Tools you DON'T need: Jointer vs Planer vs Drum sander
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 พ.ย. 2020
- Do you need all three milling machines? Just two? One? None? This video will tell you what and why.
When you use this link to visit our sponsor, you support us►
Fisch Forstner Bits: amzn.to/2tvzbJg
Fisch Drill Bits: amzn.to/2BHJLl4
(We may get a small commission if you use one of the above affiliate links.)
Subscribe (free) to Stumpy Nubs Woodworking Journal e-Magazine► www.stumpynubs.com/subscribe.html
Follow us on social media►
Instagram: / stumpynubs
Twitter: / stumpynubs
Facebook: / stumpy-nubs-woodworkin... - แนวปฏิบัติและการใช้ชีวิต
I love how you jump straight into the content, instead of spending minutes talking about sponsors, smashing the subscribe button, Patreon, or whatever's been going on in your life since your last video. It's so refreshing that I subscribed even though I'm not really planning on doing any woodworking any time soon.
The first 2 minutes of this video perfectly describes my experience woodworking so far
Same hahaha I just got into woodworking and when he started describing the scenarios, I was wondering how he knows me so well!!
Same 😂😂
yes yes, same with me. I am new to woodworking. I have to look up and watch videos about everything. This is an excellent channel. I find him easy tlo understand. I just got a table saw and was confused about jointers and planers.
Came here to say the same! lol
@@adamwpatterson i may be a month late but, as James said, get the thickness planer first. Learn how it works on a piece of wood because it may not produce the desired outcome through no fault of its design. Before buying a jointer, look into "walking sticks". I believe stumpy has another great video on those.
Am I the only one who appreciates hand planing and natural imperfections of wood?
You just perfectly describe the last 2 years of my life. Nice job.
THE LOOSE SHIRT CONTROVERSY: There's a clip in this video where the jointer is being operated with a loose shirt tail. This is dangerous. The shop assistant was reprimanded for it and the footage was re-shot because safety is a top priority in my shop and on this channel. Somehow that one clip slipped past editing. It is not a practice I condone. But everyone makes mistakes. So please cut the kid a break.
Yeah, armchair critics all. Nobody can say they've never cut a corner through absent-mindedness or haste - we all know that's not true. That's why everyone - and I mean EVERYONE - needs a safety tune-up on a regular basis. I've flagged your safety vids, and I try to review them every 3-4 months. I STILL managed to trigger my SawStop brake by touching the blade to my metal miter gauge through a moment's carelessness.
The kid will be OK - I firmly believe we learn through our errors, and we fail to learn when we don't make any mistakes. Nil illegitimi carborundum.
@@steveelves3499 Nil illegitimi carborundum Is that a new brand of sandpaper?
I've never liked long sleeve shirts. ok, not in the last 40 years. They were too long, too short or too tight. I used to work on cars and long sleeves really got in the way. Now that I am a woodworker I see where long sleeves can be very dangerous. Guys and girls, don't hurry, step back and think and you'll be safe.
I've made my share of bonehead mistakes using my shop tools.... I was just surprised to see that footage made it into the final video and as someone else said I cringed when I saw the loose shirt so close to the spinning cutting head...
@@Ofageover50 "... the footage was re-shot because safety is a top priority in my shop and on this channel. Somehow that one clip slipped past editing...."
Thanks for making this video. I started out in woodworking just a couple of years ago, and this video would have saved me lots of worries back then.
Luckily, I found a wonderful deal from a local fellow woodworker who had just upgraded his own planer and jointer and was selling the ones he had been using for about $400 together. I locked up my shop and jumped in the truck. When I got there we talked about the projects we were working on, some of the projects we were proud of and exchanged some compliments on pictures of our builds. I told him I was still working primarily with pine and was venturing into harder woods by cleaning up pallet boards. He asked me, "what could you have learned from working in pine?" My reply was simply, "The importance of a very sharp chisel and how to sharpen it."
We laughed and he asked if I had my chisels with me and I did. He said that if my chisels were sharper than his, he'd give me a hundred dollars off the sale price. His chisels were not dull, but mine cut through the end grain of a pine board without crushing fibers and left a near glass clear surface.
Anyway, I made a new friend and got a $300 jointer/planer combo that has helped me advance my ability to make projects faster. I am reminded of that story every time I use them to mill boards for a project.
Thats a badass story!
I think you should be Dr. Stumpy Nubs - A Master Woodworking Professor. Please, keep up the inspiring work!!!!
I finally got my first planer after 2 years of garage sale hunting. Hoping to get a jointer this weekend
This guy deserves more than a like and a cold one, he realy take time and effort to go into true details so everyone could understand it clear as water. He is one of my favorites woodworking channels👍
I quite agree. Things are clearly explained without any hype.
Don’t Change y’all are awesome 😎
Thank you
+1
I agree. He is very detailed and I have come to trust his opinion on any subject concerning woodworking.
WOW...Thank You!
I'm a union carpenter in the film industry. Most of my 30 years in construction were spent doing home improvements, framing, and finish carpentery. Hardwood shop work is still new to me. I REALLY thank you for this video. There's Always more to learn.
Wow. I never understood the difference in these machines. I'm 5 minutes you educated me. Thanks!
Such a clear explanation. Not a wasted word, yet you got everything that was needed in. Brilliant.
Ditto! James has a way of not wasting words, yet being clear and concise. Love it!
I can’t stop being amazed by the quality of your presentations. I wish presidential speeches were at this level.
I read your comment before watching the video and found the comment a bit over the top. Any crack head is more articulate than Trump. And it doesn't take all that much to beat Biden... but after watching this video, you are absolutely right! I watched the whole video. He didn't even once use a pet word (aah, mmmm, etc). He was.informative and engaging the whole time... he really is a great speaker.
As a budding machinist that knows nothing about the art of woodworking, metal is all I know. Thanks to your channel, I've learned a whole lot in just a few days. I love your content, man!
I am in the exact same position compadre. Give me calibrated milling machine or lathe, and I’ll make her sing. I obviously knew wood would be a different beast, but I figured cutting is cutting, and I understand those mechanics really well. Boy was I wrong.
So quick and direct. I definitely wasn't using my tools together right thanks.
Stumpy nubs is a funny name for a woodworking channel
I have nothing to say really, but I appreciate your content, and wish to help with the yt-algorithms.
Agreed, I'll also help out :-)
@Marius Hegli
What are yt-algorithms?!
@@adelkeryakos2641 TH-cam algorithms. If more people like and comment a video, more people will be shown the video in their feed.
@@mariushegli exactly
Look Ma, engagement!
you have a great talent for explaining things succinctly without any fluff. thank you for the great content, Stumpy
Perfect timing for me and, as always, an excellent explanation. Thank you James for your advice on which tool, and in which sequence of purchase. Your views will help me advance beyond the sometime less than satisfactory results i get trying to use a router sled, track saw and a Rotex as a poor man’s planer and jointer. Sincerely, Another Satisfied Subscriber.
I felt like you were describing my possible future! Haha. Thanks for saving me from confusion and frustration!
Stumpy, you're the best at explaining the reasons for using and purchasing tools and equipment
Knowledgeable and concise, thank you.
a Jointer, Planer and Tablesaw walk into a bar... a great video!
Really enjoy how you structure your videos. Its captivating, meticulous, yet brief, and informative!
I've just started shopping around for these tools, so it is great to get a breakdown of how and when to use them. I have fairly limited room in my shop, so it looks like a benchtop thickness planer and a bit of creativity to get those perfect boards. Thanks for your excellent videos!
I really enjoy watching your videos. I’m pleased to say that finally after nearly two years as a hobbyist, I actually knew most of this. But I like to watch anyway, in case I missed something. You are one of a very select few TH-cam people I actually respect. Your videos are always concise and no nonsense. Thanks again for helping me get to where I am today.
Love your organized back drop!
another great video. took a class at wood craft where I had the privilege of using, jointer, planer and drum sander to process rough sawn lumber from the lumber yard . we brought it from 1" to 3/4 to make a cabinet. thanks to my instructor who introduced us to lumber yards in Houston I no longer by sanded plywood at $84 a sheet but $34 each . i also get s4s wood from them while I am there which makes the process in the garage on a weekend even easier .I can measure, cut and assemble. I agree though a planer is a good start , I am Looking in to getting one.
Sometimes I’m reluctant to sit through the whole video but you have a great but serious sense of humor you make worth my while. Thanks for shedding light on the drum sander I’m getting one.
This is a beautifully simple explanation, thank you.
I’ve been watching your vids for about a year and missed this one. Good info as usual, thanks! Had to laugh at the insulated coffee cup inside the Redwings koosie!
Great video! I just getting past the new wood worker phase and I would love to see more tool comparison/recommendation videos like this.
Your videos are so helpful, thanks very much!
Like and subscribed! this is by FAR the simplest and most comprehensive breakdown of the difference between a jointer and a planer. Keep these coming
I really appreciate these explanation videos. Thank you for continuing to put out such great content.
Thank you for that explanation Stumpy! I am setting up my new woodshop and trying to make this exact decision. Your explanation was very straight forward and helpful!
I stumbled over your channel last week, and I love your videos. I think you are a master communicator - you explain things very clearly (when most others are confusing and off target). Thank you so much - you’ve helped me tons in my (very novice) woodworking journey!!!
So far, your preparation and clarity are the best I've found online in my new interest in woodworking.
Great video and tips. Love how you have your workshop clearly laid out as well.
You're the man! NO ONE explains it all better than you! Thank you for every video! 🙏🏼😎🛠
This is an 8 minute conversation someone should have had with me when I was 12. This is why so many entry level machines bounce around the used market all the time. Awesome idea for a video, and it was well explained. Thank you!
Exactly the video I needed right now! Thanks so much!
I'm commenting because I appreciate both the info and the Wings coozy.
Also worth mentioning that board edges can be straightened using a guide board on a table saw. We used to do this in cabinet shops with especially long boards. Run the board next to a straight board of the same length with the concave side towards the guide board and saw fence. The guide board will need a block at the back end to eliminate slippage.
That's the method I use for edges. I can't afford a jointer or a planer right now. I can both flatten and thickness-plane boards and panels or slabs with a homemade router sled.using steel guide rails, roller bearing blocks, and other parts bought online for less than $200. You just need a router of sufficient power (2.5 hp or greater), a spoiler board bit, and a flat, level, and sturdy workbench to mount the rails on. With a good sharp bit and properly flat and level workbench top, this leaves your workpiece not just flat, but so smooth it rarely needs even much finish-sanding.
Finally someone made sense of this! Brilliant video!!
My co-workers don't realize how absolutely immensely lucky we are to have a pair of 52" wide-belts, one set up with a single drum and 150hp for abrasive planing, it can sand off a quarter in per pass; And then a newer triple head machine dialed in just right to take 40 grit finished surfaces to 150 grit in one pass. We mill and dry our own hardwood slabs which we then sell and also make custom furniture and commercial fixtures with, and my boss loves him some industrial auctions, which is the only way a smaller operation like ours can have 2 wide-belts hahaha. Your video just helped drive home once again how lucky I am to have access to it and that my boss is fine with me using it for personal projects whenever I'd like!
Great video! As others have said, this is exactly how I feel right now. Extra points for the Red Wings coozie 👍
Watching this just made me realize how much I want a jointer...
Always great info that's easy to understand and retain. Thanks, James!
Great discussion James, thanks for sharing it.
I really wish I could give 13 thumbs up, weekend warriors need more videos like this!
A lot of people on here probably can't even offer two.
I got super lucky buying my jointer. The store had it on sale 50% off and it happened to be during a week when the in store sale on all items was a % off depending on the price at checkout. So I was able to get another 10% off that price. Picked up a 6" jointer for $225.
Stumpy keeps it real and to the point. Perfect for beginners getting into the hobby/trade.
Really like this video. Plane and simple, nothing disjointed. Hope this video drums up many views for you!
Thank you for the quality information. It's great to see good honest knowledge being passed on to the next generation.
Some people have so much pride that they won't teach. Keep up the good work! I am thinking of purchasing your book.
I am new to this, but I love the work I've done.
I really can't begin to express how much I love your videos!! Everything is so methodically laid out and clearly stated. Thanks to you and the people you work with to make this content!
My dad was a general contractor and tho he taught me the basics he didn't get into the details of why things were used. I feel like I'm learning everything all over again and it's fantastic!
Great video; answered all my questions! Thanks.
I like the clear and concise, and easy to understand delivery of the information. Thank you
Thank you for this video. I am exactly your target audience for this type of material. Please continue to add content on this level to your catalog.
Which is also the reason I just subscribed.
Just wanted to say thanks for making such quality videos for free. You answer questions I don't think of to ask, and your delivery and editing is so easy to digest. Really appreciate you taking the time to share your expertise to us novices.
*Also concur, with additional mention that at my level, can't afford too much & without this info, will never get there, either!
Thank you for this wonderful demonstration and explanation of these tools. A lot has been cleared up for me.
Great video - you always have the best informative advice.
Stumpy Nubs giving it to me straight. Now, just convince my wife I need these things.
Buy them first, and your wife may suggest building a workshop for you, because she doesn't want all that stuff (and sawdust!) in the house.
3 options
1 look at all the money WE will save if I make....
2 look at how much more money WE could make...
3 change the locks and don't give her a key.
easier to ask "forgiveness" than "permission"
recently at Carbatec, my local woodworking machinery store, a guy bought a new tool and his wife who saw the amount of the purchase, phoned him up while he was still in the store telling him that he wasn't buying it or else!!
@@fparker9949 First rule of the married man. (Just celebrated 50 years....)
And ... that's why I subscribe! Great info, thank you ;)
Thank you, very much, for the great information; very clearly explained. It's always helpful to learn from others!
Good video, short and straight to the point. Very informative.
Yes a video on how to use the planer to flatten boards would be great! Thank you for another great video.
What I do with boards too big for my jointer: I attach them to a piece of MDF with some expanding foam (use the minimally expanding stuff for doors and windows). Now the board is supported with the bottom face dead flat. Make light cuts so you don't deform the board (the foam only offers so much support). Then you can easily remove the board from the MDF and simply plane the other side. Most of the stock I buy these days is flat enough that this isn't even remotely necessary, but I had a bunch of 2" thick air dried maple that was very badly warped, but otherwise too nice to turn into firewood.
Spot on advice! I started with a drum sander, wish I had invested in a thicknesser first.. Now have all three machines and the scope of timbers I can now use has expanded immensly. Some real gems can be found rough sawn for half the price of pre dressed timber.
Thanks very much for the straight forward advice that just makes perfect sense. Blessed New Year to you all.
This video deserve a ton more views and this channel a ton more subscribers. Thank you for the very well laid out information!!!
for weekend warriors, a benchtop jointer is fairly reasonably priced. it won't handle large stock at all, but properly tuned it will handle a lot of the stock a typical hobbyist will be using. I think I got my planer and jointer (both benchtop models) for less than $300.
Great presentation and thanks for your time. Although I've got all those tools I usually jump from the jointer to the band saw if the stock isn't over 8" and then the drum sander. But I'm old and never been formally trained in the proper techniques of wood working. I just grew up on a farm where if you needed something you figured out how to make it yourself. The golden rule in my family was "If you didn't make it, you don't really own it". So now I'm a new subscriber. Even at 76 I have a few things to learn to better my work.
I've watched a LOT of videos on this subject. This was by far the best.
Thanks Stump! Your videos are so thorough and informative that I actually watch it from start to finish. Most other channels I just skip to the part I'm trying to figure out
My Hammer A3 Jointer-planer combination in one machine: best purchase I've made in a long time.
Do you have the helical cutter block? If so, how do you find it in terms of finish and how loud it is? Noise can be a real problem with thicknessers. I don't have one at home for that reason, but if a helical head made noise acceptable it could swing it. Even at the Menz Shed I attend I try to use the thickensser before other people arrive because of how loud it is, but we do plan to get a spiral cutter head for it.
I have the same machine with a retrofitted helical cutter head. Hammer wouldn’t sell me their head. They assume every body is stupid and can’t retrofit it. What a difference it made. Timber comes out almost glass smooth. It is a bit quieter and it doesn’t whine like the straight blade cutter. The noise factor all relevant but overall it is quieter
@@TrevorDennis100 It does have a helical cutter but I didn't install it myself. It came pre-installed by the dealer. Unfortunately I can't compare it to the straight blades on the same machine, but it's a whole lot quieter than my previous Dewalt.
Happy with my DeWalt planer; I made an easily adjustable sled that does a fair job at jointing. Wish I had a real jointer but I can't quite justify the expense (nor the space) for one, and the combination machines didn't seem all that good, and they are not very portable. Weirdly, the DeWalt 735 planer that everyone on YT seems to have is very hard to find in Europe. They sell the 733 model here (which I have). In the US, the situation seems to be reversed.
By the way, the Dutch word for planer is "vandiktebank", which means "thicknessing bench" and it reflects its actual purpose. (oh, the "van" part at the start of the word definitely sounds as odd to Dutch people as it may to English speakers). Often our names for tools are weird, like the word for spoke shave: "spookschaaf". Yes, we just took the English word and wrote it in a Dutch way, the word literally means "ghost shave". This makes it hard to find stuff in stores sometimes, if I only know the English word for a tool and not the Dutch one. Sorry, but I'm rambling...
Thanks for that interesting bit of linguistics :)
I like Craigslist for tools in retirement communities.
The older combo machines are solid, mine is 65 years but it's the opposite of portable, it weighs 400kg...
I took 4 years of German in high school, and went to Europe after graduating. One stop we made was in Amsterdam, and I was utterly amazed to find that I could read Dutch! We went to a bunch of museums, and because I spoke both English and German, I could read all the plaques and signs with only a little more effort than reading German. It was wild, it was like Dutch was a combination of English and German. I had a harder time understanding speech, since I wasn't familiar with the accents or pronunciation. It was awesome though! Plus I just really loved the Netherlands. A gorgeous country with incredibly friendly and welcoming people. Can't wait to go back!
@@evanbarnes9984 I second everything you say about the hospitality of the Dutch and their gorgeous country. I, too, can't wait to go back.
Regarding the similarity between the two languages, there must be some reason that what we call "German" is called "Deutsch" in Germany??
Lastly, a great read is "Maritime Supremacy" by Peter Padfield which relates how the spirit of the Dutch inculcated the British in ways that developed the American spirit of independence. I found it history that read like a novel.
Cheers!
This is exactly the information I needed at this early stage of woodworking. Thanks.
Thank you for this information. I've been stuck between which tool to add to my arsenal next.🤙🏼
I bought a combination planer/thicknesser machine as my first toe to dip in this water several years ago, and it has been really great but it was a big learning curve to use, and using the planer (jointer for my US friends) is a bit intimidating when you start out, particularly if the machine doesn't have an "auto-return" style blade guard.
I've been thinking about an end grain cutting board for my first proper woodworking project and was considering a planar for it. I had no idea that they explode like that. Great video, very informative!
I have made hundreds of endgrain cutting boards using a thickness plainer. Three things that allow it to be done. 1. I round edges with a 1/4 round over bit. 2. My plainer has a helical blade. 3. Moisten the board(this step is not usually necessary). Take very very small passes.
Great video. My Dewalt 735X arrived last week and I'm loving it. My shop is only 12' x 16", so I have to plan carefully what I purchase next. Thanks for the reasoning why each piece of equipment should be considered and those I can probably do without. I know I won't have room for the drum sander anyway. New subscriber looking forward to more content.
This was incredibly helpful. Thank you!
Thank you for the advice. I have been contemplating purchasing these items but due to limited space I would only be able to get one. You have helped me narrow my choices down.
I have a planer and a portable table saw and my working space is 6 feet by 8 feet :) Good luck, the tool is worth it!
Chris could you not mount a planer on one side of a flip top work bench and a jointer on the other? Should be about the same amount of space required.
Add close captions if you can. That way people can watch your vids with their phone on silent, while their kids are making them watch Paw Patrol
It is possible for users to edit video CC if a channel allows it. But it does not seem that Stumpy does allow that. Also the way he talks seems to be detected as Portugese by the CC auto generate.
This is EXACTLY what I needed to hear! Straight forward answers to my questions about this! Thank you!
Really excellent video. Greatly appreciate you taking the time to impart this very helpful information.
I am new to "wood Working" your videos have help me a lot, thank you for your videos.
Very good video. Unfortunately, whenever you see someone say do I need this tool or that tool, if you are at all serious, you'll find you need both. I might add that if you are doing rough wood and making panels, you really need a bandsaw to resaw into thinner stock that can then be glued to make a wide panel (also good for thinner drawer sides).
interesting thought process. personally i would be lost without my jointer. as once, i have two reference surfaces i can use a table saw or hand plane to finish the job. but in saying that as a retired professional maker i have the full set. i would have found it very hard to make money in hand dimensioning lumber.
Thanks for this video. Easier to understand and knowing the limitations of each piece of equipment.
James, great video, and thorough explanation. Thank you for everything you do.
Ok, what would be a reasonable price for buying a thickness planer and a jointer? I'm a weekend woodworker.
Stumpy Nubs: "if you tried feeding an end grain board through a thickness planer and had it explode on you, you know how sketchy it can be"
me: ::laughs in Lie-Nielsen No 7::
On a more serious note - thank you for the advice and the continuous stream of knowledge - I'm learning A LOT from you
I made an endgrain walnut butchers block board and like a moron I ran it through my planer....
BANG!
Then I did it again slightly less thick just to make sure would do the same thing....
BANG!
Now I use thickness planer to mill down only and use a proper hand plane for that kind of work.
I learned a lot watching this. Subscribed.
This guy is fantastic. All of his videos are so well done, and informative. How can anyone not like this guy?
You just explained my whole woodwork history to a “T”.
In the UK Planer Thicknesser's are very common, for you Americans that's a Planer and Jointer combination machine. It just makes sense
Best description/use of the 3 tools I've seen yet!!
As always, excellent advice. Thank you
The person running the board through the Jointer at 4:58 needs to tuck that shirt in to take it off....
Yeah, that made me twinge
@tyvek05 So, to you, it's a lack of common sense that you shouldn't wear any loose clothing around spinning machinery....
Yes, he was reprimanded for that. And the footage was supposed to be tossed, as well. I suppose that clip sunk by.
Both un-tucked And hanging loose. 😲
@@StumpyNubs A 2x to the back of the head?