Shostakovich - Symphony no. 13
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 พ.ค. 2024
- Dertiende symfonie in bes, op. 113 'Babi Yar' van Dmitri Sjostakovitsj. Door het Radio Filharmonisch Orkest , Groot Omroepmannenkoor o.l.v. Dmitri Slobodeniouk m.m.v. Sergej Aleksashkin (bas). Opgenomen tijdens het Zondagochtend Concert van 3 april 2011, Grote Zaal Concertgebouw Amsterdam.
- เพลง
Shostakovich's work is greatly respected and deeply admired throughout the world. Although with this symphony being extraordinary and all it seriously frightens me. Only because I can hear thousands of shattered cries and horrifying screams of unbearable anguish, and to convey that into music is incredibly powerful.
The tenderness at the end of this symphony is heartbreaking.
Magnificent interpretation. It is also worth of note the education and good manners of the spectators, who do not clap for almost 10 seconds at the end of this piece.
The first and last note on the tubular bells is the same, as if to say that the suffering continues.
the bell in the beggining and end gives me chills.
Totally earthshaking, woooooooow, how profound the music of Shostakovich, very touching, cheers from Costa Rica!
Masterwork, and such a musical tragedy... the final slow waltz is, perhaps, the most moving and sad of all music.
Beautiful music. Full of subtleties. Moving words. I didnt have much idea what happened at Babi Yar other than what I read coldly and succinctly on the back of a record sleeve in 1975. When I researched more recently I cried.
L'une des plus belles symphonies de Chostakovitch.
This is the finest performance I have ever heard of this work. The audio recording is superb as is the conductor, orchestra, choir and soloist. They raise the bar.
Agree!!!
Beautiful performance. I keep watching this and listening to this. Bravo!
Unfathomable hope in the face of acute repression and cruelty. Shostakovich's music (as separate from the person) is the embodiment of Solzhenitsyn's experience and ultimate viewpoint. I had the privilege of hearing the 13th AND the 4th on the same night a few years back - sledgehammers me every time I hear it (and think about it). Let's keep faith with the good things in humanity, eh ?
Wow, my two favorite Shostakovich symphonies in one setting..! I envy you.
This symphony makes my hands shake because its epic
The long silence following the end of this performance tells us all.
Among the best composers of the last century !
Thanks
GREAT PERFORMANCE!!! Rich, good recording and sound Edition. Conductor really sensible to the Full range of this musical drama. A deeply talented orchestra and choir.
i ordered a recording of this piece on amazon, i'm extremely excited to own this piece and add it to my Shostakovich collection!
FORMIDABLE! COHERENCIA HOLISTICA DEL GRAN COMPOSITOR Transmite musicalmente la potencia dramatica del pueblo ruso. Grande este director sinfonico y el ajuste de todo el grupo orquestal.
Excellent performance! This symphony first peaked my interest into learning more about Shostakovich. I vividly remember viewing a live performance of this piece years back in my youth and upon hearing the first movement, I was completely frightened out of my mind on how horrifying the music evoked me... and that was just the first movement....
Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful.
By far the best performance of this symphony on TH-cam
Genial !!!
stupenda questa sinfonia!!!
Fantastic symphony!!!
Quelle beauté, merci !
Esta Sinfonia, de haber existido cuando Dios creo el Universo, hubiese sido la que habria elegido para inmortalizar su obra. Impresionante.
Спасибо. Гениально исполнение, гениально произведение - весь Д.Д. Шостакович...
dieser bass - der pure wahnsinn.
Prachtige uitvoering in het Concertgebouw Amsterdam.
first come the goosebumps. then the tears. that one human could allow this to happen to another human (Hitler) makes me similtaneously angry and sad beyond belief.
Ungeschlagen immer noch die Version von Mariss Jansons mit dem Symphonieorchester des bayerischen Rundfunks. Unbedingt anhören!
Wellicht ga ik hem luisteren bedankt!
51:05 I love this subject so much!!!
De hoornsolo in het derde deel is super!!!!en trouwens ook de bass tuba niet te vergeten in het vierde deel!!!
me dejo con la boca abierta!
Paul Hanson: When you mentioned your wife was playing contrabassoon, I was reminded of the many Mahler works Claudio Abbado has on You Tube and that he hand picked many of the musicians in the Orchestras. Luckily I've been able to meet several members of the Minnesota Orchestra after a few concerts, and at least the musicians know I am a composer even though after 6 "no's" I've given up trying to get any kind of employment at the MN Orchestra.
Interesting about the text... I sang this under Gergiev in 2006, as well as at the Museum of Jewish Heritage in NYC shortly before, with Yevtushenko himself reading the title poem in commemoration of the 65th anniversary of the Babi Yar massacre. I'd think he would have read the uncensored version for this occasion, and we in the choir did not have to learn two different versions....
It's wonderful to find this sort of music on TH-cam Thank's
Though stirring in its vocal melodies, Shostakovich's Symphony No.13 was first emerging as a political gesture and then as a musical masterpiece. Challenging the bottomline of Soviet government's anti-semitic sentiment, it really stimulated those who were being in charge of cultural ministry of that country. It was an issue even Krushchev did not dare to touch, as sensitive as the Hungarian Revolt's impact to Ukrainian nationalism.
sublime!!!!!!!!!
@yuripo78 Well, they are dutch. Shosty's music is performed all over the world; you can't hire everytime a russian choir...
I wish listening Vasily Petrenko's version with Royal Liverpool Philarmonic Orchestra...but it is still missing.....
Meu pai do céu
É isso. Meu Pai do céu...
это, по моему, одна из лучших записей 13-й за последнее время, хоть голландский хор и поёт по-русски несколько нелепо. Гергиев нервно курит в сторонке))) Но, всё же, лучше Рудольфа Баршая эту музыку, наверное, никто не исполнит
0:58
3:29
4:01
6:40
8:32
13:21
15:52
17:25
19:05
20:19
23:06
26:12
29:23
32:30
35:42
39:48
41:56
42:29
44:05
48:35
50:05
52:23
54:32
57:40
59:18
Thank you, Shostakovich.
Thanks for the times, really useful
I'm a bit confused among these comments.
in this video the conductor is not valery gergiev.
in any case, is the text the right one?
4:00 is really scary...
love that part!
I didn't know that Ben Sidran was also an orchestra conductor.
Babi Yar.
男低音太棒了，合唱团让我听出来压抑的哀怨和悲愤
Find the novel by Anatoli Kuznetsov - he lived through it.
I am not very fond of the Gergiev's performance for the simple reason that he chose the second version of the text which was comprised by Yevtushenko himself under a heavy pressure of the Soviet authorities. Otherwise they would simply cancel the performances of the work in the USSR. The reason is that thge poem makes clear allusions to the Russian antisemitism, and thus touches a tabu subject in the Soviet union (Molotov -Riobentrop, "Doctors affair int he50s. should be performed with or. text
What are the differences between the two versions of the text.?
Happens to me with German compositions a lot. I still think, it's more impressive how music connects people of all countries, though.
45:09 John C Reiley scratches nose with violin
Crushing and poignant.
До слёз. Евтушенко написал великую поэму. Да, я тоже "настоящий русский"
omg soo fuckin fierce !!! 0_o
Thank you for this information. I was always under the impression that the massacre at Babi Yar was perpetrated solely against Jews. To minimise this stark fact is shocking and only serves to show that anti-semitism was, and probably still is, still alive in Russia.Of course,millions of Russians were victims of the nazis,but Shostakovich's intention (and Yeveshenko) was to show his hatred and rejection of anti-semitism.A not very popular theme then and now.What great moral courage!
@yuripo78 It's all a matter of opinion. This symphony describes the tragedy of the Ukrainian massacre at Babi Yar, so there is the responsibility to convey all that, but this singers voice doesn't bother me at all. The music provides the emotion. The singer does sound kind of monotone at times, but often, those that speak firsthand of tragedy sound in shock, monotone, emotionless, heavy, and contemplative. Shostakovich knew it all too well, and captures the emotion perfectly in this piece.
Going to get chance to hear this rarely performed work In Zellerbach Hall, Berkeley, California by the Berkeley Symphony Orchestra on May 4. Is Vodka recommended before, after, or both?
My wife is playing contrabassoon in this performance. What an incredible work!!
Symphony #13 in bb, "Babi Yar", Op. 113 (text: Ye. Yevtushenko) (B, B chorus, orch) (1962) (1st perf: V. Gromadsky, Republican State and Gnesin Institute Choirs, Moscow PO, cond. Kondrashin, Moscow, Conservatory Bol'shoy Hall, 18 Dec 1962)
0:00- I. Babi Yar
15:15- II. Yumor (Humor)
24:00- III. V Magazine (At the Store)
35:40- IV. Strachi (Fears)
46:40- V. Kariera (Career)
magnificient
@bartrazin
Yes, I very much enjoyed this interpretation, and I think this is one of the best records of 13th Shostakovich lately. Much better and more heartfelt than the performance by Valery Gergiev.
But still, I think, better Rudolf Barshai this music no one has ever performed.
Please forgive my English, translated by the Google-translator.
adiago?
I'd really like to know what they are saying. What an intense piece of music!
A very nice symphony but extremely dull performance. The music in this performance stands still, their is no rhytmic mouvement.I miss the russian spirit. The recording with Kondrashin is my number one. The quality of that recording is not so deep as this one but it is so thrilling and deepgoing musically that every other recording is in minor.
I cannot agree more with you. I could write a full essay of things wrong with this performance. The worst mistake in this, I think, is a slip between the flutes and strings at 21:04. Since I discovered Kondrashin's performance (these are the people who gave the premiere and would have had direct instructions from the composer himself), I have considered that to be the greatest recording of this outstanding piece.
Connaissez-vous des traductions en français du texte de cette symphonie ?
+Nicolas Messina Sorry could not find the text in French but here's a link for the text in English and in Russian(phonétique) shostakovich.hilwin.nl/works/ds1130.html
Anthologie de la poésie russe, Paris, Gallimard, édition de Katia Granoff, p. 522-523 pour le poème éponyme de Evguény Evtouchenko (1er mouvement).
Only the first movement?
Unfortunately.
00:51
Vi la version del sinfonia interpretada por la Orquesta Sinfonica de Jerusalem, en Jerusalem. Solo puedo decir, no hay palabras.
"Adiago" instead of "adagio"? What a professional way of spelling. Lol
:D
21:00 Shostakovich > Stravinsky.
Despues de toda la obra, dramática.. Llega el 57:40 y es gloria.
19:22 Bartok parody!!!
Is this Shostakovich's revenge for Bartok's parody of his Symphony No. 7 in the Concerto for Orchestra?
And which Bartok piece is being parodied?
Ahh, from Concerto for Orch.? Thanks for noting.
Music for Strings percussion and celesta
@@philprever2302 last movement of Bartok his concerto for 2 piano's, percussion and strings
Misschien Esther
Helicopter music in Afganistan. 😅 At least it's not Destiny's Child. 🤣 It's Space Boys. 🎉
Ok thanks.
Nuevamente, Shostakovich nos hace en trágico retrato de los horrores de la guerra. Babi Yar es a los rusos lo que Katyn es a los polacos. Los otros movimientos son los puntos que irónicamente trataba con maestría, para denunciar a los regímenes totalitarios como el nazi y el soviético. Sinfonía muy rusa y en cierto modo hace un pequeño homenaje a Mussorgsky .
Quite russian [the chant].
Powerful!
Nasreddin hoca var dediler geldik.
Few comments: first of all the choir doesn't seem to be native russian speaking at to me, as russian speaker, this disturbs being honest. i don't think that the singer is emotional enough, sometimes his singing is too monotonous. For my opinion Gergiev's performance which is available in TH-cam is better.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
For me, Gergiev is not a good director of Chostakovitch. All symphonies he directed are bad : too slow, laborious. Oh ! the time of Mravinsly and Rozhdensvetky or today Jarvi or Ashkenazy (or even Bernstein).
Oui, la musique est grandiose, mais le chanteur n'est vraiment pas bon, avec son vibrato esagerato...