@@marvinvelasquez1196 Nothing will ever match live musicians playing great music like this - a superb tribute to the original, but there is a better more recent recording out there
Anyone here because you loved this song in the 70's? Whether it's the Temptations or Phil Collins & Company, both are awesome. This is what you call great music.
The original Temptations absolutely. It’s a beautiful piece of music. They reproduce it here well. But go back and listen to the original vocals and the way they intertwined their vocal threads. Phil Collins is a musical genius in his own right. And no one can do his songs like him.
Hi Tom, I don't know if Phil Collins was a big Temps fan (but I'm sure he was). He had a big band and many singers in his background. But to tell my personal truth ... he is only half as good as the original: th-cam.com/video/nXiQtD5gcHU/w-d-xo.html "Papa was a rolling stone" was and is myfavorite songs for ever. I also like the version by George Michael ("Killer"). Greetings from Germany Erwin (I hope you understand my bad english)
I didn't know Phil had so much soul! What an homage to the great music of the 70s!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🎶🎻🎺🪇🥁🎙👌🏾🎸 I first heard of this song while watching The Temptation 🎬 the whole band did a superb job there and Phil's vocals fit perfectly. That trumpet player was badass 🔥
AS A TEENAGER I GREW UP LISTENING TO MOTOWN - AND OF COURSE THE MAGNICIENT TEMPTATIONS - THANK U SO MUSCH PHIL FOR GIVING JUSTICE TO THIS SOUL CLASSIC - '' GOD BLESS TO ALL ''!!!!!!!
damm....phil collins never ceases to amaze me....I already loved his version of "you can't hurry love" from the supremes.....but this....this is a tremendous tribute to one of the best songs of the temptations, and a big love letter to motown....phil, the band, the backing vocals, great work!!!!
That's my friend, Bob Babbitt on bass! He told me about that session the first time we met, at the salon i once worked at! It was the first time i cut his hair. Did his hair for the Motown Session on American Idol. RIP. My friend.
My tears are dropping for this master playing a master music of the legendary Temptations. I always wonder how these groups come together in one accord to sing, play and dance. Awesome
This is EPIC!. Live - capturing the studio ambience touches perfectly. the strings, the voices, the bass, the clapping the ghost of Wah-Wah Watson, straight out the left channel - so true to the original and the bass - HUGE with a bit more TR and grunt- a masters touch In my ATMOS HT, 7.4.6 , upmixed into DSU so clear, some much detail- best cover ever . .
The best Temptation song of them all, no matter were you live , who you are, this song touch a fiber in every men who never had a father figure , powerful song and beat, this have soul
just for a record....No jacket required album ......motown orientated radio stations ignored PC becouse he is, sorry to say, caucasian, and other stations ignored PC because of, sorry to say, afro people playing with him......what a shame
Cette chanson des Temptations m'a habité dès l'instant où je l'ai entendue la première fois, elle ne m'a plus jamais quitté, et un jour j'ai tenu la promesse que je m'étais faite : Arriver par bateau à New-York en appuyant sur la touche " Play " de mon Walkman, en voyant s'approcher petit à petit la Statue de la Liberté avec des frissons dans tout le corps... Je n'oublierais jamais ce matin là, ni cette ville, ni ce pays. " It was the third of September..."😉
You Go! MR. Phil Collins! You are the ONLY musical artist that can pull off doing the Temptations song! You think Peter Gabriel can pull it off too? JUST KIDDING! Your remake of "Papa Was A Rolling Stone" was absolutely sensational!!!!! I will play this often! You got a lot of SOUL Mr. Collins! God Bless you!
It was a much better cover than I thought it would be. The string and horn instrumental backup along with the Black singers made it more authentic.good job, Phil
Passing this onto the next generation (my daughter). Wow,I've always loved this song but what a cover version. Phil ,always puts his own twist. Brilliant!!
My goodness, this was a great rendition. I don't know if you guys noticed but the guy Terron Brooks is in the background played Eddie Kendricks in the Temptations Movie. That band played the hell outta this song....job well done!!!!
All I’ll say is this..at least legends like Phil are still around in 2022…most are gone. Jackson, Whitney, Prince, and the man who brought me to this video, who covered this track better than anybody else, George Michael.
if we could add a Bass for this, it would be amazing. Can we get a shot out for Phil using members of the Funk Brothers for some of the band? thats outstanding.
Fantásticamente sorprendente!!! Un gran tema con una sola nota, pero con un desarrollo tonal muy bien logrado. Phil Collins junto a una gran orquesta. Aplausos desde Chile.
Es una súper pieza musical. Los instrumentos súper bien armonizados! Es una gran composición! Muy bien interpretada! Lo único que me pone triste es el mensaje 😢
I love the Bass in this song. ❤❤❤
Todos esos instrumentos están en vías de extinción con la nueva música.
@@marvinvelasquez1196
Nothing will ever match live musicians playing great music like this - a superb tribute to the original, but there is a better more recent recording out there
Anyone here because you loved this song in the 70's? Whether it's the Temptations or Phil Collins & Company, both are awesome. This is what you call great music.
Just found this version and was worried about Phil's vocal to this. Great cover,great band backing him up.
The original Temptations absolutely. It’s a beautiful piece of music. They reproduce it here well. But go back and listen to the original vocals and the way they intertwined their vocal threads. Phil Collins is a musical genius in his own right. And no one can do his songs like him.
@@baggykev I thought the same, however Phil,s vocals are amazing 🤩 and the band also 🙌
10.2022, and on .
Classic
The original bass player, Bob Bobbitt, is playing bass on this set.
Gooooosebumps! One of the best covers! To be honest, nothin' can beat the original Temptations.
That Trumpet player…….awesome!!!!!! ENCORE!!!!!
Oh my god . This has totally changed my life , only 63 just now . Xxxxxxx
Nah too late you're fucked 😂
Phil was a big Temps fan. It's a tribute and he does pretty darn good with excellent backup.
Hi Tom,
I don't know if Phil Collins was a big Temps fan (but I'm sure he was).
He had a big band and many singers in his background.
But to tell my personal truth ... he is only half as good as the original:
th-cam.com/video/nXiQtD5gcHU/w-d-xo.html
"Papa was a rolling stone" was and is myfavorite songs for ever.
I also like the version by George Michael ("Killer").
Greetings from Germany
Erwin
(I hope you understand my bad english)
@@erwin3274 thanks for your reply. Very good english. Phil was for sure a motown fan. He did versions of other motown songs as well.
I didn't know Phil had so much soul! What an homage to the great music of the 70s!👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾🎶🎻🎺🪇🥁🎙👌🏾🎸 I first heard of this song while watching The Temptation 🎬 the whole band did a superb job there and Phil's vocals fit perfectly. That trumpet player was badass 🔥
One of the best tunes ever laid down on vinyl.
So close to perfection, briljant👌🙌🙌🙌
AS A TEENAGER I GREW UP LISTENING TO MOTOWN - AND OF COURSE THE MAGNICIENT TEMPTATIONS - THANK U SO MUSCH PHIL FOR GIVING JUSTICE TO THIS SOUL CLASSIC - '' GOD BLESS TO ALL ''!!!!!!!
💙 Wooow, what a blast from the past!! 😃 I sure miss that music from the good ole days! Thankyou Phil for bringing it back!!🥰😘
That is fantastic,first time I ever heard Phil do this song !!!!!!
damm....phil collins never ceases to amaze me....I already loved his version of "you can't hurry love" from the supremes.....but this....this is a tremendous tribute to one of the best songs of the temptations, and a big love letter to motown....phil, the band, the backing vocals, great work!!!!
really??? HAHAHA 😅 please stop LYING!!! lol 🤣🤣🤣
That's my friend, Bob Babbitt on bass! He told me about that session the first time we met, at the salon i once worked at! It was the first time i cut his hair. Did his hair for the Motown Session on American Idol. RIP. My friend.
My tears are dropping for this master playing a master music of the legendary Temptations. I always wonder how these groups come together in one accord to sing, play and dance. Awesome
This is EPIC!. Live - capturing the studio ambience touches perfectly. the strings, the voices, the bass, the clapping
the ghost of Wah-Wah Watson, straight out the left channel -
so true to the original
and the bass - HUGE with a bit more TR and grunt- a masters touch
In my ATMOS HT, 7.4.6 , upmixed into DSU so clear, some much detail- best cover ever . .
i think that the bass player was one of the funk brothers, after jamison..
Anything that involves many,many musicians playing together and obviously loving every note is always going to work. Devine. X
Some of those musicians are from the original Motown band they called "The Funk Brothers" They played all the Motown music.
The best Temptation song of them all, no matter were you live , who you are, this song touch a fiber in every men who never had a father figure , powerful song and beat, this have soul
He has been one of the best.
Agree.
👍💪🤝🇷🇺
Phil, you are a true legend and not a racist ....thank you very much for your contribution and may God truly bless you. Amen.
Phil. Happens. Happens. Very. Nice
just for a record....No jacket required album ......motown orientated radio stations ignored PC becouse he is, sorry to say, caucasian, and other stations ignored PC because of, sorry to say, afro people playing with him......what a shame
@@damirhlobik6488 WTF POLITICS
PERFECT RENDITION Sir Philip Collins👏👏👏👏
Do it Phil!!! The orchestra is fantastic too!👍👍👍👍👍
Wow, what a fabulous rendition of one of my favourite songs!
Papás hijos mucho ke rolón ea
Cette chanson des Temptations m'a habité dès l'instant où je l'ai entendue la première fois, elle ne m'a plus jamais quitté, et un jour j'ai tenu la promesse que je m'étais faite : Arriver par bateau à New-York en appuyant sur la touche " Play " de mon Walkman, en voyant s'approcher petit à petit la Statue de la Liberté avec des frissons dans tout le corps... Je n'oublierais jamais ce matin là, ni cette ville, ni ce pays. " It was the third of September..."😉
Any one listening to the song in 2024
Phil was great and That trumpet player was wicked good!
Ogod !!!my dear pjill colins i love this song till today !!!bravo my friend !! Unforgatable Temptetions!!!!
Superb rendition of the greatest song. Bravo.
A man in a suit just sings. The Temptations brought feelings to me in a unique way.
greatest intro to a song ever! real music unlike what we have today!
Thank You mr Phil collins I am impressed! Seen you in concert lots! Never blown me away this hard!!! You are bad ads!!!!
You Go! MR. Phil Collins! You are the ONLY musical artist that can pull off doing the Temptations song! You think Peter Gabriel can pull it off too? JUST KIDDING! Your remake of "Papa Was A Rolling Stone" was absolutely sensational!!!!! I will play this often! You got a lot of SOUL Mr. Collins! God Bless you!
Rock, pop, ballads ... Phil Collins can do it all
Such Electrifying ..Live Performances... I Just Do Not want to miss.
Only The great Phil Collins can pull off a classic like this..👍
Lmao this was terrible
Daryl Hall did a great job!
please don't LIE .. HAHAHA 🤣🤣🤣
Klasse das er sich an diesen Song rantraut .Gut gemacht
What a cover!!! Thanks Phil
It was a much better cover than I thought it would be. The string and horn instrumental backup along with the Black singers made it more authentic.good job, Phil
Phil, you are almost there ......thank you for the remake ....you are good ....thank you bro.
Passing this onto the next generation (my daughter).
Wow,I've always loved this song but what a cover version.
Phil ,always puts his own twist. Brilliant!!
We miss you Phil C. Big hugs to you, Happy Easter❤
Funk Brothers great addition!
Honestly this came on my feed.. I
Sooooo… glad I didn’t dismiss this…PC is a genius…. God blessed
Magnifique, je n avais jamais entendu Phil Collins chanter cela .
My radio 😮❤❤
I Love Phil Collins just Outstanding on many levels ❤❤❤❤
And never tire of this song !!!!
PHIL COLLINS est aussi surprenant que bon dans cette superbe reprise des TEMPTATIONS .
Mr . Phil Collins can at anytime surround himself with some of the best musicians in the world.
Mr.Collins, YOU, did it.
I was listening to it be Temptations and I saw that PHIL COLLINS did a version of it. Had to see for myself. I am a fan of Collins ❤️
With some of the original Funk Brothers it sounds incredible well.
Buenas noches. Impresionante interpretacion. Un genio de la música Phil Collins.
Great Phill Collins, Now that you Are Suffering I Haven’t Forget You, See You in Heaven , Old Gilbert ❤️🩹
Soy Cubano y me encanta esa canción.gracias
Bravo Monsieur Collins. Je suis et resterai un de vos plus grand fan. Encore merci de traverser ma vie
Incredible redo, deserves a thousand-times more views, and the Trumpet...up close finger-piston-play...WOW!!!
Beautiful!
Nothing like the 70's music 🎶
Guy with a trombone ❤❤😮😮
First time seeing PC perform this song. I knew the song because I have vinyl of The Ohio Players called Honey that includes it.
My goodness, this was a great rendition. I don't know if you guys noticed but the guy Terron Brooks is in the background played Eddie Kendricks in the Temptations Movie. That band played the hell outta this song....job well done!!!!
I did not notice that. They killed it!
Excellent Phil Collins..¡¡
Q buena musica de los 70 con esta rolas conoci la buena musica sana
I didn’t know that he did this song 😮 it is awesome Merry Christmas to all❤🎉
All I’ll say is this..at least legends like Phil are still around in 2022…most are gone. Jackson, Whitney, Prince, and the man who brought me to this video, who covered this track better than anybody else, George Michael.
I love the INTRODUCTION with crispy trumpet sound
great song, great instrumentals... what a legend!...
KILLER!!!!!!!!!!
Norman davenport yeah!!!
Jacqui Crawford €;-)
True legend. Legendary song, legendary performer. True.
very good cover !!! amazing music by the magical 70s group
Phill Genius....amazing music.....supreme trumpet...🙂
Que espetáculo! Performance maravilhosa do Phill e dos instrumentistas.
correct., correcto.
Love everything Temptations a hauntingly beautiful intro , one of the best , Funk Brothers , yeah great
The Temptations would be proud! I hope Dennis Edwards heard this cover from Phil!
Yay an artist that takes on the 70s ...well done Phil ❤
Great song..... thank you Phill !
La canción es tan extraordinaria que casi cualquiera que la cante es sensacional.... E interpretada por Phil es un regalo al oído
A life as in song i had me. But i loved and i love papa, even he died. Thank Phill for interpretation. Allways it impress me
Very good Phil.
Fantastic song . Then and now .
A MASTERPIECE
Brilliant concert called going back ace .
The onions got me... wow.. I can not help it but tear up..
No conocia esta version con Phil Collins..muy buena..!!
Antes solo la de George Michael
Dos grandes de la musica.,!!
Thank U
Igual yo!
So glad I ran across this one.
Not a bad rendition from Phil Collins not bad at all quite impressed good job Phil Collins
That's Terron Brooks singing in the background. Terron Brooks played Eddie Kendrick(s) in The Temptations miniseries.
Superbe version de cette merveilleuse chanson. De la musique, de la vraie
simply stunning, wow, big fan of PC
Phil loved motown
yes indeed,great rendition,great music, collins a lover of RB music does it great..
Wow the instrument is very strong love this big up mr collins Dannis edwards is smiling in heaven
The besttttt❤❤❤ grandioso😊😊😊
Maravillosa interpretación de Phill Collins...el trompetista fabuloso,el bajo sensacional!!!
Si, correcto.
My heart is bursting with amazement. It's a blast rendetion
if we could add a Bass for this, it would be amazing. Can we get a shot out for Phil using members of the Funk Brothers for some of the band? thats outstanding.
Fantásticamente sorprendente!!!
Un gran tema con una sola nota, pero con un desarrollo tonal muy bien logrado. Phil Collins junto a una gran orquesta. Aplausos desde Chile.
best version ...ever!
Not the Temptations but you did a wonderful job ... ❤️
A damn good version....
Fantástica orquestación. La recuerdo. Tegucigalpa, Honduras.
Es una súper pieza musical. Los instrumentos súper bien armonizados! Es una gran composición! Muy bien interpretada! Lo único que me pone triste es el mensaje 😢
Una tragedia de tipo social hecha obra maestra.
Now, this is great music!❤❤❤