For me personally, I think the movies handled Shinji's death a lot better than in the original game because there wasn't the weird shaking camera angles and gasps, and Shinji didn't just randomly get up only to die in front of a street light.
The fact that in the movie this was both the senpais and the leader's fault make it even sadder Akihiko and Mitsuru didn't remember And Makoto was slowing down the whole fight
@@OnurArda If you mean Mitsuru and Akihiko, then no. They 100% remembered in the movie. Proof in dialogue. It happens right at the start. Akihiko - "Where's Shinji?" Mitsuru - "Amada did tell me that he couldn't make it today, but..." Akihiko - "Those two are..." Mitsuru - "Akihiko, don't tell me that...!" Akihiko - "Today's October 4th, right? Yamagishi, try to track Shinji and Amada's positions!" They definitely knew. They just couldn't leave. It's only in the manga and game where it's after the battle until they realise.
The real reason is because he thought, that after all the Arcana Shadows (like that roulette shadow) are destroyed, he and his friends would start to drift apart because there would no longer be a common goal for them to stay with each other for.
Makoto was in a dilemma. He wanted to fight shadows to save protect his friends and to be with them. Although he didn’t want to stop the dark hour for he feels his life will have no purpose especially if he and his friends drift apart. It’s after what Takaya said to Makoto that made him think of finishing the dark hour or to stop defeating the major shadows. Makoto wants to have a purpose in his life for he still feels he has no purpose at this point still.
@@fahriza88 While I agree that Takaya is one of the weaker villains in the story and in the series in general the FeMC kinda ruins the whole underlying theme of the story. I like her design and soundtrack but... I'd rather stick with Door-kun
Anyone know the track that plays from 06:29? Seems like a variation on 'That Which Escaped The Darkness' but I can't find this version on the soundtracks for the film or game. Drivin' me crazy!
I think it's the same reason why in other similar media, characters don't just revive dying characters. If you take a close look at the healing skills, you'll notice the resurrective spells often specify "unconsicous" or "KO" rather than "death." Healing skills don't actually repair the body from severe damage - especially internal bleeding and organ failure - because they primarily reinvigorate someone's stamina rather than mending serious cuts and bruises. Revival spells bring a person back from an unconscious state, like splashing water on a sleeping person, not returning the deceased to life. This is why characters still get sick, fatigued, needing to sleep to recover, and why Shinji died.
@@superninja_youtubeThis would also explain why the protagonist can never be revived, since it's heavily implied they just die, which is further supported by the fact Joker had cut lines ordering his party to fall back or saying stuff like "No... not here..." whenever he loses all of his HP.
I wonder how this scene would go in the Female Route. Because 1. Would the pocket watch be implemented? Likely, to make a difference in the story/it happened in the stage play. 2. Makoto's character arc wouldn't work with FeMC because on how FeMC would likely already have a reason to live opposed to him and it would be a bit boring to have the same character arc. 3. She would likely be more inclined to save Shinji and try to put in more effort to fight the shadows so it would instead likely be more harder to fight the strength and fortune than in here.
They'd probably extend the festival scene, with Femc finding the pocket watch there instead of at the police station. Shinji would see it and ask where she found that. He'd say it was his and femc would give it to him. Then on the tragic day, the watch will save him. We'd also probably get an extra scene with him waking up from his hospital bed near the end and running to join the others to see femc on the roof
@@gachahero2170 What kind of Waifu is a toaster, alarm and a bodyguard and also she is an android with emotions and she has machine guns as her fingers?
@@alphakenny1620 idk. I'm just saying that if revival beads were for death, nobody would die because revival beads can be bought at a pharmacy so I think that's it's more of a getup you were unconscious
Just in case this is a serious question : Revival Beads are gameplay mechanic item outside of the narrative aspect of the game. Beads only exist in a gamplay point of view. That's the same with FF7 and Aerith death : Phoenix feathers don't exist in the narrative & you can't bring back the dead with white magic.
For me personally, I think the movies handled Shinji's death a lot better than in the original game because there wasn't the weird shaking camera angles and gasps, and Shinji didn't just randomly get up only to die in front of a street light.
Man, Persona 3 really does have probably my favourite story of the series. So intense
BTW
Grey eyes: He.... doesn't care. He can't feel anything. (Apathy)
Blue eyes: He has emotion stirring up inside him..
talk about being underleveled
Even Makoto has emotion in this one JFC
Yo Ken looking scary as fuck in this....and the deep dark tone of his voice
This dude was really about to murk my homie shinji
The fact that in the movie this was both the senpais and the leader's fault make it even sadder
Akihiko and Mitsuru didn't remember
And Makoto was slowing down the whole fight
They did remember, they just couldn't go because they had to take out the full moon bosses + the strength using it's fences to block them from going.
@@gingerhoney1038 his death could have been prevented only if they had remembered earlier though.
@@OnurArda If you mean Mitsuru and Akihiko, then no. They 100% remembered in the movie. Proof in dialogue. It happens right at the start.
Akihiko - "Where's Shinji?"
Mitsuru - "Amada did tell me that he couldn't make it today, but..."
Akihiko - "Those two are..."
Mitsuru - "Akihiko, don't tell me that...!"
Akihiko - "Today's October 4th, right? Yamagishi, try to track Shinji and Amada's positions!"
They definitely knew. They just couldn't leave. It's only in the manga and game where it's after the battle until they realise.
@@gingerhoney1038 But still, if they had remembered back when they were still at the dorm, things could have developed differently
@@OnurArda Definitely.
*did you see that shinji?*
I laughed but how dare you
Nah, it was cooler how in the game he stood up and went to die in the middle of a spotlight.
Remind me again, why did Makoto wanna stop fighting the Shadows?
The real reason is because he thought, that after all the Arcana Shadows (like that roulette shadow) are destroyed, he and his friends would start to drift apart because there would no longer be a common goal for them to stay with each other for.
Death_13th and Aegis would breakdown as she wouldn’t have a purpose with Makoto
Makoto was in a dilemma. He wanted to fight shadows to save protect his friends and to be with them. Although he didn’t want to stop the dark hour for he feels his life will have no purpose especially if he and his friends drift apart. It’s after what Takaya said to Makoto that made him think of finishing the dark hour or to stop defeating the major shadows. Makoto wants to have a purpose in his life for he still feels he has no purpose at this point still.
@@fahriza88 no
@@fahriza88 While I agree that Takaya is one of the weaker villains in the story and in the series in general the FeMC kinda ruins the whole underlying theme of the story. I like her design and soundtrack but... I'd rather stick with Door-kun
‘have fun’ at the end of the description?
lies
荒垣先輩の名言が何回聞いても泣ける(T_T)
i just notice that ken voice it's sounds like makoto's from danganronpa
Carlos Dario Funez Melendez same voice actor
yeah, Megumi Ogata. It's also the same as Nagito
makoto yuki's voice actor also the same va as togami byakuya from danganronpa
Yeah it’s Megumi san.
Also hanako and nagito of course.
Everyone's forgetting about Shinji Ikari
I don't know why, but Aigis getting smacked aside at 7:11 makes me laugh every time I see it
Billy Debiase not many people watch this today
@@benyshubenbub7665 Ok? What does that have to do with my comment?
Billy Debiase nothing, fool
lmfaooo same
ah years went by..
Why I keep crying every time I repeat this video?
Shinji: where is the fucking diarama?
Yukari, Mitsuru: whistle
phiem Quach I believe it was because the wounds were too severe, therefore they couldn’t do anything about it
The funny thing is, Persona 2 had a similar scene and funnily enough, one of the characters was suggesting to use a Dia spell to heal the deep wound.
Damn, the way the music just cuts off the moment he died.
It's that time again~
revolver jesus strikes again
Its the best day ever! 13:47 - 14:12
こうなることがわかっただろうに何の対策もしなかったのか二人は
Anyone know the track that plays from 06:29? Seems like a variation on 'That Which Escaped The Darkness' but I can't find this version on the soundtracks for the film or game. Drivin' me crazy!
This might be coming late, but I think it's called unavoidable battle.
No he's right, it's that which escaped the darkness
I still don’t understand why one of them didn’t use a dia skill, but that would be boring so it makes sense
I think it's the same reason why in other similar media, characters don't just revive dying characters.
If you take a close look at the healing skills, you'll notice the resurrective spells often specify "unconsicous" or "KO" rather than "death." Healing skills don't actually repair the body from severe damage - especially internal bleeding and organ failure - because they primarily reinvigorate someone's stamina rather than mending serious cuts and bruises. Revival spells bring a person back from an unconscious state, like splashing water on a sleeping person, not returning the deceased to life. This is why characters still get sick, fatigued, needing to sleep to recover, and why Shinji died.
@@superninja_youtube Huh, didn't know that but that's interesting
@@superninja_youtubeThis would also explain why the protagonist can never be revived, since it's heavily implied they just die, which is further supported by the fact Joker had cut lines ordering his party to fall back or saying stuff like "No... not here..." whenever he loses all of his HP.
Why Shinji had to die.....no wonder this game is very depressing and the anime was too much.
If it wasn't for getting shot Shinji would eventually die after taking those pills
I don’t know if I am happy because the 4 October it’s my birthday or sad because Shinji died
The way he sounded at 7:11
He sounds so confused on what to do
IM YOUR BIGGEST FAN OMG
The most tragic moment in p3
what is the name of the soundtrack that begin at 0:15? if anyone know, please tell me
Sense of Isolation
thank you very much!
I wonder how this scene would go in the Female Route.
Because
1. Would the pocket watch be implemented? Likely, to make a difference in the story/it happened in the stage play.
2. Makoto's character arc wouldn't work with FeMC because on how FeMC would likely already have a reason to live opposed to him and it would be a bit boring to have the same character arc.
3. She would likely be more inclined to save Shinji and try to put in more effort to fight the shadows so it would instead likely be more harder to fight the strength and fortune than in here.
They'd probably extend the festival scene, with Femc finding the pocket watch there instead of at the police station. Shinji would see it and ask where she found that. He'd say it was his and femc would give it to him. Then on the tragic day, the watch will save him. We'd also probably get an extra scene with him waking up from his hospital bed near the end and running to join the others to see femc on the roof
@@puffpuffpassmakoI could also see them implanting the NG+ moment where Shinjiro made it their first and he gets to have his romance moment with Femc.
I'M NOT CRYING, YOU'RE CRYING 😭
9:25 THE MIGHTY THOR!!!
Ken sounds like he's barfing tbh
yea this is definitely better than the p3re version (idk how it went in the original though). I refuse to believe mitsuru would just... forget.
i thaught thanatos was gonna bust someones ass
Thanatos is also known as the instant killer as it onlys has mudo skills
Aigis is best waifu change my mind
she is a freaking robot
@@gachahero2170 That is irrelavent
All the waifu’s got their cons, same goes for p4, p5 is really up for debate
@@gachahero2170 What kind of Waifu is a toaster, alarm and a bodyguard and also she is an android with emotions and she has machine guns as her fingers?
She is best waifu! Totally agree with you! Best P3 girl!
Did everyone literally forget about Revival Beads?
That's for unconsciousness not for death. If it was, then nobody would be dead at all. Humanity would have been immortal by then
@@Agent-gi4qvThen why is it game over when you become unconscious? Shouldn't that not be a problem?
@@alphakenny1620 idk. I'm just saying that if revival beads were for death, nobody would die because revival beads can be bought at a pharmacy so I think that's it's more of a getup you were unconscious
How about they can only have effect on persona users?
Just in case this is a serious question : Revival Beads are gameplay mechanic item outside of the narrative aspect of the game. Beads only exist in a gamplay point of view. That's the same with FF7 and Aerith death : Phoenix feathers don't exist in the narrative & you can't bring back the dead with white magic.
Yeah I remember
..... i hate that roulette shadow
Where did you get that video
From the second movie ?
Or if you're asking how he got a hold of the footage, probably from a streaming site like gogoanime or something.
So are we gonna talk about on how easy and annoying this boss is?
Jon the Misunderstood I mean, just wait for fear on the roulette then ghastly wail. Way too easy indeed.
@@shadowhunter-mi5su but you can actually control where it stopped by pressing x in 180° from the desired spots
@@ronnymahendra9035 ...duh. it's not as though that part is mystery to anyone
The people who made Persona 3 Reload were too lazy to work on the scenes
Why was Makoto freaking the fuck out?
Because he didn't want the Dark Hour to end by taking out another master shadow
Use Diarahan, dammit
whyyyyuyy??????
I’m here because of the memes forgive me
ガキさん…
原作再現ありがとう･･･
原作再現も何も原作のやつを映画化したんだから当然なのでは…？
せやな･･･(´；ω；｀)
Shinji sounds too much like zoro in one piece
Raiken anims same VA
Zoro, Hijikata and Shinjiro have the same VA
Atromin no imagine Shinjiro wolfing down mayonnaise while he's cooking
I wonder why~
ただのシンジくんで草
うーん天田君この一件で嫌いなんだけど.....悲しいよなぁ.....憎めない.....
普通に行けば確かに天田くん嫌いになるけど、一方的にって訳じゃなく新垣さんは受け入れた上でやってるし、なんなら新垣さんの言葉があるんよね。
闇雲に憎む事が正しい事ではないって天田だけじゃなく見る側にも刺さるニュアンスあるよなぁ
JUST USE DIA
Dead
Rip shinjiro but im different