Beatles albums ranked! Freak out!!! As It Should Be Instagram: / asitshouldbepodcast As It Should Be audio podcast: www.himalaya.com/album/as-it-... My other channel: / shortsleave
13: Yellow Submarine 12: With the Beatles 11: The Beatles For Sale 10: Please Please Me 9: A Hard Day’s Night 8: Let It Be 7: Help! 6: Rubber Soul 5: The Magical Mystery Tour 4: Revolver 3: Sgt. Peppers Lonely Heart Club Band 2: Abbey Road 1: The Beatles “White Album”
Awesome list!! Couldn’t agree more on Revolver being your number 1, after getting my hands on the recent mono vinyl released a few weeks ago (after only ever hearing it in stereo) there’s no going back!
According to Ringo Starr Abbey Road was an album where they wanted to be together and put together a last effort for the fans. They wanted to be there and they worked hard, but they also knew that that would be it for them. Their lives were changing they were going on to do their own thing, but it was more of a work effort and challenge then it was them being a group of friends working together. This is according to Ringo.
Well all right! This my favorite video you guys have done! Comparing Beatles albums is like comparing Corvettes. You really can't go wrong. Great Beatles commercials! My picks starting from number one: Revolver; Abbey Road; Rubber Soul; Sgt. Pepper; White Album; Magical Mystery Tour; Help!; A Hard Day's Night; Let it Be; Beatles for Sale; With the Beatles; Please Please Me; Yellow Submarine. And I completely agree with Paul's assessment of Revolver. Not only is it my favorite Beatles album, it's my favorite album, period. Tommy great line about "meddling sitars!"
Absolutely loved this, I applaud all 3 of y'all for doing this because it would take me 4-ever to rank them , but I do agree on "I need you" and also the one nobody seems to agree on " Happiness is a warm gun " I love that song and it is so fun to sing , for those who don't get it, they never will, also love those commercials I've never seen , the girl in the bubble bath with the Beatles , she wished ❤ , lol thank you guys so much !!
This is something I think about a lot. But my preference changes on my top five. I go with what I listen to the most as of right now. Abbey Road, Revolver, Let It Be, A Hard Day’s Night and Rubber Soul. But seriously, with the exception of Yellow Submarine any of the albums can make my top five any day. I love Please Please Me. Paul you hit the the nail on the head with that example and Crystal I’m with you on Let It Be. It has grown on me over the years and it’s my go to album. Great ranking!!! Now let’s do the Led Zeppelin albums.
You guys have great lists! Here’s mine: 1. Abbey Road (1969) 2. The Beatles [The White Album] (1968) 3. Revolver (1966) 4. Magical Mystery Tour (1967) 5. Let it Be (1970) 6. A Hard Day’s Night (1964) 7. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967) 8. Rubber Soul (1965) 9. Help! (1965) 10. Please Please Me (1963) 11. With the Beatles (1964) 12. Beatles for Sale (1964) 13. Yellow Submarine (1969)
My ranking: 1. Rubber Soul 2. Revolver 3. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 4. Abbey Road 5. A Hard Day's Night 6. Let It Be 7. Help! 8. Magical Mystery Tour 9. With the Beatles 10. The Beatles (The White Album) 11. Please Please Me 12. Beatles for Sale 13. Yellow Submarine
Great video!I never thought I'd see somebody have Let It Be as their Number 1 (It would be my #12 ). Revolver would be by #1. Sgt. Pepper's is one of The Beatles' weaker albums (mid at best. I'd take off Mr. Kite and Good Morning, Good Morning
I just subscribed because I love how Crystal didn't sugar coat her opinion of Yellow Submarine. I was busting a gut lmao when she said she hated it. I myself don't hate it but I respect honesty! Didn't even watch the rest of the video yet but you cracked me up! Thank you
My ranking might be controversial but heres my list (also I’m not including magical mystery tour because it’s a us album originally) 12. Beatles for sale 11. Yellow submarine 10. With the Beatles 9. Let it be 8. The white album 7. Please Please Me 6. Abbey Road 5. Sgt Peppers 4. A Hard Days Night 3. Help! 2. Rubber Soul 1. Revolver
I just love you guys!! Ty for tackling the greatest band of all time! I will do mine if you do not mind, and yes yellow submarine is last.....beatles 4 sale, with the beatles, PPM, Help, HDN, Let it Be, Sgt, Rubber Soul, Revolver, MMT, Abbey Road and the White Album. Yes, they are so amazing, of course we all have different views because nothing was like anything else. Love you guys!!
GREAT VIDEO!!! Love the Wings t-shirt, very classy.Top 5 ....drum roll (1) Rubber Soul (2) Beatles 4 Sale (3)Magical Mystery (4) Hard Days Night (5) Abbey Road. By the way, I absolutely Loveeeee Yellow Submarine......the movie not the album, though it's good too.
Great video guys! Ok, I am going to take a crack at it: #1. Revolver (British release) #2. Magical Mystery Tour (Capital release) #3. Help (British release) #4. Hard Days Night #5. Rubber Soul #6. Sargent Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band #7. White Album #8. Abbey Road #9. Let It Be #10. Beatles For Sale #11. Please, Please Me #12. With The Beatles #13. Yellow Submarine
So the week I go off on vacation is when y’all post this? Fine, be that way. Overall, I agree with at least one point each of you has made, and nobody seems to be completely off their nut, not that I was expecting that… I’m not even going to try to rank these albums. Part of my problem is that I don’t think of the early albums as “albums”-they are groups of individual songs to me. “Ooo, that’s the one with I Saw Her Standing There!” It isn’t until Rubber Soul that I think of these as actual, bona fide albums, so that will make ranking them hard. Yellow Submarine also won’t appear at the bottom of my list because of a technicality: as far as I’m concerned, it’s an EP, and I don’t include EPs when I rank albums. That being said, I have to give it marks simply because it has Hey Bulldog, which is one of my favorite Beatles tracks. And as much as I hate to disagree with Tommy, Let It Be Naked is ten times better than Let It Be. Yes, Phil Spector managed to make an album out of the bits and pieces he was given, but he didn’t make a Beatles album. I always hated Long and Winding Road, for example, until I heard the version on Naked.
13. Yellow Submarine 12. With the Beatles 11. Beatles For Sale 10. Let It Be 9. Magical Mystery Tour 8. Help! 7. Please, Please Me 6. A Hard Days Night 5. Sargent Peppers 4. Revolver 3. Rubber Soul 2. White Album 1. Abbey Road
What a fun video. I love all of Paul’s backstory about where and when he heard albums. My list would be peppered with similar stories of borrowing records from my neighbors and so on. (My parents were utterly indifferent to the Beatles or records in general). I enjoy the US Help film soundtrack but I’m kind of a film score nerd. Abbey Road has always been my number one. As Paul alluded to, Abbey Road only rose in my estimation after seeing the state of things during the Get Back sessions. It also occurred to me that during the span of time when the Beatles were recording, the whole concept of ALBUMS was changing dramatically. Some of the early albums were conceived purely to get product on the shelf for Christmas or whatnot. (Looking at you Beatles For Sale…it’s right there in the title!)
Thanks! Yeah, Beatles For Sale is without a doubt a case of those guys being dragged into a studio prematurely simply because an album was "needed" for the Christmas market. If the whole album was a set of originals as good as the ones they already have on it then that album would rank far higher for me.
“Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band” has always been my all time favorite album by anybody ever since it came out, but for many years now, “Please Please Me” is the Beatle’s album that I reach for most often, but I’m oriented completely to the US Capitol releases, (“Introducing The Beatles”, “The Early Beatles”). - it just has the freshness, innocence, and spontaneity, that always makes it such an uplifting listen.. And it’s the only Beatle’s album that, in my opinion - the cover versions hold up next to the originals…. The rest of the albums, fluctuate wildly in order of preference - although the Capitol release, “The Beatles Second Album” has always been my least favorite… even less than “Yellow Submarine”, due to all the so-so covers.. Nice video guys! 👍
Great lists, but I think I agree with Crystal's the most with the exception of the placement of "Let It Be". I love "Revolution 9" so much I made a full video on it. lol I have been staying away from The Beatles for awhile because I wanted to make a ranking video and wanted to listen again with a clean palate. It's tough otherwise, to rank the earlier albums because I'm so familiar with the U.S. versions. I've heard "Sgt. Pepper's" described as "tea & crumpets" and I think that's a good description of why I wouldn't put it so high on the list. My better half heard it and said it sounded like " a children's album". Is the inevitable contrarian comment coming that puts "Yellow Submarine" at the top of the list? Thanks again for the great shoutout!
I remember your video where you cut quickly to Terry and he said exactly that about Sgt Pepper. On one hand I recoil in deeply offended horror, on the other hand I can actually kind of understand what he's saying. Of course the "tea & crumpets" vibe is one of the many things I love about Pepper. Also one of the things I love about later 60s Kinks records.
Just got done watching Crystal's rating. Wow! I'm shocked by some of your placements but that's the beauty of the Beatles. Yellow Submarine is last for everyone is the general consensus but after that, it's all personal taste
1. Abbey Road 2. Revolver 3. A Hard Day's Night 4. Help! 5. Rubber Soul 6. Beatles For Sale 7. Please Please Me 8. Magical Mystery Tour 9. The White Album 10. Sgt. Pepper's 11. With The Beatles 12. Let It Be 13. Yellow Submarine People need to get their hearing checked. Don't buy into the "normie" popularity hive-mind. Be objective, listen to each album, then give each song a number rating, then add up a score for each album. You might be shocked which albums come in first. I gave bonus points to The White Album since it was a double album but had too much filler, otherwise it would be 2nd to last, but the good songs on it surpassed Sgt' Pepper's. 'Let It Be' has two good songs, the rest were average or below average at best. Sorry if any of you are offended by my rankings.
You're great guys! You gel well together, i totally agree with Crystal, my ranking would be very similar with Let it be number 1 or 2, swapping position with the white album and Sgt Pepper 7th or 8th. Abbey road would be my number 3
I have never been a fan of the early stuff but always rank Let It Be as their worst, although (huge caveat) I have never once in my life listened to Yellow Submarine, which always just sounded too bad to even bother with. My top 5: 1. Revolver 2. Magical Mystery Tour 3. Sgt. Pepper's 4. Abbey Road 5. White Album
My favorite Beatle album is Let it Be. It was the only Beatle record my Mom had when I was a kid, she said my Uncle stole all her Beatle Albums when they both moved out of my Grandparent's house 🤷♀️. She loved that album and would play that record over and over and over. I hated it for a good long time and when I finally listened to again at about 19, was like, alright I get it, now I understand why she played it all the time, Mom's right. #2 is Hard Day's Night. Need a couple months to sort out and rank the rest, but definitely know I'd take off She's Leaving Home and Within You Without You. I gotta split but wanted to also add, love the commercials.
I was suprised about some of the choices but that's all good. I totally agree with Revolver being even more awesome if they had replaced Yellow Submarine ( 1 of my least favourite songs by them) with either Rain or Paperback writer. If they released the single Yellow Submarine/ Paperback writer before Revolver and put Rain on it (after say Good day sunshine because sun/rain) who good would that be? Also Strawberry Fields Forever/ Penny Lane on Sgt. Pepper would be amazing, i'd keep Within You Without You because the album needs a George song and i'd get rid of When i'm 64 and Lovely Rita. My ranking: 13. Yellow Submarine 12. Beatles For Sale 11. With the Beatles 10. Please Please Me 9. Help 8. Let It Be 7. A Hard Days Night 6. Sgt. PLHCB 5. Magical Mystery Tour 4. Rubber Soul 3. The Beatles (White Album) 2. Revolver 1. Abbey Road
Awesome lists, here's mine: 1. Revolver 2. Abbey Road 3. White Album 4. Rubber Soul 5. Let It Be 6. Magical Mystery Tour 7. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 8. Help 9. A Hard Day's Night 10. Beatles For Sale 11. Please Please Me 12. With the Beatles 13. Yellow Submarine
The White Album is my favorite by far. It's almost perfect. The only song I don't like is Revolution 9, but then again I've never listened to it on acid and with headphones on. Perhaps that's why I don't get it.
My ranking 13. Yellow Submarine 12. Beatles For Sale 11. With the Beatles 10. Let it Be 09. Please Please Me 08. The White Album 07. Sgt Pepper 06. Magical Mystery Tour 05. Help 04. A Hard Day’s Night 03. Rubber Soul 02. Revolver 01. Abbey Road
13. Yellow submarine 12. Beatles for sale 11. With the Beatles 10. Help! 9. Let it be 8. Please please me 7. Rubber soul 6. Magical mystery tour 5. Revolver 4. A hard days night 3. White album 2. Sgt pepper’s lonely hearts club band 1. Abbey Road
Great list love any road my least are yellow submarine then let it be is so so to me Beatles for sale white album revolver sgt pepper I think because those album when big I was 10ish don't understand what they were talking about over my head I like about half white album love help with the Beatles Abby road please please me hard days night top 6 could be switched depending on mood love magical mystery tour would place no 7 actually but that's my orders no 1 meet the Beatles
The Beatles worst albums would be most bands best albums. But Abbey Rd is one special album and the medley which should be listened to always in one sitting is nothing short of phenomenal
I enjoyed watching your guys rankings. I agree the Beatles made some bad songs. Not the yellow submarine cuts but there are some atrocious early songs . You should do the who next
13. Yellow Submarine 12. Beatles For Sale 11. With The Beatles 10. Please Please Me 9. Let It Be 8. Help! 7. Magical Mystery Tour 6. A Hard Day's Night 5. Sgt. Pepper 4. Rubber Soul 3. The Beatles 2. Revolver 1. Abbey Road.
I dig this roundtable. It's like a pizza. A Round Table Pizza. You have the left nut. The right nut. And the dingleberry in the middle... It's pizza time people...let's eat. A little bit of Savoy Truffle if you please 😘
For a while I’ve had the hot take that Sgt Peppers didn’t do much for me. Is it good? Yeah, it’s solid. I just found it overly indulgent and not super memorable outside of its production and charm. I tend to prefer the more back to basics stuff like White Album and Abbey Road but Sgt Peppers has its moments. Would still probably give it like a 7/10 but I can see why people love it so much.
mine goes as follows 13# Yellow sub 12# please please me #11Meet the Beatles 10# Beatles for sale #9 Let it be #8 hard days night #7 help #6 magical mystery tour #5 abby road #4rubber soul #3 Revolver #2 Sgt Pepper #1 White Album ... Boy that was a Kinda hard .
It's VERY tough. What's more is you'll find the list is different if you try it again only a few months later. Or at least that's the way it is with me.
Strawberry Fields Forever and Penny Lane could have been included on Sgt Pepper without cutting any songs. The running time of side one is only 19:36, and side two 20:02. If Strawberry Fields Forever was included on side one and Penny Lane on side two the running times for each side would be 23:41 and 23:02. I know some engineers like to keep a side to around 23 mins to preserve sound quality, but side four of the White Album is 24:41, and side one of Abbey Road is 24:53. The biggest problem for me would be where to put them in the listing.
Sgt. Pepper with 15 songs, i like that! Strawberry Fields Forever between Getting Better and Fixing A Hole ( Lennon song between 2 McCartney songs) and Penny Lane opening side 2 maybe?
I'm such a Beatles fan that I don't think any of these albums are "bad" or anything like that. Just which ones I like the best or least. So here goes. 13. Yellow Submarine (It is most people's least favorite after all.) 12. Let It Be 11. A Hard Day's Night 10. Please Please Me 9. With The Beatles 8. Abbey Road (Gets to me this is often considered these days as their best album since it's the one album of theirs I found a big difficult to get into as a whole at first. I think the reason why is the same reason Paul had about Sgt Pepper, and that's the Sgt Pepper movie. Some of the songs on Abbey Road I first heard in that movie, so it kinda ruined it for me. Ha. I can get into it as a whole now, though, and this is where I place it. And yes, I do love that medley at the end. Certainly a great way for them to go out even though I don't think it was initially intended that way.) 7. Magical Mystery Tour 6. Help! 5. Beatles For Sale (SO underrated, this is, I think. Maybe my first favorite Beatles album, believe it or not.) 4. Rubber Soul 3. Sgt Pepper 2. Revolver (Maybe the album I've played more than any other album by anyone. Odd, since it's not my no. 1, but still.) 1. The White Album (My pick for the greatest album ever. By anyone. It's a ride from beginning to end. Yeah, tracks like Wild Honey Pie and Revolution 9 may not work on their own, but as part of the album experience, it ABSOLUTELY works. It has everything I'd want in an album. Rock, ballads, beauty, ugliness, light, shade, humor, anger, horror, experimentation, great vocals, great guitars etc. Take even just one track off it, it doesn't work. The tracks compliment each other, yet they're so varied. A perfect album to me, really. And what a cover too! ;) )
Nah, the 1978 movie wasn't my reason for my Sgt Pepper placement, I was just mentioning how I'd first been exposed to that stuff. That said, I can definitely understand why it would color your opinion. Although it's curious that the movie affects your ranking of Abbey Road but not Pepper.
@@AsItShouldBePodcast Well, I heard those Pepper songs as they were on the original album before I saw the movie, so it didn't really affect that. Took me a while longer to get to Abbey Road, I guess. Ha
@@djcrystalclear8169 HA! Yes, whew! None of you did the unthinkable or absurd and put yellow sub in a more prestigious rank than it deserved. Love it when my fellow Beatles fans can be objective about their catalog 😍 Also appreciate the lack of smugness over the “spiked” version of Magical Mystery Tour. Only gasped in horror once and that was over Paul’s disdain for Mr Kite 😱.
My rankings : 1. Revolver 2. Abbey Road 3. Rubber Soul 4. Magical Mystery Tour 5. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band 6. White Album 7. Help 8. A Hard Day's Night 9. With the Beatles 10. Please Please Me 11. Beatles For Sale 12. Yellow Submarine 13. Let It Be (would be better with « Don’t Let Me Down »)
God I gotta say this is one of the WORST Beatles ranking I've ever seen...the guy in the hat had the best list, the guy in the middle's list was terrible BUT he had Revolver at #1 which is correct, and the girl's list was ALL TYPES OF MESSED UP...none of you really get the The Beatles...Revolver should ALWAYS be #1 or #2 and Sgt. Peppers should be up there as well
![แม่กลองสองใจ - ซีแกรม โตเกียว มิวสิค [ OFFICIAL MUSIC VIDEO ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GSQfVjcr_f4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Full Episode] MasterChef Junior Thailand มาสเตอร์เชฟ จูเนียร์ ประเทศไทย Season 3 Episode 4](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/e7Oqqo90x_w/mqdefault.jpg)
In my opinion, Within You Without You is one of the essential tracks on Sgt Peppers. It is beautiful and spiritual. And the "sitars" are exquisite.
Let it Be is super underrated, not sure why many fans don't acknowledge its greatness.
I don't care what anyone says, I think Phil Spector did a a great job ! 😀
I've got a feeling goes hard
Short answer: overproducer Phil Spector. However, Let It Be... Naked is Ok.
I would probably rank Let It Be and Sgt Peppers the same score. Both probably 7/10. That’s probably a take most people don’t agree with lol.
Dig a Pony is atrocious. The Long and Winding Road is meh.
13: Yellow Submarine
12: With the Beatles
11: The Beatles For Sale
10: Please Please Me
9: A Hard Day’s Night
8: Let It Be
7: Help!
6: Rubber Soul
5: The Magical Mystery Tour
4: Revolver
3: Sgt. Peppers Lonely Heart Club Band
2: Abbey Road
1: The Beatles “White Album”
Awesome list!! Couldn’t agree more on Revolver being your number 1, after getting my hands on the recent mono vinyl released a few weeks ago (after only ever hearing it in stereo) there’s no going back!
Absolutely! Taxman in particular sounds so tough and punchy in mono.
According to Ringo Starr Abbey Road was an album where they wanted to be together and put together a last effort for the fans. They wanted to be there and they worked hard, but they also knew that that would be it for them. Their lives were changing they were going on to do their own thing, but it was more of a work effort and challenge then it was them being a group of friends working together. This is according to Ringo.
yellow sub the animation is a trip
Well all right! This my favorite video you guys have done! Comparing Beatles albums is like comparing Corvettes. You really can't go wrong.
Great Beatles commercials!
My picks starting from number one: Revolver; Abbey Road; Rubber Soul; Sgt. Pepper; White Album; Magical Mystery Tour; Help!; A Hard Day's Night; Let it Be; Beatles for Sale; With the Beatles; Please Please Me; Yellow Submarine.
And I completely agree with Paul's assessment of Revolver. Not only is it my favorite Beatles album, it's my favorite album, period. Tommy great line about "meddling sitars!"
Thanks! Your Corvette analogy is spot on.
Thanks John!
Absolutely loved this, I applaud all 3 of y'all for doing this because it would take me 4-ever to rank them , but I do agree on "I need you" and also the one nobody seems to agree on " Happiness is a warm gun " I love that song and it is so fun to sing , for those who don't get it, they never will, also love those commercials I've never seen , the girl in the bubble bath with the Beatles , she wished ❤ , lol thank you guys so much !!
This is something I think about a lot. But my preference changes on my top five. I go with what I listen to the most as of right now. Abbey Road, Revolver, Let It Be, A Hard Day’s Night and Rubber Soul.
But seriously, with the exception of Yellow Submarine any of the albums can make my top five any day. I love Please Please Me. Paul you hit the the nail on the head with that example and Crystal I’m with you on Let It Be. It has grown on me over the years and it’s my go to album. Great ranking!!!
Now let’s do the Led Zeppelin albums.
Thank, Randy! Yeah, the Zeppelin albums will definitely happen at some point.
Thank you Randy!!!
You guys have great lists!
Here’s mine:
1. Abbey Road (1969)
2. The Beatles [The White Album] (1968)
3. Revolver (1966)
4. Magical Mystery Tour (1967)
5. Let it Be (1970)
6. A Hard Day’s Night (1964)
7. Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (1967)
8. Rubber Soul (1965)
9. Help! (1965)
10. Please Please Me (1963)
11. With the Beatles (1964)
12. Beatles for Sale (1964)
13. Yellow Submarine (1969)
My ranking:
1. Rubber Soul
2. Revolver
3. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
4. Abbey Road
5. A Hard Day's Night
6. Let It Be
7. Help!
8. Magical Mystery Tour
9. With the Beatles
10. The Beatles (The White Album)
11. Please Please Me
12. Beatles for Sale
13. Yellow Submarine
Great video!I never thought I'd see somebody have Let It Be as their Number 1 (It would be my #12 ). Revolver would be by #1. Sgt. Pepper's is one of The Beatles' weaker albums (mid at best. I'd take off Mr. Kite and Good Morning, Good Morning
I guess I’m an oddball 🤷🏽♀️
I love The Beach Boys idea!
@@djcrystalclear8169 Haha. Well, I'm an oddball too. Liking the Beach Boys growing up back in the day was so uncool. I got so much flak for it! 🙂
@@myopia2020 Flack for liking The Beach Boys?!? That’s crazy!
my fav beatles song and your bird can sing off yesterday and today
I just subscribed because I love how Crystal didn't sugar coat her opinion of Yellow Submarine. I was busting a gut lmao when she said she hated it. I myself don't hate it but I respect honesty! Didn't even watch the rest of the video yet but you cracked me up! Thank you
My ranking might be controversial but heres my list (also I’m not including magical mystery tour because it’s a us album originally)
12. Beatles for sale
11. Yellow submarine
10. With the Beatles
9. Let it be
8. The white album
7. Please Please Me
6. Abbey Road
5. Sgt Peppers
4. A Hard Days Night
3. Help!
2. Rubber Soul
1. Revolver
Good list with some of the early stuff making higher spots. As it should be!
@@AsItShouldBePodcast I love some of their pre rubber soul stuff especially help!
The Magical Mystery Tour LP is brilliant. Even the Beatles chose to include it in their discography, so there's no reason to leave it out.
I just love you guys!! Ty for tackling the greatest band of all time! I will do mine if you do not mind, and yes yellow submarine is last.....beatles 4 sale, with the beatles, PPM, Help, HDN, Let it Be, Sgt, Rubber Soul, Revolver, MMT, Abbey Road and the White Album. Yes, they are so amazing, of course we all have different views because nothing was like anything else. Love you guys!!
Thank you 🎉
Thanks, Cavo! You love Rubber Soul so much you ranked it twice!
@@AsItShouldBePodcast Was a long day, but still managed to watch you guys and add, though repetitively, my list too. Cheers
You forgot Revolver. Probably why you had Rubber Soul twice?
@@michaelharrington75 This is where I doubled up on RS...ty
Within You, Without Ypu is my favorite song on Sgt. Pepper. When I'm 64 is easily my least favorite.
64 is one of my least favorites on the album too. Maybe that would be the other track I'd dump in favor of the single tracks.
@@AsItShouldBePodcast yeah I'm not a huge fan of Paul's "granny rock"
GREAT VIDEO!!! Love the Wings t-shirt, very classy.Top 5 ....drum roll (1) Rubber Soul (2) Beatles 4 Sale (3)Magical Mystery (4) Hard Days Night (5) Abbey Road. By the way, I absolutely Loveeeee Yellow Submarine......the movie not the album, though it's good too.
Great video guys! Ok, I am going to take a crack at it:
#1. Revolver (British release)
#2. Magical Mystery Tour (Capital release)
#3. Help (British release)
#4. Hard Days Night
#5. Rubber Soul
#6. Sargent Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band
#7. White Album
#8. Abbey Road
#9. Let It Be
#10. Beatles For Sale
#11. Please, Please Me
#12. With The Beatles
#13. Yellow Submarine
So the week I go off on vacation is when y’all post this? Fine, be that way.
Overall, I agree with at least one point each of you has made, and nobody seems to be completely off their nut, not that I was expecting that… I’m not even going to try to rank these albums. Part of my problem is that I don’t think of the early albums as “albums”-they are groups of individual songs to me. “Ooo, that’s the one with I Saw Her Standing There!” It isn’t until Rubber Soul that I think of these as actual, bona fide albums, so that will make ranking them hard. Yellow Submarine also won’t appear at the bottom of my list because of a technicality: as far as I’m concerned, it’s an EP, and I don’t include EPs when I rank albums. That being said, I have to give it marks simply because it has Hey Bulldog, which is one of my favorite Beatles tracks.
And as much as I hate to disagree with Tommy, Let It Be Naked is ten times better than Let It Be. Yes, Phil Spector managed to make an album out of the bits and pieces he was given, but he didn’t make a Beatles album. I always hated Long and Winding Road, for example, until I heard the version on Naked.
13. Yellow Submarine
12. With the Beatles
11. Beatles For Sale
10. Let It Be
9. Magical Mystery Tour
8. Help!
7. Please, Please Me
6. A Hard Days Night
5. Sargent Peppers
4. Revolver
3. Rubber Soul
2. White Album
1. Abbey Road
What a fun video.
I love all of Paul’s backstory about where and when he heard albums. My list would be peppered with similar stories of borrowing records from my neighbors and so on. (My parents were utterly indifferent to the Beatles or records in general).
I enjoy the US Help film soundtrack but I’m kind of a film score nerd.
Abbey Road has always been my number one. As Paul alluded to, Abbey Road only rose in my estimation after seeing the state of things during the Get Back sessions.
It also occurred to me that during the span of time when the Beatles were recording, the whole concept of ALBUMS was changing dramatically. Some of the early albums were conceived purely to get product on the shelf for Christmas or whatnot. (Looking at you Beatles For Sale…it’s right there in the title!)
Thanks! Yeah, Beatles For Sale is without a doubt a case of those guys being dragged into a studio prematurely simply because an album was "needed" for the Christmas market. If the whole album was a set of originals as good as the ones they already have on it then that album would rank far higher for me.
“Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band” has always been my all time favorite album by anybody ever since it came out, but for many years now, “Please Please Me” is the Beatle’s album that I reach for most often, but I’m oriented completely to the US Capitol releases, (“Introducing The Beatles”, “The Early Beatles”). - it just has the freshness, innocence, and spontaneity, that always makes it such an uplifting listen.. And it’s the only Beatle’s album that, in my opinion - the cover versions hold up next to the originals…. The rest of the albums, fluctuate wildly in order of preference - although the Capitol release, “The Beatles Second Album” has always been my least favorite… even less than “Yellow Submarine”, due to all the so-so covers.. Nice video guys! 👍
Yes! Objectively, Please Please Me may not be as good of an album as Sgt Pepper, but it makes me happier. But I suppose it also depends on my mood.
Great lists, but I think I agree with Crystal's the most with the exception of the placement of "Let It Be". I love "Revolution 9" so much I made a full video on it. lol I have been staying away from The Beatles for awhile because I wanted to make a ranking video and wanted to listen again with a clean palate. It's tough otherwise, to rank the earlier albums because I'm so familiar with the U.S. versions. I've heard "Sgt. Pepper's" described as "tea & crumpets" and I think that's a good description of why I wouldn't put it so high on the list. My better half heard it and said it sounded like " a children's album". Is the inevitable contrarian comment coming that puts "Yellow Submarine" at the top of the list? Thanks again for the great shoutout!
I remember your video where you cut quickly to Terry and he said exactly that about Sgt Pepper. On one hand I recoil in deeply offended horror, on the other hand I can actually kind of understand what he's saying. Of course the "tea & crumpets" vibe is one of the many things I love about Pepper. Also one of the things I love about later 60s Kinks records.
You rule Robert!
I think That Revolver is the BEST album.
Just got done watching Crystal's rating. Wow! I'm shocked by some of your placements but that's the beauty of the Beatles. Yellow Submarine is last for everyone is the general consensus but after that, it's all personal taste
1. Abbey Road
2. Revolver
3. A Hard Day's Night
4. Help!
5. Rubber Soul
6. Beatles For Sale
7. Please Please Me
8. Magical Mystery Tour
9. The White Album
10. Sgt. Pepper's
11. With The Beatles
12. Let It Be
13. Yellow Submarine
People need to get their hearing checked. Don't buy into the "normie" popularity hive-mind.
Be objective, listen to each album, then give each song a number rating, then add up a score for each album.
You might be shocked which albums come in first. I gave bonus points to The White Album since it was a double album but had too much filler, otherwise it would be 2nd to last, but the good songs on it surpassed Sgt' Pepper's. 'Let It Be' has two good songs, the rest were average or below average at best. Sorry if any of you are offended by my rankings.
You're great guys! You gel well together, i totally agree with Crystal, my ranking would be very similar with Let it be number 1 or 2, swapping position with the white album and Sgt Pepper 7th or 8th. Abbey road would be my number 3
Touching the flame 🔥
I have never been a fan of the early stuff but always rank Let It Be as their worst, although (huge caveat) I have never once in my life listened to Yellow Submarine, which always just sounded too bad to even bother with.
My top 5:
1. Revolver
2. Magical Mystery Tour
3. Sgt. Pepper's
4. Abbey Road
5. White Album
Yes, STAY AWAY FROM YELLOW SUBMARINE AT ALL COSTS!!!
Hey Bulldog is fuckin great
My favorite Beatle album is Let it Be. It was the only Beatle record my Mom had when I was a kid, she said my Uncle stole all her Beatle Albums when they both moved out of my Grandparent's house 🤷♀️. She loved that album and would play that record over and over and over. I hated it for a good long time and when I finally listened to again at about 19, was like, alright I get it, now I understand why she played it all the time, Mom's right. #2 is Hard Day's Night. Need a couple months to sort out and rank the rest, but definitely know I'd take off She's Leaving Home and Within You Without You. I gotta split but wanted to also add, love the commercials.
HOORAY!
LET IT BE FOR THE WINNNN!
The commercials are gear, baby!
I was suprised about some of the choices but that's all good. I totally agree with Revolver being even more awesome if they had replaced Yellow Submarine ( 1 of my least favourite songs by them) with either Rain or Paperback writer. If they released the single Yellow Submarine/ Paperback writer before Revolver and put Rain on it (after say Good day sunshine because sun/rain) who good would that be? Also Strawberry Fields Forever/ Penny Lane on Sgt. Pepper would be amazing, i'd keep Within You Without You because the album needs a George song and i'd get rid of When i'm 64 and Lovely Rita.
My ranking: 13. Yellow Submarine 12. Beatles For Sale 11. With the Beatles 10. Please Please Me 9. Help 8. Let It Be 7. A Hard Days Night 6. Sgt. PLHCB 5. Magical Mystery Tour 4. Rubber Soul 3. The Beatles (White Album) 2. Revolver 1. Abbey Road
My top 5
1. White Album
2. Rubber Soul
3. Abby Road
4. Revolver
5. Sgt. Pepper
Awesome lists, here's mine:
1. Revolver
2. Abbey Road
3. White Album
4. Rubber Soul
5. Let It Be
6. Magical Mystery Tour
7. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
8. Help
9. A Hard Day's Night
10. Beatles For Sale
11. Please Please Me
12. With the Beatles
13. Yellow Submarine
The White Album is my favorite by far. It's almost perfect. The only song I don't like is Revolution 9, but then again I've never listened to it on acid and with headphones on. Perhaps that's why I don't get it.
LOL
a hard day's night for me. short tunes, fabulous harmonies and catchy as hell....inspired pop rock
love yous keep it up your a hoot
My ranking
13. Yellow Submarine
12. Beatles For Sale
11. With the Beatles
10. Let it Be
09. Please Please Me
08. The White Album
07. Sgt Pepper
06. Magical Mystery Tour
05. Help
04. A Hard Day’s Night
03. Rubber Soul
02. Revolver
01. Abbey Road
13. Yellow submarine
12. Beatles for sale
11. With the Beatles
10. Help!
9. Let it be
8. Please please me
7. Rubber soul
6. Magical mystery tour
5. Revolver
4. A hard days night
3. White album
2. Sgt pepper’s lonely hearts club band
1. Abbey Road
Pretty similar to my list. Can't fault any of your choices. 🙌
Great list love any road my least are yellow submarine then let it be is so so to me Beatles for sale white album revolver sgt pepper I think because those album when big I was 10ish don't understand what they were talking about over my head I like about half white album love help with the Beatles Abby road please please me hard days night top 6 could be switched depending on mood love magical mystery tour would place no 7 actually but that's my orders no 1 meet the Beatles
The Beatles worst albums would be most bands best albums.
But Abbey Rd is one special album and the medley which should be listened to always in one sitting is nothing short of phenomenal
Without question
Beatles 2nd Album is my early fave.
I love those rose eyeglasses. Yeah, baby!
I enjoyed watching your guys rankings. I agree the Beatles made some bad songs. Not the yellow submarine cuts but there are some atrocious early songs . You should do the who next
#1 - Who's Next
Ooooh, The Who is my all-time favorite
Funny you should bring that up. I was thinking of asking C&T if they want to do The Who at some point.
@@AsItShouldBePodcast awesome, hope it’s comes out at some point. Another question would you mind if I do track Vs track on my channel.
@@Townshend90125 I got it from Ralph Viera's Almost Human channel, so it's certainly OK with me.
13. Yellow Submarine
12. Beatles For Sale
11. With The Beatles
10. Please Please Me
9. Let It Be
8. Help!
7. Magical Mystery Tour
6. A Hard Day's Night
5. Sgt. Pepper
4. Rubber Soul
3. The Beatles
2. Revolver
1. Abbey Road.
It's hilarious that you can pretty much count on Yellow Submarine and Beatles for Sale to be at the bottom of just about every list.
I dig this roundtable.
It's like a pizza. A Round Table Pizza.
You have the left nut. The right nut.
And the dingleberry in the middle...
It's pizza time people...let's eat.
A little bit of Savoy Truffle if you please 😘
TOMMY - why were you so distracted during the End Tag?😂😂😂
Hahaha, I was probably looking at some candy
For a while I’ve had the hot take that Sgt Peppers didn’t do much for me. Is it good? Yeah, it’s solid. I just found it overly indulgent and not super memorable outside of its production and charm. I tend to prefer the more back to basics stuff like White Album and Abbey Road but Sgt Peppers has its moments. Would still probably give it like a 7/10 but I can see why people love it so much.
mine goes as follows 13# Yellow sub 12# please please me #11Meet the Beatles 10# Beatles for sale #9 Let it be #8 hard days night #7 help #6 magical mystery tour #5 abby road #4rubber soul #3 Revolver #2 Sgt Pepper #1 White Album ... Boy that was a Kinda hard .
It's VERY tough. What's more is you'll find the list is different if you try it again only a few months later. Or at least that's the way it is with me.
Yeah, everybody's Beatles rankings will be different. I saw one guys list of ranking Beatles albums that had Yellow Submarine at number 7.
Ha! Wow!
the record me and my sister use t0 fight over is beatles rock n roll music
Strawberry Fields Forever and Penny Lane could have been included on Sgt Pepper without cutting any songs. The running time of side one is only 19:36, and side two 20:02. If Strawberry Fields Forever was included on side one and Penny Lane on side two the running times for each side would be 23:41 and 23:02. I know some engineers like to keep a side to around 23 mins to preserve sound quality, but side four of the White Album is 24:41, and side one of Abbey Road is 24:53.
The biggest problem for me would be where to put them in the listing.
Sgt. Pepper with 15 songs, i like that! Strawberry Fields Forever between Getting Better and Fixing A Hole ( Lennon song between 2 McCartney songs) and Penny Lane opening side 2 maybe?
💕💕
I'm such a Beatles fan that I don't think any of these albums are "bad" or anything like that. Just which ones I like the best or least. So here goes.
13. Yellow Submarine (It is most people's least favorite after all.)
12. Let It Be
11. A Hard Day's Night
10. Please Please Me
9. With The Beatles
8. Abbey Road (Gets to me this is often considered these days as their best album since it's the one album of theirs I found a big difficult to get into as a whole at first. I think the reason why is the same reason Paul had about Sgt Pepper, and that's the Sgt Pepper movie. Some of the songs on Abbey Road I first heard in that movie, so it kinda ruined it for me. Ha. I can get into it as a whole now, though, and this is where I place it. And yes, I do love that medley at the end. Certainly a great way for them to go out even though I don't think it was initially intended that way.)
7. Magical Mystery Tour
6. Help!
5. Beatles For Sale (SO underrated, this is, I think. Maybe my first favorite Beatles album, believe it or not.)
4. Rubber Soul
3. Sgt Pepper
2. Revolver (Maybe the album I've played more than any other album by anyone. Odd, since it's not my no. 1, but still.)
1. The White Album (My pick for the greatest album ever. By anyone. It's a ride from beginning to end. Yeah, tracks like Wild Honey Pie and Revolution 9 may not work on their own, but as part of the album experience, it ABSOLUTELY works. It has everything I'd want in an album. Rock, ballads, beauty, ugliness, light, shade, humor, anger, horror, experimentation, great vocals, great guitars etc. Take even just one track off it, it doesn't work. The tracks compliment each other, yet they're so varied. A perfect album to me, really. And what a cover too! ;) )
Nah, the 1978 movie wasn't my reason for my Sgt Pepper placement, I was just mentioning how I'd first been exposed to that stuff. That said, I can definitely understand why it would color your opinion. Although it's curious that the movie affects your ranking of Abbey Road but not Pepper.
@@AsItShouldBePodcast Well, I heard those Pepper songs as they were on the original album before I saw the movie, so it didn't really affect that. Took me a while longer to get to Abbey Road, I guess. Ha
@@ErnestIII83 Ah ok
I’ve always liked Revolution 9
@@djcrystalclear8169 Yeah, I always found that one fascinating.
Hey Paul! You know you were born when they recorded Octopus's Garden? I was born when they recorded Sexy Sadie. 🙂
Ah yes! I always forget about that!
yes the white came out with a boxset i didnot unbox
The U.S. version of Rubber Soul is NUMBER ONE...with a Rubber Bullet
i am looking for the butcher cover thats my mississon wish me luck
off the record i do miss the band the cars
How on Earth do you dislike Within you Without you and Fixing a Hole? Those are strong songs on Sgt Peppers.
my beatles i keep them under lock and key i collect them all emi
I don't know if I'm emotionally prepared for this but clicking play... god help us all...
Ha!
It’s been 13 hours…JOE, ARE YOU OKAY!
THREE DAYS, STILL NO REPLY!😳😩
@@djcrystalclear8169 HA! Yes, whew! None of you did the unthinkable or absurd and put yellow sub in a more prestigious rank than it deserved. Love it when my fellow Beatles fans can be objective about their catalog 😍 Also appreciate the lack of smugness over the “spiked” version of Magical Mystery Tour. Only gasped in horror once and that was over Paul’s disdain for Mr Kite 😱.
@@joerichardwad1645yellow submarine underrated
Fun fact - there are over 6.2 billion different ways you can rank The Beatles albums.
People had better start making those videos then. The human race has its work cut out for it.
@As It Should Be you've inspired me to make one!
the more songs yo make the more songs you cant take.
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
sittars georges ideas
ringos at the bottom why he gets payed less hahahaha
ranking their all no1
My rankings :
1. Revolver
2. Abbey Road
3. Rubber Soul
4. Magical Mystery Tour
5. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
6. White Album
7. Help
8. A Hard Day's Night
9. With the Beatles
10. Please Please Me
11. Beatles For Sale
12. Yellow Submarine
13. Let It Be (would be better with « Don’t Let Me Down »)
Let It Be RULES!!!!🤘🏽😎🔥
God I gotta say this is one of the WORST Beatles ranking I've ever seen...the guy in the hat had the best list, the guy in the middle's list was terrible BUT he had Revolver at #1 which is correct, and the girl's list was ALL TYPES OF MESSED UP...none of you really get the The Beatles...Revolver should ALWAYS be #1 or #2 and Sgt. Peppers should be up there as well
they're doing their opinions not the actual greatest albums