G Robinson absolute nonsense, fucking mirror home wrecker probably, all because your life is shit. Nobody has or will be you because you force it on them
@@calisurfrguy7220 Onlyother narator that comes2mind when they put there all in is creepy ghost stories besides dr creepen I suggest u listen 2 sarah's stoy 1st its what hooked me on him tbh.
I have a theory on who the Stranger is: Death. All black clothing, hat, suit, tie, etc. And his disdain for both God and Lucifer would make a bit of sense as well, for Death's role is to essentially take people's lives away but because of Heaven and Hell he wouldn't be able to do that fully, for there would be an afterlife.
Exactly. Azrael is the angel of death. Hence why he cannot do what God does not allow. Lucifer was God's favorite angel too. Perhaps he is jealous. Look into him.
I love how the Stranger is only called “The Stranger”. He has no name, no identity. He could be anyone. It adds a real air of mystery and general creepiness to him.
Reminds me of “The Blood Meridian” The Narrator/main character is called “The Kid” and then later at the end “The Man”. It’s one of the greatest books ever written, when I listen to it it sounds like poetry and when I read it, it feels as if I’m reading scripture, like it actually feels important.
Four years later and this is still one of my all time favorite stories. The sheer amount of learning, practice, blood, sweat, and tears that have gone into your work absolutely NEVER go unnoticed! I’m very grateful to have found your channel!!
It sounds completely in act with a small town church in my opinion if the organist is still sitting during the message and the Entity spirit overshadows.
Well, after the stranger got through telling everyone how terrible God was, and him saying "I am whatever you think I am" I believe that than man wasn't the Devil, but God himself.
@@dbyfitness2939 Exactly he didn't not DISS himself but what people made him out to be. But got mad asf when he was called the devil. So I'm pretty sure your right with him being the creator.
I love how the main charater is just some random dude, like. He mentions alot that he wasnt particularly close with the victims and ge just sat in the middle of a crowd idk why but i adore the narrator being just some guy
by the way he hated Lucifer and preached from the bible, my guess would be he is some sort of an angel/archangel and they didnt really care about human beings any more than the devil does.
Catalin Sebastian While the Stranger was "preaching" about how much he hated Satan he also spoke about his hate for Angels as well. He's something else. Perhaps a being as old as God or a being from another dimension. Perhaps in a very cruel twist, he is God Himself come to test man to see if we're worthy.
@@angrytwxgaming8423 That's an exceptional hypothesis. Perhaps, just perhaps you're correct. There are things out there that have existed since before the beginning of time.
Or maybe, we're all wrong. Maybe the man was something we cant begin to understand. Something we as humanity can't label as something we know, but as something we feel. Something deeper then a religious figure, or a monster of our lore. But maybe...maybe im just wrong. Maybe we all are. Maybe we must succumb to the possibility we know nothing.
This narration was phenomenal. The emotion and passion you use to speak paired with the voice effects had me at the edge of my seat! Excellent job my friend.
O. o, that was. by far (aside from the Darklings) one of THE BEST "scary" / horror / pasta I have heard in a LONG time!! my compliments to the author. and you sir, are one he'll of a narrator /storyteller
Christian here: This story is unbelievably well written, and I have no doubt in my mind that the author is very skilled and talented. Although it pained me to listen to (being a Christian) I can't help but love it. There are so many diffrent ways to interpret this story, and so many underlying messages... I can't fathom how another human being wrote this! Fantastic, simply fantastic.
"His slick back blonde hair looked as plastic as his smile" *Cough cough* Erwin Smith anyone? "Humanity is corrupted" Yep. This is secretly attack on Titan
Maybe it's Jesus if he hated God for allowing him, his only son to be crucified and did nothing to help him. And the Bible was written that he had resurrected and told people gods plan by the apostles, in an attempt to hide the fact Jesus HAD in fact resurrected, but had gone mad with rage towards God.
When asked who he was Jesus responded with “who do you think I am”, eerily similar to “I am what you think I am”. If not Jesus maybe the antichrist, either way I think you’re on to something.
Honestly, this is my favorite creepypasta to ever be written, feel free to disagree with me, but even though the writer wrote something that some may disagree with, you must admit, they wrote it very well. Cheers to you and the writer of this.
I've listened to this particular story 3 times in 2 weeks now. As the son of a pastor, i envisioned this personally. I work alone as a Night Janitor at a school and this literally scared me while cleaning. Goosebumps. Just...so much passion and emotion behind it. Excellent back soundtrack. You painted this so well, I could see every detail! I WAS THERE! 😳 This is easily my favorite story....
+Unix One I think you took my comment too seriously. I'm an atheist, and I think that no matter what religious affiliation you have, it's painfully obvious that many atheists love seeing themselves as an unstoppable tour-de-fours of rationality who can effortlessly debate anyone and win.
Andrew Bryant I wasn't taking it that seriously, I was just asking what you meant by debate. And what you say is true, sadly. Many do find themselves that, and when a religious person makes a good point they stoop to insults because they don't have an actual counter-argument.
well im an atheist too, and i don't argue with theist people unless they try to make other people believe in their gods, and im most of the time polite(unless they're really disrespectful to me) because i understand that what you believe is what you want to believe, and what i believe is what i want to believe.
That was such a great story it gave me chills I can't wait for the book! Also the stranger made some really great points that can test the faith of anyone…even the listers.
"I'm... what ever you think I am" is a response that is actually really good. I think he is god, it's pretty apparent that hes not the devil. as he just rekt'ed himself pretty bad if he was- because of how he started however. he's not wrong. but not right either.
+Wesley Allen well, he was a god in that he held power and awe over his audience and demonstrated it. Another person could say that he was simply a agent of a god that few know of, one that sows distrust, death and maddening despair within the ranks of certain populations in a effort to steal them away without the victims even realizing it.
A damn fine story. More like this please. More religion oriented stories and the ritual pastas. I understand that not everyone enjoys them, but a lot of us do. So please, heed my word. And give us what we desire.
This story is so intense! I usually go for the shorter stories because the longer ones get a little dry. But from the beginning to the very last word this story kept me on edge. I love how the story was told too. With the inflections in his voice and the music matching his enthusiasm.... man. This was a REALLY good story. Keep it up!
I know this is old, but damn, this is one of the creepiest horror stories to me. I'm not really sure why, it just makes my skin crawl and my stomach churn. I don't even believe in God. But it's still uncomfortable to me. Maybe it's because the thought of God and faith is supposed to something merciful and what a lot of people look at as good, and just seeing it in such a dark light, It doesn't feel right. Most probably won't agree with me, but that's just how I felt.
Most of us are taught that but the Bible is full of horrors. Moses and his crew being told to slaughter the Midinite men, boys and non virgin females. Then for his men to take which virgin girls pleased them as wife. To cut their nails and hair as they cried for their slain parents, and live with them as wife for 30 days. At the end of 30 days if the girl no longer pleased them, then to throw them out. But since god was merciful they weren’t allowed to sell them. Just throw them out stripped of the only value a female had in those days, her hymen. Then there’s how god snatched all the first born sons from their mothers stomachs in Egypt. And how god instructed any man who thought his wife was cheating to take his wife to a holy man and make her drink bitter water which would cause spontaneous abortion if she’d cheated. There’s so many stories that are fcked up in the Bible that tell of a prideful, vengeful, fickle god. Dude sounds like a narcissistic sociopath to me.
One of my fave tales, and you #MrCreepyPasta have been the only one so far to have told it absolutely perfectly. A truly brill feelpasta to me. tyvm as ALWAYS for the amazing work you do. with huge thanks from the UK/Glasgow-Scotland
Not only is this amazingly written, but MrCreepyPasta did a wonderful job narrating it. This is one of my favorite stories he's read based on the uh.. not sure how to put it? How it's narrated I guess. It's really good and I get completely transfixed every time.
JESUS CHRIST (no pun intended) I had a knot in my chest through this whole story! Bravo MCP! This is without a doubt one of your greatest and most terrifying narrations ever!
So to prove that people sin, he murders several people, commits blasphemy, and performs unspeakable acts on, realistically, innocent civilians? He's worse than any of them there and his whole point is to prove he's superior? Man, this is some edgy misanthropic shit. Topped with a fedora and all.
Isn't this what people do nowadays anyway? He does not have to prove any sin, he is just pointing it out to the cognitively dissonant, but i agree he didn't have to kill anyone.
You literally missed the entire point of the story, the man is God himself, his opening statement even calls himself out on his own corruption that's worse than any human, and the whole point of why he did it was because he could do what he did.
@@Youwouldknowmebtnow To be honest the complete story is subjective to the belief of the viewer and can be interpreted as a slew of different ideas, I simply stated what I stated because it happens all the time, because even then your idea is right in your eyes but wrong in someone else's 🙂
Everyone's here saying how good the story is while I'm here thinking about stories from the Bible that could support the idea presented in this story... the Christian God has done some fucked up and questionable shit...
Also nicely hinting that the stranger was in fact God. "I can only do this if God allows it" "I know more about God than you"(referring to the preacher) I am what you think I am"(God is omnipresent therefore anything) "Lucifer a failed child"(God regards satan as his only failure in revelations) Rather subtle, and I may just be reading into it, but I think that conclusion rounds off the story nicely :)
+James Brewer - it's also amusing how we can assume he was punishing sinners & preformed biblical killings. We can assume Mr. Margo is abusive to his wife when the narrator says he jerks his wife by her arm. Annie was a harlot & in the old days, they were put on display and killed. And we already get the Abraham one. The wife was killed because she got in the way. I could be wrong but just a fun thought.
Great story!! This grabbed my attention the whole time, and was fun to try and guess what was gonna happen next. He's become my favorite new author, his story "New Fish" is so well written, it's my absolute favorite creepypasta.
I did enjoy this story, but you should listen to Scary Story Time With Liam his stories are so fucking amazing (he's an author and narrates!) , his imagery and description is simply amazing. You should try Pursuit Institute, The Mangled, Mistrust Game, Glacial Ice, hell just about all his stories are amazing tbh..
9:15 Being made in the image of God doesn't mean we become perfect little angels. Being made in the image of God means we are capable of telling what's right, and what's wrong. If we aren't made in such a manner, then there wouldn't be free will.
codbarley Oh, ahahah somehow I skipped over it while reading the description even though it was in bold and went directly to your channel searching for it xD! My bad...
+MiraiMemento yeah somehow everyone is missing it. It's getting kinda tiresome pointing out the obvious. The link is in the description and like, 5 different comments at this point. You'd think people would up-vote those comments
I love that you've been narrating such good stories lately, MCP! Your reading voice is great, but hearing a well-written story is always better than your typical Jeff the Killer trash. Not that this story doesn't have its flaws, but I just listened to one of the worst stories I've ever heard on another channel and this was a breath of fresh air.
Instead of telling the man: "Im whatever you think i am", he should have said: "im the snake who was forced to slither on his belly for the rest of etenity"
+frelee4567 that would've left even more holes. If he's Christ his behavior wouldnt make sense and even if he was, the story didn't even address why Jesus would hate god. so no, his original line was perfect ans full of interpretation
DuceyBlooDoe It was something cool that i thought of. Me personaly, i dont think the snake was the devil, rather a creature who felt the same way the 'stranger' does. It is my opinion tho, i respect you're own xD
And everyone left alive would have their own interpretations of "God"...some following him...some asking to join him...some jealous of him...some wanting his power....others fearing him....yes...i like ur idea!
justin nixon You apparently do not understand taxonomy, which is the study of animal classification. It places humans in the same area as apes. In fact, there is only a 2% difference in the DNA between humans and chimps.
haha, look at you making up words such as speciesism. Man is above animals, not because he is more intelligent, but because he can control his urges unlike the lesser beings that roam this planet. An animal will eat when it's hungry, drink when it's thirsty and mate when it gets the urge. The same cannot be said for people who follow certain religions and spiritual paths. They will not become slaves of their urges, instead they will control their urges. The rest of your post is pure gibberish. The world has no problems with humans. Do you really think it cares about a certain species because it comes in a different color or it si altered slightly compared to the rest? Mankind's destruction is great, but nowhere near the destruction which happened during mass extinctions.
I did not introduce the word "speciesism" to this thread, you did. I brought up taxonomy, which is very basic biology. Humans are not and will never be above animals. This is for one simple reason, we are animals. Religion has nothing to do with this conversation, this is all science. It doesn't matter if you believe what I'm saying because at the end of the day, you're still an ape just like every single human on the planet.
jtbrad Well my reply was towards Cynical DL1, but for whatever reason TH-cam doesn't put the name of the person I am replying to. Like I said, humans can be above animals if they learn to control their urges.
so man ate a magical bad apple that god purposely put in close proximity to him, without even giving him a good explanation as to why he shouldn't eat it and instead just made a pretty vague statement,and here we are today. because man with his curious nature was purposely put close to a magic apple that he eas told not to eat.10/10 in terms of rationality and believability.
+LuiKang043 hmmm...leaving him alone with an evil magical apple, and using reverse psychology telling him not to eat that specific apple, all the while not actually offering a reason as to why he shouldn't, as any highly rational being such as a human would require, but rather treating the man as a stupid child knowing full well he is a highly intelligent and curious creature. yes i think adam could make a case, although i have no idea how he would get a lawyer to believe this insane story.
just finished listening to this for the Tenth time .... greatest story I've ever heard ... and Soooo well narrated , the reason I subscribed to this channel
i fucking love this creepypasta. in fact i was recommended this story when you made this video back in 2016 as i listeed to a lot of CreepsMcPasta and after listening to your story telling, i love it. it's seriously amazing. and because of you and MrCreeps, i make my own stories and plan to read them and make videos like this.
@@Akechi_The_Phantom_Detective well I got the stories typed up and some in the works and got some posted on Reddit r/nosleep just gotta read them. And yeah, I'll point meself out.
can we just appreciate how much emotion he uses to tell these stories
I think it's gay
G Robinson absolute nonsense, fucking mirror home wrecker probably, all because your life is shit. Nobody has or will be you because you force it on them
Agreed too many other creepy narrator have monotone or no emotion whatsoever lol
@@calisurfrguy7220 Onlyother narator that comes2mind when they put there all in is creepy ghost stories besides dr creepen I suggest u listen 2 sarah's stoy 1st its what hooked me on him tbh.
Super late to this comment but I had to say this video made me follow him lol. Then I found the Tails from the gas station series.
“I’m whatever you think I am.”
Ends menacingly then goes silent for a few seconds.
“...Hey there kids! It’s me, MrCreepyPasta!”
In famous words of ...Jim carey....Alrighty then ur my rich bf that buys whatever I want then LAWLZ!
That somehow almost gave me a heartattack. XD
I have a theory on who the Stranger is: Death.
All black clothing, hat, suit, tie, etc. And his disdain for both God and Lucifer would make a bit of sense as well, for Death's role is to essentially take people's lives away but because of Heaven and Hell he wouldn't be able to do that fully, for there would be an afterlife.
Chris Kelly
And he went to the church to show that he's more powerful than both God and Lucifer, being a deity himself.
Exactly. Azrael is the angel of death. Hence why he cannot do what God does not allow. Lucifer was God's favorite angel too. Perhaps he is jealous. Look into him.
Well that or something along the lines like “I’m time itself” or “I’m fate itself”
wrong the stranger is actually Azegothyln The Earth Tyrant
Google the last sentence from the Bible.
I love how the Stranger is only called “The Stranger”. He has no name, no identity. He could be anyone. It adds a real air of mystery and general creepiness to him.
Yes that is how good story telling is done
Reminds me of “The Blood Meridian” The Narrator/main character is called “The Kid” and then later at the end “The Man”. It’s one of the greatest books ever written, when I listen to it it sounds like poetry and when I read it, it feels as if I’m reading scripture, like it actually feels important.
I thought that it was in reference to "The Mysterious Stranger" by Mark Twain
Are you the morning star
And clearly a more ancient...thing than Lucifer himself.
I like how at the end the stranger said I'm what ever you think I am. I'd just be like damn that was the all mighty flying spaghetti monster
"I SAID, CAN I GET A FUCKING R'AMEN?!"
im fuckin dead man
Elijah STFU
This is why we can't have nice things!
"I'm David Blane"
"Are you Satan?"
"No, this is Patrick."
I would've died. Ha
😂😂
Omg 😂😂😂 thanks for makin me laugh cuz this story literally scared me...and im not easily scared. "Uneasy" id say
😂 haha wtf
😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
Four years later and this is still one of my all time favorite stories. The sheer amount of learning, practice, blood, sweat, and tears that have gone into your work absolutely NEVER go unnoticed! I’m very grateful to have found your channel!!
For some reason the sinister organ in the background really made this story work.
Even though I'm 3 years late do you know the name of the background music?
@@stone4one121 Check the description, my dude, it's in there with a link and everything so you can check out the rest of the artist's work.
@@darthzaida1881 I tried the link but it's dead. Also I couldn't find the specific track on his twitter either. Oh well ;/
Yes! And i can play like that!
It sounds completely in act with a small town church in my opinion if the organist is still sitting during the message and the Entity spirit overshadows.
That was the most aggressive atheist I've ever seen
I had to laugh at this I don't even know why
What do you guys call a Pokemon Trainer? (Respond for answer If you can't get)
dumbass atheists dont believe in god
+Batxdz _ penis - I don't know what?
,......... Ash
Well, after the stranger got through telling everyone how terrible God was, and him saying "I am whatever you think I am" I believe that than man wasn't the Devil, but God himself.
I was thinking the same thing.
He spent most of that entire "sermon" just shit-talking god. If that was god, he must have one hell of an inferiority complex
@@lapislacooli5939 shit talking the image ppl painted him as
@@dbyfitness2939 Exactly he didn't not DISS himself but what people made him out to be. But got mad asf when he was called the devil. So I'm pretty sure your right with him being the creator.
Or an Anti God
I just got an ad for a online mormon church for this. How ironic
Turns around and says "Im an athiest... from reddit..".
M'lady.
That's perfect!!! 😂
While you studied the bible I was expanding my mind with facts and logic!
@G Robinson Sounds like you're projecting pretty hard there buddy.
@@WokeandProud agreed
Thought the title was the day I lost my father. I was expecting something mediocre and instead I got the Mona Lisa of scary stories
Same
I guess this could be *puts on shades* the ballad of mona lisa
YYYEEEEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHH
get out...
*claps slowly* P!atd for life
Yasss omg
"I'm what ever you think i am."
As he left a massive microphone crushed the entire church.
I love how the main charater is just some random dude, like. He mentions alot that he wasnt particularly close with the victims and ge just sat in the middle of a crowd idk why but i adore the narrator being just some guy
"You nasty son of a biscuit!" I demand a MrCreepyPasta shirt of this.
Extremely well written. And phenomenal delivery as well, MCP.
I don't think I will ever get tired of this story. I've heard it numerous times and enjoy it every time.
by the way he hated Lucifer and preached from the bible, my guess would be he is some sort of an angel/archangel and
they didnt really care about human beings any more than the devil does.
Catalin Sebastian
While the Stranger was "preaching" about how much he hated Satan he also spoke about his hate for Angels as well. He's something else. Perhaps a being as old as God or a being from another dimension. Perhaps in a very cruel twist, he is God Himself come to test man to see if we're worthy.
@@seariakett6929 OMG he's darkness. The entity that existed before God
@@angrytwxgaming8423
That's an exceptional hypothesis. Perhaps, just perhaps you're correct.
There are things out there that have existed since before the beginning of time.
The devil does care for the humans though. He needs them as slaves. This guy is far more brutal than the devil because he doesn't need the humans
Or maybe, we're all wrong. Maybe the man was something we cant begin to understand. Something we as humanity can't label as something we know, but as something we feel. Something deeper then a religious figure, or a monster of our lore. But maybe...maybe im just wrong. Maybe we all are. Maybe we must succumb to the possibility we know nothing.
"I am whatever you think I am".
So he's God, then?
Exodus 3:14 "God said to Moses, “I am who I am.”"
When he said that I thought the same. Sadly it's too ambiguous to be certain.
Nice catch, there @ometta7!
“ I am whatever you say I am, if I wasn’t then why would I say I am” -Eminem
Makes sense because his whole argument is that God is a corrupt being and he seems to be corrupt
Exodus 3:14 "God said to Moses, “I am who I am an' that's all who I am. I'm Popeye the Sailor Man!"
This guy should publish a book
he didnt write this though?
+Chani Atreides Who wrote it if the author didn't?
I believe the thought is that DeadnSpread should write a book to which I would agree
+MrCreepyPasta yeah my fathers cousin is stephen kind i can help out a bit
no he shouldn't xD that'd be the 50 shades of gray movie of books
Damn this one was really good, anybody else pictured the stranger as Allucard from Hellsing?😂
how did you know?
I need to sprint to my church now
yep.
He sure fucked the fear turkey, didn't he?
Cheapskate X Videos Cuz I was there.
Him: "I am whatever you think I am".
Me: "Dad?"
This narration was phenomenal. The emotion and passion you use to speak paired with the voice effects had me at the edge of my seat! Excellent job my friend.
O. o, that was. by far (aside from the Darklings) one of THE BEST "scary" / horror / pasta I have heard in a LONG time!! my compliments to the author. and you sir, are one he'll of a narrator /storyteller
when Satan preaches at ya church
That face when Alucard is watching MrCreepyPasta
when they said it was a dude with a wide brim hat i thought of alucard, maybe this is what alucard does on his day off
I was actually thinking it was God. Showing he was no different than the rest of us.
Don't think he's Satan. He expressed his distaste for him. If anything I think it was god himself.
He said he didn't like Lucifer not Satan
"He's the hero Gotham deserves, but not the one it needs right now"
Christian here: This story is unbelievably well written, and I have no doubt in my mind that the author is very skilled and talented. Although it pained me to listen to (being a Christian) I can't help but love it. There are so many diffrent ways to interpret this story, and so many underlying messages... I can't fathom how another human being wrote this! Fantastic, simply fantastic.
"His slick back blonde hair looked as plastic as his smile"
*Cough cough* Erwin Smith anyone?
"Humanity is corrupted"
Yep. This is secretly attack on Titan
(Giant gasp) You are so right! XXDDDD
Except his mannerisms sound more like Kenny's.
And suit... he’s definitely Eminem from rap god
The narration & the accompanying music make this creepypasta EVERYTHING
Maybe it's Jesus if he hated God for allowing him, his only son to be crucified and did nothing to help him. And the Bible was written that he had resurrected and told people gods plan by the apostles, in an attempt to hide the fact Jesus HAD in fact resurrected, but had gone mad with rage towards God.
Jesus and God were the same being I think
xboxgamer the lines are really blurred in the Bible but the basic idea is that Jesus is God's son
xboxgamer no they're not biblically. They're only the same in certain Christian religions the idea of the trinity is not doctrinal.
When asked who he was Jesus responded with “who do you think I am”, eerily similar to “I am what you think I am”. If not Jesus maybe the antichrist, either way I think you’re on to something.
ConM i didnt think of it that way
I just love the slight distortion in the voices, really adds a whole new level of anonymity
Honestly, this is my favorite creepypasta to ever be written, feel free to disagree with me, but even though the writer wrote something that some may disagree with, you must admit, they wrote it very well.
Cheers to you and the writer of this.
I've listened to this particular story 3 times in 2 weeks now. As the son of a pastor, i envisioned this personally. I work alone as a Night Janitor at a school and this literally scared me while cleaning. Goosebumps. Just...so much passion and emotion behind it. Excellent back soundtrack. You painted this so well, I could see every detail! I WAS THERE! 😳 This is easily my favorite story....
Dude, you NEED to do more stories like these. Creepypastas like this are my favorite kind
That was grotesquely creepy. Surprisingly, I love it. Beautiful work.
This is how every atheist on Reddit feels when they "debate" someone
By debate do you mean Cherry-pick the Bible and just insult as an argument?
+Unix One I think you took my comment too seriously. I'm an atheist, and I think that no matter what religious affiliation you have, it's painfully obvious that many atheists love seeing themselves as an unstoppable tour-de-fours of rationality who can effortlessly debate anyone and win.
Andrew Bryant I wasn't taking it that seriously, I was just asking what you meant by debate. And what you say is true, sadly. Many do find themselves that, and when a religious person makes a good point they stoop to insults because they don't have an actual counter-argument.
religious people are guilty of the same thing tho. Cant we all just get along? :)
well im an atheist too, and i don't argue with theist people unless they try to make other people believe in their gods, and im most of the time polite(unless they're really disrespectful to me) because i understand that what you believe is what you want to believe, and what i believe is what i want to believe.
That was such a great story it gave me chills I can't wait for the book! Also the stranger made some really great points that can test the faith of anyone…even the listers.
"Sam, I think I found us a case..."
The dude reminded me of Dean-Micheal, his hatred to Lucifer and God and how he despises humanity.
I was confused until I read the name😂
"I'm... what ever you think I am" is a response that is actually really good. I think he is god, it's pretty apparent that hes not the devil. as he just rekt'ed himself pretty bad if he was- because of how he started however. he's not wrong. but not right either.
So damn dissatisfying. What a prime opportunity to make the stranger Death- or something even better. Guess he's Lord Chinchin instead though.
pretty sure he was god, makes sense right?
+Brian Robinette thats what i thought he would say
+Wesley Allen
well, he was a god in that he held power and awe over his audience and demonstrated it.
Another person could say that he was simply a agent of a god that few know of, one that sows distrust, death and maddening despair within the ranks of certain populations in a effort to steal them away without the victims even realizing it.
I imagine he is the embodiment of "despair'.
Carol G no it's clearly Lucifer
A damn fine story. More like this please. More religion oriented stories and the ritual pastas. I understand that not everyone enjoys them, but a lot of us do. So please, heed my word. And give us what we desire.
best TED Talks ever
This story is so intense! I usually go for the shorter stories because the longer ones get a little dry. But from the beginning to the very last word this story kept me on edge. I love how the story was told too. With the inflections in his voice and the music matching his enthusiasm.... man. This was a REALLY good story. Keep it up!
"I'm whatever you think I am"
are... are you a yoshi?
Ohhhh a man of culture as well
like he said, a n y t h i n g
Only if hes wearing those super cool boots!
I know this is old, but damn, this is one of the creepiest horror stories to me. I'm not really sure why, it just makes my skin crawl and my stomach churn. I don't even believe in God. But it's still uncomfortable to me. Maybe it's because the thought of God and faith is supposed to something merciful and what a lot of people look at as good, and just seeing it in such a dark light, It doesn't feel right. Most probably won't agree with me, but that's just how I felt.
Most of us are taught that but the Bible is full of horrors. Moses and his crew being told to slaughter the Midinite men, boys and non virgin females. Then for his men to take which virgin girls pleased them as wife. To cut their nails and hair as they cried for their slain parents, and live with them as wife for 30 days. At the end of 30 days if the girl no longer pleased them, then to throw them out. But since god was merciful they weren’t allowed to sell them. Just throw them out stripped of the only value a female had in those days, her hymen. Then there’s how god snatched all the first born sons from their mothers stomachs in Egypt. And how god instructed any man who thought his wife was cheating to take his wife to a holy man and make her drink bitter water which would cause spontaneous abortion if she’d cheated. There’s so many stories that are fcked up in the Bible that tell of a prideful, vengeful, fickle god. Dude sounds like a narcissistic sociopath to me.
Zoey
As Mark Twain said “you come to realize that god is a malign thug”
Anyone know what the orchestra music is
This is still one of the craziest creepypastas I've ever listened to.
Literally!
'The day I lost my faith'....when I played Outlast 2.
One of my fave tales, and you #MrCreepyPasta have been the only one so far to have told it absolutely perfectly. A truly brill feelpasta to me. tyvm as ALWAYS for the amazing work you do. with huge thanks from the UK/Glasgow-Scotland
Not only is this amazingly written, but MrCreepyPasta did a wonderful job narrating it. This is one of my favorite stories he's read based on the uh.. not sure how to put it? How it's narrated I guess. It's really good and I get completely transfixed every time.
This sounds like an edgy kids daydream
Pretty much.
YEEES. Was thinking the same thing
yes but remarkably lucid and although he was a vile creature he had a point about humanity
"I'm whatever you think I am"
Me: Harambe?
It's been so long since I seen a joke about Harambe..
"If i wasnt, then why would I SAY i am!"
Too Soon™
"The Day I Lost My Identity" by Spongebob Squarepants | CreepyPasta Storytime
One of the most well made creepy pastas I have ever heard.
Thats was an amazing story. Out of thousands of stories Ive read or listened to, that one is number one on my list. Pure gold.
So he's a pink fluffy unicorn dancing on rainbows
I take it you know nothing of any religion or their histories or their different incarnations
+Chani Atreides I take it you didn't catch the joke???
+DanteCross That burn though
+Isa R. *tips top hat* well thank you.
Chani Atreides You must have no humor
Awesome background music on this one!
+MrCreepyPasta : You nasty son of a biscuit.....haha...
This story is amazing. I have listened to it three times already and it is still giving me chills. Amazing job!!!!! I love your channel!!!!!
Watch stephen king's storm of the century. It's basically the same thing.
@@leoperez636 Oh cool!! I will check it out thanks for the recommendation
This is the best one I have heard, I mean its not just the story alone but the way its being delivered, the music, its just epic
4:22 When you Rekt them n0obs "Sit the fuck down!"
LoL
This would be awesome animated. Like a short anime scene 🤷🏾♂️
This is one of my favorite stories.
MCP this one needs a remaster. Or at least a rerelease. It's so good.
JESUS CHRIST (no pun intended) I had a knot in my chest through this whole story! Bravo MCP! This is without a doubt one of your greatest and most terrifying narrations ever!
Crack theory: The stranger is the guy from "Why I became an athiest" who somehow obtained God powers
The 666 carved into his skin imbued him with demon powers. Again, crack pot theory.
*he turns around*
"Im a nice guy"
*sheeths katana*
"WHY DO GIRLS GO FOR DOUCHEBAGS??? I WOULD TREAT HER RIGHT"
Last time I was this early Kevin Durant didn't lose a 3-1 Series lead
last time i was this early he was at the thunder
This is one of my favorite stories I've listened to and I've listened to most.
You MrCreepy Voice are a Legend.
Awesomeness as always
I listen to your narrations. Like all day radio
So to prove that people sin, he murders several people, commits blasphemy, and performs unspeakable acts on, realistically, innocent civilians? He's worse than any of them there and his whole point is to prove he's superior?
Man, this is some edgy misanthropic shit. Topped with a fedora and all.
Isn't this what people do nowadays anyway? He does not have to prove any sin, he is just pointing it out to the cognitively dissonant, but i agree he didn't have to kill anyone.
You literally missed the entire point of the story, the man is God himself, his opening statement even calls himself out on his own corruption that's worse than any human, and the whole point of why he did it was because he could do what he did.
His point was to sow distrust in their faith, not point them out as sinners
@@Heavensira50 you missed the entire point of the story too. The man is NOT god, but someone who acts out side the boundaries of their held faith.
@@Youwouldknowmebtnow To be honest the complete story is subjective to the belief of the viewer and can be interpreted as a slew of different ideas, I simply stated what I stated because it happens all the time, because even then your idea is right in your eyes but wrong in someone else's 🙂
Everyone's here saying how good the story is while I'm here thinking about stories from the Bible that could support the idea presented in this story... the Christian God has done some fucked up and questionable shit...
Also nicely hinting that the stranger was in fact God.
"I can only do this if God allows it"
"I know more about God than you"(referring to the preacher)
I am what you think I am"(God is omnipresent therefore anything)
"Lucifer a failed child"(God regards satan as his only failure in revelations)
Rather subtle, and I may just be reading into it, but I think that conclusion rounds off the story nicely :)
thats the funny part god himself says he is a jelous and wrathfull god,
+James Brewer - it's also amusing how we can assume he was punishing sinners & preformed biblical killings.
We can assume Mr. Margo is abusive to his wife when the narrator says he jerks his wife by her arm. Annie was a harlot & in the old days, they were put on display and killed. And we already get the Abraham one. The wife was killed because she got in the way.
I could be wrong but just a fun thought.
+iB0NKERS - performed*
+iB0NKERS ah, the bible, the gift that jut keeps giving :p
It was the super devil
Great story!! This grabbed my attention the whole time, and was fun to try and guess what was gonna happen next. He's become my favorite new author, his story "New Fish" is so well written, it's my absolute favorite creepypasta.
I did enjoy this story, but you should listen to Scary Story Time With Liam his stories are so fucking amazing (he's an author and narrates!) , his imagery and description is simply amazing. You should try Pursuit Institute, The Mangled, Mistrust Game, Glacial Ice, hell just about all his stories are amazing tbh..
It's still best after 6 years. 💝
Redditors when they parents make them go to church
9:15
Being made in the image of God doesn't mean we become perfect little angels.
Being made in the image of God means we are capable of telling what's right, and what's wrong. If we aren't made in such a manner, then there wouldn't be free will.
The music was amazing in this video
Thanks!
Please upload it on your channel @^@
+MiraiMemento it's on my website tho. I posted the link in the description and in the comments.
codbarley
Oh, ahahah somehow I skipped over it while reading the description even though it was in bold and went directly to your channel searching for it xD! My bad...
+MiraiMemento yeah somehow everyone is missing it. It's getting kinda tiresome pointing out the obvious. The link is in the description and like, 5 different comments at this point. You'd think people would up-vote those comments
THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST ONE IVE HEARD!
Nice job my man! Was on the edge of my seat the whole time! 👍
This was the first video of yours I’ve ever watched and I’m hooked! Great job sir, loved it entirely.
You’ve got another subscriber here. 🥰
It's harambe come back to judge us of our sins
I am whatever you say I am.
If I wasn't, why would I say I am?
In the paper, the news, every day I am.
I don't know, it's just the way I am.
AM, is that you?
i imagine the stranger looks like a pale david tennant lol
kiernan o'connell i never realised but that is what i also think he looks like
ya know, this is one of my favorite pastas. ive listened to this so many times ive lost track. its so well done
I love that you've been narrating such good stories lately, MCP! Your reading voice is great, but hearing a well-written story is always better than your typical Jeff the Killer trash. Not that this story doesn't have its flaws, but I just listened to one of the worst stories I've ever heard on another channel and this was a breath of fresh air.
Instead of telling the man: "Im whatever you think i am", he should have said: "im the snake who was forced to slither on his belly for the rest of etenity"
snake is supposedly the devil. he stated very sternly that he has a strong dislike towards the devil. Dont think he's the snake.
I think he should have said.I Am God.
I think maybe he should've been like the second coming of Christ
+frelee4567 that would've left even more holes. If he's Christ his behavior wouldnt make sense and even if he was, the story didn't even address why Jesus would hate god. so no, his original line was perfect ans full of interpretation
DuceyBlooDoe It was something cool that i thought of. Me personaly, i dont think the snake was the devil, rather a creature who felt the same way the 'stranger' does. It is my opinion tho, i respect you're own xD
I thought the stranger was going to say, "I am God"
And everyone left alive would have their own interpretations of "God"...some following him...some asking to join him...some jealous of him...some wanting his power....others fearing him....yes...i like ur idea!
I can't help but wonder.
The Stranger...
The Man In Black...
Were his initials R.F., reckon?
GODDAMNIT FLAGG
I listen to this every so often when i need to think about something. Gives me chills everytime.
That was beautiful, like i was there watching the whole thing laughing in the corner
Calling man a bunch of apes is not an insult to apes, it's a factual statement. Homo Sapiens is a species of apes. That's not up for debate.
+Chani Atreides we are humans there's nothing like us we build huge structures we have intelligent thought we are not ape nor are we just primates
justin nixon
You apparently do not understand taxonomy, which is the study of animal classification. It places humans in the same area as apes. In fact, there is only a 2% difference in the DNA between humans and chimps.
haha, look at you making up words such as speciesism. Man is above animals, not because he is more intelligent, but because he can control his urges unlike the lesser beings that roam this planet.
An animal will eat when it's hungry, drink when it's thirsty and mate when it gets the urge. The same cannot be said for people who follow certain religions and spiritual paths. They will not become slaves of their urges, instead they will control their urges.
The rest of your post is pure gibberish. The world has no problems with humans. Do you really think it cares about a certain species because it comes in a different color or it si altered slightly compared to the rest? Mankind's destruction is great, but nowhere near the destruction which happened during mass extinctions.
I did not introduce the word "speciesism" to this thread, you did. I brought up taxonomy, which is very basic biology. Humans are not and will never be above animals. This is for one simple reason, we are animals. Religion has nothing to do with this conversation, this is all science. It doesn't matter if you believe what I'm saying because at the end of the day, you're still an ape just like every single human on the planet.
jtbrad Well my reply was towards Cynical DL1, but for whatever reason TH-cam doesn't put the name of the person I am replying to.
Like I said, humans can be above animals if they learn to control their urges.
man was created in God's image, then man separated from God when he was ate the apple. that's the rebuttal the pastor should have used.
Of course, the author wouldn't use that rebuttal, if they did they couldn't make the story so edgy.
so man ate a magical bad apple that god purposely put in close proximity to him, without even giving him a good explanation as to why he shouldn't eat it and instead just made a pretty vague statement,and here we are today. because man with his curious nature was purposely put close to a magic apple that he eas told not to eat.10/10 in terms of rationality and believability.
Could Adam sue God for entrapment, for that apple trick of his?
LuiKang043 Nope, given they had the choice not to eat it.
+LuiKang043 hmmm...leaving him alone with an evil magical apple, and using reverse psychology telling him not to eat that specific apple, all the while not actually offering a reason as to why he shouldn't, as any highly rational being such as a human would require, but rather treating the man as a stupid child knowing full well he is a highly intelligent and curious creature. yes i think adam could make a case, although i have no idea how he would get a lawyer to believe this insane story.
I read the title as "The Day I Lost My Father" around 8 minutes in I remembered why I stopped going to church
Your creepypasta storytelling is a lot better than other TH-cam channels stroytelling because u put a lot of a emotion in it
just finished listening to this for the Tenth time .... greatest story I've ever heard ... and Soooo well narrated , the reason I subscribed to this channel
CAN I GET A MOTHERFUCKING AH-MEN!?
AHHH MEEEN
I imagine the stranger looks a lot like Voltaire the singer from awe idk why
this ship was wood
sorry auto correct *shit* *good*
Simple as it is, your comment just made my day.
James Mellenthin still makes sense though
i fucking love this creepypasta. in fact i was recommended this story when you made this video back in 2016 as i listeed to a lot of CreepsMcPasta and after listening to your story telling, i love it. it's seriously amazing. and because of you and MrCreeps, i make my own stories and plan to read them and make videos like this.
Bless you Wolvie that sounds awesome. Make sure you point yourself out when you do. This is a really good one I love the story.
@@Akechi_The_Phantom_Detective what do ya mean by "point yourself out"? Do ya mean as in my stories to get them read or somet else?
@@demongoddess2012 Yeah bud the stories, I always like looking for channels like this to listen to some well narrated horror. I always enjoy it.
@@Akechi_The_Phantom_Detective well I got the stories typed up and some in the works and got some posted on Reddit r/nosleep just gotta read them. And yeah, I'll point meself out.
this is by far my favourite story. so well written and spoken 🙄