Exactly,I want India to be a Capitalist Dictatorship like China, Taiwan, Singapore, South Korea (SK & Taiwan were Dictatorships until they became Rich by 1990s)
Question is, what should BJP do? Should bjp stop rewari and go out of power? While opposition comes in power and starts the same rewari thing???? What’s the solution? Opposition offers these things and to remain in power the ruling party follows their footsteps.
Middle class is not addicted to Modi. Its scared of Raga. When he says things like jitni aabadi utna haq and increasing reservation beyond 50 percent, it leaves no choice to middle class other than Modi. A sensible opposition can take on BJP but congress led by Raga is not that.
The last census in India was conducted in 2011. It's been over a decade since, which raises concerns about the ability to make informed policy decisions and planning without accurate data, such as the number of people living in poverty. A census provides granular data about the country, which has significant implications for India's development and planning. This data is crucial for understanding the demographic makeup of the country, tracking progress, and identifying areas that require attention. So, the opposition has been questioning how anyone can effectively allocate resources and implement programs without updated data. This concern highlights the importance of conducting regular censuses to ensure that policy decisions are informed by accurate and reliable data. The next census was supposed to take place in 2021. However, it has been delayed, and there are only hints that the census may take place soon. Unfortunately, no official date has been confirmed, leaving many wondering when the census will finally be conducted. ALL IS WELL
Isha Ambani delivered her twins in New York in order to get birthright citizenship for them. When even the Ambanis are looking for an escape route, India's woes are far greater than anyone can articulate.
It took me 11 years to realize that Modi, once seen as a strong leader, appears spineless in resisting the rewadi culture that Kejriwal started and he eventually embraced.
@@siddharth6505the problem is people mindset I have seen with my own eye people mainly votes on these things not on infrastructure ok so a politician only do or say what people wants
Or it's the demand from voters that BJP had to cater... while we are always sitting and complaining about politicians, Vishram so think about how people are looking at government services and what they are asking for
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
If I was Rahul Gandhi Immediately after the budget I would have announced that a lower income tax structures if my party comes to power and also abolishment of other draconian taxes. This would have surely migrated this class to congress
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
I read in some interview that no political party in India wants middle class to expand and become politically strong. Because this is the class that asks relevant and uncomfortable questions, that no leader of any political party wants to face. So it's in their own vested interest to keep this class weak and trapped.
@sunilkp "First time i felt i [...] Middle-class is trapped and they have no choice." =============================================== No, the middle class Hindu supporters of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co are *_NOT_* trapped by any circumstance that is beyond their control. Rather, they CHOOSE to support Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co because: 1. such supporters have allowed themselves to get completely carried away by the bogus nationalism of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co; and 2. the intense animosity that such supporters feel towards the (so-called) out-groups.
@@yevodee4024 KHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
I just dream that one day the Gandhi family will step down and someone with talent and political acumen will head congress and present a strong alternative to BJP.
@@gauravdas6741 Konsa nepotism. Modi Bajpayee ke beta nehi hai. Congress ka har leader Gandhi hai. Rahul koi aur carrrer mei accha karta par usko bhi ismei ghusana tha sabko
Over 2.15 lakh Indians gave up their citizenship and moved abroad in 2023 alone and the number is growing. Seems like. People don't want to live in Amritkaal😢
Many are facing financial challenges, even if it's not necessarily about rice. India's middle-class pay income taxes, but don't have the same opportunities as some with more money, to relocation outside India.
Cost of living & vegetable prices have increased too much for ordinary people. The vegetable prices have increased by 63.04% & fruit prices by 13.55% in Oct 2024. Consumer Food Price Index was 11%. Consumer Price Index for Oct 2024 was 6.21% & for urban CPI is 6.68%. Household saving have been dropping.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
If Congress replaced RaGa with someone competent, the middle class would vote for them. People forget that the middle class voted for Manmohan Singh in 2009. They also voted for Kejriwal in Delhi state elections.
When Congress and other non-BJP parties made even more ridiculous promises, Guptaji said we should not focus on that. 'NYAY' was very important apparently. It is not addiction to Modi. The other options are even crazier. See what Congress has done in Karnataka and AAP has done in Delhi respectively. BJP does Jan Kalyan but is not crazy like Congress which wants to do a caste-based wealth census to redistribute wealth. Who will be the target of that? - The Middle Class. Especially those who have some excess in the form of a house and some farmland. The rich will find a way. And the result of all of this will be a complete destruction of whatever economy we have. So don't provoke us to make us feel dumb, ask why the other option is even more crazier!
If congress wanted to redistribute wealth and conduct caste based census, they would have done it in 70 years. The reason other parties had taken measures of freebies is because BJP has taken away all the space for political parties to win. Entire mainstream media is a mouthpiece of one party, almost all democratic institutions are compromised. Corporate donation is going to one party only by either favouring some businessman or by using agencies against them. The investigation agencies are used to break parties and put important opposition leaders in jail unless they join BJP. And the biggest of all...Heavy polarisation of people on religious lines. There is no space for any political party to breath. Once you will take off the mask of bhakti and become a rational person, you will realise how unfair and dangerous it is. Till then you keep singing this song.
@@mathurhp Cool! I will keep singing and you will keep living in delusion. One important correction in the narrative people like you build time and again to save your precious RaGa- Corporate donation was significantly less for one party than it has commanded/wanted i.e. Congress. Everyone else including BJP got ample corporate donations. BJP led in donations even before the electoral bond saga and even during UPA. But again stating facts is Bhakti. So be it.
@@rajeev20230 your logic is dumb , the middle class run the economy through spending, they even rely less on government welfare , reducing debt and freebies
Correct. Rahul is all about caste and religion. That's why he cannot beat Modi. A normal opposition w/ a positive message can beat Modi. But Rahul is very negative and is all about religion and caste. If you want to focus on religion and caste, then Modi is better because Rahul will turn the country into a minority-appeasement factory. At least Modi has a positive future vision. Rahul is a retrograde and backward-looking.
Modani 3.0 dissapointed everyone because he has allated more time to find fault with opposition than concentrate development. He doesn't want anyone advising him asif modani knows everything god. He captured godimedia social media print media moreover ec sc it Ed hc etc all are dancing to the tune
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
TBH, atleast the service class started hating modi, but issue is on the other hand RAGA seems even worse, free money to all, reservation, caste census for jitni abadi utna haq, and appeasement politics, what choice do we have? India needs better options period.
@ lol, hindus doesnt have any law which is above anyone’s else religion, we cant marry 5, we cant claim any property as we please, temples are the only worship place which pays taxes to govt, and this govt didnt change anything, how is this appeasement? Warf board removal and UCC is required to make every religion same for the country, and frankly if congress didnt had appeasement politics, hindus wouldn’t have voted for BJP, people from one religion just got fedup being treated and 2nd class citizens hence the rise of BJP.
@@mohanishchitnis7680 ok, well i never said modi is good or worse, i just pointed out for the majority of the ppl Modi seems better than RAGA, there are alot of factor to it, better speaker, better politician, more vocal towards national issues and decisive governance. Modi works for billionaires, might be true but so did the congress, if congress were so great at what they do , why we had such a uprising of BJP, also, i would worry about reservations, i dont want anybody who is good at what they do loose an opportunity because of some govt wants to create a bocus reservation, but again im not fully against reservation our history is complicated and there were people who were neglected or to rightly put treated worse because of their birth, but the reservation suppose to decrease with time not increase, if increasing reservation after 70yrs of independence is needed that itself means that reservation created more problem. Also i would suggest you to go and search that 15lakh statement, he said ‘if we get all the black money back the amount if so huge that it will be equivalent to each indian getting 15lakh in their account’. Also RAGA is not working like europe style welfare, Europe does not give freebies when the state is in crisis, they dont promise reservation and europe has less population than that of india with almost everyone contributing to direct taxes, they can afford to give freebies not us, just have more points when you make a statement, adding two different nation with very very very different challenge and trying to apply same principle will be disastrous. Most important, dont mind ,but modi govt is bad, high taxes high inflation, zero benefits to middleclass, but opposition has to come with better statements, questions than caste ,census, appeasement and freebies, we deserve better opposition. All the opposition do is walk out of session when they can raise so many good questions to the govt, they literally are not able to push the govt to the corner because they are so narrow interms of what issue they want to highlight, for example, RAGA opposed CAA NRC and now asking govt why bangladeshi are coming in india? How tf is this making sense? Instead of asking and suggesting what was wrong with farm laws they want to repealed entire law, but then go and ask what is the modi govt doing for farmers? Ridiculous. The fact is that a part time politician cannot be the face of opposition if we want a better governance.
Sarthak you don't matter. Being in such a small minority as a middle class, I don't get why you'd think your vote even counts. We all know you'll vote bjp forever and so will the radicalised, jobless and unproductive rural heartland. Just sit down and vote for Modi instead of subtly blackmailing vishwaguru.
The Middle class is stuck between a Rock and a hard place On one place BJP is continuing to disappoint and tax terror the middle class with 0 reform and more taxes. On the other hand The Congress threatens to be even worse with Rahul Gandhi only finding caste wherever he goes. Has made Adani and Ambani ( The only constant investors) into a gaali.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
In addition to the BPL class, the Sanatani class enjoying and feeling proud with the sadhu santh who are attending crowd, are non productive, not adding any contribution to the National GDP..It seems why Modi’s make in India programme is absolute failure.. the main reason.. Actually the progressive people who are educated enough and have upgraded skills, going out side india, working far away from their families and sending money in foreign currencies by way of remittances are the real savers of Indian pride.. with out them now we are nothing.. one find day will emerge, situation will worsen, and the game sanathani, samskari, Hindu, muslin come to an end, people will be on hunt for food and survival.. This was over past and history.. will repeat again and again….
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
@@ramohan158THAT'S WHY EVEN AFTER 60 YEAR'S OF PRODUCTIVE KHANGRESS RAJ THEY HAVE TO RUN THE SAME " GAREEBI HATAO " NAARA EVEN TODAY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Started by RAGA/DMK/AAP, the situation is: no party in states can win without Dole offerings. No state party in power can be dislodged if they paid Dole 3 months before election. Dole will rule Indian political narrative for next 10-15 years. Adopt or Perish.
DMK IS IN POWER IN TN VIA 500RS/ QUARTER BY APPEASING CHURCH AND BHAI BIRYANI GROUP FDI HAS ALREADY MOVED TO BJP STATES GOPALAPURAM MAFIA DAY'S ARE NUMBERED
This is not a national interest. This is the worst form of targeting. If freebies are such a menace, why Khatakhat in is not even mentioned in this and why only BJP? Shame to see such acts being presented as national interest.
Friend Shekhar Gupta was heavily funded by Congress ..in his earlier days ..so u can never expect good word for BJP in his channel other day he was talking about net FDI is less though it is the biggest in history of India ..just one way or other he does this u can see the pattern
So can't anyone criticize the govt ? I am heavily critical of nirmala and soft modi even though I hate all other parties 10 times over. Whats wrong with people ?
The problem is u see everything through BJP's hindutva glasses and see everything wrong except this corrupt worst party called BJP.. this party will plunge this beautiful country into darkness one day
The problem is that middle class has no choices - any alternate to Modi is terribly horrifically worse. Middle class does not have resources to leave India and if it does not vote Modi but abstains, catastrophic alternatives will grab power.
Until farm reforms, labour reforms, easier land acquisition and more urbanization has to be urgently done. Congress has been anti all these. And BJP has lost it's spine to do these.
The number of millionaires leaving seems to be a small percentage of total number of millionaires. Is the net number of millionaires growing each year?
The real elephant in the room is the abysmally low-income taxpayer base in India (less than 4%). Far too many people evade taxes in India. Corporates get tax cuts, business owners rarely ever pay income tax, poor (and many self-declared 'poor') get everything for free and some sectors like agriculture are completely exempted from Taxes. This puts the entire load of fulfilling the wishes of billion plus population on SALARIED middle class who has no escape from this vicious cycle.
I have read many comments on this newspiece and your crisp and insightful arguments on this article certainly stand out. Very few people like you have demonstrated your stand with the actual ground realities and that is what makes your comments noteworthy. I really liked reading it.
Should vote out MOdi and BJP and then prepare ourselves for NYAY and "JITNI AABADI UTNA HAQ" where Congress and INDI Alliance would be giving Rs 72000 per family every year and making people almost impossible to get a job and education by reserving all the seats for specific communities :D :D Are we stupid?
Aap bc delhi ko kabadi bna kr rkha h smjha be aap sirf free and Muslim votes ke karn jit rha h uske alawa koi vote nhi deta aap ko kisi aur chij ke liye
You seem to know who to trust....in that case stick to trusting the same person and expect a difference. This is the 3rd term of this govt....do you need more time for an alternative or a change. I suppose for you time is a luxury. You must be a rich guy who is doing well. Good luck to you.
@@nobufrancis685 Bad is better than worst. change should be from bad to good not bad to worst. We need person like Manmohan Singh but we don't have one now.
The taxes saved will only go to expensive education, not consumption. The better option is keep the taxes the same for middle class, tax the corporates more and then drive growth through more infrastructure spending. In addition, double the tarrifs for Chinese imports to improve manufacturing.
Yes middle class is not getting benefited , but there is infrastructure super boom , no appeasement , no corruption in freebies distribution, no terror blasts, emotive issues like Ram mandir n 370 which looked impossible are done and forget about a face , you have a Pappu in front supported by piddis
How are you you benefitting from all this. Even if your salary is 1cr per year, it is only 125,000 USD per year. Lower middle class by world standards. More 70% of our middle class is less than poverty line of the US
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Shekhar Gupta had been eagerly waiting for this moment for the last 10+ years .. An excuse to put Modi down. There are always ups amd downs in an economy which doesnt have its own natural resources and RnD. Modi is investing in RnD but it takes decades to see the results. U have physically grown Shelhar ji but you need to really grow up!
As alternative is wealth redistribution, much more freebies, higher inflation, scams, much more dynasty, appeasement, poor infrastructure etc. Middle class think what they have now is good
Shekar ji, there are 2 reasons for this. 1. There is enormous amount of testosterone driven nationalism in middle class (as you pointed in one of your ctc episodes), 2. There is no better alternative to bjp and middle class is well aware that the Congress is overwhelmingly socialist in its instincts, things would be much worse if it comes back to power.
We as a society needs to create Education, Health care , unemployment , woman safety, R&D facilities, Manufacturing, Basic level schooling as political issue. Any party will perform better if we change our prospective and tell them that they will only get votes if they solve above mentioned issues or else we giving it to local party. I think India needs a youth leader who will represent the working class and their struggle. Modi failed ,RaGa failed. If we dont have alternative we need to create one now.
What on earth has modi done for hindus? He is just the same as congress. Left wing socialist appeasement guy. Just slightly more focus on national security, infrastructure and development than congress.
Nirmala Amma is outdated for the youth. Her eyes and ears closed in arrogance and egoism. The middle class pays 60% total taxes to various governments. But they have to pay NH Toll again for the NH but with their money. She threw into the dustbin a reference from Mohan Bhagat ji & Nitin Gadkari ji , to accept HC judgments in the Bank pensioners' case. She has been exploiting a weakness of the judicial system by taking adjournments in the appeal she filed against bank pensioners in SC. She locks EXCESS TDS REFUND SERVER for 15 months. For example, a TDS deducted in April 2025 is retained and a refund claim is not allowed till July 2026 . The server is locked from April 2025 to July 2026. Then refund will be without any interest. EQUALITY= when a tax payer delays tax payments, she imposes fine and charge interest
@gokuldastvm and I don't think you understand the pit we will be in if this opposition cocktail comes to power . But let's agree to not to understand each other
What option do we have rather than PM Modi?😂😂😂 1. Rahul Gandhi is all about the Khatakhat scheme, reservation and old pension scheme. 2. At least development projects have picked up a little speed and actually started getting completed. 3. DBT has changed the entire corruption game, deserving people are actually getting the benefits. Even middle class has received massive relief through PMAY. I myself know 4-5 people who have received 2 lakhs of PMAY. 4. BTW which government has given tax relief to the middle class? As per my opinion nobody has.
All hail supreme leader.... 1) Ache din aayenge 2) Vishwaguru banen ge 3) China ko Harayenge 4) Lekin school aur hospital nahi banayenge. 5) Corruption nahi hatayenge. 6) Ambani aur Adani ko amir banayenge.
No man school and hospital are definitely being made as i myself are working on it. I live in the east so I will talk about that area 1)Wb 11 hospital projects ongoing 6 new coming up 4 new colleges added and multiple schools have been added. 2) Orissa 15 new hospital added 7 under the planning process. 7 new colleges added multiple school have been built. 3) bihar and jharkhand 9 new hospital projects ongoing 4 new colleges project multiple school projects. 5) The north east 19 hospital project is ongoing. Infra is going good right now but the problem is quality check and corruption on every level. I know a government Contractor who has multiple cases against him still getting more contracts he mostly built bridges in bihar and now he is building a new building for the income tax directorate. You can easily bribe the executive engineer of the government it's only 2% of the total cost of construction.
Middle class votes for Modi since the other national alternative - CONG is way worse with kooky pseudo-communist ideas about redistribution, economy & reservations (saying this as an OBC) whereas regional parties except TDP, DMK have no focus on driving economic growth. This is Mr.SG being too clever by half as usual. He correctly identifies the middle class being frustrated with Modi but attributes it solely to anti-muslim stuff (which is a minor factor, but not primary) rather than looking at what other parties are offering as alternatives to the same middle class, because if he does so his conclusion & story will fall apart. If you assume the voter is right & knows his/her self interest - why not assume the same for the middle class? They know modi hasn't done much for them & are taxed too much. More likely they are afraid of what the other parties will do if they come to power!
The middle class stayed loyal to Modi because there was no alternative at the central level. Inflation and corruption charges during the 2009-2014 period have made Congress the least likely party to vote at the central level for the middle class.
Those who remove congress on corruption and inflation charges now voting modi for religion(unfounded religion threat) putting aside their earlier concerns...
Does not matter what Congress is - Congress is bad, BJP is bad, RSS is bad. We need to look for checks and balances, in differences in opinion within the ruling alliance. Vote for BJP, not Modi.
Dear Respected Shekhar Saheb , Over The Years you’ve mastered the art of Factual StoryTelling , This was a great episode with craft fully Slamming a Hard Shot yet Softly worded for both The Political shots and Public . Wah ….. Kya Baat ! Jai Ho !! Keep Up The Good Work
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Most of Middle class won’t come under income tax, they need small business and employment opportunities. Government doing good in this by encouraging with online businesses and PLI schemes for manufacturing jobs. Also serving sector growing and health sector creating lots of job with 70+ years free healthcare care. My suggestion to government is consider them for health insurance also with minimum fees like 5 lacks coverage per family with 1k to 2k per year. This is beneficial for middle class families and government can improve healthcare services.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
50 % income going to direct and indirect taxes.rest 50% goes into necessary and non avoidable recurring expenses.even people have to take loans for necessary things like education, medical and housing.Uncontrolled, unchecked and unregulated sectors. Govt purposefully doesn't do anything abt them and sems totally helpless as its a deep nexus of govt , banks and businessmen ruining these institutions.
When they say there is no one other than Modi I laugh and laugh loudly. When Indian middle class have forgiven Modi after that disasterous demonetisation and Modi's first term economic debacles, many like me have given up. Indian middle class read Hindus have blinded themselves with cultural revivalism and Hindutva. Absolute stupidity. China and other nations are getting richer while Indian per capita GDP is moving at a snail's pace. The ones who have economic and intellectual capital like me have moved out of India and many will continue to move out.
Bhai india me kabse chunav presidential way me hone lage just vote the person in your assembly who is more educated doesn't matter whuch party he comes from even it's a nirdaliya. Just send educated people in parliament not gunda mawali.
The MAIN reasons-perhaps the ONLY reasons-that most of the middle class Hindus in the Hindi-Hindu-Hindutva parts of India support Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co is that: 1. such supporters have got completely carried away by the bogus nationalism of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co, and 2. the intense animosity that such supporters feel towards 'others'.
50 years of Congress and 10 years of UPA/Indi gang addiction has ended for the right reason. Infrastructure boom has just started under middle class favourite PM Modi.
Middle class is being strangled by excessive taxes-sky-high income tax, GST on everything from basics to essentials, and zero relief. The backbone of the economy is being broken, while policymakers turn a blind eye.
गोदी मीडिया लगातार चीनी अर्थव्यवस्था के पतन की बात हो रही हैं। उसने 2024 में चीन के 992 बिलियन डॉलर के व्यापार सरप्लस के बारे में कुछ नहीं कहा। वह भारतीय अर्थव्यवस्था के पतन, बेरोजगारी, गरीबी और भारतीय रुपये के पतन के बारे में कभी बात नहीं करती है।
According to the Commenters The Man with a fake degree and the master mind of demonetization is the only "option" for India. Rest are pappus. These people should stop watching state sponsored propaganda for once .
Stop your propaganda that modi has fake degree. Supreme court has already slapped guys like you in the face for mksleading people about modi. Stop doing personal attacks and rather criticize modi on its policy based on data not whataboutery.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Stalled reforms? We have our wonderful opposition to blame for that. Farm Laws would have been a shot in the arm for all farmers and had done away with corruption and cartelization in APMC mandis but all they want is prices like a fixed salary and even pensions after all years of tax free income. Hit and Run which was applicable for all but opposed for political gains and threatened to withdraw by chakka jaam. Judicial reforms. Collegium system would have been done away with but removed by courts and opposed by opposition. Electoral bonds to remove cash donations to political parties but again opposed by opposition. Its like Congress wants to keep the system unchanged because it is on this corrupt and stagnant system that they survive. In a democracy like india where even a person with half knowledge behaves like an expert, reforms can only be brought when we have no options left like 1992 or else these 'experts' will oppose anything and everything and people can be easily swayed.
Opposition will always oppose things. BJP opposed Indo US nuclear deal, Aadhar card, GST, MNREGA, RTI, computerization of government offices and many other things. The reason Modi took back farm laws was not the opposition otherwise 370, CAA, Triple Talaq, GST and many other bills would have been scrapped too. The reason of taking back farm law bill was inevitable fall in western UP in upcoming assembly elections.
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization did you see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which files burnt. Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india. DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it. Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization we didnt see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which files burnt. Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india. DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it. Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization we didnt see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which of their neumerous scam files were burnt. Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india. DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it. Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
As someone from middle class I can’t express in words how much this video resonate with me. At this point I don’t even know what to do when my tax money is being thrown around like this.
problem is not with middle class ( majorly hindu hardworking taxpayers across states ) - problem is that opposition failed to give any alternative to economic issues - opposition more interested to devide hindus on caste, regional lines and trying always to appease the 2nd largest community of india ie muslims & reaping benefits of a pan islamic consolidated vote-bank, unless the 2nd largest community ie muslims identify themselves first as an indian ,their regional identity next and then their religion last, nothing gona change in this country...... its good that modi govt still says sabka saath sabka biswas inspite of getting zero muslim votes, consider a scenario if they stop this goodwill gesture then its oneway
Once again, great take..... To add salt to injury:- most bureaucrats are middle class, and they are the instruments of this neo politics of vote bank monetization. In the role of "sarkari babu" they are cooking their own entrails themselves and supporting it too
Who are middle class shekhar? Only 3 crore people actually pay income tax. And for sure job is an issue, and what growth have stalled? Only one quarter with low growth that too in the election quarter. But our economic model is screwed to begin with all the socialist toxicity. Also, what better option is there ? We well vote for caste census and wealth survey? R we crazy?
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@kennymon4u we have much much much better governance than any anti national secular scoundrel parties cld give. BJP is hundred times better than congress. Its the rascal socialist enablers like you and ur breed who destroyed yhe country for 60 years. Our grouse with the BJP is its too much soft on oppositions and commie babus. We didnt vote them to be democratic, we voted them to make radical changes and break the institutions to remold a new India. Our expectations are high, but we also know the practical constraints of running a complex country like India. BJP is doing fine, but we expect them to do better, we dont have any expectation from the opposition, they are just marxist-mullah coalition.
Yes! These are the kind of concerns that one expects journalism to voice, especially when opposition parties are busy doing identity dramas rather than elevating such concerns and views of the public!
Every Indians want to leave , it was not the case in congress govt . Congress was corrupt but it has not hurt the normal people like the way BJP did . High taxation has hurt everybody and people have become poor and what people have got in return ? Time for this govt to go . Delhi people pleas slap bjp with huge defeat
Congress has not hurt people??😂😂 Abey jha 2 congress has ruled this country for 60yrs. Everything we see wrong with this country be it corruption, sarkari work culture, indefinate delays in projects, 0 civic sense, lawlessness etc. is all given by congress in virasat.😂
Mujhe lagta hai bjp ne hindu muslim kar kar ke baki cheezo pe dhyan hi nahi diya lekin ek baat unhe dhyan rakhna hoga kisi bhi cheez ki seema hoti hai agar har baar wohi cheez karoge na to log aap se believe karna chod denge
Who? Anyone who delivers, doesn't hurt growth, doesn't cull freedoms. Someone politically viable. And it will happen, people have always wondered "If not he/she, who?" Voters will themselves come up with an answer if other leaders try hard enough.
Absolutely correct Shekhar ji, as usual! 🙏 Could you please consider presenting the demographic statistics based on household income? Next question would be - how many households enjoy unethical pecuniary benefits?
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Govt is trying to become richer than the citizens looting taxes from them. Cars longer than 4 meters have 42% gst. How would automobile industry grow like this?
I am a BJP voter. But here's how congress can get my vote: 1. Support farm bill and land acquisition bill 2. Stop jitni aabadi utna haq nonsense. Promise you will never even think of it. 3. Chart out a plan for next 20 years in getting India out of reservations and creating system of meritocracy. 4. Promise to remove tax gundaism.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
"what is the alternative?" -bang on Despite tax dadagiri and the financial squeeze, the middle class has seen improvements in their quality of life in the last 10 years. Fewer scams and better economic development are well appreciated by them. They don't 'love' Modi, much less Ms Sitharaman. They don't have an alternative.
Wait wait whom to vote for if not Modi? Rahul Gandhi? Why it's assumed hate for Muslims by middle class is causing them to vote for Modi, before 2014 Indians were secular and now they Hindutavadis, give middle class good option and not some part time politician
It's not about Modi. The oppositions are equally or rather worse in tax brutality. There is no 1 state ruling party which has said no to freebies. There is no 1 state which has showcased as a role model.
Modi is implementor and not new idea generator like Neharu, Narasimha Rao and Vajpeyee… India has now completed the implementation backlog and now its time to move to idea generation. Unfortunately middle class is not seeing anyone worthy of idea generation so they have no option but to stick with Modi… Unfortunate for India… This is looking like 1980’s India…
I don't think middle class is addicted to modi. They just lack better options. Modi is more of a " andho m kana raja". He is far better than others. Whenever there are options people choose them. Delhi is a classic example of this, even during the so called " modi lahar". RaGa will have to think out of the box to gain support.
Haryana bpl rate case was a very big shocker for me and when I researched more about this, then I found that bpl numbers increased recently(2022-24) by ~60% in 5 major districts. After all this bjp voting percentage gain in HR election is beyond my understanding.😮
Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
Exactly,I want India to be a Capitalist Dictatorship like China, Taiwan, Singapore, South Korea (SK & Taiwan were Dictatorships until they became Rich by 1990s)
@@ThePrintIndia Sold out bootlickers pseudo journos. No one cares what you do. Niklo yahan se.......
No Indian sales is 2.5 million cars not 2.5 Crore cars
Question is, what should BJP do?
Should bjp stop rewari and go out of power? While opposition comes in power and starts the same rewari thing????
What’s the solution?
Opposition offers these things and to remain in power the ruling party follows their footsteps.
Mindless and Ill intent vengeful minded middle class are addicted to BJP and RSS.
Middle class is not addicted to Modi. Its scared of Raga. When he says things like jitni aabadi utna haq and increasing reservation beyond 50 percent, it leaves no choice to middle class other than Modi. A sensible opposition can take on BJP but congress led by Raga is not that.
The last census in India was conducted in 2011. It's been over a decade since, which raises concerns about the ability to make informed policy decisions and planning without accurate data, such as the number of people living in poverty.
A census provides granular data about the country, which has significant implications for India's development and planning. This data is crucial for understanding the demographic makeup of the country, tracking progress, and identifying areas that require attention.
So, the opposition has been questioning how anyone can effectively allocate resources and implement programs without updated data. This concern highlights the importance of conducting regular censuses to ensure that policy decisions are informed by accurate and reliable data.
The next census was supposed to take place in 2021. However, it has been delayed, and there are only hints that the census may take place soon. Unfortunately, no official date has been confirmed, leaving many wondering when the census will finally be conducted. ALL IS WELL
You must be from general category having more reservation 10% than actual numbers
Unfortunately RAGA is the inevitable truth of India
👍
@@killeridea1685 How do you know general are less than 10%? did some gospel came and tell you that?
Isha Ambani delivered her twins in New York in order to get birthright citizenship for them. When even the Ambanis are looking for an escape route, India's woes are far greater than anyone can articulate.
Lol😂.. Trump have already abolished the citizens rule . Please be updated
@@programs23; the rule is not retrospective. It will be in effect from 20 Feb 2025 if not challenged which is likely to be challenged.
@@programs23its not applicable till Feb 19, looks like you are not upto date.
It's in their constitution. It cannot be amended without a long process. Likely to take several years
@@nitinmahajan3017 supreme court has to decide that. Likkely it will be struck down but there is possibility it will be upheld aswell.
It took me 11 years to realize that Modi, once seen as a strong leader, appears spineless in resisting the rewadi culture that Kejriwal started and he eventually embraced.
Modi has brains, n u little educated have none.😂this class is 3 crore Indians, but 80 crore enjoy BPL rations. Jay shree Ram
@@Das1 Thats the problem. You milk the cow dry there is nothing left. Modi is doing same to middle class.
@@siddharth6505the problem is people mindset I have seen with my own eye people mainly votes on these things not on infrastructure ok so a politician only do or say what people wants
Or it's the demand from voters that BJP had to cater... while we are always sitting and complaining about politicians, Vishram so think about how people are looking at government services and what they are asking for
👍
Lack of option doesn't mean addiction, Shekharji! "Better option do, Vote le lo" is generally Indian voters agenda
No. Bhakts will always remain Bhakts. Bhakts will be the end of this country.
There is no lack of option you are just delusional keep voting and sew looting
@@DataCrusade1999true they just give excuse
@@DataCrusade1999modi Ji to hai mumkin hai
Don't underestimate the middle class.... lack of viable options....
Personally, I am losing my patience, with modi gov. This is just another left wing government.
🤯🤯🤯
Hindutva hate ideology with left economics
Deadly combo
@@sandipmore814 "hate ideology", Dude modi is the most pro muslim "right wing" leader in Indian history 😂.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@sandipmore814 Next level deadly 😢
Nirmala Seetharaman will be the downfall of Modi.
LOL, if you think she has any say on any tax policy, you are a fool.
It is RSS financial wing ,
People need a woman to blame😂😂 who appointed Nirmala??
Completely agree @@japanijoota6190
Not really middle class is fool and poors enjoy freebies so nothing will happen big ceo s gonna make youngsters work 20 hours for penny
If I was Rahul Gandhi
Immediately after the budget I would have announced that a lower income tax structures if my party comes to power and also abolishment of other draconian taxes. This would have surely migrated this class to congress
the opposition is so incompetent its actually sad
You clearly haven't seen the columns that Rahul Gandhi wrote he is advocating for lower income taxes and MSME encouragement.
@@reubennelson4086 It doesn't matter what Congress does you're a bhakt and you'll vote BJP no matter what happens.
If u see 24 lok Sabha bjp got max vote share from middle class higher than 19 lost lot of poor that's how vote came dowm
@@reubennelson4086 opposition is incompetent incumbent even worst middle class still delusional
Now the same staunch supporter of BJP constantly getting middle finger on taxation matters!
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Ya so vote out BJP for 1/2 issues and whatever progress we have made in the other areas, let that go into drain...
Frustrating thing, because of BJP-voting chutiyas, the rest of us who didn't vote for Modi also have to suffer!
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S
DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
Nah you get more as the middle class! You get the middle and rest 4 fingers as well 😂
Shame of India if there is only 1 person eligible to be pm in country of 1.4 billions people
And what are you doing?? Wasting time commenting in Social media..
@sankarasubramanian6774 you know that modi has Twitter. Right?
Shameless people cannot say SHAME ON INDIA ! Your kind had no problem one family ruling India for over 37 years
@@mohanmenon1300 read carefully and again what I wrote. Understand meaning of each and every word
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
First time i felt i should comment in a print video. What you spoke is 100 % correct. Middle-class is trapped and they have no choice.
Ure right but middle class have a choice, the choice to kick out this bjp govt
I read in some interview that no political party in India wants middle class to expand and become politically strong. Because this is the class that asks relevant and uncomfortable questions, that no leader of any political party wants to face. So it's in their own vested interest to keep this class weak and trapped.
@sunilkp
"First time i felt i [...] Middle-class is trapped and they have no choice."
===============================================
No, the middle class Hindu supporters of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co are *_NOT_* trapped by any circumstance that is beyond their control.
Rather, they CHOOSE to support Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co because:
1. such supporters have allowed themselves to get completely carried away by the bogus nationalism of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co;
and
2. the intense animosity that such supporters feel towards the (so-called) out-groups.
@@yevodee4024 KHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S
DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
@sunilkp81 totally agree.
It's becoming difficult to choose. Who is more worst?? Modi or Congress.
Both are slaughteres of middle class
Arnab Goswami should intern at print
Good one!😂
ARNAB IS NOT A ITALIAN MALAI DIHADI TO INTERN AT PRINT LIKE COUPTA
This is the best comment i read today
I just dream that one day the Gandhi family will step down and someone with talent and political acumen will head congress and present a strong alternative to BJP.
@mohanishchitnis7680 Gandhi family is anything but merit.
Gandhi's will not go anywhere anytime soon. Prianka's kids are lining up after her
That's your day dream.
Abe BJP mai kya nepotism nhi hai kya har waqt gandhi gandhi 😂😂😂
@@gauravdas6741 Konsa nepotism. Modi Bajpayee ke beta nehi hai. Congress ka har leader Gandhi hai. Rahul koi aur carrrer mei accha karta par usko bhi ismei ghusana tha sabko
Over 2.15 lakh Indians gave up their citizenship and moved abroad in 2023 alone and the number is growing. Seems like. People don't want to live in Amritkaal😢
It's Amitkaal actually
2.15 lakh is less than a drop in 140 crore. Have some bearing and common sense.
Yes, go ahead and call me names now.
2.15 L is nothing, these migrations are good for us.
Many are facing financial challenges, even if it's not necessarily about rice. India's middle-class pay income taxes, but don't have the same opportunities as some with more money, to relocation outside India.
Cost of living & vegetable prices have increased too much for ordinary people. The vegetable prices have increased by 63.04% & fruit prices by 13.55% in Oct 2024. Consumer Food Price Index was 11%. Consumer Price Index for Oct 2024 was 6.21% & for urban CPI is 6.68%. Household saving have been dropping.
The option is between Centre left (BJP) , left of centre left (Congress) and extreme left (AAP). In India only socialism works.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@kennymon4u lol, bro youre copy pasting so much ..... cope harder mulle
AAP Extreme Left LMAO 😂
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S
DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
KHANGRESS AND AAP ARE BOTH AMERICAN DEEP STATE PUPPETS
PAPPU WORKS FOR SOROS NETWORK
KHUJLI IS A FORD FOUNDATION DIHADI
If Congress replaced RaGa with someone competent, the middle class would vote for them.
People forget that the middle class voted for Manmohan Singh in 2009.
They also voted for Kejriwal in Delhi state elections.
Congrats! Congress has elected mallikarjun Kharge as party president
@@rajeev20230 Cosmetic change. The PM face matters in elections; No one cares about who the party president is.
@@rajeev20230 he is another puppet of gandhi family , most decisions and rallies are done by rahul gandhi only
I agree
@@rajeev20230 not that guy
When Congress and other non-BJP parties made even more ridiculous promises, Guptaji said we should not focus on that. 'NYAY' was very important apparently.
It is not addiction to Modi. The other options are even crazier. See what Congress has done in Karnataka and AAP has done in Delhi respectively. BJP does Jan Kalyan but is not crazy like Congress which wants to do a caste-based wealth census to redistribute wealth. Who will be the target of that? - The Middle Class. Especially those who have some excess in the form of a house and some farmland. The rich will find a way. And the result of all of this will be a complete destruction of whatever economy we have. So don't provoke us to make us feel dumb, ask why the other option is even more crazier!
If congress wanted to redistribute wealth and conduct caste based census, they would have done it in 70 years.
The reason other parties had taken measures of freebies is because BJP has taken away all the space for political parties to win. Entire mainstream media is a mouthpiece of one party, almost all democratic institutions are compromised. Corporate donation is going to one party only by either favouring some businessman or by using agencies against them. The investigation agencies are used to break parties and put important opposition leaders in jail unless they join BJP. And the biggest of all...Heavy polarisation of people on religious lines.
There is no space for any political party to breath.
Once you will take off the mask of bhakti and become a rational person, you will realise how unfair and dangerous it is. Till then you keep singing this song.
@@mathurhp Cool! I will keep singing and you will keep living in delusion. One important correction in the narrative people like you build time and again to save your precious RaGa- Corporate donation was significantly less for one party than it has commanded/wanted i.e. Congress. Everyone else including BJP got ample corporate donations. BJP led in donations even before the electoral bond saga and even during UPA. But again stating facts is Bhakti. So be it.
Who is this middle class ? Not even 10 % of the population. It's time we make policies that cater to the majority of the population
@@rajeev20230 your logic is dumb , the middle class run the economy through spending, they even rely less on government welfare , reducing debt and freebies
Spot on
I am not addicted to modi but afraid of Congress of their love for minorities and no focus.
Correct. Rahul is all about caste and religion. That's why he cannot beat Modi. A normal opposition w/ a positive message can beat Modi. But Rahul is very negative and is all about religion and caste. If you want to focus on religion and caste, then Modi is better because Rahul will turn the country into a minority-appeasement factory. At least Modi has a positive future vision. Rahul is a retrograde and backward-looking.
Modani 3.0 dissapointed everyone because he has allated more time to find fault with opposition than concentrate development. He doesn't want anyone advising him asif modani knows everything god. He captured godimedia social media print media moreover ec sc it Ed hc etc all are dancing to the tune
100% right
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
TBH, atleast the service class started hating modi, but issue is on the other hand RAGA seems even worse, free money to all, reservation, caste census for jitni abadi utna haq, and appeasement politics, what choice do we have?
India needs better options period.
You don't like the appeasement policy of the ruling party?
@ lol, hindus doesnt have any law which is above anyone’s else religion, we cant marry 5, we cant claim any property as we please, temples are the only worship place which pays taxes to govt, and this govt didnt change anything, how is this appeasement?
Warf board removal and UCC is required to make every religion same for the country, and frankly if congress didnt had appeasement politics, hindus wouldn’t have voted for BJP, people from one religion just got fedup being treated and 2nd class citizens hence the rise of BJP.
@@mohanishchitnis7680 ok, well i never said modi is good or worse, i just pointed out for the majority of the ppl Modi seems better than RAGA, there are alot of factor to it, better speaker, better politician, more vocal towards national issues and decisive governance.
Modi works for billionaires, might be true but so did the congress, if congress were so great at what they do , why we had such a uprising of BJP, also, i would worry about reservations, i dont want anybody who is good at what they do loose an opportunity because of some govt wants to create a bocus reservation, but again im not fully against reservation our history is complicated and there were people who were neglected or to rightly put treated worse because of their birth, but the reservation suppose to decrease with time not increase, if increasing reservation after 70yrs of independence is needed that itself means that reservation created more problem.
Also i would suggest you to go and search that 15lakh statement, he said ‘if we get all the black money back the amount if so huge that it will be equivalent to each indian getting 15lakh in their account’.
Also RAGA is not working like europe style welfare, Europe does not give freebies when the state is in crisis, they dont promise reservation and europe has less population than that of india with almost everyone contributing to direct taxes, they can afford to give freebies not us, just have more points when you make a statement, adding two different nation with very very very different challenge and trying to apply same principle will be disastrous.
Most important, dont mind ,but modi govt is bad, high taxes high inflation, zero benefits to middleclass, but opposition has to come with better statements, questions than caste ,census, appeasement and freebies, we deserve better opposition.
All the opposition do is walk out of session when they can raise so many good questions to the govt, they literally are not able to push the govt to the corner because they are so narrow interms of what issue they want to highlight, for example, RAGA opposed CAA NRC and now asking govt why bangladeshi are coming in india? How tf is this making sense? Instead of asking and suggesting what was wrong with farm laws they want to repealed entire law, but then go and ask what is the modi govt doing for farmers? Ridiculous.
The fact is that a part time politician cannot be the face of opposition if we want a better governance.
Sarthak you don't matter. Being in such a small minority as a middle class, I don't get why you'd think your vote even counts. We all know you'll vote bjp forever and so will the radicalised, jobless and unproductive rural heartland. Just sit down and vote for Modi instead of subtly blackmailing vishwaguru.
The Middle class is stuck between a Rock and a hard place
On one place BJP is continuing to disappoint and tax terror the middle class with 0 reform and more taxes.
On the other hand The Congress threatens to be even worse with Rahul Gandhi only finding caste wherever he goes. Has made Adani and Ambani ( The only constant investors) into a gaali.
Ambani and Adani don’t invest
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
An ego less fm will focus on simplifying gst, attracting fdi, creating good jobs, & reducing food inflation.
@@YankeeForever2001 they do in infrastructure
😮😂this class is 3 crore Indians, but 80 crore enjoy BPL rations. Jay shree Ram
In addition to the BPL class, the Sanatani class enjoying and feeling proud with the sadhu santh who are attending crowd, are non productive, not adding any contribution to the National GDP..It seems why Modi’s make in India programme is absolute failure.. the main reason..
Actually the progressive people who are educated enough and have upgraded skills, going out side india, working far away from their families and sending money in foreign currencies by way of remittances are the real savers of Indian pride.. with out them now we are nothing..
one find day will emerge, situation will worsen, and the game sanathani, samskari,
Hindu, muslin come to an end, people will be on hunt for food and survival..
This was over past and history.. will repeat again and again….
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@@kennymon4uKHANGRESS IS THE NO#1 ENEMY OF HINDU'S
DON'T FORGET TODAY KHANGRESS IS IN COURT'S AGAINST THE REPEAL OF WORSHIP ACT WHICH WANTS HINDU'S TO FORGET MUZLIM DESTRUCTION OF HINDU TEMPLE'S
@@ramohan158THAT'S WHY EVEN AFTER 60 YEAR'S OF PRODUCTIVE KHANGRESS RAJ THEY HAVE TO RUN THE SAME " GAREEBI HATAO " NAARA EVEN TODAY
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
12 lakh per annum to 5 crores per annum. Am i simply poor to think that anybody earning above 1 crore per annum is rich in India.
Started by RAGA/DMK/AAP, the situation is: no party in states can win without Dole offerings. No state party in power can be dislodged if they paid Dole 3 months before election. Dole will rule Indian political narrative for next 10-15 years. Adopt or Perish.
Started by AIADMK, a BJP Ally which helped Tamil Nadu in the long run
DMK IS IN POWER IN TN VIA 500RS/ QUARTER BY APPEASING CHURCH AND BHAI BIRYANI GROUP
FDI HAS ALREADY MOVED TO BJP STATES
GOPALAPURAM MAFIA DAY'S ARE NUMBERED
@@jaitrajoshi07 ADMK is not in NDA update yourself
Middle class is angry that opposition is stuck with a leader who can’t lead and concentrate unless it’s Ambani-adani
This is not a national interest. This is the worst form of targeting. If freebies are such a menace, why Khatakhat in is not even mentioned in this and why only BJP? Shame to see such acts being presented as national interest.
Well bjp has started the circus and others have no choice but play along.
Friend Shekhar Gupta was heavily funded by Congress ..in his earlier days ..so u can never expect good word for BJP in his channel other day he was talking about net FDI is less though it is the biggest in history of India ..just one way or other he does this u can see the pattern
So can't anyone criticize the govt ? I am heavily critical of nirmala and soft modi even though I hate all other parties 10 times over. Whats wrong with people ?
The problem is u see everything through BJP's hindutva glasses and see everything wrong except this corrupt worst party called BJP.. this party will plunge this beautiful country into darkness one day
LoP will focus on simplifying gst, attracting fdi, creating good jobs, & reducing food inflation?
For indian middle class, it's a matter of being safe (modi) than sorry (RaGa). They aren't addicted to Modi.
Yes, now govt is going to put safety tax.
Welcome to fantasy world
*_MATURITY IS WHEN U UNDERSTAND A SELF PROCLAIMED NON BIOLOGICAL IS BEHIND ALL OF THESE MESS NOT NIRMALA_*
The problem is that middle class has no choices - any alternate to Modi is terribly horrifically worse. Middle class does not have resources to leave India and if it does not vote Modi but abstains, catastrophic alternatives will grab power.
I dont think its addiction, middle class has no other choice. That's the problem.
👍
Only BJ party IT cell people use name of RaGa to scare Indian voters and make them vote for modu
Middle class is brain washed
Because they can read..
Watch fancy news and all propoganda
This no choice business is a fraud people like to play on themselves.....
@@mohanishchitnis7680 Mouth the choice ! The Maa Aur Beta who collect funds from the Chinese for their private trusts ?
This guy also shifted his interest becoming a godi from 2018 and like a perfect opportunist he is switching side to save his image
Journalism is all about that . When you see something is not working out you call out in front of people.
These are the reasons why Modi doesn’t do real interviews or no press conferences, his image, his mirage of growth will shatter to pieces
Until farm reforms, labour reforms, easier land acquisition and more urbanization has to be urgently done. Congress has been anti all these. And BJP has lost it's spine to do these.
The number of millionaires leaving seems to be a small percentage of total number of millionaires. Is the net number of millionaires growing each year?
Grt question....
The real elephant in the room is the abysmally low-income taxpayer base in India (less than 4%). Far too many people evade taxes in India. Corporates get tax cuts, business owners rarely ever pay income tax, poor (and many self-declared 'poor') get everything for free and some sectors like agriculture are completely exempted from Taxes. This puts the entire load of fulfilling the wishes of billion plus population on SALARIED middle class who has no escape from this vicious cycle.
I have read many comments on this newspiece and your crisp and insightful arguments on this article certainly stand out. Very few people like you have demonstrated your stand with the actual ground realities and that is what makes your comments noteworthy. I really liked reading it.
Should vote out MOdi and BJP and then prepare ourselves for NYAY and "JITNI AABADI UTNA HAQ" where Congress and INDI Alliance would be giving Rs 72000 per family every year and making people almost impossible to get a job and education by reserving all the seats for specific communities :D :D
Are we stupid?
Finally Aap is there for the Middle Class! It raised the actual issues!
Ho gaya punjab bankrupt. Dilli bhi ho jayega.😂😂
@@Aditav8680 Delhi witnessed a revenue deficit in 31 years!
Aap bc delhi ko kabadi bna kr rkha h smjha be aap sirf free and Muslim votes ke karn jit rha h uske alawa koi vote nhi deta aap ko kisi aur chij ke liye
Ghanta...
😂😂
You are completely mistaken sir; it is not Modi. This is due to the opposition leader Rahul Gandhi, who lacks trust.
Yeah keep electing Modi & the BJP again and again. Economic Salvation 100% guaranteed. Good Luck.
@@nobufrancis685 What is the alternative ? :)
You seem to know who to trust....in that case stick to trusting the same person and expect a difference. This is the 3rd term of this govt....do you need more time for an alternative or a change. I suppose for you time is a luxury. You must be a rich guy who is doing well. Good luck to you.
@@nobufrancis685 Bad is better than worst. change should be from bad to good not bad to worst. We need person like Manmohan Singh but we don't have one now.
@@kiranreddy1258when he was alive all he got was criticism
And now see
India govt needs to reduce income tax.. Only then there will be a huge boom
Try moving to US or UK
@sankarasubramanian6774 for what?
The taxes saved will only go to expensive education, not consumption. The better option is keep the taxes the same for middle class, tax the corporates more and then drive growth through more infrastructure spending. In addition, double the tarrifs for Chinese imports to improve manufacturing.
Lol forget about reducing income tax, they need to milk the middle class to compensate for the reduced corporate tax......
@@ashboy7968Well this government believes in reducing corporate tax heavily.......
Yes middle class is not getting benefited , but there is infrastructure super boom , no appeasement , no corruption in freebies distribution, no terror blasts, emotive issues like Ram mandir n 370 which looked impossible are done and forget about a face , you have a Pappu in front supported by piddis
How are you you benefitting from all this. Even if your salary is 1cr per year, it is only 125,000 USD per year. Lower middle class by world standards. More 70% of our middle class is less than poverty line of the US
Journalism has become a medium of transmitting what the BJP IT cell hands out. You can be a Clerk and still become a journalist in Godi Media.
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Boring comment...irritating..plse upgrade yourself
U mean 'clerk'.....😂😂😂
Cope harder. Punjabi landlord.
@ u got it right
Shekhar Gupta had been eagerly waiting for this moment for the last 10+ years ..
An excuse to put Modi down.
There are always ups amd downs in an economy which doesnt have its own natural resources and RnD. Modi is investing in RnD but it takes decades to see the results.
U have physically grown Shelhar ji but you need to really grow up!
Chal be apne baap modi ko defend karne aa gaya waah😂
@Kattar_rationalist_atharva Hagne aya hai ya koi reasoning hai tera?
@JoyP09 chal be woh to dekh liya apne baap modi ko kaise hag ke defend kar raha dekh liya tunne 🤣🤣
@JoyP09 aise bengali tunne ko seriously nahi lete ham 🤣
As alternative is wealth redistribution, much more freebies, higher inflation, scams, much more dynasty, appeasement, poor infrastructure etc. Middle class think what they have now is good
Shekar ji, there are 2 reasons for this. 1. There is enormous amount of testosterone driven nationalism in middle class (as you pointed in one of your ctc episodes), 2. There is no better alternative to bjp and middle class is well aware that the Congress is overwhelmingly socialist in its instincts, things would be much worse if it comes back to power.
Middle class is benefitted by ease of living focus, infra growth and lower income tax rates compared to past
We as a society needs to create Education, Health care , unemployment , woman safety, R&D facilities, Manufacturing, Basic level schooling as political issue. Any party will perform better if we change our prospective and tell them that they will only get votes if they solve above mentioned issues or else we giving it to local party. I think India needs a youth leader who will represent the working class and their struggle. Modi failed ,RaGa failed. If we dont have alternative we need to create one now.
We are attached to Hindu Sanskruti and Modi is part of the same.
What on earth has modi done for hindus? He is just the same as congress. Left wing socialist appeasement guy. Just slightly more focus on national security, infrastructure and development than congress.
Nirmala Amma is outdated for the youth. Her eyes and ears closed in arrogance and egoism. The middle class pays 60% total taxes to various governments. But they have to pay NH Toll again for the NH but with their money. She threw into the dustbin a reference from Mohan Bhagat ji & Nitin Gadkari ji , to accept HC judgments in the Bank pensioners' case. She has been exploiting a weakness of the judicial system by taking adjournments in the appeal she filed against bank pensioners in SC. She locks EXCESS TDS REFUND SERVER for 15 months. For example, a TDS deducted in April 2025 is retained and a refund claim is not allowed till July 2026 . The server is locked from April 2025 to July 2026. Then refund will be without any interest. EQUALITY= when a tax payer delays tax payments, she imposes fine and charge interest
Middle class is not addicted nor it is blind but the opposition seems to be even a worse bet
I don't think you see the depth of the pit we're in, if you think the opposition is worse.
@gokuldastvm and I don't think you understand the pit we will be in if this opposition cocktail comes to power . But let's agree to not to understand each other
This will change only when BJP supporters starts questioning their vishwaguru 😢
Modi has become the monster, he was fighting against.
no, he pretended to fight agnst
Very well said ❤❤
Homeschooling is best.
What option do we have rather than PM Modi?😂😂😂
1. Rahul Gandhi is all about the Khatakhat scheme, reservation and old pension scheme.
2. At least development projects have picked up a little speed and actually started getting completed.
3. DBT has changed the entire corruption game, deserving people are actually getting the benefits. Even middle class has received massive relief through PMAY. I myself know 4-5 people who have received 2 lakhs of PMAY.
4. BTW which government has given tax relief to the middle class? As per my opinion nobody has.
Let's say what option we have to BJP, not PM Modi. He has had his time! The middle class is irrelevant. It gets exactly what it deserves.
Dr Singh
Problem is that opposition is not even raising the middle class concern and getting involved in jitni abadi utna hak and 75-100% reservation 😅
All hail supreme leader....
1) Ache din aayenge
2) Vishwaguru banen ge
3) China ko Harayenge
4) Lekin school aur hospital nahi banayenge.
5) Corruption nahi hatayenge.
6) Ambani aur Adani ko amir banayenge.
Hindutva and TINA factor work for Modi. Coupled with money power and RSS man power.ED, CBI and Income tax helps to remain Modi in Power.
No man school and hospital are definitely being made as i myself are working on it.
I live in the east so I will talk about that area
1)Wb 11 hospital projects ongoing 6 new coming up 4 new colleges added and multiple schools have been added.
2) Orissa 15 new hospital added 7 under the planning process.
7 new colleges added multiple school have been built.
3) bihar and jharkhand 9 new hospital projects ongoing 4 new colleges project multiple school projects.
5) The north east 19 hospital project is ongoing.
Infra is going good right now but the problem is quality check and corruption on every level. I know a government Contractor who has multiple cases against him still getting more contracts he mostly built bridges in bihar and now he is building a new building for the income tax directorate.
You can easily bribe the executive engineer of the government it's only 2% of the total cost of construction.
@@sandeepnerurkar4918 evm ko bhul gaye
China ko haraya Galwan mein. Pangong se China retreated in 2021.
@@rajx7120 ohh phir toh jo 38000 sq. Km pe jo kabza karke baitha hai vo bhi vapas kar dega na ?
You can remain addicted to Rahul Gandhi - Congress Party who will slow down the India growth further.
Middle class votes for Modi since the other national alternative - CONG is way worse with kooky pseudo-communist ideas about redistribution, economy & reservations (saying this as an OBC) whereas regional parties except TDP, DMK have no focus on driving economic growth.
This is Mr.SG being too clever by half as usual. He correctly identifies the middle class being frustrated with Modi but attributes it solely to anti-muslim stuff (which is a minor factor, but not primary) rather than looking at what other parties are offering as alternatives to the same middle class, because if he does so his conclusion & story will fall apart.
If you assume the voter is right & knows his/her self interest - why not assume the same for the middle class? They know modi hasn't done much for them & are taxed too much. More likely they are afraid of what the other parties will do if they come to power!
Anti muslim is minor factor.... Lol
That is only factor
Batenge to katenge...
Andbhbkt agaya😂
As a middle class person who believes in meritocracy, I cannot get myself to rage RAGA seriously.
The middle class stayed loyal to Modi because there was no alternative at the central level. Inflation and corruption charges during the 2009-2014 period have made Congress the least likely party to vote at the central level for the middle class.
Those who remove congress on corruption and inflation charges now voting modi for religion(unfounded religion threat) putting aside their earlier concerns...
Does not matter what Congress is - Congress is bad, BJP is bad, RSS is bad. We need to look for checks and balances, in differences in opinion within the ruling alliance. Vote for BJP, not Modi.
👍
those charged with corruption in congress period have now joined bjp
adarsh scammer and coal scamer charged before 2014 now in bjp
An new fm may focus on simplifying gst, attracting fdi, creating good jobs, & reducing food inflation.
Dear Respected Shekhar Saheb , Over The Years you’ve mastered the art of Factual StoryTelling , This was a great episode with craft fully Slamming a Hard Shot yet Softly worded for both The Political shots and Public .
Wah ….. Kya Baat ! Jai Ho !!
Keep Up The Good Work
So Shekhar, what is the solution…. Immediate, short term and long term? Freebies and subsidies have to stop
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Most of Middle class won’t come under income tax, they need small business and employment opportunities. Government doing good in this by encouraging with online businesses and PLI schemes for manufacturing jobs. Also serving sector growing and health sector creating lots of job with 70+ years free healthcare care. My suggestion to government is consider them for health insurance also with minimum fees like 5 lacks coverage per family with 1k to 2k per year. This is beneficial for middle class families and government can improve healthcare services.
Superb work. Keep people educating with facts. 🙏
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
50 % income going to direct and indirect taxes.rest 50% goes into necessary and non avoidable recurring expenses.even people have to take loans for necessary things like education, medical and housing.Uncontrolled, unchecked and unregulated sectors. Govt purposefully doesn't do anything abt them and sems totally helpless as its a deep nexus of govt , banks and businessmen ruining these institutions.
When they say there is no one other than Modi I laugh and laugh loudly. When Indian middle class have forgiven Modi after that disasterous demonetisation and Modi's first term economic debacles, many like me have given up.
Indian middle class read Hindus have blinded themselves with cultural revivalism and Hindutva. Absolute stupidity.
China and other nations are getting richer while Indian per capita GDP is moving at a snail's pace.
The ones who have economic and intellectual capital like me have moved out of India and many will continue to move out.
What's the alternative?? Rahul Gandhi and his alliance?? 😂😂😂😂😂
When asked to choose between bad vs little less bad, the less bad is chosen
Bhai india me kabse chunav presidential way me hone lage just vote the person in your assembly who is more educated doesn't matter whuch party he comes from even it's a nirdaliya. Just send educated people in parliament not gunda mawali.
You're a Modi bhakt even if the world's best candidate contests the election you'll vote BJP so move on you bhakt.
@@vijaysontyal2788you're addicted to modi 's free burnol,
Sala addicted to modi 's free burnol
looting south gst to give 15KCRORE to INCOMPETANT NITISHKUMAR who caused 12 train accident in 2 weaks shows how incompetant you are
The MAIN reasons-perhaps the ONLY reasons-that most of the middle class Hindus in the Hindi-Hindu-Hindutva parts of India support Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co is that:
1. such supporters have got completely carried away by the bogus nationalism of Modi-Shah-Bisht & Co,
and
2. the intense animosity that such supporters feel towards 'others'.
50 years of Congress and 10 years of UPA/Indi gang addiction has ended for the right reason. Infrastructure boom has just started under middle class favourite PM Modi.
It costed us eight times than actul cast alot of it is in pvt hands but created 2.5L crore public dept😅
North Indian favourite
250 LACK CRORE world debt🤣
not 10 years, it is 16 years now.
@@killeridea1685 hahaha chaprasi ka exam clear nahi hoga bhangi quota mai yeh sab se
Middle class is being strangled by excessive taxes-sky-high income tax, GST on everything from basics to essentials, and zero relief. The backbone of the economy is being broken, while policymakers turn a blind eye.
गोदी मीडिया लगातार चीनी अर्थव्यवस्था के पतन की बात हो रही हैं। उसने 2024 में चीन के 992 बिलियन डॉलर के व्यापार सरप्लस के बारे में कुछ नहीं कहा। वह भारतीय अर्थव्यवस्था के पतन, बेरोजगारी, गरीबी और भारतीय रुपये के पतन के बारे में कभी बात नहीं करती है।
According to the Commenters The Man with a fake degree and the master mind of demonetization is the only "option" for India. Rest are pappus. These people should stop watching state sponsored propaganda for once .
Stop your propaganda that modi has fake degree. Supreme court has already slapped guys like you in the face for mksleading people about modi. Stop doing personal attacks and rather criticize modi on its policy based on data not whataboutery.
“ dil hai ki manta nahi “ was a super analogy 😅 …
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Evm bhi nahi manti
@ jeet jaana toh maan liya aur haar jaana tab nahi maana … ajeeb samasya
@@tapemaj samasya he toh hai, jo opposition mai isse koste thae aaj sar aakho par rakhte hai
Please support Modi
Stalled reforms? We have our wonderful opposition to blame for that.
Farm Laws would have been a shot in the arm for all farmers and had done away with corruption and cartelization in APMC mandis but all they want is prices like a fixed salary and even pensions after all years of tax free income.
Hit and Run which was applicable for all but opposed for political gains and threatened to withdraw by chakka jaam.
Judicial reforms. Collegium system would have been done away with but removed by courts and opposed by opposition.
Electoral bonds to remove cash donations to political parties but again opposed by opposition.
Its like Congress wants to keep the system unchanged because it is on this corrupt and stagnant system that they survive.
In a democracy like india where even a person with half knowledge behaves like an expert, reforms can only be brought when we have no options left like 1992 or else these 'experts' will oppose anything and everything and people can be easily swayed.
Opposition will always oppose things. BJP opposed Indo US nuclear deal, Aadhar card, GST, MNREGA, RTI, computerization of government offices and many other things.
The reason Modi took back farm laws was not the opposition otherwise 370, CAA, Triple Talaq, GST and many other bills would have been scrapped too.
The reason of taking back farm law bill was inevitable fall in western UP in upcoming assembly elections.
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization did you see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which files burnt.
Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india.
DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it.
Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization we didnt see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which files burnt.
Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india.
DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it.
Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
Excellent rebuttal to the propagandist.
@@mathurhp bjp never opposed rti, they opposed gst because of destination state getting all tax, MNREGA because there was no DBT and all money was given to contractors and not actual people also they were not doing any useful work, if they opposed computerization we didnt see any huge protests like farm laws and hit and run?? Then what stopped Congress from doing digitization? It was congress itself because there would be trace of all govt transactions. Plus remember central secretariate offices catching fire after 2014 results and files burning?? No one will know which of their neumerous scam files were burnt.
Farm laws were taken back because khalistanis were easily creating soft spot for themselves in punjab again by helping so called farmers from outside india.
DFC was announced during early UPA2 but had 0 progress in 5 yrs because of road transport lobby this does not mean UPA gets credit for it.
Announcing things does not give anyone credit, it is implementing them properly
1 dollar = 86 rupees (non biological value; maximum contribution in fall 35% of any PM of India)
BUT UNDER YOUR SECULAR KHANGRESS REGIME COUNTRY WENT BANKRUPT 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I am surprised to note that middle class are those who earn 12 lacs to 2 crore per year. What is their percentage?
You are right to point it out. Its not even 10% and half of whom dont even go out to vote.
@@ks20234if you are earning less than 12 lacs per annum , in current day and age you are poor .
I’m willing to venture they aren’t even 5%
Probably more like 1-2%
1 to 2 percent
As someone from middle class I can’t express in words how much this video resonate with me. At this point I don’t even know what to do when my tax money is being thrown around like this.
problem is not with middle class ( majorly hindu hardworking taxpayers across states ) - problem is that opposition failed to give any alternative to economic issues - opposition more interested to devide hindus on caste, regional lines and trying always to appease the 2nd largest community of india ie muslims & reaping benefits of a pan islamic consolidated vote-bank, unless the 2nd largest community ie muslims identify themselves first as an indian ,their regional identity next and then their religion last, nothing gona change in this country...... its good that modi govt still says sabka saath sabka biswas inspite of getting zero muslim votes, consider a scenario if they stop this goodwill gesture then its oneway
Once again, great take.....
To add salt to injury:- most bureaucrats are middle class, and they are the instruments of this neo politics of vote bank monetization. In the role of "sarkari babu" they are cooking their own entrails themselves and supporting it too
Who are middle class shekhar? Only 3 crore people actually pay income tax. And for sure job is an issue, and what growth have stalled? Only one quarter with low growth that too in the election quarter. But our economic model is screwed to begin with all the socialist toxicity. Also, what better option is there ? We well vote for caste census and wealth survey? R we crazy?
3 crore average family size in india is 5-6 . that is 15-18 crore people
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
@kennymon4u we have much much much better governance than any anti national secular scoundrel parties cld give. BJP is hundred times better than congress. Its the rascal socialist enablers like you and ur breed who destroyed yhe country for 60 years. Our grouse with the BJP is its too much soft on oppositions and commie babus. We didnt vote them to be democratic, we voted them to make radical changes and break the institutions to remold a new India. Our expectations are high, but we also know the practical constraints of running a complex country like India. BJP is doing fine, but we expect them to do better, we dont have any expectation from the opposition, they are just marxist-mullah coalition.
Yes! These are the kind of concerns that one expects journalism to voice, especially when opposition parties are busy doing identity dramas rather than elevating such concerns and views of the public!
I still believe Modi is a messenger of God sent during a time of chaos. Yes, Sitaraman and Finance Ministry should go easy on individual taxation.
Not all middle class. Those who are fools are influenced by Modi.
Every Indians want to leave , it was not the case in congress govt . Congress was corrupt but it has not hurt the normal people like the way BJP did . High taxation has hurt everybody and people have become poor and what people have got in return ? Time for this govt to go . Delhi people pleas slap bjp with huge defeat
Haha..in your dreams.
Congress has not hurt people??😂😂
Abey jha 2 congress has ruled this country for 60yrs. Everything we see wrong with this country be it corruption, sarkari work culture, indefinate delays in projects, 0 civic sense, lawlessness etc. is all given by congress in virasat.😂
Kuch bhi, mention the taxes which got increased compared to the taxes from UPA term
Mujhe lagta hai bjp ne hindu muslim kar kar ke baki cheezo pe dhyan hi nahi diya lekin ek baat unhe dhyan rakhna hoga kisi bhi cheez ki seema hoti hai agar har baar wohi cheez karoge na to log aap se believe karna chod denge
Bjp hindu muslim ke karn nhi jit rhi bjp opposition chutiya h isliye jit rhi h sabko pta h bjp e problem but kya kre opposition aur bda chutiya h
Who? Anyone who delivers, doesn't hurt growth, doesn't cull freedoms. Someone politically viable. And it will happen, people have always wondered "If not he/she, who?" Voters will themselves come up with an answer if other leaders try hard enough.
It is not love for Modi but alternative Congress led coalition is worst in revadi culture plus their well known hatred towards wealth creators.
Absolutely correct Shekhar ji, as usual! 🙏
Could you please consider presenting the demographic statistics based on household income?
Next question would be - how many households enjoy unethical pecuniary benefits?
Very truly spoken 👍. Vikshit Bharat is going nowhere.
Vikshit Bharat is taking Shit in the loo
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
Govt is trying to become richer than the citizens looting taxes from them. Cars longer than 4 meters have 42% gst. How would automobile industry grow like this?
I am a BJP voter. But here's how congress can get my vote: 1. Support farm bill and land acquisition bill 2. Stop jitni aabadi utna haq nonsense. Promise you will never even think of it. 3. Chart out a plan for next 20 years in getting India out of reservations and creating system of meritocracy. 4. Promise to remove tax gundaism.
Abe chal na tu bra man hai isliye tujhe fark nahi padta 😂
You So Very Eruditely and Eloquently SPEWED VENOM So True to Your Left Leaning DNA
Slogan for bhakts-> Bhakti mein shakti hai.
Slogan of GhadeeLovrz Halala mei Shakti hai...
Because Media like you were not doing journalism, but encouraging and enabling Modi’s & BJP lies, jumlas, hatred, corruption and loot. You never told the truth or showed the mirror; you always sided with Modi and tried to silence others by making excuses or trying to show a false narrative of others opposing Modi
The slogan is "Bhakti hi shakti hai" from Hero TV show for kids.
😂😂😂
Abdul spotted opinion rejected
"what is the alternative?" -bang on
Despite tax dadagiri and the financial squeeze, the middle class has seen improvements in their quality of life in the last 10 years. Fewer scams and better economic development are well appreciated by them. They don't 'love' Modi, much less Ms Sitharaman. They don't have an alternative.
Wait wait whom to vote for if not Modi? Rahul Gandhi? Why it's assumed hate for Muslims by middle class is causing them to vote for Modi, before 2014 Indians were secular and now they Hindutavadis, give middle class good option and not some part time politician
Troll BS
It's not about Modi. The oppositions are equally or rather worse in tax brutality. There is no 1 state ruling party which has said no to freebies. There is no 1 state which has showcased as a role model.
RaGa is real threat to middle class, economy in general, and country as well.
elaborate
Modi is implementor and not new idea generator like Neharu, Narasimha Rao and Vajpeyee…
India has now completed the implementation backlog and now its time to move to idea generation. Unfortunately middle class is not seeing anyone worthy of idea generation so they have no option but to stick with Modi…
Unfortunate for India… This is looking like 1980’s India…
I don't think middle class is addicted to modi. They just lack better options.
Modi is more of a " andho m kana raja".
He is far better than others.
Whenever there are options people choose them. Delhi is a classic example of this, even during the so called " modi lahar". RaGa will have to think out of the box to gain support.
Haryana bpl rate case was a very big shocker for me and when I researched more about this, then I found that bpl numbers increased recently(2022-24) by ~60% in 5 major districts. After all this bjp voting percentage gain in HR election is beyond my understanding.😮