You are a genius both in studio and on the stage live. I don't mind if you become more popular and so more pop. More people need to listen to your great music moving forward, and not just prog lovers like myself.
Yes, and he will as he is now... but that's really up to him if he wants to choose to be less proggy unfortunately, just like when he decided to found PT.
@@amirtech2005 he's rarely released a bad song, he's one of the best artists Britain has ever produced. But, he lacks identity, Is he prog, alt rock, metal, mainstream, electronic or pop?? He needs to nail down a style or genre if he wants to go mainstream. But i really don't think he gives a shit, and neither do I, i wouldn't have him any other way, that's what makes him unique.
This song was mesmerizing live. He uses a screen and runs the hologram off the screen. The dancing lady ends up being like 40' high. Very dramatic and really captivates.
Anyone who said this was "out of character" for Steven obviously hasn't poured over his whole musical history...Insurgentes set the scene for this song, and it's a beautiful spiritual successor to that phenomenal album
Although I've been playing guitar for a bit more than 30 yrs, I will never reach that level of achievement... Thank you Steven Wilson, you exactly reflect how I see music.
Cleve Crudgington it’s massive! But I got one piece of advice for you. Bring ear plugs. My ears were bleeding after the full two part set. It was the loudest concert I‘ve ever heard attended. By far. Way too loud and not even enjoyable without any plugs. It it wasn’t just me - pretty much everyone who went to see him in Germany said that.
@@halt.halt.halt. It depends where you sit. I have seen him several times at the same venue and yeah it's pretty crazy loud if you're in the first few rows. I saw this last tour about midsection and it was much more tolerable and sounded great. Main downside is you don't get to be 5 feet away from the band anymore!
Tony Tran I‘ve been sitting in the midsection when I saw him play and the venue even had several delay lines and quite the nice line array so it should have been as loud pretty much anywhere in the building. That’s what most anyone said afterwards. As did other fans from different German shows said. In a fan group people have said that his sound engineer had a hearing loss, but I don’t know about that. Still - with modern line arrays and proper delay lines the definitely shouldn’t be any place anywhere near as loud as it was. The mix was lacking crucial nuances as well and I have been in a very good spot to hear them all. Still, the concert itself was a blast and I wouldn’t hesitate going again!
@@halt.halt.halt. Oh man, that's a shame. The venue he comes to in my area is quite small, so it mostly relies on the sound from the stage so there is a big difference between front row seats and midsection seats. There was much more clarity and nuance in the midsection (previous two shows I saw front row) But yeah agreed even when I was front row and lost some of the music, it was still an awesome show. Honestly, this most recent your might have been my favorite. Great performance and the set list was such a good mix of new album material and back catalog.
Tony Tran yeah, you are totally right! When I saw him, he played most of Hand. Cannot. Erase. and To the Bone, as it was the second night in the same City which was very nice! Unfortunately I don’t have time to see him again in winter, but the musicians he brings with him as well as Steven himself are just great, even without Marco or Gavin and Guthrie.
Pop??? Steven Wilson is my all time favorite male musician favorite. (Beth Hart is my female). Can't wait to see him in concert on Sunday in Atlanta... By the way: My American wife is listening to modern country music (Horse Jazz) in the car. She actually liked the Marillion concert at the same upcoming venue some months ago and she was teary eyed afterwards. She has seen SW before with Porqupine Tree (Fear of a blank planet), and it went well. Hopefully one day she will be an openly prog fan!
I just saw Steven Wilson perform this song in Calgary, Alberta, on Monday night. Probably only 500 people in the room. I have waited 10 years for a chance to see him live. I wanted to shake some of the audience members who just listened passively. Any artist would probably call them lame. I tried to yell and cheer loud enough for 10 people. Thank you Steven for including our city on your tour!
If you haven't been lucky enough to watch this live and you thought this performance is great, wait until he releases the ~11min live version of Detonation.
Was at the glasgow gig. yes a few songs stood out for just having that big effect this was one. Im not a big fan of this song but i really like the live one.
Reminds me to the depeche mode devotional tour set up... the looks and atmosphere is as intense. Of course DP is a big influence to steven nowdays, tremendous conbination
I won’t follow you in the new direction your music is going, but still, I am sure you are going to do it perfectly, SW. I’ll wait for the next album, hopping it will be more proggy.
Lyrics I'm truly sorry but This is my addiction You're deep in my system In my system I gave it all up I gave it up to show you that I care To show you that I could But don't you ever ask me to give up you I gave up all the late nights I gave up hunting bars I gave up all the drinking And trashing all the cars I gave it all up I gave up all the gambling I gave up picking fights I gave up saying sorry I gave up being polite I gave it up I gave it all up I gave it up You are mine I gave it all up I gave it up You're in mind I gave it up I gave it up I gave it all up I gave it up I gave it all up I gave it up You're in mind I gave it up I gave it up You're in mind I gave it up T'es sous le sable T'es dans l'eau I gave it up Gave it up J'abandonne You're in mind You're in, you're in mind I gave it up You're in mind You're in mind
@@gunner. He did play those. Were you at his concerts? Come on, Steven Wilson is pure musical genius. While I loved PT, I do not miss it one bit. He was PT.
I hear a Blend of Depeche Mode eurythmics and ELO Love this song It was the mindblowing performance of this tour .. it has an 80s dark ,menacing vibe for sure
This is so much better than album version. Original sounds too overproduced, soulless, just like most of the modern pop music. It's my least favourite track on the album. This, on the other hand, is like old school pop mixed with a bit of prog and raw musicianship. Love it.
The song has a very cold and polished production but it's millions of miles away from "modern pop". I find it very '80s-sounding actually. Not exactly Taylor Swift...
In this live version, I distinctly hear a Prince influence which of course is widely known from Steven's interviews so nothing new. I do agree though, this is a much better version than off the album and looking forward to receiving my blu-ray in a week. .
My god, he performs with more and more passion every year.
It became sexual
sallysimpson7 totaly agree on this
He really does. Steven truly gets it.
He really does. Steven truly gets it.
Crazy ... Love it
This song is great in studio version but live it just blows you away. Best live track I have ever experienced.
Totally agree. I saw him in MIlwaukee. I liked the studio version, but it was just mesmerizing live.
Agree. Absolutely mindblowing.
Highlight of the Philly show - it's crushing.
You are a genius both in studio and on the stage live. I don't mind if you become more popular and so more pop. More people need to listen to your great music moving forward, and not just prog lovers like myself.
Amir H No. More ppl need to stop listening only to pop music.
It's easy to say.
if by 'pop' you mean popular, then yes.
Steven Wilson should be huge.
Yes, and he will as he is now... but that's really up to him if he wants to choose to be less proggy unfortunately, just like when he decided to found PT.
@@amirtech2005 he's rarely released a bad song, he's one of the best artists Britain has ever produced.
But, he lacks identity,
Is he prog, alt rock, metal, mainstream, electronic or pop??
He needs to nail down a style or genre if he wants to go mainstream.
But i really don't think he gives a shit, and neither do I, i wouldn't have him any other way, that's what makes him unique.
Great performance! Dark, menacing and haunting, just like "Index".
Holy shit this is insane, so deep and dark, remember me to the ultra album from Depeche Mode. I want an album like this. You did again Steven.
This song was mesmerizing live. He uses a screen and runs the hologram off the screen. The dancing lady ends up being like 40' high. Very dramatic and really captivates.
Anyone who said this was "out of character" for Steven obviously hasn't poured over his whole musical history...Insurgentes set the scene for this song, and it's a beautiful spiritual successor to that phenomenal album
Very true, this song its like a lost memory from Insurgentes, greetings from Mexico!
Definitely one of the coolest things I've ever seen live in a concert.
How does this man get one step more perfect everytime?
Saw this at Keswick Theatre sitting in middle of orchestra with surround speakers behind us. Our jaws dropped. Incredible visuals in surround sound.
This guy is nothing but a fucking magician.... He's waaaaayyyyyyy waaaaayyyyyyy above than just a legend 🔥
Simply put... Steven is a badass. So are all musicians he works with.
People should be kneeling before his musical prowess. This live version is so much better than the studio one. Holy shit!
It completely destroys you live...viceral
Saw the show last night at HOB-Houston. Utterly mesmerizing. Do whatever you can to experience this show!!!!
Creativity at highest level.
This piece should be the intro of a new Bond film!
Let's make it happen
Although I've been playing guitar for a bit more than 30 yrs, I will never reach that level of achievement... Thank you Steven Wilson, you exactly reflect how I see music.
They did this at The Cap Port Chester NY. Best show of the year by far.
GENIO!!!!🔝🤟🍾
Я це бачив в Києві, на заключному його турне по світу. Це було щось неймовірне.
I love it. I'm seeing Steven live for the first time in a couple of weeks and I couldn't be more psyched.
Cleve Crudgington it’s massive! But I got one piece of advice for you. Bring ear plugs. My ears were bleeding after the full two part set. It was the loudest concert I‘ve ever heard attended. By far. Way too loud and not even enjoyable without any plugs. It it wasn’t just me - pretty much everyone who went to see him in Germany said that.
@@halt.halt.halt. It depends where you sit. I have seen him several times at the same venue and yeah it's pretty crazy loud if you're in the first few rows. I saw this last tour about midsection and it was much more tolerable and sounded great. Main downside is you don't get to be 5 feet away from the band anymore!
Tony Tran I‘ve been sitting in the midsection when I saw him play and the venue even had several delay lines and quite the nice line array so it should have been as loud pretty much anywhere in the building. That’s what most anyone said afterwards. As did other fans from different German shows said. In a fan group people have said that his sound engineer had a hearing loss, but I don’t know about that. Still - with modern line arrays and proper delay lines the definitely shouldn’t be any place anywhere near as loud as it was. The mix was lacking crucial nuances as well and I have been in a very good spot to hear them all. Still, the concert itself was a blast and I wouldn’t hesitate going again!
@@halt.halt.halt. Oh man, that's a shame. The venue he comes to in my area is quite small, so it mostly relies on the sound from the stage so there is a big difference between front row seats and midsection seats. There was much more clarity and nuance in the midsection (previous two shows I saw front row) But yeah agreed even when I was front row and lost some of the music, it was still an awesome show. Honestly, this most recent your might have been my favorite. Great performance and the set list was such a good mix of new album material and back catalog.
Tony Tran yeah, you are totally right! When I saw him, he played most of Hand. Cannot. Erase. and To the Bone, as it was the second night in the same City which was very nice! Unfortunately I don’t have time to see him again in winter, but the musicians he brings with him as well as Steven himself are just great, even without Marco or Gavin and Guthrie.
I'd trip balls if I were fortunate enough to see him live. Music is the medicine! Lots of love from Iran
One of the highlights of the show with "Arriving Somewhere" IMO ! Spectacular !
i remember this ahow in Milan.Italy.😄 Simply Awesome.😈.love yoy Steven.
I saw this in April, and by God I'm gonna be there in November. Steven Wilson is AMAZING LIVE!
Pop??? Steven Wilson is my all time favorite male musician favorite. (Beth Hart is my female). Can't wait to see him in concert on Sunday in Atlanta... By the way: My American wife is listening to modern country music (Horse Jazz) in the car. She actually liked the Marillion concert at the same upcoming venue some months ago and she was teary eyed afterwards. She has seen SW before with Porqupine Tree (Fear of a blank planet), and it went well. Hopefully one day she will be an openly prog fan!
I just saw Steven Wilson perform this song in Calgary, Alberta, on Monday night. Probably only 500 people in the room. I have waited 10 years for a chance to see him live. I wanted to shake some of the audience members who just listened passively. Any artist would probably call them lame. I tried to yell and cheer loud enough for 10 people. Thank you Steven for including our city on your tour!
Thank you for delightful feast yesterday in Krakow. The best show in my life. Perfect on so many levels.
If you haven't been lucky enough to watch this live and you thought this performance is great, wait until he releases the ~11min live version of Detonation.
Qué rola, tan más perfecta!🤘🏽😎
Dancer. Moves. Hypnotic performance.
Awesome. So happy I got to see you in that last leg of the tour. I cannot wait to see you again.
Freaking awesome performance
and that is what we call stage presence
"God wears glasses and walks with unshod feet." - Jeremiah, 12:16
damn, the 2 track mix on YT is great, can't wait to hear the 5.1. Was fortunate enough to attend all 3 nights at the RAH, can't wait to re-live it!
All 3! Waow!
UNAtender el mejor mùsico de todos los tiempos... Sabe todo!!!
Epic!
This song remind me the Insurgentes era
Whoa... wish I’d seen that show. Awesome.
Estoy extasiada 🖤
Can we just take a second to appreciate the production here?! I mean if I were on weed at this concert I'd trip my balls off.
Was at the glasgow gig. yes a few songs stood out for just having that big effect this was one. Im not a big fan of this song but i really like the live one.
Cardiff Show was immense. My 11 year old daughter loved it too - not just for middle aged progs
Great performance!
Wow. Can't wait to see him on November @ Edmonton.
Me acuerdo de este tema en vivo... Qué power!!!
It's pleasantly surprising how much better the live versions of 'Permanating' and 'Song of I' sound! I wish this gets released on Google Play Music.
Se han afincado en mi cabeza y gustosamente los llevare conmigo para siempre, la banda
Bloody perfect!
Reminds me to the depeche mode devotional tour set up... the looks and atmosphere is as intense.
Of course DP is a big influence to steven nowdays, tremendous conbination
The best song on the album.
hasta el alma!!
Amazing!!!
wonderful like ever
Love it
I won’t follow you in the new direction your music is going, but still, I am sure you are going to do it perfectly, SW. I’ll wait for the next album, hopping it will be more proggy.
~●~The Wonderful Mister Wilson And Company~●~《●》BRILLIANCE《●》~●~
November is gonna be a good month for releases! Can't wait
Musical Brick what’s coming out in November to keep an eye out for?
Yeah ; Thats true. Opeth will release also their new live blu ray the same day as SW will do.
Muse's new album as well
Silent planet
Hi @@Prog4Prog, adding to the above comments: The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway book, and Queen movie :)
Ipnotica...💓
I’ve seen this song live in roma and it was really impressive
C'est de la pyrotechnique je pense.
C'est vraiment intéressant.
Merci j'adore impressionnant.
Amicalement bisous Sophie
Alex Hutchings is awesome! ᗩᒪE᙭ TᕼE ᗷEᔕT!!
Espectacular
SIN COMENTARIOS... BARBARO
ES PEC TA CU LAR!!!!!! ❤️
Can't wait until he gets here to Fla.
Me too!! Seeing him on 12/16. Best day EVER
Same! Do you think the holograms are royal Albert hall only?
@@prasanthshyamsundar35 I hope not but either way, so happy to see him live finally
👌
Lyrics
I'm truly sorry but
This is my addiction
You're deep in my system
In my system
I gave it all up
I gave it up to show you that I care
To show you that I could
But don't you ever ask me to give up you
I gave up all the late nights
I gave up hunting bars
I gave up all the drinking
And trashing all the cars
I gave it all up
I gave up all the gambling
I gave up picking fights
I gave up saying sorry
I gave up being polite
I gave it up
I gave it all up
I gave it up
You are mine
I gave it all up
I gave it up
You're in mind
I gave it up
I gave it up
I gave it all up
I gave it up
I gave it all up
I gave it up
You're in mind
I gave it up
I gave it up
You're in mind
I gave it up
T'es sous le sable
T'es dans l'eau
I gave it up
Gave it up
J'abandonne
You're in mind
You're in, you're in mind
I gave it up
You're in mind
You're in mind
Amazing!....did everyone else see the giant dancing girl, or was it just me?
Still miss PT.
Clarence Doskocil me too....and i miss Wilson from first 2 solo records. I just hate Bollywood dancers and crap....
@@xfilesfoxisdead7979 me too. Baffling that he doesn't play songs like Deform To Form A Star, Significant Other, Raider II, Insurgentes, etc
@@gunner. He did play those. Were you at his concerts? Come on, Steven Wilson is pure musical genius. While I loved PT, I do not miss it one bit. He was PT.
🖤🖤🖤
I don't understand what i just saw... Were those holograms? Or effects added digitally?
♥
much better than the original one!
I'm probably being thick asking this but was that dancing woman projection really there? Or has it been added to the DVD/BluRay???
It was at the shows
Its not a post production effect, it's a real hologram projected onto a clear screen.
ohibok❤
Oddly enough, this reminds me of "Mama" by Genesis with a peter gabriel twist
I hear a Blend of Depeche Mode eurythmics and ELO
Love this song
It was the mindblowing performance of this tour .. it has an 80s dark ,menacing vibe for sure
I like this live version better too. Wasn’t too keen on this track on the album.
Very Gabrielesque
This is so much better than album version. Original sounds too overproduced, soulless, just like most of the modern pop music. It's my least favourite track on the album. This, on the other hand, is like old school pop mixed with a bit of prog and raw musicianship. Love it.
Have to agree it is the worst song on the album, but it was great to see live
The song has a very cold and polished production but it's millions of miles away from "modern pop". I find it very '80s-sounding actually. Not exactly Taylor Swift...
i love the orchestral build up in the 3rd movement.
Most powerful.
Definitely punchier live
In this live version, I distinctly hear a Prince influence which of course is widely known from Steven's interviews so nothing new. I do agree though, this is a much better version than off the album and looking forward to receiving my blu-ray in a week.
.
Steven Wilson 😊
Prog Rock Pop god
If he's not God, who is?
Thom Yorke
King Crimson ~○~
Rohan Dutta Maybe 20 years ago - maybe
Rich Campus Are you having a laugh
Hiromi Uehara is.
is Sophie Hunger on stage?
I don't think so, she would appear on screen at least once. I guess...
I knew this song would be next after Pariah.
Me too, cos it says so on the set-list.
gah why letterbox it... youtube supports ultrawide now, but here I am watching this lovely presentation in a black box
i miss PT .
Waiting for postman.
Hologram is real now!
So, would this be considered dark pop? If that even exists? If not, well then
Primo!
This is my least favorite song from TTB, but I love this performance.
Human --Alien S Wilson?!?!
Охуенно
I don't like Craig Blundell as drummer at all but damn it sure was a amazing show to see.
Gavin Harrison was a drum kit in a previous life to be fair, I suppose having 2 musical God's on stage is not going to happen again 😞
Pulgar arriba si lo viste en Groove con la "cortina de baño" y te voló la peluca igual.
I don't think he gave it all up.
‘the most successful British musician most people have never heard of’ ... and why is that?
I like the song, but the video he's playing in the background on tours is so weird and not fitting.
jFrenetic completely disagree. The song is about him giving up a woman and how she is still in his head...listen to the lyrics.
I want the background video only version. Mesmerizing!
The video editing is pretty crappy
I miss Gavin.