LostSoldier20 I had literal nightmares of capturing hundreds of sheep, in mario odyssey! (There were only six sheep in the game, but it's so frustrating getting them!)
When you said that you're going to rank them on being kingdoms, I honestly thought for a moment you would talk about their infrastructure, politics and the such.
@@HungryWardenand it most likely also has the best economy and definitely the best infrastructure, the only thing where it’s not at the top is defense, which probably goes to bowsers, but that’s still great
Ceave: "In my opinion. Objectively. Represents my opinion." Next video: "My opinion of what my opinion is on my objective opinion of what represents my opinion, objectively, in my opinion's opinion."
Cloud Kingdom was definitely a huge letdown. It is STUNNING and my heart just sank when I realized that there wasn't going to be this beautiful cloud world to explore.
Yeah he says it's not a kingdom and just a castle, but in my opinion the cloud kingdom is just as boring and doesn't have the great atmosphere to help it.
But it’s the potential represented by the atmosphere that just fizzles out. When I got there in game I was in awe of the setting. Such a jaw-dropping art piece with a difficult boss battle, only to find out that’s basically it for that kingdom. The cloud kingdom is just a cloud arena, boring. I didn’t finish the collecting, so I didn’t play dark or darker. But I had such high hopes for ruins, which Nintendo ruined
Cloud Kingdom is the worst for me. It's basically just an arena with a bowser fight and that's pretty much it. They could have made at least a bit platforming before the fight. (Nope that 3 hat clouds don't count)
Cloud and Ruins shouldn't count as "Kingdoms," since they just serve as boss stages and provide a handful of objectives. They're more like mini-hubs rather than fully fledged kingdoms.
"Alright level, you get one fuzzy" "But butt but...I have penguins!" "I don't care, you still only get-" "🐧" "Ugh, fine, your penguins get a fuzzy too...>.>"
Its also great how the "carbonated water" that makes up the sea in the Seaside Kingdom always makes the controler rumble a little when youre in the water!
Honestly I feel like I love all the kingdoms and each have their highlights. Honestly I can’t decide which is the best from sand, metro, wooded, or luncheon for me. I do think cloud is the worst as for me it’s really hard to see with my brightness settings and it’s look isn’t as interesting as ruined. The rest of the kingdoms I really Love
i think the ranking of worst was because it broke Ceave's heart with unfulfilled expectations, to which i kinda relate. I wanted to capture the epic dragon and getting inside one of those towers with edgy dark enemies would be epic.....still disagree with ceave's decision: I think the cloud kingdom was the worst.
I know, right? The game has tons of unique, original versions of all the classic Mario settings, but the sky area isn’t even as exciting as New Soup sky levels.
Read the map descriptions for cloud kingdom. While it's really lackluster on content there's a lot of lore they put into it. The arena is a moon phase themed one and it gets it's name as a kingdom from being the host to an ancient civilisation. The overall aesthetics packed into it are really good as well. I just wish there was more to it.
I think the tease factor is what lowered its rating. I’ll admit I was disappointed with that one more than the cloud kingdom. At least the cloud kingdom can be taken at face value.
My problem with the seaside kingdom is that once you defeat the boss, the kingdom turns from sunny and bright to a sunset theme, which feels a lot less exciting and fun. I wish there was a way to turn the sky back to normal
Yeah even though I do like the post bossfight version of seaside better, I do wish that you had the option to revert kingdoms back to their pre boss fight state. Like metro could go back to night and snow could go to blizzard, ect...
I feel like it's kinda unfair to rate the kingdoms after the story ends. The kingdoms you rated the lowest were amazing, but not in an exploration kind of way. Cloud was the first time you fought bowser, ruined had an amazing battle with a friggin dragon and darker side had a challenge that took me weeks to complete. I get that you wanted to put every kingdom on the same field, but not including the purpose of the kingdom feels like such a waste...
Those kingdoms you named, he ranked them low because they were a let down, they are just used for boss fights, i wish they were boss levels and full fledged kingdoms
The Metro Kingdom is probably my favorite because I love platforming on top of and through the buildings, and I actually live really close to New York City, so it's cool to see it in a Mario game.
I apologize for disagreeing but I just don’t think Wooded Kingdom is all that memorable. I swear if you put a screenshot of it and asked me which Mario game it is in, I would think it was a galaxy from Super Mario Galaxy. I don’t know why but I feel like the objectives, atmosphere, and captures aren’t as fun and more tedious in this kingdom. (I still love the stretchy plant captures though). This still doesn’t change my mind that Mario Odyssey is by far one of the best 3D Mario game. (It is near perfect with a few less than noticeable flaws)
I kind of don’t like how he did the Darker Side dirty, not counting the whole point of the stage. That’s like not considering the boss in a kingdom that is a boss arena. *Oh wait-*
I agree on Sand Kingdom. When I first played the game, I spent 3 hours collecting as many moons as I could in that stage before moving on to the next stage. Super engaging!
This has to be one of my favorite videos by you. You rarely make videos about pure video game design, and this one is so well made. It’s polished, presents clear but intelligent analysis, and doesn’t shy away from criticizing design choices you disagree with. **please** make more videos like this. They are excellent.
Actual love for lost kingdom?? Its one of my favorites. Very compact with so much to find, love the atmosphere and weird music. It also feels the closest to how stages would be in super mario 64. Something about it just works. Also, my favorite kingdom is luncheon.. mostly because the music is awesome and the level theme is just perfectly goofy.
Man. I’ve been watching you for years, and I STILL love your overly eccentric tone and thick accent. You’re fun to listen to, dude. Keep up the good work. Edit: If you ask me, it seems a bit unfair to rank Ruined Kingdom as the worst based on what it _isn’t._ In my opinion, Cloud Kingdom is the worst due to it being just a completely empty, not very visually appealing space used for one Bowser fight. The Ruined Kingdom on the other hand is beautiful and is home to one of the most APESHIT bosses in Mario history.
my favorte is wooded i love the aesthetic and everything.. luncheon is my second favorite actually but i respect your opinion. sand is third its really good yeah i find cloud the worst because it barely has anything going for it. ruined at least has some pretty interesting lore even if there was Nothing done with it
The Accidental Hipster Mario goes to Egypt, the Bermuda, Easter Island, and China. I dunno, sounds like cultural appropriation to me. That's not very PC, Mario. No wonder Daisy has forsaken this cursed land.
I liked snow stages because there is no snow here so the only times I see snow is if Im outside of my country which doesnt happen a lot so at least I can see snow in the game
using your list, my least favorite of the kingdoms nominated is cloud. I always forget it exists until i need to fight bowser 1, and that speaks for everything. there is nothing to do, with, from what i recall, less than 10 total moons even with the moon rock. ruined is so aesthetically pleasing and surprising, i dont think anyone can forget it. Darker is safe due to the final challenge nature of it, mixed with all the feels in the beginning and end. excited going into it, and nostalgically sad leaving it. also, "no platforming challenges built into seaside kingdom"? i dare you to play "the water is lava" and make a lap around the outer ring of islands surrounding the central glass. it is possible, and quite a fun self-imposed challenge.
Switch the four fuzzy levels with the 5 fuzzy levels and I’m perfect with this list. Bowser, Lost and Wooded just had so much atmosphere and fun, the best captures, the areas felt more dense and had a ton of variation to them and stuff hidden better. 4 stars > 5 stars for me.
“Cascade Kingdom is missing something at the top like a giant dinosaur skeleton.” Literally the next shot shows the dinosaur skeleton that is at the top of Cascade Kingdom.
I love the Wooded Kingdom for one major reason. It reminds me of Planet Wisp from Sonic Colours and Sonic Colours is actually the first ever videogame I remember playing, so it’s always held a special place in my heart.
Speaking from my experience, I LOVED Snow Kingdom. I loved its different take on the formula, its citizens and would rate it a 5/5 fuzzies. Its my second favourite kingdom in the game after all.
I feel like the most interesting kingdom themes were the ones delegated to boss arenas. Like a ruined castle & clouds would’ve been cool level times if they were fully explored.
The deep woods was a total surprise. I had no idea it existed until I went back after beating the game. So I really enjoyed it as a secret, mysterious area.
My favorite is seaside because the seascapes are beautiful and I love how the boss fight takes place around the whole kingdom instead of having a little sub area for the battle
Bowsers kingdom is my favorite though. The atmosphere, the way you climb up, the peaceful island halfway with crazy cap, the way the music and atmosphere gets much more dynamic near the main courtyard entrance, the hakama plus the Luigi cap are my favorite outfit combination, and that’s easily my favorite. Also the ruined kingdom is in my top 3 kingdoms despite it being empty. I just love it so much. I don’t even play games like dark souls or games with this type of art style. Also I kinda hate sand kingdom. It was the most annoying to 100% and every time I started 100%ing it, I abandoned cuz it was just so annoying. For me, ruined is better.
You nailed the best stage. I told my friend right when I finished playing this game two years ago: "nothing quite lived up to the sand kingdom for the rest of the game"
Cap Kingdom: Small, yet simple. Each part is easily recognizable but also doesn’t feel boring. Favorite Part: The Town Least Favorite Part: Having to use the ParaGoomba a lot Cascade Kingdom: Bigger, and a lot more fun. Great music, fun boss, and just great to find secrets in. Favorite Part: Playing as a T-Rex Least Favorite Part: The Small World Levels Sand Kingdom: Amazing to explore in, many ways to get around, and very iconic. Favorite Part: Tostarena Town Least Favorite Part: The underground sections Wooded Kingdom: More Compact, but still great to explore. Awesome combination of forest and factory. Favorite Part: The well designed branching paths Least Favorite Part: The Deep Woods Lake Kingdom: Small, but still fun as no section feels unnecessary or slow. Favorite Part: The Underwater Dome Least Favorite Part: The frog poison mini level Cloud Kingdom: Barren and also small. Lost potential for a fun sky level. Favorite Part: Fighting Bowser Least Favorite Part: Everything else Lost Kingdom: Small, but still fun. The branching paths kept the kingdom from feeling too linear. Favorite Part: The tropical wiggler Least Favorite Part: The poison Metro Kingdom: Every area is great to explore, fighting the MechaWiggler is awesome, and jumping on the roof tops is thrilling. Favorite Part: The festival Least Favorite Part: Jump Rope Challenge Snow Kingdom: The town is cute, but the Main Land and Bound Bowl races aren’t fun. Favorite Part: The town Least Favorite Part: The Mainland Seaside Kingdom: Waaay too many areas and isn’t fun to explore. Even the boss is just alright. Favorite Part: The Beach House Least Favorite Part: Swimming Luncheon Kingdom: Amazing theme and fun to explore. The lava bubble capture is ingenious and all the areas are recognizable. Favorite Part: The cooking Carnival Least Favorite Part: The peak climb Ruined Kingdom: Lost potential and way too small. No fun to revisit either. Favorite Part: Fighting the Lord of Lightning Least Favorite Part: Everything else Bowser’s Kingdom: Great Theme and the linear design is great. Really builds up the final battle. Favorite Part: Pokio Least Favorite Part: The purple coins Moon Kingdom: The mainland is kind of boring but the moon caverns and final battle are awesome. Favorite Part: The ending Least Favorite Part: The mainland feels too barren Mushroom Kingdom: Great references and simple to get around in. The castle was awesome and playing as Yoshi was fun. Favorite Part: The Mario 64 callbacks Least Favorite Part: Toadette’s achievement moons
The intro music, Shunshine music combined with Ceaves voice makes these videos very relaxing. Like a Podcast almost. I love them you can just put them on while playing a game or going for a walk or even just chilling in general, since the video itself *basically* is not required, just his voice really. Very good videos, well done
the metro kingdom its just awesome i really like the super mario bros style that the kingdom approach for not talking about his boss and the donkey kong part its just awesome
Ceave, when you showed the nominations for the worst kingdoms, the 3 kingdoms showed up on the screen in order: left, middle, right. And then the middle kingdom (Ruined) got chosen as the worst. But for the best 3 stages, you put them in the order middle, right, left. And the middle got chosen again. Did you switch up the order on purpose? Because you wanted the middle one to be chosen both times? Sneaky...
What is better: Cool boss arena with A DRAGON❌ The same arena, but uncool and boring and cloud ✅ Also I never even noticed that ,,big problem" with Luncheon. S tier for me.
I love how you explain this Ceave! I’ve been playing Odyssey for 4 years and have never thought of some of the things you’ve said. Glad you’re back making videos again! :)
I think agree with everything in the video except for two kingdoms: Sand Kingdom -- While I agree that it's fun to explore and has really good design, it also feels like a LOT of empty space. So much empty space, in fact, that they had to invent a whole new method to traverse it in the form of the Jaxis. I love the ruins, the towers, the pyramids, but it's surrounded by this huge body of sand and in 90% of that sand there's absolutely nothing to do except for find some REALLY ANNOYINGLY PLACED purple coins. It just feels like it could've been tightened up or fleshed out further. I'd rate this one as a 4/5. Ruined Kingdom -- I also agree with almost everything but the rating here. Ruined isn't much, but it has such a unique atmosphere that it remains one of the most memorable portions of the game to me. I absolutely wish they had done more with it, but at the same time, for a section of the game that is relegated to being a boss arena either way, they already did a lot with it. It's no Cloud Kingdom, after all. 2/5.
My favorite kingdom is the Wooded Kingdom. The rustic arcological aesthetics, the beautiful natural vista juxtaposed with the machinations, the sheer verticality and the different areas offering a slew of places and new discoveries while retaining their raw beauty, and the music echoing in the background for an oddly enjoyable if misplaced beach music. Really, the level is all over the place (pun definitely intended), and that's why I love it so much. There is nothing else quite like it for me, but Sand Kingdom and New Donk City are quite close. Now Snow Kingdom on the other hand... Hands down the absolute worst. Extremely boring, uninteresting palette and level design, nothing much to do, and very closed in without much personality to it. Had they gone with a full-scale sandbox Christmas-themed level, it could have been amazing, especially with how auroras and festive lights could have been implemented into the level's atmosphere. In terms of wide-open sandbox levels go, then Luncheon Kingdom is the worst in that regard. Very boring, uninteresting, and extremely disappointing considering the equally large levels that come before it.
The Sand Kingdom is my favourite kingdom because I'm absolutely in love with all the cultural panache they put in. From the Dia De Los Muertos styled inhabitants to all the ruins and the ice deity as the boss! The only bad part about is how badly some parts of the lore are handled. For example, who is Knucklotec? Why didn't they give him a little context? Like someone mentioning him in-game. He appears everywhere, meaning he is extremely important to the inhabitants. But he gets destroyed. Nobody questions it. He was the guardian of the FRIGGIN' RING. Not even the guide mentions him. All the things we know about him are from the art book and that's it. Other than that, it's such a fun atmosphere to explore. I finished it 100% just for that. I absolutely adore the SeaSide Kingdom as well. I despise Metro Kingdom tho. Y'all can kill me now.
Cloud Kingdom takes bottom for me. At least Ruined Kingdom looked cool and had a great boss fight. The Cloud Kingdom is just an empty white space that had one of multiple Bowser fights.
You totally missed your chance for a "the moon kingdom lacks... Atmosphere" pun there
fact
JzudemD Such a shame for such *breathtaking* landscapes
@@Yolwoocle HA
If he did that pun, they would stop *airing* the video.
Except that Mario can breathe for some reason.
Yeah, I dunno either.
Someday, Ceave will catch us all off guard and rate one really bad thing with five awful coins instead of one fuzzy.
Delicious but deadly coins
@@Brulebassani luncheon kingdom be like
But then how would he rate a coin?
@@sirbob430 it would get a 1 coin rating
@@sirbob430 One P-switch that turns the floor into shiny yet deadly coins.
"Easiest Kingdom"
Someone's never tried to herd those damn sheep...
That's tedious more than difficult
@@albondI found the 2d area that had a small area you had to stay in that was moving more difficult. Spent hours on it.
@@napane3939 Yeah, that was annoying
LostSoldier20 I had literal nightmares of capturing hundreds of sheep, in mario odyssey! (There were only six sheep in the game, but it's so frustrating getting them!)
Capturing sheep was so EASY
"Ruined kingdom is just an empty tower"
_Yeh well cloud kingdom is just a cloud with an arena on it_
He rated it with 1 fuzzie
Better yet it's just a ☁️
I really like ruined. Despite it being small it’s probably in my top 3 kingdoms
Why?
At least the ruined kingdom looked cool.
When you said that you're going to rank them on being kingdoms, I honestly thought for a moment you would talk about their infrastructure, politics and the such.
lol!
See, Metro Kingdom is definitely on top, because it actually has politics (Mayor Pauline)
@@HungryWardenand it most likely also has the best economy and definitely the best infrastructure, the only thing where it’s not at the top is defense, which probably goes to bowsers, but that’s still great
@@art-games6230 yeah I agree.
"In my opinion. *Objectively* represents my opinion."
Oh, Ceave. Never, ever change.
What? You can objectively present a subjective opinion.
I was gonna type the same thing
I can't even tell if he's doing it on purpose.
@@SpecterVonBaren Totally on purpose. I mean he does this on every rating video he does ^-^
“Winged Red Koopas With Wings”
when ceave gaming is rating your favorite kingdom, but then he adds a "but"
I feel the pain with cascade kingdom, it was so redemable.
@David Schwartzberg Nice. I won't like it to change it.
Me who’s favorite was 5 fuzzies: :D
I loved the snow kingdom! :(
“Winged goombas with wings”
...ceave we talked about this
Did you, when?
~_~
@@PluslePlayzYT that doesn't answer my question.
Y E S
@@PluslePlayzYT no
Ceave: the kingdom is too short for a perfect 5 fuzzys
Also Ceave: Here’s a fuzzy for a penguin
LOL
and thats why i disagreed with all of his opinions.
I bet he was originally gonna rank it 2 fuzzies but he decided to put a joke in. That wasn't the reason it had 2 fuzzies.
@@koolaid33 very shallow of you for what was obviously a gag
@@koolaid33 so metro kingdom sucks in your opinion?
"A tier list that in my opinion, objectively represents my opinion."
Sorry, my ears blinked, what?
sorry my eyes couldnt hear what you said, can you repeat that?
My ears couldn’t see wtf you mean. My eyes didn’t hear them either, they got infected after you said that.
@@odusthecat You callin' me stupid or are you tryna extend the joke?
AleJJtheNinja extend. It was a hilarious joke.
Is someone going to get wooooshed?
Ceave: "In my opinion. Objectively. Represents my opinion."
Next video: "My opinion of what my opinion is on my objective opinion of what represents my opinion, objectively, in my opinion's opinion."
You forgot: "That premise may seem overwhelming to some of you at first, but it's actually surprisingly simple to understand..."
Why didn't u give the wooded kingdom 1 it sucks
Merge “In theory, it sounds so cool to become a winged goomba WITH wings and to fly around...” 3:07
Makes total sense
Opinions can have opinions?
Cloud Kingdom was definitely a huge letdown. It is STUNNING and my heart just sank when I realized that there wasn't going to be this beautiful cloud world to explore.
@@the_most_ever_company It's probably considered amazing because many other people clearly had more fun with it than you did
When you’re playing the picture match, the cotton candy pastels are fun to stare at
The ruins can't be the worst. It has a dragon. A dragon makes it 10/10 that's just how dragons work
Yeah he says it's not a kingdom and just a castle, but in my opinion the cloud kingdom is just as boring and doesn't have the great atmosphere to help it.
Agreed!
Yeah but a flamingo would make it even cooler
But it’s the potential represented by the atmosphere that just fizzles out. When I got there in game I was in awe of the setting. Such a jaw-dropping art piece with a difficult boss battle, only to find out that’s basically it for that kingdom.
The cloud kingdom is just a cloud arena, boring. I didn’t finish the collecting, so I didn’t play dark or darker.
But I had such high hopes for ruins, which Nintendo ruined
Yeah, the Ruined dragon is amazingly cute too.
“The cascade kingdom is really missing something on top of it, like a gigantic dinosaur skeleton” HMMMMMMMMMMMMMM
True, forgot about that.
HE ALSO SHOWS THE F***** SKELETON AND AS SOON AS HE SAID THAT HE CUTS STRAIGHT TO THE SKULL OF THE DINOSAUR
@@fluffgalaxy4884 language!
Ayan Sharma no i am not Shy Guy Mask
@@fluffgalaxy4884 You are the toast!
The wooded kingdom is definitely the best play to hide balloons, there are so many layers that it is really hard to find where one is.
Ceave back with his penguin friend
Rigging rank lists with a fury
Flying penguin
Omg hi Mayro! 👋🏻
Big Fan!
Almost as obsessed with you as Mollowo!
Ok
yes
Cloud Kingdom is the worst for me. It's basically just an arena with a bowser fight and that's pretty much it. They could have made at least a bit platforming before the fight. (Nope that 3 hat clouds don't count)
I'd like to explore Bowser's airship after the story, that would be cool.
And still I die at those 3 hats
Cloud and Ruins shouldn't count as "Kingdoms," since they just serve as boss stages and provide a handful of objectives. They're more like mini-hubs rather than fully fledged kingdoms.
0:45
“...That we, as critical Super Mario Nerds...”
-Ceave 2019
I happily declare myself a Super Mario Nerd.
ALL HAIL THE SUPER MARIO NERDS!
"Alright level, you get one fuzzy"
"But butt but...I have penguins!"
"I don't care, you still only get-"
"🐧"
"Ugh, fine, your penguins get a fuzzy too...>.>"
Lol
Loved this moment lol
I don’t know... I thought the sand kingdom was pretty dry
Ba bum chhh
it probably got pretty moist after all the ice melted
@@bokocop5725 just like your mom
@@Ruby-yb8kk No u
Dor me it really turned up the heat
Its also great how the "carbonated water" that makes up the sea in the Seaside Kingdom always makes the controler rumble a little when youre in the water!
true I though I was the only one to notice that lol
I loved that subtle touch, the water really did feel "fizzy" and not just like normal controller rumble
Hd rumble is honestly super nice when integrated correctly. Sadly many games don't make use of this technology (usually ports, which makes sense).
@@garageghost6038 odyssey has the best use of this. The motorcycle rumble is just feels like real motor (Says a real motor user)
@@Ozzymandias0 For sure. Odyssey makes the best use of HD rumble out of the games that I've played so far. Super Mario party is also not bad.
17:58 I only now notice that the tower looks like a giant carrot.
Oh my god! I didnt notice that either! Yeah it's the rabbit ridge.
That's cool
Hahaha
I noticed that right away
You mean top hat tower
Honestly I feel like I love all the kingdoms and each have their highlights. Honestly I can’t decide which is the best from sand, metro, wooded, or luncheon for me. I do think cloud is the worst as for me it’s really hard to see with my brightness settings and it’s look isn’t as interesting as ruined. The rest of the kingdoms I really Love
Nope wooden is big only because I hate deeper woods
Was it inspected to see you here.
Messed up my typing sorry
holy shit i was jus binge watching all ur vids😭😭😭
HI ODDESY
Me on my first playthrough: „Omg, Next kingdom is metro kingdom“
Lost Kingdom: „Sike bitch you thought“
Lost Kingdom is the worst kingdom.
@@SerialDesignationR814 I don't think it's that bad, but the fact they teased with metro and hit me with the Lost kingdom just ruined it for me
I like it to
@@SerialDesignationR814 lost kingdom is fuckin awesome
@@craz5634 agreed. It’s honestly my favorite
"Ruined kingdom is just an empty tower"
The Dragon that had a lot of effort in it: am i a joke to you?
I get what he means in rating it as an actual kingdom. In a ranking of boss fights, the dragon is probably #1
i think the ranking of worst was because it broke Ceave's heart with unfulfilled expectations, to which i kinda relate. I wanted to capture the epic dragon and getting inside one of those towers with edgy dark enemies would be epic.....still disagree with ceave's decision: I think the cloud kingdom was the worst.
@@crazydud3380 Dragon is my favorite part for my (Cleave, read this) IMAGINATION!
Ruined is my top 5 favourite bc of the dragon and the atmosphere
@@crazydud3380 the dragon looks good but I hate the boss fight it's so easy
It honestly breaks my heart how empty the Cloud Kingdom is
I mean honestly it's just the sky
I know, right? The game has tons of unique, original versions of all the classic Mario settings, but the sky area isn’t even as exciting as New Soup sky levels.
Kinda wish they did something like the Cloud Area (Can't remember the name. It's where Mallow is from) from Super Mario RPG.
Name checks out.
Read the map descriptions for cloud kingdom. While it's really lackluster on content there's a lot of lore they put into it. The arena is a moon phase themed one and it gets it's name as a kingdom from being the host to an ancient civilisation. The overall aesthetics packed into it are really good as well. I just wish there was more to it.
"Its cool to be a winged goomba with wings,"
Ceave 2019
Well a winged goomba without wings is just sad.
69 likes
It is cool to be a goomba with big wings
Ah yes, the floor is made out of floor.
At least Ruined Kingdom looks super cool. How did it lose to bland Cloud Kingdom lol.
He somehow rated missing potential lower than not having potential lol
Yes just yes
I think the tease factor is what lowered its rating. I’ll admit I was disappointed with that one more than the cloud kingdom. At least the cloud kingdom can be taken at face value.
I now if there's a sieecwel I hope they expand on it
@@erincaisley5416 a.... What? Sequel? 😂😭
My problem with the seaside kingdom is that once you defeat the boss, the kingdom turns from sunny and bright to a sunset theme, which feels a lot less exciting and fun. I wish there was a way to turn the sky back to normal
Yeah even though I do like the post bossfight version of seaside better, I do wish that you had the option to revert kingdoms back to their pre boss fight state. Like metro could go back to night and snow could go to blizzard, ect...
I feel like it's kinda unfair to rate the kingdoms after the story ends. The kingdoms you rated the lowest were amazing, but not in an exploration kind of way. Cloud was the first time you fought bowser, ruined had an amazing battle with a friggin dragon and darker side had a challenge that took me weeks to complete. I get that you wanted to put every kingdom on the same field, but not including the purpose of the kingdom feels like such a waste...
The thing is that cloud and ruined didn't need to be it owl kingdom lol.
I actually beat darker side 1st try
@@ThePersonWhoAsked447 cool but who asked
@@ThePersonWhoAsked447 nobody cares
Those kingdoms you named, he ranked them low because they were a let down, they are just used for boss fights, i wish they were boss levels and full fledged kingdoms
10. They
9. Are
8. All
7. great
6. Kingdoms
5. And
4. None
3. Are
2. Bad
1. Snow kingdom
XD
DX
xO
Ox
XP
"That, in my opinion, *objectively* represents - my opinion"
Mario bruhdda moment
literally noticed that the second he said it, and went into the comments to see if someone else noticed it, and found u
@@shmulinadel9527 same here XD
Wow, he should have made a joke about that!
Every 60 seconds in Africa, a minute passes.
Time Stamp????
The Metro Kingdom is probably my favorite because I love platforming on top of and through the buildings, and I actually live really close to New York City, so it's cool to see it in a Mario game.
Honestly my favorite is the wooded kingdom. I absolutely love the atmosphere
Wooded Kingdom gang! Steam Gardens slaps harder than almost any other BGM in the game.
I apologize for disagreeing but I just don’t think Wooded Kingdom is all that memorable. I swear if you put a screenshot of it and asked me which Mario game it is in, I would think it was a galaxy from Super Mario Galaxy. I don’t know why but I feel like the objectives, atmosphere, and captures aren’t as fun and more tedious in this kingdom. (I still love the stretchy plant captures though). This still doesn’t change my mind that Mario Odyssey is by far one of the best 3D Mario game. (It is near perfect with a few less than noticeable flaws)
If you love the atmosphere, you must hate the moon kingdom
Agreed, I keep bouncing back between that and the City. Has some of the best music too.
I love luncheon and don't really like the wooded kingdom.
my question is, did he forget to include the "i" question or did youtube remove another great feature
option 2
removed ;-;
I kind of don’t like how he did the Darker Side dirty, not counting the whole point of the stage. That’s like not considering the boss in a kingdom that is a boss arena. *Oh wait-*
Exactly
I agree on Sand Kingdom. When I first played the game, I spent 3 hours collecting as many moons as I could in that stage before moving on to the next stage. Super engaging!
This has to be one of my favorite videos by you. You rarely make videos about pure video game design, and this one is so well made. It’s polished, presents clear but intelligent analysis, and doesn’t shy away from criticizing design choices you disagree with. **please** make more videos like this. They are excellent.
The sand kingdom gets 0 out of 5 fuzzies because it’s course, rough and gets everywhere
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I actually hate sand. Dead serious. I can't move my toes without flinching
just like glitter, sand is an invasive species
I hate sand. It gets everywhere
66 likes.
*Ironic*
Wooded Kingdom deserves 6/5 fuzzies just because of the soundtrack. It's amazing how much time I spent in that kingdom without the music getting old.
i used to rule the world...
th-cam.com/video/cgQPlbwyX8w/w-d-xo.html
Metro Kingdom: **Home to the song "Jump Up, Super Star"**
Ceave: **Chooses the Sand Kingdom as the best one**
This is incredibly *Odd to see*
Spoilers much m8
OOOOOOOOH! I GOT IT!! Hehehheheheheehheeheheheh
@@megalampada2372 i dont get it, could you please explain
Bruh
odd to see Odyssey
Actual love for lost kingdom?? Its one of my favorites. Very compact with so much to find, love the atmosphere and weird music. It also feels the closest to how stages would be in super mario 64. Something about it just works. Also, my favorite kingdom is luncheon.. mostly because the music is awesome and the level theme is just perfectly goofy.
Man. I’ve been watching you for years, and I STILL love your overly eccentric tone and thick accent. You’re fun to listen to, dude. Keep up the good work.
Edit: If you ask me, it seems a bit unfair to rank Ruined Kingdom as the worst based on what it _isn’t._ In my opinion, Cloud Kingdom is the worst due to it being just a completely empty, not very visually appealing space used for one Bowser fight. The Ruined Kingdom on the other hand is beautiful and is home to one of the most APESHIT bosses in Mario history.
Is he German?
Austrian
Ok it's really hard to tell
Ceave: “The Seaside Kingdom is home to my favorite capture: the gushen.
Oh my gush!”
*I see what you did there*
ceave:"4 fuzzies for the lost kingdom". the fuzzies on screen:" you have underestimated me."
0:21
What is this? Ceave grabbing coins???
Alex Cox No, it’s a payed actor, he never would touch the shiny yet deadly coins
(Confused screaming)
... and the floor didn't collapse!
my favorte is wooded i love the aesthetic and everything.. luncheon is my second favorite actually but i respect your opinion. sand is third its really good yeah
i find cloud the worst because it barely has anything going for it. ruined at least has some pretty interesting lore even if there was Nothing done with it
You said everything I thought about this video
Yes
Me too
That's why it hurts the most. The name is a little too literal.
Ceeve is just disappointed with ruined kingdom he wants to explore all the other towers
"Mario Odyssey has a bit of an identity crisis"
*Laughs in Mario Galaxy*
@The Accidental Hipster I thought it was supposed to be Chinese?
@@hazelnotxyz you just proved his point
The Accidental Hipster Mario goes to Egypt, the Bermuda, Easter Island, and China. I dunno, sounds like cultural appropriation to me. That's not very PC, Mario. No wonder Daisy has forsaken this cursed land.
@@zeeteepippi275 Ah yes, the reason I wish Mario Land never existed, introduced the single worst character in the entire franchise
Marshall R. *Best princess in all of existence (Looks like you made an oopsie, fixed it for you.)
Not gonna lie, snow kingdom my favorite
I'm a sucker for winter/Christmas stages,and this gives me the winter vibe
I liked snow stages because there is no snow here so the only times I see snow is if Im outside of my country which doesnt happen a lot so at least I can see snow in the game
At the very least it has the best music.
What is your problem? :(
Cláudio Vieira ?
I live in North Dakota. I already live in the snow kingdom.
15:39
Cappy when mario is dying in lava : "dead end I think"
Mario litterally dying : "YEAH I BELEIVE SO"
using your list, my least favorite of the kingdoms nominated is cloud. I always forget it exists until i need to fight bowser 1, and that speaks for everything. there is nothing to do, with, from what i recall, less than 10 total moons even with the moon rock. ruined is so aesthetically pleasing and surprising, i dont think anyone can forget it. Darker is safe due to the final challenge nature of it, mixed with all the feels in the beginning and end. excited going into it, and nostalgically sad leaving it.
also, "no platforming challenges built into seaside kingdom"? i dare you to play "the water is lava" and make a lap around the outer ring of islands surrounding the central glass. it is possible, and quite a fun self-imposed challenge.
"Objectively represent my oppinion" I'm sooo stealing that!
I'm really surprised by your sand kingdom choice...
Switch the four fuzzy levels with the 5 fuzzy levels and I’m perfect with this list.
Bowser, Lost and Wooded just had so much atmosphere and fun, the best captures, the areas felt more dense and had a ton of variation to them and stuff hidden better. 4 stars > 5 stars for me.
4 fuzzys > 5 fuzzys
“Cascade Kingdom is missing something at the top like a giant dinosaur skeleton.”
Literally the next shot shows the dinosaur skeleton that is at the top of Cascade Kingdom.
Ikr
y e s , i a g r e e
It is missing something at the actual top. The skeleton is a small baby thing on the side that involves, like he mentioned, no platforming at all.
I feel like I could listen to him say “cheep cheep” for an hour straigjt
I love the Wooded Kingdom for one major reason. It reminds me of Planet Wisp from Sonic Colours and Sonic Colours is actually the first ever videogame I remember playing, so it’s always held a special place in my heart.
Same here actually
Speaking from my experience, I LOVED Snow Kingdom. I loved its different take on the formula, its citizens and would rate it a 5/5 fuzzies. Its my second favourite kingdom in the game after all.
What’s your first
I like the idea of the Snow Kingdom, but it was a disappointment
I do like the snow kingdom but it does lack a little bit of exploration
snow kingdom best
what a trash opinion
Wooded kingdom will always be my favorite because of its cool setting and chill ass surfer theme music
I feel like the most interesting kingdom themes were the ones delegated to boss arenas. Like a ruined castle & clouds would’ve been cool level times if they were fully explored.
Cascade is a “Dinosaur Cliff Thingy” -Ceave 2019
So you dont wanna keep your fuzzys? I mean im not selfish, but giving a fuzzy away, is..... Fuzzys are the best thing and id wanna keep it.
Darf der Kevin spielen kommen?
@@Donnersora Hä?
@@dersps5905 ist zwar sehr bekannt in Deutschland aber du kennst es wohl nicht
Honestly wooded kingdom was my favorite kingdom. It’s just so massive and sprawling. I can genuinely get lost and I love that feeling.
The deep woods was a total surprise. I had no idea it existed until I went back after beating the game. So I really enjoyed it as a secret, mysterious area.
Falling into the deeper woods be like:
AAAaaaAaaaaaaaAA
There are 9 moons there though.
potatobearkelm AAAaaaAaaaaaaaAA
Cool
My favorite is seaside because the seascapes are beautiful and I love how the boss fight takes place around the whole kingdom instead of having a little sub area for the battle
Bowsers kingdom is my favorite though. The atmosphere, the way you climb up, the peaceful island halfway with crazy cap, the way the music and atmosphere gets much more dynamic near the main courtyard entrance, the hakama plus the Luigi cap are my favorite outfit combination, and that’s easily my favorite. Also the ruined kingdom is in my top 3 kingdoms despite it being empty. I just love it so much. I don’t even play games like dark souls or games with this type of art style. Also I kinda hate sand kingdom. It was the most annoying to 100% and every time I started 100%ing it, I abandoned cuz it was just so annoying. For me, ruined is better.
@Breya Burgess except for the three coins that were on the edge of the map, finding the purple coins in sand wasn't bad, maybe even fun.
"Winged Goomba with Wings." Does he have wings? You really should clarify this.
Nah, I think it has very large wing-looking feathers
Again, it's a paragoomba
Man, I'm loving all the GameCube music, especially the SMS tracks. Sunshine is one of my all-time favorites.
You nailed the best stage. I told my friend right when I finished playing this game two years ago: "nothing quite lived up to the sand kingdom for the rest of the game"
sameeee :)
Cap Kingdom: Small, yet simple. Each part is easily recognizable but also doesn’t feel boring.
Favorite Part: The Town
Least Favorite Part: Having to use the ParaGoomba a lot
Cascade Kingdom: Bigger, and a lot more fun. Great music, fun boss, and just great to find secrets in.
Favorite Part: Playing as a T-Rex
Least Favorite Part: The Small World Levels
Sand Kingdom: Amazing to explore in, many ways to get around, and very iconic.
Favorite Part: Tostarena Town
Least Favorite Part: The underground sections
Wooded Kingdom: More Compact, but still great to explore. Awesome combination of forest and factory.
Favorite Part: The well designed branching paths
Least Favorite Part: The Deep Woods
Lake Kingdom: Small, but still fun as no section feels unnecessary or slow.
Favorite Part: The Underwater Dome
Least Favorite Part: The frog poison mini level
Cloud Kingdom: Barren and also small. Lost potential for a fun sky level.
Favorite Part: Fighting Bowser
Least Favorite Part: Everything else
Lost Kingdom: Small, but still fun. The branching paths kept the kingdom from feeling too linear.
Favorite Part: The tropical wiggler
Least Favorite Part: The poison
Metro Kingdom: Every area is great to explore, fighting the MechaWiggler is awesome, and jumping on the roof tops is thrilling.
Favorite Part: The festival
Least Favorite Part: Jump Rope Challenge
Snow Kingdom: The town is cute, but the Main Land and Bound Bowl races aren’t fun.
Favorite Part: The town
Least Favorite Part: The Mainland
Seaside Kingdom: Waaay too many areas and isn’t fun to explore. Even the boss is just alright.
Favorite Part: The Beach House
Least Favorite Part: Swimming
Luncheon Kingdom: Amazing theme and fun to explore. The lava bubble capture is ingenious and all the areas are recognizable.
Favorite Part: The cooking Carnival
Least Favorite Part: The peak climb
Ruined Kingdom: Lost potential and way too small. No fun to revisit either.
Favorite Part: Fighting the Lord of Lightning
Least Favorite Part: Everything else
Bowser’s Kingdom: Great Theme and the linear design is great. Really builds up the final battle.
Favorite Part: Pokio
Least Favorite Part: The purple coins
Moon Kingdom: The mainland is kind of boring but the moon caverns and final battle are awesome.
Favorite Part: The ending
Least Favorite Part: The mainland feels too barren
Mushroom Kingdom: Great references and simple to get around in. The castle was awesome and playing as Yoshi was fun.
Favorite Part: The Mario 64 callbacks
Least Favorite Part: Toadette’s achievement moons
I mostly agree with everything, but my least favorite part of Seaside is the volleyball.
The intro music, Shunshine music combined with Ceaves voice makes these videos very relaxing. Like a Podcast almost. I love them you can just put them on while playing a game or going for a walk or even just chilling in general, since the video itself *basically* is not required, just his voice really. Very good videos, well done
You should have said
"Excuse me for gushing about gushon
I think he did say "oh my gush".
18:20 "many, many decades ago" 🤣
0.2 decades is too many...
Finally someone who likes the sand kingdom more than the metro
You only like sand kingdom because of "diversity"
the metro kingdom its just awesome i really like the super mario bros style that the kingdom approach for not talking about his boss and the donkey kong part its just awesome
Ceave: the lava bubble captures are slow
Me, who shakes the controller: try this out
Ceave, when you showed the nominations for the worst kingdoms, the 3 kingdoms showed up on the screen in order: left, middle, right. And then the middle kingdom (Ruined) got chosen as the worst. But for the best 3 stages, you put them in the order middle, right, left. And the middle got chosen again.
Did you switch up the order on purpose? Because you wanted the middle one to be chosen both times?
Sneaky...
there's a reason for that
Snow Kingdom should've been an instant 6 fuzzies because of the Shiverians
shiverians are the reason people buyed odyssssssey
@@Whisper71 Are you a snake
@@krillbilly1435 no, im just parseltongue
Haven’t watched the video yet but I expect “number of fuzzies in kingdom” to be a primary factor.
It is 🤓
Me playing 3d all stars games then playing odyssey and getting so confused that coins don't heal
What is better:
Cool boss arena with A DRAGON❌
The same arena, but uncool and boring and cloud ✅
Also I never even noticed that ,,big problem" with Luncheon. S tier for me.
I love watching videos rating how good are parts of a game that I've never played
Well then you need to get Odyssey!
if the lost kingdom was bigger, its be the best one, no doubt
imagine Boo Hoo's in this kingdom
11:55 dat voicecrack though
I love how you explain this Ceave! I’ve been playing Odyssey for 4 years and have never thought of some of the things you’ve said. Glad you’re back making videos again! :)
I love seaside kingdom. Being a gusher is amazing, exploring the random underwater areas is amazing!
Sand Kingdom Review: Starts
Ceave: Starts playing Tee Hee Valley OST
I love you Ceave
I feel personally offended. Snow Kingdom is my favorite :/
I like seaside because you can easily travel in the air and underwater
I think agree with everything in the video except for two kingdoms:
Sand Kingdom -- While I agree that it's fun to explore and has really good design, it also feels like a LOT of empty space. So much empty space, in fact, that they had to invent a whole new method to traverse it in the form of the Jaxis. I love the ruins, the towers, the pyramids, but it's surrounded by this huge body of sand and in 90% of that sand there's absolutely nothing to do except for find some REALLY ANNOYINGLY PLACED purple coins. It just feels like it could've been tightened up or fleshed out further. I'd rate this one as a 4/5.
Ruined Kingdom -- I also agree with almost everything but the rating here. Ruined isn't much, but it has such a unique atmosphere that it remains one of the most memorable portions of the game to me. I absolutely wish they had done more with it, but at the same time, for a section of the game that is relegated to being a boss arena either way, they already did a lot with it. It's no Cloud Kingdom, after all. 2/5.
I agree with everything you said there
cascade Kingdom litterally does have a boss on top of the mountain..... but only if you just get there
“Limits it for no reason”
Top of top hat tower: am I a joke to you?
I agree for the most part about Luncheon, but you do know that you can shake the joycon to move significantly faster with the Lava Bubble, right?
Snow kingdom sucks, and it was the first and mostly only kingdom I didn’t like playing, but I’ll be honest, the bouncy ball minigame is really fun.
Snow is good and your opinion is shit
My favorite kingdom is the Wooded Kingdom. The rustic arcological aesthetics, the beautiful natural vista juxtaposed with the machinations, the sheer verticality and the different areas offering a slew of places and new discoveries while retaining their raw beauty, and the music echoing in the background for an oddly enjoyable if misplaced beach music. Really, the level is all over the place (pun definitely intended), and that's why I love it so much. There is nothing else quite like it for me, but Sand Kingdom and New Donk City are quite close.
Now Snow Kingdom on the other hand... Hands down the absolute worst. Extremely boring, uninteresting palette and level design, nothing much to do, and very closed in without much personality to it. Had they gone with a full-scale sandbox Christmas-themed level, it could have been amazing, especially with how auroras and festive lights could have been implemented into the level's atmosphere. In terms of wide-open sandbox levels go, then Luncheon Kingdom is the worst in that regard. Very boring, uninteresting, and extremely disappointing considering the equally large levels that come before it.
The Sand Kingdom is my favourite kingdom because I'm absolutely in love with all the cultural panache they put in. From the Dia De Los Muertos styled inhabitants to all the ruins and the ice deity as the boss!
The only bad part about is how badly some parts of the lore are handled.
For example, who is Knucklotec? Why didn't they give him a little context? Like someone mentioning him in-game.
He appears everywhere, meaning he is extremely important to the inhabitants.
But he gets destroyed. Nobody questions it. He was the guardian of the FRIGGIN' RING.
Not even the guide mentions him. All the things we know about him are from the art book and that's it.
Other than that, it's such a fun atmosphere to explore. I finished it 100% just for that.
I absolutely adore the SeaSide Kingdom as well.
I despise Metro Kingdom tho.
Y'all can kill me now.
Metro Kingdom is my favorite one!
My rating:
* Hat: 3
* Fossil Falls: 4
* Dessert: 4
* Lake: 2
* Forest: 5
* Cloud: 1
* Lost: 3
* Metro: 5
* Snow Kingdom: 4
* Seaside: 3
* Lunch Kingdom: 2
* Ruined Kingdom: 2
* Bowsers Kingdom: 5
* Moon: 2
* Mushroom Kingdom: 5
* Dark Side and Darker Side: 1
I'd say, the winner is Forest.
When just talking about your three favourites, it's Metro.
@@goosehonkernot1694 Ok, about what and where?
@JohngamerYT I think so. I probably meant "Desert"
Stages with Fuzzies should get an extra Fuzzy
3:10 a winged goomba with wings
Cloud Kingdom takes bottom for me. At least Ruined Kingdom looked cool and had a great boss fight. The Cloud Kingdom is just an empty white space that had one of multiple Bowser fights.
Luncheon deserves 5 because the shop keepers tell me that I’m worth it.