Download Dashlane for free on your first device by clicking here bit.ly/34v3hwG and automatically get a 30 day free trial of premium! No credit card required at signup!
This is too true. I first heard Hala Hala several months ago and it was instant love. The only other groups that have done that for me at first listen were BTS and Mamamoo haha.
Since they're debut, Ateez have this aura that give us the impression they will become something really really big. An halo none of the other rookie have and what's the most incredible is that it give this sensation to most of the people who listen them
@@tyddlup same. since the debut I was so amazed by them. only exo made me feel like this before. idk how to explain but as pd said, ateez is gonna be legendary
@@toumi7484 EXACTLY. EXO was the only group that made me feel like this. I have so much passion and admiration for ateez, I can't even describe how proud I am of them. They're gonna be *BIG*
Oh my you're speaking right out of my soul, love it!! ~😘 I'm always talking about a 'proud mum' thingy when I people praise them, especially about their passion, hard work and transparent personality😇
I'm not even mad they didn't get ROTY, tbh, I'm sure Korea was just like “lmfao why is a *senior* group doing at the rookies category?!?! ksksks y'all craycray”
They still can get roty in SMA since they choose 2 or 3 winners!🥺EDIT: we didn't :') but we have one more chance that I think is physical award! Here: www.topmusicuniverseawards.com/2019/03/top-music-universe-awards-19.html?m=1 please I hope I can comment again with a win 😖🙏
Why are people still liking my comment it makes me remind we didn't give them the roty 😭 But let's give them this one that I think they give a physical award 🥺🤞www.topmusicuniverseawards.com/2019/03/top-music-universe-awards-19.html?m=1
What ATEEZ has, and I can only judge from watching their live stages, besides performance, vocals and rap, is they have an incredible stage presence. It’s been said before but they are like a long established experienced group and not rookies.
*"it's like this trembling sense of being in the edge of greatness..."* I could never have said it better PD. ATEEZ IS GONNA BE THE NEXT ATEEZ. They have this collective sense of who they are as a group music-wise and personality-wise, and they aren't afraid to take risks. They know each other strengths and they use it well to make the team stronger.
There’s a K-pop review blog called The Bias List, and the guy that runs the blog said about them, “At this point, it feels that ATEEZ’s only limitation is their own ambition. And judging by the past year, ambition doesn’t seem to be a problem.” And I think that’s a great way to put it. I can’t wait to see what they’re going to accomplish next.
If feels like wonderland was the climax of the story and answer is the conclusion. I don’t think any of us understand the story but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t a wonderful journey!!ATEEZ are a group to be reckoned with on the stage and I can’t wait to see them grow even more in terms of performance and popularity. I’m so proud to be an atiny!! ❤️
The story hasnt ended. Yeosang hinted there's more at the last fansign. He said Enemy > Enemy X So the darkateez are not bad.... Also, San's tear drop make up on the comeback stage means something but the meaning will be revealed next comeback. (Also said at las fansign)
Not the end, one more to go Each album title relates to each other, the last word of each album is the first in next one So the conclusion should be called Answer to All
Vanessa R L even tho people started noticing Ateez mostly from pirate king Even my brother who doesn’t like kpop AT ALL and it shows how good that gem is
@@nimolino139 YES I knew about them with that song I remember seeing everyone telling to watch Pirate King and a lot of reactions meanwhile Treasure wasn't THAT appreciated
also because there are more vocal layers (there are harmonies almost through out the whole song) rather than the different instruments/synths usually found in their other songs
ATEEZ are truly the face of 4th Generation Kpop BGs, they bring an entirely different feel from anything you got from second, or third generation. These boys put on a show like no one else, not a single other BG matches their energy on the stage, and frankly, I am living for it.
fun fact : this song starts with the end of Beginning of the End on their last album ;) Also they have the full version of Precious on their new album :) The song on their that I like the most is Horizon for sure
This music video is ART! I really like Hongjoong's clock scene and Yeosang desert scene! Also it's not a repackage! It's a new mini album! The end of the Treasure series!
@@shdwfax1024 ? I don't get your point? Your sentence doesn't make sence! I know he had met them.. I'm asking if he is going to the concert tha is Coming...
It hit me so hard when he said (they're gonna be memorable, they're gonna be legendary.) that i'm honestly tearing up. Being an Atiny for so long now almost since debut, i always knew it in my heart that their future is way more than bright. It's so rare when kpop artists get me so inlove with them and so emotionally connected to them, but ateez did, and since the very first day when i found them. They are the future, they are history. Just thought i would leave this comment here as a proof for when this actually comes true a while later. The world needs to stan ateez.
I really love their storyline and how their whole music is connected! I don't know if you noticed but the first part and the chorus of "Answer" was the whole "Beggining of the End" instrumental track in their last album! San even sang his part at the end! Also it's not a repackage, I will love to see a listening party!
Answer will forever be my top song from ateez. The vocals, instrumental, harmonies…it has them all. And the lyrics are so melancholic I tear up a little every time; ;
I WAS WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION!!!! This comeback just proves how they are super versatile and how they step up their standards so fast. They're AMAZING.
I hope you will do a listening party for 'TREASURE EPILOGUE: Action to Answer'! It does have two amazing songs that I think you will like (Horizon and Precious)!
This song for me especially makes me super emotional, so I'm glad you pointed that out. The song itself just sounds like a testament to and a retelling of their entire journey so far, both in carreer and in their concept storyline. In the lyrics, there's a lot of callbacks to previous title tracks almost in chronological order. Hongjoong mentions the desert that they started in, as shown in Treasure and Pirate King. Mingi then says Say My Name, which is obvious. Seonghwa and Yunho mention "the wave", which is obviously for Wave and Illusion. I don't know, I just feel like crying everytime I hear it. It just feels like one of those songs to cry in pride over, similar to Mikrokosmos by BTS. God, I just love Ateez.
I love how the endings of each song (like previews) pertain to another song or a sneak peek to their future song. For example the ending to this song goes with Ateez’s section 1
So I had this feeling that they'll become not even big but legendary indeed, since I saw them at the first time! Thanks for mentioning this, PD! Expecting them to take over the world soon!
I fell in love with Ateez from answer..I accidentally watch Answer MV ads on TH-cam ..I was gonna skip it and then I saw San on the table ..so here I am now ATINYYY
This song was what made me an Atiny, so this is a really special song. I will keep coming bafk to it iver and o er again. This song really solidified my love for these men.
8:54 and 13:14 Yeees I love that so much! It makes you LISTEN to the song without making you feel like it's too much loaded, just enjoying the ride slowly and be intrigued curious and dynamic and FREE. And those feelings applies not only to the music but their mvs, choreography and overall vibes, just like your friends welcoming you and being with them on a journey always together and free, with Ateez NEVER feels shallow never! That's why they are pirates! 👀 (You can tell they are a scorpio watery group, the emotions and passion! they make you feel too never industrial or shallow again :') )
I just realized the set with the dinning table could be a room next to the say my name room. Like a museum of sorts. I kinda see both scenes happening side by side.
thanks for reacting to this! i always enjoy watching your reactions to ATEEZ. quick thing: this isn't a repackage, it's a new mini album - all new songs! :D (and one full version of an interlude from their previous album.)
I agree with PD so much about wonderland feeling like it’s supposed to build up to something but Answer just in your face powerful from the start with that amazing chorus that’s super catchy and emotional. Just amps me up but also makes me feel sad even though the lyrics is all about positivity
This by far, has to be their best title track yet! I’m so happy to see my boys only being known as KQ fellaz from their dancing to just being THAT amazingly talented rookie group among many other groups.
*it's actually incredibly insane how ateez, each and every comebacks, they still continue to impress me. every freaking time, i swear to god. they became one of my ult, because i can't help it but fell in love with their work. they just embrace and create exactly the type of music i'm into, and i love it.*
things I noticed! The first line says something like: „Cheers. Come down like a thunder and watch it run out“ I‘m not sure tho. My mothertongue is German😅. Anyway, you can see San smashing his hand down from above -> like a thunder and after you can witness his hand shaking symbolising the draining drink from their glasses - In the snow part with Wooyoung you can see the snow going up and not down. Maybe that‘s a callback to „Say my Name“ given the appearance of the Suicide Squad from „Say my name“ and the fits from „Hala Hala“ - Have you noticed Yeosang standing in the Desert with line „this is where it all started“ that clearly a callback to „Pirate King“ and „Treasure“ (MV‘s) - Butterfly‘s stand for rebirth. Maybe that’s linked to the men dressed in white and the snow rising instead of falling in Wooyoung‘s solo dance scene. - that‘s some of what I managed to notice! Have fun and love you Atinys and Ateez!
Surprised you didn’t mention the connection between this, say my name and HALA HALA lol. I really like how you delved deep into the set and production.
That set at 10:44 is a clock. This video does a lot relating to time. I especially love how they’re sitting across from their past selves and toasting. This is such an epic song and video.👏👏👏👏
I agree with you.. I'm not a stan, I barely know the members, I haven't listened to their albums but from what I've seen so far, ateez have the potential to be big. with every cb they do, they are attracting & gaining more fans. I feel like once the 3rd gen groups hype slows down, ateez will be one of the top groups.
I like your analysis on ATEEZ music... honestly ATEEZ and their entire team have had the entire treasure series planned since debut if you listen to some of their songs you can hear them repeat sounds from their intros and other songs every song is linked one way or another they are super amazing
Thanks for doing a Kulture Study on ATEEZ. Loved all you had to say about them, and I especially agree about that feeling of listening to legends in progress.
It's so refreshing to see people affirming that ATEEZ is going to be big. Thanks for your Kulture Study video. I always find it super awesome to hear people's perspectives on not just the music but also the MV. You're 1000% right, they have a big future ahead of them!
Ateez is slowly taking their time in building their career. I’m confident to say that they’ll be hella popular very soon. Don’t sleep on such great talent, sleep on your bed, dummy. Stan ateez, you won’t regret it. Becoming an atiny is literally Free, no tax included either. You won’t regret it. ❤️
I don't know what it exactly is about ATEEZ, maybe the iconic, anthemic, unique songs they produce, but I see them being as iconic as BIG BANG even though they're still rookies. As in they're beginning to create a wave that will make them game changers in the kpop industry, more so than they already are.
Swear all of ateez's song are way ahead of their time. If their popularity is as big as bts or blackpink all their songs will be a big hit and you will always hear in the streets as worthy as they should
Thank you so much for the reaction! I love hearing about the more technical sides of ateezs work and you address it so neatly and it’s easy to understand and follow. They do have new songs on this album, hope you enjoy! Answer tops wonderland for me too. The emotional aspect of it is so powerful and you captured the feeling of the song exactly - “the feeling of standing on the edge of greatness” that’s exactly how it is! The lyrics are so meaningful too - the callback to SMN (bulleo bulleo), yeosangs part acknowledging them starting in the desert as a callback to Treasure, the reference to illusion/wave(the burning sun/the crashing wave), and the line San starts the mv with was hinted at in their last album All To Action! The lyrics were so pretty and really conveyed that feeling of finishing a long journey and asking the world to see them and notice them. ateez is HERE and they’re loud and proud and powerful! Loved this reaction, thank you for always supporting ateez!
SOOOOO happy to see someone else really love this song, I feel that so many atiny wanted to throw them down and say they didn't like it even though it was way better than wonderland.... love the reaction, new subscriber
PD thank you! I was waiting for your reaction, it always makes me happy to watch you acknowledging ateez and appreciating their music and team. I hope in the future you can give us a listening party of action to answer because yes it has 3 new songs and 1 intro.
REAL RECOGNIZE REAL always appreciate your reviews on ateez!! they deserve so much credit and recognition for their hard work + creativity, especially in their performances.
Download Dashlane for free on your first device by clicking here bit.ly/34v3hwG and automatically get a 30 day free trial of premium! No credit card required at signup!
Been waiting for your reaction to Psycho by red velvet
Reaction to Red Velvet Psycho please
Please react to SUPER JUNIOR - 2YA2YAO,
"They're not just gonna be big, they're gonna be memorable, they're gonna be legendary" PD, 2020
This is too true. I first heard Hala Hala several months ago and it was instant love. The only other groups that have done that for me at first listen were BTS and Mamamoo haha.
Since they're debut, Ateez have this aura that give us the impression they will become something really really big. An halo none of the other rookie have and what's the most incredible is that it give this sensation to most of the people who listen them
@@tyddlup same. since the debut I was so amazed by them. only exo made me feel like this before. idk how to explain but as pd said, ateez is gonna be legendary
@@toumi7484 EXACTLY.
EXO was the only group that made me feel like this. I have so much passion and admiration for ateez, I can't even describe how proud I am of them. They're gonna be *BIG*
"Trembling sense of being on the edge of Greatness" I felt that and have never agreed more with someone in my life.
last time i was this early, chen was still single
Izhdkkk I'M DYING
@@hellonice8331 and unmarried....and without a child...
Good one! Probably the first such comment anywhere.
😂😂😂
😂😂😂
As an ATINY I get a sense of pride when people give my boys acknowledge and see their greatness! ATEEZ have it all.... Thank you for a great video!
IamSweetCharlotte same❤️😭
Oh my you're speaking right out of my soul, love it!! ~😘
I'm always talking about a 'proud mum' thingy when I people praise them, especially about their passion, hard work and transparent personality😇
Same and this is the same feeling i got when i started stanning bts in 2014 and they started gaining recognition in 2015 😭😭😭
yESSSSS 💟💗💟💗💟💗💟
Its funny how I'm younger than them yet feel like a mom when people appreciate their videos u know haha
I'm not even mad they didn't get ROTY, tbh, I'm sure Korea was just like “lmfao why is a *senior* group doing at the rookies category?!?! ksksks y'all craycray”
They still can get roty in SMA since they choose 2 or 3 winners!🥺EDIT: we didn't :') but we have one more chance that I think is physical award! Here: www.topmusicuniverseawards.com/2019/03/top-music-universe-awards-19.html?m=1 please I hope I can comment again with a win 😖🙏
@@vanessarl8 thanks for the information!
@@kireekire You're welcome
Perhaps I cackled
Why are people still liking my comment it makes me remind we didn't give them the roty 😭 But let's give them this one that I think they give a physical award 🥺🤞www.topmusicuniverseawards.com/2019/03/top-music-universe-awards-19.html?m=1
Answer is not a repackage!!!
It's an epiloge of the treasure series for sure. But it's a full comeback with a full mini album with new songs
What ATEEZ has, and I can only judge from watching their live stages, besides performance, vocals and rap, is they have an incredible stage presence. It’s been said before but they are like a long established experienced group and not rookies.
Hanguchiku no, they are very much rookies, they just perform like they have more experience, imo.
YESSS JUST how I LIKED ITTTTT PD BEING SPEECHLESS FOR THE WHOLE MV, I SWEAR THIS SONG IS EVEN STRONGER THAN THE OTHER TITLES IM STILL NOT OVER IT
IM STILL NOT OVER PIRATE KING YALL
@welcome new user IMODUTACHEWOOOOO u u uuuuu TAEWODUSHIIII u u uuuu
(accurate romanised)
@@kari-fh9vl yall I'm still jamming like a demon to Treasure I'm not even SORRYYYYY
@@emems6620 TREASURE IS A BIG BOP
I AGREE WITH EVERYTHING HERE
me: *see’s PD post an ateez reaction*
also me: *throws everything away from me while aggressively clicking on the video*
Me too PD reaction is just too cool and actually analyze and appreciate more than visuals
Me too
Song Joanne agreed, that’s why he’s my favourite reactor
*"it's like this trembling sense of being in the edge of greatness..."*
I could never have said it better PD. ATEEZ IS GONNA BE THE NEXT ATEEZ. They have this collective sense of who they are as a group music-wise and personality-wise, and they aren't afraid to take risks. They know each other strengths and they use it well to make the team stronger.
There’s a K-pop review blog called The Bias List, and the guy that runs the blog said about them, “At this point, it feels that ATEEZ’s only limitation is their own ambition. And judging by the past year, ambition doesn’t seem to be a problem.” And I think that’s a great way to put it. I can’t wait to see what they’re going to accomplish next.
This March this is coming more true than ever
Ateez has a devil line.
A DEVIL LINE.
This group is something else.
evapinkunicorn honestly tho man.
bro that was accurate
What devil line, did you mean the whole group? 😂
A devil line? You mean the whole ATEEZ? 😂
I know all of Ateez are devils, but especially San, Seonghwa and Hongjoong
never clicked this fast in my life i swear
SAME OMG-
lmao thats me
Same lol
SAME
JJAJJSJS
If feels like wonderland was the climax of the story and answer is the conclusion. I don’t think any of us understand the story but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t a wonderful journey!!ATEEZ are a group to be reckoned with on the stage and I can’t wait to see them grow even more in terms of performance and popularity. I’m so proud to be an atiny!! ❤️
Natalie Lowery I know the story and main theories (-: I can send u videos if I want to help out with that
@@honeymelon_b I think they meant that those are 'just' theories, none of us KNOW, we're just guessing with diff interpretations :)
The story hasnt ended. Yeosang hinted there's more at the last fansign. He said
Enemy > Enemy X
So the darkateez are not bad....
Also, San's tear drop make up on the comeback stage means something but the meaning will be revealed next comeback. (Also said at las fansign)
Serenity F. That’s why I said theories 😬
Not the end, one more to go
Each album title relates to each other, the last word of each album is the first in next one
So the conclusion should be called Answer to All
ive never seen rookie as powerful as ateez, they're really gonna take over the world huh
Yep
No like why are they SO good, my mind doesn't work anymore listening to them cause it's just good music after good music.
Remember Pirate King was also their debut song not only Treasure uwu
Vanessa R L even tho people started noticing Ateez mostly from pirate king
Even my brother who doesn’t like kpop AT ALL and it shows how good that gem is
@@nimolino139 YES I knew about them with that song I remember seeing everyone telling to watch Pirate King and a lot of reactions meanwhile Treasure wasn't THAT appreciated
Vanessa R L treasure deserves the spotlight tho so..👀
@@egghead168 Yes ofc Treasure is one of my queens
Treasure is such a queen 🥺🥺
And pirate king is a...kiNg :D
I think that the more emotional sound comes from it being kind of like the end of a chapter of the ateez universe..
end of the treasure era :)
A new series on their next comeback. More puzzles and confusions to come when i haven’t even learned their whole treasure discography yet 😪😅
also because there are more vocal layers (there are harmonies almost through out the whole song) rather than the different instruments/synths usually found in their other songs
i want to see their reaction to precious and horizon,,,
Horizon is gonna blow his mind
Me too especially Horizon!
Nathalia Rodriguez Just a reminder, PD uses they/them pronouns
PD said it will come, but they have a big list to react first
hoeseok 100%!
I like how 4 years later you can see that PD was 1000% correct about Ateez. They are going to Coachella, and they continue to top each comeback.
ATEEZ are truly the face of 4th Generation Kpop BGs, they bring an entirely different feel from anything you got from second, or third generation.
These boys put on a show like no one else, not a single other BG matches their energy on the stage, and frankly, I am living for it.
Lmfao
@@sascha_w what is funny?
Yea what funny they truly are the face of 4th gen
Martix x lmao you’re funny :/💀😒
I dont want to compare them but I'm just gonna say that my style matches totally Ateez and I do think they are the best out there
this song is one of the most satisfying ive ever had the pleasure of listening to 😩
pd: "they really outdid themselves with the choreo"
me: *wait until you see yunho's part in horizon*
I was so shocked and in awe for yunho's part in horizon I replayed it like so many times I can't keep count.
omg...im scared what hAPPENS
Nobody:
The auto-generated subs: “go tell your daddy”
Idk what I‘m doing here “gonbae haja like a San-der, go tell your daddy ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
fun fact : this song starts with the end of Beginning of the End on their last album ;) Also they have the full version of Precious on their new album :) The song on their that I like the most is Horizon for sure
Ateez has improved with every single comeback they've released so far-- they never disappoint!
This music video is ART!
I really like Hongjoong's clock scene and Yeosang desert scene!
Also it's not a repackage! It's a new mini album! The end of the Treasure series!
Yes very nice Monsta x had it to💝👍🏻
@@garfieldshiela7433 Theirs was different
Of cours not relly the same but same idea 😅😉
PD! THEY JUST ANNOUNCED THAT THEY ARE REALISING ADDITIONAL TICKETS FOR THE ATEEZ TOUR SINCE IT WAS ALL SOLD OUT! ARE YOU GONNA GO??
Really it sold out... fans are so lucky..... For an Indian with no salary it's hard to see our idols.
@@Jungkookwifebuthedontknow ya... I hope ateez acknowledges desitinys and have a concert in india too...
Pd doesnt just go, he met them too.
@@shdwfax1024 ? I don't get your point? Your sentence doesn't make sence! I know he had met them.. I'm asking if he is going to the concert tha is Coming...
@@shravberri You mean Atinys?
It hit me so hard when he said (they're gonna be memorable, they're gonna be legendary.) that i'm honestly tearing up.
Being an Atiny for so long now almost since debut, i always knew it in my heart that their future is way more than bright.
It's so rare when kpop artists get me so inlove with them and so emotionally connected to them, but ateez did, and since the very first day when i found them.
They are the future, they are history.
Just thought i would leave this comment here as a proof for when this actually comes true a while later.
The world needs to stan ateez.
Qq Ww I’m a baby atiny but I still teared up. I guess I’m just overly emotional lol. I’m so glad I stanned them tho, I was really missing out
I really love their storyline and how their whole music is connected!
I don't know if you noticed but the first part and the chorus of "Answer" was the whole "Beggining of the End" instrumental track in their last album! San even sang his part at the end!
Also it's not a repackage, I will love to see a listening party!
The two dislikes on this are from San's bones after almost being broken from all his dope ass dance moves.
bold of you to assume san even has bones
seulgibble goshdammit you’re right
19 minutes??? PD loves Ateez😂❤️
Only 1 year in the industry and they’re already the kings so imagine in a few years... Just like PD said they’re gonna be legendary
PD: I like Answer
Theories: Are we joke to you?
3:05 you can see the “oh shit... this is gonna be good!”
The set may not be expensive, but the boys sure are
Answer will forever be my top song from ateez. The vocals, instrumental, harmonies…it has them all. And the lyrics are so melancholic I tear up a little every time; ;
I WAS WAITING FOR YOUR REACTION!!!! This comeback just proves how they are super versatile and how they step up their standards so fast. They're AMAZING.
Just expect a shocked PD in the thumbnail everytime he reacts to ATEEZ😄
This is so unapologetically LEEZ. How does he do it across genres, across groups? Great song, holy...
I hope you will do a listening party for 'TREASURE EPILOGUE: Action to Answer'! It does have two amazing songs that I think you will like (Horizon and Precious)!
And Star 1117!
YES YES YESSSS
This song for me especially makes me super emotional, so I'm glad you pointed that out. The song itself just sounds like a testament to and a retelling of their entire journey so far, both in carreer and in their concept storyline. In the lyrics, there's a lot of callbacks to previous title tracks almost in chronological order. Hongjoong mentions the desert that they started in, as shown in Treasure and Pirate King. Mingi then says Say My Name, which is obvious. Seonghwa and Yunho mention "the wave", which is obviously for Wave and Illusion.
I don't know, I just feel like crying everytime I hear it. It just feels like one of those songs to cry in pride over, similar to Mikrokosmos by BTS. God, I just love Ateez.
I love how the endings of each song (like previews) pertain to another song or a sneak peek to their future song. For example the ending to this song goes with Ateez’s section 1
Ateez World Domination
Ben is here too 😂😂😂😂
So I had this feeling that they'll become not even big but legendary indeed, since I saw them at the first time! Thanks for mentioning this, PD!
Expecting them to take over the world soon!
Please have a listening party for ep: epilogue
This is actually a title track of a new album. "Answer to Action" 🙏🏻 But good reaction
its actually "treasure epilogue: action to answer"
I'm ready for a listening party !
Answer and Horizon came from heaven.
ATEEZ The Promised Kings of 4th generation bgroup, no one is even close PERIODT
This not a repackage, this is a mini album ! We NEED a listening party, all the songs are bops.
I fell in love with Ateez from answer..I accidentally watch Answer MV ads on TH-cam ..I was gonna skip it and then I saw San on the table ..so here I am now
ATINYYY
Say My Name was my number 1 KPOP song for 2019 and obviously favourite ATEEZ song..... And then this just whizzed past saying HIIIIIIIIII
This song was what made me an Atiny, so this is a really special song. I will keep coming bafk to it iver and o er again. This song really solidified my love for these men.
i'm not even kidding but i CRIED when i first listened to this song
literally SAME
this was the song that made me love ateez i wanna stan they are SO TALENTED
YeS
I recommend checking out their comeback stage on M Countdown for Horizon (another album track)
8:54 and 13:14 Yeees I love that so much! It makes you LISTEN to the song without making you feel like it's too much loaded, just enjoying the ride slowly and be intrigued curious and dynamic and FREE. And those feelings applies not only to the music but their mvs, choreography and overall vibes, just like your friends welcoming you and being with them on a journey always together and free, with Ateez NEVER feels shallow never! That's why they are pirates! 👀 (You can tell they are a scorpio watery group, the emotions and passion! they make you feel too never industrial or shallow again :') )
it's actually legit not fair how good they are already
YES THEY SOLD OUT AND ADDING MORE SEATS FOR THE TOUR! I AGREE WITH YOU PD, ATEEZ WILL BE LEGENDARY
you being speechless and just bopping your head to the song is a whole mood tbh
i was just thinking how much i wish you had a reaction up for this. PD never disappoints ^^
We all died during San's part
"Go tell your daddy?" Wait what-
3:13 with captions-
Pd saying they will be memorable is just opinionated but speaking straight facts
I just realized the set with the dinning table could be a room next to the say my name room. Like a museum of sorts. I kinda see both scenes happening side by side.
thanks for reacting to this! i always enjoy watching your reactions to ATEEZ.
quick thing: this isn't a repackage, it's a new mini album - all new songs! :D (and one full version of an interlude from their previous album.)
It's not a repackage! It's a whole other Treasure album!!
I agree with PD so much about wonderland feeling like it’s supposed to build up to something but Answer just in your face powerful from the start with that amazing chorus that’s super catchy and emotional. Just amps me up but also makes me feel sad even though the lyrics is all about positivity
I actually can’t, this song is a bloody masterpiece 🙌🏻 words can’t even describe how magnificent it is
This by far, has to be their best title track yet! I’m so happy to see my boys only being known as KQ fellaz from their dancing to just being THAT amazingly talented rookie group among many other groups.
*it's actually incredibly insane how ateez, each and every comebacks, they still continue to impress me. every freaking time, i swear to god. they became one of my ult, because i can't help it but fell in love with their work. they just embrace and create exactly the type of music i'm into, and i love it.*
you know that pd loves the mv when the duration is almost at 20 minutes. I'M PROUD OF MY BOYS!!! FIGHTING ATEEZ.
things I noticed!
The first line says something like: „Cheers. Come down like a thunder and watch it run out“ I‘m not sure tho. My mothertongue is German😅. Anyway, you can see San smashing his hand down from above -> like a thunder and after you can witness his hand shaking symbolising the draining drink from their glasses
-
In the snow part with Wooyoung you can see the snow going up and not down. Maybe that‘s a callback to „Say my Name“ given the appearance of the Suicide Squad from „Say my name“ and the fits from „Hala Hala“
-
Have you noticed Yeosang standing in the Desert with line „this is where it all started“ that clearly a callback to „Pirate King“ and „Treasure“ (MV‘s)
-
Butterfly‘s stand for rebirth. Maybe that’s linked to the men dressed in white and the snow rising instead of falling in Wooyoung‘s solo dance scene.
-
that‘s some of what I managed to notice! Have fun and love you Atinys and Ateez!
Surprised you didn’t mention the connection between this, say my name and HALA HALA lol. I really like how you delved deep into the set and production.
Glad that I found someone who like Answer more than Wonderland.
It feels really good when other people realize that ateez is breaking everything
However many people ignore them😔
Answer is a masterpiece. The chills i get whenever I listen to it. It never fails to give me chills. 🥹😍
I was watching this video and right after pd was done watching the whole mv, the mv played again as an ad. I AIN'T SKIPPING!!!!
'Answer' is definitely my favorite Ateez song and video!
It's like almost 3am right now and i clicked this video right away
That set at 10:44 is a clock. This video does a lot relating to time. I especially love how they’re sitting across from their past selves and toasting. This is such an epic song and video.👏👏👏👏
The part when they were facing each other at the table gave me GOOSEBUMPS!!!
YESSSSS THIS IS WHAT I'VE BEEN ANTICIPATING
PD has blessed us with a video to end my day at school ♥♥♥♥ love your work PD ☺
I also agree we haven’t seen the explosion yet. A very bright future.
I agree with you.. I'm not a stan, I barely know the members, I haven't listened to their albums but from what I've seen so far, ateez have the potential to be big. with every cb they do, they are attracting & gaining more fans. I feel like once the 3rd gen groups hype slows down, ateez will be one of the top groups.
I like your analysis on ATEEZ music... honestly ATEEZ and their entire team have had the entire treasure series planned since debut if you listen to some of their songs you can hear them repeat sounds from their intros and other songs every song is linked one way or another they are super amazing
Thanks for doing a Kulture Study on ATEEZ. Loved all you had to say about them, and I especially agree about that feeling of listening to legends in progress.
okay, i'm not that early but i was really waiting for this video, because i still can't get over their new album
It's so refreshing to see people affirming that ATEEZ is going to be big. Thanks for your Kulture Study video. I always find it super awesome to hear people's perspectives on not just the music but also the MV. You're 1000% right, they have a big future ahead of them!
Ateez is slowly taking their time in building their career. I’m confident to say that they’ll be hella popular very soon. Don’t sleep on such great talent, sleep on your bed, dummy.
Stan ateez, you won’t regret it. Becoming an atiny is literally Free, no tax included either. You won’t regret it. ❤️
I don't know what it exactly is about ATEEZ, maybe the iconic, anthemic, unique songs they produce, but I see them being as iconic as BIG BANG even though they're still rookies. As in they're beginning to create a wave that will make them game changers in the kpop industry, more so than they already are.
Swear all of ateez's song are way ahead of their time. If their popularity is as big as bts or blackpink all their songs will be a big hit and you will always hear in the streets as worthy as they should
i adore ateez, they inspire me sm
PD we need to see a listening party and I feel like I speak for everyone when I say that we need to see your reaction to Precious and Horizon!!
Thank you so much for the reaction! I love hearing about the more technical sides of ateezs work and you address it so neatly and it’s easy to understand and follow. They do have new songs on this album, hope you enjoy! Answer tops wonderland for me too. The emotional aspect of it is so powerful and you captured the feeling of the song exactly - “the feeling of standing on the edge of greatness” that’s exactly how it is! The lyrics are so meaningful too - the callback to SMN (bulleo bulleo), yeosangs part acknowledging them starting in the desert as a callback to Treasure, the reference to illusion/wave(the burning sun/the crashing wave), and the line San starts the mv with was hinted at in their last album All To Action! The lyrics were so pretty and really conveyed that feeling of finishing a long journey and asking the world to see them and notice them. ateez is HERE and they’re loud and proud and powerful! Loved this reaction, thank you for always supporting ateez!
They already performed the song a few times if you want to see the coreography. They also performed horizon (another song from the new album)
I am floored by their music and I love the whole album, can't wait to see the listening party for this.
This is my favorite atm. Can't stop listening to it!
I was waiting for your reaction for very long! FINALLY YESSS SO HAPPY
SOOOOO happy to see someone else really love this song, I feel that so many atiny wanted to throw them down and say they didn't like it even though it was way better than wonderland.... love the reaction, new subscriber
PD thank you! I was waiting for your reaction, it always makes me happy to watch you acknowledging ateez and appreciating their music and team. I hope in the future you can give us a listening party of action to answer because yes it has 3 new songs and 1 intro.
REAL RECOGNIZE REAL
always appreciate your reviews on ateez!! they deserve so much credit and recognition for their hard work + creativity, especially in their performances.