Kamahl was ‘spot on’ with $40 billion Indigenous spending claim
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ก.ย. 2024
- Sky News host Peta Credlin says Kamahl was “spot on” during his interview with The Project, where the musician claimed Australia spends about $40 billion every year on Indigenous people.
Ms Credlin points to the Productivity Commission’s 2017 Indigenous Expenditure Report, which states the total direct government expenditure on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians was estimated to be $33.4 billion in 2015-16.
“Then there's all the specific Indigenous programmes run by state and federal governments, such as the $4.5 billion a year spent by the National Indigenous Australians Agency,” she said.
“Adjusting the 2016 figure in the Productivity Commission's report for inflation, well, that gives us a figure of $39.5 billion in Aboriginal spending today.”
Ms Credlin warned against “misleading” and “deceptive” commentary surrounding the Voice to Parliament debate.
Typical project panel - insufferable. Thanks Kamahl. Vote No
They have remained of the American show call the View the women on the show are horrible and a very aggressive.
Paid disingenuous woketards
those catty smug high school girls, also known as the Project hosts, do love to white-splain now don't they?
its got to be made for people with intellectual disabilities i swear
In the interest of fairness and free speech it ought to be renamed "the choice"
*do you choose to divide, relinquish rights, vote for inequality and higher taxes?*
Of course you don't but that is what the voice will be able to do, *no high court can override the constitution* (if these facts scare you, VOTE NO to the utopian woke BS of the Australian Low-Ball Party)
Thanks, Project. This confirms why we're voting NO!!
It also confirms why I don't watch The Project.
@@LittleTumbleweed22who does?
I particularly enjoyed the bit where a whole bunch of white people told a brown man what he should be thinking... = \
The Project is the bastard child of the ABC (Australian Bureau of Communism)!! .... and the WOKE Capital of Australia.
Confirms why I don’t watch the project and why I’m voting a big fat NO
I agree with Anthony Albanese, we should all listen to Kamahl. So let's Vote No Australia.
🤣👍
He even coined a new term Kamahl-mentum
@@kennedysan1045Perfect timing too. Thank you Albo 😂👍
I saw a comment last week, some guy said if yes is good enough for kamayl, then it's good enough for him.... so he is no voting now as well? 😂
@@trixmanialol
Khamal was asked onto the show to be a poster boy for the Yes, but as soon as he indicated he is voting No, they all had to go offsript and they targetted him to discredit him and embarrass him. it was disgusting but typical of how No voters are treated. this is why No voters keep quiet. Khamal should be admired for being brave and advocating for the No. The Project totally exposed themselves.
No voters keep quite ??? what planet are you on .. Kamahl is an arrogant idiot , i know him personally .. where are all these so called Billions ? there are less than one million indigenous in this country , if you gave every single one of them one $million that equates to One Billion, so where are these so called 30 or 40 billion ? ... and are all aboriginals Millionaires ?. Thats one of the reasons for the Voice , to sort out the bullshyte you support without ever investigating if its true .... thats how Hitler coned a nation , propaganda and bullshyte.
The Project needs to clarify their mistake publicly on the show. They tried to make Kamala look stupid.
Shouldnt the Project be held accountable for misleading the public about the 40 Billion?
misinformation from the project!
I wonder if the Project is aware of how many viewers they have lost
Yes they should .. communists don’t understand money
That's misinformation , & dissinformation you project fuckwitts
Yes !
40 billion dollars for 700.000 or so people who claim to be indigenous with half that actually on the indigenous registry system. Where is the money going? He's right. Someone has their pockets full of cash
Pretty sure it's over 300,000 First Nations with the latest census have under 500,000 claim it. This is why I wish they would remove the "what ethnicity" question as people can claim anything with no proven ancestry.
I've always wondered myself. Where the hell is all the money going. And what about all the mining royalties from mining on Aboriginal land. That money alone should be able to make Aboriginal communities better and outcomes. Taxpayers shouldn't be needed any more.
@@baz3575 I agree. But it still don't answer the question on where the money gone. If they get 40 billion dollars a year that's 400 billion dollars a decade for only a small manoirty of people. That's a lot of money. You could build a entire first class city looking better than surface paradise with that amout of cash. Why are indigenous Australians don't even have a local hospital and some living in run down homes. Who's got the cash? Someone needs to be put in Jail. Australia not only need to say no to this voice but find out where the money gone. The tax man needs to cancel all transactions till they find out who has it and what they did with it
Australia with all its natural resources is probably on level with the UAE with its oil money whom are building cities like Dubai, but where is our money going to? That’s right, 40 billion a year is going to a community with little in return. We should have cities rivalling Dubai on our eastern shores so this probably explains why we are a nation resource rich but little to show for it.
Yeah white people
$40 billion taxpayer dollars a year spent on Aboriginal projects is a phenomenal amount of money, & yet there isn’t enough to build a boarding school for outback indigenous children who need help & guidance? Something doesn’t add up right here???
Albenese would rather spend it on advertising than actually helping those in need
It's money laundering for kick backs to Communists and UN officials. You think ALP actually won an election with votes?
If you worked in a variety of positions in the welfare system for several decades as I have, then you would know where the money goes. It goes to white leftist-feminist witches pretending to be societies' most caring people.
AGREE but its more: Budget October 2022-23: National Indigenous Australians Agency
Implementation of the Uluru Statement from the Heart
$50.2 million for the Australian Electoral Commission to prepare for the referendum to enshrine a Voice to Parliament in the Constitution.
$5.8 million to commence work on establishing an independent Makarrata Commission to oversee processes for agreement-making and truth-telling, as part of the Government’s $27.7 million election commitment.
Indigenous health & education
$54.3 million to train 500 First Nations health workers and practitioners.
$164.3 million for vital health infrastructure projects that will provide modern, high-quality health clinics in areas of large and growing First Nations populations, and to build capacity in targeting chronic disease treatment and rehabilitation.
$22.5 million to build a dedicated Birthing on Country Centre of Excellence at the Waminda health service in Nowra, New South Wales.
$14.2 million to double the current funding to the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) to combat Rheumatic Heart Disease in high-risk communities over the next three years.
$45 million for 30 four-chair dialysis units to provide better renal services across Australia.
$800,000 to improve the care of patients with chronic diseases to be delivered by the Redfern Aboriginal Medical Service and the Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation Aboriginal Medical Service.
Wilcannia, White Cliffs and Menindee in New South Wales will benefit from $1.9 million to purchase dialysis treatment buses to deliver care closer to home.
$14.1 million to place First Nations educators in 60 primary schools to teach First Nations languages and provide greater cultural understanding.
$33.7 million to make early childhood education and care more accessible for Indigenous families, with access to 36 subsidised hours per fortnight.
$190.0 million over four years to help First Nations controlled and Community Sector Organisations (CSO) to maintain quality services in light of rising costs.
Housing in remote communities
$25 million for housing and essential services on Northern Territory homelands as an immediate boost, with a further $75 million allocated for 2023-24.
Justice investment
$81.5 million to invest in up to 30 community-led justice reinvestment initiatives across Australia and establish an independent national justice reinvestment unit as recommended by the Australian Law Reform Commission, the largest funding package in justice reinvestment ever committed by the Commonwealth.
$13.5 million in additional funding to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (ATSILS) to increase its capacity to provide culturally appropriate legal assistance in coronial inquiries.
$1 million to build greater capacity in the peak body, the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (NATSILS) to provide leadership across the Indigenous legal sector.
$3 million to support the National Family Violence Prevention Legal Services Forum, and the FVPLS providers who deliver legal assistance and non-legal support to victim-survivors of family and domestic violence and sexual assault.
In addition to the above:
$14 million will be delivered over four years as part of the Government’s Central Australia Plan to deliver immediate and medium-term crime prevention and community safety programs in Central Australia.
the highly successful Indigenous Protected Areas program will be extended beyond 2023, and 10 new Indigenous Protected Areas created by 2028.
$83.8 million will be invested to develop and deploy microgrid technology across First Nations communities to increase access to cheaper, cleaner and more reliable energy.
$2 million will establish an Ambassador for First Nations Peoples to take Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives and experiences to the world.
funding will be provided for a trial program as a first step to replacing the Community Development Program. Australian Government site: check it out - OVER REPRESENTED AND TIME THE GRAVY TRAIN GOT CUT!
There is not "$40bn taxpayer dollars a year spent on Aboriginal projects". That is a fucking lie.
Thanks Kamahl. We must stand against racism ✊
So you are voting Yes?
Kamahl's an Aussie living legend ✌️
The Project's simply a joke 😤
Great comment. You've obviously gone to a lot of trouble to find the truth.
@@user-eq8iq2gh6kTheir land their Country their Rule
As simple as that....yess a biggg yess to indegebious rights
World us watching closely on ausie and their hypocrisy
The Project should publically apologise. It was disgusting how they treated him.
We know that’s not going to happen.
@brucemoller7012 the Liberal politicians should at least be exposing their lies on national news. Then maybe the Project will apologise.
The Liberal Party should take a stand against this sort of dirty politics.
@@k20t30pllibs are not on our side bro. They set us up with covid/jabs, and hospital passed the election to labour. Then the identity politics and climate change goes forward. This was conspiracy theory 1 year ago. They were right again
@@k20t30plThere are no lies on the NO side .
Why are people so unkind?
For God's sake, I'd be happy if we spent 40 billion to get rid of the Project!
lol
I'd spend more
It would be worth $1 Trillion
And get rid of channel 10 .
I never watch the stupid show it's so hipicrol on people but it's all for a laugh isn't it Project.
I was disgusted with the pile on and the derision let alone the inaccurate fact check. These unprofessional individuals should be sacked!
It will add to the No vote for sure. I mean how does this look from their own ideological optics? A bunch of white people piling on a brown man?
Disgusted but not surprised.
News delivered in a different way is their motto isn’t it? In other words news delivered without being based on facts.
Smug bunch of Leftie latte sippers
They are horrid people pretending to be caring.
The fact check was accurate. It's Peta who should apologise for lying.
Plain and simple . . . . . . . discard the Voice and AUDIT the Indigenous programs, whether it is 4 Billion or 40 Billion, still alot of money that needs to be accounted for.
Indigenous programs are about $4 billion but Indigenous spending in general is $40 billion
I can't believe how the tore him to pieces. That was disgusting and the fact that 40 billion is what we all heard in the past is correct...
the project should apologise to Kamahl. they are the ones who got it wrong.
They were not wrong, they were being deceitful, manipulative and bullying.
Well thats a first! NOT
The show project has some activists who are wrong and that annoying man verbalising questioning Kamahl's credibility he didn't seem to want to believe this 40 billion dollar tax payer funded bill is real . Vote NO !
And then he got the sh*ts when the interview was over and almost threw his pen. All those activist types have serious anger issues and just want to cr*p up the place, like a child throwing a tantrum. If he really wants to throw a tantrum he should hold his breath, for as long as it takes...
sadly, while he is correct, he needed information to back the number. needs to watch this to affirm this position.
That's because he's a Project poppet.
I wonder how much they got paid by the yes campaign for that little stunt? Me & my mum used to love that show but no longer. How much do you want to bet they won't apologize for embarrassing a great Australian or for telling a bunch of made up lies on national TV either? I suppose the whole yes campaign is built on on a fat sack of lies anyway so why would one more lie get in the way of yet another BS story? Vote NO!!
Don't watch the crap show. Don't like Walleed. Just another leftie program. Wouldn't waste my time.
Vote No Australia, we are one people in Australia.
Sorry, but wherever Whi te people are, there will never be "one people." Everywhere Whi te people are, there is a large portion of the others that are always going to be envious and hateful towards them, no matter how much they get from the Whi tes. Not to mention, as a unique global minority, being "one people" with others is ultimately a path to eventually not existing anymore. Which is really what a lot of these ppl want.
I bet your white 😂
I'm native and I'm voting NO
@@gravellergear4703 well that's your choice but always let other people have they're own, as it's they're own country by native blood and birth of great grandfathers who were the original Australian
@user-dc8uu4zj9t if they gave us all the details of what it the voice is about, then I may reconsider it. But they can't even answer simple questions. It's like buying a mystery box, but the mystery box is titled "The Voice" and it's costing taxpayers billions of dollars.
Thank you for correcting the figures that the "Project" wanted to hide. I bet they won't come out and fix their blunder. Please keep spreading the truth. All Aussies should be treated equally. If certain groups need extra assistance, there is more than enough FUND$$$ to go around. There is only 25million of us, so 40 BILLION should suffice.
she didn't "correct" anything. She lied about it.
and they wonder why so many Aussies are walking away from TV shows like the Project and Q and A. The days of well researched hosts and reporters are mostly gone and these types of shows are run by Narcissists.
cheap trailer trash tv
Kamal should demand an apology from the project for trying to make him look like a fool . An on air apology admitting their fact checking was not fact
Yes, on TV
The project can’t apologise for their years of atrocious “reporting”… I highly doubt they would have the guts to apologise on this one.
Yeah , goodluck with that...
Na,he’s voting no so no apology..
Thanks for backing up Kamahls accurate figure regarding $ spent on Aboriginals and shame on The Project talking heads for their toxic, dismissive responses.
The project Muppets are a bunch of flogs
Implementation of the Uluru Statement from the Heart
$50.2 million for the Australian Electoral Commission to prepare for the referendum to enshrine a Voice to Parliament in the Constitution.
$5.8 million to commence work on establishing an independent Makarrata Commission to oversee processes for agreement-making and truth-telling, as part of the Government’s $27.7 million election commitment.
Indigenous health & education
$54.3 million to train 500 First Nations health workers and practitioners.
$164.3 million for vital health infrastructure projects that will provide modern, high-quality health clinics in areas of large and growing First Nations populations, and to build capacity in targeting chronic disease treatment and rehabilitation.
$22.5 million to build a dedicated Birthing on Country Centre of Excellence at the Waminda health service in Nowra, New South Wales.
$14.2 million to double the current funding to the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) to combat Rheumatic Heart Disease in high-risk communities over the next three years.
$45 million for 30 four-chair dialysis units to provide better renal services across Australia.
$800,000 to improve the care of patients with chronic diseases to be delivered by the Redfern Aboriginal Medical Service and the Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation Aboriginal Medical Service.
Wilcannia, White Cliffs and Menindee in New South Wales will benefit from $1.9 million to purchase dialysis treatment buses to deliver care closer to home.
$14.1 million to place First Nations educators in 60 primary schools to teach First Nations languages and provide greater cultural understanding.
$33.7 million to make early childhood education and care more accessible for Indigenous families, with access to 36 subsidised hours per fortnight.
$190.0 million over four years to help First Nations controlled and Community Sector Organisations (CSO) to maintain quality services in light of rising costs.
Housing in remote communities
$25 million for housing and essential services on Northern Territory homelands as an immediate boost, with a further $75 million allocated for 2023-24.
Justice investment
$81.5 million to invest in up to 30 community-led justice reinvestment initiatives across Australia and establish an independent national justice reinvestment unit as recommended by the Australian Law Reform Commission, the largest funding package in justice reinvestment ever committed by the Commonwealth.
$13.5 million in additional funding to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (ATSILS) to increase its capacity to provide culturally appropriate legal assistance in coronial inquiries.
$1 million to build greater capacity in the peak body, the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (NATSILS) to provide leadership across the Indigenous legal sector.
$3 million to support the National Family Violence Prevention Legal Services Forum, and the FVPLS providers who deliver legal assistance and non-legal support to victim-survivors of family and domestic violence and sexual assault.
In addition to the above:
$14 million will be delivered over four years as part of the Government’s Central Australia Plan to deliver immediate and medium-term crime prevention and community safety programs in Central Australia.
the highly successful Indigenous Protected Areas program will be extended beyond 2023, and 10 new Indigenous Protected Areas created by 2028.
$83.8 million will be invested to develop and deploy microgrid technology across First Nations communities to increase access to cheaper, cleaner and more reliable energy.
$2 million will establish an Ambassador for First Nations Peoples to take Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives and experiences to the world.
funding will be provided for a trial program as a first step to replacing the Community Development Program.
Nope. Kamahl was misled and Peta is lying.
@@anonleft prove it Einstein
@anonleft the figure is from the government expenditure report. So it's the government's lie... no one else's. But you still wholeheartedly trust them obviously
They owe Kamahl an apology. What disgusting behaviour. Also they showed how inept they are as journalists.
Their not real journalists their scumbags
Garbage, Kamahl owes everyone an apology for lying.
@@anonleftlying about what?
@@anonlefthe wasn’t lying.
@@michellelindsey8432yes. He was.
Alot can happen in 48 hours, 👍
Well done Kamahl, Much Respect Sir
The indigenous people of Australia already get about twice the government expenditure per capita over the rest of the Australian citizens.
The project should be made to retract their ‘FACT CHECKING’ error on live television, issue an apology to Kamakl, then re-present the facts to the public all on prime time television
Maybe fact check Credlin and read the full document
@@user-ov1kk8fe9k
Racist
Made? By whom? They didn't make an error - Kamahl did. Well, or he just lied and didn't realise or care. Peta knows she's lying, that's why she carefully edited the segment to remove the bit where Kamahl tried to argue indigenous people get $40bn to spend themselves.
@@anonleftYou're the one who's lying and nasty calling someone a liar because you can't handle someone having a different opinion than yours.
@@user-eq8iq2gh6k What's "opinion" got to do with it? The "$40bn" figure is a deliberate lie. You can't back it up. Peta can't back it up. Her claim that you can take the 2017 PC figure and multiply it by "inflation" and that's what the govt spends is ludicrous, and you'd have to be a dribbling halfwit to think that's how anything works. And the 2017 PC figure is itself nonsense, as used by the "no" case - it's not a figure of money given to indigenous orgs. It's an arbitrary "share" of ordinary spending, like defence, or Peter Dutton's salary. Pretending that a submarine is "us supporting aborigines" is utterly delusional and bad-faith.
OMG! Such ignorance/passive bullying shown to Kamahl by the Project panel! Reminds me why I never watch that program! Vote NO!
Narcs
That arrogant Project team owe Kamahl an apology.
I accidentally watched the show once. They owe all of Australia an apology for being on TV
The narcissists won't apologise
You can tell in 5 seconds that none of these Project panelists have ever had an interaction with an indigenous person but are happy to sit back and berate someone with a different opinion that's no less informed than theirs.
Now I know what a Dingbat is..... An apology is not needed Kamalh. ... you handled the Dingbats well...
The Project had the hide to say they are journalists and work with facts. Hilarious interview.
Far from journalists that lot.! More like lefty looney uni students on a budget program show
pathetic people ganging up on Kamahl
Foreign owned channel, rootless cosmopolitan hosts.
Most of their facts are very wrong, how dare they insult Kamaal like that. I'm sure they have really cemented his No vote now. They are all insulting!!!
The project was correct, it is Peta and Kamahl who are lying.
Omg! They wouldn’t let Kamahl speak! Verbal bullying! He was quite correct in the points he made.
Whitesplaining .
@@stewatparkpark2933🤡
@@stewatparkpark2933 Lettardsplaining
Kamal should ask for an apology from the Project and an admission their fact check was just lies.
You're right on the money Kamal thank you for coming out so those who see this will be more informed. We are asked to vote yes to something we do not know how it will work. I put it this way to people If I were a car salesman and said you just give me the money you want to spend and I will find a car for you. Doesn't matter if you like it or not you will be stuck permanently stuck with that car. Now would you really do that then why would you vote yes then with absolutely no information. This yes vote is more about taking the indigenous rights away as the land owner to then go to phase two to strip land ownership. Are you ready to give up your paid-for home or farm and land?
Just vote No . Pure and simple .
What would you expect, the Project panel host is a woke recycled ABC staffer.
Oh look the project's credibility sinks lower! I didn't think that was possible 🤔
Now... the big question: Will the Project have the courage to APOLOGIZE to Kamahl? And, admit to their viewers that they have got this wrong? By their actions, they have failed to do due diligence, and have made false and misleading statements to the public. Questions now need to be asked if they are "Fit and Proper" persons to be on television.
Your answer is no. They wont
I guess we could all call them up- that is the station, is it channel 9 and demand an apology?
They should apologise. As they said themselves during the interview “ this is a referendum, we have to get these things right”
They will not apologize. They may offer a backhanded excuse, which will demonstrate their complete intellectual dishonesty.
Why should they apologise? It's Kamahl and Peta who are lying, and it'll be a miracle if either of them apologise.
The Project an absolute disgrace. They all need to be sacked and fact checked for everything they speak
I met Kamahl many years ago at his house. Spent a few hours there as a guest of his daughter. Lovely man, made all of us feel welcome.
Vote no to "One country, two systems".
That isn't what the voice is, you f*cking moron.
Thank you Kamahl, stop splitting the country in half, Vote NO.
There is ALREADY a minister for waman and not for men.
You people are ALL fooled
Kamhal knows more than Chanel 10 reporter lol
Those people on the project were trying to intimidate him to change his mind and this was a disgraceful. Thanks God I stopped watching the stupid show.
With all their resources they couldn’t counter him? Am I living in some alternate reality devoid of facts? Oh I forgot….it’s a feelings based reality.🤮
@katrinakaesehagen7676 that’s what they pay him for, to be stupid. Good money if your stupid.
It's a low bar
The Project has been notoriously known for its low credibility from its poor sourcing
They didnt let Kamal have a Voice...
That interview was disgusting. I was appalled to the point of never wanting to see the Project again. They humiliated the poor man.
Just finished watching ACA tonight. Last offering was that you can call Channel 9 to ask questions about the voice...
I imagine this will be manned by nothing but 'Yes' campaigners. This whole thing is going from wrong to WRONG. 😡
The "woke" Current Affair will lose viewers after that.
Like to ring and fact check them
@@kevingrace7428 does the yes vote mean the end to white aboriginals...
Yeah, Nah@@NeelCowabunga
As with covid n climate change,channel 9 along with 7,10,abc and sbs are 'in on it'. They are activists for the left.
Kamahl stick to your guns ✔️. Tell it as it is Not smoke and mirrors from the Labor government
The project needs to issue a correction and an apology.
Well done for this broadcast. Plain English, integrity and facts.
not translated into any Aboriginal languages though
The policy has not been written....the 24 selected activists, will write the constitutional policy., after the vote.... madness 🇦🇺
No, parliament will write the policy.
The Project doing “fact checks”. That’s a comedy routine surely.
Their fact check was a quick google and pulling up a number that was not relevant
I've actually seen better fact checking before
@@mmmmmmmmmmm10 No, it was the facts. The $4.5bn is the total actual specific FN spending. Peta and Kamahl are lying.
@@anonleft It was one organisation, not total expenditure.
It is like saying it only costs me $50 to run my car a week because that is the cost of fuel - completely leaving out maintenance, insurance, registration etc. The project conveniently left the rest out
@@pauljh74no, it's the total for indigenous programs, which are run by the NIAA.
The only way you get to $40bn is by
- lying
- multiplying the PC report by inflation which is not actually how govt budget items work
- counting, as in the PC figure, ordinary spending for "all" Australians, like submarines and Peter Dutton's salary
- pretending that the extra cost of ordinary service delivery to the regions is only a problem when it's received by indigenous people.
The $40bn number is a lie.
Need set up a royal commission investigation to scrutinize how this 39.5 billion are spend on the indigenous.
How they can spend so much money.
Otherwise is not fair to all other Austrians.
Austrians have nothing to do with this. lol
"Otherwise is not fair to all other Australians" - CORRECT
@@Sydneywide1
Australians are just the tax slaves that pay for all the grifters!
The ones who pay all the tax get nothing spent on them and are suffering. It doesn't effect the rich, only the working class.
It shows failure of leadership in the Aboriginal community and its activist class which fosters resentment and dependence. Aboriginal people deserve better. A full scale audit is needed.
"Why are people so unkind". We miss you Kamahl.
The Project exemplifies why people are saying No. If you're not in line with what they think they try to berate you into backing down without having an actual informed discussion and being able to see where you're coming from and they try to 'win' the argument just by talking louder.
Basically, The Project is social media personified in TV format
There seems to be a common thread in Government spending in the past decade. More money … less and/or wasted outcomes.
Like the NDIS ( refer to 4 corners on the ABC last night), Education ( declining Mathematics and literacy ), Defence( submarine disaster ) and Aboriginal affairs.
The voice, if it gets in, on this past record will be added to this list.
We need accountability not hijacking or mismanagement, or WOKE redirection of taxpayers funds.
The last decade was mostly Liberal party. Maybe become a teacher or a politician
So much for the Project panel !!
They’re shockers !!
Vote NO
Agree.. they think they run this country
I thought as Australians within our democratic system, we have a right to our own opinion. It seems that these reporters, who are putting immense pressure on Kamal, to make him look like a dumb fool just can’t seem to stomach his point of view. Their anger, ridicule and sarcasm is plain for all to see. But there again we have this undemocratic PM who runs only one point of view from only one side of the coin.
Too right u r ✅
NAIDOC is funded to the Indigenous “Voice “ thru this project $40 billion
That’s what we all know as information or disinformation
Have you only just noticed? This failure of a so called democracy has been going on since covid. The sensorship has been enormous. Also, if you don't voice an opinion that is in line with the governments look out. This is backed up by mainstream media who tow the line of this coming New World Order. That's it, its no longer a conspiracy.
Albo is a loser, just like his welfare thieving morally loose mum.
Albo, like all politician pay no tax (after their dodgy accountants run their deductions), so its up to the common taxpayer to "pay the $40B bill" to welfare thieving Aboriginals on an annual basis.
He was being a dumb fool and spouting stupid lies.
The Project's treatment of Kamahl was disgraceful. They tried to make him out to be a liar, a fool and a bigot. When he tried to tell them his reasoning they talked over the top of him and you could see he was getting quite put off - and who wouldn't have been intimidated by such unprofessional conduct bordering on bullying. They need to issue an unreserved apology if they have any shred of decency. Wankers.
Albo may have told them too ..he would be chucking a tantrum with this lol
Wouldn’t expect anything else from the Project, it needs to be pulled from air. Total left wing propaganda.
I have met Kamahl several times, he is a fool and an arrogant one at that. Sky under Murdocks agenda are divisive, antagonistic and have a charter to endorse chaos . Use your head for once , there are only less than 1 million indigenous people left in Australia , if the government gave each and every one of them $1million that equates to $1Billion ,, so are all and every Aboriginal persons multi millionaires ???? go do some math and original thinking
@Yadnarie12absolute crap
The project is so biased towards leftist BS it’s a shame any Australian watches them
I was reading documentation from the Electoral Commission explaining what voting a YES or NO would mean. Even it stated that by voting YES is would be a legally risky decision and that the "Pay the Rent" policy will be imposed onto all non indigenous Australians. This means, that we all pay compensation to the Indigenous for living in "their country". I can see why the Govt wants to push for a yes vote because that will mean they will have their own lapdogs represent the Indigenous people and access that bucket of money. The govt is very sneaky and not to be trusted. Their hidden agendas are being gift wrapped in an Aboriginal sympathy campaign to fool people into voting yes. I remember when we all fell for the lies about GST. The govt cannot be trusted when it comes to spending money that is coming out of our pockets - they're forever trying to find new ways to make you pay for everyday things on top of the taxes you already pay from your employment, leaving you with less than half of your pay in REAL spending capability. Our dollar goes nowhere these days at the supermarket, electricity and gas bills, water bills, rates, GST etc. So darned if we are going to be hot with an Indigenous Land Rates Rent... or should I say, TAX!! Please vote a definitive NO!!!!! NO. NO. NO. NO. NO!!!
Where in the 120 plus words in the proposed amendment does it suggest we would pay rent? Native title has been with us since the 1990s ... I'm not paying rent on my home nor did I have to hand back ownership.
Good on you, Kamahl.
This is why I haven’t watched 7,9,10,ABC and SBS for over 10 years. They are the most appalling talking heads.
Yes. That small dose was enough to immunize me against them permanently.
You’re right on it,television to me is dead,all they produce now is rubbish,reading a good book beats them hands down.
me too.@@credenza1
DON'T BE LAZY. Make sure you vote and don't think its a SHOE IN
Can I vote NO to The Project as well as to The Voice?
You me and every other person with a working brain
They twist the words to confuse the general public because they know it works. My deepest apologies to Kamahl for how they treated him. He's obviously a learned gentleman & understands the importance of being valued by our characters not by our colours!
Channel 10 and ABC need to be accountable for their actions and start reporting truthfully
Last time I watched 'The Project' was when they grilled Margaret Court over her views and not supporting same sex marriage. They didn't really want to hear her reasons, they just wanted to attack her. That show raises my blood pressure and makes me want to throw stuff at the television.
2:57 Virtue signalling bully.
The Project is just leftist propaganda, it’s no different to Q&A on ABC. A leftist dogpile on non conforming leftist and people on the right.
I can't bear to watch it.
I don’t waste my time to watch such a programme
The Project will huff and puff until it blows itself up. Could just respect Kamahl and his change of view.
I was so disappointed with The Project last night they were so rude and disrespectful to him.
The host (who is a male) on The Project that questioned Kamahl was the same one who effectively questioned Germaine Greer on her credentials as a feminist. I can clearly still remember the look of surprise on her face, and the pause of at least a couple of seconds that went along with it.
NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, from me.
The project 'hosts' seem to think our Australian parliament isn't there to represent every Australian, regardless of race.
It's actually mind boggling how they can't see how racist it is to advocate for a race-based 'voice' being enshrined in the constitution...
The project interviewer should now make a public apology for being ignorant and not having done his homework on the substance of the issues involved. Vote NO because the yes campaign have not only run out of plausible arguments but they are also not informed of the facts.
Bring the legend Kamahl onto Sky to ask the Project for a public apology
My thoughts exactly 🥰 he deserves a full apology nothing less
Top idea !
This show the Project should b taken off the Air. They tried to over ride him and bully him. He was so true in what he said it is a racist between black and white it’s dividing us the project I watched it was disgusting trying to override and bullying him. Good on u Kamal project should be taken off it. It is 40 billion a year it is so true !!!! They are spending that amount a year. How are they treat a man like this. The way that Hamish spoke down to Kamal was disgusting and how they all tried to override him. I really turned off the show. I only watch it occasionally. I’ll never be watching it again.!!!!!
If 40 BILLION dollars doesnt work, how is a round-table of activists going to work
See, even Kamahl got it right at the end. The PM should have waited.
See, even Kamahl is confused but finally He got it right because He is smart.
Kamahl played him and owned him and made a mug out of AnAL
👏🏻
WOW - The Aboriginal people are really being looked after in terms of government assistance. Twice as much as non-Aboriginal people.
Probably like all those Foreign Aid companies begging for money - 90% is used in Administration and 10% may get to those in need.
It has been that way ever since I remember. a good mate of mine got paid from childhood for being partial aboriginal. and he's barely a quarter-caste. It's a race tax and it's been around at least since the 80s.
40 billion dollars which doesn’t seem to be making much difference!
40bn for 2% of the population, that works out to around $77,000 for every indigenous person.
"Twice as much as non-Aboriginal people." which is breaking the Law of Discrimination.
Ive seen that expenditure report in full and exactly what goes where. It is 40 billion. The truth is but grassroot everyday Aboriginals dont get the money so where is it actually spent and by who. ?
Wow, those Project hosts should hang their heads in shame. Where is the accountability for them?
Peta, you do such good work of pulling the covers off of the liars and obfuscators !
Peta Credlin is a hard hitter.
Love her. Go girl.
Whining murdoch turd crUdlin, still searching for relevance, thanks you for sucking up 👅 and being her 69th braindead supporter.
Not only vote NO but there must be NO more pointless spending of billions of our tax dollars, full stop.
Consultants, unfortunately.
I don't mind $$$ being spent on aboriginal people but this changing of the constitution is unnecessary. 😮😮😮 they already have an advisory board attached to the PM OFFICER.
@@susanparsons9365
So why do we elect these monkeys to run the country? Why not just pay the consultants and get rid of the middle man?
@@lucylovic
Exactly what i've been telling people, if they have an advisory board and federal politicians in power then that is already more than the rest of us have. There is something sinister about all this especially coming from the labor party.
40 billion in job keeper to tax dodging millionaires and billionaires who wernt entitled to it as their companies were profitable during covid is that acceptable depends who's getting the money right.
No flies on Kamahl. A legend - no two ways about it, if you know what I mean. No pretentions. No exaggerations. No nonsense. So noble too. Nobody better to leave a person in no doubt as to how to make sense in a no-win situation. So good to know. Thanks Kamahl.
Kamahl is completely ignorant, he is so ignorant he happily played an Aboriginal man in a 1967 movie called Journey out of Darkness
@@marilynshepherd6480 How does that make him ignorant? Meanwhile, the Voice will be an unrepresentative unelected body that is intended to preserve the current corrupt Aboriginal Welfare system. Billions of dollars of government money gets wasted each year on woke activists, bureaucrats and "consultants", but very little of it gets out to the indigenous communities in remote areas that really need it. This is why Jacinta Price says vote No to the Voice, and demand an audit of the system.
Implementation of the Uluru Statement from the Heart
$50.2 million for the Australian Electoral Commission to prepare for the referendum to enshrine a Voice to Parliament in the Constitution.
$5.8 million to commence work on establishing an independent Makarrata Commission to oversee processes for agreement-making and truth-telling, as part of the Government’s $27.7 million election commitment.
Indigenous health & education
$54.3 million to train 500 First Nations health workers and practitioners.
$164.3 million for vital health infrastructure projects that will provide modern, high-quality health clinics in areas of large and growing First Nations populations, and to build capacity in targeting chronic disease treatment and rehabilitation.
$22.5 million to build a dedicated Birthing on Country Centre of Excellence at the Waminda health service in Nowra, New South Wales.
$14.2 million to double the current funding to the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) to combat Rheumatic Heart Disease in high-risk communities over the next three years.
$45 million for 30 four-chair dialysis units to provide better renal services across Australia.
$800,000 to improve the care of patients with chronic diseases to be delivered by the Redfern Aboriginal Medical Service and the Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation Aboriginal Medical Service.
Wilcannia, White Cliffs and Menindee in New South Wales will benefit from $1.9 million to purchase dialysis treatment buses to deliver care closer to home.
$14.1 million to place First Nations educators in 60 primary schools to teach First Nations languages and provide greater cultural understanding.
$33.7 million to make early childhood education and care more accessible for Indigenous families, with access to 36 subsidised hours per fortnight.
$190.0 million over four years to help First Nations controlled and Community Sector Organisations (CSO) to maintain quality services in light of rising costs.
Housing in remote communities
$25 million for housing and essential services on Northern Territory homelands as an immediate boost, with a further $75 million allocated for 2023-24.
Justice investment
$81.5 million to invest in up to 30 community-led justice reinvestment initiatives across Australia and establish an independent national justice reinvestment unit as recommended by the Australian Law Reform Commission, the largest funding package in justice reinvestment ever committed by the Commonwealth.
$13.5 million in additional funding to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (ATSILS) to increase its capacity to provide culturally appropriate legal assistance in coronial inquiries.
$1 million to build greater capacity in the peak body, the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (NATSILS) to provide leadership across the Indigenous legal sector.
$3 million to support the National Family Violence Prevention Legal Services Forum, and the FVPLS providers who deliver legal assistance and non-legal support to victim-survivors of family and domestic violence and sexual assault.
In addition to the above:
$14 million will be delivered over four years as part of the Government’s Central Australia Plan to deliver immediate and medium-term crime prevention and community safety programs in Central Australia.
the highly successful Indigenous Protected Areas program will be extended beyond 2023, and 10 new Indigenous Protected Areas created by 2028.
$83.8 million will be invested to develop and deploy microgrid technology across First Nations communities to increase access to cheaper, cleaner and more reliable energy.
$2 million will establish an Ambassador for First Nations Peoples to take Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives and experiences to the world.
funding will be provided for a trial program as a first step to replacing the Community Development Program.
I met Kamahl back in the 70s... he's such a beautiful person and also honest! We need more people like him, speaking the truth!!
God forbid someone says NO!
Why is the Project so unkind? Good on yah Kamahl!
Tearing kamal apart for changing from yes to no is dispicable
Thank you for setting the record straight. 40 billion is a lot of money! We need an inquiry as to where all this is being spent. Plus an inquiry into the land councils.
The govt probably knows the results of an inquiry which is why there most likely not be one.
AGREED: Budget October 2022-23: National Indigenous Australians Agency
Implementation of the Uluru Statement from the Heart
$50.2 million for the Australian Electoral Commission to prepare for the referendum to enshrine a Voice to Parliament in the Constitution.
$5.8 million to commence work on establishing an independent Makarrata Commission to oversee processes for agreement-making and truth-telling, as part of the Government’s $27.7 million election commitment.
Indigenous health & education
$54.3 million to train 500 First Nations health workers and practitioners.
$164.3 million for vital health infrastructure projects that will provide modern, high-quality health clinics in areas of large and growing First Nations populations, and to build capacity in targeting chronic disease treatment and rehabilitation.
$22.5 million to build a dedicated Birthing on Country Centre of Excellence at the Waminda health service in Nowra, New South Wales.
$14.2 million to double the current funding to the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) to combat Rheumatic Heart Disease in high-risk communities over the next three years.
$45 million for 30 four-chair dialysis units to provide better renal services across Australia.
$800,000 to improve the care of patients with chronic diseases to be delivered by the Redfern Aboriginal Medical Service and the Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation Aboriginal Medical Service.
Wilcannia, White Cliffs and Menindee in New South Wales will benefit from $1.9 million to purchase dialysis treatment buses to deliver care closer to home.
$14.1 million to place First Nations educators in 60 primary schools to teach First Nations languages and provide greater cultural understanding.
$33.7 million to make early childhood education and care more accessible for Indigenous families, with access to 36 subsidised hours per fortnight.
$190.0 million over four years to help First Nations controlled and Community Sector Organisations (CSO) to maintain quality services in light of rising costs.
Housing in remote communities
$25 million for housing and essential services on Northern Territory homelands as an immediate boost, with a further $75 million allocated for 2023-24.
Justice investment
$81.5 million to invest in up to 30 community-led justice reinvestment initiatives across Australia and establish an independent national justice reinvestment unit as recommended by the Australian Law Reform Commission, the largest funding package in justice reinvestment ever committed by the Commonwealth.
$13.5 million in additional funding to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (ATSILS) to increase its capacity to provide culturally appropriate legal assistance in coronial inquiries.
$1 million to build greater capacity in the peak body, the National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Services (NATSILS) to provide leadership across the Indigenous legal sector.
$3 million to support the National Family Violence Prevention Legal Services Forum, and the FVPLS providers who deliver legal assistance and non-legal support to victim-survivors of family and domestic violence and sexual assault.
In addition to the above:
$14 million will be delivered over four years as part of the Government’s Central Australia Plan to deliver immediate and medium-term crime prevention and community safety programs in Central Australia.
the highly successful Indigenous Protected Areas program will be extended beyond 2023, and 10 new Indigenous Protected Areas created by 2028.
$83.8 million will be invested to develop and deploy microgrid technology across First Nations communities to increase access to cheaper, cleaner and more reliable energy.
$2 million will establish an Ambassador for First Nations Peoples to take Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander perspectives and experiences to the world.
funding will be provided for a trial program as a first step to replacing the Community Development Program. Australian Government site: check it out - OVER REPRESENTED AND TIME THE GRAVY TRAIN GOT CUT!
She isn't "setting the record straight", she's lying, and you're dumb enough to fall for it.
there are less than 1million Indigenous people in Australia , so $40 Billion equates to $40 Million dollars for each and every Aboriginal , Have you seen many multi Millionaire indigenous people ?, SKY is not a news service it is a bunch of right wing influencers who spew whatever Murdocks agenda dictates , it's prime function in Australia as in Canada and USA is to sow seeds of division through propaganda to foster chaos.fear and control how a population can be influenced at the expense of common sense. you muppets .
It won’t just be 40 billion if the Yes referendum wins. It will be 80 billion. Guaranteed.
This was a disgrace ! Kamahl was treated like garbage , He simply reflected on what so many of us have wondered, where does the bilions of taxpayer funds paid into Indigenous Affairs actually end up ?It would appear by the conditions many of them live in very little of these funds are reaching them .He voiced what so many of us have wondered and your panel attacked him like a pack of hyenas,Same tactics as Albabese of not wanting to hear or consider that taxpayer's might wonder just why there is never any improvement in any facit of their lives.Are you styling your programming on the ABC, nothing to see here ,no bias just professional journalists acting like Labor hacks ?
So The Project questioned Kamahl over his source for the figure he quoted.
They then dismissed it with their 'fact checking', yet they clearly they didn't practice any quality journalism in fact checking their 'fact check'
Well done to Sky News for having the balls not to automatically jump on the 'yes' side of campaign like the rest of the media.
And a big thumbs down to The Project for bullying Kamahl over his on view on this issue.
They should publicly retract their 'fact check' and apologise to Kamahl for treating him like a fool.
So will the PM still call him courageous?
If you think Aukus submarines are expensive.......
True the indigenous Australians getting 400 billion a decade 40 billion a year. Say NO to the Voice.
Aukus submarines are worth it, so much better than Malcolm Turnbull's French submarines that was spent just purely for pork barrelling
@@jaidentslgl2753 no argument from myself.
CCP trying to establish a base in the South Pacific, they will soon be a necessity to maintain our sovereignty.
The project should apologise publicly with the same length of time as they queried him all least.
Thanks so much Peta for the truth .
So fantastic to hear his honesty . To separate humans into categories is insane ! It’s terrible and racist . It’s to assume that indigenous peoples need (!) white people help and can’t do without . It’s assuming they are disabled of sorts . It’s racist , inappropriate and disrespectful. In addition we have plenty of Aboriginal advisory committees who will continue to advocate and assist .
You're the voice, try and understand it, Make a noise and make it clear VOTE NOoooooo, vote NOoooooo
What a total legend Kamahl is. Could listen to him all day.
I love his voice, he should be on tv/radio telling stories 😊 I’d tune in from Uk! I hope the msm apologises to him for trying to make a fool out of him
The true facts and figures should be shown to the Project team and then they should be made to issue an apology.
The "Yes" campaign cannot debate rationally. As a flying doctor I witnessed massive amounts of money spent on health care and housing for Aboriginals in central Australia. They were more than looked after by the Australian Taxpayer in money spent and services. They were looked after with dignity and compassion by all health care workers, and race never entered the conversation. A "Yes" vote is for a small politically motivated group who wish to control all Australians, including indigenous Australians. It will not improve Aboriginal welfare but will divide our country on racial grounds.
"We are One, we are all Australian".
The project: “We are making up people’s minds”
The project should be axed, this is not the first time that they have reported dirty.....rotten lot !!
Vote N0 !!!