Believe me, Giles & Co will already have a whole team demixing all the available 4 Track masters into separated multi-tracks, ready for Rubber Soul & Help... right back to Please Please Me. Giles may not get round to remixing those albums for the while to come, but he'll have them ready to work from when the time comes.
To Giles & Sam - I'm 68 and I love what your doing with the contemporary mixes... and the AI de-mix is so good at isolating that it opens all kind of doors for the earlier albums. Rubber Soul next, please.
Bless Giles Martin and the work he’s doing. It’s like listening to the Beatles for the first time. I remember being floored by the Sgt Pepper 50th anniversary. Genius.
@@p0llenp0ny Yeah I personally think someone else could've done a better job. The drums on 'Here Comes The Sun' sound like they have more distortion on them than the vinyl . I wish he'd cut out the fancy plugs and just stick the tracks up rawer.
The credit goes normally to Paul 's bass playing, George's musical guitar solos, their superb vocals and their songwriting, but John's rhythm guitar and Ringo 's drums are vastly underrated. Ringo on Revolver is probably at his best ever.
He is the most under-rated drummer in pop music history. In my opinion, his work with The Beatles is nothing short of Brilliant. Let's face it, they weren't "The Beatles" until Ringo joined. 😎👍🏾♥️🎶🎼
The drums in the remixes are so much clearer, whereas before they were muddy and tended to get lost behind the other instruments. I have a new appreciation for how perfect his fills were. He's not flashy or blowing you away with his virtuosity, but he's always adding just the perfect amount.
The de-mix technology is amazing. All the available de-mixer software offerings I have tried so far will produce something which is maybe just about good enough for karaoke, but what Giles has here is light years better,: really professional level. Are they ever going to turn this into a product? I would pay good money for it!
The wierd part is that this guy is using a computer from almost 20 years ago, (judging by the mouse and the keyboard) so I'm curious how old this clip is?
@@BeauregardHall He's probably just got an old computer that's capable of running a DAW well enough; why replace it? It's not necessarily the computer that was used to de-mix the song.
I'd imagine part of what makes this tech work so well is specific training on that material. Access to hours of tape tracks of the actual instruments and voices as they sounded in those records. If they were to use it on another band, it would need to be re trained.
This technology is amazing. Able to dissect one mono track into several individual tracks? What? If I understand correctly Giles and someone else invented some computer program to do said task for the live touring years documentary. Bravo 👏
such a real ART to the engineering - technical side of the group, that had it not been so well done the first time, who knows what we would have been listening to all these years thank God for George Martin (then) & Giles Martin (now)
Giles Martin is a genius to what his father left and now he continues his father's greatest work! I'm glad to see that there not messing the songs up just making them better and keeping the history in the recordings! What he's done was bring out the instruments so that you can really here how good the Beatle's really were and still are today!
@@GRHKTjaP you get paid to promote this act or are you in it or what? Every post of yours promotes this. Why? You bring this up out of the blue over and over.
As a technical guy I love this, as a musician and Beatles fan, this is becoming a "Han shot first" situation. Soon it'll be so convoluted with all these remasters/re-mixes done over the last 30 years, to ever get the original mixes to listen to as they were intended.
thats what hes trying to fix. Hes trying to find how they originally “should” have sounded as the mono mixes were the only ones the beatles wanted. No one in 20 years is going to be like “hey i really wanted to listen to that version of taxman where the drums and guitar are in the right speaker and vocals left”
What I think would be cool is if Giles produced the sons of the Beatles. Wish they'd all get together and do a one off, even a charity album. I don't expect them to sound like the Beatles but what you'd get are elements of them and that would be pretty darn cool.
Guitar isolated sounded fine up until 1:33 where it didn't sound as clear for some reason (maybe due to the cymbal crash?). Remix still sounds great though and can't wait to see where this technology takes us next.
Yes, it will never be possible to isolate everything perfectly, you will end up with some artifacts, very common when 2 or more instruments play at the same time.
Dear God.... Love Me Do, PS I Love You, She Loves You.... they could all be in immersive 5.1???????!!!!!! We've never even had those in stereo before. Woooow.
I seriously hope this technology goes beyond Revolver. They can go back and do the entire catalog and I'll be happy! I think he should take on the Star Club recordings.
when you listen to George alone it sounds like She's a Woman. All these parts alone sound like nothing special and then they come together and it's just an explosion of perfection
If that could be done to "She loves you", it would be the first stereo mix of the song ever. All their early records could be remixed that way so that stereo is not vocals to the right music to the left.
I believe it could have but the tracks were either lost, mixed together or recorded over, making it not possible. At that stage in their careers nobody probably realised that there'd still be that much interest in them sixty odd years later.
@@pleasepermitmetospeakohgre1504 I believe Paul is referring to the fact that the beatles revolver tracks were demixed using machine learning, so you don't need the original tracks. There might be some issue with the fact its mono and not stereo, but they could probably grab the instruments from the german version of "she loves you", which is in stereo.
So, could a respectable job of this sort be done with "She Loves You" (exists only in mono)? or for that matter the 2-track stereo songs on the first two albums?
So we'll have Rubber Soul, then goes backwards to Please Please Me, then Star Club tapes, Cavern Club tapes, home demos and rehearsals for official releases?
Precisely. That's the very same de-mixing technology that was made for Peter Jackson's Get Back, so that they could isolate voices & instruments, drums & bass, guitar & vocals, even Paul & John or George or Ringo.
@@juan.orduz.musico that being said, time for Giles to consider, Love Me Do, PS I Love You, She Loves You and I'll Get You giving them a stereo re mix OFFICIALLY
There is something I don't quite understand. As Giles Martin said, Texman's drums, rhythm guitar, and bass were all recorded on one track, so how can their sounds be clearly separated?
It sounds like George does the count off on this recording Giles is playing. But who actually counts it off on the album? I've googled this in the past and there seems to be no "consensus". I always thought it was John, because that weird slow deep count matches his sense of humor.
Two count ins. First is Paul apparently doing the comedy voice ( I always believed it to be John too)and George in the background doing the real one.Though to me it sounds like Ringo. Drummers usually do count ins.Most frustrating .
@@scottandrewbrass I searched here on TH-cam, and found this video from a few weeks ago that agrees it was Paul doing the "main" count, and supplies good evidence to support that. Sometimes I forget that Paul has a "comedic" side to him. th-cam.com/video/QuNm58x9eMc/w-d-xo.html
@@jrussellcase Yeah thanks for that Russell. Commented on there a few weeks back. It's all fascinating stuff isn't it? But the real question that's always puzzled me is who did the voice on Revolution#9.
AI, and machine learning technology. It essentially "learns" what each instrument sounds like, and is able to (pretty clearly) remove them. That way, each of the instruments can be separately placed in the mix rather than all 3 being stuck together.
I didn't like the new remix of Tomorrow Never Knows, the seagulls like sound and other sound effects that I love appear to be lower, more buried in the new mix. I still prefer the original, those sound effects sound louder and in your face.
This is the one track I was a bit disappointed about. THE COWBELL!! You guys should have used the cowbell as is it heard in the MONO mix of Taxman. The stereo mix got it wrong in 1966 and it still sounds wrong to me in the new remix.
We need a full documentary series with Giles doing this on all their albums !!!! PLEASE MAKE IT HAPPEN!
Yeah! That would be someting👏👏
@@Mr.Petlover Absolutely - a great idea - that would be amazing
Not just all the albums, but Magical Mystery Tour & Past Masters as well. 🎸🎸🥁🎸
There were mini documentaries on the makings of all their albums that came with the 2009 remasters.
If only the multitracks of all of their songs were available... 😍
It will be soon. The technology already exists.
Believe me, Giles & Co will already have a whole team demixing all the available 4 Track masters into separated multi-tracks, ready for Rubber Soul & Help... right back to Please Please Me. Giles may not get round to remixing those albums for the while to come, but he'll have them ready to work from when the time comes.
@@stereofidelic67 Yes, they will re-release and remix this material in any and every form they can, until the world ends.
Some are
@Adventures.
And that's a bad thing how?!
Best band EVER!!! ❤️❤️
Besides The Shaggs of course...
@@sandervdbrink84 What about The Rutles? 😉
@@goldtown6747 brilliant band. A possible Nr 3?
There were much better bands 230,000 years ago
To Giles & Sam - I'm 68 and I love what your doing with the contemporary mixes... and the AI de-mix is so good at isolating that it opens all kind of doors for the earlier albums. Rubber Soul next, please.
This time next year I reckon Cindy.
@@scottandrewbrass Me too👍
Bless Giles Martin and the work he’s doing. It’s like listening to the Beatles for the first time. I remember being floored by the Sgt Pepper 50th anniversary. Genius.
The Sgt. Pepper 50th is a boomy, overcompressed mess. I hope he redoes it one day.
@@p0llenp0ny Yeah I personally think someone else could've done a better job.
The drums on 'Here Comes The Sun' sound like they have more distortion on them than the vinyl .
I wish he'd cut out the fancy plugs and just stick the tracks up rawer.
@@p0llenp0ny The compression and EQ sound fab to me
Come together - legendary song
Any Beatles songs is legendary in it's own way...
@@sandervdbrink84 Any song in general is legendary in its own way...
@@IsaacWale2004 good one, cannot deny that!
Insane how tight Ringo's playing is...and people just shrug him off!
Not me - I think he’s awesome!
The credit goes normally to Paul 's bass playing, George's musical guitar solos, their superb vocals and their songwriting, but John's rhythm guitar and Ringo 's drums are vastly underrated. Ringo on Revolver is probably at his best ever.
Ignorants; that's what they are.
He is the most under-rated drummer in pop music history. In my opinion, his work with The Beatles is nothing short of Brilliant. Let's face it, they weren't "The Beatles" until Ringo joined. 😎👍🏾♥️🎶🎼
The drums in the remixes are so much clearer, whereas before they were muddy and tended to get lost behind the other instruments. I have a new appreciation for how perfect his fills were. He's not flashy or blowing you away with his virtuosity, but he's always adding just the perfect amount.
This demixing technology is absolutely stunning. Maybe we can team up and use it to finally solve some of the lingering Beatle mysteries… 😎 🎧
I so loved this song....
Very fascinating, I would love a Disney+ series on mini movies like these for the Beatles!😃👍☮️❤️
this is incredible mixing technology and i can’t wait to see what they’re capable of when it comes time to do the two track and mono only songs
he has the most fun job in the world !
Love from India ♥️♥️
i never realised how in depth and great this backing track was. you're doing Gods work, Giles
The de-mix technology is amazing. All the available de-mixer software offerings I have tried so far will produce something which is maybe just about good enough for karaoke, but what Giles has here is light years better,: really professional level. Are they ever going to turn this into a product? I would pay good money for it!
Apple Music Sing has been rolled out to machine-learn how to demix, I suspect. Within a decade, comparable technology will be baked into iOS.
The wierd part is that this guy is using a computer from almost 20 years ago, (judging by the mouse and the keyboard) so I'm curious how old this clip is?
@@BeauregardHallThe clip was recorded last year
@@BeauregardHall He's probably just got an old computer that's capable of running a DAW well enough; why replace it? It's not necessarily the computer that was used to de-mix the song.
I'd imagine part of what makes this tech work so well is specific training on that material. Access to hours of tape tracks of the actual instruments and voices as they sounded in those records. If they were to use it on another band, it would need to be re trained.
Thank you Giles
This technology is amazing. Able to dissect one mono track into several individual tracks? What? If I understand correctly Giles and someone else invented some computer program to do said task for the live touring years documentary. Bravo 👏
such a real ART to the engineering - technical side of the group,
that had it not been so well done the first time,
who knows what we would have been listening to all these years
thank God for George Martin (then) & Giles Martin (now)
All wonderful videos of the music and then the vocals!
Giles Martin is a genius to what his father left and now he continues his father's greatest work! I'm glad to see that there not messing the songs up just making them better and keeping the history in the recordings! What he's done was bring out the instruments so that you can really here how good the Beatle's really were and still are today!
GILES YOU'RE VERY MUCH LIKE YOU'RE GREAT FATHER SIR GEORGE, YOU BOTH PUT YOU'RE HEART AND SOUL INTO MUSIC, ESPECIALLY THE BEATLES Yeh,Yeh, Yeh,
The Beatles Forever is greatest moments of history.
This is awesome.
Great job, Giles! This new release sounds fantastic. I just can’t get enough of it.
The remaster is just insane !
Remix, in this case.
Remix. Where have you been?
It's a full remixed version
not a remaster at all, it's a remix
Don't care at all just enjoy it folks
Giles is doing such important work
@@GRHKTjaP you get paid to promote this act or are you in it or what? Every post of yours promotes this. Why? You bring this up out of the blue over and over.
Just… INCREDIBLE that we can do this now! I’ve been wanting this for years. What a time to be alive.
Noting the Károly Zsolnai-Fehér reference
Like father, like son: genius.
At the end of the day their music is fabulous 👏
🔥I very like that one of the best band in the world - Beatles!! Beatles - forever!!🙌
Genius !!!
Brilliant
Bravo! Bravíssimo!!! 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
As a technical guy I love this, as a musician and Beatles fan, this is becoming a "Han shot first" situation. Soon it'll be so convoluted with all these remasters/re-mixes done over the last 30 years, to ever get the original mixes to listen to as they were intended.
thats what hes trying to fix. Hes trying to find how they originally “should” have sounded as the mono mixes were the only ones the beatles wanted. No one in 20 years is going to be like “hey i really wanted to listen to that version of taxman where the drums and guitar are in the right speaker and vocals left”
This is sooooo beautifullllllll
Magic
if i had this technology, I'd never leave my room
Great making from you. Lg from Germany, Beatles Fan Ellen ✌ ❤
WE WANT ALL BEATLES ALBUM
One gets to hear how each member approached their individual parts. Interesting to hear the different tonalities. Then the whole bigger than the parts
Thank you for the information.
Very Fab Indeed 🏆
Amazing
Would love to see Giles go over the multitracks for the rest of the songs off Revolver
Revolver is the greatest pop album
Pop no is Rock jajaja
*Greatest Rock album
Greatest album.
Rock not pop
Guys rock was pop back then
What I think would be cool is if Giles produced the sons of the Beatles. Wish they'd all get together and do a one off, even a charity album. I don't expect them to sound like the Beatles but what you'd get are elements of them and that would be pretty darn cool.
@wierdDO the Beatles still sell every time a new compilation comes out or remasters like this. Strangely, they are still relevant.
This is so cool!
He should release the multitracks to the public so we can mess around with them...
lol fat chance.
Wow cool
Truly amazing. Technology can be a great thing!
Guitar isolated sounded fine up until 1:33 where it didn't sound as clear for some reason (maybe due to the cymbal crash?). Remix still sounds great though and can't wait to see where this technology takes us next.
Yes, it will never be possible to isolate everything perfectly, you will end up with some artifacts, very common when 2 or more instruments play at the same time.
Epicoo
Imagine being able to isolate all the Beatles's tracks like that.
I've been dreaming of it since I was a kid.
There are tools already available to try now - Moises AI - it's obviously not as high quality as Revolver Remixes, but it gets most of the way there
More of this type of video please. Long format perhaps?
Esto es muy interesante súper asombro
💜💜💜
Hello,how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
Dear God.... Love Me Do, PS I Love You, She Loves You.... they could all be in immersive 5.1???????!!!!!! We've never even had those in stereo before. Woooow.
No pressure Giles ….it’s just The Beatles !
The Flaming Mustards!! :) d.
That take 11 with no cow bell is awesome !
I seriously hope this technology goes beyond Revolver. They can go back and do the entire catalog and I'll be happy! I think he should take on the Star Club recordings.
🤩🤩🤩
I do look forward to Giles explaining how he remixed She Said She Said.
That mouse & keyboard take me back a couple decades
when you listen to George alone it sounds like She's a Woman. All these parts alone sound like nothing special and then they come together and it's just an explosion of perfection
To Giles Martin:
Are you going to remix the Rubber Soul album ?
♥️🇮🇹👋
I don't need to feel like I'm surrounded by the band in the studio. I just need a good mix, Giles.
What is "BD" in takes 1,2 8 and 9....in EMITape rear box notes???
What is this clip from? Is there a full episode?
what program do you use
Giles looks like he would make a good James Bond villain... and I mean that in the best possible way
- You expect me to listen to each instrument separately?
- I expect you to DIE, Mr. Bond!
Haha, yeah, good observation.
Now this process needs to be applied to Rubber Soul. Please.
That'll be next year, definitely.
@@stereofidelic67 I really hope so
Ok I can get down on this
Very clever....but no surround sound blu ray in the super deluxe edition is a HUGE mistake.
Wow. He is talking about a song that was recorded 3 years before he was born like as if he was there.
👍🏻👍🏻
I can hear his dad George, in Giles' voice.
How he separate the drum so clean?, that is to clean for de mix a.i
its like looking at George he even sounds just like him as well
Hello,how are you doing it’s nice meeting you here.
If that could be done to "She loves you", it would be the first stereo mix of the song ever. All their early records could be remixed that way so that stereo is not vocals to the right music to the left.
I believe it could have but the tracks were either lost, mixed together or recorded over, making it not possible.
At that stage in their careers nobody probably realised that there'd still be that much interest in them sixty odd years later.
@@pleasepermitmetospeakohgre1504 I believe Paul is referring to the fact that the beatles revolver tracks were demixed using machine learning, so you don't need the original tracks. There might be some issue with the fact its mono and not stereo, but they could probably grab the instruments from the german version of "she loves you", which is in stereo.
So, could a respectable job of this sort be done with "She Loves You" (exists only in mono)? or for that matter the 2-track stereo songs on the first two albums?
the master tape was thrown out after issuing
@@xxEzraBxxx I know, but theoretically this new technology could isolate each instrument on the existing mono tape.
So we'll have Rubber Soul, then goes backwards to Please Please Me, then Star Club tapes, Cavern Club tapes, home demos and rehearsals for official releases?
I wonder why the "Anthology" documentary is not on TH-cam.
Valeu
Interesting.
Does this mean Giles employed some kind of digital extraction to separate the instruments?
Precisely. That's the very same de-mixing technology that was made for Peter Jackson's Get Back, so that they could isolate voices & instruments, drums & bass, guitar & vocals, even Paul & John or George or Ringo.
@@juan.orduz.musico thanks for the info!
@@juan.orduz.musico that being said, time for Giles to consider, Love Me Do, PS I Love You, She Loves You and I'll Get You giving them a stereo re mix OFFICIALLY
@@juan.orduz.musico It would have been helpful if they had mentioned something about it in the video...
There is something I don't quite understand. As Giles Martin said, Texman's drums, rhythm guitar, and bass were all recorded on one track, so how can their sounds be clearly separated?
Peter Jackson's demixing technology.
@@mungofinalfi4480 Thank you for your answer. Thanks to you, my question was solved.
It sounds like George does the count off on this recording Giles is playing. But who actually counts it off on the album? I've googled this in the past and there seems to be no "consensus". I always thought it was John, because that weird slow deep count matches his sense of humor.
Two count ins. First is Paul apparently doing the comedy voice ( I always believed it to be John too)and George in the background doing the real one.Though to me it sounds like Ringo. Drummers usually do count ins.Most frustrating .
@@scottandrewbrass I searched here on TH-cam, and found this video from a few weeks ago that agrees it was Paul doing the "main" count, and supplies good evidence to support that. Sometimes I forget that Paul has a "comedic" side to him. th-cam.com/video/QuNm58x9eMc/w-d-xo.html
@@scottandrewbrass @6:21 so you don't have to play the whole thing.
@@jrussellcase Yeah thanks for that Russell. Commented on there a few weeks back. It's all fascinating stuff isn't it? But the real question that's always puzzled me is who did the voice on Revolution#9.
@@scottandrewbrass I'm pretty sure it wasn't Paul. Or George, or Ringo. 🤣 But that's a fascinating question.
what software is that on the computer?
I wanna know too....
I think it’s ProTools.
if he said all the instruments - guitar bass drums, were recorded on one track, then how did he separate the instruments?
AI, and machine learning technology. It essentially "learns" what each instrument sounds like, and is able to (pretty clearly) remove them. That way, each of the instruments can be separately placed in the mix rather than all 3 being stuck together.
He looks and talks so much like his dad
PLEASE RELEASE CARNIVAL OF LIGHT 🙏🙏🙏
1:27 the attack on the bass is totally missing! The ai isn't perfect and shouldn't have been used yet.
Same with guitar at 1:33, clarity drops for a second. Don't seem to notice it when it's all played back together though.
I didn't like the new remix of Tomorrow Never Knows, the seagulls like sound and other sound effects that I love appear to be lower, more buried in the new mix. I still prefer the original, those sound effects sound louder and in your face.
This is the one track I was a bit disappointed about. THE COWBELL!! You guys should have used the cowbell as is it heard in the MONO mix of Taxman. The stereo mix got it wrong in 1966 and it still sounds wrong to me in the new remix.
Quit messing around and release a documentary on just the mixing process and the software that was used.
My God...some of us have been waiting 50 years to watch/listen to this. Can't wait til they remix the early, awful-sounding "With The Beatles."
BUT WHO DID THE FUNNY COUNT IN GILES
I didnt know Christopher Nolan produced the Beatles.
Eccomi