About the same time you published this, Red Ebony did one discussing F2P 5 star generals vs 1 star premium generals. I think this is worth exploring, especially looking at the premium generals available in Trial of Knights. Lu Xun is of particular interest to me. To be able to find comparable generals without the high cost of Blood of Ares is very appealing.
... and this was _before_ *Marco Polo* turned up who I wouldn't be surprised if he was right up there too (barring that March Size with no Red Stars which I love *Washington (Prime)* for as Assist
Marco Polo 3 red stars might be better than full dev Napoleon prime LOL. Also, now we can have a very strong combo just with 2 or 3 copies of this generals. Washington Prime+Marco or Marco 1red+Washington. Run the math mate :) thanks again
@@paulovaz3387 Marco + Washington at base level is going to be a crazy combo. At 3 stars Marco Polo is better than Napoleon and Washington at full ascension.
The disparity generally resides in march size. Particularly at higher keep levels, (but even at lower) march size is king. Washington prime doesn't get MS from red stars (save for 5%) , that's why this particular disparity is so glaring. Also why Alexander is even viable, since without MS, he's not even a topic of conversation. Messena is mid tier, if not for his MS as well.
hello ! i did some quick math while disregarding base stats and stats growth and here is what i got it is a comparison between a maxed ronald+WP as assitant vs WP 1red+java and this is what it boils down to 11% march size(Ronald and washington) OR 25% atk and 15% def/hp(washington and java guy, no base growth accounted for)
Everyone can decide what way they want to play. A mate in my alliance went ans fully ascended Elektra, Minamoto, King Arthur, Boudica. He suck the blood of ares there and is happy, saying he would ultimately put them in Senate. I use premium generals with 1-3 stsrs depending on luck. Now saving premium summon tokens for next combo general event (ala Gunther + Melisande, Ragnar + Signur). I am saving Blood of Ares for duty generals. Different ideologies, hardly any big mistake between the former or the latter. As for your big surprise - every similar game does this. Power creep over time is a serious thing one needs to keep in mind. it has nothing to do with "fair" or "unfair", as noone is being barred from getting lucky enough to get one copy of a new general. I actually find that the new generals being viable at 0 to 1 red star is actually quite nice. sure, for the top notch buff you have to get full ascension with skins and everything... so only for big spenders. this way, small coiners or f2p can actually get relevant assistants
It is nice that they are usable as a base general, I just think that they shouldn't make a free general that someone worked on obsolete. The only other mobile game I've played extensively is Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes, and I like their model better. They have new characters that have power creep, but they become available to everyone to fully upgrade within 6 months to a year. They also rework old outdated characters to make them useful. In SWGOH you need a large roster of characters since they have many different uses, so very few could be considered useless. In Evony you need maybe 10 generals for PvP, and once they aren't useful for that they can go sit in the senate.
Where can we find this excel file to test what’s the best general for our marches? I’m thinking all these ranks always consider only using top t14-15 troops and no layers. March size buffs may be overrated.
Washington prime is the best right now but give it 6 months and Washington prime will probably slip to mid tier to obsolete compared to the lastest greatest that comes out in 6 months time
I'm using full poli as a main with Washington as an assistant, so basically it's now worth switching them up since I can only 2 red star Washington? Lol that's sad
"hidden stats" was a term I used for the thumbnail. They aren't really hidden, the formula to find them is hidden. If you look at your base attributes + cultivation it will tell you what your current atk/def/hp % is, but my calculator will tell you what that number will be at future levels. For my videos that are based on a level 30 general with 5 gold stars.
@@Maath_Faseli ok. Red Evony just did a similar video where he basically said 6 star premium are better than 10 star free. I’m still not convinced a 1 red star Merlin is better than 5 red Electra and I’m too lazy to do the math.
Not gonna lie I was starting to regret getting 16 copies to fully ascend him a bit out of Fomo despite already having Napoleon Prime, but this makes me at least feel like I may have other uses for him
About the same time you published this, Red Ebony did one discussing F2P 5 star generals vs 1 star premium generals. I think this is worth exploring, especially looking at the premium generals available in Trial of Knights. Lu Xun is of particular interest to me. To be able to find comparable generals without the high cost of Blood of Ares is very appealing.
... and this was _before_ *Marco Polo* turned up who I wouldn't be surprised if he was right up there too (barring that March Size with no Red Stars which I love *Washington (Prime)* for as Assist
"hit like, or something" 😂
Good catch man. Thanks for the depressing news. LOL Take care.
And now we have Marco Polo mounted General that looks better than Washington prime
Marco Polo 3 red stars might be better than full dev Napoleon prime LOL. Also, now we can have a very strong combo just with 2 or 3 copies of this generals. Washington Prime+Marco or Marco 1red+Washington. Run the math mate :) thanks again
yeah he is better, I'm editing the video now
@@paulovaz3387 Marco + Washington at base level is going to be a crazy combo. At 3 stars Marco Polo is better than Napoleon and Washington at full ascension.
@@paulovaz3387 i was still using a 2 star martinus so i just went all in getting marco polo ascended using 86 gen chests/glory chests haha.
The disparity generally resides in march size. Particularly at higher keep levels, (but even at lower) march size is king. Washington prime doesn't get MS from red stars (save for 5%) , that's why this particular disparity is so glaring. Also why Alexander is even viable, since without MS, he's not even a topic of conversation.
Messena is mid tier, if not for his MS as well.
hello !
i did some quick math while disregarding base stats and stats growth and here is what i got
it is a comparison between a maxed ronald+WP as assitant
vs
WP 1red+java
and this is what it boils down to
11% march size(Ronald and washington)
OR
25% atk and 15% def/hp(washington and java guy, no base growth accounted for)
Everyone can decide what way they want to play.
A mate in my alliance went ans fully ascended Elektra, Minamoto, King Arthur, Boudica. He suck the blood of ares there and is happy, saying he would ultimately put them in Senate.
I use premium generals with 1-3 stsrs depending on luck. Now saving premium summon tokens for next combo general event (ala Gunther + Melisande, Ragnar + Signur). I am saving Blood of Ares for duty generals.
Different ideologies, hardly any big mistake between the former or the latter.
As for your big surprise - every similar game does this. Power creep over time is a serious thing one needs to keep in mind. it has nothing to do with "fair" or "unfair", as noone is being barred from getting lucky enough to get one copy of a new general. I actually find that the new generals being viable at 0 to 1 red star is actually quite nice. sure, for the top notch buff you have to get full ascension with skins and everything... so only for big spenders.
this way, small coiners or f2p can actually get relevant assistants
It is nice that they are usable as a base general, I just think that they shouldn't make a free general that someone worked on obsolete.
The only other mobile game I've played extensively is Star Wars Galaxy of Heroes, and I like their model better. They have new characters that have power creep, but they become available to everyone to fully upgrade within 6 months to a year. They also rework old outdated characters to make them useful. In SWGOH you need a large roster of characters since they have many different uses, so very few could be considered useless. In Evony you need maybe 10 generals for PvP, and once they aren't useful for that they can go sit in the senate.
Where can we find this excel file to test what’s the best general for our marches? I’m thinking all these ranks always consider only using top t14-15 troops and no layers. March size buffs may be overrated.
Watch my latest video to see where to get them and how to use them
Washington prime is the best right now but give it 6 months and Washington prime will probably slip to mid tier to obsolete compared to the lastest greatest that comes out in 6 months time
I'm using full poli as a main with Washington as an assistant, so basically it's now worth switching them up since I can only 2 red star Washington? Lol that's sad
So in that case it would depend mainly on the attributes/cultivation. You'll still get most of Washington's buffs as an assistant so probably use him
There's no such thing as balance in evony 😂
It's fair to them. You line their pockets and they give you Worth while generals. Free to Play is always given a raw deal.
Boo Hoo. Thats with every game
@@Sid_2007 not every game, mobile games are generally worse than others, but evony is bad even for mobile games
Give covenant on ftp general's to even it out
Does this make us rethink wall general Assistants? (That aren't wall generals?)
this won't affect the discussion about assistants in any category, and the wall generals are more balanced than others so I don't think so.
Quit evony that is the best part of your life
I already did, I just make the videos now 😂
Does your calculator include the “hidden stats” you talked about before when you increase your red stars?
Or is it purely the stat value stated in the stat column
"hidden stats" was a term I used for the thumbnail. They aren't really hidden, the formula to find them is hidden. If you look at your base attributes + cultivation it will tell you what your current atk/def/hp % is, but my calculator will tell you what that number will be at future levels. For my videos that are based on a level 30 general with 5 gold stars.
@@Maath_Faseli ok. Red Evony just did a similar video where he basically said 6 star premium are better than 10 star free. I’m still not convinced a 1 red star Merlin is better than 5 red Electra and I’m too lazy to do the math.
Which genral is best in mounted troops in 2024 in traven
Roland
@@Maath_Faseli can we take him base attacks or monster .. If possible can you please share best genrals in all sectors..
@@vijaykatari4520 he works for both. If you want to see the best generals for all categories watch my free to play guide
So what does this mean for Prime assistant, is it still Napoleon?
yes it doesn't change anything about assistants
ENG: Ha ha ha 😂😂😂 LoL
Not gonna lie I was starting to regret getting 16 copies to fully ascend him a bit out of Fomo despite already having Napoleon Prime, but this makes me at least feel like I may have other uses for him
Until they release someone better he is by far the best general in the game
I spoke too soon lol, the power creep is unreal