J.S. Bach / Ich habe genug, BWV 82 (Herreweghe)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750)
Cantata BWV 82: Ich habe genug (2 February 1727)
1. Ich habe genug (Aria: B)
2. Ich habe genug (Recitative: B) 07:25
3. Schlummert ein, ihr matten Augen (Aria: B) 08:26
4. Mein Gott! wann kömmt das schöne: Nun! (Recitative: B) 18:04
5. Ich freue mich auf meinen Tod (Aria: B) 18:47
Bass Soloist: Peter Kooy
Performed by Philippe Herreweghe and the Choir & Orchestra of La Chapelle Royale. Recorded by Harmonia Mundi in 1991.
"'Ich habe genug' was written for the Feast of the Purification of the Virgin (2 February - Candlemas Day), which in 1727 (the year of its composition) fell upon the fourth Sunday after Epiphany. It has been established that another cantata was performed on this occasion, BWV 83 (Erfreute Zeit im neuen Bande) written in 1724 and therefore belonging to the first of the five annual cycles of cantatas composed by Bach. The libretto of this new cantata (anonymous) is lacking in any reference to a biblical text. The early version in C minor was later subjected to a number of changes without, however, losing its character as a solo cantata. It was transposed into E minor for soprano in 1731, then, in 1735, revised again for mezzo-soprano with a transverse flute instead of an oboe, and finally it regained its original shape between 1745 and 1748 with a return to the bass soloist while the oboe was replaced by an oboe da caccia. The recitative 'Ich habe genug' (No. 2) and the aria, 'Schlummert ein' (No. 3) figure in the Notenbüchlein compiled for Anna Magdalena from 1725 on, but these pieces were not inserted before 1730, which proves that the version in the cantata score was written before that date. The cantata has no chorus and consists of no more than three arias and two recitatives. All the arias employ identical instrumental forces (concertante oboe, strings and continuo), which is unique in Bach; the recitatives are 'simple', but with passages in arioso style. The entire score is suffused with a personal and intimate tone (again in the first person), closely related to the Song of Simeon, addressing God after having taken the infant Jesus in his arms, 'For mine eyes have seen thy salvation' (Luke 2, 30) -- we are told that it had been revealed to Simeon by the Holy Ghost 'that he should not see death, before he had seen the Lord's Christ' (Luke 2, 36). Of the whole Gospel narrative of Christ's presentation in the Temple (Luke 2, 22-32) the poet has retained only this aspect, with the result that the cantata becomes a contemplation of death considered as the liberation from the afflictions of this world and the uniting of the soul with its Savior. Each of the three arias follows a particular formal pattern. The first (A B B') is a page filled with sadness which has often been compared with the aria, 'Erbarme dich, mein Gott' from the St. Matthew Passion. The second, a lullaby which has made the cantata famous, is also comparable in mood to the great masterpiece written at the same period; it has the form of an expanded da capo aria (A BAC-A). The third aria, dance-like in character, is in a free da capo form." - Alberto Basso
Painting: Girl with Sunflowers, Michael Ancher
One of THE most heart-wrenchingly beautiful pieces of music ever written, in my humble opinion.
2020 felt that
This beautiful, heart retching song is also used in the St. Matthew Passion near the end after has died
@@cahopwood Love what Mark Swed said: "These last four months Bach has been classical music’s No. 1 comfort-giver, music bestowing a sourdough for the soul. But who, in their right mind, is currently content? Who’s not sleeping either too much or too little, with nights spent if not in escape then in angst?"
Father Seraphim pray to God for us...thank you for everything!
"BWV 82 - Ich habe genug" ist eine Kantate von Johann Sebastian Bach, die im Jahr 1727 für das Fest der Darstellung des Herrn komponiert wurde. Der Text der Kantate basiert auf den Worten des alten Simeon im Lukasevangelium, der erklärt, dass er bereit ist, zu gehen, nachdem er das Kind Jesus gesehen hat.
Die Kantate ist für einen Bass-Solisten geschrieben und besteht aus fünf Sätzen. Der erste Satz ist eine langsame und traurige Arie, in der der Sänger seinen Wunsch nach Erlösung von irdischem Leiden und seinen Wunsch ausdrückt, von diesem Leben zu scheiden, um bei Christus zu sein. Der zweite Satz ist ein Rezitativ, in dem der Sänger über die vergängliche Natur des Lebens nachdenkt und den Trost reflektiert, der aus der Verheißung des ewigen Lebens kommt.
Der dritte Satz ist eine fröhliche und lebhafte Arie, in der der Sänger sich über den Gedanken freut, die Sorgen und Schmerzen dieser Welt hinter sich zu lassen. Der vierte Satz ist ein sanftes und nachdenkliches Rezitativ, in dem der Sänger seinen Inhalt und die Akzeptanz seines Schicksals ausdrückt.
Die Kantate endet mit einer ruhigen und schönen Arie, in der der Sänger erklärt, dass er genug hat, dass er seinen Frieden in Christus gefunden hat und dass er bereit ist, von diesem Leben Abschied zu nehmen, wann immer Gott ihn ruft.
Die Kantaten von Bach sind bekannt für ihre musikalische und theologische Tiefe, und "Ich habe genug" bildet hier keine Ausnahme. Die Kantate erforscht die Themen des Lebens, des Todes und der Verheißung des ewigen Lebens, und sie ist eine kraftvolle Meditation über die menschliche Bedingung und die Hoffnung, die im Glauben gefunden werden kann.
One of Bach's best cantatas. He is and will remain the best composer
🙏
The first two arias of this cantata ('Ich habe genug' and 'Schlummert ein') surely represent Bach's musical invention at its most inspired and elevated. Truly sublime inspiration!
I'm slowly dying of ALS/MND and this meditation on the words of Simeon, " now let thy servant depart in peace" speaks to m y heart
Mr Hughes, not quite sure how to react to what you shared. .... Surely, a comfort to have such beauty to accompany you on your journey. I will be thinking of you. And from below, there is a post that I quote:
Grög Bier
1 month ago (edited)
Music that gets you completely dumbfounded, so beautiful and heavenly you have to wonder if you are dreaming. So thank you so much for posting
John, I obviously don't know you, but may I say how sorry I am to read this.
thank you, Basil, for your kindness. Recently an elderly mystic wrote to me on hearing of my illness and said "I am awestruck by the news of yourself: awestruck by the grace Our Lord is giving you to live so close to Him in your sharing of His Passion.". And however counter intuitive it seems, I experience it as true. I know to a non believer it sounds madness, but it's very clear to me. Best wishes
I’m truly sorry you are going through this and I hope you are okay. I’m glad Bach has given you solace.
Not only is the music divine, but when you think that the title is "I've had enough ..." My heart thinks now that it is Sublime ♥
I hear you brother! Stay still and know you are not alone! ♥
Thank you, Father Seraphim Rose, for introducing to me this piece of art.
:)
Antonia Andra , la fel...Viata si lucrarile Parintelui Serafim Rose, m-au adus aici...cu bucurie🌈⚘
@@laurentiagilda1881 Mare bucurie! Te îmbrățișez în rugăciune!
@@antoniaandra149 🙏❤🌺
Father Seraphim Rose brought me here, too. I can picture him, eyes closed, enjoying the beauty of this piece. Every time I listen, I think of him and the joy this piece gave to his soul. May he intercede and pray for us all and for the world. ☦️❤️📿
One of my all time Bach pieces. Sang the vocal part a number of times, years ago, and it still lingers in my heart. Glorious!
Nie habe ich Bach genug
Bach ist UNENDLICH
Je crois que tu dis "je n'ai jamais assez de Bach" :) Je réponds : "moi non plus" !
@@KayHarpaGone Yo tampoco
Very funny
Genau!
το ακούω κάθε μέρα και κλαίω !das ist einmalig, beste hymne ueberhaupt.Bach ist unsterblich.αθανατος
"Musica Medicina Dolorum"....
*"The music of my father has a higher purpose. It's not to fill the ears, but to set the heart in motion"*
--- C.P.E. Bach (his most talented son who later became Mozart's teacher and father figure)
That's how I want to compose music
We owe a great deal of our knowledge of Bach, and the preservation of his legacy, to CPE Bach-- a worthy composer in his own right and a pioneer of the Classical Era.
MOZART REWROTE SOME OF THE CPE BACH SINFONIAS. OR MAYBE, JUST REORCHASTRATED THEM.
@@ronwalker4849 Mozart considered CPE Bach as his father figure and most important teacher..
He also learned a lot from Bach's other son JC. Mozart as we know him today would be unthinkable without the Bach family.
I would say that Wilhelm Friederich was the deeper, greater and more original talent than CPE.
Ok Johann - I give up - God exists
If I were not a believer, I would copy Boris Vian's quote: God exists because Bach invented Him
And then to know Bach was ignored the first decades after his death
@@PM.68 Thank God for Mendelsohn.
😆😆😆👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
Yes ! Amen. ALLÉLUIA ! 🙏🏻✝️💘🇻🇦
A favorite of Father Seraphim Rose (memory eternal).
Beautiful music. Very profound. reminds me of the Matthew's Passion which I love. Thank you Bach.
You’re right! I came to the same conclusion.
Der Himmel voller Geigen, die Engel empfangen den fünften Evangelisten mit Freude!
I find it easy to cry with this music
Now, this is what I call music. This is peace for the mind and soul. There is a lot of noise that we use to call it music these days.
Agreed. Not only is pure trash called music, but the performers of it dare to be called ARTISTS!
Die Oboe spielt göttlich!
Cette musique n'a pas d'époque !
I had the immense pleasure of seeing the great Peter Kooy many times and it is wonderful to have recordings of him.
The bass aria, "Schlummert ein", is one of Bach's greatest creations. Thank you so much for posting this excellent version.
Yes I totally agree, this is simply unbeatable. Everything is just divine. Never heard anything close to that. Thank you!
Souffle, caresse, intelligence, tendresse, loyauté, fidélité, souci et attention. On trouve tout cela dans la cantate 82 de Bach.
The music is beautiful and so is the painting. Michael Ancher, Danish, 1849 - 1927
Une des plus belles cantates de Bach... Sublime !
🤝🏻 On est d'accord Gérard. C'est Divin !
Salut les compatriotes !
My love for this musician does not end
When I was young I said my religion was Bach. Actually I still think so.
Fader Bach får mig nästan att tro på Gud och det är ett gott betyg från en inbiten hedning❤️
I do not know anything about classical music, and you are more apt to find me in a dive bar listening to blues or rock and roll, but this song is so beautiful I could easily become emotional.
Go on with classical music!
I think I should! 😊
❤
Dip your toe into Bach's work - you won't look back
@@benphilips9918 Thank you! Better than listening to videos about politics. I’ll take your advice.
One of the ten best Cantatas of J. S Bach.
What is your top10?
If I had to pick 10 of his best cantatas, it would be the following:
BWV 82
BWV 198
BWV 21
BWV 131
BWV 106
BWV 177
BWV 5
BWV 22
BWV 164
and finally, BWV 205.
I love bwv 198!
Bach es el padre de la música, sus obras sublimes llegan al alma, saludos desde Chile 🎼🎶🇨🇱
Odette , merveilleusement, j' e te aimé
Schlummert Ein must be one of the most beautiful and moving pieces of music ever written. It never fails to bring tears to my eyes. Thank you for posting this wonderful performance.
Fr. Seraphim Rose, pray to God for us.
💖🙏 Amin !
A la grâce de DIEU😢
Just reading the book in his life and came here right after that chapter.
Blessed St Seraphim pray for us.
This is my all-time favourite Bach cantata,especially Schlummert Ein,ihr matten Augen,is perhaps the greatest vocal piece in this work,and I`m a great admirer of Bach`s music,when I was 9 years old,and still love his music as well as the other members of the Bach family,and I think their music from the Baroque era is absolutely great.
Divine music, Bach is literally the best
Definitivamente J.S Bach, para mi es el mejor compositor de música que que ha habido de todos los tiempos. Su música, como está cantata te hace sentir sentimientos que florecen desde lo más profundo del alma.
Danke seer.Dziękuję. Grazie.❤❤❤❤
Una cantata maravillosa, como toda la música de Bach.
We're going to die sooner or later and we better gain some wisdom before our time is up:
More Bach, please!
Oh Bach, this is such a beautiful piece !
The thoughtful and inspiring performance of maestro Philippe Herreweghe. Every note is perfect.
J'aime aussi bcp la version du soliste max van Egmont
A gorgeous and moving piece of music-it never fails to give me chills and tears.
I'm not going to cry, I'm not going to cry...
SCHLUMMERT EIN-
I can't stop crying
I have just read the translation of "Schlummert ein" and now i understand why i felt so compassionate before i knew what the song meant .
Sehr schõne Einspielung einer der schõnsten Bach-Kantaten. Danke dafūr!
Es una cantata de Bach que llega al alma!!
Bach es el mayor genio de todos los tiempos.
..and to think that Bach wrote one of these cantatas every week for some seven years in addition to all his other responsibilities and composition. It beggars belief! There are so many extant cantatas, more than 200, that it is a struggle to listen to them all - I tried over a period of three years and probably didn't get past half way. How he could have written them at the same rate as I was stuggling to listen to them is something that can only be marvelled at. Of course they were, at some level, disposable (in the sense that the vast majority were not revisited in his lifetime) though anyone who knows Bach will know that he will still have striven to make them as perfect as his time allowed. Perhaps the most gargantuan effort in all classical composition (yes, yes, I know that Telemann wrote more but at a much lower level of inspiration; not that he doesn't have his moments). It amuses me that if Bach had written only ten of these cantatas they would be much more revered like Beethoven and his symphonies. 200+ is so hard to get to grips with. You could say that less is more but of course with Bach more is more......................
Simple answer: Bach wrote because he had to, it just flowed from him. Just as other musical greats just poured out their music, because they had to.
I agree with you....quite inexplicable how Bach wrote so much sublime music... Could there have been Devine intervention, or is it a Devine gift... ..or ,or, do I do a dis- service to Bach himself...who wrote his music to glorify and celebrate The Lord and why it is said Angels listen to Mozart but when The Lord listens to music HE listens to Bach..
It always amuses me when scientists look for alternatives to a Devine Creator of the Universe when right before them, closer to home. is such incredible beauty of Bach that can never he explained or replicated by mathematical formula or a computer. that they should shake their heads in dismay over their own blindness and stupidity.
THEN Bach had to make parts for the instruments and singers, and rehearse it all!
If
I wonder what Bach would be doing if he was born in our times
Love the dance like quality of the fifth movement alternating between the minor and its relative major before settling on that e flat chord at the end.
Und ploetzlich fuehle ich mich sosehr zufrieden. Das kann nur Johann Sebastian Bach.
Das Stück ist aber voller Kummer.
Wenn man Wehmut zulaesst, kommt man wesentlich besser damit zurecht,
als wenn man dagegen ankaempft. Johann Sebastan Bach hilft dabei . . .
Bach es un milagro.Bach es la perfección absoluta.
Gorgeous. My soul needed that
La paix de l'âme...
I'm flying in heaven!
A las 20.30 horas voy a escuchar esta conmovedora aria en el Maestranza de Sevilla en el día de hoy. Quedan dos horas...
GRANDE BACH.
Fue una experiencia única.
Mañana 4 años después en el mismo festival o sea el festival de música Antigua de Sevilla voy a estar presente pero esta vez con un contratenor como es Andreas Sholl
WOW. nothing compares to this.
I absolutely love it ! Danke schön
Wunderschöne Gesang -und instrumental Interpretation! Herreweghe ist "THE BEST"
"THE BEST" is BS
Absolutely wonderful! Lovely aria, beautifully sung (IMO)
Thank you!! Beautiful performance, magnificent voice and orchestra. A very special thanks for the description of the post. Really didactic and educational. Congratulations. Soon it will be Christmas, very appropriate for the time.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐🌷
Excellent
Glorious!
God has revealed himself in general and special revelation and in the compositions of J.S Bach.
1. Ich habe genug (Aria: B) 00:00
"Ich habe genug,
Ich habe den Heiland, das Hoffen der Frommen,
Auf meine begierigen Arme genommen;
Ich habe genug!
--
Ich hab ihn erblickt,
Mein Glaube hat Jesum ans Herze gedrückt;
Nun wünsch ich, noch heute mit Freuden
Von hinnen zu scheiden."
2. Ich habe genug (Recitative: B) 07:25
"Ich habe genug.
Mein Trost ist nur allein,
Dass Jesus mein und ich sein eigen möchte sein.
Im Glauben halt ich ihn,
Da seh ich auch mit Simeon
Die Freude jenes Lebens schon.
Laßt uns mit diesem Manne zehn!
Ach! möchte mich von meines Leibes Ketten
Der Herr erretten;
Ach! wäre doch mein Abschied hier,
Mit Freuden sagt ich, Welt, zu dir:
Ich habe genug."
3. Schlummert ein, ihr matten Augen (Aria: B) 08:26
"Schlummert ein, ihr matten Augen,
Fallet sanft und selig zu!
--
Welt, ich bleibe nicht mehr hier,
Hab ich doch kein Teil an dir,
Das der Seele könnte taugen.
--
Hier muss ich das Elend bauen,
Aber dort, dort werd ich schauen
Süßen Friede, stille Ruh."
4. Mein Gott! wann kömmt das schöne: Nun! (Recitative: B) 18:04
"Mein Gott! wann kömmt das schöne: Nun!
Da ich im Friede fahren werde
Und in dem Sande kühler Erde
Und dort bei dir im Schoße ruhe?
Der Abschied ist gemacht,
Welt, gute Nacht!"
5. Ich freue mich auf meinen Tod (Aria: B) 18:47
"Ich freue mich auf meinen Tod,
Ach, hätt er sich schon eingefunden.
--
Da entkomm ich aller Not,
Die mich noch auf der Welt gebunden."
Vielen Dank für den Text.
Thank you so very much!
So beautiful. I heard Ely Ameling do this in concert and this is this is the first time I've heard it surpassed.
+David Goorevitch Check out Herreweghe's BWV 82a with Nancy Argenta if you want to hear the same cantata sung by soprano.
I have it. It's this version I mean when I say it surpasses Ely. But her stage presence! Only Springsteen and Armstrong compare(d).
Mit dieser wundervollen Musik möchte ich sterben...sie geht so tief in die Seele...
superbe!!frissons garantis
One of the best cantata🎉
Бах, просто необыкновенно!
First time im listen this cantata Best cantata im listen in my Life
Beautiful performance--so poignant. I used to have an LP with Hermann Prey. If memory serves, this sounds even more beautiful.
I had it too and I agree.
I'm learning this cantata....it's so difficult and marvellous at the same time...Herreweghe's good version
Grazie Micheal
va in loop da quando ce l'hai regalata!!!
son certa che metterai il cuore nel cantarla e sarà omaggio a Bach e a chi avrà la fortuna di ascoltarti
Grazie Presidente, mi stai adulando troppo....è difficile però è ricchissima di pathos. Grazie.
io non adulo !!!
Ok, come non detto, non arrabbiarti....grazie per le belle parole
Que lindo ! Tocou me a alma.
fantastic performance
Шедевр!
Schlummert ein is the most soothing and hugging of all lullabies in the history of music. It is also the most profound death and peaceful resignation 😭😭😭 according to words
Je suis comblé, c'est exactement ça...
It is enough.
My one consolation is this:
That I am Jesus’ beloved and he is mine.
In faith, I hold him.
For in Simeon, I already see
The joy of life to come.
Let us go forth with Simeon!
The words of the cantata refer to Luke's Gospel near the beginning where old Simeon takes the infant Jesus in his arms with wonderful words in his mouth. Rembrandt has a moving painting of the scene. It relates to what Bach was thinking. The lady with the huge bunch of sunflowers does not unfortunately!
One correct translation could also be : I have got enough. The way they sing it, sounds more like this one. And I like it so much more.
@@nicolaschmidt5334 exactly. ‘Ich habe genug’ would be best translated as ‘I’ve had enough’ , I guess
Cuando la música alcanza estos niveles expresivos y poéticos, trasciende el ámbito de la música y se adentra en el de la espiritualidad.
Thanks for this music, beautifull perfomance
It is everything.
Saint Simeon pray for us. What a treasure to translate the Old Testament into Greek LXX, live almost 300 years and see the God-Man in the flesh. What a glorius life! What a glorius death! What a gift for Bach to honor with such beauty.
Bach el mejor
The most beautiful singing of "Schlummert Ein" is by German Bass/Baritone Thomas Quasthoff, in my opinion. His voice is so rich and velvety.
Ich Habe Genug von leben.
Έχω αρκετά. Έχω δεχθεί το Σωτήρα, την ελπίδα των πιστών στην αγκαλιά μου που Τον λαχταρούσε. Έχω αρκετά. Αντίκρισα Εκείνον, η πίστη μου έχει αγκαλιάσει τον Ιησού και σήμερα θα άφηνα με χαρά αυτόν τον κόσμο. Μοναδική ελπίδα μου είναι ο Ιησούς ότι θα γίνει δικός μου κι εγώ δικός Του. Στηρίζομαι σ’ Αυτόν με πίστη και όπως ο Συμεών, διακρίνω ήδη τη χαρά αυτής της άλλης ζωής. Ας Τον ακολουθήσουμε. Είθε ο Κύριος να με απελευθέρωνε από τα δεσμά της ανθρώπινης μορφής μου- Είθε η ημέρα της αναχώρησής μου να είχε φθάσει με χαρά τότε θα έλεγα στον κόσμο:«Έχω αρκετά».
«Αναπαυθείτε τώρα κουρασμένα μάτια- κλείστε απαλά και ειρηνικά. Κόσμε, δε μένω άλλο πια εδώ. Σε αποκηρύσσω, ώστε το πνεύμα μου να αναθάλλει. Εδώ τα πάντα είναι δυστυχία, εκεί όμως θα αντικρίσω γλυκιά ειρήνη, τέλεια ανάπαυση». Σ’ αυτό το σημείο εκφράζεται μια θερμή παράκληση: «Θεέ μου! Πότε θα με καλέσεις να έλθω ειρηνικά κοντά Σου, να ξαπλώσω στη δροσερή γη και ν’ αναπαυθώ εκεί σε Σένα;». «Θεέ μου! Πότε θα με καλέσεις να έλθω ειρηνικά κοντά Σου, να ξαπλώσω στη δροσερή γη και ν’ αναπαυθώ εκεί σε Σένα;». «Καληνύχτα κόσμε!». «Αγαλλιάζω στο θάνατο μου»…
+Astrolpsis σε ευχαριστώ, το μεγαλείο της μουσικής συνοδεύει και τους στοίχους και το νόημα τους
Παρακαλώ!
π.Σεραφείμ Ρόουζ "Η Ζωή και τα έργα του." :)
@@NN...1809 Ο Πατήρ Σεραφείμ Ροουζ (για εμένα, Αγιος Σεραφείμ, και ας μην έχει γίνει ακόμη επίσημη άγιοκατάταξη) με παρακίνησε να έρθω να ακούσω. Τι ομορφιά. Τον σκέφτομαι με τα μάτια του τα όμορφα κλεισμένα απαλά, η μουσική να αγαλλιάζει την ψυχή του την ταπεινή. Να πρεσβεύει για όλους μας. Αμην. ☦️❤️📿
О. Серафим, моли Бога о нас!!!
Gratidão!!
And thank you Herreweghe !!!
Proof of the God and heaven.
For Grey Macleod: the performance you are describing was Lorraine Hunt Lieberson in a Peter Sellers production. There is a wonderful CD of her singing this cantata. Worth chasing down.
The wonderful Lorraine was terminally ill with cancer at the time. A great loss to music.
You might be talking about the recording I was listening to before coming here. It has both BWV 82 and 199. Search for
nonesuch 79692-2
Ωωω...Πατερα Σεραφείμ προσευχησου στον Θεο για εμας στον κοσμο...❤
IN GREECE WE LOVE BACH A LOT.HE IS THE BEST COMPOSER OF ALL SEASONS.WE LOVE ALSO GERMAN PEOPLE.THE PLACE OF GREECE IS IN EUROPE.
+ΑΝΤΩΝΙΟΣ ΔΑΝΕΖΗΣ haha since when greek people like german? huh...
Ναι όλο Μπαχ ακούμε στην Ελλάδα. Ραδιόφωνα σε μαγαζιά, καφετέριες, ταβέρνες και στα σπίτια μας. Στη μουσική εμείς οι έλληνες έχουμε φοβερό γούστο....
Που φανταζεσαι αυτές τις σαχλαμάρες? Η Ελλάδα είναι τριτοκοσμική χώρα και τα σκυλάδικα την χαρακτηρίζουν μια χαρά. Το Ich Habe Genug όχι μόνο δεν αρέσει στην Ελλάδα σαν μουσική αλλά ακόμα και σαν κείμενο είναι εντελώς ξένο στην νέο-ελληνική κουλτούρα της καλοπέρασης με τα λεφτά άλλων (και καλύτερα των Γερμανών). Για παράδειγμα, πόσες ακριβώς ορχήστρες με όργανα εποχής έχουμε που ερμηνεύουν καντάτες του Bach στην Ελλάδα? Μηδέν - απολύτως καμία. Οπότε άστο, λέμε και καμία που και που για να περνάει η ώρα... Τράβα τώρα στο Μέγαρο παρέα με τον παίδαρο...
With of course the ECB... ahem!
It is better to hear a voice of love than of hate
어떻게 이런선율 화음 감성이 그시대에 있을수있단말인가
Unas de mis Cantatas preferidas.
아끼고 좋아하는 곡
Bach was from a time of small populations. Imagine how many geniuses we could have produced if our education system were not so dumbed down.
Geniuses like Bach are not “produced” from any type of educational system. They are intrinsic. A true genius will stand out often even when deprived of opportunities. A good education system can make a world of difference, but you’re not going to get more J.S. Bach’s from them.
@@landonpoch that's a bit of a myth. Geniuses like classical music geniuses, Shakespeare, etc. were, more often than not, extremely highly educated. We don't push pupils hard enough in our soft, woke education system, and don't teach them the right things.
@@JimEadon I was briefly a high school teacher to pay for university. They don't learn anything in schools anymore. The education programs are all about learning through social interaction, which, if you're interacting with ignorants, doesn't do much.
I'm also a church organist. Most kids don't even know what an organ is.
@@JimEadon It's not about pushing pupils hard. Genius follows its own purpose and carves out its own path. Thats why most geniuses are self taught Da vinci, Edison , Feynman so on and so on. We actually need to give pupils more freedom to follow their natural inclinations and provoke them to think critically and take nothing at face value. . But i also agree with Landon, this will not produce any more geniuses but may help sharpen those that already exist.
@@Rudolph1722 Considering school is where children and teenergaers learn how to socialize (and are socialized by that process), i would argue that it does very much in that regard
8:28 a beautiful aria
До слёз!
Ein echt toller Kommentar!
Ich habe genug, dass wir nicht genug haben.