I've noticed that faster solos like Fade To Black or Tornado Of Souls in both cases worked pretty well with Comfortably Numb and Hotel California than the viceversa
Waiting for Gilmour fans come and say: ”Comfortably numb with Comfortably numb’s solo is the most beautiful thing ever. Period.” Or something along those lines
Man, this actually sounds really good! Two of my favorite solos and they actually sound pretty good switched. I dig this kind of content. Great job in making them sound so good!
Nice job making subtle timing shifts in your playing to fit the backing track of each. They both worked really well. Two of my favourite solos of all time.
Wow Literally the first two solos that made me go "holy shit" back when I first got into rock, and what were for a long time my two favorite solos Both songs are probably like top 15 best songs ever, great rendition Beanie Hall 👍
Seriously, it’s hard to just free style your own stuff with such a familiar track in the background and not revert back to the original, much less try to keep with an entirely different known song. Great job!!!
This experiment shows how good Kirk is at writing melodic guitar solos. His solo fits a song like Comfortably Numb so well and the proof is in the comments. Cheers to Kirk and for you too Bradley for creating such a nice video, keep it up.
@@gurrenmed5319 Also Fuel, Spit Out the Bone, Inamorata, Room of Mirrors etc. He didn't really stop doing good guitar solos, their quality just kinda dropped :/ I'm really glad Unforgiven 3 solo gets recognition tho, that solo is amazing.
It's funny bc I think the Comfortably Numb solo doesn't work that well on FTB bc it's not intense enough for that type of song but FTB's solo works surprisingly well on CN.
Nice switch, interesting to hear Fade to Black with a bluesy and mellow solo, and Comfortably Numb with a more intense and shreddy solo. I like the contrasts
All of us would be lucky and ecstatic to write an iconic solo as either one of these... hats of to both of those greats, and cheers to Mr. Hall for making the swap happen so flawlessly.
Honestly I’d have to say the Comfortably Numb solo over Fade to Black sounds so much more in key and just fits so well with the other parts in the song
Agreed. I'm sure people will throw rocks at me (and I don't care) but Fade to Black solo has a lot of weird moments with badly chosen pentatonic scale not fitting the key of the original song... Not even talking about it played over Comfortably Numb. What does that tell us? That Fade to black solo is not as great as people make it out to be :)
@@GarikBronnikov I think you're wrong because playing notes out of key doesn't mean they are badly chosen, using "wrong notes" tastefully is what makes solos interesting.
@@Vivi_9 Yes, you are right. But I doubt that playing a whole pentatonic scale out of key can be described as "tasteful". Anyway, I see your point, all further discussion will be purely subjective so let's just agree to disagree :) Also just so you know, I'm not a Metallica hater or something. I grew up listening to their songs and idolising them. And there are some Metallica solos that are not completely in key, but they are great! Solo in The Unforgivern for example; it has a pentatonic run that's slightly off key, but it sounds great :) So it's just a Fade to Black solo I'm having a problem with
Agreed. It fit so well that in some parts, I found myself expecting it to go back into the Fade to Black solo. I wonder how it would sound, switching back and forth between the two solos?
I think FTB's solo fits Comfortably Numb perfectly and CN's solo fits FTB really well - your playing brings out the majesticity of both solos too. I'm going to rewatch the video!
I fucking loved this, I’ve done the exact same thing when I’ve jammed to these songs and it’s so much fun. Both Kirk’s and Gilmour’s solos were perfectly with each other’s song and I love it, great as always man
it was amazing how hard my brain tried to hear the correct solo while you played the other one! very unexpected. i was going to click the like button for this alone, but then you had the wet fart sound, now i have to click the like button for that as well
Cheers for the great videos! When I was younger I really got into metallica and a little later pink floyd was my 3am drunk music. Great to come home at 2 am from the pub to see and listen to this
Goodbye Blue Sky sounds a lot like the intro to Fade to Black. I just reheard that song for the first time in a long time after watching Rick and Morty yesterday.
As my teacher once said "as long as it's in Key, anything sounds Amazing over the Comfortably Numb backing track"
Yeah, B blues. Pretty good fun.
I'm just going to leave this here th-cam.com/video/Jj7pDNDuoJ0/w-d-xo.html
wise words
True
See also: Purple Rain
comfortably numb with fade to black's solo works surprisingly well
Probably same key and bpm
cuz of the same key very little changes are made to fit it in
I've noticed that faster solos like Fade To Black or Tornado Of Souls in both cases worked pretty well with Comfortably Numb and Hotel California than the viceversa
Both is in b minor
It does somewhat highlight some of kirk's questionable note choices though.
Comfortably Numb with Fade To Black's solo is the most beautiful thing I have ever heard
I agree
Waiting for Gilmour fans come and say: ”Comfortably numb with Comfortably numb’s solo is the most beautiful thing ever. Period.” Or something along those lines
Comfortably Numb with Comfortably numb is better
STOP THE CAP
I think the other one was better - Fade 2 Bkack with the Numb solo
I think Fade To Black solo is probably one of the best ever written, it's so emotive, but perhaps that's just the entire song.
I agree completely with you. The song got me, and is still helping me through some dark times, it’s truly a masterpiece and ride the lightnings finest
The harmonies of musical genius Cliff Burton
Absolutly, I love it, more and more each time I see it live
Wasn't the solo improvised?
One of the best easily
It sounds so good, i think than Crazy Train solo can go well with Rainbow In The Dark
That would be incredible
It needs to be happen
DIO would roll in his grave tho
@@sirjanska9575 no he wouldn’t! He loved randy Rhodes
YES!! Read my mind here
David´s solo is just perfect. One of the best solos of all time.
Now Fade To Whom the Bell Tolls for the Lightning of Cthulhu.
Orion but with the lead bass line from call of kthulu.
Fade To Whom the Bell Tolls for the Lightning of Cthulhu Trapped Under Fire
ktulu not cthulhu or kthulu
New tattoo idea.
from the album "Kill the Riding Master of Black Justice Angrily in the S&M Garage, Lulu!"
Shows how B minor is one of the best keys
What really matters more is that both songs' solo sections are in the same key.
@@bluebay0 I think that's what the original comment was implying but yeah
@@kybamclane9357 it is indeed exactly what i was trying to say
@@bluebay0 And nothing else matters 😝
@@ashleighsalinas8526 😑
dude the comfortably numb with fade to black solo is soooo good
Man, this actually sounds really good! Two of my favorite solos and they actually sound pretty good switched. I dig this kind of content. Great job in making them sound so good!
Nice job making subtle timing shifts in your playing to fit the backing track of each. They both worked really well. Two of my favourite solos of all time.
Wow
Literally the first two solos that made me go "holy shit" back when I first got into rock, and what were for a long time my two favorite solos
Both songs are probably like top 15 best songs ever, great rendition Beanie Hall 👍
Based as fuck
It must be incredibly difficult to play a different solo over a very familiar backing track! Very nicely done!
Yeah no doubt, I'd definitely keep accidentally veering back into the original song
I assume he just played it to the original track each and then edited on into the other.
Seriously, it’s hard to just free style your own stuff with such a familiar track in the background and not revert back to the original, much less try to keep with an entirely different known song. Great job!!!
Comfortably numb solo in any style and any solo in Comfortably numb style would always sound simply beautiful.
This experiment shows how good Kirk is at writing melodic guitar solos. His solo fits a song like Comfortably Numb so well and the proof is in the comments. Cheers to Kirk and for you too Bradley for creating such a nice video, keep it up.
Yeah, he has a bunch of really nice melodic, calmer solos. Shame how most of his playing is sloppy pentatonic noodling while slamming on the wah -,-
@@penttikoivuniemi2146 90s and beyond yes, although he had a few decent ones then too. Most of his 80s stuff is golden though
Sadly anything after justice for all is bad except Unforgiven 3
@@gurrenmed5319 Also Fuel, Spit Out the Bone, Inamorata, Room of Mirrors etc. He didn't really stop doing good guitar solos, their quality just kinda dropped :/ I'm really glad Unforgiven 3 solo gets recognition tho, that solo is amazing.
Proof is in the comments? Don’t you mean the proof is in the video?
The second one sounds like a movie outro, not gonna lie.
Please keep doing these man! Such unlikely Combos that sound awesome when done right!
This is so surreal, because the solo outro to FTB ALWAYS made me think of comfortably numb, and now I discover that it wasn't just me
It's funny bc I think the Comfortably Numb solo doesn't work that well on FTB bc it's not intense enough for that type of song but FTB's solo works surprisingly well on CN.
Stevie T. has also done the Comfortably Numb solo on Fade to black few years back.
It's crazy how good it fits !
Damn. I thought I was the only one who knew that here. Congrats man cuz you totally are a Stevie T fan too. 👍
Nice switch, interesting to hear Fade to Black with a bluesy and mellow solo, and Comfortably Numb with a more intense and shreddy solo. I like the contrasts
All of us would be lucky and ecstatic to write an iconic solo as either one of these... hats of to both of those greats, and cheers to Mr. Hall for making the swap happen so flawlessly.
That worked out so well. I actually love the fade to black solo over comfortably numb. It works. Good work m8
Damn I was just thinking about this switch up the other day 🤯
Cool demonstration! I think the Fade to Black solo worked much better in Comfortably Numb than vice versa.
Honestly I’d have to say the Comfortably Numb solo over Fade to Black sounds so much more in key and just fits so well with the other parts in the song
Agreed. I'm sure people will throw rocks at me (and I don't care) but Fade to Black solo has a lot of weird moments with badly chosen pentatonic scale not fitting the key of the original song... Not even talking about it played over Comfortably Numb. What does that tell us? That Fade to black solo is not as great as people make it out to be :)
@@GarikBronnikov I think you're wrong because playing notes out of key doesn't mean they are badly chosen, using "wrong notes" tastefully is what makes solos interesting.
@@Vivi_9 Yes, you are right. But I doubt that playing a whole pentatonic scale out of key can be described as "tasteful". Anyway, I see your point, all further discussion will be purely subjective so let's just agree to disagree :)
Also just so you know, I'm not a Metallica hater or something. I grew up listening to their songs and idolising them. And there are some Metallica solos that are not completely in key, but they are great! Solo in The Unforgivern for example; it has a pentatonic run that's slightly off key, but it sounds great :) So it's just a Fade to Black solo I'm having a problem with
Was looking for this comment, it sounded better out of the 2 but both were awesome
Agreed. It fit so well that in some parts, I found myself expecting it to go back into the Fade to Black solo. I wonder how it would sound, switching back and forth between the two solos?
Why did you have to put two songs of incredibly significant meaning and somehow put them together? I love it!
That's just amazing how they fit together so perfectly
Any solo in the same key as comfortably numb backing track sounds amazing
Thank Cliff for the rhythm part of Fade to Black's solo.
2 of the best solos ever
I love Kirks „ Fade to black“ Solo
The sick the dying and the dead backing with dystopia melody
I think FTB's solo fits Comfortably Numb perfectly and CN's solo fits FTB really well - your playing brings out the majesticity of both solos too. I'm going to rewatch the video!
Fade to black final solo is a master piece especially when you play it slow we can see all the details in the phrasing
Honestly I hadn’t felt much listening to these songs for years. This makes both new and fresh again! Wow! 🤘🤘🤘
Absolutely love this series bro, seeing these solos at different tempos and how well they work is fucking mind blowing. Please do more!
The fade solo over the numb backing really works the reverse I was not feeling but your killed the lead
This is what I am doing at next band practice. Pure gold
Fade to numb goes hard
This was AMAZING! LOVE IT BRADLEY! THANK YOU SO MUCH!
The second one sounds absolutely wonderful
This is definitely one of your best ideas man, for me what's most amazing's that it sounds amazing!!
There were moments where I couldn’t tell which was over which! That’s impressive shit
Loved the sound and the way you played. Hard to explain, but it has a soul, something that makes it alive.
The fade to black solo with this backing track sounds kinda like if gilmour improvised live
They both fit really nice. Good idea.
Those both sound great meshed like that. Thanks for posting this video, I enjoyed this very much.
Imagine Kirk Hammett just saying while explaining how to do the solo to Fade To Black, "You just bend the string right here. Feel the tension..."
The fade to black solo worked a bit better in comfortably numb. But both were a pleasure to listen to.
Wow, Fade To Black with Comfortably Numb solo sounded fanstastic, and also the opposite worked surprisingly well.
been waiting for this video since I was about 12 when I realised the connection between the two pieces of music.
That's crazy how well these worked!!!
I'd like to hear more mash ups like this.
2 my favorite songs with THE most favorite solo
These are my two favorite songs of all time! To hear them combined like this is a dream come true!
Two legendary solos on legendary songs, no wonder they work so well of each other.
These switcharoo solo series is 🔥
I fucking loved this, I’ve done the exact same thing when I’ve jammed to these songs and it’s so much fun. Both Kirk’s and Gilmour’s solos were perfectly with each other’s song and I love it, great as always man
Great, as usual ❤️
These are both so fucking awesome! I never even noticed how similar these solos were - the power of pentatonic. lol
Comfortably Black and Fade to Numb sound great
off topic but nice waking up to bradley and some guitar in the morning!
I was just listening to Fade to Black when I got notified! Nice one!
Fade to numb and comfotably black ❤
knocking on heavens door and every rose has its thorn
This is the best, most innovative video idea ever
Finally well played Comfortably Numb solo on Your channel. Congratulations
My mind is currently melting down right now....
Whoa.... 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
someone has actually done what i been thinking of for years 😭 thank you
Best series, please keep doing this...
takes me back to when I put Fade to black over the Comfortably numb part of the The wall movie back in 2014
Even though Comfortably numb solo over Fade to Black sounded absolutely sacrilegious, the reverse wasn't what I thought, actually not half bad
Fade to Black is probably my favorite solo, along with Unforgiven III and the last one in Sultans of Swing
A REAL timing exercise!
can't believe it fits perfectly
I think that may be my FAVORITE video of your! Well done, Cheers!
More of this please. Love it.
I know how to play both of those solos and never ONCE thought of that. Holy shit.
Can i even say this but that indeed made me Comfortably Black...
Good job. My favorite songs from each of these bands. A nice mix of blending them together and taking turns on each ending solo.
Please switch the solos from Nothing Else Matters and Wrong Side Of Heaven, would sounds gourgeous
Almost rings of Paul Gilberts Technical Difficulties
I think this is my new favorite Beadley format
The best version so far!❤
it was amazing how hard my brain tried to hear the correct solo while you played the other one! very unexpected.
i was going to click the like button for this alone, but then you had the wet fart sound, now i have to click the like button for that as well
Brilliant! First solo went well. Fade to black for the first few seconds didn't but then found its footing! Great stuff!
that sounds beautiful~~~~ made my day 😄thanks!!!! love ur vids!
Cheers for the great videos! When I was younger I really got into metallica and a little later pink floyd was my 3am drunk music. Great to come home at 2 am from the pub to see and listen to this
answering the questions noone asked but man, that slaps
after the "RammFloyd" I thought I would not hear anything like it, but, you make my day
Thanks you Bradley *-*
Switch are you gonna go my way with you really got me
Fade to black literally faded to black lol
Nice vid, I really liked comfortably numb with fade to black solo
Fucking amazing! love your work!!
This sounds amazing. Both these songs are in my personal TOP, just love them! You nailed it.
That was unexpected, but in the best way possible. Absolutely awesome!
Keep doing these videos man! They're great.
😳 bro!!! That was amazing 👏 please more!!!!👏👏👏👏
Mind blown. This was unbearably cool.
Goodbye Blue Sky sounds a lot like the intro to Fade to Black. I just reheard that song for the first time in a long time after watching Rick and Morty yesterday.