One of the most mistreated character EVER!! Before watching s12, I tought she was a bad person seeing how much hate she got, but now that I'm watching it, she's always so kind, sweet but also pretty smart...she's only a bit hesitant, but even Jo and Steph, her only friends, turned their back for a REALLY SILLY reason!!! I hope, just for a bunch of ep, she'll return to have an happy ending as an accomplished neurosurgeon now that she's single!
I hate her because she went to a grieving wife and apologize and when rambling about how she is no a good doctor for the freaking wife's patient that she lost, and made MEREDITH confort HER. Like in the audio said, the patients grief it's the biggest thing in the room, and she made it about herself to a point Meredith had to give her a pep talk. That's when I hated her and it went downhill from there.
@Fatoumata Cisse not really, what was she suppose to do? Slap the doctor in the face and do burr holes herself as a resident that has never done that before
@@joocelyyynn she's one of the most complex characters on the show lol, the reason meredith is such a great character is because of how flawed she is. She wasn't kind to Amelia but let's not pretend it was one-sided. They both said mean but valid things to the other.
@@anacrys1494 imo she’s not. she can be very annoying and so is amelia. meredith used to be likable but after season 8 she got very annoying. she’ll never be anything like christina yang
@@anacrys1494 I totally agree. I experienced losing my younger brother (he was 22) in last december via "hospital accident". I see it on my parents, how they are acting very often with zero sense eversince. The giref took over.
it wasnt penny fault techinally but you can't just expect everyone to be happy. Penny reminds them of derek's death so they;re probalby uncomfortable around her
I don’t see why she blames herself for his death I mean it was that male doctor’s fault. She tried her very hardest to convince him to get a CT and he didn’t listen to her. She really didn’t deserve all that hate, props to her for sticking through it though
sad that this seemed to be more about meredith than penny herself, but i guess that was just her character in a nutshell, wasn't it? another great edit :)
I don't understand the fact that everybody hates penny, she tried to save Derek until the end but she wasn't Listened... I hate it undead because they needed to find a culprit...
I loves your edits! I usually don't enjoy Grey's edits, because they are often very cliché. But your editing-style is unique and amazing. I really would like to see more of it! ☺️
I get where Meredith was coming from but you definitely cannot blame Penny for Derek's death. Number one I think she was an intern not even a resident (could be wrong). Number two if it was Meredith she would have expected her interns or residents to do exactly what she said. Penny asked for the head ct multiple times and her attending said there wasn't time. In the episode with the hiker Peirce kept asking for an EKG and Meredith kept saying there wasn't time. She almost killed him so how is that any different from Penny?
Personally, I didn’t hate Penny, and she didn’t deserve all the hate she got from us fans and the characters; she did not kill Derek but how was everyone supposed to know that? She did her best for Derek, she didn’t fight hard enough for him - as Derek said inside his head, she was a woman so her voice wasn’t listened to or the voice of reason when she was the only one saying that Derek needed a head CT. While Meredith was tough on her, if it wasn’t for Meredith, Penny wouldn’t have stepped up and changed for the better.
emily's edits the edits are only on characters that aren’t in the show anymore as their story has wrapped up. So don’t expect a Alex and Meredith story anytime soon. Arizona and April in the other hand.....
I feel like they didn’t hate Penny for that long. Sure, the times they hated her was extremely annoying but it only lasted for a couple of episodes but I do hate her with Callie and I am glad she left the show because she is a very unnecessary character.
It's not the fact that she killed Derek, because I don't feel like she did, not every resident will push like Cristina, Alex or Meredith to prove they are right, so that it's not the reason I hate her. I hate her because when Meredith went outside the hospital, and Penny was crying, instead of going inside and leaving a grieving wife alone, she not only made her listen to her apologize again, but then to start rambling about how she is not a good doctor and he deserved someone better, and basically forced meredith to make her feel better, telling about the one, telling her she will be a better doctor, and convince her to still be a doctor. She went to a grieving widow and made it about herself. Honestly, just leave the damn woman alone. And then she applied to the hospital that has HER NAME on it! And said that it was a big hospital so she didn't think they will see each other? One Google search and she would have realize that 1: Meredith owns part of the hospital, 2: that she was a surgical doctor and 3: that she was an attending. Like, how dumb can you be to think that you won't see an attending from a surgical program you want to enter? And then said that she wouldn't apply for that grand, then applied last minute, and put Callie and a difficult position with her child and Arizona. Although that I also blame Callie because who the hell moves across the country for a woman you been dating for less than a year? Disrupt your child's whole life so you can get laid? Take a child away from her mother? Not even ASKING the other parent if they are okay, just jumping the gun and not caring about other people? Anyway, I hated her the moment she did that to Meredith, and let's not forget that at the dinner party, after Meredith asked her to leave, instead of leaving, telling Meredith that she did not forget about her Derek. Like bitch, stop making you feel better about yourself. Get out. Don't come back, that woman doesn't need a constant reminder of how you couldn't convince an attending of a head CT for a patient could was bleeding in the head and COULD NOT TALK and how her husband died. And she didn't even get any great moment besides helping Meredith take the wires off her jaw. Besides the chemistry with the other actors were off and the script didn't help me like her, specially since they didn't give her room to grow and tried to make her perfect (perfect penny) and then the hole Callie mess. I just don't like her.
...do you think it was her fault as in she planned to do anything that befell her and the people around her? all of those encounters were beyond her control. Grey sloan memorial was the best teaching hospital in the country..it was all medical students dream to get taught in there. You are here complaining about the grant do you know why she applied later before the attendings meeting that night? It was because her only friends despised her 'coz she was from dillard..and for the fact she was trying to blame herself for derek's death it is because she is human she is trying to atone for her inefficient skills to save derek's promising to be better it's unfortunate her fate crossed with people who lack some basic human decency and ain't mature enough to understand her angle regardless of them being brilliant Doctors.
Believe it or not it's not easy for Doctor or nurses to lose their patients. Based on what I read from everyone in the comments it's not her fault that everything happened. It's hard for Doctor and Nurses to lose their to the point they get emotional about it. So her expressing that she'll wants to become better Doctor because of everything that had happened.
She didn’t. She pushed for the head ct that would have saved his life, but she was overruled by the other doctor who said it wasn’t as important as his internal bleeding. Meredith just needed someone to blame so penny got a lot of the blame, even though it wasn’t her fault at all
![일상 속 기분 좋음 [Proto disco meme]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DwmEIaZ7XGQ/mqdefault.jpg)
One of the most mistreated character EVER!! Before watching s12, I tought she was a bad person seeing how much hate she got, but now that I'm watching it, she's always so kind, sweet but also pretty smart...she's only a bit hesitant, but even Jo and Steph, her only friends, turned their back for a REALLY SILLY reason!!!
I hope, just for a bunch of ep, she'll return to have an happy ending as an accomplished neurosurgeon now that she's single!
Wasn’t expecting to see one of these on Penny! Pleasantly surprised, she was an interesting character.
You guys hate on Penny yet you are comfortable with April forgetting to look at patient’s throat and Izzie cutting the lvad ON PURPOSE.
this!!
Really gonna forget how Meredith and Lexie cost a girl her ability to speak.
i hated april.... and izzy should've never been a dr lol
In my opinion penny just killed the mcdreamy we are made to hate her
She really didn’t deserve all the hate she was getting
reign san she didn’t kill Derek AT ALL tho
Monkey.D Luffy she didn’t kill him she was pushing for a ct and the attending kept saying no
I hate her because she went to a grieving wife and apologize and when rambling about how she is no a good doctor for the freaking wife's patient that she lost, and made MEREDITH confort HER. Like in the audio said, the patients grief it's the biggest thing in the room, and she made it about herself to a point Meredith had to give her a pep talk. That's when I hated her and it went downhill from there.
They don't hate her they hate the fact that she didn't tell them herself that she was Dereck's doctor. And that she didn't tell anyone how she is.
@Fatoumata Cisse not really, what was she suppose to do? Slap the doctor in the face and do burr holes herself as a resident that has never done that before
I hated the way mer blamed penny for Derek’s death because she pushed for a CT and the attending kept ignoring her like penny was still a resident???
when you’ve lost someone you love everything else disappears. meredith was drowning in grief.
I fel tlike mer didn't blame her that much, but like amelia and all the freaking fans do. for one, I don't.
@@anacrys1494 idc is she was in grief she was such a bitch for that. she’s the most annoying person on that show
@@joocelyyynn she's one of the most complex characters on the show lol, the reason meredith is such a great character is because of how flawed she is. She wasn't kind to Amelia but let's not pretend it was one-sided. They both said mean but valid things to the other.
@@anacrys1494 imo she’s not. she can be very annoying and so is amelia. meredith used to be likable but after season 8 she got very annoying. she’ll never be anything like christina yang
God this poor women they treated her like trash
Well, it was a logical move to write her out because of moving away
they were all crowded by their grief. it wasn’t penny’s fault, but when you lose someone you love you blame whoever you can.
@@anacrys1494 I totally agree. I experienced losing my younger brother (he was 22) in last december via "hospital accident". I see it on my parents, how they are acting very often with zero sense eversince. The giref took over.
it wasnt penny fault techinally but you can't just expect everyone to be happy. Penny reminds them of derek's death so they;re probalby uncomfortable around her
I don’t see why she blames herself for his death I mean it was that male doctor’s fault. She tried her very hardest to convince him to get a CT and he didn’t listen to her. She really didn’t deserve all that hate, props to her for sticking through it though
Kendall yeah but Meredith wasn’t there in the room. When
@@sofiaozuna5992 she's the one that took him off life support so yes it is her fault he could have woken u anytime during that time but SHE gave up.
But she could’ve tried harder to get the fr and she knows it too. But at the end of the day it was a mistake she had to learn from
@@ceesayt9379 you need to understand that she was a resident. she’s not in charge
@@sherlyhyppolite1962 she wasn’t in charge. there’s nothing she could have done.
sad that this seemed to be more about meredith than penny herself, but i guess that was just her character in a nutshell, wasn't it? another great edit :)
I don't understand the fact that everybody hates penny, she tried to save Derek until the end but she wasn't Listened... I hate it undead because they needed to find a culprit...
I need one for Arizonaaaaa that would be so amazing
Penny was so unnecessarily over hated. Samantha Sloyan is one of the best actresses.
That is what I was saying;people were so cruel.
I’m watching this right now ! I wish they explored penny a lil bit more
I loves your edits!
I usually don't enjoy Grey's edits, because they are often very cliché. But your editing-style is unique and amazing. I really would like to see more of it! ☺️
Penny was one of my favourite characters.
I love these so much. Thank you for continuing to make them.
Who's here after Midnight Mass?
she was treated so unfairly
The next one has to be Kepner
Amazing work. It was nice how you justified Meredith's dedication to teach her as thats what Derek would have done.
Amazing edits, my God they are beautiful.
Wow! What a character arc!
I get where Meredith was coming from but you definitely cannot blame Penny for Derek's death. Number one I think she was an intern not even a resident (could be wrong). Number two if it was Meredith she would have expected her interns or residents to do exactly what she said. Penny asked for the head ct multiple times and her attending said there wasn't time.
In the episode with the hiker Peirce kept asking for an EKG and Meredith kept saying there wasn't time. She almost killed him so how is that any different from Penny?
An Addison one. please. You make brilliant videos.
April and Arizona will be next after this season 😭 I love your work and all for all characters you done but it sucks losing great characters
I REALLY REALLY WANT TO SEE ONE FOR ADDISON!
omg i love penny
Personally, I didn’t hate Penny, and she didn’t deserve all the hate she got from us fans and the characters; she did not kill Derek but how was everyone supposed to know that?
She did her best for Derek, she didn’t fight hard enough for him - as Derek said inside his head, she was a woman so her voice wasn’t listened to or the voice of reason when she was the only one saying that Derek needed a head CT.
While Meredith was tough on her, if it wasn’t for Meredith, Penny wouldn’t have stepped up and changed for the better.
slow clap, you're the best baby
i forgot derek liked her
I’m rewatching season 12 god they treated her so badly
I was just watching the episode this video started on. It made me think of meredith talking to penny when derek dies
What is the episode?
please do april next!
please do April next!
i LOVE this
That compilation made me like Penny and despise Meredith even more than I already did.
This was so good. JFC.
another WOW!
I love how they put Derek and Christina scenes in this
She got so much hatred which she Didn't deserve
Penny 😂👏Amazing💕😍
Derek my McDreamy liked Penny and you know what?? That's good enough for me if Derek liked her then I like her.
Do one on both April and Arizona!!!!!!
FANTASTIC!! 😆😆
Arizona, April, Jo, Alex and Meredith please ❤️🙏. Thank you so much!
emily's edits the edits are only on characters that aren’t in the show anymore as their story has wrapped up. So don’t expect a Alex and Meredith story anytime soon. Arizona and April in the other hand.....
Loved her. Always hated Wilson.
Do Arizona next. Then Addison. Then Stephanie, then Leah or Shane, then Heather Brooks, and finally, Hahn
Please do one of these for Alex Karev, I love them so much❤
Please do April and Arizona . Or even Webber or Bailey.
Do Stephanie next
Please comeback and make more tributes
I feel like they didn’t hate Penny for that long. Sure, the times they hated her was extremely annoying but it only lasted for a couple of episodes but I do hate her with Callie and I am glad she left the show because she is a very unnecessary character.
WAIT PENNEY IS THE WOMAN WHO LOST HER HUSBAND??! WHATTTT
do karev and grey!
FIRSTTTTT!
It's not the fact that she killed Derek, because I don't feel like she did, not every resident will push like Cristina, Alex or Meredith to prove they are right, so that it's not the reason I hate her. I hate her because when Meredith went outside the hospital, and Penny was crying, instead of going inside and leaving a grieving wife alone, she not only made her listen to her apologize again, but then to start rambling about how she is not a good doctor and he deserved someone better, and basically forced meredith to make her feel better, telling about the one, telling her she will be a better doctor, and convince her to still be a doctor. She went to a grieving widow and made it about herself. Honestly, just leave the damn woman alone. And then she applied to the hospital that has HER NAME on it! And said that it was a big hospital so she didn't think they will see each other? One Google search and she would have realize that 1: Meredith owns part of the hospital, 2: that she was a surgical doctor and 3: that she was an attending. Like, how dumb can you be to think that you won't see an attending from a surgical program you want to enter? And then said that she wouldn't apply for that grand, then applied last minute, and put Callie and a difficult position with her child and Arizona. Although that I also blame Callie because who the hell moves across the country for a woman you been dating for less than a year? Disrupt your child's whole life so you can get laid? Take a child away from her mother? Not even ASKING the other parent if they are okay, just jumping the gun and not caring about other people?
Anyway, I hated her the moment she did that to Meredith, and let's not forget that at the dinner party, after Meredith asked her to leave, instead of leaving, telling Meredith that she did not forget about her Derek. Like bitch, stop making you feel better about yourself. Get out. Don't come back, that woman doesn't need a constant reminder of how you couldn't convince an attending of a head CT for a patient could was bleeding in the head and COULD NOT TALK and how her husband died.
And she didn't even get any great moment besides helping Meredith take the wires off her jaw.
Besides the chemistry with the other actors were off and the script didn't help me like her, specially since they didn't give her room to grow and tried to make her perfect (perfect penny) and then the hole Callie mess.
I just don't like her.
...do you think it was her fault as in she planned to do anything that befell her and the people around her? all of those encounters were beyond her control. Grey sloan memorial was the best teaching hospital in the country..it was all medical students dream to get taught in there. You are here complaining about the grant do you know why she applied later before the attendings meeting that night? It was because her only friends despised her 'coz she was from dillard..and for the fact she was trying to blame herself for derek's death it is because she is human she is trying to atone for her inefficient skills to save derek's promising to be better it's unfortunate her fate crossed with people who lack some basic human decency and ain't mature enough to understand her angle regardless of them being brilliant Doctors.
Believe it or not it's not easy for Doctor or nurses to lose their patients. Based on what I read from everyone in the comments it's not her fault that everything happened. It's hard for Doctor and Nurses to lose their to the point they get emotional about it. So her expressing that she'll wants to become better Doctor because of everything that had happened.
Can somebody explain to me why she « killed » Derek?
She didn’t. She pushed for the head ct that would have saved his life, but she was overruled by the other doctor who said it wasn’t as important as his internal bleeding. Meredith just needed someone to blame so penny got a lot of the blame, even though it wasn’t her fault at all
i hated penny sm
Why?