All i can say is thank God for Steve hackett and his band wow they are amazing genius musician's and thank you steve for keeping the Genesis sound alive and a big thank you too nick n lex from ian over in the UK
Steve Hackett is a greatly under rated musician. He has done some live concerts on dvd in recent years, well worth a look. Another favourite cover Steve did is the haunting prog rock, Court of the crimsom king, i think nearly as good as the original. As a genesis fan, i have seen them several times in concert in uk, at Wembly, Knebworth, Milton Keynes over the years. Thank you for reviewing.
Genesis and Steve’s version of them, is orchestrated to the tee. Each guy knows his part, like an orchestra, and blended together is incredible. This is why I love prog!!!
I only recently gave Steve a chance and WOW. They are so good. I am glad Hackett is keeping this great prog music alive......LIVE. Need to see this live. Hope he comes to Denver soon.
Another superb reaction guys,just a reminder that i mentioned Nad Sylvans amazing talent as not just a vocalist but also a songwriter a while ago now and referred to a track off his .Spiritus Mundi album entitled 'You've got to find a way' where both Steve Hackett and Guthrie Govan ,both close friends of Sylvan and feature on the track with the most amazing 5 minute guitar solos,you really should give it a listen guys.Nad Sylvan is so underrated and this track just puts him on the pedestal he deserves,give it a listen,i am sure you will just love it.
He's also done some pretty good progressive solo albums - Courting The Widow (2015) and The Bride Said No (2017) coming to mind first. He definitely is a fine story teller, songwriter and multi-instrumentalist. (And I watched this video in Finland)
Watching from the UK. The Firth of Fifth reaction came out yesterday and this reaction hit 5 hours ago here. I'm so glad you have relistened to 'Squonk' Nick, and re-evaluated the song. I think we all knew you would come around sooner or later! This was in Manchester where I'll be seeing Steve in October. So exciting. Thanks guys!!!
I'm so glad that I've seen Steve Hackett perform about 15 times by now, unfortunately never with Genesis though. The energy is always there. The band is always top notch. Last time so far was last July in Zoetermeer, Netherlands (he played 4 nights in a row). At the time of this performance he was 71 (born in 1950). Saw Genesis live in 1978 in Maastricht (NL), Leiden 1981 (NL), Brussels 1982 (B), Rotterdam 1987 (NL), Rotterdam 1992 (NL), Rotterdam 1997 (NL), Amsterdam 2007 (NL), Düsseldorf 2007 (D) and Amsterdam 2022 (NL).
So glad you are reacting to Steve’s band. They are fantastic live. However I prefer the Genesis live version of Squonk on Seconds Out. I saw your initial reaction on Patron and said that you need to give it a chance through repeated listening. So glad you did as Squonk is one of my Favourite Genesis tracks.
Adding to my comment: I’ve seen Genesis at least 8 times, starting with Trick of the Tail in 76 through the 92 double album tour We can’t dance. Had tickets to the Lamb tour in 75 ($6.00 tickets) in Dallas, but cancelled because of lack of interest. Imagine that!! Seen Steve 3 times starting in 79 with the Spectral Morning tour, still have the program signed by him. Once in LA back in 2014 and last April in Dallas. He still has it!!! You have a lot to explore with Hackett.
The track is my youth...we listened to it over and over again in the party cellar! As the third song on the first concept album after the Gabriel era, Squonk is Phil Collins' vocal baptism of fire! After PG left, they were desperately looking for a singer...and couldn't find a suitable one! Collins himself didn't think it was possible at the time that he would be responsible for the band's fortunes and success with his double part! Since a lot of material had obviously been processed, which was crowned by an incredible desire for experimentation, especially by Hackett's "guitarism", two albums were released in 1976! The 'Trick' and 'W&W' albums were the main elements of a second "Hackett" era, which reached its climax and then its end with the concerts for it and especially with the 76/77 world tour, which then resulted in the live double album "Seconds Out"! Since then, Hackett has continued to be successful with the tracks where his music played a key role...as was the case with "Squonk" at the concert in Manchester in 2021! I was too young back then, but later I experienced two Genesis concerts that still leave me speechless today! These are unique experiences that you will never forget! #nicknlexrequest Greetings from Germany
I watched this video a few days ago and I’m in Ohio. Genesis is my favorite band. I saw them in ‘83, ‘92, ‘07, and ‘22. “A Trick of the Tail,” and “Duke” are probably my favorites. Favorite Song w/ Peter Gabriel - “The Cinema Show.” Favorite Songs w/ Phil Collins - “Evidence of Autumn,” and “Afterglow.” I can’t believe that the closest thing to seeing Genesis now is Steve Hackett. You two MUST see him.
Saw them a couple years ago and they were amazing. Fungi was involved. He played solo stuff and Seconds Out all the way through. Suppers Ready was awesome. The whole band and singer were top notch. They had an intermission and, when I told the 20 something girl tending bar, "great show." She said, "yeah, those guys are killing it." See them while you can.
Nick and lex, try not to take negative comments to heart regarding long intros, I for one love the back stories of how and when you came across these songs. Keep up the great work. ❤
I love Hackett's Genesis Revisited project. Also recommend going back and checking out the Second's Out live version with Phil on vocals. This was an amazing part of their live set in the late 70's.
Watching in Canada. Was lucky to have seen Steve Hackett twice, once doing Genesis Revisited and once for mostly his solo work. He has a series of live CD/video sets that are amazing, each distinct from each other. The live at Hammersmith album has many guests stars. Strongest recommendation for the video of him doing Entangled with Jakko Jacszyk from King Crimson on vocals. It is one of the most incredibly beautiful things I've ever heard.
I'm in the USA. I have been a HUGE Genesis fan since High School (the 70s). They are "Top 2 for me (tied with Pink Floyd). I saw them live on their Duke tour in the 80s (Chester Thompson on drums). This is both classic Genesis AND a Steve's slightly different-but-still-awesome performance!
You should listen to the live version from Genesis "Seconds Out", which includes Steve Hackett. It's a great version. Actually,, the entire album is incredible. Carpet Crawlers is another standout cut from that live album.
Phil says he was going for the Kashmir/Zep vibe on this. This album proves again it was when Steve left that the band was no longer the same. No one has done more to keep the glory days alive than Steve.
There was definitely a change for the worse but as opposed to many, I thought ATTW3 and Duke were great albums. Abacab destroyed it for me, but it gave me the impetus to explore backwards to the beginning. I came in 'new' to the two I mentioned, with no preconceived ideas or biases for or against any individuals?
Hi Guys, the stage set up is identical to the dvd I have Steve Hackett live > "Genesis Revisited Seconds Out & More" and I'm wondering this IS from that dvd ? ...The entire concert is stunning and apart from "Carpet Crawlers" that is a must watch moment ...I cannot recommend highly enough from this dvd ... "Suppers Ready" It is the most superior version I have ever heard and that includes by Genesis. It IS Prog Rock by far heavier than anything I've heard before. It truly brings this track to another level ...and OMG Nad Silvan !!! on vocals absolutely shines !!!!! I really have no doubt if you were to buy the 2 dvds / 2 cd's set you will not regret it. Sound + vision is superb + a 2nd dvd disc of goodies. I'm so glad Nick gave this track a 2nd chance. To hear this immediately after "Entangled" on the studio album is just stunning.... ; Lex ... I could not tell Phil from Peter for years and that's the original. Lol ... Nad Sylvan has melded his voice to sound like both ...so it's actually what this track may have sounded like had Peter not left ...which is just brilliant !!! Byee Jim X
So great! Remember that Phil was trying to sound/sing like Peter on this his 1st Genesis vocal album. I used to BLAST this song with my Cerwin Vega 15" woofers pounding. HaHe twas good. ThX guys. 👍 P.S. Not blocked in Canada🍁 P.P.S. BPM seemed right to me. It has a slowish slogging yet unstoppable tempo, which works imho.
You may want to do a reaction to Second's Out... It's this era, and it usually tops best live albums of all time lists a lot. There was a reason Genesis got voted best live band in those years.
La mejor version de Squonk, como muchas otras canciones de Genesis están incluidas en el mejor disco (doble) en vivo de la historia, Seconds Out, que para colmo de "bienes" tiene el mejor, mas majestuoso e imponente cierre de un concierto ever, "Los Endos" (un cóctel de palabras, mezclando inglés y español, que creó Phil para darle nombre a esa maravilla) Los Endos = The finales. Besitos a Marley
I've seen Steve 8 or 9 times live and he's brilliant. Just a word about the drummer here, Craig Blundell who replaced Gary O'Toole, I thought Craig was brilliant. Other favourite musicians that have played with Steve were Nick Beggs and Amanda Lehman!
Hackett knows perfect how that song was, because he was deeply involved. Sure! Trick of the Tail 1976 were the first album without Peter Gabriel but Phil Collins singing everything for the first time, drumming also but just recorded in studio. In this version many melodic parts were done by the woodwinds that gives another sound to the song, that was quite straight forward compared to the other from the album.
Really try his SHADOW OF THE HIEROPHANT live with some epic drumming by Gary O Toole (not the orchestral one) and NICK BEGGS on huge bass pedals. Overwhelming.
If I may make one more recommendation from the Steve Hackett "Genesis Revisited" shows, it's their take of "The Battle of Epping Forest" from "Selling England by the Pound". Excellent performance by all, and Nad Sylvan's execution of Gabriel's various voices in this song is astonishingly good! (Here's the TH-cam link: th-cam.com/video/KcaHUA6Z4SQ/w-d-xo.html)
I find it very difficult to listen to these songs individually. Dance on a volcano, Entangled, Squonk etc because they all lead into each other. I need to play the entire side of this album or not at all. It's like trying to listen to a song off side 2 of Abbey Road by the Beatles. Just can't do it.
Phil and Peter are world class vocalists and deserve someone with a better/stronger range to pay them tribute. I can't see Hackett concerts anymore because of this. Sad.
I saw him twice in the seventies. It was bad when Gabriel left, but when he left Genesis, it was all downhill. All soul or spirit of the band disappeared.
As soon as I heard it I knew that it was tuned down from D minor to C minor, perhaps for the sake of Nad Sylvian's voice, but frankly upsets the voicings of the guitar, so the whole thing sounds wrong for me, like a cover version more than an interpretation/reproduction (which the bulk of Hackett/Genesis-Revisited succeeds at so well)
I prefer the original. Strange enough, I saw Hackett in 2004 live in Germany near Frankfurt and on that gig, he played zero !!!! songs of Genesis, (I was surely disappointed then). Ok.
Good version. Drums aren’t as good as Chester live, or Phil on the album (I’m a drummer, so can be too picky). I’ve seen Genesis back in the 70s and Steve Hackett more recently. We are very lucky to have Hackett keeping this stuff alive.
Have hard feelings about Steve's Genesis songs. It's a good cover and as much as I like Steve it's still just a cover band.. Doesn't hit me as I wish it would... 😥
![STEVE HACKETT - Firth of Fifth [Live at Royal Festival Hall 2018] FIRST TIME COUPLE REACTION](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UvKr99_nHgs/mqdefault.jpg)
![STEVE HACKETT - Firth of Fifth [Live at Royal Festival Hall 2018] FIRST TIME COUPLE REACTION](/img/tr.png)
TH-cam says this video is blocked in the US, Canada, UK etc. Can you guys please leave the country your watching from in the comments? Thanks
Sweden.
Playing fine in UK
desde Argentina
Montana. US.
Use a VPN and choose your country. Some is free, the good ones costs a bit but could be worth it.
All i can say is thank God for Steve hackett and his band wow they are amazing genius musician's and thank you steve for keeping the Genesis sound alive and a big thank you too nick n lex from ian over in the UK
Hackett’s concerts are astounding. You should watch their performance of “Shadow of the Hierophant.” Simply perfect.
Saw this concert in Boulder. Steve is amazing in concert if you ever get to see him and his crew.
Nad has the amazing ability to sound like Peter Gabriel, and Phil Collins.
He surely does!
Steve Hackett is a greatly under rated musician. He has done some live concerts on dvd in recent years, well worth a look. Another favourite cover Steve did is the haunting prog rock, Court of the crimsom king, i think nearly as good as the original. As a genesis fan, i have seen them several times in concert in uk, at Wembly, Knebworth, Milton Keynes over the years. Thank you for reviewing.
Genesis and Steve’s version of them, is orchestrated to the tee. Each guy knows his part, like an orchestra, and blended together is incredible. This is why I love prog!!!
I only recently gave Steve a chance and WOW. They are so good. I am glad Hackett is keeping this great prog music alive......LIVE. Need to see this live. Hope he comes to Denver soon.
Another superb reaction guys,just a reminder that i mentioned Nad Sylvans amazing talent as not just a vocalist but also a songwriter a while ago now and referred to a track off his .Spiritus Mundi album entitled 'You've got to find a way' where both Steve Hackett and Guthrie Govan ,both close friends of Sylvan and feature on the track with the most amazing 5 minute guitar solos,you really should give it a listen guys.Nad Sylvan is so underrated and this track just puts him on the pedestal he deserves,give it a listen,i am sure you will just love it.
Nad's voice is something between Peter' and Phil's. I love that man. And yes hi is from Sweden.
He's also done some pretty good progressive solo albums - Courting The Widow (2015) and The Bride Said No (2017) coming to mind first. He definitely is a fine story teller, songwriter and multi-instrumentalist.
(And I watched this video in Finland)
Watching from the UK. The Firth of Fifth reaction came out yesterday and this reaction hit 5 hours ago here. I'm so glad you have relistened to 'Squonk' Nick, and re-evaluated the song. I think we all knew you would come around sooner or later! This was in Manchester where I'll be seeing Steve in October. So exciting. Thanks guys!!!
The "Hacket band" doing Suppers Ready is SUPERB
It's an absolute gem of a song.
Steve and band are so great live. I go and see them on every tour must be at least 15 times now. And I do not know how but they are better everytime.
I'm one of those peeps that watches the videos to see the both of you. ❤ The fact that ir cones with music and commentary is a plus. Love you, both!
Love you mamma 🥰!!
I'm so glad that I've seen Steve Hackett perform about 15 times by now, unfortunately never with Genesis though. The energy is always there. The band is always top notch. Last time so far was last July in Zoetermeer, Netherlands (he played 4 nights in a row). At the time of this performance he was 71 (born in 1950). Saw Genesis live in 1978 in Maastricht (NL), Leiden 1981 (NL), Brussels 1982 (B), Rotterdam 1987 (NL), Rotterdam 1992 (NL), Rotterdam 1997 (NL), Amsterdam 2007 (NL), Düsseldorf 2007 (D) and Amsterdam 2022 (NL).
So glad you are reacting to Steve’s band. They are fantastic live. However I prefer the Genesis live version of Squonk on Seconds Out. I saw your initial reaction on Patron and said that you need to give it a chance through repeated listening. So glad you did as Squonk is one of my Favourite Genesis tracks.
Good reaction, with this band and their quality you are completely back in time😘
Adding to my comment: I’ve seen Genesis at least 8 times, starting with Trick of the Tail in 76 through the 92 double album tour We can’t dance. Had tickets to the Lamb tour in 75 ($6.00 tickets) in Dallas, but cancelled because of lack of interest. Imagine that!! Seen Steve 3 times starting in 79 with the Spectral Morning tour, still have the program signed by him. Once in LA back in 2014 and last April in Dallas. He still has it!!! You have a lot to explore with Hackett.
The track is my youth...we listened to it over and over again in the party cellar! As the third song on the first concept album after the Gabriel era, Squonk is Phil Collins' vocal baptism of fire! After PG left, they were desperately looking for a singer...and couldn't find a suitable one! Collins himself didn't think it was possible at the time that he would be responsible for the band's fortunes and success with his double part! Since a lot of material had obviously been processed, which was crowned by an incredible desire for experimentation, especially by Hackett's "guitarism", two albums were released in 1976! The 'Trick' and 'W&W' albums were the main elements of a second "Hackett" era, which reached its climax and then its end with the concerts for it and especially with the 76/77 world tour, which then resulted in the live double album "Seconds Out"! Since then, Hackett has continued to be successful with the tracks where his music played a key role...as was the case with "Squonk" at the concert in Manchester in 2021! I was too young back then, but later I experienced two Genesis concerts that still leave me speechless today! These are unique experiences that you will never forget! #nicknlexrequest Greetings from Germany
I watched this video a few days ago and I’m in Ohio. Genesis is my favorite band. I saw them in ‘83, ‘92, ‘07, and ‘22. “A Trick of the Tail,” and “Duke” are probably my favorites. Favorite Song w/ Peter Gabriel - “The Cinema Show.” Favorite Songs w/ Phil Collins - “Evidence of Autumn,” and “Afterglow.” I can’t believe that the closest thing to seeing Genesis now is Steve Hackett. You two MUST see him.
Watching from Austria. Love the style of your reactions. Intros and outros included. 😉 Especially when you do Genesis.
Thank you so much 😁
Saw them a couple years ago and they were amazing. Fungi was involved. He played solo stuff and Seconds Out all the way through. Suppers Ready was awesome. The whole band and singer were top notch. They had an intermission and, when I told the 20 something girl tending bar, "great show." She said, "yeah, those guys are killing it." See them while you can.
Nick and lex, try not to take negative comments to heart regarding long intros, I for one love the back stories of how and when you came across these songs. Keep up the great work. ❤
Very cool! So glad you shared this reaction! Love you guys❤
Saw the tour when they played all of Seconds Out - was a dream come true for me and it sounded amazing
The ddrums are absolute amaizing ... this is why I like Genesis so much, the Masters.
Steve hackett "Blood on the roof tops" a must
I love Hackett's Genesis Revisited project. Also recommend going back and checking out the Second's Out live version with Phil on vocals. This was an amazing part of their live set in the late 70's.
Watching in Canada. Was lucky to have seen Steve Hackett twice, once doing Genesis Revisited and once for mostly his solo work. He has a series of live CD/video sets that are amazing, each distinct from each other. The live at Hammersmith album has many guests stars. Strongest recommendation for the video of him doing Entangled with Jakko Jacszyk from King Crimson on vocals. It is one of the most incredibly beautiful things I've ever heard.
you need to hear "Shadow of the hierophant" live...it's something magnificent.
I'm in the USA. I have been a HUGE Genesis fan since High School (the 70s). They are "Top 2 for me (tied with Pink Floyd). I saw them live on their Duke tour in the 80s (Chester Thompson on drums). This is both classic Genesis AND a Steve's slightly different-but-still-awesome performance!
Love this song, this album and you two! 💚💙💜❤98.9K tick, tick, tick. 💥
Love Squonk, and I love the portion of it in Los Endos as well :) Watching from Canada.
You should listen to the live version from Genesis "Seconds Out", which includes Steve Hackett. It's a great version. Actually,, the entire album is incredible. Carpet Crawlers is another standout cut from that live album.
NAD SYLVAN has sever outstanding albums of his own,
She is very very pretty❤️ Italy
Phil says he was going for the Kashmir/Zep vibe on this.
This album proves again it was when Steve left that the band was no longer the same. No one has done more to keep the glory days alive than Steve.
There was definitely a change for the worse but as opposed to many, I thought ATTW3 and Duke were great albums. Abacab destroyed it for me, but it gave me the impetus to explore backwards to the beginning. I came in 'new' to the two I mentioned, with no preconceived ideas or biases for or against any individuals?
Hi Guys, the stage set up is identical to the dvd I have Steve Hackett live > "Genesis Revisited Seconds Out & More" and I'm wondering this IS from that dvd ? ...The entire concert is stunning and apart from "Carpet Crawlers" that is a must watch moment ...I cannot recommend highly enough from this dvd ... "Suppers Ready" It is the most superior version I have ever heard and that includes by Genesis. It IS Prog Rock by far heavier than anything I've heard before. It truly brings this track to another level ...and OMG Nad Silvan !!! on vocals absolutely shines !!!!! I really have no doubt if you were to buy the 2 dvds / 2 cd's set you will not regret it. Sound + vision is superb + a 2nd dvd disc of goodies. I'm so glad Nick gave this track a 2nd chance. To hear this immediately after "Entangled" on the studio album is just stunning.... ; Lex ... I could not tell Phil from Peter for years and that's the original. Lol ... Nad Sylvan has melded his voice to sound like both ...so it's actually what this track may have sounded like had Peter not left ...which is just brilliant !!! Byee Jim X
love it...Hackett is a master......2 more packages on the way ;) keep reacting my Rocky Mtn Friends
So great! Remember that Phil was trying to sound/sing like Peter on this his 1st Genesis vocal album. I used to BLAST this song with my Cerwin Vega 15" woofers pounding. HaHe twas good. ThX guys. 👍
P.S. Not blocked in Canada🍁
P.P.S. BPM seemed right to me. It has a slowish slogging yet unstoppable tempo, which works imho.
Im coming from the Indio Solari video....and i really love this song
Jonas Rheingold on bass is also from THE FLOWER KINGS
Most Excellent song and reaction listening in the US of A.
Thank you Scott!!
Do you guys know Steve played with Tod mobile as did Jon Anderson’s of course
The version of suppers ready is majestic
I suggested that one too
You may want to do a reaction to Second's Out... It's this era, and it usually tops best live albums of all time lists a lot. There was a reason Genesis got voted best live band in those years.
Love the clarinet
Soprano saxophone......
Hi Guys,
I saw Genesis in 1998, with Ray Wilson on Vocals.
The Calling All Stations Tour.
Ronnie 😊
Aunque hagan un canal un yungonlavo igual vamos a estar presentes son una sana adicción AGUANTE 🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷👍💪 PAPAAÁAAAAA
Love the intros.
La mejor version de Squonk, como muchas otras canciones de Genesis están incluidas en el mejor disco (doble) en vivo de la historia, Seconds Out, que para colmo de "bienes" tiene el mejor, mas majestuoso e imponente cierre de un concierto ever, "Los Endos" (un cóctel de palabras, mezclando inglés y español, que creó Phil para darle nombre a esa maravilla) Los Endos = The finales.
Besitos a Marley
I’m in 🇨🇦
Singer Nad Sylvan has solo albums
All great prog
Check out Steve with the Hungarian band DJABE
You will be blown away
No conocíais a Nad Silvian?
Escuchar sus discos en solitario.
Es la pura esencia Genesis
I've seen Steve 8 or 9 times live and he's brilliant. Just a word about the drummer here, Craig Blundell who replaced Gary O'Toole, I thought Craig was brilliant. Other favourite musicians that have played with Steve were Nick Beggs and Amanda Lehman!
👏👏👏👏👏🇦🇷
Reaccinen a DAVID LEBON/RICARDO MOLLO, Mundo agradable grabado en estudio👍
Why not give some of his solo material a try? “Spectral Mornings” is a cool track from that same concert.
Hackett knows perfect how that song was, because he was deeply involved. Sure! Trick of the Tail 1976 were the first album without Peter Gabriel but Phil Collins singing everything for the first time, drumming also but just recorded in studio. In this version many melodic parts were done by the woodwinds that gives another sound to the song, that was quite straight forward compared to the other from the album.
Craig Blundell!
Trick of the Tale is Genesis best album…..with Squonk in their top five……Steve does a great job here enjoy cheers……
Have U heard The lamia singing by steve hackett?
uk,no problems here
Really try his SHADOW OF THE HIEROPHANT live with some epic drumming by Gary O Toole (not the orchestral one) and NICK BEGGS on huge bass pedals. Overwhelming.
Hey guys, singer reminds me of Dio.. Pink Floyd, and the Beatles.... Well alright!
PG left before this album😊
you guys should revisit morphine-
cure for pain
candy
the saddest song
empty box
just a few must listens
If I may make one more recommendation from the Steve Hackett "Genesis Revisited" shows, it's their take of "The Battle of Epping Forest" from "Selling England by the Pound". Excellent performance by all, and Nad Sylvan's execution of Gabriel's various voices in this song is astonishingly good! (Here's the TH-cam link: th-cam.com/video/KcaHUA6Z4SQ/w-d-xo.html)
I find it very difficult to listen to these songs individually. Dance on a volcano, Entangled, Squonk etc because they all lead into each other. I need to play the entire side of this album or not at all. It's like trying to listen to a song off side 2 of Abbey Road by the Beatles. Just can't do it.
Phil and Peter are world class vocalists and deserve someone with a better/stronger range to pay them tribute. I can't see Hackett concerts anymore because of this. Sad.
Please, react to the album version.
We have already✌
@@NicknLex When ?
As a part of the full album on Patreon :)
Good one. How the hell can you get emotional about a story about a mythical creature?
As a cover, this was good.
Peter left after LAMB.
Steve will be playing the U.S. in 2025.
Dates tba
Yay!! Thank you!!!
I saw him twice in the seventies. It was bad when Gabriel left, but when he left Genesis, it was all downhill. All soul or spirit of the band disappeared.
Wrong
@@jimhardiman3836 Patrick Bateman, is that you?
As soon as I heard it I knew that it was tuned down from D minor to C minor, perhaps for the sake of Nad Sylvian's voice, but frankly upsets the voicings of the guitar, so the whole thing sounds wrong for me, like a cover version more than an interpretation/reproduction (which the bulk of Hackett/Genesis-Revisited succeeds at so well)
I prefer the original. Strange enough, I saw Hackett in 2004 live in Germany near Frankfurt and on that gig, he played zero !!!! songs of Genesis, (I was surely disappointed then). Ok.
Good version. Drums aren’t as good as Chester live, or Phil on the album (I’m a drummer, so can be too picky). I’ve seen Genesis back in the 70s and Steve Hackett more recently. We are very lucky to have Hackett keeping this stuff alive.
This still doesn't compare to the energy of Genesis doing it live. You need to watch a live version of Genesis doing this.
Have hard feelings about Steve's Genesis songs. It's a good cover and as much as I like Steve it's still just a cover band.. Doesn't hit me as I wish it would... 😥
Bell'arrangiamento di squonk ma il cantante continua a non piacermi
Italy
Nad yodels around the notes too much for my taste! Far too fiddly.