*Live Q&A - Engage, Challenge, Clarify* || _29 August 2024 ; Thursday_ 0:00:13 Stream begins, followed by discussion between Ibn Hazm Al Idrissi, and Hashim _Discussion with / Questions from guests/chat section_ 0:10:20 AdilS [ Muslim - from Kazakhstan; currently working in Abu Dhabi, UAE ] :: [[ thanking dawah efforts of the brothers ]] _0:14:51__ answering question from private chat :: Is mubahala permissible in Islam ?_ 0:18:41 Xyz person [ ex-Muslim - from Hyderabad, India ] :: [[ the "evidence" guy ]] _asks how to verify that Prophet (saws)'s prophecies actually were from him_ 0:51:19 Arshad Hussain Hameed [ Muslim - from Tamil Nadu, India ] :: _asks how the Qur'an was revealed in seven different ways_ 1:04:38 Jackson [ Muslim - from Alabama, USA ] :: [[ has a "speakers' corner" in his barber shop ! ]] _asks about witnesses to Jesus (as)'s death_ [[ discusses different issues ]] _1:24:00__ Mansur joins the panel_ _1:54:11__ spineless Islam-haters cannot even discuss face-to-face rather behave childishly in private-chat section. shame on them !_ 1:55:30 Aagam Boss [ Muslim - from Hyderabad, India ] :: _asks for the background of the hadith regarding a person urinating in a Masajid_ 2:08:36 MaheenAman [ Muslim ] :: [[ discusses that a girl not having menstruation as yet does not determine that she is underage ]] 2:36:42 Juan Martinez [ Christian - from New York, USA ] :: _asks why Muslims have the conception that today's Bible is corrupt_ [[ needs to learn decorum of a discussion ]] _2:48:02__ Mohammad joins the panel_ 2:52:16 sekhar / Akshay [ Hindu - from India ] :: _asks whether our souls made an agreement with God before coming into this world; and if so, then why we don't remember that_ 4:21:12 sheba [ Christian - from Malaysia ] :: [[ from being "soba" to "sheba" ]] _asks for explanation of verse no. 39 of Surah Al-Hajj_ [[ from being "jizyah" to "fight" guy ]] 4:58:48 jay [ Muslim ] :: [[ just thanking the brothers ]] 5:00:51 Ali [ Muslim ] :: _asks for clarification on the hadith regarding eating seven 'Ajwa dates_ [[ asks several other questions ]] 5:20:29 Keshav [ Hindu - from Florida, USA ] :: [[ tries to discuss the issue regarding Ali Dawah, and his wife ]] [[ soap opera is not entertained on this channel, guys ! ]] 6:09:25 Rajeeyah [ Muslimah - from Alabama, USA ] :: [[ tries to refute the misconception about African-American people ]] 6:18:21 Ivo [ Christian ] :: _asks if he has to accept that Muhammad (saws) is the greatest prophet in order to become a Muslim_ [[ a sincere person ]] 7:01:22 Jay [ revert Muslim - from Toronto, Canada ] :: _asks what the intoxication ruling is in Islam_ 7:12:36 Son of the soil [ Christian - from New Zealand ] :: _asks the same old "right hand possesses" question_ [[ discussion on slave issue in Islam, and Christianity ]] 7:46:09 Closing thoughts [[ book recommendation : "Slavery & Islam" - by Jonathan A C Brown ; pdf link : openmaktaba.com/slavery-and-islam/ or openmaktaba.com/wp-content/uploads/books/Islamic-English-Books/otherbooks/islam%20and%20slavery.pdf ]]
@wiktormytych9881 Basically you can pronounce words slightly different.. when people read the qiraat they sort of sing it in a tune and some times the keep there tune in sync they use slight variation of a specific pronunciation of a word. Now this by NO MEANS CHANGES THE QURAN. The variations have names as they was also explained as dialects. Take Bangladeshi language for example in that country there was 2 types of of dialects (could be more it's just what I have cone across) You have Sylehti which they say is a slang language of Shudohh. Both have some same words alot have similar words. Funny thing is the Sylehti can be understood by shodooh people but the other way around is abit tricky. So in arabic they don't seem to have this problem due to design of there language. This demonstrates how all 7 modes although with slight variation has been preserved as we have them today and still has the recite them from the day and age of the prophet pbuh and also have artifacts and manuscripts carbon dated from that time too. Some scholars also say accent back then also played a part like in the UK you have manchester known ans mancqunians and in Birmingham they have there's and down south in London they have there's. Think of that as speech pattern in some areas. Again scholars say this is another way it was preserved as when the quran reached far and wide it didn't change even then.
Sheba you have a problem with God permitting people DEFENDING themselves from the aggressors' attacks!? So you expect people to be sitting ducks and not defend themselves and the weak and oppressed!!? Your objection to someone defending themselves is UNJUST!!
If someone is taking Sahadah ,take him instantly even if another people is already in the call. The motive of this program is to give knowledge & now if someone gets right knowledge and wants to come to islam he/she should be given more priority.
6:33:05 bro Muhammad should've pressed more on how the trinity is not three gods after doing such a good job of establishing the different identities of the three persons
When one is aware of his ego he is no more his personality then he is decisions re free of his personal bias and his actions dont cause him accountability... When you re god concious your actions re not yours(personal).. When not truly concious the world is all it is for a person and then there is duality/conflict..and you do everything in order to protect your assumed self/ego...not knowing this ego is the root of all suffering/conflicts.. For only god concious/non dual only god is that exists... It is a metaphor as said by many poets like to invite god in your heart there must be no one in it even no space for I .. Let there be only god... Then you re liberated in true sense...
Subhanallaah, This is for xyz this an evidence: surah 3 verse 6 ,He is the One Who Shapes you in the wombs of your mothers as He wills. There is no god ‘worthy of worship’ except Him - the Almighty, Al wise.
The absolute perspective or gods perspective... Only god exists... Which means other things "ie the world " just exists in his knowledge like a simulation and is not real in absolute perspective... And nothing is beyond his knowledge...so our own knowing of ourselves is also in god's knowing... No one is god becs our minds can know only it's own content... But since we re in a simulation of god's mind he knows all the perspectives possible in the world... Whether relative to space time or individual consciousness.. The purpose of life is to know god... But god is not a knowledge to be known... Purifying our soul/conciousness by understanding and analysing the ego the ego/nafs is the way to realise that he is watching everything... God is not knowledge.. The answer to who is god is only negation ...neti neti (not this not this) Duality exists only when we assume the world as true... don't understand its reality from the absolute perspective
2:54:12 OMG again a common understanding between islam and advait... i.e. the conciousness itself is a process of particles interaction just like any other particle...we re not different fundamentally from the universe... Particles too re aware to certain extent... The conditioning of the pure conciousness due to body, mind and society... Its difficult to remain truly concious /saakshi bhaav becs till we consider the world real we re mostly like robots just following repeating patterns...to protect our existence/being/ego..becs then there is duality me and the world...the unawareness of "i" am the same as the world and others a biological machine made of matter...nothing special is in me... We re truly concious when we re aware of the functioning of the conciousness/ego and its tendancies and that can be done by separating us from our ownself to look at it without any bias honestly.. When in hopeless calamity a person does not run but looks inward... detaches from the world trying to falsify the world...or maybe if this being of mine/ego(through body mind) didnt exist..i would not suffer... When one is aware of his ego he is no more his personality then he is decisions re free of his personal bias and his actions dont cause him accountability... When you re god concious your actions re not yours(personal).. When not truly concious the world is all it is for a person and then there is duality/conflict..and you do everything in order to protect your assumed self/ego...not knowing this ego is the root of all suffering/conflicts
Your live streams are becoming difficult to listen to because Ibn Hazm can't stop butting in and interfering all the time. It's bad manners. Someone please advise him or bring some other Arabic speaking brother.
@@FirasathHussain-cv5uj Ibn Hazm consistently butts into conversations, whether at speakers corner or on live streams. It's rude and comes across as impolite. Just because he's older and wiser doesn't mean that his bad manners should be tolerated. It sets a bad example. He needs to learn to let someone finish their point before butting in. Its not disrespectful to point out or give advise to brothers or sisters when they're wrong, it's nasihah, the way of the sunnah. Hadith On the authority of Tameem ibn Aus ad-Daree (ra): The Prophet (ﷺ) said, “The deen (religion) is naseehah (advice, sincerity).” We said, “To whom?” He (ﷺ) said, “To Allah, His Book, His Messenger, and to the leaders of the Muslims and their common folk.” [Muslim] Hadith 7, 40 Hadith an-Nawawi Someone close to him needs to politely advise him. You shouldn't be defending peoples bad actions. That makes things worse. When someone gives sincere advice and you don't like it, that's your problem.
Juan thinks the gospels he has today are from eye-witness accounts? How ignorant. They don't even claim to be. And even if they did, there is no evidence to support the internal claim. The gospels themselves contradict each other. Christian scholars themselves admit they've changed and have errors. There is no instruction from Jesus in handling the revelation given to him. He was sent to a particular people at a particular time, thus no need for preserving his book for different people at later times, especially dogs.
What type of nonsense is Br Mohammad peddling about slavery. Can someone please cut it out of the video? "if Muslims come across a community where slavery is present, it is MANDATORY for them to free the slaves" what is the source of this mandatory ruling?
Ivo or Ivan kid it was so funny he said " Joseph & Marry age is Catholic believe in it and he doesn't believe in it" So when it is convenient it is ok. Ahhhhhhmmmm First Church was Catholic and Trinity was also formulated by Catholic. How come IVO you don't reject that? My protestant friend said the same thing. He said we don't believe in Catholic saints extra. So I ask wasn't Paul saint according to Catholic & Catholic were involve in every decision from the inception of Christianity? It said your lord is One. They say three. It say no graven images they created statues and images. It say don't eat pork. They say we will eat it. It say do good works. They say not required. People hate affirmative action because they say it unfair. However, affirmative heaven action they are perfectly fine. We do no works and surely door of heaven will be wide open for our laziness.
@@Superheroeeth Almighty God revealed the Injeel to Prophet Jesus PBUH. What Christians have today are the Gospels according to Matthew, Luke, Mark and John. Lol, who are they!!??
@Superheroeeth Crucifixion did not happen. There is NO eyewitness testimony and NO carbon dated archaelogical evidence. Just hearsay biographies known as Gospels written by anonymous unknown authors.
*Live Q&A - Engage, Challenge, Clarify* || _29 August 2024 ; Thursday_
0:00:13 Stream begins, followed by discussion between Ibn Hazm Al Idrissi, and Hashim
_Discussion with / Questions from guests/chat section_
0:10:20 AdilS [ Muslim - from Kazakhstan; currently working in Abu Dhabi, UAE ] :: [[ thanking dawah efforts of the brothers ]]
_0:14:51__ answering question from private chat :: Is mubahala permissible in Islam ?_
0:18:41 Xyz person [ ex-Muslim - from Hyderabad, India ] :: [[ the "evidence" guy ]] _asks how to verify that Prophet (saws)'s prophecies actually were from him_
0:51:19 Arshad Hussain Hameed [ Muslim - from Tamil Nadu, India ] :: _asks how the Qur'an was revealed in seven different ways_
1:04:38 Jackson [ Muslim - from Alabama, USA ] :: [[ has a "speakers' corner" in his barber shop ! ]] _asks about witnesses to Jesus (as)'s death_ [[ discusses different issues ]]
_1:24:00__ Mansur joins the panel_
_1:54:11__ spineless Islam-haters cannot even discuss face-to-face rather behave childishly in private-chat section. shame on them !_
1:55:30 Aagam Boss [ Muslim - from Hyderabad, India ] :: _asks for the background of the hadith regarding a person urinating in a Masajid_
2:08:36 MaheenAman [ Muslim ] :: [[ discusses that a girl not having menstruation as yet does not determine that she is underage ]]
2:36:42 Juan Martinez [ Christian - from New York, USA ] :: _asks why Muslims have the conception that today's Bible is corrupt_ [[ needs to learn decorum of a discussion ]]
_2:48:02__ Mohammad joins the panel_
2:52:16 sekhar / Akshay [ Hindu - from India ] :: _asks whether our souls made an agreement with God before coming into this world; and if so, then why we don't remember that_
4:21:12 sheba [ Christian - from Malaysia ] :: [[ from being "soba" to "sheba" ]] _asks for explanation of verse no. 39 of Surah Al-Hajj_ [[ from being "jizyah" to "fight" guy ]]
4:58:48 jay [ Muslim ] :: [[ just thanking the brothers ]]
5:00:51 Ali [ Muslim ] :: _asks for clarification on the hadith regarding eating seven 'Ajwa dates_ [[ asks several other questions ]]
5:20:29 Keshav [ Hindu - from Florida, USA ] :: [[ tries to discuss the issue regarding Ali Dawah, and his wife ]] [[ soap opera is not entertained on this channel, guys ! ]]
6:09:25 Rajeeyah [ Muslimah - from Alabama, USA ] :: [[ tries to refute the misconception about African-American people ]]
6:18:21 Ivo [ Christian ] :: _asks if he has to accept that Muhammad (saws) is the greatest prophet in order to become a Muslim_ [[ a sincere person ]]
7:01:22 Jay [ revert Muslim - from Toronto, Canada ] :: _asks what the intoxication ruling is in Islam_
7:12:36 Son of the soil [ Christian - from New Zealand ] :: _asks the same old "right hand possesses" question_ [[ discussion on slave issue in Islam, and Christianity ]]
7:46:09 Closing thoughts [[ book recommendation : "Slavery & Islam" - by Jonathan A C Brown ; pdf link : openmaktaba.com/slavery-and-islam/ or openmaktaba.com/wp-content/uploads/books/Islamic-English-Books/otherbooks/islam%20and%20slavery.pdf ]]
Thanks bro
May Allah reward you
May ALLAH reward you
ﺟﺰﺍﻙ ﺍﻟﻠﻪ ﺧﻴﺮﺍ
The 7 modes of recitation is another proof that the quran has been preserved and not made up in some time after the prophet of islam pbuh.
I don’t understand how this proves preservation, please explain.
@wiktormytych9881 Basically you can pronounce words slightly different.. when people read the qiraat they sort of sing it in a tune and some times the keep there tune in sync they use slight variation of a specific pronunciation of a word. Now this by NO MEANS CHANGES THE QURAN. The variations have names as they was also explained as dialects. Take Bangladeshi language for example in that country there was 2 types of of dialects (could be more it's just what I have cone across) You have Sylehti which they say is a slang language of Shudohh. Both have some same words alot have similar words. Funny thing is the Sylehti can be understood by shodooh people but the other way around is abit tricky.
So in arabic they don't seem to have this problem due to design of there language.
This demonstrates how all 7 modes although with slight variation has been preserved as we have them today and still has the recite them from the day and age of the prophet pbuh and also have artifacts and manuscripts carbon dated from that time too.
Some scholars also say accent back then also played a part like in the UK you have manchester known ans mancqunians and in Birmingham they have there's and down south in London they have there's. Think of that as speech pattern in some areas. Again scholars say this is another way it was preserved as when the quran reached far and wide it didn't change even then.
Sheba you have a problem with God permitting people DEFENDING themselves from the aggressors' attacks!? So you expect people to be sitting ducks and not defend themselves and the weak and oppressed!!? Your objection to someone defending themselves is UNJUST!!
If someone is taking Sahadah ,take him instantly even if another people is already in the call. The motive of this program is to give knowledge & now if someone gets right knowledge and wants to come to islam he/she should be given more priority.
agreedos!
Alhamdulillah
MashaAllah great stream, thanks brothers, may Allah Azzawajal bless you all, ameen.
ameen amigo
Assalaamu alaikum brothers and sisters. hashim arkhee kayfa haaliq
5:53:10 in fact it is more sensible to abuse power in a karma based reincarnation system since you always have the next life to fall back on.
4:19:20 having a fear of hellfire presupposes the creator of hell
❤️ Love ❤️ you ❤️ so ❤️ much ❤️ brother ❤️ Imteyaz ❤️ and ❤️ brother ❤️ Adnan ❤️ may ❤️ Allah ❤️ SWT ❤️ bless ❤️ the ❤️ DawahWise ❤️ team ❤️ Ameen ❤️
ameen
Sheba is cp's student , if am not wrong ,one in a stream he did make the claim
5:32:00 fitra is universal, karma ia supposedly person specific
There is a Japanese man who is interested in Islam. I want him to talk to you and answer his questions. How can he do that? Please
tell him to come to live stream. Every Thursday at around 9.30 pm(IST) this live stream happens. Simply you need to click the link pinned in live chat
may Allah guide him as well as all of us, ameen
وَعَلَيْكُم السَّلَام وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ
6h 23mins caller claimed Jesus was being worshipped in the bible.. source of verse?
Can someone provide a link to the paper of the pophecies dicussed in the stream?
yaqeeninstitute.org/mohammad-elshinawy/the-prophecies-of-prophet-muhammad
@@DawahWise JazakAllahuKhayran
6:33:05 bro Muhammad should've pressed more on how the trinity is not three gods after doing such a good job of establishing the different identities of the three persons
When one is aware of his ego he is no more his personality then he is decisions re free of his personal bias and his actions dont cause him accountability...
When you re god concious your actions re not yours(personal)..
When not truly concious the world is all it is for a person and then there is duality/conflict..and you do everything in order to protect your assumed self/ego...not knowing this ego is the root of all suffering/conflicts..
For only god concious/non dual only god is that exists...
It is a metaphor as said by many poets like to invite god in your heart there must be no one in it even no space for I ..
Let there be only god...
Then you re liberated in true sense...
Subhanallaah, This is for xyz this an evidence: surah 3 verse 6 ,He is the One Who Shapes you in the wombs of your mothers as He wills. There is no god ‘worthy of worship’ except Him - the Almighty, Al wise.
The absolute perspective or gods perspective...
Only god exists...
Which means other things "ie the world " just exists in his knowledge like a simulation and is not real in absolute perspective...
And nothing is beyond his knowledge...so our own knowing of ourselves is also in god's knowing...
No one is god becs our minds can know only it's own content...
But since we re in a simulation of god's mind he knows all the perspectives possible in the world...
Whether relative to space time or individual consciousness..
The purpose of life is to know god...
But god is not a knowledge to be known...
Purifying our soul/conciousness by understanding and analysing the ego the ego/nafs is the way to realise that he is watching everything...
God is not knowledge..
The answer to who is god is only negation ...neti neti (not this not this)
Duality exists only when we assume the world as true... don't understand its reality from the absolute perspective
2:54:12 OMG again a common understanding between islam and advait...
i.e. the conciousness itself is a process of particles interaction just like any other particle...we re not different fundamentally from the universe...
Particles too re aware to certain extent...
The conditioning of the pure conciousness due to body, mind and society...
Its difficult to remain truly concious /saakshi bhaav becs till we consider the world real we re mostly like robots just following repeating patterns...to protect our existence/being/ego..becs then there is duality me and the world...the unawareness of "i" am the same as the world and others a biological machine made of matter...nothing special is in me...
We re truly concious when we re aware of the functioning of the conciousness/ego and its tendancies and that can be done by separating us from our ownself to look at it without any bias honestly..
When in hopeless calamity a person does not run but looks inward... detaches from the world trying to falsify the world...or maybe if this being of mine/ego(through body mind) didnt exist..i would not suffer...
When one is aware of his ego he is no more his personality then he is decisions re free of his personal bias and his actions dont cause him accountability...
When you re god concious your actions re not yours(personal)..
When not truly concious the world is all it is for a person and then there is duality/conflict..and you do everything in order to protect your assumed self/ego...not knowing this ego is the root of all suffering/conflicts
Your live streams are becoming difficult to listen to because Ibn Hazm can't stop butting in and interfering all the time.
It's bad manners.
Someone please advise him or bring some other Arabic speaking brother.
Assalamualaikum, be respectful and tolerant. Nobody is perfect. If you are not able to bear him, there are other dawah streams that you can watch.
@@FirasathHussain-cv5uj
Ibn Hazm consistently butts into conversations, whether at speakers corner or on live streams.
It's rude and comes across as impolite.
Just because he's older and wiser doesn't mean that his bad manners should be tolerated.
It sets a bad example.
He needs to learn to let someone finish their point before butting in.
Its not disrespectful to point out or give advise to brothers or sisters when they're wrong, it's nasihah, the way of the sunnah.
Hadith
On the authority of Tameem ibn Aus ad-Daree (ra):
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, “The deen (religion) is naseehah (advice, sincerity).” We said, “To whom?” He (ﷺ) said, “To Allah, His Book, His Messenger, and to the leaders of the Muslims and their common folk.” [Muslim]
Hadith 7, 40 Hadith an-Nawawi
Someone close to him needs to politely advise him.
You shouldn't be defending peoples bad actions. That makes things worse.
When someone gives sincere advice and you don't like it, that's your problem.
Dawah wise should consider retiring Br Mohammad from the streams
Juan thinks the gospels he has today are from eye-witness accounts? How ignorant. They don't even claim to be. And even if they did, there is no evidence to support the internal claim. The gospels themselves contradict each other. Christian scholars themselves admit they've changed and have errors. There is no instruction from Jesus in handling the revelation given to him. He was sent to a particular people at a particular time, thus no need for preserving his book for different people at later times, especially dogs.
What type of nonsense is Br Mohammad peddling about slavery. Can someone please cut it out of the video?
"if Muslims come across a community where slavery is present, it is MANDATORY for them to free the slaves" what is the source of this mandatory ruling?
Ivo or Ivan kid it was so funny he said " Joseph & Marry age is Catholic believe in it and he doesn't believe in it" So when it is convenient it is ok. Ahhhhhhmmmm First Church was Catholic and Trinity was also formulated by Catholic. How come IVO you don't reject that? My protestant friend said the same thing. He said we don't believe in Catholic saints extra. So I ask wasn't Paul saint according to Catholic & Catholic were involve in every decision from the inception of Christianity? It said your lord is One. They say three. It say no graven images they created statues and images. It say don't eat pork. They say we will eat it. It say do good works. They say not required. People hate affirmative action because they say it unfair. However, affirmative heaven action they are perfectly fine. We do no works and surely door of heaven will be wide open for our laziness.
2:46:04 Bro thought his bibles are Injeel 😅
Injeel is the what talks about Jesus
@@Superheroeeth Almighty God revealed the Injeel to Prophet Jesus PBUH. What Christians have today are the Gospels according to Matthew, Luke, Mark and John. Lol, who are they!!??
2hr 50min christian argues Quran came 600yrs after Christ...but he forgot Gospel came 1300yrs after Torah
@@fidelcatsro6948 gospel came 40-60 years after crucifixion. Not 1300. That is a false ststement
@Superheroeeth
Crucifixion did not happen.
There is NO eyewitness testimony and NO carbon dated archaelogical evidence.
Just hearsay biographies known as Gospels written by anonymous unknown authors.
Torah ie the time of Musa AS. Not the cruciFICTION.
@@Superheroeeth wheres the false statement? read my statement properly
Sheba you are such a dishonest AH.
وَعَلَيْكُم السَّلَام وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ