Ambas son increíbles, pero realmente no sé si vale la pena compararlas una es mezzo y otrs soprano....., sin dudar el timbre de voz y la capacidad vocal son asombrosas en ambas!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tarja junto a Nightwish son legendarios en el metal. La voz de Tarja produce muchas cosas y ella es una de las pocas cantantes que son más potentes en vivo, que en el cd.
Simone es buena aunque en vivo desafina un poco pero por mas buena que sea le faltara mucho para alcanzar a Tarja para mi ella es la mejor cantante femenina del metal es una diosa
Simone is definetly better at translating pure emotion with her voice. She has that godess stage presence which is probably second only to Floor Jansen. With Tarja it's very hard to judge. I'll just say this. Tarja easily takes it as an opera singer, while Simone takes it as a metal singer. Overall I just like Simmons more. Tarja is known for being a prima donna. She never did much for Nightwish aside from singing the parts which Tommas wrote for her. While Simone worked hard over the years to develop a much more versitile range, wrote a couple of songs herself. She went miles ahead from her first album, while Tarja kinda always stayed in this comfortable spot where she had to do the operatic parts, thus never bothering to develop a more raw singing style.
They both have a beautiful voice!! Tarja has a really clear, strong and powerful voice (and she sings really well in live too).. Simone has a very nice delicate voice..(and some times i don't like her singing live).. I must choose Tarja.. Forza tarjaaaaaaaa =) =) =)
I just tried to take part of songs where their voices are more similar. it was difficult because obviously they are different. I try to compared them when they don't sing too differently. I should have taken other songs or other parts but they will result so different that they won't be comparable!
Cuando Tarja la vea alcanzar una nota D6 a toda potencia por 8 segundos como lo hace Floor en The Phantom of The Opera o vea a Simone mantener sus notas más altas en vivo sin desafinar y el desenvolvimiento escénico de Sharon den Adel en los conciertos entonces te voy a creer.
You know what? They are both wonderful to me, 'cause guess what? Simone was influenced by Tarja's album Oceanborn, and this is why she decided to sing Symphonic after learning to sing in the style of Popular Music. But, to me, Simone took it a step further...pretty much every song Simone made could be said to be a #1 Hit in some way. It's hard to believe she is singing even these background vocals or even the main vocals - so ethereal! She is just SO skilled a vocalist, and you'll NEVER lose interest in Epica. So, rock that hair, Mrs. Simons-Palotai!
en lo personal me gusta mucho simone me recuerda buenos tiempos ya que fue una de las primeras que empese a escuchar despues tarja pero como tenian el mismo genero me gusto un poco mas pero soy fiel a simone, aun asi no se le quita la hermosura a las 2, que guapas
El timbre, el tono inocente y tierno de simone, suave, y tan fino... lo adoro, pero tarja, tarja tiene su hermosisima voz tambien, su tono mas a lo musica clasica, o opera, a mi gusto, prefiero a simone :3
The thing that makes Tarja special is that she has conservatoire music studies from Finland, Germany and Argentina. She took the music as a passion and a serious job. It could be better for any artist to have music backgrounds in order to deliver to their fans better songs with more quality. If Simone had such kind of preparation, she would have a better voice.
SImone Simons!! She has an amazing voice and sings beautifully live, she is gorgeous. But more than that... She connects with the audience. You can tell she really loves her fans. Tarja has an amazing voice but I get the feeling it's more about her. Not to put her down AT ALL. I think she's awesome. But she is more negative in her messages as opposed to Simone who encourages and teaches people. I think they're both awesome but I'm gonna have to say Simone.
Ambas son geniales. Personalmente me gusta más Simone, porque es mi mismo tipo de voz, y puedo practicar perfectamente con sus canciones... Conocí primero a Tarja, pero Simone se la lleva...
Tarja has a very deep and divine voice. She was born to sing in a group like Nightwish, she's just perfect for the Symphonic Metal. Simone is just an angel, her voice is something sweet and powerful at the same time. Simone was inspired by Tarja, so here we have the Mother of the Symphonic Metal and the Daughter.
Me parece que ambas son excelentes cantantes... Tarja es una soprano clasica con un perfil vocal de 3 octavas, y si sumamos el hecho de que estudio mucho el repertorio de los mezzosopranos tenemos un rango de vos muy amplio y una voz muy potente. Simone es una mezzosoprano por lo cual necesita un poco de ayuda con las notas altas pero logra un voz de soprano alternando su voz de pecho con su voz lirica.
I prefer BOTH. Lol. Nightwish makes me discover Epica. But I've became more an Epica fan not just because of her looks but her sweet voice. Not as high and technical as Tarja's but lovely and pleasant to listen to. I go for SIMONE!
There is a reason everyone compares Tarja with everyone, because she is the best. All the greats vs T. Tarja made the mark and is still the mark. A force to be reckoned with the original force if you like.
I like both, but if I have to chose, Tarja is the better one of the two. Simone is good, but Tarja is the mark you compare any other vocalist of the genre to and she has been unmatched ever since.
Они обе по своему уникальные и профессиональные Нет смысла обсуждать.Они дополняют друг друга.Сдесь надо объединить Два уникальных голоса и найти общую гармонию .
Tarja is one of the greatest operish singers of the 21st sanctuary.She is perfect on live stage wile Simone makes lots of mistakes but on the other hand,Simone is so beautiful and sexy that no one really care about her mistakes.Tarja is beautiful too so ,for me she is pure perfectness.
It is a difficult choice to make, both incredible singers..! I like both Epica and Nightwish even though I don't listen to them since Tarja left. So I say draw. Both with out of this world voices and let me say this - looks aren't all so for the people choosing Simone because she's hotter, YOU DON'T KNOW JACK S*IT ABOUT MUSIC!!! Just imagine though a duet with Tarja and Simone.. o.o :3
Concuerdo en que Simone contrajo una enfermedad de las vías respiratorias pero eso fue en el 2008, actualmente está totalmente recuperada, y en lo de la pérdida de técnica vocal no estoy hablando de que no alcance las notas altas, si no que se está dejando influenciar por muchas cosas y eso se nota en su canto, además si uno no le pone interés a lo que hace termina fracasando.
I don't really think there is a 'better.' Both great singers, on every level. They do what they have to do, and they do it in a fucking awesome way. And both very beautiful women too (not that that's of any importance to the music, but I couldn't just ignore that fact right?)
A la mierda los que tratan mal a Simone. Ambas son hermosas y cantan excelente. Sin embargo yo me quedo con Simone, su voz es mas dulce y te hace sentir mas cosas que cuando escuchas a tarja, ademas de las letras. Es mi opinion. Ademas, Simone a pesar de ser menos estudiada y mas joven que Tarja en edad y carrera musical se ha ganado un gran respeto en el mundo de el metal. Ella es una de las diosas del metal duelale a quien le duela, asi que no la insulten estupidos!
simone es sexi guapa pero en voz es como un gorrión pero tarja si es bonita para los ojos de nosotros sus fan pero es cono el aguila el condor grande en su voz dificil de olvidar
Epica is my favourite band so I prefer Simone without doubt but I really like Nightwish too.You should have taken Death of a Dream,Simone's voice in that song is AWESOME.
Instead of comparing them they should do a song together, that would be awesome.
Ambas son increíbles, pero realmente no sé si vale la pena compararlas una es mezzo y otrs soprano....., sin dudar el timbre de voz y la capacidad vocal son asombrosas en ambas!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tarja junto a Nightwish son legendarios en el metal. La voz de Tarja produce muchas cosas y ella es una de las pocas cantantes que son más potentes en vivo, que en el cd.
TARJAAAAA 😘😘
Simone es buena aunque en vivo desafina un poco pero por mas buena que sea le faltara mucho para alcanzar a Tarja para mi ella es la mejor cantante femenina del metal es una diosa
its stupid to compare, tarja is soprano and Simone is mezzo soprano.
Tarjista forever!!!
Excelentes las dos soprano y mezosoprano cada quien en su estilo ¡¡¡ las amo ¡¡
Simone is definetly better at translating pure emotion with her voice. She has that godess stage presence which is probably second only to Floor Jansen. With Tarja it's very hard to judge. I'll just say this. Tarja easily takes it as an opera singer, while Simone takes it as a metal singer. Overall I just like Simmons more. Tarja is known for being a prima donna. She never did much for Nightwish aside from singing the parts which Tommas wrote for her. While Simone worked hard over the years to develop a much more versitile range, wrote a couple of songs herself. She went miles ahead from her first album, while Tarja kinda always stayed in this comfortable spot where she had to do the operatic parts, thus never bothering to develop a more raw singing style.
They both have a beautiful voice!!
Tarja has a really clear, strong and powerful voice (and she sings really well in live too)..
Simone has a very nice delicate voice..(and some times i don't like her singing live)..
I must choose Tarja..
Forza tarjaaaaaaaa =) =) =)
Me quedo con Tarja Turunen. Indudablemente tiene una voz preciosa y muy fuerte.
I just tried to take part of songs where their voices are more similar. it was difficult because obviously they are different. I try to compared them when they don't sing too differently. I should have taken other songs or other parts but they will result so different that they won't be comparable!
Oh, come on! Don't make one more holy-war!!! Both are great as well as Floor or Lori or Sharon den Adel and others goddesses of female metal stage.
Well, I prefer the Simone's timbre because it's sweet, but the Tarja's singing technique is better.
Tarja!!! i like that she play more with her voice!, she inspires me a lot!
Both are wonderful singers. Simone it's because Tarja 🤩
I love both of them! They are beautyfull singers! But for me, Tarja is the Queen of metal!!!
Tarja and Simone are both Great!!
Tarja best of the best.
Simone : Beautiful
Tarja : Beautiful and the best singer of the world
Although i love queen simone . but still , Tarja's voice is way beyond comparisons, PERIOD.
Tarja!
passaria uma eternidade toda escutando essas duas anjos cantando para mim.
wahoooo me quedo con las dosss de verdadd queee las dosss me encantann sus vocess no las comparo con ningunaaa otraaa
Tarja tiene una voz mas potente! Nadie canta como ella! en cambio como simone hay varias, Floor Sharon etc!
Cuando Tarja la vea alcanzar una nota D6 a toda potencia por 8 segundos como lo hace Floor en The Phantom of The Opera o vea a Simone mantener sus notas más altas en vivo sin desafinar y el desenvolvimiento escénico de Sharon den Adel en los conciertos entonces te voy a creer.
@@TheWatcherofsky Simone Simons Omega Alive, sin desafinar el mejor livestream, ha mejorado muchísimo, que Within y Nigthwish ahí está tú respuesta,
No puedo decidir!!! las dos me super gustan!!!
You know what? They are both wonderful to me, 'cause guess what? Simone was influenced by Tarja's album Oceanborn, and this is why she decided to sing Symphonic after learning to sing in the style of Popular Music. But, to me, Simone took it a step further...pretty much every song Simone made could be said to be a #1 Hit in some way. It's hard to believe she is singing even these background vocals or even the main vocals - so ethereal! She is just SO skilled a vocalist, and you'll NEVER lose interest in Epica. So, rock that hair, Mrs. Simons-Palotai!
I Love them both, but Simone will be my favorite singer forever!
You can't compare a Soprano and a Mezzo, it's so unfair. Sopranos can be compared to each other, specially if they have the same type of voice
simone simons i love she is .... wow
I cannot decide who is the best because they both are!
SIMONE SIMONS FOREVER !!!
Tarja... You can't compare. I absolutely LOVE Simone, she's my idol, but as singer Tarja is something inexplicable.
Simone is superb singing Cry for the Moon ! Lovely voice too ..
No hay ganadora las 2 son extremadamente excelentes
Tarja was the inspiration for Simone Floor Jansen and many others I do not know can compare
I prefer Simone but both are extremely talented
I love both very much, they have amazing voices
I love Simone she is the queen of metal and is very beatiful
en lo personal me gusta mucho simone me recuerda buenos tiempos ya que fue una de las primeras que empese a escuchar despues tarja pero como tenian el mismo genero me gusto un poco mas pero soy fiel a simone, aun asi no se le quita la hermosura a las 2, que guapas
Ush *w* Simone & Tarja mis idolas definitivamente :'D
Simone Simons es una diosa
SIMONE IS BETTER
HAs to be Tarja,,simone sings realty well but the chills come from T
Both
El timbre, el tono inocente y tierno de simone, suave, y tan fino... lo adoro, pero tarja, tarja tiene su hermosisima voz tambien, su tono mas a lo musica clasica, o opera, a mi gusto, prefiero a simone :3
faço de suas palavras as minhas
SIMONE IS THE BEST
The thing that makes Tarja special is that she has conservatoire music studies from Finland, Germany and Argentina. She took the music as a passion and a serious job. It could be better for any artist to have music backgrounds in order to deliver to their fans better songs with more quality. If Simone had such kind of preparation, she would have a better voice.
Simone!!! Simone is the best!
simone simons the best!!!!!!!!!!!
Simone simons 4Ever =)
SImone Simons!! She has an amazing voice and sings beautifully live, she is gorgeous. But more than that... She connects with the audience. You can tell she really loves her fans.
Tarja has an amazing voice but I get the feeling it's more about her. Not to put her down AT ALL. I think she's awesome. But she is more negative in her messages as opposed to Simone who encourages and teaches people.
I think they're both awesome but I'm gonna have to say Simone.
Both of them are awsome
Tarja is technically better, but for me Simone has a more beautiful voice and tone. Anyway, I love both. They both have angelic voices!
Ambas son geniales. Personalmente me gusta más Simone, porque es mi mismo tipo de voz, y puedo practicar perfectamente con sus canciones... Conocí primero a Tarja, pero Simone se la lleva...
Tarja is unmatched ❤
Simone
Tarja has a very deep and divine voice. She was born to sing in a group like Nightwish, she's just perfect for the Symphonic Metal.
Simone is just an angel, her voice is something sweet and powerful at the same time. Simone was inspired by Tarja, so here we have the Mother of the Symphonic Metal and the Daughter.
I
simoneeeeeeeeeee ♥♥♥♥ love herrrrrrrrrr
Me parece que ambas son excelentes cantantes... Tarja es una soprano clasica con un perfil vocal de 3 octavas, y si sumamos el hecho de que estudio mucho el repertorio de los mezzosopranos tenemos un rango de vos muy amplio y una voz muy potente.
Simone es una mezzosoprano por lo cual necesita un poco de ayuda con las notas altas pero logra un voz de soprano alternando su voz de pecho con su voz lirica.
excelente deducción lastima que se separo de su grupo tarja porque ninguno de los dos puede sin el otro
simooooone
simooooone
simone is number one
my opinion no critics please
Both are terrifics.. singers and females.. In between lies my heart
I prefer BOTH. Lol. Nightwish makes me discover Epica. But I've became more an Epica fan not just because of her looks but her sweet voice. Not as high and technical as Tarja's but lovely and pleasant to listen to. I go for SIMONE!
pues la verdad me gusta mas la voz de Simone
aunque Tarja sea genial
LOL, 0:06 Nemesis
no deberian compararlas las dos tienen voz de angeles..... ELlas cantan hermosoooo¡¡
Have they ever done a song together? Cuz they totally should!
Why put them against each other!? I love them both!!!
There is a reason everyone compares Tarja with everyone, because she is the best. All the greats vs T. Tarja made the mark and is still the mark. A force to be reckoned with the original force if you like.
lamento contradecirte, aunque respeto tu opinion la vi en vivo a Simone y la voz es increiblemente perfecta....
I like both, but if I have to chose, Tarja is the better one of the two. Simone is good, but Tarja is the mark you compare any other vocalist of the genre to and she has been unmatched ever since.
Они обе по своему уникальные и профессиональные Нет смысла обсуждать.Они дополняют друг друга.Сдесь надо объединить Два уникальных голоса и найти общую гармонию .
I absolutely love both bands, but I must give the edge to Simone Simons because her voice is simply that of an angel.
las dos tarja y simone somons
5:56 - I may need to lower my contrast, 'cause...WOW! Look at that...BEAUTIFUL hair!
Tarja!!
I love them both and I can't say who better sings.. they are so different, but has similar styles. Great. That's all..;p
Tarja is one of the greatest operish singers of the 21st sanctuary.She is perfect on live stage wile Simone makes lots of mistakes but on the other hand,Simone is so beautiful and sexy that no one really care about her mistakes.Tarja is beautiful too so ,for me she is pure perfectness.
@kevingthompson13 Your comment is the best !Agree!
Tarja for me...but I love both..
Οh by the way...27/5/12! CAN'T WAIT :)
@orlyane thank you so much =)
TARJA TURUNEN simply THE VOICE of the music.
It is a difficult choice to make, both incredible singers..! I like both Epica and Nightwish even though I don't listen to them since Tarja left. So I say draw. Both with out of this world voices and let me say this - looks aren't all so for the people choosing Simone because she's hotter, YOU DON'T KNOW JACK S*IT ABOUT MUSIC!!! Just imagine though a duet with Tarja and Simone.. o.o :3
Concuerdo en que Simone contrajo una enfermedad de las vías respiratorias pero eso fue en el 2008, actualmente está totalmente recuperada, y en lo de la pérdida de técnica vocal no estoy hablando de que no alcance las notas altas, si no que se está dejando influenciar por muchas cosas y eso se nota en su canto, además si uno no le pone interés a lo que hace termina fracasando.
I don't really think there is a 'better.' Both great singers, on every level.
They do what they have to do, and they do it in a fucking awesome way.
And both very beautiful women too (not that that's of any importance to the music, but I couldn't just ignore that fact right?)
I love both, I want to be like them when I grow up :')
I can't compare these two singers, both are as great as the other.
A la mierda los que tratan mal a Simone. Ambas son hermosas y cantan excelente. Sin embargo yo me quedo con Simone, su voz es mas dulce y te hace sentir mas cosas que cuando escuchas a tarja, ademas de las letras. Es mi opinion. Ademas, Simone a pesar de ser menos estudiada y mas joven que Tarja en edad y carrera musical se ha ganado un gran respeto en el mundo de el metal. Ella es una de las diosas del metal duelale a quien le duela, asi que no la insulten estupidos!
Love them both, i cant say one is better than the other, but I will say this, Simone blows Tarja out of the water in the looks department.
Simone
TARJAAAAAAA
Tarja
simone es sexi guapa pero en voz es como un gorrión pero tarja si es bonita para los ojos de nosotros sus fan pero es cono el aguila el condor grande en su voz dificil de olvidar
What's the song at the start?
Me parece q en una revista de Gotica Simone dijo q Tarja fue una gran influeincia para ella y q por eso empezo a cantar
@metalerablack Okay, well hope it DOES happen one day :) Thanks!
@tomavroxricopcaro Thanks so much!!
Epica is my favourite band so I prefer Simone without doubt but I really like Nightwish too.You should have taken Death of a Dream,Simone's voice in that song is AWESOME.
SIMONE forever!!!!!!!!!!!!!!