ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 มิ.ย. 2024
- From July 1, India will have a whole new set of criminal laws. The Indian Penal Code, Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Evidence Act will be replaced by three new laws drafted and passed by the previous Union government. The Wire's Jahnavi Sen speaks to senior advocate in the Supreme Court Sanjay Hegde and The Wire's national affairs editor Sangeeta Barooah Pisharoty about concerns that have been raised about this overhaul of the criminal justice system - from the chaos that we are likely to witness to what it means for civil liberties. The three also discuss the raging entrance exam scam in the country and what this means both politically and for students' futures, and Arvind Kejriwal's bail - granted by the trial court and stayed by the Delhi high court on Tuesday.
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
To declare emergency is constitutional but without declared emergency, applying the acts like emergency is unconstitutional.
How many rules have been imposed by executive order without discussed in parliament is mind boggling. The last 10y is inferior than emergency than people discarded in 1977 vote like bjp is tought for same kind of torture by trimming its seats own.
Being a Lawer for more than 23 years, i am very unsettled with the new Laws for the same reasons as enumerated in this discussion; beside that i am unnerved because of lack of any upgradation of the whole system before enforcing the new Laws & lack of any thorough analysis. I am also shocked rather depressed for not finding any voices in the legal fraternity for or against this critical milestone in our legal system. @sanjayHegde
Can the opposition not do anything ?
It's like demonetisation & will have long lasting negative effects on our countries judicial system & humanity
Not only Judiciary but almost every independent constitutional agencies like EC, ED, CBI, IT, etc have saffronised by Sangh Parivaar to implement Manusmriti by the centenary year of RAJYADROHI Sangh Parivaar. But, people realised the threat of the antinationals and start reacting appropriately to save constitution and democracy.
@@simonvarghese8673Emergency, Supporter.😊
Sanjay Hegde sir is an absolute gem of a person. Very clear, intelligent, and precise. Looking forward for more of his conversations.
THIS IS WHY IT IS SAID THAT JUSTTICE DELAYED ISS JUSTICE DENIED !
We are always with neutral and intellectual media and Wire.❤😂🎉.
Lelo 2 rs. 😂
Modi Sarkar still continues, the same ministers, the same mind set of authoritarianism.
chai jayegi ro pit k besti kara ke, 1 saal mei
How valid and legal is the stay on the bail judgement and that too after the presiding judge at the lower court made stern observations and gave good dressing down to investigative agencies.
A professional course entering exam scandal is required SIT since 2000????? Is it true for the skilled student????
Hamare Loktantrik Desh Bharat mein Loktantrik Moolyon ki Raksha Honee Chahiye.---- AJAM, Buxar, Bihar.
The Wire the The honest and unbiased media platform ❤
This is a strong message to our country. You 140 crore cannot do anything to change me. I am king, the almighty and will do as per my fancies and you have to accept.
Insightful analysis
An accused person cannot be anyhow kept in police custody more than 15 days, I personally think, 15 days is too much if not established crime , in many cases that can be reduced by considering different circumstances
Definitely, i think It is time for the Supreme must look into this and these laws must be kept abeyance
good point
Democracy gone, education gone,food security gone ---
What about you ? Gone ?
If C. M of Delhi and other big shots can be held behind bars, no trails delayed tactics, ordinary citizens position is very compromised, their dignity as human being is facing the heat.. 😢😢😢😢
Happy to see that there us no abusing, name calling or bullying in comment section for shedding their understanding and keeping their opinion.
Sixty days of police custody is shocking.
90 days
And the power that will lie with the police n we know how this power is often abused and misused.
Lovely talk. THIS IS DEMOCRACY.
These presentation is very much educative informative and may even educate Policymakers who initiated this misadventures to:
Rename them into Hindi terms which is unfamiliar to the entire 2/3 of India except Hindi Belt. Law enforcement agencies are not familiar to enforce these 3 New laws in 1st July 2024, which may create a Chaos confusion in Criminal justice system in India. Hope good counsel prevail upon all those involved in this matter .
This is with reference to Adv Sanjay Hegde's reference to Pathalgadi movement, we should refer to the courage of the adivasis there and to Stan Swami who constantly was writing and talking about it and one of the 'real' reasons for his arrest and the subsequent custodial 'death'.
Police and system should be accountable if accused is not convicted should be included
Police ko to hata do, koi use nhi inka
If during emergency Indira Gandhi had access to the new criminal laws including PMLA and UAPA enacted by BJP then she could HAVE ARRESTED all BJP leaders and put them in jail and they would have remained there till today without bail. Thats the difference between declared and undeclared emergency.
Firstly, Thanks for the topic raised and extend the thanks to honourables guest.
Secondly, Should have included retired commissioner of Police of any state as well.
would love to see from Police vs Judges view as well.
regards,
Modi in 2014 said "yeh committee vamitee sabh bandh", to speed up Good Governance as it was seen to hamper implementations. 2019 committee s introduced thru the back door to duck allegations. Come 2024, committee's formed and introduced from the front door to camouflage bad governance. A failed decade of chaos and confusion in governance.
Constitution is a limitation on power 🎉🎉
It should be stayed ! It will surely cause chaos and confusion. Don't know what lawyers are doing. Definitely scared !
We are in the time of digital age, why still justice time delayed for 50 instead reducing it to 20 days sir? Are the new law makers aware of the constitutioal freedom and rights or party political influence.
Thanks for spreading awareness on this controversial topic. The need is to bypass courts and laws. All powers will be with police. It would be very easy to take action against any citizen. This is mission of RSS.😢
Can you please do a piece / interview on how the laws wef 1/7 will impact the common citizen. There was talk of some broadcast laws where freedom of speech will be impacted, for voices of dissent, you tubers, citizens etc. If we write our views as posts on social media can there be consequences n repercussions and if yes , what can they be. As a citizen what shud I be aware/ cautious or careful about , esp visavis freedom of speech and expression.
All laws r meant for comman persons not for vvips vip. Leaderd politicians. Rich man 👍
Chaos 😢
Next non communal government should restore the law!
No one question in 10 years.now question arised.hindi belt subidhayaon the now gujrati harrap liya.
Don't know what is happening.will happen and who is acceptable ??
Another example of executive overreach executed through the judiciary
Why President madam agreed?
Very true we will not find any good doctors. We will not have MDs . Just get the degrees n do nothing but get married to a rich girl for dowry. India was known for best doctors will go down.
Actually @modigovernment should start auction for medical administration that would stop all paper leaks and coping & all similar things
पैसे लाओ और सर्टिफिकेट पाओ,😁😁😁
Just similar to
पहले आओ पहले पाओ 😁😁😁
@16:55......once you acknowledge that it's an *"unfair exam"*
Modi Ji would like be - ये exam unfair नहीं हुए हैं जी, उलटा हमने तो exam में पिछडने वालोंको आगे बढ़ने का मौका दिया हैं, जैसे पहले सरकारे पिछड़ी जातियों के छात्रों को आरक्षण देती थी, हमारे सरकार ने छात्रों को डायरेक्ट मार्क दे दिये, उसमे कुछ गलत बात नहीं है। क्या exam में कम मार्क लाने वाले छात्र को जीवन में आगे बढ़ने का हक नहीं है?
I m like - वाह मोदि जी वाह 😁😁😁😁
India is being changed with two major goals in mind. Change constitution and all laws to make the country a Hindu state based on patriarchy and feudal practices. Pave the way for a fascist government in Delhi run by auotocrats and take away all powers from regions and states. These forces are studying various models like Russia and North Korea. Gradually elections will be discontinued and the next generation of autocrats will arrive. After this PM there will be ten more even more aggressive ones waiting to take over.
😢😢😢
It's scary to imagine sharia in saffron.
No use discussing these issues. Politician rule the nation. 😊✅💯🇳🇪🤣🤣🤣
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻🌿🌿
Hukumat emna tarfen ma kaeink aavi sake uchit ..nyayitvo karti nasamji itni ki bagdor vale vagh kisi ke samne pinjare se khulla me rakh dete fir ...kehte is me ham tum kya sakte dhundho..sab ..meter of sab jyudishry se aage ek nai histry likhne me dam kham jalva kayem ho is tarah ka ek khel voters v avam ya rsachhi rajnitik baate cum aur ..ghunch bhelshel .kehna ka portal .me shortal kar diya samaj lo sab ham hukumat himayet vaale hei. .Noor hajarat samay pe baki aate aate . Khastahal desh v .praja to...koi hei sach bol de yaha se itna .bhag ya pura ka pura ..nakafi .sirf pention apna amiri jagiri ke liye hi aur vasta kya ho sakta ..!!? Har saal pathayei v abhyashkram digriya deto ho ..sarlikaran sundartam sach kidhar hei...!!?
Making of India into a Police State.
aaj Tamilnadu me 60 log mr gye jab vidhansabha me Vipach k MP me un mare hue logo ki awaj uthai to unko bahar nikal diya gya lekin kisi jhoote Besaram reporter ne iski bat nhi ki kyu savidhan kaha gya
education modi ka department na tha na hai....
Jahnvi please learn how to pronounce Hegde.. Indians should know how to pronounce Indian names
Mujhe bhi bula lo kabhi panel mei, bakchodi mujhe bhi aati hai, tum sarkari naukri walo ko hi bulate ho
The Wire, Modi abusers channel .😊
bhaad mei jao, gum ho jao, tumre dimag khokla hai, danav ho
Millions of viewers don't want to watch modijis godhi media
Frivolous excuses.
What is the point of discussing with idiots in the opposition whose only objective is to delay, delay, delay. Their leader RaGa cannot even utter three coherent sentences.