To me, this is the probably the best performance of this show to date. A lot of Chinese female singers have really thin, high-pitch voice but she is one of the few who has powerful voice with a wide vocal range.
Yes, but Lee Jia Wei is no more weaker than Jacyln is. She works hard all the way up till now, she never quit learning and appreciating. By the way, i am not truly agree on what you said there, Jaclyn is ONE of the best singer in Asia yes, but not better than ANY ASIAN SINGERS, if you include Taiwan, HK, China, Korea, Japan in ur ASIA definition too. Go do some research and listen to more songs before to make this a statement.
@hasher22 if u wan to debate on that, it'll take ten years. u dun even have that kind of understanding. do u nid a guy to spell i like u for a girl to know that. in msn, people use emoticon to represent "feelings" which words cnt express. when we use noob, troll, lol n et, we automatically tuned to that kind of mutual understanding. like i said, there are tonnes of languages in umbrella term chinese, but we are tuned to understand it is mandarin.
if u find kpop idols singing in english (not raised in US), all of them have accent and trouble singing in english. in that case only ur analogy is correct becoz korean is their native tongue. even people like dbsk yoochun and snsd jessica speak english as if they're americans because they learnt english since young eventhough their native tongue are korean. malaysian chinese do not have that mandarin accent like China's chinese and to be able to sing in english is like singing in chinese.
@King881109 By the way, you just proved what I just said. You learnt English as a second language from kindergarten, learn to spell. Here are some tips; u = you kindergarden = kindergaten whut = what ur = your but in your sentence you mean you're or you are after each full stop, have the next word with a capital letter. Have you heard of the Chinese whispers? It seems that your English teacher was uneducated and passed some bad English habbits to you. Thankyou
@King881109 Again you're not making sense. ANYONE who sings in their second language cannot pull off a song. Its like a strong accent Scottish man singing in English. This is a good example. It's like me singing in French, English is my native toungue but I know I cannot sing a French song even though I can speak it. If you cannot see that and if you think I'm racist then you have alot of learning to do.
@kokkitchan lmfao. firstly, you can't make anyone shut up on the internet. secondly, OBVIOUSLY you didn't target only those who tried to put down Jess in your first comment. This is exactly what you said: "Really no point comparing with Beyonce and Charice. They are great no doubt, but comparing them to Jess is just sounds to me like jealousy." Thirdly, you're clearly the hurt bird. seriously? a reply to you TWO MONTHS BACK can make you so furious and incoherent lmfao
@kokkitchan FYI, neither Beyonce nor Charice are my idols. I was just stating facts, what I felt after listening to all three version. So how is that jealousy when I compare them? When singers take on the same song, comparison is sure to take place. Comparing is good. It makes people improve themselves. People always bring in jealousy as their argument. It makes no sense here though, to me at least.
Sometimes I wonder those people who make comments. do they know about what they are talking about or not? When you compare Jess Lee with a 13 Grammy Awards Winner such as Beyonce, you are talking nonsence, how can you compare a new blood with a diva. Every voice is unique, and when people can handle a difficult song nicely, give her a praise and applaud, an encouragement is better than an awkward critism to build a person, don't you feel the same! Jiayou! Jess Lee.
@King881109 Chinese is not a language - ask anyone. I find it facinating that you refer to wiki as a source of information. Universities, highschools and even colleges bans students from getting their information from wiki. lol you're getting angry for nothing hahaha...... I say this again 'Chinese' is not a language. Mandarin is.
>Malaysians : Please be more humble and diplomatic in your delivery without exploiting your expressions of Malaysian nationalism, with regards to serving your pseudo-autocratic nation as a second-standard citizen, encumbered with the absurd obligation to learn Bahasa Melayu as dictated by your archenemy allotted in supremacy.
Charice really can sing well, this is undenialable, but Charice doesn't have her own song make famous like "Listen" of Beyonce, she still needs to put in effort to make her own famous song. Jess Lee is another talent new comer who is trying hard to push herself in the music industry, so let's give support but not sabotage to both of the gifted. Both deserve a praise from us.
@kokkitchan I say making baseless assumptions and not reading before criticizing is the worst and the most stupid behavior. And if you did read the comments, not everyone who prefer Charice/Beyonce's version denies Jess is good. In fact, we did admit she's good. How is goosebumps not good? lmao
Ohh! he knew whom I'm referring to! his head is not so empty after all. Still got a tiny little ostrich brain in there! Lol. Enough said, instead of entertaining him any further, I seek better entertainment elsewhere. Cherios. Have A Good Day!
@suktuckng Totally agree, some people just wanted to show off and started point out grammar mistake which not related to the video. He wants to be the fucking hero. Such a prick child, we need to guide him to the right way. Poor guy.
@King881109 Again Chinese is not a language. You're bringing topics into the conversation that is irrelevant. I'm still dumbfounded on why an Asian such as yourself cannot come to the fact that Chinese is not a language
@kikitaylorhaha you shud be disapointed to your ear!!hehe,,jess lee is a gud singer no doubt,.,.,.,.but i have to disagree to what you've said!in terms of power vocals and the pronounciation,she's no match to charice!
Gdness! this is the worst "Listen" version i have heard of!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WHy has Li Jiawei's standard drop so terrible in this rendition????????? her "going home" Huijia is very very gd!
She's really good and all you people saying that she was off key at some points, well she's singing in a different language so I'd like to see you all try to do that :)
UPSS creo que le quedó grande la canción ,por qué les gustá agrandarse los ojos si con sus ojitos jalados se les ve tan bonitas , me refiero a la presentadora, quieren parecer occidentales ????
No matter what chinese, but u r malaysian chinese..not same at all for all chinese in the world, malaysia boleh.. U all can find the defferent only in malaysia..
@tzinwei90 聲音沒有穿透力? 拜託不要裝懂好嗎? 難道要我叫您一生裝董哥? 好吧 董哥 開心嗎? 你拿一個從小就學習聲樂學習歌唱技巧的人根一個沒有學習任何聲樂過的人比 還可以被邀請到各大節目然後因此爆紅的比較? 拜託 董哥 李佳薇上洋人的節目 我看他還沒有到那樣的能力吧.. 拜託請你去聽聽夏芮絲的 I Have nothing , and i am telling you i'm not going , i will always love you 除非你是耳包 不然我真的不知道該用什麼來形容你的耳朵 董哥^^ 是阿 李佳薇跟夏芮絲比 夏芮絲真的還差的遠 夏芮絲根本就是鬼神等級的 我還是只能說 等到李佳薇被艾倫或是歐普拉邀請上節目 再來這邊捧 加油^^
眼神 演唱前 演唱後
完全變了一個人
這就是唱歌該有的自信
我只能說她詮釋這首歌真的感動到我，同時他站在台上給我的感覺也帶有無比的勇氣，很喜歡他這段表演。
李佳薇把这首歌发挥得淋漓尽致，她的实力是不容置疑。另外，评判能够打高分也是对她的肯定。
好美的声音w0w
對音樂有要求的人是去要求自己不是一直去要求別人
事實上已經很好聽了，這種歌手難得耶.....
如果現在的李佳薇再唱這歌一定再更厲害了
沒錯！真的
我偏愛符瓊音的版本😆
@@lingootzy9565 你說他感冒所以很多細節沒辦法掌握好，有些音飄掉，最高潮的地方破音的那一個版本嗎？還是之後再次演唱的版本？
差希拉一大截
@@Nicholas0123破音才把感冒當藉口，難道別人都沒感冒過XD
就算沒感冒我看符還是一樣破音啦XD
李佳薇強在用這種聲音也能唱出那麼雄厚的聲音，那個力量我認為和beyonce 或Charice的唱法能抗衡，誰說只有外國的唱法，原唱的唱法才算好聽。音樂無界限；李佳薇用不同的唱法，具自己特色，同樣所有高音都能到，我個人認為也很好聽。
Wai Chung 差太多了吧，氣息肺活量技巧差那兩位太多，聲線我認為也是另二位勝，當然，李的功力已經勝一堆人
jill 你確定勝那兩位歌手嗎⋯⋯
@@sun-te5ce listen这首歌夏芮丝＞碧昂丝＞李佳薇，但只论唱功李佳薇＝夏芮丝＞碧昂丝
@@j19960131
她可是來自星馬地區的女王!
@@吱娜终国 charice beyonce 旗鼓相当
天阿~~~現在的佳薇比以前更漂亮也更有層次了 !
佳薇不是唱歌缺乏感情 這首歌她詮釋的是力量，堅定，自信，夢想已接近的感覺。。每一個歌手詮釋這首歌都有不同的感情.
聽過各種選秀的Listen
李佳葳的最好聽
最接近原唱的標準原唱除了夏芮絲就是李佳薇了，但這首歌的翻唱我只有聽過臺灣的選秀節目有唱，國外是否有更強的翻唱我也不知道，但這2位的翻唱真的是我聽過最好聽的了
+廖先鴻 可以聽Sam Bailey 的～
+廖先鴻 覺得李少了原唱跟夏芮絲得渾厚厚實的音色 但以選秀得來說算不錯 這首要唱得像原唱那樣水準 應該就Shila Amzah跟夏芮絲
歌曲的味道有了 奈何这歌实在太难唱
那么多年了, 我还在单曲循环
Van lv
我認為歌手最成功的地方不是因為唱得好不好..唱得好不好都會有人喜歡..有人不喜歡..而是她的歌聲能為聽眾帶來甚麼樣的感動與啟示..更何況她唱的這麼好..如果聽說過她的成長故事..你就會會知道..她一直很努力用功..她的努力用功絕對值得得到我們的掌聲鼓勵..她會這麼努力用功..不是為了要超越多少人..而是只想讓更多的人看到她..聽到她..她會這麼努力用功..只是想讓幫助過她..關心她的人..支持她的人都能看到她的努力..她曾說過..好的評論壞的評論她都會虛心接受..然後她會更加油的努力....任何歌手都是很努力也都有值得學習的優點..在她身上..我看到..體會到了兩件事..[ 謙卑 ].. [ 永不妥協 ]..先不要和別人比較..先問問自己做不做得到自己想要的夢想..自己真的可以像李佳薇一樣勇敢的努力用功追逐自己的夢想嗎..最後成與敗就已經不重要了..因為我真的會為自己的永不妥協過程而感到驕傲..沒有人是完美的..當我們努力認真的學習別人的優點時..我們就會發現有多少的不足..堅強的堡壘部是建立來的..而是學習別人的優點得來的..想要無堅不摧就要學會謙卑及永不妥協..佳薇..加油..
天啊！這咬字太清楚了吧！
她真是屬於不用靠舞蹈來求取更高分的人..
太厲害了..
聽Listen的時候要了解背後的意思-聆聽內心裡等待呼喚的夢想
李佳薇版的Listen從一開始Listen的喁喁細語,
Oh the time has come逐漸推進, 到高潮的Listen配合燈光淋漓盡致
最後My own回歸原點, 整個起承轉合個人覺得是完美的
太棒了!
for a chinese who can reach this high is already damn good im proud of her :)
Totally agree wit u
she's not a chinese
she's malaysian
Benson Chen malaysian got indian chinese malay. so Chinese right? LOL
get it!
but i think Asian is a better statement?
asian you're talking in general right? im stating specific
同樣的listen,beyonce呈現更多技巧及情感,但好像稍多的調味，但是李佳薇音質更好,更有力量飽滿度,及樸實直接，我喜歡這種直接的表現,這是老天爺賞飯吃,假以時日,更多經歷之後,李佳薇更發光發熱.
我覺得她可以飆很高 但是唱歌不是比高音就好 Listen的感情部分 她比較沒有兼顧到 可以聽聽符瓊音版本或Beyonce 都有不同種的listen 而不是一味地飆那高音來顯技巧 當然也有可能是因為比賽 衝越高音 得高分機率比較大的關係 期待她下次私下能用更多情感唱這首~
放很容易 收很難 這首歌難在收
唯一小小的缺點就是在收
但是佳薇已經很棒了!!!
太厲害了 她唱再升半key 根本難不倒她
wahh...sedap suara kau..malaysia boleh !
聲音有點尖
但細膩度掌握得太好了
果然是鐵肺女王
聲音寬又高
讚讚讚~
在台灣佳薇唱這樣已經算很猛了，當初我也是被佳薇震撼到。Charice我也聽了好幾個版本，尤其是她唱Listen，真的太恐怖，後半段氣勢簡直爆走，更難是她13~15歲還是小朋友就可以唱成這樣，當然生長的環境不同也是有差異的。簡單來說佳薇聲音稍微細膩點，Charice聲音比較厚實點，各有各的味道，原唱Beyonce是天后的氣勢，沒人可以比較。
don't really like she sang this song... too over..
+David Tan I agree
2021年還在聽舉手
無論如何他唱這首歌的感情是如此堅定, 很令人感動
林依晨真的很暖 有一次雨伞一半好一半破洞的 她把好的那面对着张天爱 真的很好❤
wow amazing .... i am ryan from indonesia
敢在歌唱比赛唱Listen根本没几个，寥寥可数。还能唱成这样真是太屌了
Chinese Malaysian
To me, this is the probably the best performance of this show to date. A lot of Chinese female singers have really thin, high-pitch voice but she is one of the few who has powerful voice with a wide vocal range.
not bad as far as a Chinese singing competition goes, but definitely not Beyonce level.
Yes, but Lee Jia Wei is no more weaker than Jacyln is. She works hard all the way up till now, she never quit learning and appreciating. By the way, i am not truly agree on what you said there, Jaclyn is ONE of the best singer in Asia yes, but not better than ANY ASIAN SINGERS, if you include Taiwan, HK, China, Korea, Japan in ur ASIA definition too. Go do some research and listen to more songs before to make this a statement.
重看居然會想哭
@hasher22 if u wan to debate on that, it'll take ten years. u dun even have that kind of understanding. do u nid a guy to spell i like u for a girl to know that. in msn, people use emoticon to represent "feelings" which words cnt express. when we use noob, troll, lol n et, we automatically tuned to that kind of mutual understanding. like i said, there are tonnes of languages in umbrella term chinese, but we are tuned to understand it is mandarin.
I feel you did a great job!
if u find kpop idols singing in english (not raised in US), all of them have accent and trouble singing in english. in that case only ur analogy is correct becoz korean is their native tongue. even people like dbsk yoochun and snsd jessica speak english as if they're americans because they learnt english since young eventhough their native tongue are korean. malaysian chinese do not have that mandarin accent like China's chinese and to be able to sing in english is like singing in chinese.
我雞皮疙瘩都起了XD讚
@King881109
By the way, you just proved what I just said. You learnt English as a second language from kindergarten, learn to spell. Here are some tips;
u = you
kindergarden = kindergaten
whut = what
ur = your but in your sentence you mean you're or you are
after each full stop, have the next word with a capital letter.
Have you heard of the Chinese whispers? It seems that your English teacher was uneducated and passed some bad English habbits to you.
Thankyou
好棒呢~
@King881109
Again you're not making sense. ANYONE who sings in their second language cannot pull off a song. Its like a strong accent Scottish man singing in English. This is a good example. It's like me singing in French, English is my native toungue but I know I cannot sing a French song even though I can speak it.
If you cannot see that and if you think I'm racist then you have alot of learning to do.
哇塞!!
@kokkitchan lmfao. firstly, you can't make anyone shut up on the internet.
secondly, OBVIOUSLY you didn't target only those who tried to put down Jess in your first comment. This is exactly what you said: "Really no point comparing with Beyonce and Charice. They are great no doubt, but comparing them to Jess is just sounds to me like jealousy."
Thirdly, you're clearly the hurt bird. seriously? a reply to you TWO MONTHS BACK can make you so furious and incoherent lmfao
超愛
@kokkitchan FYI, neither Beyonce nor Charice are my idols. I was just stating facts, what I felt after listening to all three version. So how is that jealousy when I compare them? When singers take on the same song, comparison is sure to take place. Comparing is good. It makes people improve themselves. People always bring in jealousy as their argument. It makes no sense here though, to me at least.
不知道他用那種聲樂發音對其他人會不會很不公平~
雖然我不是很確定對唱法也不太了，但我個人認為，
他的高音都會接半假音轉換，很難聽出來銜接的很棒。
真的很強~~~
聽得出來，他的聲音是經過歲月修練而來的，
而且他肺活量真的是世界級的，
因為他的唱法銜接很好，而且這種肺活量...
一般人很快就會掛掉。
而不同於常人的是，
一般很會唱歌的人，就是很會唱，
但是不能迎刃有餘的控制自己的唱法，
BUT~佳薇是少數那幾位。
我從他唱那首open your eyes開始被吸引，
我從來沒有聽過有人能詮釋的這麼好，
我只能說我好喜歡佳薇~~ 他太棒了!!
最後一個我覺得~他只有一個缺點，
就是太強了~~~很像唱歌機器~~~
Sometimes I wonder those people who make comments. do they know about what they are talking about or not? When you compare Jess Lee with a 13 Grammy Awards Winner such as Beyonce, you are talking nonsence, how can you compare a new blood with a diva. Every voice is unique, and when people can handle a difficult song nicely, give her a praise and applaud, an encouragement is better than an awkward critism to build a person, don't you feel the same! Jiayou! Jess Lee.
過強的技巧表現已經超出情感與歌曲該有的貼合
感覺只是在聽她的武功高強，
在一些需要宣洩情感的地方突然間被拋到一個很華麗的煙火空間
失焦頗嚴重
王乃恩版本的情緒貼合密度就很高，可以確實打到悸動處
簡單來說
就是李佳薇版本像是得道高僧一切法喜充滿
但王乃恩版本是能確實讓你感覺到搥胸頓足的情緒
@King881109
Chinese is not a language - ask anyone. I find it facinating that you refer to wiki as a source of information. Universities, highschools and even colleges bans students from getting their information from wiki.
lol you're getting angry for nothing hahaha...... I say this again 'Chinese' is not a language. Mandarin is.
符瓊音比較適合listen
>Malaysians : Please be more humble and diplomatic in your delivery without exploiting your expressions of Malaysian nationalism, with regards to serving your pseudo-autocratic nation as a second-standard citizen, encumbered with the absurd obligation to learn Bahasa Melayu as dictated by your archenemy allotted in supremacy.
Charice really can sing well, this is undenialable, but Charice doesn't have her own song make famous like "Listen" of Beyonce, she still needs to put in effort to make her own famous song. Jess Lee is another talent new comer who is trying hard to push herself in the music industry, so let's give support but not sabotage to both of the gifted. Both deserve a praise from us.
能完美詮釋ALL BY MYSELF的女歌手，還要拿來比甚麼比，都已經站在世界頂端的一群人了
@kokkitchan I say making baseless assumptions and not reading before criticizing is the worst and the most stupid behavior.
And if you did read the comments, not everyone who prefer Charice/Beyonce's version denies Jess is good. In fact, we did admit she's good. How is goosebumps not good? lmao
Ohh! he knew whom I'm referring to! his head is not so empty after all. Still got a tiny little ostrich brain in there! Lol. Enough said, instead of entertaining him any further, I seek better entertainment elsewhere. Cherios. Have A Good Day!
@suktuckng Totally agree, some people just wanted to show off and started point out grammar mistake which not related to the video. He wants to be the fucking hero. Such a prick child, we need to guide him to the right way. Poor guy.
@King881109
Again Chinese is not a language. You're bringing topics into the conversation that is irrelevant. I'm still dumbfounded on why an Asian such as yourself cannot come to the fact that Chinese is not a language
@kikitaylorhaha you shud be disapointed to your ear!!hehe,,jess lee is a gud singer no doubt,.,.,.,.but i have to disagree to what you've said!in terms of power vocals and the pronounciation,she's no match to charice!
Now anytime someone sings Listen.. they are always compared to Charice... :\
Not sayin' that Charice isn't awesomely awesome
Gdness! this is the worst "Listen" version i have heard of!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
WHy has Li Jiawei's standard drop so terrible in this rendition????????? her "going home" Huijia is very very gd!
She's really good and all you people saying that she was off key at some points, well she's singing in a different language so I'd like to see you all try to do that :)
UPSS creo que le quedó grande la canción ,por qué les gustá agrandarse los ojos si con sus ojitos jalados se les ve tan bonitas , me refiero a la presentadora, quieren parecer occidentales ????
Saying she had ruined the song is a bit too much. But i do agree with some users: This is not her song. Plentiful of youtube singers are better.
@nocridnocrid well, she chose the arrangement beyonce did so i guess that is why i compared the vocal based on that very arrangement...
O my god your voice is soft but you could sing very difficult song ,,listen`` by Beyonce amazing voice like very much yeahhhhhh
我想知道”没开发的土人“的意思 请你解释一下。 如果你是天才，厉害的话，那就把答案清清楚楚地揭晓。如果你的答案内容里包含”笨蛋“，”白痴“，”烂国家，“马来摸”等等的贬义词，那明显地表现出你社会地位是非常低，道德观念有问题，也不能称上是天才，厉害反而只会回答一些没关联性的废话的人。 你说的“没有开发的土人”令我想到的一样东西是马来西亚没有任何的建筑物和民主的社会。你的眼睛瞎了吗，是不是， 我们马来西亚各州一年一年发展，建筑物的数量比往年增加。我知道你的想象力很丰富，你的脑子里肯定浮起马来西亚全国人民住在山洞里，树上面，没有民主社会的画面。当全国人民看了，知道了你这样想法之后，肯定回应就是“真是废物想法，目中无人”，这不是我想说的喔，只是举个会可能发生的可能性喔。如果这些不是你所想的，那就要实实地地地回答什么意思是”没开发的土人“。 如果不正面回答，只回答内容贬义的废话，那你就逃不开你是废物，受道德教育低的批评。你再使用贬义词来贬低我们人民，你就会惹事生非了。你现在觉得这是开玩笑，但等到某一天该到来的时候，你就知道”不好过“怎么写了。 我不想这么说，只不过为了全国人民，我就这么做了没办法
你说大马人的中文很烂已代表了我们马来西亚全国人民的中文烂。 你这样的说法也代表歧视我们全马人民喔。 你说人家不会用词啊。。。 我觉得你也不会用词啊 你不但没有想过哪句说法是有歧视的成分 还硬着头皮说下去啊。我不是说你脑子有问题，只不过看你还没经过思想，没想出这方面，我觉得。。。幼稚，不成熟这名号应该非你莫属比较适合一些 因为我可怜地不比你这方面厉害 hm... 我应该期待大马人民会给你留一些怎样的留言呢？ 不管是全部，很多或很少的大马留言者，那肯定是一件拭目以待的事情喔。hm...你应该是不害怕的人吧，那应该连对这方面的心理准备都做足，那你好好保重咯 哎呀 人家先问你20岁了吗 就答是还是不是啊。 哎哟真奇怪eh 还倒头来问人家请问你几岁啦。 小六的学生都会知道人家问东的时候，就别答西的。 几乎只会答西的人都是你eh 真了不起。 你说“你的心智是小学六年级吗？“hm... 可是从这例子来看， 你的心智几乎不过是小学六年级喔。 应该很多人会有这样的同感呢。
哈哈哈 我就猜到你会这么说的了 哎啊 这位唱将双下巴 爆牙 大嘴 肥胖身材 粗腿 人家天生是这样啊 有什么办法呢 喔我想到了大家大家听一听 这位hoho7509 一定 是最有钱 最有实力 最有能力的 他一定能把李佳薇整型成非常漂亮的女唱将 不只有料而且有靓样 大家觉得认同呢 支持支持他吧：） 有一件事我想不透 大概全世界的人在你眼中都是白痴 难道！ 你肯定是最聪明的人了 大家和我真的很想要知道这位大人的厉害的学历还有在哪里念很厉害的学校 如果真的那么厉害 那就在全世界刊登新闻讲述你的学历有多厉害吧 还有还有你应该也要上电视 让大家知道你的外表是比李佳薇出众十倍百倍 还有还有一定要在任何的电视节目贴着hoho7509这名字 才知道原来那就是你本人 大家大家我们一定要支持hoho7509做到上述的要求 而且必须在明天做到 对不对啊大家 因为啊hoho7509是天才 最聪明的 这一点点小事都难不倒他啊 hoho7509我想知道是怎么一回事 你是天才 怎么你几乎离了我想问的问题呢？ 问题对大家而言都非常明显
You want to hear a better cover of this song, even better than this one?
Search "Listen Charice" on youtube. Believe it or not.
哎哟 你不是天才吗？ 你的思维是不是出了问题了。 你很像没有好好地经过思考喔 我都说过了你发出这类的言论就等于跟所有的大马人民作对了。 听好喔 不只是我生长在你所说的”栏国家“，还有成千上万的人民也生长在这里耶。 你说我生长在烂国家意思是说所有的大马人民住在同一个烂国家咯。 哎哟好恶毒又不正面的想法喔。 你这么爱骂”马来摸“，”土人国“和”烂国家“的话，你可以订一张机票飞往马来西亚这里骂所有的人民”马来摸“，”土人国“，”栏国家“因为这里所有人都跟我一样生长在你说的”栏国家“，也同时是你说的”马来摸“。你一定要这么做喔因为如果你不这么做的话，所有人都不知道原来我们是”马来摸“，居住在一个”土人国“，”烂国家“，那我们的国家也不会算是”栏国家“了。 马来西亚随时欢迎你到来喔：）
哎呀 你刚刚的回复我都看过了 我觉得你真的比我还更加俗辣eh 我刚刚是在赞美你 天才 聪明 厉害 你反而说成人家很像得罪你似的 你有一句话你的文字很烂 我承认我是马来西亚人 我觉得因为国籍关系 使你说我文字很烂一点都不见怪 喔因为你是内地大陆人对不对 所以你想欺负不是本地人 我的妈呀 真是凶恶啊 你得罪的人不是很多咯 我真的真的很想强调说是你根本一点也没清清楚楚地回答我前面的问题 一直在离题eh 你20岁了吗请问 我觉得你每一次的留言都不大人化 反而只留下很多令人不舒服，难听，带有点幼稚的话语 又联系不上其他人的问题 你是不是在精神和心理上受到了创伤 要不要我带你去见精神和心理医生 应该会好些 我知道你接下来会说你才有精神病 应该是你去医院才对 我劝你别再这样啦 成熟点吧 这样很多人都不讨厌你啊 留点好听的留言对你来说不是艰难的事吧
Thanks to compare she with Beyonce or Charice. She just amateur at that singing competition. Anyway she performed well....
哈咯 steven7588 我支持你 因为是真的我们做人真的要在何时何刻谦虚 评语是可给 只不过要懂得如何是适度 若过度反而会让人觉得不可理喻 说个实话 我们人真的想要天生生出来是有料但没靓样吗 我觉得长得丑陋会使一个人没自信 伤心 被周边的人排斥
hoho7509其实我不想要跟你吵啦 只是想想看如果你是很丑的人 你此刻的心情会是如何的？ 你看到丑的人他们内心隐藏着伤心和自卑吗？ 他们根本不想天生是这样的啊 hoho7509你真的有想过丑的人的感受和心情吗？ 我奉你一句话人的心是最美丽 有了美丽的心就可以在舞台上散发真正的光芒与荣誉
@amishuon0518
讨厌看..就不要看罗. 在家照镜子看自己 这样你就不生气了.
我不是李佳薇的粉丝 但我觉得已经唱得很不错了. 那你有新歌吗?出了专辑?有的话post上来让我听听, 我也想看看你的高音有多强?
是的..一堆傻子去听他唱歌 我想你也是其中一个吧 因为你听了才懂他唱得不好 所以你也是傻的. 不是吗?
看起来你很专业...那麻烦你让大家知道..show大家一下 如何把高音唱得能让人听得进去.
李佳薇唱得这样你却说得一文不值 完全不好听..那麻烦你这位专业歌神 示范一下 如何才是好听 让我对你说个服字 让我无话好说.
如果你不能 就别在这里疯言疯语 像只疯狗一样.
哇 你留了真多负面留言啊 我才过了半年后再看李佳薇的影片留言 wow 几乎都是你的留言 而且非常厉害得负面喔。 我才昨天刚刚开始留言给你 你却认为因为我的留言 台湾歌迷会举报我 哈哈哈 你的负面留言比我刚刚昨天打出来那几个留言的多得太厉害了 想想看 台湾歌迷会举报我啊 那太不逻辑 太不合理了喔。 最合理，最逻辑的应该是台湾歌迷会举报一个在李佳薇影片的留言里疯狂留言太多负面留言（比我更加多的负面留言）的疯狂人物， 那就合理， 逻辑多了：）
听了 符琼音 朱俐静 张念蓉 Charice 李佳薇 版
每个人都有不同的诠释方法
我还是比较喜欢佳薇版 因为我是她的FANS 嘛 XD
我最喜欢她的声音 清清亮亮的 还有她的动作眼神 很杀啊！（观众缘XD）
charice 的真的很强大 她唱歌时的气势和肢体都震到我了 （好厉害啊！！）
符琼音的 也不错听啊！ 她抓住了我的耳朵~~
朱俐静 张念蓉 的 我不喜欢 不得我缘 （很主观的哦！）
不要炸我 跪地 ORZ
Not good! You need a lot of work. The whole song was off key. Her voice is too weak. The band was off key.
不好意思 您的留言能稍微清楚一点吗？ 不然会引起误会 我想说我的讲评是正面的 是好的 难道我要说太棒了 太棒了 拜托您应该找好讲评坏的对象 不要突然在我讲评空格的上面留着会令人误会的留言 我并不想责备在这里说佳薇唱地不好的人 而是忍不下手 因为我是佳薇的粉丝 不想偶像被批评没感情 没味道 所以佳薇获冠是应得的 之不应该的是对她留下负面留言 专业评审说好 有的这里说不好 反差会很大
@aloha676767 yup... i knew tat.. but singing is not bout hw high you reach... but she's good i noe.. :)
@g74x700417 charice 真的有这么强吗？？？刚好奇就听了charice唱的。。。抱歉，没感动到我，而且总觉得听起来很压力很压力，唱歌一段一段的，听了很辛苦。。。。本人不是佳薇迷，但看了你的留言好像赞到charice没人能及似的。。。咳，每个人有他的歌唱技巧与特色，无须作无谓的比较。难道你赞charice唱得好你有钱分吗？？？无聊透顶。。。。。>
@Charlehurst
这是嘶吼但也是黑人的唱法，不是没有感情，如果你多听黑人的 r&b ,soul, 就知道这是黑人对感情表达的一种，这与黑人的文化有关，遭到社会，白人歧视，他们以呐喊，嘶吼与一点点不满的唱法来诠释感情，歌曲。。
我认为是叮当对她的影响，上次与叮当的合唱就建议佳薇把自己当成黑妞，要放些，把爆发力完全出来，之前佳薇唱英文歌并没有这种的。
这是比赛，是歌唱能力的测试以及能力的释放。
就好比一辆性能优良的汽车在推出市场以前要进行速度的测试一样，它可能会加速到2-300km的时速，但是并不代表我们以后开车时要去到那个速度啊。。。
况且，一位声音有力量的歌手要唱如你们所说的大歌是易如反掌，更何况普通的温柔小曲。相反的，没力量的歌手就好比1马力的车要去到200km时速。。。不想而知（个人观点）
She doesn't have a rich n powerful voice as compared to beyonce BUT, she really did a great job! ;)
这是嘶吼但也是黑人的唱法，不是没有感情，如果你多听黑人的 r&b ,soul, 就知道这是黑人对感情表达的一种，这与黑人的文化有关，遭到社会，白人歧视，他们以呐喊，嘶吼与一点点不满的唱法来诠释感情，歌曲。。
我认为是叮当对她的影响，上次与叮当的合唱就建议佳薇把自己当成黑妞，要放些，把爆发力完全出来，之前佳薇唱英文歌并没有这种的。
eh.. No... You are the one typing in a foreign language right now.. As this show is from taiwan :)
如果你觉得认为人家笨的话，干嘛还做出回应呢。 笨的，令人不明白的留言别人都不会去理， 干嘛你去理呢。 当初你是说我的中文烂， 留言令人不明白， 谁会理我， 现在理我啦。 天才~~~你的记忆和分析能力出了什么状况了， 该理的时候，就不理。 该不理的时候，就理， 真是非一般的奇怪耶。 这也令我质疑你的厉害和天才是假的喔：（
@leoah121 FAIL. 'bad English pronounce' haha let me hear yours with such epic grammar hahahaha
she is asian.....which makes her pretty good already, its just her voice is not thick enough..
No matter what chinese, but u r malaysian chinese..not same at all for all chinese in the world, malaysia boleh.. U all can find the defferent only in malaysia..
什么意思不行了 我健康的很 我去了多间的医院， 医生说我没问题 很健康 如果我是一名孕妇 快要生小孩了 我觉得你的话比较成立一点 还有啊 你说想来劝说 hm.... 也代表你是真的该被劝说的人了 你的精神和心理上应该有一些问题吧 要不要我哼几句劝说的话给你听 安抚安抚一下你的心啊？
@tzinwei90
你是眼睛有問題嗎 董哥?
"你拿一個從小學習音樂的根一個沒有受過任何音樂訓練的比?" 我想表達的是這個你懂嗎 董哥?
林育群他在星光唱的歌 放在TH-cam上 沒多久 就被艾倫愛說笑邀請上節目
請問李佳薇???? 而且誰說一定要唱原KEY才厲害? 唱高音時聲音單薄沒有爆發力 有爆發力的只有那幾個詞 其他都是很虛的在唱 !!
只是被肯定了?_? 沒實力能被肯定?_? 你腦袋是?_? 說什麼"換成李佳薇上洋人節目 點閱率一定比夏芮絲高" ??
拜託 TH-cam是全世界都可以看到的 如果真的唱這麼厲害 早就被發掘了 不然林育群跟夏芮絲是怎麼被發現的 ?_? 拜託不要不懂裝懂好嗎 董哥??
我並不是因為討厭李佳薇才來這邊酸什麼的 只是有這麼多人把夏芮絲講的一文不值一樣
我只想說 如果夏芮絲沒有這麼厲害 他不會被邀請上這麼多個大節目 也不會馬上被大衛佛斯特簽下來
就每次幾個人唱一些大哥就要拿去跟原唱比 拿去跟夏芮絲比 拜託 你們把碧昂絲跟夏芮絲的地位放在哪?
還是老話一句 等到李佳薇被艾倫跟歐普拉欽點上節目 再來這邊捧 謝謝
charice 每一首歌都是唱現場的 而且可以說直接收入在CD發片都沒問題 靠的是捨麼 靠的是charice在每一首歌的轉音技巧跟音域的頂點都不是他的極限 更不用說他的肺活量了 所以每首歌都唱的迎刃有餘 像國內的頂級歌手幾乎都如此 差別在每一位頂尖歌手知道自己的能力位子在哪 以這版的Listen 來說 超偶 朱 符 張 星光的佳微 以這首Listen 可以放入唱片嗎?? 我想沒人買吧 整首歌已經超過自己的極限 唱出來會好聽嗎? 當然他們會進步 未來或許會很強 但現在呢?? 一些符迷 或者是這版的歌迷 請以公平的角度去判斷 部是只是某位的歌迷 就自以為是最無懈可擊的 所以現在一些歌迷把Listen 這首歌 去跟 charice 比較 只是讓人覺得想笑 charice是唱翻唱Listen這首歌的鼻祖 我想每個參賽者都當charice是一個標竿吧 不只這首 有很多首 佳微唱最多charice翻唱的
嗯，用心就是专业。台下的人往往不知参赛者究竟是抱着怎样的心情与期待，付出与努力勇敢站上那受到万人瞩目的舞台。在批评别人的当儿，是否应该想想自己是否完美呢？每个人都有属于自己的舞台，不同的风格才能显现世界的多样化，如果风格一成不变，这世界便会处于灰色地带，没有颜色，也不再精彩。
@g74x700417 说那么多干嘛，我个人就是觉的佳薇的比较好听，charice的不好听，就那么简单！跟我说什么欧美公认欧洲发片什么的，So what!音乐又不是欧美的专利！就是不喜欢欧美的唱法不行吗！你放心，我不会说charice那么厉害叫她去中国发片这种白痴话来！
說實話.....我不懂你們在這邊筆戰什麼....
身為一個挑戰者本來就要接受大眾的評論，唱得好也好：唱不好也好，真正被評論的是挑戰者，怎麼去看到這些評論使自己更上一層樓，是她的事。 沒必要在這邊吵。
對於反對“批評佳薇”，力挺佳薇的人，甚至有人說過她的新歌沒人唱得比她好；你們這麼懂得評論的話，怎不去當評審？ 再說，少少的幾個評審給的分數高到近乎滿分，就代表她真的棒嗎？ 好不好聽，是由所有的聽眾去決定，並不是那些評審！
單純就以聽眾的角度來看佳薇唱的listen，不管他想表達的是原本的意境；抑或是她另外想詮釋的意境........你們有感覺到他想傳達的東西嗎? 至少對我而言是沒有！
也許是我對音樂敏感度不夠好，那麼就請支持佳薇且覺得她百分百的人，說說看你們從她唱的這首歌接受到了什麼樣的訊息吧。
@tzinwei90
而且看來閣下打Online Game 打怪升級時 點技能因該都點嘴巴吧QQ??
從頭到尾我看到你只有在打嘴砲 而不是在評論
拜託 一點知識都沒有 還想要學人家裝專業 拜託 加油好嗎?
林育羣跟夏芮絲 是從TH-cam爆紅 而不是上洋人的節目 拜託 多去增廣見聞 不要什麼都不知道
整天在網上打嘴砲
這樣很對不起父母的 你知道嗎
林育羣 4/9號被PO在TH-cam 4/21就被邀請到艾倫愛說笑了 阿現在是換你要說笑就是了?
請問 這影片放多久了? QQ
我怎麼覺得你好可愛 到現在這句話還是讓我笑最久"林育群大哥上星光節目的時候收視率和點閱率都很好..現在星光的點閱率和收視率都那麼差..佳薇當然很難被人發現" LOL
記住 這是網路 世界各地的人都可以進來看
不要在這麼可愛了 ROFL
@tzinwei90
聲音沒有穿透力? 拜託不要裝懂好嗎?
難道要我叫您一生裝董哥? 好吧 董哥 開心嗎?
你拿一個從小就學習聲樂學習歌唱技巧的人根一個沒有學習任何聲樂過的人比
還可以被邀請到各大節目然後因此爆紅的比較? 拜託 董哥 李佳薇上洋人的節目 我看他還沒有到那樣的能力吧..
拜託請你去聽聽夏芮絲的 I Have nothing , and i am telling you i'm not going , i will always love you
除非你是耳包 不然我真的不知道該用什麼來形容你的耳朵 董哥^^
是阿 李佳薇跟夏芮絲比 夏芮絲真的還差的遠 夏芮絲根本就是鬼神等級的
我還是只能說 等到李佳薇被艾倫或是歐普拉邀請上節目 再來這邊捧 加油^^
個人覺得...能有多少個人能像beyonce?能像charice??答案是沒有,每個人都不同,而且拿已經演譯這首歌無數次的beyonce歌手來比,不覺得對選手不公平嗎?若每個都能唱到像beyonce 和charice 那樣,那麼歌唱界不是很不的空??beyonce 跟charice還用混飯吃???而且,歌不是拿技巧來衡量,衝不衝得上是個人體力跟訓練的結果.歌最主要的演譯出來感情,她有否糟蹋了LISTEN這首歌呢?憑心而論,若拿beyonce跟charice她的確無法比擬(目前而言),將來她絕對會好很多.這首歌曲她的感情演譯得的確不錯,雖然無法說能感動到流眼淚,但是那一刻的確有觸動到人心.建議,評論前大家能否站在客觀的立場來評論呢??感恩.
@cc760330 一樣比賽影片..跟Charice比?? 拜託Charice是捨麼等級 用的著跟佳薇比?? Charice 的世界級唱歌技巧 紅的程度 跟歌迷的支持 不知道就遠過 佳薇 幾百倍了 拿捨ㄇ比 妳教我?? 只能說像是用螞蟻去撞大象 .. Charice 被譽為世界最會唱歌的的女歌手 音域的寬廣 聲音爆發力及穿透力 以及無人能及的肺活量 比?? 看不懂要比捨麼ㄟ Charice唱的不夠細膩 會批評 挖靠 Charice如果去星光踢一次 我看連評審老師都要拜他為師了 妳到底懂不懂捨ㄇ叫唱歌 覺得妳只是佳薇的忠實歌迷罷了...