Yasir Qadhi is WRONG about Khilafah - Here’s Why
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ค. 2024
- On this first episode of The i3 Show, Sheikh Usta reacts to Yasir Qadhi’s video “Thoughts on re-establishing Khilafa” and breaks down some crucial flaws in his argument. For Muslims, Khilafah is a heavily-loaded question, but one thing is clear- it should not be treated as an option.
Interested in shifting your paradigm? Subscribe to I3 Institute and join our mission to empower Muslims with a non-secular, intellectual understanding of Islām.
Want to become a Muslim with a vision?
Join the Muslim Blueprint program here ⬇️
www.i3institute.ca/programs/mbp
Find Sheikh Usta on Instagram and Twitter: @sheikhusta
Follow I3institute’s IG: @I3institute
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Playoffs Lower Bracket Final // PRX vs DRX](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/5HwO1bQyAx4/mqdefault.jpg)
Great video Sheikh! Khilafah is necessary because without it, we're going to just complain to Westerners about Muslim issues, which they don't care about. It's so pathetic.
If we can get just 5 or 6 countries to unite, it would make an impact, insha Allah.
Please let me know when you get 2-3 !! Your in Dreamland... We are in the end days... Wake up
Which countries ? Those which have sworn alligence to the rulership of kufr at the UN? Nullifiers of Islam are an extremely serious matter.
Don't expect the current Muslim nations to unite, and implement a Khilafah. They're all led by Puppet masters to the UN and US. We need to establish a Khilafah based on the Prophetic Methodology, which fully imposes Sharia without any sugarcoating.
Also, do you think the West and the "Muslim" nations would simply allow a Khilafah to emerge? Look how they all united to defeat the ones whom tried doing so (I'm not supporting them), that shows you that you can't rely solely on these Muslim nations whom are the lap dogs of western nations.
Not to mention anyone who holds these views will be labelled as a fanatic, kharijite, terrorist, extremist, but alhamdulillah we still have people working to establish it. People also fantasize and think it can be implemented without shedding any blood, or without going through countless of wars. This is a delusion, and retaliation from those who oppose islamic doctrine is to be expected. Study how the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) and his companions (May Allah be pleased with them) expanded Islam and the Khilafah.
Islam began as something strange and will revert to being strange as it began, so give glad tidings to the strangers." - Sahih Muslim 145
Only Allah is the sole owner and ruler of the whole universe.
Allah has chosen Ahlul Beyt household of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his family.
Imam Ali is the first caliph and
Imam Mahdi is the last caliph who will establish Islam on the whole earth.
Imam Mahdi Alaihissalam is agreed upon in all the Ummah
So we must establish Islamic system like Islamic system Iran is fighting against America and Israel...
Like Islamic Yemen zaydi Mujahideen fighting against America and Israel.....
Labbaika Ya Mahdi Alaihissalam 🕋🇾🇪🇵🇸🇮🇷
The evidence that “Whoever dies while there was no allegiance on his neck dies a death of the days of ignorance (Jahiliyyah).” is warning enough along with the Sahabaa delaying the burial of THE Prophet Mohammed alayhi elsalam solely to choose a Kahleef, subhaan Allah how serious must it be and how major is the position and the role it plays in the Muslim Ummah
No need to choose khalifa
Just give bayat to the caliph choosen by Allah.
Only Allah chooses caliph not people.
Only Allah is the sole owner and ruler of the whole universe.
Allah has chosen Ahlul Beyt household of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his family.
Imam Ali is the first caliph and
Imam Mahdi is the last caliph who will establish Islam on the whole earth.
Imam Mahdi Alaihissalam is agreed upon in all the Ummah
So we must establish Islamic system like Islamic system Iran is fighting against America and Israel...
Like Islamic Yemen zaydi Mujahideen fighting against America and Israel.....
Labbaika Ya Mahdi Alaihissalam 🕋🇾🇪🇵🇸🇮🇷
@@user-ss6fi7fp5s Imam ali couldn't save his wife according to shia theology. Shia's alleged imam mahdi aka dajjal is hiding in cave from abbasid soldiers for over 1200 yrs in fear of getting killed and eventually be killed by bearded woman. Ayatollats are living off lavishly on khums money on behalf of fabricated imam mahdi given by gullible shia and made up khurafaat. Khomeini la came up with concept of WTF(wilaya tul faqih) bcoz shia were asking why mahdi is not coming out of hiding and doing his job. And hence contradicted his own theology and arguments against sahaba that only divine allocated person can rule yet he who was not divinely appointed assumed the role. May ALLAH swt guide you and all other strayed from path.
Imaam al-Ghazali (rh.a.) when writing of the potential consequences of losing the Khilafah said,
"The judges will be suspeneded, the Wilayaat (provinces) will be nullified, ... the decrees of those in authority will not be executed and all the people will be on the verge of Haraam".
(al Iqtisaad fil Itiqaad page 240.)
Imam an-Nawawi (Rh) said:
"They (the scholars) consented that it is an obligation upon the Muslims to appoint a khalifah and that its obligation is by revelation, not reason."
[Sharhu Sahih Muslim page 205 vol 12]
Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The Israelis used to be ruled and guided by prophets: Whenever a prophet died, another would take over his place. There will be no prophet after me, but there will be Caliphs who will increase in number." The people asked, "O Allah's Messenger (ﷺ)! What do you order us (to do)?" He said, "Obey the one who will be given the pledge of allegiance first. Fulfil their (i.e. the Caliphs) rights, for Allah will ask them about (any shortcoming) in ruling those Allah has put under their guardianship."
[Sahih al-Bukhari 3455]
It has been narrated on the authority of Abu Huraira that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said:
One who defected from obedience (to the Amir) and separated from the main body of the Muslims - if he died in that state-would die the death of one belonging to the days of Jahiliyya (i.e. would not die as a Muslim). One who fights under the banner of a people who are blind (to the cause for which they are fighting, i.e. do not know whether their cause is just or otherwise), who gets flared up with family pride, calls (people) to fight for their family honour, and supports his kith and kin (i.e. fights not for the cause of Allah but for the sake of this family or tribe) - if he is killed (in this fight), he dies as one belonging to the days of Jahiliyya. Whoso attacks my Ummah (indiscriminately) killing the righteous and the wicked of them, sparing not (even) those staunch in faith and fulfilling not his promise made with those who have been given a pledge of security - he has nothing to do with me and I have nothing to do with him.
[Sahih Muslim 1848 a]
Beautiful, may Allah SWT bless you.
I am a Revert from Germany. I am glad to see such a good Video. This is the First Video i saw from this Chanel. I have to subscribe
Willkommen, Bruder aus Polen.
Willkommen Bruder. Mashaallah
Welcome to Islam. Dear brother. Seeing people reverting makes my heart warm.
And the fact that you're watching this video, shows Allah loves you and wants the best for you. May Allah bless us all. Ameen.
May Allah keep you steadfast on the deen❤
I'd recommend you better to listen to salafi publications.
If we have a khilafa everything within the deen will follow, Allah swt doesn't change the situation of one another untill they change what's in themselves. We have to throw 'wahn' out (love for this life) and unite as one ummah
Brother isn’t it the other way around Allah swt doesn't change the situation of one another untill they change what's in themselves. Deen in ourselves then khalifah will come barakalafi
@@abdullahanselin8474 yes i agree, but our mindset needs to be wanting a khilafa and throw 'wahn' our of our lifes (love for dunya). Only the laws of Allah swt (sharia) will remind people our purpose in life. In orded for that to implement in society we need a khilafa and spread awareness amongst our brothers and sisters in sha'allah
💯💯💯 exactly why oppression is happening , Hadith says we are I s tage 4 of 5 rulership currently under global tyranny. Global Hollywood deception all politicians , countries armies leadership are on same team taking orders from shaytan and his minions ... Also we were warned about.misguided scholars, manufactured news, hired actors misdirecting Ummah etc. May Allah guide and unite us Insha Allah Imam Mehdi up next Al Hamdulillah
Sunan Abi Dawud 4297
Narrated Thawban:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said: The people will soon summon one another to attack you as people when eating invite others to share their dish. Someone asked: Will that be because of our small numbers at that time? He replied: No, you will be numerous at that time: but you will be scum and rubbish like that carried down by a torrent, and Allah will take fear of you from the breasts of your enemy and last enervation into your hearts. Someone asked: What is wahn (enervation). Messenger of Allah (ﷺ): He replied: Love of the world and dislike of death.
This was amazing. Need Sh Yasir to have a discourse Sh Usta ASAP.
Jazak Allah Khair this is the conversation we as an ummah need to be having. Unlike what Sheikh Yasir said its not among the top 10,20 things, this is top priority to solve the oppression of Muslims everywhere.
What about oppression by muslims?
May Allah bless you Sheikh Usta, that was a very powerful, effective and astute breakdown. It’s definitely necessary to combat this mindset of incompetence and helplessness that has taken over the Muslimeen. Furthermore, to correct straw-man arguments and distortions of the Ahadith that are being used to bolster a stance of weakness in the Ummah, and acceptance of Western sovereignty. We have to stop thinking that we can achieve justice within the corrupt systems of the West, and we have to stop considering the establishment of Hukm of Allah to be “optional”.
No need to choose khalifa
Just give bayat to the caliph choosen by Allah.
Only Allah chooses caliph not people.
Only Allah is the sole owner and ruler of the whole universe.
Allah has chosen Ahlul Beyt household of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his family.
Imam Ali is the first caliph and
Imam Mahdi is the last caliph who will establish Islam on the whole earth.
Imam Mahdi Alaihissalam is agreed upon in all the Ummah
So we must establish Islamic system like Islamic system Iran is fighting against America and Israel...
Like Islamic Yemen zaydi Mujahideen fighting against America and Israel.....
Labbaika Ya Mahdi Alaihissalam 🕋🇾🇪🇵🇸🇮🇷
Jkr
During the pre-lslamic period of ignorance I saw a she-monkey surrounded by a number of monkeys. They were all stoning it, because it had committed illegal sexual intercourse. I too, stoned it along with them.
Sahih al-Bukhari 3849
Barakallahu feekum Sh. Osta, well balanced outlook on the issue of khilafa and unifying the Muslim ummah - especially how the matter is presented in such a low-priority manner when it is a fardh.
Definitely agree with you here!
I'm so glad the i3 institute could make a response to that video! JazakumAllahu khairan, there were many points I didn't agree with in there, and this video explains and sums it up perfectly!
Yasir Qadhi may like history read a lot of history but how he interprets it, is very problemetic. nd sadly he often sides with oriental interpretations I want to suggest two videos one is Library chat 24 and Yasir Qadhis understanding of Banning Coffee vs Coffee was once banned from Blogging theology.
also another point comes to mind when Yasir Qadhi talking about Printing press. When i first heard it, i thought it was a good explanation even i heard Faras Zahabi talking about this. But once i started to read more about it, the situtaion is not that easy, it was very complex.
One of the reasons Ottomans didnt allow it for muslims beause every early printed book was Christian reigious book, Missonary books.
when Europeans first came to our land first thing they published was a Christian missionary book, that is the fisrt printed book in Bangla. So now when Yasir Qadhi talk about History i am more cautious.
You will see those who follow defend and support tasir qadhi justify orientalism because only deviants will defend another deviant
Barakallahu feek sheikh and for doing this with great manners.
MashaAllah. It was the ONLY lecture from Shaykh Qadhi out of thousands I had a bit pain in my stomach while hearing it. Let us agree on that we somtimes dont agree on everything. It is his opinion. As far as I know he did not forbid it at all. It seems like it is his opinion and nothing more. May Allah Azza jall bless the whole ummah and bring us back together to finaly act like a whole body. Amin.
That murtadd, Yasir Qadhi, has made many kufri statements. This is nothing new.
Akhi, Assalamu Alaikum. It It's the only lecture that you find problematic, you should be more careful. Yani, he said many things, too many things not to notice or find problematic. May Allah guide us all.
@@ServantOfAllah36 Walaykum Asalaam Warahmatullahi Wabarakatuhu akhi. I’ve known Yasir Qadhi for almost 20 years. I used to take knowledge from him when he still had a Sunnah beard and was talking about tawheed. However, after 9/11 he has changed a lot, just like murtadd Hamza Yusuf (who I also used to defend back in the days). Alhamdulillah for guidance from Allah The Magnificent to show me authentic Islam through scholars like Shaykh Ahmad Musa Jibril and Shaykh Nasir Al Fahd (and many more like Shaykh Younus Kathrada). Ones you taste the sweetness of authentic imaan, then you will notice the pattern of the filthy ones. Ameen to your beautiful dua. May Allah The Majestic guide us to whatever pleases Him alone.
@@Holistic_Islam Dear Brother, I know you have strong opinions against Sh. Qadhi, but the man is a practicing Muslim.
From one Muslim to another, and with sincereity, I kindly advise you to not speak ill of our fellow brother, regardless of what your opinion on him might be. To call someone a "Murtad" on the internet for hundreds of people to see, without Sh. Qadhi being available to comment and defend himself, is akin to backbiting. I know you are a God Fearing brother and would not do such a thing.
If I came across as rude, I apologize. Thanks for taking the time to think about this.
@@serenevalor Jazak Allah Khair for your kind words and your sincere concerns. However, this is not an issue that I just came up with. The Ulama have declared him a murtadd more than a decade ago. Yasir Qadhi is not a man enough to debate Shaykh Ahmad Musa Jibril, in order to make these matters clear for all of us and in order for him to defend himself. Why is he a coward and doesn’t debate Shaykh Ahmad Musa Jibril in an open public forum? Someone who is knowledgeable and sincere should be able to defend themselves. Muslims aren’t stupid, we can see through lies. How is Yasir Qadhi a practicing Muslim when he says to a kaffir Christian enemy of Allah that he and his buddies (other “scholars”) are in process to change the hudud punishments? That’s kufr akbar that no two Muslims can disagree on. This is just the most recent Kufr statement he has done, together with saying that the filthy Jews of today (who are mushrikeen and kuffar) are the true followers of Musa (Sallalahu alayhim Wasalam). I’m not even talking about his kufri statements regarding Yajuj and majuj or all his other kufri statements that go back more than a decade ago. I’m not exaggerating when I say that I can bring you dozens of his statements that are kufr akbar. However there’s no need of that, unless you want me to tell you. Please read my previous replies in which I talk about knowing him for almost 20 years. Please listen to any lecture of Shaykh Ahmad Musa Jibril in order to know what true scholarship is from someone who radiates taqwa.
Very informative video to watch, with solid evidence. May Allah help us to be those who revive this Ummah on the Haqq
What a powerful response to Yasir Qadhi!!! May Allah bless sheikh Usta.
I just love his levels of adab BaarakaLLAHU feeh
An Umma without a head a Khalifa is like a chicken with no head.
May Allah bless Shaykh Yasir Qadhi and grant him Jannah
Yasir Qadi is very realistic looking at the world we live in now and he’s not in favour of removing the khalifa or against it, he’s just pragmatic about it and he’s right u gotta start somewhere small, somewhere low then make your way up to the kalifa. The main thing is unity! We must achieve unity first in the ummah via any tactics or methodology.
To ones carrying the dawah in a comprehensive way, which includes the active obligation of the resumption of Islamic way of life, through an Islamic polity (Khilafah) are teaching the Muslims and our kids to be the leadersbof tomorrow.
The ones who have it below their "top 20" in some vague and ambigious description of priorities are teaching the Muslims that the establishment of the Deen and the free and total submission to Allah swt by implementing His Adress to mankind is of no priority and that our childeren should prepare themselves for subservience to oppressive and un-Islamic Deens, their systems and ways of life.
The Chinese managed to become a superpower within a timespan of 30 years due to an idea, vision, determination, striving and patience. And all of this upon kufr and jahiliyyah.
We have Islam... yet some seem to fail to recognize the need, urgense, vital priority.
We may ask, who or what determines our priorities ? Is it personal opinion or is it the Shar' ? And if itbis the Shar' then in what way did we arrive at our conclusions.
Great stuff sh usta... always a treat to watch you...
More harmful than dajjal....!!!!
Abu Dhar said, "I was with the Prophet ﷺ one day and I heard him saing: “There is something I fear for my Ummah than the Dajjal.”
It was then that I became afraid, so I said: 'Oh Rasool Allah! Which thing is that?" He ﷺ said, “Misguided and astray scholars.”
Musnad Imam Ahmad, hadith - 21334 aur 21335. Shaykh Shu'ayb al Arna'ut graded it sahih li ghayri (authentic due to corroborating narrations) in his tahqiq of the Musnad Imam Ahmad.
11:58 A new modern explanation of the hadith that is consistent with this is that the absence of Khilafa and the Baia to a Caliph Global has brought about the Jahiliya. Interest was frowned upon at the time of Khilafa by most peoples, even in Europe, but today it is part of the system. In Europe and in many other areas, people wore headscarves or moral clothing, today they wear nudity. Marriage was standard worldwide, today it has become an exception, etc. Etc. Etc.
Mashallah Sheikh Usta, this is my first time listening and I think the polite yet firm clarification is really helpful, especially for the younger generations! I would encourage reaction videos, like this.
6:44 subhanalloh, i can't believe my ears. He is a role model for millions of muslims??
this Mr. Yassir is a fitnah himself. He is one of those "scholars" who is ruining everything Islam stands for. May Allah give him hidayah and save us from him and his types of fitnah. Ameen.
Ameen
The preachers of peace and romance
Fear Allah. Why are you slandering a scholars in RAMADAN? 3EEB.
@@ninaaden8338 i fear Allah. Which is why i consider yasir qadhi a fitnah. You should do the same, my brother.
Can you detail what exactly we are looking for?
Jazak allahu cheiran, this soulde be watched by all muslims
Fascinating! ❤️ May Allah swt Guide us! Aaamin
Ameen
Should be discussed the matter personally as Ummah Should Respect each other, by the way, Yasir Qadhi never mentioned anyone’s name and I see his utmost respect to this kind of different opinion’s! So , in my point of view , in the name of awareness, none should be humiliated as this manner! Period!
Allah (awl) bless with respect whomever He(swt )Wants and takes away respect whomever He(awl)Wishes, then who are we to judge someone’s intention publicly! Sheikh Yasir Qadhi is our fellow brother and this should be addressed in his presence, not through the public platform where he is missing! I’m not very knowledgeable, but it’s my ethics! Allah (awl) is the Best disposer of the affairs and Best Knower!May Allah (awl) grant us Unity among the Ummah and bless us with the ability to respect each other! Ameen ya Rabb
Jazak Allah Khair Shaykh for clarify the totaly wrong statements of Shaykh Yasir Qadi in his Video abaout the Khilafah. Barak Allah Feek
We do need Khilafah
Jzk sheikh Usta amazing video , may Allah unite the ummah upon His deen and grant us victory over the disbelievers and hypocrites ameen
I can’t wait to be a student of shaikh Ustah may Allah preserve him. I waited for so long for the program to launch and when it did I was accidentally forgotten. I’m inshallah going to be the first student next round. Jazak Allah khair for this very clear and very beneficial response shaikh.
Ameen
As salaamu alaykum Shaykh. Shukraan for the very important reminder for the Ummah to reinvigorate the efforts to re-establish the authentic khilafah/islamic system of governance.
mashaAllah, I can't imagine the level of patience this Shaykh has to politely refutes kindergarten arguments.
10:51 1 day under righteous rule is equivalent to 60 (in other 70) years of Ibada. Every day in Khilafa is almost like Laylatul Qadr here without! What is this guy talking about !?😡
Simply for living. For breathing. What if you experience Laylatul Qadr in Khilafa? Ya Shaykh Yasires explain
I really don't know what is Sheikh Yasir is on about. I followe him for a very long time and followed his complete series on the seerah of the prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) and it was great but then he started to change with stange views starting from the preservation of the Quran, view on LGTV, khilafa on blood brothers podcast and etc..
May Allah guide him. I really like the way he speaks but it's becoming more and more problematic :(
@@mshaz452
I think Daniel Haqiqatjou hit the bull's eye with the videos in which he exposed his person.
Yasir Qadhi is a puppet.. Don't be fooled
May Allah bless you sheikh Usta!
why khilaf is not important ? are you serious don't confuse ummah
What a defeated and non encouraging attitude has this Sheikh Yassir Kadhi.
Great refutation!!!
Secular Muslim minds should be fixed by reengineering so that they can elevate their confidence in Allah SWT and His Deen totally 100%, not less.
Yasir Qadhi expressed his support for the concept of striving for a khilafah, but considering the current situation, he views it as more of a fantasy. His main priority is to address the critical issue of preventing Muslims from abandoning their faith. He also mentioned that in the event the khilafah is established, he intends to contribute within its structure.
If that's how he's prioritizing the issues of Islām then he lacks basic understanding of Deen and Seerah of RasūlAllahﷺ, & he must be corrected for his Bātil views of maintaining status-quo and trying to solve the present problems with UnIslamic solutions which are not even open for Ijtihad but clear fard.
😂😂😂
He is doing demagoguery to the apostate, a demagoguery to those who have already developed ills about islam in their heart.
Rather than fixing those ills, and washing them with away with light of Imaan, rather than trying to cure their heart to love deen of Islam, he is letting those ills grow more and more by water-dowing the islam itself, simoly to appease their ill-sentiments. Such that even if they would return, they would return to the deen whch is not completely and originally revealed by Allah, but something that appeals to their personal prejudice, biases and wishfull desire.
Speaking in western a youth terms -
It is like a guy who was ditched by a cunning play-girl, whon began to hate himself in desperaton, and gaveup all goodness from his heart, just to beg the girl return to him. Now he start to hate his own goodness just because that girl is not retuning anymore, the fool thinks there was something wrong in himself rather than realizing that she would have never left if she was honest.
@mdfahd24 "The prophet salla Allahu alaihi wa sallam had not talked about khilafa like many of the ignorant people claim!
He worked all of his life to establish matters of aqeedah and teach people how to implant sharia law.
People of innovation neglected all of that and only want to establish an Islamic government and to rule the people regardless of how. This is not the way of the prophet nor his companions" - Assim al Hakeem
@@badarambogeFirst off, you have to prove that Asim Al Hakeem said that because that is a very problematic statement to make. Secondly, Rasool Allah ﷺ didn't need to mention the word "khilafah" because it was understand by everyone, believer or non believer what Islam truly was. The elites knew Islam was a threat to their power structure because Islam is a system that restructures society to the way that Allah SWT has commanded and revealed to us through the Quran and Sunnah.
Is it legitimate to believe we can be split nations so long as we strive to have Sharee'ah of Allah implemented fully
I have a small question to my fellow ummah. Who is the most suitable amongst the living Muslim leaders to become the Khalifa?
Excellent video sheikh that you have delivered with such respect and true humbleness. We have hope. Alhamdulillah
Shiekh keep it up spread the truth and Haqq'
23:39 🔥 peaceful prophetic dawah
JazakumAllah khair Sheikh, great video
basically listen to Sheikh yasir qadhi and think about the stuff that he says are the least priorities, actually have the possibility of being the highest priority, Sheikh Usta is a great teacher
Jazak Allahu Khayr
Jazzak Allah Khir , great clear professional respectful refute
Muslim enemies have two main strategies that they use to dismantle Islamic power, one is KHILAFA should not come back and secondly any ruler who rules two main holy cities should have good relations with them, and when I saw sheikh Yasir Qadi’s speech they have succeeded for those two main.
Assalaamu Alaikkum Wa Rahmathullaahi Wa Barakaathuh, Dear Brothers and Sisters, I would like to express my humble opionions. For my knowledge, recently in regards of Khilafa, none has the dare to speak, when somebody expressing their opinions, this becomes an debate, in my humble opinion Shk.Usta should discuss with Shk.Yasser Qadhi with the presence of some other Shks.
Today we just keep watching the Genocidal in Gaza, there are so many Muslim countries around the world, none of them did nothing not even a boycott against jews products, majority of our Muslim countris are not bothered to unite after 30,000+ Shuhadhaas, 70,000+ wounded and the whole Gaza looks like a construction sites, there is no hospital, no medicines, no electricity, no school, no Masjid, no food so, the list is ever ending, in this situation how can he priorotize among top 10 or 20.
What surprises me is that YQ did so much schooling , how does he get dumber
Arrogance
Arrogance or agenda!
@@publicpm8809 it might be agenda
@@eastafricanqueen9866 100% possible cuz this is not the first time that people from Yaqeen institute are aligning with liberal secular values instead of Islamic values plus Yaqeen institution gets funding from non-Muslim governments.
@@publicpm8809 basically sellouts , what a shame
Yasir Qadi needs to stop addressing the Ummah as of TODAY, it’s time for him to apologize misleading our Ummah. We are going through Gaza and we don’t need internal divisions
How is he misleading the Ummah? You need help for real
Here you started fascist dictatorship
Even if a shaykh says something you disagree with, doesn't necessarilly mean we should neglect everything else he has done for the ummah. Sh YQ is definitely not misleading wholistically if we consider all his content, that's different from giving people the wrong idea through his opinions. Not everythimg is black and white like that.
Assalamu Alaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu.
Masha Allah, a very clear response.
Maybe, the best thing would have been to sit with him first and discuss this before making a video publicly debunking him. This is what creates animosity between scholars. Trust me that if you later sat with him and talked about this, the effect of this video would not be undone.
It's not important for Yasir Qadhi because its not important to anti-Muslim Western leaders. And Yasir has to appease them
Actually, every one is agree that Khilafah is must including shaikh yasir Qazi but how to establish it in the present scenario?
This the Question which needs to be Answered.
Actually I am shocked that a Shaykh like Yasir Qadi who says he is master in Hadith and Seerah seems to have very big lack of knowledge in this very famouse Ahadith about the very important Issue about the re-establishing about the Khilafah and how Rasulullahs (saw) Method was to establish the first Islamic state in Medina. And what actions our dear Prophet (saw) took to achieve his (saw) goal to get to the point when he (saw) was able to establish the Islamic State in Medina.
I am a student of knowledge that has admired the work of Shaykh Osta and have attended a lot of events locally. However, I don’t think much was achieved through this response except debunking the opinion of Shaykh Yasir. I find it difficult to grasp and agree with all the points shaykh Osta made and to an extent, there maybe some allegations and points quoted out of context. Such as, “….why don’t you teach….as if Allah and the system that he revealed to us from a political perspective is just like all the man made systems.. full of gaps and ruins..”
Do you really think that someone like a shaykh Yasir would undermine the system of Allah or equate that to a man-made system? This is misrepresentation and distortion of the opinions yasir Qadhi presented.
Moreover, having a private talk and criticizing someone’s views privately is much better than creating a video on how they “messed up”.
It’s more beneficial for a Muslim community to benefit from a knowledge based video than a video highlighting the flaws of another scholar.
جزاكم الله خيرا
Shaykh should have the channel with his own name. It would generate much more views.
BarakAllahufeek Sheikh
Response to 23:22
What do you call the conquest of Mecca or the abolition of the religious systems of the pagan Arabs? What do you call the destruction of their places of worship, their priests and priestesses? What do you call the overthrow of the power structures in the Hijaz and North Africa in the 7th century if not an Islamic revolution?
Besides, how was the Khalifa maintained and secured? Do you really believe that a Caliph can conquer foreign lands, impose Islamic rule, demand Jizya, and that's it? No one will complain and no one will push back? Sheikh Yasir once pointed out that it is no accident that the borders of Islam today are largely the borders of conquest.
If Muslims want to establish a "meaningful" Khalifa that looks anything like the Rashidun Caliphate, they'll first have to confront other Muslims. Why? Because that's what happened in the 7th century! The best Muslims (Sahabas) battled each other to establish and maintain the Khalifa. Why think it will be any different today?
How successful was Mohammed in establishing the Khalifa in Mecca when he was only giving Dawah? And when he established the Khalifa, was it before or after clashing violently with his pagan opponents?
Today's opponents of Islamic rule are home and abroad. So if you are calling for the revival of the caliphate, you should at least be honest about the likely cost.
ما شاء الله تبارك الله، نعم النصيحة ووفق الله أخانا للرجوع إلى الحق.
Bless the men of knowledge, and respect them in their respective fields, and do not exceed Beyond once’s capacity.
For example, if you ask a women what is a flour, she would say ‘rose’
You ask a chef what is flower, he would say wheat. The word khilafah has different meanings to Muslims who teach different areas of knowledge. So the discipline in the Scenice of Quran does not automatically give the mind the intellectual capacity to understand politics, the affairs of society, this necessitates political thinking.
Yasir qadhi say : start small
I hope sh. Yaser apologizes, and starts fresh, may Allah opens his heart to understand this properly
Shame to see muslims dissing muslims, casually calling kufr on others without knowing for sure that when they die what their own status will be. If you disagree on something, just do it in a respectful manner. It would not be a surprise that the very negatives that you publicly call/shame on others, may very well be seen in your ownself in the future. A muslim is a mirror to another!
Where did he do takfeer on him? In fact Usta displayed the highest level of adab and respect to YQ. He provided valid criticism without attacking him.
Talking about comments section here.
The history of human on earth began with Khilafa. Allah Swt could have said to send “human” instead of “khalifa”.
1. Why did Allah mention khalifa?
2. Why did he first officially appoint Daud as caliph?
3. How many people became Muslim during the first 13 years of Prophet pbuh in Mecca and why the number was so less?
4. Why was Yarthrib chosen for migration instead other places?
5. Why did the Prophet pbuh not share the power with others (in Mecca and yathrib)
6. Why was the burial of the prophet pbuh delayed for 3 days?
7. Why did Allah say “establish prayers”?
8. How do you establish the rule of Allah on earth without having a Khalifa and how do you implement hudud?
8. On what basis a handful of Muslims ruled two-thirds of the world and the world witnessed peace and harmony all over? On the contrary, why the billions of Muslims are being tortured, humiliated and killed all over?
I am a lame Muslim. Not much knowledge on islam but my common sense says that the peace and tranquility will never be established on earth if the command of Allah is not implemented.
Why was the caliphate in turkey been abolished when there was no need of it as the power of the Sultan was just like the pope?
Beautiful analysis! Jazakallah
Very true
Allahuma barik
There is an excellent book, "Al Tawheed" by Shahid Ismā'il al Farooqi. Within this invaluable book is a chapter on understanding and establishing a Khilafa.
"The ummah, is the agent of world reconstruction, or world reformation to fulfill the Divine Will... As a state, the ummah should be referred to as al khalifa rather than al dawlah. The former is closer to the Islamic tradition and to al tawhid of which it is a direct and Qur'anic deduction. The latter (al dawlah) is a modern notion, and stands at the farthest remove of the Qur'anic idea of vicegerency which is the raison d'être of the umma."
Y. Qadhi is ruining the principles of actualizing Islam.
barakallahu feek!
Am so happy we have Checks and Balances, this is very important for our ummah
Having no khilafa is like saying the company will be own its own and every employee will do what he see fits and go where he see fit and there would be no coherence and system to keep us on a unified track.
Lets see the sheikh in the light of the country he lives in ie USA. Can he say we need khilafa more than ever? CIA is keeping watch on him and he knows it probably.
May Allah guide us all!
Honestly a lot of weak arguments. You mostly agreed with YQ in essence but disagreed in rhetoric. You fundamentally ignored his main point, that Khilafa is fard on those who are able to implement it أهل الحل و العقد not on the average Muslim, and you failed to address this.
It seems that criticizing YQ is the popular thing to do these days, so people will do it-loudly and publicly-even when they mostly agree with him. I agree it would be better if we had people that can get away with rhetorically calling for the reestablishment of the Khilafa, but you and I both know the dangers of that. Barak Allahu feek sheikh and may Allah bless us all reaching the solution to this problem in this life time
I stopped listening to Yassir Qadi since Daniel Haqiqatjou (the Muslim Skeptic) first exposed him, this video just confirmed it.
Highly doubt you even watched Shaykh Yasir Qadhi's content to begin with. 😉
@@ninaaden8338it's interesting seeing how people like yourself resort to making assumptions and ad hominems when emotionally triggered and incapable to responding objectively.
Facts, to establish a khilafah would require so much bloodshed and chaos, it's not even feasible.
We need to actually get Muslim unity first, rather than this nationalism curse we have at the moment.
You will only get unity through Khilafa.
The salaf fought wars to make sure there was 1 Imam for the ummah.
yaa now u Muslim are very stable condition know? i know u r same then u r ok...go to syria ...iraq ...yamen... Palestine....read seerah
@@existenceofgod.1927, stop please. You have typed gibberish.
@@-------....___, all you will get is a dictatorship , not a khilafah.
Please use your brains.
@@-------....___ the salaf fought each other, it was chaos.
Alhamdulillah. Your understanding and interpretation are better and in alliance with Qur'an.
People can’t even have peace within their own families let’s begin there first In’sha Allah
Why not work on both? Plus the khilafah will fix the family issues. Khilafah is not a paradise for the pious but it is a hospital for the impious.
@@AymanSaabwe need secularism
It’s not one or the other. Nor do people need to be perfect to live under a just system. Both are necessary to work towards and both will bring success in the home and in society. If the society is built on kufr, who do you think gets influenced by it and then brings those ideas to the home?
@@jj-yi1newe already have it and judging from the results, no thanks we don't need it
@@AymanSaab yeah I agree I'm all for it. But everything starts at home first? We need to educate ourselves and our kids about Islam properly, build the foundations and build strong men and women In'sha Allah
How will the Khilafah will fix the family issues, plz do elaborate so I can understand this better
There is no universally recognised Khalifa since 1924
Thanks to Saudi and Jordan. They are the ones helped Their master Britain to take down Ottoman.
@@brace_yourself true
No need to choose khalifa
Just give bayat to the caliph choosen by Allah.
Only Allah chooses caliph not people.
Only Allah is the sole owner and ruler of the whole universe.
Allah has chosen Ahlul Beyt household of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him and his family.
Imam Ali is the first caliph and
Imam Mahdi is the last caliph who will establish Islam on the whole earth.
Imam Mahdi Alaihissalam is agreed upon in all the Ummah
So we must establish Islamic system like Islamic system Iran is fighting against America and Israel...
Like Islamic Yemen zaydi Mujahideen fighting against America and Israel.....
Labbaika Ya Mahdi Alaihissalam 🕋🇾🇪🇵🇸🇮🇷kdkdkkd
السلطة المطلقة تفسد تماما (absolute power corrupts absolutely) is it evidenced by Hadith ? It has different perspective . But القوة المطلقة (absolute power) has different perspective. English language is a barrier . Allah has absolute power Allah provide the power to some individual (e.g., Dhu al-Qarnayn ذُو ٱلْقَرْنَيْ) Allah established him (إِنَّا مَكَّنَّا لَهُ) But was he prophet ? Most like “no” He was empowered by Allah; he said “we will penalize wrong doer (نُعَذِّبُهُۥ) then after the death same wrong doer will be punished by Allah (فَيُعَذِّبُهُ) with an unheard-of torment.
جزاك الله خير
May Allah bless you.
You always use a daleel ❤
Shaikh. Can you please talk about Imran Hossain ?
Thanks for this, kind of shocked that Yasir Qadhi made so many interesting arguments initially... It's not good to go unchecked and be surrounded by yes men I guess
Sheigh can you a realistic method of selecting a khalifah for a global ummah, does he have to be Arab. Getting 5 Muslims in a room to agree on an issue is almost impossible how are you going to to get 2 billion Muslims to agree on a particular persona as a khalifah. Quotes is fine and pleasing but reality is different, those closest to the prophetic era when the Muslims were few in number could not agree on a khalifah then, how are they going to agree now. It's utopian to think of a global khalifah.
Look man, fear Allah this is not the time to refute another Muslim.
I agree with yasir qadhi because I think a khilafa should be a natural thing witch comes from the grassrooth and not pushed from above. If we are good musims Allah will unite us in a khilafa inshalah. Allah will change the situation of a people if they change themselfs first
Thank you Sheikh. I am asking all Muslims. Keep me in your duas. My ex has blocked all contact with my children.
May Allah make it easy for you and may you be re united with your children, stay strong
@@zak992ameen. We are in last 10 days, we will make dua for things to improve Insha Allah
So the public opinion of kuffar matters so much that it can change the policies of western governments entirely but our scholars are telling us that consensus of Ummah and opinion does not matter?
This is defeatist attitude! Seeking for genuine and authentic leadership is not only religous requirement but also a natural human desire.
Politics require strong heart and inevitably possibility of voilence, and in these matters you can't take from him.
If a Khalifa has been necessary for 100 years or thereabouts, it just shows the lack of competence maybe of Muslims? It seems to be all chatter and no action. Anyway, I don’t see what’s wrong with electing a nominal Khalifa although I’m not an expert in law and actual definitions but surely a nominal Khalifa with no real power would be a step forward rather than trying to do 1000 step long jump in one leap with little assistance from anyone and a lot of guns pointing in the other direction.
As far as I know there is jihad or striving of the heart , striving of the tongue and striving of the sword .
In a Hadith from the Shia Muslims, Ali ra says you will be overcome with the sword first, then the tongue and then the heart will be suppressed as well or words similar .
This means that we are lacking the sword, but we may have the heart and the tongue remaining .
Therefore, it seems timely to act to get results before the tongue is outlawed as well and all that remains is the heart .
In fact, you don’t actually even need a nominal Khalifa maybe you could just do an exercise in consultation and voting amongst the ulema for a potential Khalifa .
Anyone who has had a broken arm knows that the muscles decay when the plaster cast is on, and they atrophy and become weak, and they need light work before they can do the heavy work and get back to regular exercise again .
And if you have a Khalifa of the year with a change every 12 months this will stop institutionalisation of power in one hand and also be more scientific as we could learn more rapidly. What type of attitude is productive rather than waiting for 30 years for a change of analysis.
And if Isis complain why not just give them a role equivalent to the CIA lol. A pack of criminals who are banned but secretly do the dirty work on the sly - and so goodly citizens of the free world don’t blame us the precedent was not in the Middle East it was in America. God bless the khalifa
Okay, I accept that may not be appropriate, but I’m not the sissy either.
But beware if you make progress then foreign powers will try and install their own version of a Khalifa which is palatable to their own interests and values .
However, if I say I want the whole program initiated by the end of the week and completed by the end of the summer you know I mean business but I know you mean tea and biscuits so what’s the flaming point?
💯💯
Sheikh Yasir is a learned man and knows history very well! He should know that the Romans (The Western world) is powerhouse that wont be defeated till Judgement day because whenever one nation falls another nation takes up the standard and keeps on fighting. And from my understanding that is only possible because they have the Pope. The Pope is an institution that focuses their energies to one goal of destroying Islam. If we dont have a Khalifah we cannot compete against the Romans.
Yasir Qadhi is americas Sir Syed Ahmad Khan
yasir qadhi has always been on mossad payroll and still is.
are you a muslim?
do you have evidence for your claim?
if not I suggest you retract your claim. It is libel.
are you a hasbara troll?
Since the earliest days of Islam, there have been many Muslim sultanates and states, run by different rulers. They did not pledge alliance to for example the Ottoman Empire. We have nation states, and let's face it no Arab wants to be ruled by a non Arab and no non Arab wants to be ruled by an Arab, the list is endless. At best all these nation states can do is create a constitution where the akham ad deen in the public domain are the basis of the law of the land. And no Muslims living now wants the fiqh laws of the madhabs, they are outdated and are not relevant to Muslims now.