Will India Be the Next China?| An Indian's Take | OVERLAP
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ธ.ค. 2023
- It has been going on for many years now and there are always voices saying that India will be the next China. This voice is especially numerous when the total size of India's population has surpassed that of China to become the most populous country in the world, and when India continues to export its elites and scholars to the world. And it even affects China-India relations to some extent. What are the reasons supporting this view? How do Indians and Chinese view this argument? How do they view each other's countries and the bilateral relations? In this episode of Overlap, we invited Mr. Jayant Bhandari, a senior commentator from India, and Zephyr, a leading current affairs commentator from China, to discuss all the topics above!#India #China #India-ChinaRelations #Overlap #WaveMedia
Not sure if India will be the next China. But very certain that America will be the next India. 😂😂😂
You might be right.
We do have lots of homeless here and I believe is getting worse...
Brilliant, brilliant way to enlighten us, it certainly is going that way very soon
@@loveblindhate9318your America still far better then İndia.. Even Ciwil War Cauntry like a Syria Better then İndia.. Dont believe these İndians cause They are To much Nasionalist. Travel the İndia, see with your eyes, Then you will understand what is the Hell...
Currently, the US has a VP is half Indian. Also, the coming US election, the next President or VP can be an Indian American. In short, the US, UK who are the current leaders of the free world are practically run by Indians...
Former prime minister of Singapore LKY said: India is the country of the future where the future NEVER arrives 😂
hot damn 😂
yes
LKY then only see the indian were quite smart lots, but he overlooked their political policies and divided groupings that all went out of the windows. The future will never arrived
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
Did he really say that?
Not unless they become more honest, less vile, more polite, less deceptive, etc.
40 years of experience tells me this.
Yes .. Americans have a long way to go.
the best of Made in India, for me personally, is Darjeeling Tea...but still, it was brought to India from Fujian, China...😅😅😅
In Australia. The only things I can see from India are spices and a type of rice for briyani . That’s about it . More things from even Bangladesh and Sri Lanka
India should target to be the next US, not CHina. China is already much bigger than the US. Don't try to run before learning how to walk.
Short of a social and cultural revolution. Ain't gonna happen!
Why should we. We want to be above petty politics and power games. We want to be vishwaguru.
@@tekumallasrinivasachakrava9214 Above petty politics? Have you seen your country's politics? Petty politics are what India does 24/7!
@@tekumallasrinivasachakrava9214 Petty politics is everything India represents
India 2023 GDP is similar to China 2007 GDP but....one is in DEFICIT the other was in SURPLUS.
*India 2023:*
GDP: $3.9 trillion (est)
Exports: $772 billion (est)
Imports: $832 billion (est)
Trade Deficit: $100 - 200 billion (est)
Forex Reserves: $615 billion
Literacy Rate = 69%
*China 2007:*
GDP: $3.43 trillion
Exports: $1.22 trillion
Imports: $956 billion
Trade Surplus: $264 billion
Forex Reserves $1.33 trillion
Literacy Rate = 95%
Today despite similar population number at 1.4b, India only have 672m workforce vs 931m for China. 48% Indian worked to support the others 52% unproductive population vs 66% Chinese worked to support the others 34% unproductive population.
*India:*
Population 1.4b
Male 700m = 73% labor force participation rate
Female 700m = 23% labor force participation rate (On par with Somalia, Pakistan, Palestine)
Total workforce = 511+ 161 = 672m
Literacy Rate = 69%
*Educated workforce = 463m*
Arable land = 154 million hectares
Grain production = 330 million tons
Grain Reserve = 57.9 million tons
*China:*
Population 1.4b
Male 700m = 72 % labor force participation rate
Female 700m = 61% labor force participation rate (On par with Canada, Netherlands, Israel)
Total workforce = 504 + 427 = 931m
Literacy Rate = 97%
*Educated workforce = 903m*
Arable land = 127 million hectares
Grain production = 686 million tons
Grain Reserve = >700 million tons
Comparing *India to China* is akin to comparing *Pakistan to Japan* , *Bangladesh/Nepal to South Korea* , *Sri Lanka to Taiwan* . One group is influenced by Chinese civilization, the others group is influenced by Indian civilization. Two different class. One is Yellow the others is Brown/Dark. One uses chopsticks, the others uses bare hand. The most developed country in ASEAN is Singapore, a nation populated by predominantly Chinese an East Asian origin people.
One group collectively & consistently ranked within the world top 10-20 in IQ Test, PISA Score, University Rank, International Collegiate Programming Contest (ICPC) & Mathematical Olympiad, standing shoulder to shoulder with western world ....while the others group collectively & consistently ranked somewhere in the middle out of 100+ participant nation standing shoulder to shoulder with some failed states & banana republic.
Comparing South Asia with East Asia is like comparing Africa with Europe. No developed countries exist outside of Western & East Asian world.
sounds a bit harsh but fact is fact.
Racism is a property of white people and their victims (people who hate their own race), one day all people in this world will be able to live in their own “developed countries”，This is what our Chinese government has always believed. We have also experienced absolute hunger, absolute poverty, and self-denial. We Chinese do not believe that race determines destiny.
I agree with you, but one sad thing I have noticed that the high iq chinese women (east Asian) are marrying south Asian men in huge numbers and the sad fact is that, the richer the Chinese women become, more they get mixed with brown Indian men. 😢 Soon east asian will mix with Indians and Africans Sadly. I see this all day in Singapore 😔 save chinese women 😢
Palki Sharma will give a fitting reply to Bandari
@@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq --- Palki is still working on it, it may take eternity
I was in New Delhi for exhibition at the Exhibition Centre Pragati Madan before Covid-19. An Indian that I have met in one of the Indian exhibition booths and he told me this when we were discussing and comparing Indian and Chinese products. I was surprised he told me this. "The Chinese they are learning very fast from us. In the next 20 years times they will sure be catching up with us" I just smiles and say nothing.
Staggering delusions of superiority.
❤😂😂😂😂
20年我觉得赶不上，起码得200年吧
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
Unfortunately this will keep them from progressing forward. Delusion is never good for growth
Not because l differ with Indian policy and attitude, but l prefer truth, facts and unbiased views, l feel like saluting Mr Bhandari, sir. Thanks for fair and truthful info, gentlemen.
Every country has cycles of highs and lows. Trashing India does nothing for the betterment of mankind.
Its Indians that who are trashing India, he is just making observations of the trash that India is.
@stephenc6955 India seems to diving deep into the ravine at current time. I don't see anyway out , unless there is a strongman with brain, like putin. Modi is strong but may not be strong enough, and certainly has no brain.
@stephenc6955
4 hours ago
Every country has cycles of highs and lows. Trashing India does nothing for the betterment of mankind.
Indians live in fantasy world believing they are going to be number one in the world. The truth hurts
谁也蹂躏不了印度，能蹂躏印度只有印度自己，我们谈论印度只不过拿他当一个分析案例而已@@stephenc6955
This is one rational and truthful Indian. He understands the Indian situation well.
No no no, to Indians he is a complete anti national who doesn't want any good for his country, which is why he's wasting all of his time which he could've rather spent on actual business on criticising India.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
Dude you haven't seen him entirely, he is one big chunk of fake news and government should be looking at him seriously.
Anglo Saxons are good at listening and Indians are good at talking them up, whereas Chinese are good at doing.
I am an Indian and I am offended at this. I also begrudgingly accept the truth in this.
Jayant is so knowledgeable and articulate. His factual analysis will not please extreme Indian nationalists 😢
Lol he is simply biased😂
There are so many wholes in his arguments that one can drive a Maruti car through it.
@@arunsar7893 not as many holes as your grammar
@@rjbse Typos aren't grammatical errors, genius.
@@arunsar7893 Give me an example
Impossible to be China 2.0. For this you need a government focused on the interests of the nation. Democracy forces the focus to be on the politicians to remain/gain power.
Think about this, India doesn't have a national language, the can't even communicate within themselves! lol
What a good answer!
Modi has been working very hard just for that, so it’s happening and it will be done.
Even if they can duplicate the success, it will take them 20 years to reach where Cina is today. By that time, Cina will be at another level.
What about korean success, that should be the model.
The guest description of India paints an image of my Nigeria to me.
These diverse democracies of developing countries are highly corrupt, hence development is slow. They all have a long way to go before their economies will be truly developed
In that sense, India is truly a leader of global South 😜😜
Yes Jayant Bhandari, an Indian Financial analyst doesn't bullshit about India. Indians got no moral compass. Just grab and enjoy for the moment, without a thought for the consequences tomorrow. Police stations are rape and bribe centers in India. Only in japan, Taiwan and China are places where he is never scare of the police. He was shocked that women can ventured out alone onto the streets at night. Democracy is the worst form of government because it puts idiots in charge. In the west, out of 100 , 2 will help you when you are in a difficult position, In India, out of 10,000, all will leave you to die on your own. There was shame in bribe, but nowadays it is the norm for all politicians and government employees. Only country worse than India is Congo. Indians are feral beings-only wants material and sex. Indians treated other Indians so badly, that the population welcome the Mughal Muslim rulers. He travelled over 100 countries, studying the inhabitants and way of life by staying out of hotel and live like the natives , all to better advise his clients about international investments. But he is not completely right in his observation. But India? A complete hopeless case, just take the bribe.
Nigeria & India is indeed have a lot of thing in common. Recently in Nigeria, the police demand money from a Dutch rider on the highway. The exact something had happened in India. Recently in India, the police demand money from a Korean driver on the road. Both Nigeria & India police seem to be having the same modus operandi.
In India, police stations are rape and bribe centers. Bribery is an accepted in India, and it is open-everybody knows and it is not hidden. I doubt it is the same in Nigeria. Nigerian will be quiet about it?
@@udhayakumarMNNigeria is more chance to become Rich than India because they've oil and gas, India's biggest disadvantage is energy insecurity
Most Chinese dont care about India, but the Indians love China soo much😂😂😂
Especially palki sharma..
You need a /s on the end of your comment for those who are not in on the joke...🤣😂🤣😂
Most intelligent people will get the joke.
Lol may be it's ur assumption
@@cashmerecat9269 Palki Sharma can not be alive without saying CHINA once a day .
For everyone who has been in both China & India will know that India has no chance in overtaking China… especially with the Caste system in place , the smart Indians who tried to get out of this has no choice but to leave India
Not just the caste system. The people disciplines, boastful mouth and arrogant mentality need to change too.
The caste system wipes out around 1 billion potential population, for they're looked at like animals AND HAVE NO CHANCE. India's economy is catered to around 400 million and that might be a good stretch on my part.
@@panyaboonc5621No education.
The modren victims of caste are bramhins only. The scs and st s are privileged now with government schemes, reservations etc. Hence majority of bramhins are forced to migrate.
@@tekumallasrinivasachakrava9214And the brahmins were the historical intelligentsia of India. With their migration, India has no brain.
My father who himself was a Govt officer in India, was forced to retire because he was straightforward. And after retiring he continued to fight the local town bureaucrats, and finally he won after spending 20,000 for court trials and such, for a bribe amount of 2000 which he refused to give.
😂😂😂
It’s indeed a rude surprise to know corruption are so rampant in India. It has become part of India’s culture
@@basichem1 Part of Indian culture? It is the Indian culture IMHO.The caste system that has been destroyed on paper, but still prevalent on every bit of Indian society is the biggest corruption and the largest obstacle India is facing today.
😂
😂
Always love to hear Mr. Jayant Bhandari views
Insightful. Hope India will not be used by western countries. And India must realize that China, as a close and ancient neighbour, is much more valuable that any of its former colonial masters.
It is too bad for India that Modi is an American idolizing poodle and feels comfortable on a leash.
The real idea is to recreate an empire by recapturing lands controlled by BHARATS, a legendary tale in the Rigveda
@EdinAibak
4 hours ago
The BJP government is carried by RSS ideology of Hindutva nationalism, and idea not to develop India into a great power like China, the idea to become to a country called Ramarajya. A fully hindu run state, and all other minorities should be suppressed. After they took control of India, what they doing is changing all things related to secularism and enforcing state government to accept it, and dismantling democracy. If any state not willing implement their ideology, punishing them with using central institutions. So now most of the state are in trouble to survive by economically and demographically. And today's India is more divided, no hope to succeed
Indians only looks upto only Anglo Saxons.
@@biggpicture2930What's university
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
The sad part is that they are more poor and hungry people in India than there are in sub Saharan Africa.
I’m really like this Indian guy telling the truth about the talks. Many thanks!!
It takes courage to be so objective
This gentleman is stating facts and current truth and in the long run, Indian might learn how China became successful and follow that path. Working with China would improve the the economic. But with the current India rhetoric and anti China view, India will be stuck in the limbo.
Settle border? When they want to conquer CHINA.
Wild disturbing dream of all Hindu in conquering South East Asia, China Pakistan etc . what-are-some-negative-aspects-of-akhand-bharat-1b185a860cb3
Akhand Bharat: United India
This one word is enough to describe the Dream of Every Hindu.
If you don’t know about Akhand Bharat, then let me explain it to you.
This is How Akhand Bharat looks like
Akhand Bharat isn’t a Good Idea at this Point. But at what point?
Problems Before Making Akhand Bharat:
India has to deal with 2 Nuclear Powers namely China and Pakistan. and it seems to be the worst idea to go for a full-fledge war with these 2 countries.
It also depends on whether the people from the countries that I have mentioned above even want to join with India or Not. Because if they don’t want to join with us then there will be some major Civil Wars that will happen across these Countries and groups of People.
Getting International Recognition will be hard because many people throughout the world will not accept this and this may even harm the image of India on the International Stage.
If India somehow succeeds in making Akhand Bharat then there are a lot of Chances that some fringe elements will again try to Separate our Country.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
@gotislay The Indian gentleman couldn't come up with any good ideas. He is not the mouthpiece of the National Congress Party as you might imagine. Because India's problems cannot be solved by one person. Even the genius Lee Kuan Yew couldn't solve it.
All Jayant Bhandari did was tell the TRUTH. Why can’t you Indians accept it and try to make your country better?
I don't think he is telling complete truth
Yes Jayant, amongst the few telling the truth
@@prashanth7097 coz you're brainwashed by Hindutva Nationalism
Truth or not, the.fact that multinational corporations like Apple, Microsoft, Foxxcon, HUAWEI, Xiaome left india tells us something
@@prashanth7097 Believe me, Jayant spoke the truth, everything he said was 100% correct because they all are things I already knew about india and indian attitude and culture.
Great discussion. 🫡 Mr. Jayant Bhandari.
Even though the truth really hurts him deep down, but he courageously called a spade, a spade.
May India have somebody like Mr. Vladimir Putin or the late Mr. Deng Xiaoping. I know, both are far from perfect, but what they have done to their nation, is HISTORY.
India will never have. Because of the freaking Caste System.
Sista behaving badly.
They make other black people look bad.
th-cam.com/video/iruNtX04500/w-d-xo.html
Endia has palki sharma to smear China..
I think he enjoys bashing india
Yes Jayant Bhandari, an Indian Financial analyst doesn't bullshit about India. Indians got no moral compass. Just grab and enjoy for the moment, without a thought for the consequences tomorrow. Police stations are rape and bribe centers in India. Only in japan, Taiwan and China are places where he is never scare of the police. He was shocked that women can ventured out alone onto the streets at night. Democracy is the worst form of government because it puts idiots in charge. In the west, out of 100 , 2 will help you when you are in a difficult position, In India, out of 10,000, all will leave you to die on your own. There was shame in bribe, but nowadays it is the norm for all politicians and government employees. Only country worse than India is Congo. Indians are feral beings-only wants material and sex. Indians treated other Indians so badly, that the population welcome the Mughal Muslim rulers. He travelled over 100 countries, studying the inhabitants and way of life by staying out of hotel and live like the natives , all to better advise his clients about international investments. But he is not completely right in his observation. But India? A complete hopeless case, just take the bribe.
INDIANS TALK THE TALK.
CHINESE WALK THE WALK.
This gentleman is actually doing a service by speaking the truth.
Funny fact, it is India that uses the old colonial map, of their old colonial master, the British-Raj, to claim territory of all their neighbors.
And there was no "India" as a country until the British came to unite the regions by force right?!
Exactly, it was the Moghul Empire, nothing to do with H-Indians.
Moghuls are Muslims.
People of Brag-Rhat can be Muslims, but the leadership of the Moghul Empire were Muslims, not H-Indians.
The real idea is to recreate an empire by recapturing lands controlled by BHARATS, a legendary tale in the Rigveda
@EdinAibak
4 hours ago
The BJP government is carried by RSS ideology of Hindutva nationalism, and idea not to develop India into a great power like China, the idea to become to a country called Ramarajya. A fully hindu run state, and all other minorities should be suppressed. After they took control of India, what they doing is changing all things related to secularism and enforcing state government to accept it, and dismantling democracy. If any state not willing implement their ideology, punishing them with using central institutions. So now most of the state are in trouble to survive by economically and demographically. And today's India is more divided, no hope to succeed
Wild disturbing dream of all Hindu in re-conquering South East Asia, China Pakistan etc . what-are-some-negative-aspects-of-akhand-bharat-1b185a860cb3
Akhand Bharat: United India
This one word is enough to describe the Dream of Every Hindu.
If you don’t know about Akhand Bharat, then let me explain it to you.
This is How Akhand Bharat looks like -'CHECK MAP'
Akhand Bharat isn’t a Good Idea at this Point. But at what point?
Problems Before Making Akhand Bharat:
India has to deal with 2 Nuclear Powers namely China and Pakistan. and it seems to be the worst idea to go for a full-fledge war with these 2 countries.
It also depends on whether the people from the countries that I have mentioned above even want to join with India or Not. Because if they don’t want to join with us then there will be some major Civil Wars that will happen across these Countries and groups of People.
Getting International Recognition will be hard because many people throughout the world will not accept this and this may even harm the image of India on the International Stage.
If India somehow succeeds in making Akhand Bharat then there are a lot of Chances that some fringe elements will again try to Separate our Country.
And thats why they H*** Communist Party of China.
Fascist and Communists are sworn enemies.
The next China is................CHINA!
India Day Dreaming
5:05 India exporting all their best talent overseas is precisely why they cannot surpass China. The brain drain is not returning to the motherland. They increase the power of the West!
Indiais their HR pool but the pool itself cannot grow a forest
but they also hold dual citizenships which could be beneficial to India
@@intelmind789 India does not allow dual citizenship
@@intelmind789Nice joke don’t lie Indian government doesn’t allow dual citizenship moreover you won’t be able to integrate back into Indian society once you become a temporary member of any other country of the world!
@@intelmind789Once you leave India you become an NRI ( Non Resident Indian) you have to give up your citizenship of other country only then you can become an Indian citizen once again 😂!
You have to respect this guy being critical of his own country while most Western media, motivated by the anti-China agenda, increasingly praises India will overtake China soon.
Ha ha ha ha ha ha
The msm are looking for lackeys for the empire, well India and the Philippines are kissing their ass now
這樣的人才是可怕的對手，因為他知道自己的問題，然後對症下藥去改善，不像一些自大而愚蠢的人，連自身有什麼問題都不知道。
they want war between china & india. Whoever is left, they want to colonize that country.
Very enlightening
What I know about India is second hand. And I picked up basically what the guest said about India. Although I was surprised by the claim of rampant bribery. India will never become the next China. That is something I completely agree with. The leadership is the problem in India. And ignorance is becoming rampant in India.
Yes Jayant Bhandari, an Indian Financial analyst doesn't bullshit about India. Indians got no moral compass. Just grab and enjoy for the moment, without a thought for the consequences tomorrow. Police stations are rape and bribe centers in India. Only in japan, Taiwan and China are places where he is never scare of the police. He was shocked that women can ventured out alone onto the streets at night. Democracy is the worst form of government because it puts idiots in charge. In the west, out of 100 , 2 will help you when you are in a difficult position, In India, out of 10,000, all will leave you to die on your own. There was shame in bribe, but nowadays it is the norm for all politicians and government employees. Only country worse than India is Congo. Indians are feral beings-only wants material and sex. Indians treated other Indians so badly, that the population welcome the Mughal Muslim rulers. He travelled over 100 countries, studying the inhabitants and way of life by staying out of hotel and live like the natives , all to better advise his clients about international investments. But he is not completely right in his observation. But India? A complete hopeless case, just take the bribe.
India is one of the most corrupt countries in the world. Most Asians know this.
During Deng's era, corruption and bribery were problems that China tolerated a small amount of corruption and bribery because things still got done. Under Xi, China got very serious about clamping down on corruption. Under Modi, corruption isn't being reduced, likely because Modi and his cronies are on the take. Worse still, in India, bribes don't guarantee things actually get done. In China, if you pay bribes for a bridge, you still get a working bridge. In India, you pay bribes and are lucky if any progress occurs.
@ZweiZwolf Elections in India also cost lots of money. The rich pays for modi's election. Modi pays the voters etc. The rich gets airport or port, and walked away from criminal investigations. Voters get money and entrenched in nationalist Hindutva ideology- most voters buy into his ideology and he is very safe in winning. Modi run India by spending time praying at temples. Bribes are expected at all levels. Police stations are also mob HQ. They kicked out the old gangs, and took over their operations. They are money making centers. Top national police job pays so much less that nobody wants the position.
@ZweiZwolf
17 minutes ago
During Deng's era, corruption and bribery were problems that China tolerated a small amount of corruption and bribery because things still got done. Under Xi, China got very serious about clamping down on corruption. Under Modi, corruption isn't being reduced, likely because Modi and his cronies are on the take. Worse still, in India, bribes don't guarantee things actually get done. In China, if you pay bribes for a bridge, you still get a working bridge. In India, you pay bribes and are lucky if any progress occurs.
China had lots corruption bribery 20 years (give or take few years) ago, is why there is a listing of rich Chinese live in the West that are Wanted....
I've watched many of Jayant's videos. He's really intelligent and a world class citizen who sees things through deeply.
I'm a personal friend of his. He is indeed a great man. It takes balls to expose this nation day after day. He gets abused a lot on Twitter by offended deluded Indians.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
@@gotislay yeah and it is good for us 😂😂 , otherwise they will create problem for us which will be bad for our growth in long run
Thank you for JB’s honesty, as he says fact is fact. I have watched many videos and comments people made that India will be the next China until we visited India this December. My humble opinion aligned with Mr. JB. You need to understand their social systems, religions, political systems, education issues, infrastructure state, etc., then you will agree with Mr. JB. We saw hungry people, starving cows and starving dogs everywhere. Royal families are still holding wealth and properties in most of the regions except south of the India (Kochi where we visited). After visiting India, we are positive that India will not be the next China. Go see yourself and try to understand their culture and history, you will know Mr. JB is right.
Exactly!
I used to think so but I changed my opinion. It is very much possible for India to become next china as India is moving faster.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
Only parts in North India are truly poor and undeveloped.
But that doesn't mean the entire country is worn down.
I have travelled throughout the country. India is opening itself up to the world much later than China did. So developments will take time.
Moreover major economists, world bank, Goldman Sachs have predicted India will see a steady rise in its GDP per capita in the 20 years to come.
More people are exiting poverty.
The caste system exists in villages and that too in North India.
Come to India to see yourself that the constitution have given certain reservations, facilities to the lower castes in Education and Job sectors.
Sc/ obc/ st quotas are there in all government institutions and jobs for the scheduled castes, tribes and backward classes. Their cutoff marks are far lower than general castes to secure those seats.
@@user-sn6hd4kg6b "Moreover major economists, world bank, Goldman Sachs have predicted India will see a steady rise in its GDP per capita in the 20 years to come." These institutions and so-called economists that wrongly predicted the collapse of Chinese economy how many times now? Short of a social and cultural revolution, India will stay more or less the same in the future.
Do agree when I went to India the immigration official was asking for a bribe.
Never say never. Nobody would have predicted that China would become the second-largest economy in such a short time when it first opened to the world. But it is going to be hard for India to replicate the China miracle.
That day will be forever. Hinduism is all about paying bribe to 'gods' for something good in the future. It got worst and everybody is accepting bribes as a culture. India 's government is not in charge. The rich are in charge and have control of the country. Election need lots of money to win. Whomever help pay to win elections will see corruption stays. So no hope for India.
Yes, never say never.. but I don't see it happening in the next 100 yrs tbh..
Well, Napoleon sort of predicted that, didn't he?
Modiji clearly told that he does not care about GDP statistics. What he proposes is permeanent wealth , prosperity and comfortable lifestyle for common people. This model is worthy endeavour. It may take longer time but results are worth the prolonged time.
I was thinking about the same. The guest may have been little to pessimistic but he is wishing well for India as we all are.
Nothing against India and a good stable India is good for the world as well but what Mr. Jayant Bhandari says reflects the actual true scenario. It is what it is.
In my country, the only thing made in India are immigrants
A full thesis would be too long, but there are generally many factors why India keeps falling behind China, even though it is supposed to have the benefit of 'democracy' since independence.
To begin with, spiritually(this is often not discussed), the inability of India to eliminate historical social inequality, and caste, over millenias creates Karmical Debt preventing blessings. Comparatively, China has rid itself of feudal yoke, thanks to Mao Zedong. Without institutiuonal equality, free-market capitalism becomes exploitative.
Culturally, the absence of 'Confucian ethics' system, which can be deemed non-democratic, can explain the economic miracles of the 4 Asian Tigers, as well as China. To be a top tier power, or for India to be the next China, it has to first be a manufacturing powerhouse, which will be difficult given it's difference in 'having discipline'.
In a more layman observation, generally, very good Talkers are rarely good 'Do-ers', for if you can talk yourself away, there is no real need to have actual performance. On the other hand, many exceptional 'Do-ers', find it hard to explain to the crowd. At the macro level, we can see very obviously that one culture is a Talker, while the other can be categorized more as a 'Do-er'.
4 Asian tigers are almost extinct except for Singapore 😂 then Taiwan and Hong Kong are increasingly dependent on Mainland China
@@Carbuncle0168 True, because none of them were able to develop and execute deep strategies as Singapore, known as a 'nanny state' or the least democratic amongst these peers. short term rotating governments who did not look beyond their terms, as well as domestic and international real-politik did all the other Tigers in...
@@johnchan1272 what do you think about Taiwan?
@@Carbuncle0168 That would be such a sky-wide question, but here is my 2 cents from the top of mind as a casual outsider:
Taiwan, a lovely and more lively country than staid Singapore, where old Chinese traditions can retain and modern talents can thrive, but is unfortunately and probably sleep-walking to disaster, because of 'English-Tsai' and gang, who though seems to be battle-crying for 'Freedom', but alas, may not have the ultimate concerns for the common folks of Taiwan, nor for her own race that she was born to ...
India is where words are more important than deeds.
We also have to understand why Indians are not united -- before the British came, there was no such a country called India. The land was populated by many ethnic groups and controlled by different warlords and small kingdoms. Although the land is united now, the fraction still exists. That's why it is so difficult to build infrastructure that spans multiple states; The bickering is real.
British had done a great job on science and industry, but then look what British left all over the world 😂
Exactly, they don't even speak the same language.
Pre-Raj, there were 500+ Indian kingdoms. India has NEVER been a country, NEVER been united. India would actually be better as a loose Confederation of 500+ self-governing states.
Actually, in our ancient literature our geography is clearly defined.althou different kingdoms were there, culturally india is one.all the population except communists accept this. So inspite of your ignorance , india will be united, prosper and progress.
@@tekumallasrinivasachakrava9214 Hate to break it to you. Short of a social and cultural revolution, India will stay more or less the same in the future. Good luck 'cause India is going to need a lot of it!
I have been to cities like Mumbai, Delhi, Agra, and Goa and I cannot envisage India to be like China in the 21st century, prosperous, safe, industrialized and even more modern than the west. It is the western perception that by making products with the Indian cheap labor the west can benefit and pushes India up to be the “factory” of the world. But the practice is the contrary, many western companies have encountered problems of low quality, lower productivity, cultural differences and government’s meddling that make them loose their competitiveness against Chinese companies. India has never had unity nor human rights.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
AIPAC vs. AOC & The Squad
th-cam.com/video/ksIRypOsgAM/w-d-xo.html
My !!! U went to India , Up to today I have no Intention or plan to visit or go for a tour of any places in India . I speak Tamil not able to read or write , - Understand Southern Indian culture
Florida's Cities in Crisis Due to Homelessness, Poverty, and Crime
th-cam.com/video/pal019F8-p4/w-d-xo.html 😕
India is India
I think it's very difficult for India to achieve what China has achieved. The bureaucracy, countless opposing voices within India, and also their work culture and business ethics still cannot match. I just saw a TH-cam that said India decided not to pay up for the remaining amounts due for rafale fighters to France and has been trying to make things difficult for France by proposing to pay in rupee which France does not need. The contract is for payment in euro, so just perform accordingly and stop all these games
Lol that's just one of 1000s of examples. France learned the hard way. India must always pay in full in advance before even things are made for them ! And what is rupee for? India makes nothing so u cant use ruppees
Dont forget also India is considered a graveyard for foreign investment..
That is the very essence of being a Indian ,
Win at all cost today ,
Let the next generation worry about today bad action and consequences .
See any trend of Indian migration cha ging from outward to inward migration ?
People vote with their feet , that's very telling .
@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq That day will be forever. Hinduism is all about paying bribe to 'gods' for something good in the future. It got worst and everybody is accepting bribes as a culture. India 's government is not in charge. The rich are in charge and have control of the country. Election need lots of money to win. Whomever help pay to win elections will see corruption stays. So no hope for India.
@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq
49 minutes ago
@biggpicture2930 At one point China wasn't also as corrupt until arrival of Xi Jumping. India may one day have her own "Xi Jinxing"
Yes Jayant Bhandari, an Indian Financial analyst doesn't bullshit about India. Indians got no moral compass. Just grab and enjoy for the moment, without a thought for the consequences tomorrow. Police stations are rape and bribe centers in India. Only in japan, Taiwan and China are places where he is never scare of the police. He was shocked that women can ventured out alone onto the streets at night. Democracy is the worst form of government because it puts idiots in charge. In the west, out of 100 , 2 will help you when you are in a difficult position, In India, out of 10,000, all will leave you to die on your own. There was shame in bribe, but nowadays it is the norm for all politicians and government employees. Only country worse than India is Congo. Indians are feral beings-only wants material and sex. Indians treated other Indians so badly, that the population welcome the Mughal Muslim rulers. He travelled over 100 countries, studying the inhabitants and way of life by staying out of hotel and live like the natives , all to better advise his clients about international investments. But he is not completely right in his observation. But India? A complete hopeless case, just take the bribe.
To his point that everything around him is made in China, I would add that the laptops or smartphones and wifi equipment they are using to teleconference are very likely made in China. If it's a Zoom meeting, they have Eric Yuan to thank--born in Shandong, China.
Furthermore, broadband communications are dependent on fiber optics, invented by Shanghai-born Charles Kuen Kao.
When I worked in London, I had an Indian collegue who wanted to invest several millions pounds in India. He went to a minister and tried to bribe him. The minister asked if he had bribed his subordinates. My collegue said not yet. The minister said you must do that first and then you can reach me. This really shocked me.
Lol, he's making sure his subordinates are on the same boat first.
Sour grapes
Visiting minister is that easy? 😅 which country? 😅
@@On_my_way_to_Nirvana-jx7ps Xiaomi, which was personally invited by Modi to invest in India, has been fined thirty times. The most recent one was 4.8 billion yuan.
Taiwan's Foxconn is the world's largest electronics contract manufacturer. Foxconn also left India this year.
@@On_my_way_to_Nirvana-jx7ps According to statistics, all Chinese companies in India are losing money. The reasons were demands for bribes and fines.
Fact is, India’s increased momentum in Trade as of recent Is primarily due to the West having switched their Trade imports from China to India. The Collective West tend to play these games as they did so with Japan in their Rise and Fall, in the Tech Industry. Once a nation is seen as an Economic giant, the West tend to see it as a threat and begin the process of decline so the country has to focus on rising unemployment, rather than redirecting the Exports to keep the Manufacturing. Currently in China, the Train has left the Docks, and BiG Ship has left the Station. Trains that Cruise and Ships that Ride, and now US have been in a State of Panic for many Years in trying to stop China but it’s too late. While US were implementing their PLan, China carefully bolstered up ties globally including their own National Securtiy. When the US sees issues within as their plan is in full flow, usually the Civilians take it out on the Government and US snake their way in to cause further disruption, let alone pushing false narratives about their neighbouring country that’s thriving on new Trade deals with the West generating hatred within the nation that’s on a down turn. The Chinese people being disciplined remained poised and the Trade redirected to other regions of the planet to sustain growth.
India has to prep to avoid the same rhetorics of the West and not to become too dependent on the Good Times, put a little away for a rainy day should US suddenly play the Games of Yester-years.
Well Done China and Do Good, WorkHard Stay Sharp to the bottom of the GLass India..!
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
@@gotislay
Don’t know what PoLitical state India is in, but it’s certainly calm in respect to the rest of the WorLd. I assume only due to the Historic events that has been Overlooked and Lessons Learnt. China too have an understanding, that war ought to be the last resort. The two populated countries are representing themselves in the respectable manner despite the West painting a different narrative.
@@gotislay Very true.
"Currently in China, the Train has left the Docks, and BiG Ship has left the Station. Trains that Cruise and Ships that Ride, and now US have been in a State of Panic for many Years in trying to stop China but it’s too late. " - Not really. Almost every country in the world made a transition from a centralized dictatorship to a democracy when their growth rates slowed down. The shock of slow growth after having experienced 10%+ growth for years isn't easy to handle politically. Brittle systems with no flexibility break in such scenarios, especially when there is external pressure. China has over-capacity in everything. Those things have to be shutdown as more manufacturing shifts to other countries. The question is will Chinese system able to handle that pressure or will it break ? .. Unlike democratic systems where the political parties and the people in power change, the bureaucracy, military, govt's at local levels and courts keep functioning. That's not the case in China. If CCP goes it takes down the bureaucracy and PLA with it. In Opaque systems no one really knows until the last moment.
Until then the Chinese can keep listening to bought and paid morons like Jayant Bhadari and be happy comparing the present day India and China without comprehending the simple argument that when the west talks about India it talks in future tense and hence stupid questions like "What do you see around you that is made in India?" doesn't apply.
@@arunsar7893
Yes it’s dangerous’Over Capacities’ cause there are Nations obsessed in putting holes in your vessel to stop you taking so much of the Pie. If there’s anybody planning to annihilate what China has built would be the West. It’s the same OLd rhetoric the West is trying On with Russia. Using the Neighbouring puppet regimes to take down the, “So Called Enemy”. Yet it’s no Enemy to the Neighbours, but more that to the Outsider that’s trying to keep the Region Divided & Conquered. I believe the Chinese were aware of such fragility, so bolstered up for a rough ride.
Its No small wonder why those that seek to snake their way in to cause disruption at the earliest opportunity.
Japan was ruled after WWll having lost and had to obey the Master -Rise to payback the War Cost and accept Time to FaLL, and the US initiated this.
China doesn’t need the same Master, or any other, just do business on a progressive scale. My advice to the Neighbouring States in FarEast, work with Big Man and Go Further, rather than Experience Trickster to come in and Not Leave.!
If India would settle the border issue and work with China there would be mutual benefit. It worked for China and Vietnam, so why not for India?
It is impossible to work with Toxic people. They are not normal people.
usa wont allow its vassal to live in peace, like Ukraine
Vietnam and China now have a defacto alliance
Settle border? When they want to conquer CHINA.
Wild disturbing dream of all Hindu in conquering South East Asia, China Pakistan etc . what-are-some-negative-aspects-of-akhand-bharat-1b185a860cb3
Akhand Bharat: United India
This one word is enough to describe the Dream of Every Hindu.
If you don’t know about Akhand Bharat, then let me explain it to you.
This is How Akhand Bharat looks like
Akhand Bharat isn’t a Good Idea at this Point. But at what point?
Problems Before Making Akhand Bharat:
India has to deal with 2 Nuclear Powers namely China and Pakistan. and it seems to be the worst idea to go for a full-fledge war with these 2 countries.
It also depends on whether the people from the countries that I have mentioned above even want to join with India or Not. Because if they don’t want to join with us then there will be some major Civil Wars that will happen across these Countries and groups of People.
Getting International Recognition will be hard because many people throughout the world will not accept this and this may even harm the image of India on the International Stage.
If India somehow succeeds in making Akhand Bharat then there are a lot of Chances that some fringe elements will again try to Separate our Country.
The problem for India is the US will punish them ( human rights, Kalisthan, Manipur....) Justin Trudeau already sent a message to Modi warning him the consequences
Everyone knows India is the bribes heaven on earth in fact you could get arrested for not paying a bribe😅😅😅😅
Iam from india..just recently i paid bribe to a lawyer to get my house papers done openly.
On a visit to India years back, I asked people in the street the way to my hotel. I asked 5 persons first, they all said they did not know. With the 6th person, I hold a Rs50 bill. He told me the answer and accept my Rs50
This man hit me so hard with his first question.
"What is in your surrounding that has made in india?"
He is damn right. I still remember when china started accelerating their economy, about 20 years ago. Suddently everything were made in china. From lugnut, stationary, dresses, furnitures, electronics, everything. Now, i haven't see any made in india around me
I did buy some brand name clothes and shoes that said "made in India"
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
All the medicines you eat are Made in India, Yoga is Made in India, the boss of the company you work for is also probably Made in India
@@drona9sure, if you live in India
Chicken Tikka Masala ...ever seen it?
Bollywood?
Never. Why? Two words. "Caste System"
There is no next China.
BUT...
Indians generally, are EXTREMELY PROUD of their Caste in the System. Except of course, if they are unfortunate enough to fall in the lowest PARIAH CASTE.
😊
Caste system is a shame for India it taints everything good about India
@@evergreenhills china is crumbling in its debt...😂 I think in future there will be no china
I am afraid it is a LOT more than the 2 words
NOT EVEN CLOSE INDIA IS DECADES AWAY FROM GETTING ANYWHERE CLOSE TO CHINA
Jayanth is absolutely correct about government offices in India. Absolutely horrendous and high on corruption. You may think Jayanth is exaggerating, but sadly, it's all true 😢.
Sessions With: History of Trade Routes (featuring Kishore Mahbubani)
th-cam.com/video/kg8TmKuaYAQ/w-d-xo.html
Just like the Chinese economy, corruption in China is 5x of what you see in India. If you think corruption is the major problem in India then you are wrong.
If India is lucky, it will be the next Pakistan
totally agree with every word your guest said
Hi Jayant. In relation to your question - how many items I have bought are made in India, I have nothing, zero, zilch. So if I buy an item made in India, then India have made a 100% increase growth? Actually in mathematics, (1/0) x100 it is an infinite growth. Would you agree it will be an infinite growth for India just by selling 1 item to new buyers like me???😊
Yes, but not to the end of time. If you then buy something 5000 years hence the ratio will move away from infinity. Hope this clarifies.
India don't even have its own phones, all the phones from China 😂
I have to say that the Indian elites are very powerful and see problems very accurately. Fortunately, these elites are all in Europe and the United States and have not stayed in India.
Interesting discussion. Was expecting questions about what Modi's government is doing to attract foreign investment, given what they were doing to Xiaomi and Vivo in recent times. Also India's effort to get Apple to move production from China.
Xiaomi and Vivo deserved it. They should have paid attention to past experiences of others and listen to advices given to them.
@@biggpicture2930 Very true. Xiaomi and Vivo deserved it. India have been targeting foreign investor for ages. Back in 2018, Mr. Ananda Krishnan a Malaysian billionaire of India descent lost a whooping USD$7 Billion after 12 years investing in India & was wanted by Indian Police.
@mknndvcvv All businesses, even multinationals in India scam their customers. They only look for new victims. So warranties are mostly useless. That is their business model. The rich are powerful and will work with government to scam off technology and money.
@mknndvcvv
2 hours ago
@biggpicture2930 Very true. Xiaomi and Vivo deserved it. India have been targeting foreign investor for ages. Back in 2018, Mr. Ananda Krishnan a Malaysian billionaire of India descent lost a whooping USD$7 Billion after 12 years investing in India & was wanted by Indian Police.
It's gonna be really funny in 5-10 years, when Apple tries to take profits in India, and suddenly, they get investigated and fined for Billions. LOL
Indians are too smart. You can not swindle them.
If India says that China is not doing well, I just can't imagine how horrific it must be in India
This is like an F-grade student telling an A+ student he is not doing well.
- China's economy is 6 times larger than India's.
- China's yearly growth is 5 times greater than India's.
- China has better living conditions and healthcare; on average, they live a whole decade more than their Indian counterpart.
- China is 60 times richer than India. (I know it's unfair that the British looted 45 trillion from India, but it is what it is).
- China launches 20-50 times more rockets than India into space every year.
- China is a lot more intelligent, with an IQ of 104 compared to India's 76.
- China is more athletic and stronger than India, winning 38 times more gold medals than India in the world olympic games.
- China's reserves is 7 times larger than India's reserves.
- India is forced to use the Chinese currency when purchasing oil from Russia, Iran, or Venezuela. Due to weak & undesirable Indian Rupees.
- China has 21 times more companies in the Fortune 500 than India.
Rovers on Mars China: Yes India: No
Brought back Lunar Samples China: Yes India: No
Humans in space China: Yes India: No
Space station orbiting above us right this moment China: Yes India: No
Reference:
FirstPost : China overtakes US to become world's richest nation
Wion - At $514 trillion, China overtakes US in terms of amassing the biggest net worth
Indiatoday - China overtakes US as world’s richest nation
Tribuneindia - China overtakes US as world’s richest country
Businessinsider india - China overtakes US as the richest country in the world
Thequint - China Overtakes US as the World's Richest Nation
Hindustantimes - China overtakes US to grab top spot in list of richest countries
Indiatimes - Global wealth surges as China overtakes US to grab top spot
NDTV - China Is Now World's Richest Nation, Ahead Of US
NewsX - China Overtakes US As World's Richest Nation
India - China Becomes Richest Country In The World, Overtakes US To Grab The Top Spot
Timesofindia - Global wealth surges as China overtakes US to grab top spot
Newindianexpress - China overtakes US as richest country in the world
Oneindia - China overtakes US as the richest country in the world
News18 - चीन बना दुनिया का सबसे अमीर देश, अमेरिका को किया पीछे
Aajtak - छिन गया America से ताज, अब China दुनिया का सबसे अमीर देश!
Zeenews - Worlds Richest Country: America पीछे... China बना दुनिया का सबसे अमीर देश
TV9 Hindi - अमेरिका को पछाड़कर चीन बना दुनिया का सबसे अमीर देश, 20 साल में बनाई इतनी संपत्ति
Newsleadindia - चीन ने अमेरिका को पछाड़ा दुनिया का सबसे अमीर देश
List of countries by GDP (nominal)
Medal Tally | Tokyo Olympics 2021
List of countries by FOREX reserves
Fortune Global 500 2021 | Full list of ranking
Spaceflights in 2021
Average IQ by Country 2022
USA News
BIoomberg - Global Wealth Surges as China Overtakes US to Grab Top Spot
Yahoo Finance - Global wealth surges as China overtakes US to grab top spot
Japanese News
Nikkei - China overtakes U.S. in national net worth to grab top spot
UK News
Dailymail - Global wealth trebles in last 20 years as China overtakes US with the highest net worth - accounting for a third of world's growth
Dreams do eventually come true.... it largely depends on the decisions of the leaders!
Never happen in India! Leaders are puppet of the Rich. @MattsFikezolo-lo7wq That day will be forever. Hinduism is all about paying bribe to 'gods' for something good in the future. It got worst and everybody is accepting bribes as a culture. India 's government is not in charge. The rich are in charge and have control of the country. Election need lots of money to win. Whomever help pay to win elections will see corruption stays. So no hope for India.
@MattsFikezolo-lo7wq
49 minutes ago
@biggpicture2930 At one point China wasn't also as corrupt until arrival of Xi Jumping. India may one day have her own "Xi Jinxing"
I love China's growth. China shared so much to other countries in many aspects.
Chinese growth rate in negative....
@@bikashkr.choudhary4572
So are every other countries
@@bikashkr.choudhary4572？
Like Covid death in millions around the world.
@@bikashkr.choudhary4572 who said ? Imf said china will grow at 5.4% for this financial year.
Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors:
1. China = 37
2. USA = 7
3. UK = 0
4. Germany = 0
5. Japan = 0
*In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas
Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI)
**India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical
Bangladesh GDP per capital EXCEEDS that of India.
Check it out.
Quiet Bangladesh. Slow and Steady. without screaming and shouting.
there are 160-200k chinese immigrants in bangladesh, the speed of bangladesh's conomies development will faster than india.
I really enjoyed your frank point of view
Great insight into how India works. I wonder how I can survive in the Indian context. Thanks.
India under Modi will go back to caves 😅😂🤣
Why china can be what it is today is because Deng Xiaoping humbly accepted LKY's advise and foresight by opening up China to the world .
Obvisouly, you have no real sense about how different between SG and China, basically in any way. however, I admire such a massive confidence of you.
@@jeffwang1643 Of course Singapore is a small area and less than 4 millions people and it is easily being managed compared to China with 1.4 billions population and the whole of China was still very backward in all aspect when China was opening up...
@@CarpsterKingEven today, China is still backwards in some aspects.
What I am trying to say is that SG should place itself in the right place since it has not been wealthy for a very long time as well, and particularly, not in a position to mentor china how to do the things. However, when you still are persistently to do so, if not becacuse of a "confidence" blown out of propotion, I simply cannot interpret it otherwise.
@jeffwang1643 You are so ignorant. Does a small country mean it is easy to govern? Does a big country mean it is difficult to govern?
Look at Sri Lanka, Panama, Serbia, Haiti. Most small countries in the world have failed. And people in these countries will say that we failed because our country is too small, has no resources, no talents, and no market.
Before the Third Plenary Session of the Eleventh Central Committee of the Communist Party of China, Deng Xiaoping paid a special visit to Singapore and Japan. But Singapore shocked Deng Xiaoping even more!
Why?
First, Deng Xiaoping visited Singapore when he was young. He was going to study in France at that time. At that time, Singapore was a fishing village far behind Shanghai. The quality of the people is extremely low. Deng Xiaoping got off the plane and was immediately shocked by Lee Kuan Yew's Singapore. Especially since this country even has to buy drinking water from Malaysia.
Second, Deng Xiaoping was having dinner with Lee Kuan Yew. Lee Kuan Yew bluntly stated that if China wants to develop, it must say goodbye to fundamentalist Leninism and must stop exporting revolution to Southeast Asia. Mr. Deng Xiaoping was silent at first, and then asked Lee Kuan Yew, "What do you need me to do?"
What kind of mind and magnanimity is this?
Third, Deng Xiaoping returned to China to attend the Third Plenary Session of the Eleventh Central Committee and decisively launched a bloodless coup to overthrow the rule of Leninist Hua Guofeng. Make China fully return to Confucian collectivism and gradually restore the commodity economy.
Third, Shenzhen’s industrial park system is completely copied from Singapore’s Jurong Industrial Park. Even Chinese TV dramas express this point outright. "Deng Xiaoping at the Turn of History"
Fourth, in 1989, Western liberals and Leninists joined forces to create riots. Deng Xiaoping couldn't bear it and suppressed it decisively. Based on its admiration for Western liberalism, even Pakistan does not dare to express support for China. Only Confucian collectivist Lee Kuan Yew in the world has explicitly expressed support for China in suppressing this riot. This incident ensured that Confucian collectivists would continue to be in power in China and that China's urbanization and industrialization movement would continue to advance. This is how the glorious China is today.
It can be said that Mr. Lee Kuan Yew's modern Confucian collectivism and pragmatism spirit as well as his zero-tolerance attitude towards crime have influenced the governance of too many Confucian economies and even influenced Kagame in Rwanda. And Rwanda is now considered the most successful country in Africa.
@@jeffwang1643 Deng Xiaoping's most famous speech during his southern tour specifically talked about how Singapore's governance inspired him. (Of course, for well-known reasons, it was inconvenient for him to directly quote his conversation with Lee Kuan Yew)
At long last we see somebody of Indian origin who is not afraid to call a spade a spade! Jayant Bandari is not bias! This guy speaks of what is really happening on the world economic and geopolitical arena in today global economic turmoil, with India trying to catch up with China which is years ahead in every sphere of development. He makes a true and vivid diagnosis of the present economic perspective and the real situation facing India to the effect that his native country will never become the next China! This 30 minutes interview is a food for thought that must be seen by one and all. His economic analysis is totally opposite to what Indian Prime minister, Narendra Modi, has been saying day in day out: that India is the next superpower of the world that will overtake China in less than a decade! When you take note of Modi's repetitive bullshit narrative and that of his bootlicker journalist of Vantage, Palki Sharma, and other Indian propaganda media, we cannot help asking ourselves whether the Indian illiterate masses are not being taken for a long ride since Modi comes to power a decade ago. Bandari underlines that between the government and weak infrastructure of India, most companies that want to move operations to India, end up not doing so because of rampant corruption at all level of the Indian society and the sluggishness of the Indian bureaucracy taking weeks to process a simple development certificate submitted by overseas companies!( Roland Tsang kwai kew 10.10.23)
Gigantic China was humble & courageous enough to make the change to follow some good examples of little dot Singapore.
Meanwhile, India (& USA) cannot accept that the little dot Singapore & the people of China have anything worthy of their respect to lose face to. India (& USA) *_"think"_* they are the best - not because they are actually the best !
There is ancient saying in China: when you see three people walking on the streets, there must be someone who can be my teacher. The moral of the story: even if you are the best you can still learn from others.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and primarily Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
humility comes after getting smashed. 100 years of humiliation.
@@jethrot4314 Humility comes after 5000 years of wisdom - not dumb arrogance.
Did you become dumb after being smacked in the head by your colonial ruler & then China in 1962 ? Need another smack ?? 😅
China can obliterate anyone forcing narcotics onto them today !😂😊
This has been a very illuminating video
As an Indian passport holder, I'd like for Mr. Jayant to tell us what he really thinks of his homeland.
All doom and gloom
Suggest you watch this video instead of asking the question and if you are still not clear there are scores of other videos here where he says the same things, so you have a huge goldmine to plow through. Enjoy it.
I notice a common theme among Chinese interviewers -- they are almost always smiling, and wishing the best for everyone -- even for people who consider them enemies. Given their history of invasion and exploitation by the West and Japan, it's just incredible.
Indian people have the capacity, big companies around the world are headed by Indians. The issue is the corrupt indian government and colonial mentality...
Jayant Bhandari, is 100% correct ..Indian P M Narendra Modi on Saturday launched projects worth 157 billion rupees ($2 billion) in Ayodhya, a town considered sacred by Hindus, in the Uttar Pradesh state. a massive project to build a temple dedicated to the Indian god Ram is underway .PS ... Where are the American investor that Biden promise Modie on his visit to Washington ! they all come to India and gone home , business /investors are not Politician , their wealth don't rely on the "direction of the wind Blow on the day" .While in Washington , Modie was in Cloud 9 ! like a little kid from one of the slum in India . walk into a Buffet restaurant !
Ayodhya is the foundation for ramarajya i.e. ruling with righteousness. If Ayodhya Rama temple is consricated, it results in sweeping changes in the government's corruptionless adminstration.
@@tekumallasrinivasachakrava9214itna stupid Kaise..kalyug me
Of all G20 countries, India is the only lower middle-income country. Lower middle-income economies are those with a GDP per capita between $1,136 and $4,465 btw. India is only in the G20 due to its population size, that's all
It is a concrete third-world standard. Call it what it is.
Honesty to one’s weaknesses, pitfalls and failures is hope for a real change in the future.
The BJP government is carried by RSS ideology of Hindutva nationalism, and idea not to develop India into a great power like China, the idea to become to a country called Ramarajya. A fully hindu run state, and all other minorities should be suppressed. After they took control of India, what they doing is changing all things related to secularism and enforcing state government to accept it, and dismantling democracy. If any state not willing implement their ideology, punishing them with using central institutions. So now most of the state are in trouble to survive by economically and demographically. And today's India is more divided, no hope to succeed
The real idea is to recreate an empire by recapturing lands controlled by BHARATS, a legendary tale in the Rigveda
@EdinAibak
4 hours ago
The BJP government is carried by RSS ideology of Hindutva nationalism, and idea not to develop India into a great power like China, the idea to become to a country called Ramarajya. A fully hindu run state, and all other minorities should be suppressed. After they took control of India, what they doing is changing all things related to secularism and enforcing state government to accept it, and dismantling democracy. If any state not willing implement their ideology, punishing them with using central institutions. So now most of the state are in trouble to survive by economically and demographically. And today's India is more divided, no hope to succeed
@@biggpicture2930 Only mystery throughout history, was not an empire, instead of several kingdom.
@EdinAibak Problem with your answer, is that you are missing the point I am making. . Bharat's time was supposed to be 1000BC. Even though, it there was no evidence.
@EdinAibak
57 minutes ago
@biggpicture2930 Only mystery throughout history, was not an empire, instead of several kingdom
Most savage critique of India ever! I've seen older videos of his describing india as barbaric.
He is just negative, he is having small fixed mindset about india
India is rapidly changing country, but this guy will still cry. 😂
@@nikhilPUD01 No he is absolutely spot on. I have worked in the US and China.
It is. The grandson of an ex prime minister made 3000 sex videos by exploiting over 200 girls and women. The government allowed him to run away to Germany.
It should be Can India be the next US. To be China for India is thousands of miles away and never will be.🤣🤣😛😛
India exporting talents worldwide means only that the inequalities in their country forced these scholars to work abroad where they could have a chance to become significant. They could grab onto fame and fortune offered by Western liberalism either thanks to being born with a silver spoon or sacrificial funding for their education from family and friends. Talented people exist all around the world, but will only strive if offered good education. Now that's not to say that the education system in their country failed them! It might well be the opposite... It's the lack of job opportunities in their own country after graduating there. Post graduate schools will often lacks essential investments in hi-tech or medical fields found in wealthy countries like the US-UK, Germany, China, France...even though India is doing well in Software Engineering and Pharmacology as resources needed there is not unaccessible... For a country to economically strive as a whole, its middle class must strive. The scholars must be serving their country instead of selling their intellect abroad. If that's the case with India, then there is hope. If not India economy will remain stagnant until then.
Mr. Jayanthi Bhandari is absolutely correct about the India/China border dispute will never be peacefully resolved as the ruling Indian leadership critically needed it as a bogey for controlling domestic electorare support.
Bhandari is a good recipie to keep chinese and Indian left ecosystem calm and hopeful of political change in India 😂
What an amazing insides into the subject. Most enlightening to learn the not-so-obvious Indian politics and cultures. Thanks for the wonder informations and insights.
He is obviously ignorant and stupid leftist. He is absolutely clueless about current conditions. Anybody with sufficient IQ can see through him.
India have to pass Africa before even thinking of passing China.
One key reason that India will never be China 2 is average IQ China 105 VS India 76.
Average IQ should be about equal, but lower for Indians due to malnutrition. But education level is a huge divide.
Actually 88% of indians in india are illiterate as in only 12% can read and write their own name. The video is in my channel.
That IQ of 76 if true is likely from the indians that went to school in india and not a true reflection of the entire population.
the majority of Indian children suffer malnutrition and that affects their neurological and cognitive development
Malnutrition kills any hope for India future workforce or innovative capability.
This is because Indian children are malnourished.
During the Tang Dynasty India doesn’t exist, there were some 50+nations then
India is just a geographical concept, this is the norm of history.
But later on, Britain stitched it together and turned it into a sewing monster.
@@zen-mc4ju heard about Mauryan dynasty ? India had became unified a century before China. Mauryan dynasty collapsed due to Pacifism imposed by Ashoka. Ashoka could have done anything if he wanted.
@@bhanupratap1063 Where is the ancient Indian civilization？Language, people，characters？
@@bhanupratap1063 The only time India was unified was during the reign of Emperor Ashoka. This was the only unification of ancient India in thousands of years.
Ashoka was an amazing character.
Study about Muaryan Dynasty
Forget government, if you go the temple and give extra money to the priest.. you will get preference. Major temples in Tamil Nadu ( state in south India) have special entrance fees to take you directly to the main Deity in shortest route. Free routes are longer routes erected in a snake like pattern to accommodate crowds.
I was told the poor Dalits people some temples have prohibited them to enter and worship.
@@panyaboonc5621 I don't thinks widespread in major temples, probably in rural areas. They have progressed in social aspects.
It depends one's benchmark, is to compare with own past then it's an accomplishment, if you compare yourself with someone else who have made bigger strides to move forward, then you have long way to go.
India is too fixated on the trivial border issue with China.
NO, the One and may be the most important reason is, the Mentality
100% rational assessment of the comparison between the two countries.
Even if most of these things are true, there is no practical benefit for India to open up to China. Indian exports are not going to find a big market in China because other countries like Bangladesh and Pakistan already fills those roles. And conversely, China goods may outcompete Indians in their home market.
Ss, true, our target is Africa 😢
I am Chinese. What you said is true.
And Indians constantly saying that they are not the next China, they are the next America.
Im Indian and i accept his facts,
He said right about indian are not smart you prove his point to accept his pseudo facts 😂
Two of my favorite people!
I am a fan of both the host and the guest. Great to see them together.
You mean India will be the next Ukraine 😂😂
Indians always thought their country already top of the world .supper power in the world .different Chinese people always thought their country behind everyone in the world had to work very hard catch up .when you talk to Indians friends they said India everything numbers one in the world .we see .time will tell.
The Chinese just work hard, get educated and save their earnings to invest and things fall into place. Indians brag, dream of being a Super Power, talks of unrealized potential and predictions. That is the difference.
One is a super-bragger and the other is a super-achiever. That's one of the main differences.
India will remain the same India for the next 100 years.
Throughout world history, no country's strength has been accomplished and sustained solely by external forces. China's reconstruction was based on external siege and its own strength. India, on the contrary, has always been the favorite of the international community, from the Nehru era and many socialist countries close relations, to the post-Soviet period, boasts of "the world's largest democracy", so that India completely lost a strong endogenous momentum. Under these circumstances, it is basically impossible for India to become China 2.0. The Indian government seems to be very eager to earn enough respect in terms of the strength of its international reputation, but it has forgotten the most important point, which is also the most important need of the Indian people, that is, India should develop itself to meet the needs of its people, instead of pointing fingers all over the world.