This recording will remain a gift. I can't imagine without this tremendous contrapuntal work by J.S. Bach or the variety on interpretations including organ. I noticed some changes in Contrapunctus XII both rectus and inversus not following strictly the score. It doesn't sound too bad. Everyone who has the CD is truly blessed!
Marvelous performance of this wonderful music, very accessible. I had the same very fine experience with J.S.Bach's Musical Offering with Karl Munchener. Many thanks !
@Divergent Integral The fact of being Bach's heirs does not mean they're always right in everything. Especially C.P.E., who is well-known for his attempts to build a myth about his father. The only significance and "recompense" of the Choral Prelude is being Bach's last composition, written down by dictation if you want to believe in C.P.E.'s statements. That Bach heirs' "thought" seems to be a sort of consolation to themselves after their father's passing.
La transcription pour Orchestre est une excellente idée, elle permet de mieux saisir le travail et les sentiments du Maître. Le clavecin au son aigrelet tend à rebuter l'auditeur, malgré la réalité du fait que c'est une œuvre pour "l'ancêtre" du piano. Le constat est que J. S. Bach est un compositeur moderne. La gloire du monde passe mais pas celle du Cantor d'Eisenach qui a consacré ses œuvres à Dieu
Triple rencontre au sommet des sommets : Bach tardif avec le couronnement de son œuvre , même chose pour Munchinger qui a parfait son interprétation jusqu'à ses derniers jours , tout cela en "présence" de ce prodigieux Rétable riche en beauté artistique et profondeur théologique . Bach , dont les Contrepoints de plus en plus complexes a boutissent au silence de l'inachévement , et qui signait toutes ses œuvres "Soli Deo Gloria" ( à la gloire du Dieu unique ), se met face au Rétable auChrist ensanglanté et en adoration extatique murmure en musique : Tu es le plus beau des enfants de l'homme (Ps 44) Munchinger , d'une beauté à la Gérard Philippe qui faisait dire à Gavoty : Comment lui résister ? , conserve rigueur et grâce inégalée , se souvenant que...."La beauté sauvera le monde". Merci pour ce concert de l'oreille , de l'œil et du cœur .
Monsieur, votre réponse est absolument superbe ! En quelques lignes vous avez tout dit, tout expliqué . Merci à vous. c'est agréable des gens comme vous . Pierre Mosnier
Wonderful performance from a very young William Stewart. I have the great pleasure in accompanying William nowadays, and just to let folks know ,that he only uses that handkerchief for his other passion of Morris Dancing, which he dose every Sunday..........😂
Marvelous performance ! Wonder why this Wolfgang Graeser's amazing arrangement has not been performed more often. (Small technical detail : audio channel (L/R) seems to be reversed here)
Unfortunately, this is the complete film made by French television. I guess the film was not to exceed 60 minutes ... Munchinger always conducted the entire Art of Fugue.
@@wendelhubert2210 Yes I have the Double Decca CD - I particularly miss Contrapunctus 9 here - it's vital to the flow of the piece and to miss it is most unfortunate and very hard to understand
To my ears Münchinger had a rare gift for getting JS Bach tempos spot on. Many thanks for this excellent recording of a wonderful performance.
A toi, c 'est merci!! alle waren ooooooooops, we were all sick that day, and played like this!!!!!!
This recording will remain a gift. I can't imagine without this tremendous contrapuntal work by J.S. Bach or the variety on interpretations including organ. I noticed some changes in Contrapunctus XII both rectus and inversus not following strictly the score. It doesn't sound too bad. Everyone who has the CD is truly blessed!
00:08 Contrapunctus 1
04:07 Contrapunctus 2
06:56 Contrapunctus 3
10:52 Contrapunctus 4
14:20 Contrapunctus 5
19:03 Contrapunctus 7
22:03 Canon alla Duodecima
25:00 Canon alla Decima
29:21 Contrapunctus 12a (rectus)
32:27 Contrapunctus 12b (inversus)
35:37 Contrapunctus 14 (unvollendet)
44:04 "Vor deinen Thron tret' ich hiermit"
THANK YOU!!!!....
Marvelous performance of this wonderful music, very accessible. I had the same very fine experience with J.S.Bach's Musical Offering with Karl Munchener. Many thanks !
Sorry "Karl Munchinger" ! A version I always come back to.
Un tout grand Maître et un superbe orchestre!
this music is so wonderful.
My version, despite all those fanatics of historicism!
Mine, too!
It's not historicism, but simply truth. That Choral Prelude has no place there.
@Divergent Integral The fact of being Bach's heirs does not mean they're always right in everything. Especially C.P.E., who is well-known for his attempts to build a myth about his father. The only significance and "recompense" of the Choral Prelude is being Bach's last composition, written down by dictation if you want to believe in C.P.E.'s statements. That Bach heirs' "thought" seems to be a sort of consolation to themselves after their father's passing.
COMPLETAMENTE d'accordo!!🤝🤝
Simply Great!
...traumhaft ♡
La transcription pour Orchestre est une excellente idée, elle permet de mieux saisir le travail et les sentiments du Maître. Le clavecin au son aigrelet tend à rebuter l'auditeur, malgré la réalité du fait que c'est une œuvre pour "l'ancêtre" du piano. Le constat est que J. S. Bach est un compositeur moderne. La gloire du monde passe mais pas celle du Cantor d'Eisenach qui a consacré ses œuvres à Dieu
Maravillosa versión!!!
Thank You!....
Perfect !
Incredible
The 4 genius German "Karls" of Music:
- Richter
- Münchinger
- Ristenpart
- Forster
Berg
Böhm
Il testamento del Cosmo... GRUNEWALD...JSB ...MEIN GOTT!!!
Wow!
Beautiful !
Thanks a lot
Triple rencontre au sommet des sommets : Bach tardif avec le couronnement de son œuvre , même chose pour Munchinger qui a parfait son interprétation jusqu'à ses derniers jours , tout cela en "présence" de ce prodigieux Rétable riche en
beauté artistique et profondeur théologique .
Bach , dont les Contrepoints de plus en plus complexes a boutissent au silence de
l'inachévement , et qui signait toutes ses œuvres "Soli Deo Gloria" ( à la gloire du
Dieu unique ), se met face au Rétable auChrist ensanglanté et en adoration
extatique murmure en musique : Tu es le plus beau des enfants de l'homme (Ps 44)
Munchinger , d'une beauté à la Gérard Philippe qui faisait dire à Gavoty : Comment lui résister ? , conserve rigueur et grâce inégalée , se souvenant que...."La beauté sauvera le monde".
Merci pour ce concert de l'oreille , de l'œil et du cœur .
Ces concerts Münchinger du Festival de Colmar restent à jamais gravés dans mon coeur
Monsieur, votre réponse est absolument superbe ! En quelques lignes vous avez tout dit, tout expliqué . Merci à vous. c'est agréable des gens comme vous . Pierre Mosnier
REtable et non pas Rétable !!!
Munchinger... 🤯🔥🎼👌🏻
thank you!
@j.veerman4743
5 年前（編集済み）
00:08 Contrapunctus 1
04:07 Contrapunctus 2
06:56 Contrapunctus 3
10:52 Contrapunctus 4
14:20 Contrapunctus 5
19:03 Contrapunctus 7
22:03 Canon alla Duodecima
25:00 Canon alla Decima
29:21 Contrapunctus 12a (rectus)
32:27 Contrapunctus 12b (inversus)
35:37 Contrapunctus 14 (unvollendet)
44:04 "Vor deinen Thron tret' ich hiermit"
Stilfuldt og meget følsom musik lige i øret. Smukt........
Wonderful performance from a very young William Stewart. I have the great pleasure in accompanying William nowadays, and just to let folks know ,that he only uses that handkerchief for his other passion of Morris Dancing, which he dose every Sunday..........😂
You can get this recording on another TH-cam channel with all the movements keyed
Le sublime. Moi, les personne que je respecte le plus au monde, ce sont les musiciens.
Marvelous performance ! Wonder why this Wolfgang Graeser's amazing arrangement has not been performed more often. (Small technical detail : audio channel (L/R) seems to be reversed here)
Check out 29:20 to 29:27. I wonder why.
I prefer the extraordinary Karl Ristenpart version (orchestra, too)
😍👌👌🙏
Chi sono i due esperti che dissentono da questa esecuzione? Sarebbe interessante conoscere il loro commento tecnico!
We are sorry - you have reached the ending of music - there is no more. ~ You may go back home and feed your cats, and do the dishes...
True, no more, no further. The Omega.
Impossible, the reverse mode has given up, we are stucked at the unfinished Contrapunctus !
La bonne année est 1984 et non 1985 (cf. générique de fin).
Best there is - but why is this TH-cam version incomplete?
Unfortunately, this is the complete film made by French television. I guess the film was not to exceed 60 minutes ...
Munchinger always conducted the entire Art of Fugue.
@@wendelhubert2210 Yes I have the Double Decca CD - I particularly miss Contrapunctus 9 here - it's vital to the flow of the piece and to miss it is most unfortunate and very hard to understand
On vhs and never remastered?
still can't decide which one I should buy, his version or Sir Neville Marriner (mind the spelling)
Munchinger, but with Stuttgart
Chris Phillips isn't he always with the Stuttgart - any way I ended up buy both of them ;D
Really is hard choice
@@e21bigWhich recording did you buy?
WHO IS GRUNEWALD? And for the past...for the present...for the future...WHO IS JSB???
nice, but there is no lick
hi
...really?!