Vocal Coach Reacts to Eason Chan｜國外聲樂老師點評 陳奕迅《是但求其愛》/《致明日的舞》
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มิ.ย. 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks｜加入會員提前解鎖完整版影片:
/ @clubzeromedia
*Performance videos and instrumentals may have been censored due to copyright concerns. Please visit our Bilibili for full-versions of the reaction: space.bilibili.com/7295246
Stayed tuned for more professional vocal coach reaction videos!
Follow Rozette on TH-cam: @RozetteSaaangs
Follow Rozette on TikTok: / rozettesaaangs
Artist Booking: clubzeromedia.com/rozette
#reaction #vocalcoach #reactionvideo #是但求其愛 #致明日的舞 #陳奕迅 #是但求其吹 #林家謙 #麥曦茵 #小克 - บันเทิง
![《是但求其愛》陳奕迅 Eason Chan [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/bJHCgo85irM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HIGHLIGHT] หมีLIVEปะ? | EP.171 เห็นแต่ในจอ วันนี้มาต้องขอคารวะ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gPWLxa0e_Z8/mqdefault.jpg)
老師在聽「是但求其愛」的時候哭了，而在「致明日的舞」時笑了，她不懂中文，但被Eason的歌聲中的情緒感染了，說明好的歌手能夠通過他的聲線，表達的感情、打動任何人。這就是陳奕迅最好的地方，也就是老師口中的“人性”。
當年Eason在英國大學學習音樂時的法國籍歌唱老師在教Eason的時候曾這麼說過：“真正好的歌手，能把歌唱變成像在耳邊予人說話一般（真切）！” Eason一直很感恩那位老師的教誨，如今的他，在這方面可謂華語、乃至世界樂壇的佼佼者。
Eason 最厲害之處不是他的唱功，而是他能輕易地唱入你的心。❤
能唱入你的心的前提是有技巧支撐，Eason是大道至簡，唱功高明到你看不到他出招你就已經內傷了....
Hate to say it but, 那就是唱功啊😂
Hate to say it but, 那就是唱功啊😂
陳奕迅出名有唱功啊！ 你懂唱歌嗎？ 不懂就勿胡亂說…
他是英國皇家音樂學院的😊
好幾條影片老師都大讚陳奕迅的演出，他的確是粵語歌手的頂端，一直都覺得陳奕迅的唱功就好像一般說話、一般呼吸地自然的說故事，要做到這點已經很不簡單，的確是非常罕有的類型。
另外可能他的個性比較調皮，在他的演出總會覺得他很會「玩」音樂，他的作品主題可以很廣而到位，要快樂有快樂，要悲傷有悲傷，要狂氣有狂氣，這很利害。
這首歌eason唱的多好我不用多說
聽不太懂廣東話的觀眾，我強烈推薦大家去找的這首歌的歌詞分析。歌詞非常出色的運用了廣東話的詞彙以及發音所帶出的雙關含義。是現在少見詞，曲，唱都很出色的作品
是但求其愛真的好聽～ 當時 開頭那句 論盡半生不懂愛～直接沈醉 愛上這首歌
他广东话发音真的字正腔圆 虽然我不是广东人 但是他听起来就是耳朵爽!
這兩首歌我都很愛⋯曲和詞寫得很棒
是但求其愛對歌手的廣東話發音要求很高，唱歌說話有懶音的人來唱就不用說（可以直接點蠟），就算是平時廣東話咬字清楚的人要處理chorus部份那些尾字／尾音還處理得這麼清晰且動聽有感情是一個極限級的挑戰，絕對不只是普通的字正腔圓這麼簡單。
@@mcdullpork8775 這歌詞很多地方只要錯了一個字 意思就跑掉了......
衷心 vs 忠心
終身 vs 終生
其實Eason最能突出一個真正的歌手要求, 一個story teller
彈鋼琴的是林家謙
香港新生代代表之一
很厲害的演唱創作者
寫了很多很多好歌
也唱了很多很好聽的歌
但佢唱歌真心真係麻麻 唔係果種層次 只係比起依家樂壇 ..
@@user-fx4jv7ml1m 但最好唔好唱歌 創作好啦
陳奕迅厲害之處是，他唱的歌貌似平淡無奇，但其實都包含了無數的技巧、練歷與感情在內。普通人、甚至乎一些專業歌手都無法輕鬆駕御到這種技巧運用的
我認為很多香港歌手能夠唱進內心，多半來自環境及生長過程。壓力、艱困、以及面對的美好未來。人與人之間的聯繫緊密、共情力擴張。當然還有天生的音色還有資源、才能夠被大家聽見。然後只有短短的幾分鐘
平淡無奇？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？？
@@minkye9883 沒法飆高音在大陸某些樂迷心目中確實就是平淡無奇的小品，而不是大戲
@@lorenzoxiong2611 他有非常多厲害的轉音和氣音以及顫音技巧，並且又將情感融入的非常恰到好處，我學過聲樂，有一定程度以上的歌唱能力，但我在ktv幾乎不點他的歌，因為都好難唱🤣🤣尤其是他那口氣和技巧都兼具的能力，太難了_(:_」∠)_
@@minkye9883 他意思應該想表達沒有很造作，炫技的意思，只是用詞不當😂
Eason 的這種真誠和情感真的是與生俱來，他就是一個很真誠的人，會因為一些小事而被逗得哈哈大笑，亦會因為聲帶出問題無法給觀眾一個好的表演而落淚，今年fnd《相信你的人》《任我行》《最佳損友》《K歌之王》他都唱哭過自己，正因為這樣他能把最真實的情感投進歌曲裏。慶幸樂壇能有這個歌手。
The pianist is the composer of this two songs. His name is Terence Lam. He is also one of the most talented musician and singer-songwriter in Hong Kong lately. Hope to hear the review of him by Rozette soon.
Agree!
敲碗評某種老朋友和喃嘸師感官漫遊🙏🏾😊
he is talented musician but not a great vocalist
Yeap. Nothing much to review vocally.
林生唱歌似諗經多D,吾好玩啦
普通人都知EASON犀利，但由咁專業既老師分析都係有讚無彈，我對EASON既崇拜感覺上又再高一個層次，
老師唔識廣東話都聽到流淚..真係不得了
之前都是負評吔、因為她亦不懂広東語、說Eason唱push and pull、唱法dated🙂↕️⋯⋯現在她知人家有多受歡迎、多有感染力、所以改口:)
陳奕迅唱歌就是這麼有感染力
老師聽陳奕迅的歌
都會很享受他的歌 近乎忘記講解
我想這就是對E神最崇高的評價
冇得彈
大道至簡，反璞歸真，見山仍是山。
雖然Eason Hit歌無數，但最喜歡的仍然是冷門歌 "不如不見" 粵語版 粵語版 粵語版
重要的事要講三次，不是普通話版 "好久不見"
不能認同更多，有時寧願自己聽唔明不如不見，至於好久不見真係差左幾個層次
2首歌都是鋼琴手作的！他都是歌手！林家謙！我最愛的男歌手之一
原來兩個係校友，都是st jo 仔
很久才一次Eason ,還要等那麼久😢
仲未等到軒仔 🥹
@@theodoresiu266😮💨都唔知要等几耐。
了解歌词後才可完全體現eason的味道，對歌的诠释，
是但（随便）•求其（不认真）爱
是（肯定）•但求（不动摇）•其爱 （这份爱）
一語双义的歧义句，歌名太棒了
但求（只求與自己所願）
小克的詞，從來都很精彩
Both songs are composed by Terence Lam 林家謙 who is the pianist in this performance. He is a talented musician, songwriter and singer in Hong Kong. Wish we can see your review on him soon. Thank you !
即便聽影片裡的無配樂版本，依然被Eason的聲音所感動❤
Eason本身就是一個真誠的人，所以可以將一首歌的情緒藉由他的演繹唱入聽者的心。他不特別炫技，因為他實力雄厚的唱功讓他唱歌的時候看起來游刃有餘。當聽者已經沉靜在歌裡就無需強調技巧。
他跟燕姿一樣，音色太強了，基本不可能被複製，強到不需要太多奪耳的技巧去修飾也能打動絕大多數的華語聽眾。
Eason說故事的技巧是廣東歌曲最頂尖的其中一，是但求其愛最難就是第一段近乎清唱的感情演繹
老師可賞析一下張國榮嗎？
第一次見老師對歌手的表演有如此反應，周森同JJ再強也只是讓老師讚口不絕，Eason果然唔簡單。🥲
jj 咁油膩 淨係審美已經同eason冇得比
一呼一吸盡是感情
但jj還是老師最愛。老師唯一一首加進自己歌單的就是願與愁，jj自己譜的曲
@@user-ir2uj2lr5b但jj就是老師最愛，更多華人聽嘅歌手，藝術性更上一層樓
這老師根本不喜歡広東歌好嗎？！看她以前的、處處嫌棄吔
Eason唱歌真是一個境界
極喜愛的兩首歌，各方面都無可挑剔的佳作。只希望以後還能繼續有這個水準的廣東話歌。
琴手是林家謙！“是但求其愛”
“至明日的舞”作曲人
林家謙是香港一位出色獨立唱作歌手音樂人
不過終於有專業人士講佢和音有時有啲怪😂佢係原作我呢啲一般人真係唔敢講啲咩😂
如果老師聽到林家謙唱歌會有咩comment 😂
@@chanchu6048 好想睇😂😂
@@iiiiishida 佢有講的，家謙用左高8度和左果幾句，不過你細心啲聽話會發現其實佢唔係句句都咁樣和，係精心安排的，不過鐘唔鐘意就各人不同啦
如果林家謙唱，就去唔到個意境
Eason是一個超越語言，音域，環境都可以令人安心欣賞嘅一個歌手❤❤❤。我相信我未來依然會期待他的每一個live.
I want to introduce Terence Lam (the pianist) for Rozette too. He is the songwriter of these songs and a popular singer in Hong Kong, very talented.
中文名字是？
林家謙
@@captaincool197 th-cam.com/video/_WatP6yaH50/w-d-xo.htmlsi=Pyh_cIxgLVFq5EF4
Yes! He is very talented!
好期待！希望多re陈奕迅最新的fear and dreams现场作品，真的非常好👍
認同，Eason這次Fear and Dreams的歌包括encore唱的都帶給我們很多驚喜，很想讓老師一起欣賞
就算不懂歌詞，只要是Eason都能感動我們❤真感謝他，給了我們純粹的歌聲❤
感動到老師，果然是我最愛eason
❤❤Eason的感情表達真的很好，老師幾次都深深感受到❤
陳奕迅，我一生的偶像🥰
祝願您健健康康、開開心心，一切順順利利、完完滿滿😘
希望臣臣會再返香港、澳門、臺灣開多幾廿場FnDs，我一定會搶飛捧場😝
EASON的歌真的很容易讓人落淚🥲
真摯的感情及歌聲，直接唱進心坎裡😢
演唱會真的看幾場哭幾場，如果有機會希望大家都能現場聽聽看😭
聽Eason碟同live係2樣野嚟，佢好多歌live係好聽好多
現場聽他唱［我們］
直接原地升天😢
@@darren9493 agree！
@@user-qs8yh1iy2v 真的......還有我們萬歲，我看幾場哭幾場(超喜歡的歌)
Eason就算用學校講台的麥克風都可以唱的很好聽❤❤
Eason's singing is touching because he is a genuinely nice person-gentle, humorous, sincere, and emotionally delicate. His voice embodies his personality. He can handle songs of various styles. I love his reggae, funk, and jazz performances. I also enjoy watching him dance😊❤
Eason sings into your heart… love him
"Not flawless but it was just right". "Pitch deviation becomes part of the magic". Humanness and the art is indeed what is most important. Thank you Rozette for the lovely review of Eason's performance. Eason's gift of a storyteller voice is so precious.
The pianist in the video is the composer of both songs, he actually ask Eason to change the way of singing that he is used to. Less vibrato and dynamics etc. to sound more modern he said😂and eason love it. These are what you can feel from the original video
The Pianist is also an well-known singer-songwriter in Hong Kong. His name is Terence Lam. The 2 songs performing from this video “Love Perhaps” and “a Dance for Tomorrow”are 2 songs composed by him and he also co-produced these 2 songs and also the rest of Eason’s latest album.
Also I would like to share Terence’s solo song with Rozette : th-cam.com/video/5L23Xvtblu8/w-d-xo.htmlsi=ICCa_RbZCf4dEDuV
I am just very curious how would Rozette comment on his vocal as he is very popular in Hong Kong now but still quite controversial on his voice 😂
陳奕迅是一位前無古人後無來者的歌手
絕對好到爆炸❤
超期待😊
這集在準備的時候我就先開提醒了
太期待這集了😍😍
好期待！
Love him so muchhhhhhhhhhhhhh
It's the vulnerable, fragile, uncanniness and frank in his voice. I'm touched by Eason, that's his weapon, not his top top skills, but his delicacy. Yet he can be wild, ferocious, vicious, resilent and powerful! You are in a rollercoaster ride in his songs which no one can take you. My eyes are wet.....
2 hours left to watch my favorite singer 😚😚😚
So glad to hearing you can finally enjoy the music and appreciate the imperfections in it~yeah~
Eason is a treasure to me, I really really enjoy this video and your TH-cam channel.❤
OMG...first time seeing 老师 cries and i cried for Eason's performances so many time too. It is so truth he became the top one singer of my favorite. And our happiness that he have given us so many great song. I love him and you guys! Thanks for sharing. ❤❤
The handsome Pianist is the composer of the songs and he is a singer-songwriter who has quite a unique (which is a bit controversial among the mass) style of singing. Hope to see review on him soon :)
I just want to say thank you to this channel. My family immigrated to Canada when I was six years old. I’ve always found myself in an in-between, unidentifiable culture limbo. Thank you Rozette for having such an open mind, proving that music is truly a language without borders.
Edit: stupid autocorrect!
第一首太好聽了，Eason的歌只能是Eason唱❤
超喜歡這個live版本❤
之前聽過一些評論，Eason這唱法就是減掉法，首先要有一定嘅唱功再拋開技巧完全投入唱出感情傳遞出去，這是很難的，因為大多歌手會著重唱歌時高音甜中音準低音沉轉音要夠勁，聽過其他歌手也學習緊Eason這種唱法
Eason的歌永遠可以入人心.love him !
哇，期待💘
eason so far is the best canton pop singer imo❤❤❤
One of the best singers in the world I would say.
我太爱陈顺了 太爱太爱太爱了 从他小时候就这样了 无比真诚地歌唱
他是我心中的歌神
Thank you Rozette!
Thank you Eason!
鋼琴手是林家謙 最香港目前最強唱作人
大家都讚嘆eason的高音假音， 但是我最愛他的中低音。 very passionate and sexy
沒錯 好迷人又好性感的音線
Eason 真係好有感情去唱每首歌！
片尾老師那段近乎清唱好屌
OMG! The best Eason is " it is not flawless but exactly right" That is why I love him so much! Whether you understand what he sang, you always feel the emotion of his performances. Glad the Teacher indicates the importance of humanness when an artist is performing, especially in this era when all can be edited.
The pianist is also the writer of the songs and he is also a singer himself, very talented as well, hope you guys check his video sometimes too
Eason always delivers his song truthfully.
By the way the one on piano, Terrence Lam is also a singer, he composes these songs. I’d say he’s better composer than being a singer. Terrence Lam won a lot of rewards in the past few years
Love the chat about hook difference! Love the song seasick as a mandarin speaker!
Music indeed speaks itself! Rozette could tell it's a uplifting song without knowing a word that was sang. Also, if I remember correctly, this performance was livestreamed. I waited 2 months for this review, worth the wait!! Please consider reviewing some of his more lively and recent performance, there's plenty of such videos from his Fear and Dreams Concert, I'd recommend 馬里奧派對 and 愛是懷疑
老师衣服超美滴
我也哭了，刚看视频太认真。手里刚吃一口不小心掉地上的汉堡让我落泪，
之前就有專業的錄音師說他把唱功分為3層，第三層是駕馭節奏和音準，唱的失去一點音準，但是是為了感情這麼做的，而陳奕迅就是這種....和老師的感受有對應上了，果然專業的看的都一樣，就不知道為什麼還老是有人說Eason唱功不好~~
因为Eason的技术都是为了表达服务，而不是闭着眼睛炫技
遙遠的她 live必聽
補充說明一下，這個錄音師說唱功分為3層，第一層是說音準和節奏，第二層再來說感情，我覺得錄CD會要求音準，所以一般Eason錄CD會拿出第二層的實力，但是Live的話Eason就會拿出第三層的實力，失去一點音準是為了感情而去做，正好對應該老師在12:30說的一些走音, 反而會成就這種氛圍，最後就會出現大家說的Eason的live比CD好聽，代價就是失去一點音準~~~所以不要再說Eason沒音準了，連這個錄音師都說他錄過Eason一遍過，連一個音都不用修。
Eason 8級聲樂😂應該無人會話佢唔識唱歌
吓？Eason 都話唱功唔好？我覺得咁多年來，都無一個歌手有佢唱得咁好咁投喎，張學友當然唱功好好，但唔自然，常常賣弄技巧，Eason就好自然享受唱歌，呢點無乜歌手做到
好喜歡eason❤
厉害的歌手唱的是歌 更厉害的歌手唱的是灵魂
Love eason
是但求其愛的廣東話歌詞，如何翻譯😂😂😂不是懂的廣東話的，這個是根本接近瘋狂！
Chase that love causally or simply just to love😂
@@meis2720😂😂其他呢一句兩、三個意思
歌詞不了🥲
給老師聽聽最近那次浮誇現場🤗
FYI, Eason係英國皇家音樂學院八級聲樂（業餘最高級)
有考試已經唔係業餘 係專業了
唔係想撥你冷水
不過ABRSM 8級通街都係
求心的距離🥹
😂零距離，超誇張
期待eason❤
Eason 成功把老师唱哭了！太厉害
期待Eason❤
我們光聽Eason的聲音，已經想哭，真的很打動人心啊🥺
The pianist is actually the composer of the both songs!!
Just wanna say that the people watching in front of the vdo including u guys or me and who works or loves music, or just audience. Anytime we give our heart out to listen, we must get thought and learn something from a attentive performance. The connection of human to human through music. LOVE is the greatest thing we should keep keeping.
In fact, I cried when I heard the first song in my very first time. Too much emotions. It's still resonates, regardless of how many times of looping this.
突然想起“愛是懷疑”， 好想看老師的reaction !
Love Eason Love Rozette😊🥰😘😘😘
新城頒獎典禮版的六月飛霜，我覺得都好值得去睇吓
我喜歡大氣音樂會的版本🥰
我也提議過 希望有看到
是真正頂流 thanks for making us proud Eason.
我最愛的歌手Eason❤
心的距離
年紀越成熟越愛Eason
他的歌不挑情緒
什麼狀態下聽都能一下就進入到他想傳達的感情
learn Cantonese, you will understand how beautiful this language is 😊
感染王不是浪得虛名😂
這個慈善音樂會也很好看，有點像Busking
從清晨開始唱，唱到日出
香港真係好靚🥹
th-cam.com/users/live9KBBYv5neMk?si=VXhEDYUSgXhisCAb
He is a great stroy teller, his can use the perfect tone and match with the song.
聽Eason 第二首歌 看著他唱歌 好開心的樣子（我聽不懂，但真好聽
Terence Lam is the pianist, also the song writer of both songs. Actually, the songs of the whole album are written by Terence. He is also a singer himself, he is years of awardee of singer writer in Hong Kong. You guys may look him up.
The pianist is Terence Lam林家謙, hope to see the review on his performance, maybe 某種老朋友 live in summer blues concert.