How Politics Affects Indian Cinema
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- In this video, I'm not talking about outright propaganda films like The Kashmir Files and The Kerala Story. I'm sticking to the portrayals of men and masculinity in commercially successful mass-appeal films. Still think politics and cinema don't go together? Watch this video and decide.
FACEBOOK: / cinemawali-92278671791...
INSTAGRAM: / thecinemawali
TWITTER: / paromabose
I'm sorry to everyone I scandalized by flashing Dwayne Johnson's measurements 10 seconds too early. 🙈
Edit: This video was recorded before the crackdown on Arundhati Roy and the houses of innocent Muslims. Just to clarify, these are horrific signs that the government is still trying to show 'strength', even after their lack of response to the J&K attacks, the NEET scam and the railway tragedy. The fight for democracy isn't over. Keep speaking up. Jai Hind.
Are ye to leftist nikli😅
I support BJP but that doesn't mean I hate you because you see rahul gandhi as pm material rather I love your content and I don't give a fuck about your political views nor you should for my political views and belief. We r different human beings we can agree to disagree but since I love your Cinephiles aspect of your personality that doesn't mean I love your other aspects too like political views or food choices etc i'm here because I think our ideas, thought and perspective about movies and cinema as art matches somewhere...
@@BILASPANDE are you for real you support bjp and also her.
@@pipipupu5104There are some weirdos out there. I know women who call themselves radical feminists and vote BJP. It's a mess.
@@thomascromwell6840 this women seems way bigger weirdo to me i followed her channel for genuine reviews never thought she is a some pathetic libra. Du...
Staying out of politics is a Privilege.
Kudos to you for doing a video that could potentially lose audience.
The topic is too good
Also narratives from news, movies, social media all simply wrong, fake, false or to spread hatreds. And everything is politics, even some friends say don't talk politics (if we speak up for the justice), but they post or text the "festivals", which are the real politics by hindutwa.
So if some one don't care politics means he/she are privileged so not worry about the "others"
Losing andhbhakt viewers isn't much of a loss actually.
is it really? In a world where 'everything is political' I think its rather impossible. To be apolitical is... of course, possible and dare I say ideal for the world that we're living in.
@@abdulrenishr From what I've observed in Indian politics, it’s clear that Congress has become the new Islamic Party of India, while the BJP has turned into the new Congress party of India. The concept of Hindutva is non-existent.
Ignore the “why politics??” comments!! Everything is politics!!
Kudos to you @cinemawali
So is relegion
@@techsa2675No, everything is not religious but religion is political.
looved it!! Would love to see more videos on influence of Politics on Movies and vice versa
I have never seen such mature, clear and all-inclusive political commentary recently. That too in the POV of a movie critique!! Your movie reviews also have immense depth and passion. Hope you continue doing what you’re doing. 😊
As an Adivasi thank you for pointing out the casteism of RRR. Only few people raised their voice against this. For example Komuram Bheem knew 5 Languages - Gondi, Telugu, Hindi, English and Urdu but by the end of the film Brahmin character Alluri Sitarama Raju taught him "How to write" it was so baffling for me.
Also what I didn't like the most about Janwar was the cow urine drinking scene and "Make in India" dialogue scene - It confirmed that this director is regressive Sanghi.
Which film is this about? "Make in India" dialogue scene ->>>>?
@@opinionated8095 Animal which I referred to as Janwar.
@@cringerage make in India makes him sanghi lmao are you a librandu.
@@cringerage how is make in India regressive?..
@@cringerage how is make in India regressive.
I don't think pathan argument of having adversery as ally holds as I belive success of pathan is more signifier of narrative around Srk at that time. I mean if that were the case tiger 3 shd have been a blockbuster.
Finally regarding jawan , While I agree that he is a rebel with cause, I think you in your analysis are undermining the cause of your political adversaries, it is just that their causes are different from what you consider important i.e, for some their faith in a diety, or dealing with a terror state with heavy hands , or getting a water tap or housing (Antodaya) may be the cause to which they ascribe to, srk just amplifies the message that are too generic, you giving it your value judgement as if they ascribe to left wing or Congress in India, is a shallow understanding of Indian politics. For ex when you say elite is trapped in this bubble , Remember that BJP won most of its seats in Northern India, and while it is true rural vote is the reason bjp lost, the reason might not be that they were less or more polarized rather multiple factors like fake news of taking away reservation , arrogance of bjp leadership, revival of Congress etc were the reasons. While BJP treatment of women and its heavy handed politics cs did play a role in its loss, ascribing credit to it solely would be a reach.
And it is ignorant of various forces holding it together and tiring it apart.
Finally, while I understand what BJP govt is doing with Arundhati roy amount to legal harrasment , it is a legit case(not conviction), a country have rules a regulation you can't escape the trial if you did something wrong in the past or in the folloy of youth abd activism as that is w very dangerous argument( And frankly it helps BJP in shifting focus on bigger issues like Train accident and NEET)
On bulldozing houses, that is just sad reflection of the state of Indian politics and shitty legal system, the heavy cocktail of two is what you see in rhese cases. I am angry and yet apethetic because I know the only solution to these is litigation and taking issues via streets to the people of India( like in farmer protest) because otherwise politicians have no incentices to change status quo.
P.S. I am not saying BJP is right or wrong, rather I am saying your presentation of Indian politics from your lens is distorted because of your inherent biased. What is needed is a case for more civic awarness and courtrooms to not remain feifdom of urban middle class and elites
Debut video of Cinemawali for me. Just subscribed. This is what makes a great TH-cam commentator -- the ability to bring the most intricately complex ideas to the simplest words and sentences. Professors like me have a lot to learn from you🎉
There are Only two genders: Man and Political. Only two religions: Majority and Political. Only two Casts: Upper and Political. Only two ways of being: Status Quo and Political.
"regression disguised as growth" ....hats off ma'am
you talk about manual Moitra as if she did not deserve to be pushed aside.I thought you were a bengaki but it seems you too are outsider. These people from tmcs have don't worse things to us and they deserve to be in jail.
Do not agree with you in this polotical aspect, you are just trying to potray ur side of political view and as u said modi has been among people from years and then reached to this position not the privileged to be bone and just become a member of parliament, if rahul gandhi is so grounded then should have first started work on city level.u just trying to influence people with ur political views
haan toh bhai uska channel hai khudka hi perspective dikhaegi na.
Long Live Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic of India 🇮🇳
India isnt a socialist country,its a mixed (socialist and capitalist) india is not a secular country ,its a dharmic nation which birthed indigenous cultures like hinduism,buddhism,jainism and sikkhism.
So biased.......video............. Pro congress and pappu...and anti Modi and bjp.
A political propagandist masquerading as a cinema analyst. Hilariously biased but seems to have reached its audience.
Wow... Portraying bjp as hypermasculine and mysogenistic is literally bizarre... You've shown Modi's speech about mamta, let's reverse it and kindly show mamta's speech about modi also... And btw I'm from wb, you can search mamta's speeches on several victims of **** , where she claims that victim was pregnant or victim had relationship with perpetrators... I haven't seen more anti women party than tmc... Just some days back their leader had beaten an women and recorded it, now he's saying it's all fine in Muslim rastra... Sorry to say but this is not objective analysis, this is clearly political propaganda
The problem with Kannada cinema is that there is no film going culture in Karnataka except in the parts bordering the Telugu and Tamil speaking states. These areas tend to like the hero-worshiping kinds of films which is why massy Kannada films resemble Telugu and Tamil potboilers.
That said, there has always been a set of evolved film-makers and authors (whose stories were turned into films). There were Girish Karnad and Girish Kasaravalli in the past. I have also heard good things about Puttanna Kanagal and Shankar Nag but am yet to explore them (beyond Malgudi Days). In the current set of filmmakers good things are happening in films made by those raised in and appealing to audiences from Bangalore and the coastal belt. The coastel belt audience is also a little unevolved (stuck in the comedy genre phase), but the film-makers are not.
Raj B Shetty and Hemant Rao are my favourites followed by Rakshit Shetty. Kiranraj and others lesser known directors are also trying to narrate different kinds of films. There is an art-house movement alive even now but does not attract as many audiences and remain restricted to festival circuits.
In short, I would not equate Kannada cinema to Telugu cinema.
Coming to Kantara, it has some uncomfortable moments, but it is not trying to justify the bad behaviour. The protagonist gets told off by his mother countless times for his behaviour including the way he treats his girlfriend. It is meant to be a depiction of waywardness.
For every Kantara, there is a Swathi Mutthina Male Haniye. Unfortunately, Hindi-inclined Cinephiles do not discover the films that do not cross borders in a big way. So, you end up watching only the KGFs. I appreciate GangsOfCinepur for being more adventurous in this respect. She has covered a wide range of films and discovered many of the under-appreciated gems.
Missing content on serial soap opera and parallel acceptance of Hindutva within serial and through them this essay does some justice. 😊
What do you mean
"parallel acceptance hindutva"?
@@antarakmit4114 andhbhakti
Even in old times when there was less media , I think in politics people were always drawn towards men who speak in a very assertive agressive,self-righteous ways. I think people equate speaking with strong words makes the speaker strong . Being able to take a side , and unapologetically supporting it through and through is something people look up to . Maybe its because everyone is flawed and they want to feel supported and superior even if they do wrong . They naturally gravitate towards leaders who bash the opposition harshly . Now in this age women are able to contemplate and 'properly' get into deciding their votes,they choose people like RG who doesn't seem to be so male aggressive in their approach towards getting votebanks .
Yes . Everything is politics. Being apolitical is also political. Such a nice video , its like discussing with some on tea time 🔥 .
Everything being political is a Carl Schmittian concept, suggesting that within the modern nation-state, even the most personal choices-like whether we consume beef or pork-are subject to politicization for the big boss to decide. This viewpoint reflects a deeply colonial mindset that has been effectively leveraged by the far right of our nation. Over the last decade, our nation has witnessed a decline in empathy, ethics, and gracefulness-inherently human qualities, and perhaps even transcendent, helping us glimpse the divine. We should move beyond the notion of everything being political and embrace art and cinema for the sake of gracefulness and love for the other....great video dear.....
Why politics
Because it matters in everything
Don't put all urban voters in the umbrella of indifference and sitting in drawing rooms painting naive political pictures. Also if you're influenced enough by Bollywood movies to get an awakening, you need to have better taste. This is just dumb blabbering.
Everything is political ......
Until you don't agree with the opinion
@@aakashsen7344 Even the disagreement is political.
@@aakashsen7344 no. You have a right to disagree. The thing is if your right to disagreement is nomenclatured as some form of generalisation whereby you are declared to be an anti national for holding an opinion, that is where the objection starts. The rest, is apparent.
no.people make everything political
@@savins2826 Yes? But it still doesn't change that it's political. All art is political, everything is political. You just lack perspective to how far one politics has merged itself with our daily lives and how broad the definition of politics can be.
Classic ref to the difference between a movie about misogny and misogynist movie would
Appan ( Father, Mal )- Sony Liv & The Animal (Hindi).
Why Rahul Gandhi is so attractive?..... because he born with golden spoon in Gandhi dynasty......😂😂😂😂
Yes, just like Jay Shah. So hot.
@@Cinemawaliyahh nd Jay Shah isn't in Politics uk
BJP gained vote share with rural poor, rural women and urban youth. Their national share hardly took a dent. The gains made in Orissa look irreversible for the near future.
The overall electoral results might be some sort of respite. But as a student of politics, I don’t feel or see any sense of long term joy. In fact, this overtly joyous celebration by left wing social media, especially the adulation for Rahul Gandhi - who is not a street fighter, despite what you make of his BJY - makes me fear that this is going to be short lived.
R Gandhi brought more feminine qualities forward and so a more balanced manifestation of a strong being. India needs to see more of this. Enough with spy agent violent movies. They don’t have to be underdogs necessarily. The world thinks of India is jingoistic and muscular and it’s a turn off. Never liked RRR.
Read Covenant of Water to feel male and female sentiments on a deep level.
Please post such commentaries. Although I would disagree with a few things, I loved the overall message of this thoughtful video.
Out of syllabus❤good keep it up😂kam se kam aap consistent to rahogi😅
Rrr's portrayal of masculinity is hyper but is nothing toxic..the actual points you could have rasied abt that film could be like how bheem's character is portrayed as an illiterate
If you don't take interest in politics, then politics will take interest in you.
Rahul Gandhi is the ranbir kapoor of politics. Nepo babies but grounded
Muslim social attitudes on modern issues have caused controversy everywhere. Islam to be incompatible with secular society, and that, unlike other religions, Islam positively commands its adherents to impose its religious law on all peoples, believers and unbelievers alike, whenever possible and by any means necessary. Islam allows to propagate abuses, such as the mistreatment of women and homosexuals, and slavery. They also state that multiculturalism allows a degree of religious freedom that exceeds what is needed for personal religious freedom and is conducive to the creation of organizations aimed at undermining secular values. According to poll, high people had an unfavourable view of Islam, higher than for any other religion. Islamic rule in India was a form of colonialism, characterized by the imposition of a foreign islamic culture, religion, and political system on the Indian subcontinent. Muslims were foreign invaders who came to India and imposed their Islamic faith and culture on the indigenous population. They point to examples of the destruction of Hindu temples, the imposition of Jizya tax on non-Muslims, and the forced conversions to Islam as evidence of this colonialist mindset.
Please watch 'Hey Ram ' movie Tamil. I think you'll like it 😊
Yes ,propaganda movie😅😅
had a tough day today and watching this video felt so good. Vital points were made. Thank you
You are right Modi did this time went too below the belt in his speeches and RG has always been a likeable guy the problem with him is he doesnt have any experience of administration, he has been an MP of Amethi for 15 years what has done for us, Rajivji tried to bring factories to Amethi even though much didn't happen of it but atleast there was an effort i dont understand RGs economic beliefs but its certainly not liberal he is too much to the socialist side and his belief of not interfering where there is a certain need of jobs and production to ramp he just not talking about it.Even in the latest manifesto jobs generation is mentioned but practically how is missing without burdening government institutions.He is still not a character i would want for a PMs post eventhough i will support INC it has to remove this guy he just cant control an institution because many prominent people came from his family, he has to leave.
Half way into the video i realized that her views aligns with mine more than any of my friends and te guys i hangout with.
Brilliant, just brilliant. Sharing this video everywhere. It deserves to be shared
well made video you have put down your points really well on a very polarising and a confusing topic.
Love the last few lines - 'Great time to be an Indian' The signs are truly horrific about how they're trying to show strength. As long as people keep speaking up...But yes, an important one.
2:13 I think u took twitter too seriously.
Thank god, not everyone is not on twitter
But didn't RRR also show the emotional sides of the protagonists.
That they are too vulnerable and face internal conflict.
The problem is historical revisionism. They changed what the person stood for in order to support their regressive agenda.
OMG. I love you for what you said about RaGa. I am glad people are now accepting him.
He is a shitty leader like modi
Amazing Video!!!!!! Can I call you the Lindsay Ellis of India? Lol. But have you ever considered making a video about how Male Power Fantasies work, because that would explain a lot about why these movies are being made. (Also, RaGa is a DILF, lmao). I was thinking of starting my own channel to talk about these things, still do, so..................any suggestions?
Can u pls explain How Raga is what u write? and is it bad or good?
@@SACHIN-jf3ct DILF-a sexually attractive older man, typically one who has children. I was commenting on how he is a good-looking dude. I don't know if it's good or bad.
Personal is Political... so is Cinema !
Just loved it, Looking forward to more such videos!❤
13:13 bruh people CAN find him NOT ATTRACTIVE 😭 bcuz he isn't. if you find him attractive it's fine?? why are you insulting us who don't by saying we find modi better
My parents don't like Modi but I'm also pretty sure they aren't attracted to Rahul. To put it simply, I'm not talking about you so don't take it so personally.
I agree with you that RRR was hyper-masculine but I think it was in a good way, it never put down women and even showed a healthy bromance between two men, on the other hand I find Pathan extremely patronising in every sense.
As I was writing this I googled to see if there was somebody name Rathore in Pathan or was I confused with recently released movie "Kill", and unsurprisingly it did have "Vikram Rathore". Bollywood Movie have a way of glorifying these upper caste names like "Singh", "Rathore", "Pathan" and "Pandey", at least RRR tried to represent a tribal figure.
i mistook jawan for pathan. lol
Thank you for making such content, always showing a new narrative. ❤
I disagree
BJP has never been in power in Telugu states
So RRR has nothing to do with Modi
Seems like you went to Galgotiya University.
@@SameerPatra-ld1iu ja na re chaddi
@@dv9239 yede sakha chap sanghi ki chaddi utar gayi
She didn't Said Anything Similar to That 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
@@JuJuDen47 RRR is an outright casteist movie. Stop worshiping your masters, you slaves.
I was here to see the affects of politics on cinema not a discussion on politics, Its great to express yourself and also I respect and love your content very much, but as a viewer I am here to see and understand more about cinema rather than politics, cause as a youth and film-maker I am aware of my country and their politics, and we also got different channels and people who shows the country in a transparent way. My only complain would be that i am here as a cinephile not a political nerd, In my opinion this video is 30% cinema and 70% your political view. But still it's your right to express yourself and I respect that.
Did you listen to her? Have you understood anything? Well, I think no. If you are offended by any political party mentioned, then sorry, please question your existence. If not better cease existence lol.
@@Daniehltaku yup I watched her whole video, watched her previous videos and will watch her later videos too , I listened and then after it I commented, I know what I am saying.
@@PICTIONFILMS.03 Doesn't matter, if you have a opinion that even slightly different, that means you should unalive yourself.
@@PICTIONFILMS.03well, then, better you work upon your comprehension skills
@@Daniehltaku Damn🤣
Wow
Why are you so beautiful?? 🥺❤️🔥💖😩 I really enjoy your videos .. i want to focus, but cant stop thinking about wow she is very pretty 😢. Im a straight girl btw
Weird
good work
excellent topic!
great!
One day i wanna do a podcast with you
It's basically ANIMAL💥 vs JAWAN 🫡
.... girl, that "oo didi" was a reply to Mamata for talking about him in an even worse way.
Sweat is not a visual problem, it's problem is of odor, and fortunately it can't be experienced virtually.
I'm glad you believe that. You should definitely not watch my video about Dark. 😛
@@CinemawaliI know a film reviewer named Aritra from Kolkata who often reviews films being sweaty, but he doesn't mention of that. May be it's a problem of his masculinity 😛
If not for specific Telugu film, but can you do like a round about of the films like . Im a Telugu girl and would love to see your thoughts on Telugu films.
Rahul Gandhi the Prime Minister 🤡
Rahul Gandhi the influencer🗿
Long Live Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic of India 🇮🇳
Once again a lovely vid
Madam I like your videos because your point of view is different and it am like to see in that content how you see any thing is very different and I want you to share that talent
thanku for talking about rahul gandhi and his impact.
U r beauty with brain
Beauty 😂😂
🤔🤔🤔🤔 WHAT ⁉️⁉️🤔🤔🤔🤔
Are You saying she is Ugly in a Diplomatic way 😂😂😂😂😂
How?@@JuJuDen47
Your best video yet !
Lage raho cinemawali!! Very informed commentary on complex issues...loved it.
Quite impressed .
Great to hear abt RaGa ❣️ Indeed he has many flaws but my man Got something ,He is notna Give up guy ,he fought as many does in politics but his opponents had huge money & muscle power but my man proved that he has his own character we can criticize him make jokes but its hard to face such things he faced ❣️
rahul is hot.....u can sweat!!
Yku are the best person to debate with SAIDEEPAK .your clarity of mind is as much as his
though both stand for opposite ideologies.
J Sai Deepak will eat her for breakfast😅😅
Reminds me of " monkey man " (2024)
"Animal" doesn't deserve all the flak it gets for being "toxic". The protagonist in the movie is the arguably the most pathetic character in recent Bollywood history. And it couldn't not have been by design!
I 100% agree with every single point you made. Very good content.
Before this i watched your implacable analysis on " sir movie" so I wanted to check out other content also and here after watching your stand on political scenario I'm feeling proud that I have subscribed to a revolutionary channel❤
After Bharat jodo Yatra Rahul Gandhi become a new strong mass leader👍
If an artist is not politically committed then, is his art relevant??
- party 1980.
Kudos to you for sharing this interesting commentary. There will be people in comments who will stoop to the lowest levels to defend their right wing destructive ideology but don't pay heed to them. Keep up the good work!
Please do create a video on movie Godavari a marathi film. I would love and a treat to hear from you.. your thoughts and its nuances..
I love you❤
You are simply a upperclass bengali libarandu commi
Namashkaram mam
You are just just fabulous .❤❤❤
Such a good content.
Not only the information but the way you delivered it .
The video was weaved so intricatically that it was smooth like silk. 🌊🌊
Kab khatm ho gaya Pata nahi chala.
🍒 Cheery on cake is your voice
A delicate balance of confidence with tit bit of softness here and there.
The pauses while talking , giving away examples but then quickly coming to the main topic of video , all of these just made the video so much watchable.
I have always wanted to become an orator like you and make videos just like this
Just as smooth as silk
No break in rhythm throughout the video.👍👍👍👍👍👍
As an audience of the video and now a fan of you I must give an answer to question you asked in the last
BTW I am just a teen who has zero vote impact and who is curious in many fields like cinema, politics, history , IR ,etc.🤓🤓🥸😎
I am still deciding which ideology to follow and which party to support
For now i am neither left nor right , but Indie wing
👈 ❌❌
👉 ❌❌
What I could get through your video is ki right wing is hyper musculanity👊💪🗿🗿 and left is so liberal😊, so secular 😊 just like an ideal world 😇yah they have their flaws but this is the crux of their ideology
I used to think same .
And this viewpoint of mine just became rock solid🪨🪨🪨🪨🪨🪨 after watching left wing and even right wing you tubers ( because these right wing guys were just so much drowned in their hyper musculanity ki they just don't want to give valid point and facts just pouring down🤢🤢🤮 their emotions towards left guys with so much hatred😤😡 😡😡, anger😡👿👿👿, sometimes even abusing🤬 towards other end while on other hand left wing you tubers were at peace😇😇😇😇😇, good muculanity, fun going😄😄😄, even handsome🥰🥰 😅😅 🤭)
But some thing just started to erode my rock solid 🪨🪨🪨🪨🪨🪨stance towards left just like a thin rope erodes 🌊🌊🌊a big bulky rock
And that was......
Coming into contact with
J. SAI DEEPAK ( Indie wing, SC advocate) ⚖⚖⚖
ANANDA RANGANATHAN ( atheist )
Vikram Sampant 😇😇( historian )🥸🥸
And many other U tubers and individuals
Now you could see where my Indie wing stand has came
I started to discover flaws in left wing slo lo low low low ly 🎶 that I ditched them
( ya but I didn't shifted to right wing because of the reasons I already mentioned which are the same like yours )
These guys always talked with facts .
Mam you may also check out their interviews, debates vand books
While Anand sir uses harsh words some words are so heavy I don't even understand some words are abusive too
But he justify his emotions through facts
( not a huge fan of him due to his frustration)
but ya😇😇😇 Vikram 😇😇😇sir is so calm and at peace
Deepak sir being an SC advocate cut through my rock like stance for left with his sharp facts🪨🪨🪨🌊🌊
All I learnt from them is what the history is being taught to us is not completely wrong but ya highly distorted
Our history books doesn't take into account the real masscare and cruelty Our sweet country went through in medieval times and even in modern times, the many unsung heroes of medieval and modern times.🤺🤺🤺🤺🙈🙉🙊🙈🙉🙊🙈🙉🙊
How caste system wasn't a thing based on birth , how our society was primarily matriarchal , how our society is highly liberal , plural and democratic in its core values
How the irregularities and misconceptions in today's society is due to the destruction of their place of learnings and not because it was already like this
How the leaders which we think were liberals were not actually like that but a complete reverse 🤡🤡🤡
I may be wrong
Or I may be right
Let the discussion go on which you started with your question at the last
😁😁😁🤔🤔🤔☺☺☺
Well Done... Amazing Thoughts ....Very Good... Keep It Up...
First time watching your video. You are telling the truth. ❤
The difference between a leader and supremo is a leader is inherently dependent on those who he leads, but the supremo is the one expected to not depend on anyone and be the macho ideation of leadership. Both are flawed, both depend on the periods through which people must evolve through
Don't get me wrong. But what personally do you expect out of your man? Beyond and beneath text. What is that which is your expectation?
Typical radical feminist
Don't u think kgf & rrr both are underdog stories .
I understand where you're coming from. That's why I mentioned that there should be something lacking in the hero. Technically, in both films, the heroes seem invincible. I haven't watched KGF but in RRR, all they lack is direction. Anyway, that's not a problem on its own. My issue is with everyone winning every fight with brute force instead of ideas, ideology or skill like in Maidaan, Lagaan or even a comedy like Crew.
@@Cinemawali But they both are action movies , so they have to go with action or brute force they have to show the spectacle also . If it's a politcal drama or satirical movies thn this argument is right . And i don't think majority of the indian audience like that kind internal conflict movies , they want mass masala .
@@amaannkhan lol she made a video on pathan and praised it. Lmao pathan had literally rip off all scenes from major hollywood movies. It was awfull it only ran because of srk and John Abraham....
@@Cinemawali rrr is a different type of movie all together. It was marketed as just an action film, NOT A HISTORICAL FILM, and that's all it was. Not every film has to make it a point to discuss ideologies and politics and whatnot. Some films are for entertainment, just for the fun of it. It is an action film, for action lovers. Maybe it's not your thing and that's okay but everything doesn't have to yk
Rahul chose to be a hero like protagonists in Pad man or Toilet a love story or Majhi The mountain man... A common man trying his level best to resolve a day-to-day problem... Yet it's a man who leads others to the solution... Definitely not a hyper but milder version of masculinity...
Brilliant! Thank you for speaking up!
Great analysis 👍
Why havent u covered ur face with a burqa??
Dont agree with few points but cool video nonetheless. Keep it up!!!
The reason why Rahul Gandhi can do all this gimmicks and facades is because he is a politician and not a prime minister.
I guess people has been watching Nayak movie on repeat and getting the idea that a nation of 1.4 billion can be easily run just by suspending the corrupt and getting on slums.
😂😂😂😂
India's ground problems can never be solved as we as a citizens of India doesn't have a social unity. Everyone only care about personal progress!!
We lack a common purpose.
Unless that's identified we will never progress as a society.
Unfortunately, we indians are not bright morally and philosophically too even after having a rich and ancient culture.
So naturally the only identity of our land is our hindu religion for which we are known around the world.
The nation's identity is being restored and the lefts are not able to tolerate that.
Guess that is why the so-called prime minister is the one who has to resort to constant gimmicks of camera hoarding and being the true camera jeevi of the country? The same PM who made a fan following through peddling the same Nayak dialogues and concocting mellifluous dialogues like "na khaunga na khane dunga" when his special dost were having a good lunch at the behest of common man.
Even if Mr. Modi is Prime Minister and is unable to go on ground and campaign like Rahul Gandhi, can't he do one simple press conference? One unscripted interview? No, he can't because that megalomaniac doesn't have the ability to do one.
All Indians have a common purpose- survive. It is just that people like us are too privileged to think about things like food, shelter and clothing but many do.
"We Indians are not bright..........." Oh, please, don't club us with blind devotees of a hateful ideology of yours and the cult of personality of one man. Some of us (perhaps unlike you) have some brains.
Did you know that the common identity of "Hindu" is very recent that came along in the late 19th century? There is a video by India Ink that explains it very well- search for- How Brahmanism and the British Created India's Hindu Majority.
The Nation's identity is diverse, with several languages, multiple traditions, different cultures, dozens of religions and amazing differences. I am really proud of this diversity, but you want to reduce it to one identity, which is counterproductive at the least and batshit crazy at the worst.
The thing is you are correlating "we" indians from your example alone. You are not morally or philosophically enriched. That is why you make farcical agreements, and make blanket statements like Left this. Right that. The identity of this land is also not Hindu, btw. Buddhism, and Jainism, and multiple forms of tribal religions are commonplace in this land. That is what hindutva aims to erase. That is what you are not able to tolerate the truth. The truth that Hinduism itself is a concoction of multiple schools of thought, from Yoga to Tantra to Sattva to Idol based worship like Shaiva or Shakti. Hinduism is indefinite and no amount of forcibly unitarianism would change that. The same man who said Jai Shri Rama, was forced to forget Rama and embrace Jagannatha mahaprabhu.
Also, suspending the corrupt should be the aim of every "leader" right? Or are you suggesting to embrace corruption? Either way, all you have made are frivolous arguments not worth even responding to. Have a great day nevertheless, and Jai Jagannath!
@@nananou1687 That Jai Jaganath was personal, lmao!!!
Wakeup...cinemawali droped a new video
Love it- the explanation, analysis!!!
Can't thank you enough for this video. ❤❤❤
Thank you so much for making this content ❤
Nicely argued. Thank you. ❤ 🎉
F UAPA all my hommies hate UAPA
Cry about it
"KASHMIR IS AN INTEGRAL PART OF INDIA"
I dont understand why people call it "South Indian" Film industry,there might some similarities in southern industries but Anyone with badic movie sense will that there is huge amount of toxicity, Sexism,cringe crap scenes which have no reason to even be present in a movie just randomly adding comedy scenes which make no sense and that industry is the most Nepotistic industry in the whole country.Malayalam films are on a whole another level and some Tamil films also have great content.Iam a Telugu guy and have grown up watching those Telugu films and have never seen even a good content Telugu film which can be taken seriously,Iam glad that people are now pointing it out and expressing how disgusting they feel when they watch those movies,even the actress in Telugu movies are all from other states 😂
Lol lmao she is a libra ndu can't you see.
@@pipipupu5104 Dude , Iam a hard-core Right wing guy and you don't have to be right or left wing guy to criticize that crap Telugu film industry,That industry has 0 Nationals awards and the movies are just blatant cringe with high amounts of sexism and toxic masculinity.Dont know how idiots like you can't even understand this simple thing