some good musicians to hang with on the other side. Save me a good seat at the show.
My first wife split after six years of marriage. She returned about four months later. I heard this tune in my apartment, from a Band album, and played it for her upon her return. She sat and listened with no emotion whatsoever. That's when I knew it was over. I moved forward and am with the love of my life after 36 years. A truly great tune and it played an important role in my life! Thank you Robbie and the Band for providing such beautiful music for a generation and more!!
In late 1976, my partner moved to another city, about 1,000 miles away. in the months before I was able to join her there, I bought The Best of The Band on Cassette, and discovered this song. When I came to the verse "Well, I love you so much that it's all I can do to keep myself from telling you that I never felt so alone before," it broke me up, I was a mess, but it sustained me till I joined her. I already knew some of The Band's work, and had the NME review of the concert, and went to the Australian Premier of the movie. After 15 or 16 times I lost count of the number of times I saw it, and now have all of their studio work and live work, including their time with Dylan. My favourite band of all time.
Like John Prine's Far From Me - Why, we used to laugh together And we'd dance to any old song Well, you know, she still laughs with me But she waits just a second too long
That scar under Rick’s right eye? I have one just like it. It was created as I was being born. I was born breach, meaning the doctor had to reach in with his forceps and grab me by the head to get me out. Many equate breach birth to PTSD. All I know is, even that far back, I didn’t want to come out.
I had to grow up (many years) to appreciate how great The Band really was. As part of my Thanksgiving ritual I saw The Last Waltz again today. The more I hear Rick Danko, the more I love him. He draws you in. When the song is done you don't know whether to hug him or give him a bowl of soup to care for him.
Goddamnnn. I so miss Rick Danko! What a voice! I never get tired of hearing Rick singing this song, but this has to be the best, most heartfelt version, I've ever seen! RIP Rick Danko!
No one like them, ever!!The Band was so underrated, its sad. The whole Last Waltz was an AMAZING concert, and It Makes No Difference from this concert was & will always be my favorite version of this song. Listen up youngsters, THIS is music.
The best thing Scorsese ever did was to save this, the best version of The Band's most heart wrenching song, for us to cherish until Death do us part. Period. Thank You, The Band. The best band of the 20th Century.
Yes, indeed, Garth’s sax solo makes up for the first guitar solo. JRR had to up his game after hearing that and finished stronger. Now Rick and Solomon Burke must be trading hellacious verses on that one up in heaven. Great song, thank you for sharing it.
This is as close to perfection as one can get. Not in a sense of the perfect rhythm or every note perfect, but in a sense of music perfectly expressing human emotions. They created a magic moment we can all share.
One of the purest songs ever- I can listen to this over and over again. The sax is brilliant. Appreciate all of these musicians. You will be missed Robby. Your music will live on. Rest in peace 🎼☮️
they were all brilliant. this version of this song is heartbreakingly beautiful. it's been making me cry since it was released. they're all gone now except Garth. there's no holding back the tears as I'm listening now...
I learned about the Band because I changed my major from writing to screenwriting in college (Syracuse University). I had one class about music in film and had to watch this film. I fell in love with their music. My mother bought me a case of CDs by the Band for Christmas.
I miss this band, I wish there was another that could come close to doing what they did. Wow what a collection of musicians that complimented each other so completely.
4:45 am June 6th of 2020, I said my finals goodbye to my mother. I have a gaping hole where my heart once resided. And the first thing I thought of was the lyric “and the sun don’t shine anymore, and rains fall down on my door.” Only difference is that the rains fall on my soul as I weep for my dear sweet mother. It breaks my heart I didn’t get to say I love you one last time. Rest easy mom, no more pain.
One left...RIP Robbie. I'm so fortunate to have listened to your songs growing up. Last Waltz is one of the best music documentaries ever made. Man this one hurts.
Check out the conception and how this was made and you'll understand why it's better than a studio version. It's great to see that other people haven't forgotten what good music is.
I’m 37 yrs old and I know this music was before my time but this literally gives me goosebumps every time listening to it…. Pure, raw, unfiltered emotions through music…. There is not much music that can or ever will compare to the skills the Band had. Legends in my book…. Will be listening to this until the day I die. Thank you Robbie, Rick, Levon, and Hudson
David Crosby, Gordon Lightfoot and now Robbie Robertson. I grew up listening to their music in the 60s & 70s. It was a real privilege to hear them getting started.
Dear Dr Rick.... Sorry to notice about your loss.... I lost two wives 10 years apart were murdered when I wasn't around to protect them.... Talk about stampeding cattle...... Sorry for your loss I'm not trying to make mine bigger than just is what it is man. Luckily I have an old friend of 44 years and she might be my next wife but I told her you have to come armed!!! Feel like I'm a hex on my women !!! They all die!!! But Pamela is pretty tough and she has guns !!!
One of the greatest songs every written, beautifully, tastefully performed. I hope that Robbie, Rick, Richard, Levon rest in peace and that Garth lives in peace. "If there is a rock n roll heaven, you know they have a hellova band!"
My wife and I listen to the Last Waltz every couple of weeks, and we have for 22 years of courting and marriage. Before that I listened to The Band for many many years. They are the best. Never saw them, though. Took them for granted when I was young and in America. Lived half a world away most of my life, and when in NYC never even made it to the Midnight Rambles... don't put off for tomorrow what you owe it to yourself to do today.
One of the best song ever written! Great lyrics (Robbie was a real poet....We'll miss him so much)...wonderful, heartful sax solo...unique lead vocals ...celestial harmomies...This song is a pure beauty
I can remember attending a Ringo's All-Star Band concert and seeing half of the Band play with him. This was back in the 1980s. It was a truly amazing concert.
Thanks for the great songs Robbie and the Band. What a beautiful heartfelt exchange between Robbie and the Sax. In particular, Robbie's solo before the first sax solo really stands out to me. Another great artist lost, but luckily for everyone, this fantastic concert was wonderfully captured for all to see. The last Waltz is a glimpse of a time gone by with many talented artists doing their thing!
I feel exactly the same way. The combination from Robbie’s greatest solo part to Garth’s saxophone always gives me goosebumps! Can't find this great play so often. I will never be bored with this tune. Rick’s desperate voice also captures me. This is the best tune in the ‘Last waltz’ film for me.
Danko seemed like the gentlest soul. Richard seemed like he was always hurting in every way. I hope he found peace and is playing music with his brothers Rick and Levon.
I knew Rick and Levon, to a lesser extent. Rick and I were friends for over 7 years before he passed away. He was funny, goofy, shy, and would literally give his shirt off his back to someone in need. He was truly one of the purist souls I've ever met. His demons are what eventually killed him. I visit him and Levon at least once a month when I'm near Woodstock. I miss him.
@@zahrahblissHow lovely for you to be able to say this, Danko’s voice sure reaches the parts ❤- thank you for your lovely words about him. I’ve loved listening to the Band since I first saw The Last Waltz many moons ago 🐝
One of the best love songs of all time.I loved those guys and my first concert ever was them in Long Beach,Ca after I returned from Vietnam,unforgettable.
I was driving on the PA Turnpike listening to WXPN from Philly and they announced Rick' death and played this song. I had to pull off to the shoulder to cry my eyes out.
Ironically, being from Phila..too,my brother saw Rick in a little bar (he forgets where exactly but it was near Reading, possibly Allentown, towards his later days...After TR show was over,there was Rick at a table signing his book, alone...
47 and spent 21yrs of being a daily heroin junkie waste of space, coming up to 5 yrs clean and I thought that I knew great music ( 60s and 70s) but had never heard of "THE BAND " now clean I hear lyrics and I sit and cry,only few songs get me( hurt,Johnny cash,dock of the bay) EFFIN GREAT BAND AND EVERY SINGLE ONE WAS SOMETHING SPECIAL ❤
@rippi37 " day at a time, and I'm doing fine." I appreciate your message. "It helps, believe it or not, a stranger who will never meet me but takes a minute to type? Tells me that you are a good soul, so thank you
God knows how I loved every member of this iconic BAND. I grew up from 15 yrs old listening to them many times over and still do. I will go to my grave knowing how they broke my heart ,yet enriched my life beyond explanation. Thank you for getting together to leave us your best , and great legacy. I still love it, and more now than ever.
Years ago I drove from UK to Brussels to fight for a woman I loved. Had this song on continual repeat the whole journey. It's beautiful and heartbreaking beyond belief.
RIP Robbie Robbertson, as well as Levon, Rick, and Richard. The brilliance of this song makes it hard to compare it to anything modern. These guys were truly unparalleled.
What a tragedy rick danko a voice gifted by god. R.I.P . How i miss this group their have been many so called super groups for me the band is and was a true super group. Im 70 and there music will stay with me always.
My BIL turned me on to the Band when I was in grammar school in the late 60's. Been a fan ever since and saw them on several occasions at the Filmore East as well at Watkins Glen which for the most part was a total disaster. Still enjoy watching the Last Waltz with all the great performances. It Makes No Difference is just awesome and my favorite with Van' s Caravan right behind it.
I agree with you Michael PM... And this is my favorite version of this song . I don't like to bring it up but I can't not say it... reminds me of my fiance's passing about 45 years ago. And how I felt then.Anyways yes Rick sings great on this . And Robbie Robertson blows my mind ! That plucking muting thing he does on his guitar . His signature I think. To me anyway !
Rest in peace, Robbie Robertson (7, Aug 2023), Rick Danko, Richard Manuel, Levon Helm. Brilliant musicians (Hawks) and creative forces in our time. We will remember.
This performance is sublime. Imagine being up there on stage, knowing you will never do this again. Robbie's playing amazed and mystified other guitarists when he was stll a teenager with the Hawks. This a rare taste of that fire. Rick steps right up here. We get to hear Levon's voice as a harmony - we can't really hear Richard's but we can feel it. ...And then Garth tops it all off for us. What a band.
"Well I love you so much and it's all I can do Just to keep myself from telling you That I never felt so alone before." The way that Danko sings those lines just cracks my heart wide open.
Just sent this to my bestest lover of 40 years ago... we are actually thinking of reuniting... this may well do it. Ric's "Well I love you so much" at 3:45 are to me the lovingest 6 words in all of rock. As well as the immaculate playing and harmonies by all. And then Garth suddenly descends from Heaven with his sax. Never fails to tear me up. Only one wish - that they had done one more chorus again at the end. But that's OK - I can push Replay again. And again. This is a miracle 💓
"I never felt so alone before" is so true. My wife died and I miss her so much. This is such a powerful song. Rick's singing makes the lyrics so sad. Than you have Robertson;s riffs are so planted in the song that it's stunning. I saw them with Dylan way back when.
100%. I’ve watched this performance so many times it’s almost embarrassing to admit, but it’s just perfection, by every single member. Thanks to Robbie Robertson for writing this most gorgeous, saddest of songs, and having the vision to recognize that Rick Danko was the only one to sing it, Also love Robbie’s tasty, soulful note-pinching solos and fills. Garth’s sax brings me to my knees. The harmonies are so beautiful. Rick’s emotion and broken voice filets me every time, and my heart just bleeds out.
Every time you see one of these spectacular Band performances, one can only curse what hard drugs and booze deprived us of. No group was better than when these guys were together.
![Eric Clapton - Makes No Difference (Live) [Crossroads 2023]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LPOeZnbEcBU/mqdefault.jpg)
There should be a limit on how many consecutive times one can listen to this version. After three, you are bordering on a state of despair that renders one useless for the remainder of the day.
😆 true..!!!
This was played at my husband funeral. No limit I say
Amen Vince. This one hits deep!
What?
because of alcohol? or
And the dawn don’t rescue me anymore. Kills me every time.
I agree, somebody breaks up with you, or you break up with someone, not necessarily because you don't love them, but because you feel the relationship is not going anywhere. I speak from personal experience and the line "the dawn don't rescue me" rings true, you get up in the morning thinking things will get better, and you realize it is not getting better. Totally identify with his song. Rick pours all his emotions into it, such heatache, such perfection
Although Hudson is physically frail - he has reportedly been living in an assisted care facility since the death of his wife, Maud, in 2022 Garth is the sole survivor of The Band, I'm 70 and can only wish to live as long as Garth. They were a truly amazing band so special and light years ahead of their contemporaries.
Maybe it’s Garth’s memories that keep him going. A guy who might have ended as a music teacher in small town Ontario, instead was given the gift of sharing his instrumental legacy with the world. Without Garth, The Band would not have been.
@@johntechwriter The whole Band was the sum of one piece. Take out 1 piece you lose the Band.
Absolutely agree with you about their music being light years ahead 💜 I just turned 71 and listening to this song today, sounds so good, their sound has traveled well over the years
They did just fine without Robbie @@Alexandra_acount3
After Levon passed, my brother and I trekked to Woodstock to to show his daughter was giving at The Barn. An intimate musical performance I will never forget, bringing me to tears. Not a dry eye in the place. What a great band.
I cannot describe my sadness on the loss of Robbie Robertson- “and the rains fall down on my door- and the dawn don’t rescue me no more.” I’ve followed The Band for decades and have the clearest memories of listening to The Last Waltz over and over and over. These losses of great musicians are hitting me harder and harder and harder. Thank you Robbie.
love to you, Deborah.....I get it...and as I came here to watch Robbie.....then you see Rick and Levon....and then Garth comes out on the sax...the only one left. The music matters.
We made a tactical error, Deborah. We attached deeply to literally hundreds of musicians that were ten years or so older than us, and now they are dying almost daily. And the ones who wrote the insightful songs, and the challenging songs - the songs that pushed us into becoming deeper ... those are the ones, whose passing hits us the hardest. I think that, when Dylan dies, the country will just shut down for a week.
Robbie's face made it on a Canadian stamp in 2011. The Canadian people recognised what a treasure they had long ago❤
I listen to this one so much. This is my favorite song in The Last Waltz. Rick's vocals are crushing. Robbie's magical right hand shimmy shake during the solo. Garth on smooth sax. Sighhhhh. They are so young and beautiful and talented here. Time Flies. Rest well, Robbie. You've got some good musicians to hang with on the other side. Save me a good seat at the show.
Greatest rock and roll movie of all time. And will always be the greatest. RIP Robbie, you blessed us with some great music..
Danko’s heart was breaking when he sang “read em and weep.” His literal love letter to his B(b)and. Gorgeous.
Rick was just, fuck man what a voice ❤❤❤
One of the most heart breaking songs I've ever heard.
Nothing compares
Heart wrenching. Very time.
This song cuts to my soul
My first wife split after six years of marriage. She returned about four months later. I heard this tune in my apartment, from a Band album, and played it for her upon her return. She sat and listened with no emotion whatsoever. That's when I knew it was over. I moved forward and am with the love of my life after 36 years. A truly great tune and it played an important role in my life! Thank you Robbie and the Band for providing such beautiful music for a generation and more!!
Southtexashombre…lucky you escaped!😎
In late 1976, my partner moved to another city, about 1,000 miles away. in the months before I was able to join her there, I bought The Best of The Band on Cassette, and discovered this song. When I came to the verse "Well, I love you so much that it's all I can do to keep myself from telling you that I never felt so alone before," it broke me up, I was a mess, but it sustained me till I joined her. I already knew some of The Band's work, and had the NME review of the concert, and went to the Australian Premier of the movie. After 15 or 16 times I lost count of the number of times I saw it, and now have all of their studio work and live work, including their time with Dylan. My favourite band of all time.
Like John Prine's Far From Me - Why, we used to laugh together
And we'd dance to any old song
Well, you know, she still laughs with me
But she waits just a second too long
I am a huge Levon fan, but really love Rick Danko's singing on this track. Probably Robertson's best playing as well. God they were a talented bunch
Yes they were and now all we could do is listen.
Your comment nailed it! Yes.
Probably some of Robbie’s best writing, as well. And he’s written so many great ones.
They were the best
there will never be anything like them
Best song of the entire show. After 45 or so years of watching this movie, that’s my story and I’m sticking to it.
Second best is Stage Fright also performed by Rick
Danko was their Best vocals
That scar under Rick’s right eye? I have one just like it. It was created as I was being born. I was born breach, meaning the doctor had to reach in with his forceps and grab me by the head to get me out.
Many equate breach birth to PTSD. All I know is, even that far back, I didn’t want to come out.
I always come back to this song.. beautiful
I think you are correct.
58 yr old,chilling near Edinburgh,only one band member still with us,thank you for giving us this wonderful music..may your wishes all come true,❤
99999
Have a good life Garth!!
Are you talking about Edinburgh Scotland?
Awesome enjoy the music from ‘the band’
I had to grow up (many years) to appreciate how great The Band really was.
As part of my Thanksgiving ritual I saw The Last Waltz again today.
The more I hear Rick Danko, the more I love him. He draws you in. When the song is done you don't know whether to hug him or give him a bowl of soup to care for him.
As a 60 year old, can't emphasize how much I miss the music from my time. Damn....
Goddamnnn. I so miss Rick Danko! What a voice! I never get tired of hearing Rick singing this song, but this has to be the best, most heartfelt version, I've ever seen! RIP Rick Danko!
Rick danko owns this song. Forever.
You bet he does…pure magic.
💯
No one like them, ever!!The Band was so underrated, its sad. The whole Last Waltz was an AMAZING concert, and It Makes No Difference from this concert was & will always be my favorite version of this song. Listen up youngsters, THIS is music.
The Band was the best Band ever. Nothing more to say.
“The dawn don’t rescue me no more” is one of the most powerful lyrics I have ever heard, especially how it is sung here.
Amen. Most great music is born in pain. You feel his, 40 years later.
That lyric sticks with me too. It's absolute desperation.
Yeah, that lyric is the polar opposite of "The sun will come out tomorrow..." It makes no difference when despair and heartbreak prevail.
Bawled my eyes out first time I sang and played this tune, that was the line that broke the dam.
Amen, rest in peace Mr. Danko, Mr. Helm, Mr. Manuel✌️🎶❤️
The best thing Scorsese ever did was to save this, the best version of The Band's most heart wrenching song, for us to cherish until Death do us part. Period. Thank You, The Band. The best band of the 20th Century.
Yup.
The Band and the Staple Singers....brilliant, amazing and unbeatable! Just....WOW
But he passed on "Acadian Driftwood."
yep
True that
The greatest heart breaking song of all time. Pure genius. One of the greatest performances you'll ever hear.
This song makes me cry. It is crazy beautiful.
Maybe my favorite song from the band.
Rest in peace.
Robbie
Levon
Richard
Rick
❤❤
Ditto. This song rips my heart out.❤
When Garth comes out I lose it every time. The pure joy of watching these guys is something I always cherish.
That first lick on the sax gets me every time.
Me too Phil that floored me in the Movie and still years later, it don't get no better.
Greatest Band ever!
4:32 pure heaven
Yes, indeed, Garth’s sax solo makes up for the first guitar solo. JRR had to up his game after hearing that and finished stronger. Now Rick and Solomon Burke must be trading hellacious verses on that one up in heaven. Great song, thank you for sharing it.
What an absolute monster of a heartbreak song!!!!!
Thank you Robbie Robertson, not ashamed to say I cried when I heard the news. 'Lay a flower in the snow, fallen angel'. Rest in Peace
This is as close to perfection as one can get. Not in a sense of the perfect rhythm or every note perfect, but in a sense of music perfectly expressing human emotions. They created a magic moment we can all share.
Yes, and I bet Levon, Rick, and Richard are up there jamming out on this Easter Day, '19. RIP, guys!
@@blancobasnett Lots of magic going here & no overdubs.
Proving yet again it's not what you play it's how you play it. his was one hell of a performance of pure feel..
pawelpap9 no one will drive with me this is the only song I have played for 8 months at least 12 times a day
haha
One of the purest songs ever- I can listen to this over and over again. The sax is brilliant. Appreciate all of these musicians. You will be missed Robby. Your music will live on. Rest in peace 🎼☮️
And don't forget to mention Rick Danko's soulfull and emotionally singing. He really brings it home.
they were all brilliant.
this version
of this song
is heartbreakingly beautiful.
it's been making me cry since it was released.
they're all gone now except Garth.
there's no holding back the tears as I'm listening now...
Yes, the Sax 🎷 solo! Brings a tear to my eye
This is the stand out track ... just beautiful...
I only came across this song a week ago & can’t stop listening to it! And I can’t take my eyes off Rick Danko! 😍
He's something else
Gorgeous talented and a kind man
RIP Legend
My friend you are now 'hooked',
Luuuuv Rick Danko
heart wrenching and graceful at the same time Danko rules
Muitas saudades dessa formidável Banda
Yep....and Robertson fkd it all up.
Dave Chmela : No need to keep bringing all that up. Just enjoy the music and the fact we can at least see them.
Agree, remember this is back when music was actually MUSIC... and I was born in 84, but you no greatness when you see it....
SOUTHPAW731 Danko was your friend??
This was the first song played at my husbands funeral. This song means a lot.
My all times favorite song ❤
Still listening to this in 2021. The Band was great. Man I miss real music.
It’s stil out there, but you’ll have to keep an open mind!
Ya same
Me too. It will never lose its style and "...never seems to fade away..."
.... check out billy string's.... you'll like!
Check out lower back pain, I hear they’re releasing an album this summer
3:46 "Well I love you so much" his voice cracks and so does my heart, every time.
RIP Robbie Robertson. This song is pure perfection.
I learned about the Band because I changed my major from writing to screenwriting in college (Syracuse University). I had one class about music in film and had to watch this film. I fell in love with their music. My mother bought me a case of CDs by the Band for Christmas.
This voice.....so unique, so beautiful and expressive. One of a kind. RIP Danko
Your'e so right!
It's almost like he's possessed when the music starts and the it all just pours out of him.
I miss this band, I wish there was another that could come close to doing what they did. Wow what a collection of musicians that complimented each other so completely.
RIP Rick. What a voice. He died far too soon.
💗 💖 💘 💝 💟
Danko makes me want to hug him after the show
So wish Rick and Richard hadn't gone they way they did, they were supreme ❤❤❤
You can tell he feels every word. Robbie felt Rick could sing it without it coming off as self pity, which Robbie did not want. He was right.
Danko is so hot
Danko and Robbie both.@@로열위드치즈
God, rest, Rick, it's never been the same
4:45 am June 6th of 2020, I said my finals goodbye to my mother. I have a gaping hole where my heart once resided. And the first thing I thought of was the lyric “and the sun don’t shine anymore, and rains fall down on my door.” Only difference is that the rains fall on my soul as I weep for my dear sweet mother. It breaks my heart I didn’t get to say I love you one last time. Rest easy mom, no more pain.
Head up Ricco. She would want that I'm sure...
We all meet again brother, with no more rain!
She knows!
I lost my Dad on June 7. I feel your pain. I miss him so much.
@@GraveyardPoet and Ricco, Grief is a measure of how much you loved someone. And how much they loved you.
One left...RIP Robbie. I'm so fortunate to have listened to your songs growing up. Last Waltz is one of the best music documentaries ever made. Man this one hurts.
This is better than the studio version. Best version I have heard.
Check out the conception and how this was made and you'll understand why it's better than a studio version. It's great to see that other people haven't forgotten what good music is.
Drugs always brings out that pain😪
My favorite too
I agree. So much expression wants to make u cry
Absolutely. ❤️
I’m 37 yrs old and I know this music was before my time but this literally gives me goosebumps every time listening to it…. Pure, raw, unfiltered emotions through music…. There is not much music that can or ever will compare to the skills the Band had. Legends in my book…. Will be listening to this until the day I die. Thank you Robbie, Rick, Levon, and Hudson
richard?
Yep, Richard Manuel. I almost cried the moment I heard he took his own life. He was The Band’s voice.
What a group they were,who else would just jump in with a saxophone,absolutely awesome
Still weep every time I listen to this.
David Crosby, Gordon Lightfoot and now Robbie Robertson. I grew up listening to their music in the 60s & 70s. It was a real privilege to hear them getting started.
RIP Robbie Robertson. Your music touched a much younger generation.
I've been listening to this song for more than 40 years and am blown away every time!! WOW!!
That Sax. Those Vocals. All of it! Love me some Band.
These guys were at the absolute top of their game here. What a band.
THE Band
This and Stage Fright are my favorite The Band songs. Danko is perfectly imperfect as a singer.
What an image, "stampeding cattle, they rattle the walls." No other song expresses the loss of my wife more than this one. Beyond poignant.
Sorry about your wife
Dear Dr Rick.... Sorry to notice about your loss.... I lost two wives 10 years apart were murdered when I wasn't around to protect them.... Talk about stampeding cattle...... Sorry for your loss I'm not trying to make mine bigger than just is what it is man. Luckily I have an old friend of 44 years and she might be my next wife but I told her you have to come armed!!! Feel like I'm a hex on my women !!! They all die!!! But Pamela is pretty tough and she has guns !!!
One of the great Torch songs of the modern era, post Sinatra and Elvis
Up with the best to doubt about that.
Rest In Peace to your beautiful wife. Peace and love brother.
No matter how many years pass I find myself returning to this song whenever I miss my dad
Garth holding his last note for what seems like 10 seconds, one of the sweetest sounds I've ever heard.
and he blows it a little stronger toward the finish for a crescendo
You are so right - I often listen to this song alone for the sound of Garths sax. It’s pure art!
One of the greatest songs every written, beautifully, tastefully performed. I hope that Robbie, Rick, Richard, Levon rest in peace and that Garth lives in peace. "If there is a rock n roll heaven, you know they have a hellova band!"
My wife and I listen to the Last Waltz every couple of weeks, and we have for 22 years of courting and marriage. Before that I listened to The Band for many many years. They are the best. Never saw them, though. Took them for granted when I was young and in America. Lived half a world away most of my life, and when in NYC never even made it to the Midnight Rambles... don't put off for tomorrow what you owe it to yourself to do today.
One of the best song ever written! Great lyrics (Robbie was a real poet....We'll miss him so much)...wonderful, heartful sax solo...unique lead vocals ...celestial harmomies...This song is a pure beauty
Four of them gone... rest easy, Rick, Robbie, Levon + Richard. What a loss to the world.
Truly a loss to the world, they are missed.
I can remember attending a Ringo's All-Star Band concert and seeing half of the Band play with him. This was back in the 1980s. It was a truly amazing concert.
Rip Robbie Robertson 😢. Incredible songwriter. No one ever sounded like The Band
It always amazes me how the singers harmonize so beautifully with no ear piece in their ears and yet never a wrong note…
Thanks for the great songs Robbie and the Band. What a beautiful heartfelt exchange between Robbie and the Sax. In particular, Robbie's solo before the first sax solo really stands out to me. Another great artist lost, but luckily for everyone, this fantastic concert was wonderfully captured for all to see. The last Waltz is a glimpse of a time gone by with many talented artists doing their thing!
RIP Robbie
I feel exactly the same way.
The combination from Robbie’s greatest solo part to Garth’s saxophone
always gives me goosebumps!
Can't find this great play so often.
I will never be bored with this tune.
Rick’s desperate voice also captures me.
This is the best tune in the ‘Last waltz’ film for me.
Makes me want to cry today.
Danko seemed like the gentlest soul. Richard seemed like he was always hurting in every way. I hope he found peace and is playing music with his brothers Rick and Levon.
Shannon, check out festival express to catch a lot of Danko
I knew Rick and Levon, to a lesser extent. Rick and I were friends for over 7 years before he passed away. He was funny, goofy, shy, and would literally give his shirt off his back to someone in need. He was truly one of the purist souls I've ever met. His demons are what eventually killed him. I visit him and Levon at least once a month when I'm near Woodstock. I miss him.
Danko was fearless. He inspired me to pursue singing songwriting
@@zahrahblissThank you
@@zahrahblissHow lovely for you to be able to say this, Danko’s voice sure reaches the parts ❤- thank you for your lovely words about him. I’ve loved listening to the Band since I first saw The Last Waltz many moons ago 🐝
One of the best love songs of all time.I loved those guys and my first concert ever was them in Long Beach,Ca after I returned from Vietnam,unforgettable.
Rick, Levon, Richard and Robbie: one hell of a rocking band in heaven!❤😢
I hope heaven has a quality PA and a great person running the board.
I was driving on the PA Turnpike listening to WXPN from Philly and they announced Rick' death and played this song. I had to pull off to the shoulder to cry my eyes out.
Still do on this song every time.
Ironically, being from Phila..too,my brother saw Rick in a little bar (he forgets where exactly but it was near Reading, possibly Allentown, towards his later days...After TR show was over,there was Rick at a table signing his book, alone...
......But the music lives on. Thanks for the memories. ✌️
47 and spent 21yrs of being a daily heroin junkie waste of space, coming up to 5 yrs clean and I thought that I knew great music ( 60s and 70s) but had never heard of "THE BAND " now clean I hear lyrics and I sit and cry,only few songs get me( hurt,Johnny cash,dock of the bay) EFFIN GREAT BAND AND EVERY SINGLE ONE WAS SOMETHING SPECIAL ❤
Keep it up friend one day at a time
One day at a time 💪💪
You must be proud of yourself....heck I am ! Peace love health and happiness to you and yours xxx
✌️thanks
@rippi37 " day at a time, and I'm doing fine." I appreciate your message. "It helps, believe it or not, a stranger who will never meet me but takes a minute to type? Tells me that you are a good soul, so thank you
Garth Hudson, what an ABSOLUTE GENIUS!!!!!!!
One of their greatest songs and the saxophone at the end just kills it
God knows how I loved every member of this iconic BAND. I grew up from 15 yrs old listening to them many times over and still do. I will go to my grave knowing how they broke my heart ,yet enriched my life beyond explanation. Thank you for getting together to leave us your best , and great legacy. I still love it, and more now than ever.
Every member of The Band is a musical treasure! They really were amazing!!!
Years ago I drove from UK to Brussels to fight for a woman I loved. Had this song on continual repeat the whole journey. It's beautiful and heartbreaking beyond belief.
RIP Robbie Robbertson, as well as Levon, Rick, and Richard. The brilliance of this song makes it hard to compare it to anything modern. These guys were truly unparalleled.
Rick Danko and one of the best songs of all time ... music in the best sense of the word ... and sax at the end ...greetings from Croatia
What a tragedy rick danko a voice gifted by god. R.I.P . How i miss this group their have been many so called super groups for me the band is and was a true super group. Im 70 and there music will stay with me always.
My BIL turned me on to the Band when I was in grammar school in the late 60's. Been a fan ever since and saw them on several occasions at the Filmore East as well at Watkins Glen which for the most part was a total disaster. Still enjoy watching the Last Waltz with all the great performances. It Makes No Difference is just awesome and my favorite with Van' s Caravan right behind it.
I agree with you Michael PM... And this is my favorite version of this song . I don't like to bring it up but I can't not say it... reminds me of my fiance's passing about 45 years ago. And how I felt then.Anyways yes Rick sings great on this . And Robbie Robertson blows my mind ! That plucking muting thing he does on his guitar . His signature I think. To me anyway !
Pure emotion from the heart, often replicated, never duplicated
Rest in peace, Robbie Robertson (7, Aug 2023), Rick Danko, Richard Manuel, Levon Helm. Brilliant musicians (Hawks) and creative forces in our time. We will remember.
This performance is sublime. Imagine being up there on stage, knowing you will never do this again.
Robbie's playing amazed and mystified other guitarists when he was stll a teenager with the Hawks. This a rare taste of that fire. Rick steps right up here. We get to hear Levon's voice as a harmony - we can't really hear Richard's but we can feel it. ...And then Garth tops it all off for us. What a band.
"Well I love you so much and it's all I can do
Just to keep myself from telling you
That I never felt so alone before."
The way that Danko sings those lines just cracks my heart wide open.
It's almost as if he's going break down and cry right there...
That brought a tear to me eye. Heartbreaking and haunting.
Absolutely beautiful. Garth's sax gets me every time.
This is so beautiful. When the sax solo enters, bring tears to my eyes.
The Garth sax solo still gives me chills…….I’m 77, heard it a few timrs
Just sent this to my bestest lover of 40 years ago... we are actually thinking of reuniting... this may well do it. Ric's "Well I love you so much" at 3:45 are to me the lovingest 6 words in all of rock. As well as the immaculate playing and harmonies by all. And then Garth suddenly descends from Heaven with his sax. Never fails to tear me up. Only one wish - that they had done one more chorus again at the end. But that's OK - I can push Replay again. And again. This is a miracle 💓
This is one of the greatest moments in the history of rock music
Gad, they EACH shine individually and together. They were the best...BAND!
"I never felt so alone before" is so true. My wife died and I miss her so much. This is such a powerful song. Rick's singing makes the lyrics so sad. Than you have Robertson;s riffs are so planted in the song that it's stunning. I saw them with Dylan way back when.
🍺
I feel you pain. I hope G-dad’s tender mercy heals your heart soon.
I’m so sorry for your loss,music such as this truly can be the thread to the life we lived with our dearly departed
Rick puts his all into this....I loved them in 69 and still do...
RIP Robbie- the music will last forever
Saw them in 1969 first time
50 years after first hearing these beautiful songs I cry listening to them now.
This brings me tears age 60 !
Incredible voice but more importantly one of the purest souls. No affectation.
Danko at his very finest, The Band close to breaking up but never better, Hudson.. what a genius
100%. I’ve watched this performance so many times it’s almost embarrassing to admit, but it’s just perfection, by every single member. Thanks to Robbie Robertson for writing this most gorgeous, saddest of songs, and having the vision to recognize that Rick Danko was the only one to sing it, Also love Robbie’s tasty, soulful note-pinching solos and fills. Garth’s sax brings me to my knees. The harmonies are so beautiful. Rick’s emotion and broken voice filets me every time, and my heart just bleeds out.
@@genevievegelatto8447 What a great, beautiful, poetic reply, thank you!
close to breaking up? In the act of breaking up!
that is Richard Manuel, not Hudson
Danko..what an amazing lost soul
Oh, how I have always adored this band. My sadness at the loss of Robbie is true. I had such extraordinary respect for him. RIP beautiful man.
there is no sadder song... delivered with an iconic vocal.
I agree
Thank you,Mr Danko for this wonderful song. R.I.P
AMEN
Love Rick Danko's passion when he's singing this song--what a great song👍🏽👏🏼🤠
Every time you see one of these spectacular Band performances, one can only curse what hard drugs and booze deprived us of. No group was better than when these guys were together.
Happy Birthday, hard to believe Rick would have been 77 today.
What an amazing talent, seems like a really nice guy too.
"And the dawn don't rescue me any more" brilliant and may be one of my favorite lyric lines.
One of the greatest songs ever. So much talent in "The Band." 🙏