You won this fight, but I agree that it is hard to see everything. It takes a fraction of a second to make a decision, and the judges don't have the slow-motion resource.
Great Fight ! Jeannot wins - The old men's eyes of the referees simply can no longer capture these quick actions in this sport - we live in the 21st century and then in Japan - VAR !!!!!!!!! - the same thing over and over again in Japan - old men decide for their own people = a shame and sad -
@1'02- It looks like both fighters missed their targets. @1'33 - from this POV it looks like the kick misses the target. However, some referees have given points for that. @1'46 - It looks like White got a point in. @2'59 - From this POV, RED is in first. Also, he lost balance for a split second, but he didn't fall down. So, the point still stands. @3'39- Referre is right, Red is in first. White did score, but Red got in before. @4''09 - From this POV, one cant see if RED scored. If he did, then he is in first, however, White definitely scores. @4'43 - NO POINT. Weak/ineffective technique. @5'16 - From this POV, it looks like white misses. Great fight.
For what is possible to see, the head kick could have been a wazari or even ippon. I agree that some aiuchi you guys did were super close even if the judges instantly gave wazari to aka. But lots of points you highlight in my opinion were a little out of target or out of distance. Very close, but it is fine they were not wazari in my opinion. Overall, complete masterclass of modern kumite, absolutely impressive performance from both you guys. I love how JKA kumite is right now
Très beau combat de Jonathan, vous devez être fier de lui. Honnêtement ce type de résultat est la raison pour laquelle j'avais personnellement abandonné le karaté compétitif à mon petit niveau amateur. Les arbitres ne peuvent tout voir en temps réel, cela va trop vite et trop d'angles à couvrir. Il faudrait user de vidéo et ralenti à chaque action. Ca et le fait que, dans un véritable combat où l'on porterait les coups, Jonathan aurait certainement eu l'ascendant : allonge, puissance, agressivité, il est clair qu'il a l'avantage. Faites qu'un jour le karaté sportif évolue pour éviter les yakutsuki en chaine et les décisions contestables. Bravo à l'athlète quoi qu'il en soit !
Oui un très beau combat pour Jo ! Croire au one punch .... Il est temps que le karaté évolue .... Technique mouvement et stratégie trop faible le Jap !
it’s a shame that whenever there is aiuchi the brown nose referees just stick their flags out for the Japanese, every single time. It’s been the case at every jka tournament throughout history.
Daylight robbery. This is what will kill this sport. It’s bad enough that it’s not a real fight but to also rob fighters is ridiculous. Might as well let them fight it out.
kind of like dekker fighting in thailand, hits the guy clean with a kick in the head no point, clearly scores his punch first several times and the judges give the point to the other guy, favoritism plain and clear, near the end the black guy should have knocked out the japanese fighter and taken the disqualification
First Place: You lost. Making videos on TH-cam, focusing on your "best moments", doesn't change anything. Points while striking backwards are often not scored. His shot was out of range too, his foot passed the Japanese's head. Conclusion: The Japanese fighter, even though he is smaller, has a better karate stance, fought better, had better technique and won because he was better.
@@plets1172 "Oh yes, of course. Eric Hoffer explained this in his book True Believer. For you, karate begins and ends with the JKA, and you believe the JKA world champion is the world champion of karate. I forgot I was talking to a fan. But my point is about respect, which is something greatly lacking on the part of foreigners toward the Japanese people. This video is proof that competition is valued more than respect. Well, as for me, it would be a pleasure to do a Kumite training with anyone, but please, no TH-cam video."
Its tough going against a multiple and current japan champion. The decision was ok. Could have gone either way . Both gyakutsuki looked to be a split second faster by the opponent. Excited to see more from Jonathan.
I understand your frustration. I feel the same many matches I compete in. I was at iskf world shoto cup in London England. Sometimes, winning the “fight” is not the same as winning the ippon match. I can see for terms of points where Aka scores first. But real life shuro actually had the better attack or counter. Ippon kumite is the rule set we compete in. And sometimes the judges make right or wrong decisions. And sometimes they care to much of the technical point compared to the real life consequences of said points being scored. I competed against an Australian at the shoto cup. Felt I won the fight but he won the “points” to make ippon. You did an amazing job and have amazing karate. Osu! From Alberta canada!. Keep up the amazing training and work! Nothing to hang your head about
You won this fight, but I agree that it is hard to see everything. It takes a fraction of a second to make a decision, and the judges don't have the slow-motion resource.
Great Fight ! Jeannot wins -
The old men's eyes of the referees simply can no longer capture these quick actions in this sport - we live in the 21st century and then in Japan - VAR !!!!!!!!! - the same thing over and over again in Japan - old men decide for their own people = a shame and sad -
@1'02- It looks like both fighters missed their targets. @1'33 - from this POV it looks like the kick misses the target. However, some referees have given points for that. @1'46 - It looks like White got a point in. @2'59 - From this POV, RED is in first. Also, he lost balance for a split second, but he didn't fall down. So, the point still stands. @3'39- Referre is right, Red is in first. White did score, but Red got in before. @4''09 - From this POV, one cant see if RED scored. If he did, then he is in first, however, White definitely scores. @4'43 - NO POINT. Weak/ineffective technique. @5'16 - From this POV, it looks like white misses. Great fight.
For what is possible to see, the head kick could have been a wazari or even ippon. I agree that some aiuchi you guys did were super close even if the judges instantly gave wazari to aka. But lots of points you highlight in my opinion were a little out of target or out of distance. Very close, but it is fine they were not wazari in my opinion. Overall, complete masterclass of modern kumite, absolutely impressive performance from both you guys. I love how JKA kumite is right now
日本空手協会の組手はルールは素晴らしいが審判の考えにおおきな偏りがある
Mulolo should have win this one ... by faaaaaar
They should have use VR here
How manymawashi did Mulolo Kicked
Très beau combat de Jonathan, vous devez être fier de lui. Honnêtement ce type de résultat est la raison pour laquelle j'avais personnellement abandonné le karaté compétitif à mon petit niveau amateur. Les arbitres ne peuvent tout voir en temps réel, cela va trop vite et trop d'angles à couvrir. Il faudrait user de vidéo et ralenti à chaque action. Ca et le fait que, dans un véritable combat où l'on porterait les coups, Jonathan aurait certainement eu l'ascendant : allonge, puissance, agressivité, il est clair qu'il a l'avantage.
Faites qu'un jour le karaté sportif évolue pour éviter les yakutsuki en chaine et les décisions contestables.
Bravo à l'athlète quoi qu'il en soit !
Oui un très beau combat pour Jo ! Croire au one punch .... Il est temps que le karaté évolue .... Technique mouvement et stratégie trop faible le Jap !
La victoria fue tuya, felicitaciones Mulolo, el tiempo te dará revancha saludos desde Uruguay oss!
Mulolo definatly won that match 100%
Mulolo a gagné, nous avons tous vu, comme c'est face à un japonais on lui a arraché la victoire.
On veut la revanche
That's day light robbery
Mulolo Winner please
it’s a shame that whenever there is aiuchi the brown nose referees just stick their flags out for the Japanese, every single time. It’s been the case at every jka tournament throughout history.
Jonathan should've won it. but they sided with the opponent. So it is what is then. Respect! Oss!
Daylight robbery. This is what will kill this sport. It’s bad enough that it’s not a real fight but to also rob fighters is ridiculous. Might as well let them fight it out.
Hello Jon, that was a good match!
👊🏼ss !!! 🇧🇷
Не честно! чёрный выиграл
kind of like dekker fighting in thailand, hits the guy clean with a kick in the head no point, clearly scores his punch first several times and the judges give the point to the other guy, favoritism plain and clear, near the end the black guy should have knocked out the japanese fighter and taken the disqualification
Tem um bandeira que mesmo encoberto marca para o AKA....que triste isso!
Belgier haben nichts drauf
Das wusste man schon in der fremden Legion
First Place: You lost. Making videos on TH-cam, focusing on your "best moments", doesn't change anything. Points while striking backwards are often not scored. His shot was out of range too, his foot passed the Japanese's head. Conclusion: The Japanese fighter, even though he is smaller, has a better karate stance, fought better, had better technique and won because he was better.
Where is your JKA world championship video Mr Keyboard expert?
@@plets1172 "Oh yes, of course. Eric Hoffer explained this in his book True Believer. For you, karate begins and ends with the JKA, and you believe the JKA world champion is the world champion of karate. I forgot I was talking to a fan. But my point is about respect, which is something greatly lacking on the part of foreigners toward the Japanese people. This video is proof that competition is valued more than respect. Well, as for me, it would be a pleasure to do a Kumite training with anyone, but please, no TH-cam video."
Lo bombearon al negro..
Those moments that you repeated so many times, I think it was not enough. Next time see if you can repeat them at least 20 times!!
Its tough going against a multiple and current japan champion. The decision was ok. Could have gone either way . Both gyakutsuki looked to be a split second faster by the opponent. Excited to see more from Jonathan.
I understand your frustration. I feel the same many matches I compete in. I was at iskf world shoto cup in London England. Sometimes, winning the “fight” is not the same as winning the ippon match. I can see for terms of points where Aka scores first. But real life shuro actually had the better attack or counter. Ippon kumite is the rule set we compete in. And sometimes the judges make right or wrong decisions. And sometimes they care to much of the technical point compared to the real life consequences of said points being scored. I competed against an Australian at the shoto cup. Felt I won the fight but he won the “points” to make ippon. You did an amazing job and have amazing karate. Osu! From Alberta canada!. Keep up the amazing training and work! Nothing to hang your head about
ホントにこれで勝っていいのか？VAR導入コスト高いならスマホでチェックできるだろうに。
老いた審判の動体視力を競技人生左右する場に委ねていいのか？
Je sui déçu de sept victoires
あなたの勝ちだと思う。
それにしても酷い判定だ。
Primeiro passou, nada
eu fui escolhido pelo karatê arte divina paixão a primeira vista
What a ripoff! - Quelle arnaque !
Jonathan lutou bem melhor