Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir is focusing on the contradiction in ideologically hindu party celebrating Indians working in arab islamic countries. This contrast doesn't appear to make sense in the nationalist mindsets, where religion is fully intertwined with politics. So hindu nationalists see no contradiction in their desire for India to be a hindu nation, similar to how Pak is an Islamic nation.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir Ji, it would appear your understanding of History is a wee bit fuzzy.Why would Indian people hold a grudge against Arab Muslims? Arabs never really got anywhere with their invasion of India. They were largely held back. Only Sindh was taken by Arabs. Post that the three major empires in India plus a few chiefs managed to hold back the Arab invasions. The Delhi Sultanates were almost all Turko-Afghan or Central Asian. Our Mughal emperors were also Turko-Mongols. Please understand not all cultures are the same even if they follow the same religion. Arabs had trade relations with India LONG before they accepted Islam. Reducing all cultures to Just their religious identity seems simplistic and intentional. As usual your Maserati Marxist world view and understanding of history hinders you from accepting that Indians largely can differentiate between an Arab or Persian and a Turk or Mongol.
@@HassanAli-xl8kr Christianity emerged from the Semitic world, and Jesus was indeed a Jew. Although British colonial rulers, who were Christians, subjugated India, it does not logically follow that Indians would harbor hatred towards Jews.
Vir Shangvi understanding of global politics is shallow. His understanding of India is even more so. Thankfully, good English knowledge is not equated as wisdom anymore. He edited newspapers and that shows the calibre of those media.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
1. That 85% figure is no longer accurate. The new census should tell us more. 2. Many temples are controlled by state government trusts that mismanage funds and use them for their own agenda. 3. People like Anand Ranganathan have talked about discriminatory laws that do not allow Hindus to run their own institutions. This is the country where the Ramakrishna mission once argued in court that it was not Hindu because it wanted to avoid government control of its schools. Minority run institutions enjoy a much greater degree of autonomy. This is patently unfair and people see this as being so. 4. Demographic change matters - it matters everywhere. There’s a reason why the gulf countries you talk of do not allow residents to get citizenship or even permanent residence. There’s a reason Singapore has such strict laws on gaining nationality. Europeans have been foolish enough to relax their norms and are suffering as a result.
Am Indian migrant too. Indians feel entitled to gain Western citizenship as they think the high tech world needs Indians only who pay taxes nd benefit the West. But the better infrastructure schools hospitals social benefits provided by hosts are also a Right. Vir mentioned Hindu vs Muslim yet go there for a better economic life and Western colonisers/oppressors are filling up with illegals from India, 3rd largest in world migration index.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir, you need to sleep well.. you’re way too young for dementia.. rich Indians are not moving to middle-east.. only poor laborers go to gulf.. rich Indians have much better places to move like USA, Europe, Australia etc with golden visas. Modi is in middle-east not for this chindigiri but for strategic reasons to counter-balance China.. there I fixed your analysis
I agree that Vir is full of nonsense but rich Indians (not just labourers) also move to the Gulf, especially UAE. Thousands of wealthy Indians drive Lamborghinis and live in gated mansions in Dubai. Modi is in Middle East to secure oil supplies and balance China.
@@xxyz2023 Sadly India is still a third world country with a passport that is unwelcome. Indians are known to Overstay UK and Uncooperative US as GOI doesn't take back its citizens. Why not make India great with toilets roads healthcare education and safety net for every citizen. Why are Christian West secular citizens not seeking asylum outside their countries. We owe our countries for our existence. Perish the thought Indians
We thought the likes of singhvi and Gupta, what they wrote on news papers as gospel truth during our teens, now we know how shallow and agenda driven people these are in the era of social media.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
The original Arab Muslims are comfortable in their identity , and they have excellent and cordial relations with Hindus and Hindu civilisation . Modi recognises this . Hindustan has only had problems with forcibly converted Muslims , whether from Uzbekistan, Afghanistan or Iran or Turkey . These Muslims were forcibly converted, lost their cultural identity and are rootless , hence the chaos
Vir is talking all nonsense, to say the least. Which BJP state govt is acting against Muslims? Have Muslims started to look at Middle Eastern countries in the last 10 years or they always looked to Ummah since 1947? What price Indian Muslims are paying anyway? Vir should not talk loose and get away with it!!
This guy is such a joker. He is saying that non-Muslims have more religious freedom in Arabic Islamic countries than non-Hindus in India. Ask him when was the last time, non-Muslims could take out a religious procession in these countries. Yes. non-Muslims have a good life but it is because the overall country is economically rich and country maintains law and order which is not the case in India. India has much more religious freedom but doesn't provide good life to 90% of its population. In fact India might be the only country which has special privileges for minorities.
Dear Veer, how long you are u planning to sell this theory of Abdul being a victim? Yes, Turkic, Persian and Arabian invaders did some horrible things to Indian Hindus, but we have moved on from that phase. We don't hold the current Arabs responsible for bad things that was done by the predecessors just like the current Britishers are not responsible for the acts of there predecessors. We don't see any harm in doing business with all these nations who treated us badly in the past. However, we are against those people who glorify these barbarians by making them Heros...
What to say about Kashmir, Assam demographic change and more recently things coming out from Sambhaal. Middle East is totally a different set of political dispensation with authoritarian regimes not a n appeasement based democracy.
And Modi is polar opposite. At least their people do not have to illegally migrate for a better life. Whereas democracy provides Zero social benefits. Best infrastructure and status than Indians. Indians confined to slave labour on their bldg sites with hard hats boots overalls and regular monthly wage unlike their home countries where middlemen take a cut.
Mr Modi wants to stamp his legacy as one of the most consequential prime ministers of all time. He wants to be seen as a pan-india leader cutting cross regional, religious and caste divides. He doesn't want to be solely seen as a hardline champion of one ideology and hugely divisive or polarizing figure. He wants to be seen as an able administrator with a positive record on welfare architecture, tightening security, increasing the penetrating of digitization, rapidly developing infrastructure and rising diplomatic stature in global affairs. Will he succeed or not is another question.
Nupur Sharma never said anything offensive. She spoke the facts. It was Zoo Bear's distorted narrative which went viral and Nupur had to pay the price. BJP has done injustice to her. She will be back in Delhi elections. Wait and watch.
Dear Vir, the irony is that the converted are more radical than the originals. The originals have apparently educated and modernised themselves. Note this nuance.
It concerns me when a pro-Congress writer attempts to balance religion, nationalism, and geopolitics, particularly in how they view Prime Minister Modi. Being a nationalist is not a crime. When Modi engages with Muslim-majority countries in the region, he seeks to build relationships that have been absent for decades. This does not imply that he disregards Indian Muslims. For years, Indian Muslims have been exploited for vote-bank politics, often by Congress, with little regard for their well-being. Indian Muslims must seize the opportunities created by government initiatives. The problem is that Congress established a narrative long before 2014, painting Modi as anti-Muslim. However, he has already done much for a state like Gujarat and remains committed to doing more for the entire country, Bharat.
Done a lot for Gujarat. Yet 3rd largest in the World Migration Index of illegals no wars but Poverty. After Punjabis Gujaratis rank 2nd of people paying Agents for a student or tourist visa to Christian West even Freezing in Canada which no other nationality has done.
@@agnescraig2912 Every mindset is a challenge, we cannot change that thought process when individuals decide or been decisive when they want to migrate. We cannot be just specific why someone migrate - jobs, better life, education etc. There can be many reasons, and things does not change for better overnight it takes time. We are seeing a stepping stairs but we tend to ignore or not seeing it.
Vir is focusing on the contradiction in ideologically hindu party celebrating Indians working in arab islamic countries. This contrast doesn't appear to make sense in the nationalist mindsets, where religion is fully intertwined with politics. So are the awards from arab nations to pm. So hindu nationalists see no contradiction in their desire for India to be a hindu nation, similar to how Pak is an Islamic nation.
He is either morally bankrupt and lacks elementary analytical skills. I wonder how such people make it. This is one of the masterclass of most poor analysis.
Most of the comments in the column are reasonably and as sharp edge asfar as possible but Vir seems to be very big blunt edge. Blunt in TN we call (mokka),this guy seemto be mokka not sharp.
3:58 to be fair Vir, the remarks were distasteful, but in line with Islamic beliefs. Should we be calling them offensive? 6:15 What you are saying makes me think you are understanding a Modi supporter in binary terms frozen in time. You must mix more with RW 7:00 Again, if we are 1/10th income per capita of another country, 10 yrs of excellent growth can make it may be 1/5 by stretch. we'll still be behind after a few decades. basic arithmetic Vir! 7:30 all communities have been flocking to middle east for decades primarily for economic reasons and good law and order. Additionally the religious situation has eased in recent years, not specific to Modi. in fact many Indian muslims dislike MBS for liberalising. Again you are using extreme arguments leaving no scope for a gray/nuance. 8:30 because Hindus do not "belong" in Arab, they do not have any heritage sites taken over. Imagine if hindus had attacked any muslim religious site in Arab 200 hundred years ago, which they want back and hindus refuse to vacate. Hypothetical but that's the equivalence.
5:33 Modi never ever hugged terrorist supporting leaders nor kept warm relations with them... again how miserably you fail to understand these simple facts
It's not so much about the muslims as a whole but the opposition parties who tend to make their votebanks based on caste and religion of different areas. For the longest time atleast in North India the regional parties held sway by this method of divide and rule. Even now they can't stop rambling about caste census. The bjp is not that perfect when it comes to other issues like development but there is no hope for that from the opposition parties either.
Sir u must take a posting to Bangladesh for a year or two. They seem to need your words of wisdom more than Indians at this moment.. once you achieve a secular tolerant Bangladesh you can return back. Because your ranting against Modi hasn't worked and let's see if you can bring back some change in Bangladesg
Some sense seems to have dawned on you but much more is needed. What every right thinking Indian knew since 2000, you have realised after 24 years! Quite a tube light.
The key point missed here is that the Arab (Sunni) world is changing and modernizing at a rapid pace. The engagement both from the Indian leadership as well as people to people connections need to be analyzed with that context in mind.
The simple explanation is that Arab leaders do not see Modi or his government as being anti-Muslim or anti-Arab despite all the rhetoric by Singhvi and his like minded colleagues.
“He gets Netanyahu to set Pegasus” - Vir knows something that even Supreme Court committee didn’t! That’s such an irresponsible statement for him to say
It's mostly concluded that any purchase of Pegasus would involve the Indian govt directly, since Israel's official statement was that they only sell Pegasus through govt to govt.
Your shift to a narrative of anti-BJP and pro-Muslim without any objective basis is surprising and saddening to someone like me who used to follow you in print and on The Print. You need to step back and reflect on your recent output or rather outbursts.
Extremely Dumb analysis. For a starter: Indian Right wing doesn't have an issue with Islam or Muslims, its the Islamism or the ideology of Ikhwān al-Muslimīn or the Muslim brotherhood, Which is the same ideology that the sheikhdoms of middle east also have a lot of issue with. I don't know why but these guys with extremely polished english and some fancy education, pretend or rather themselves completely believe that they are all knowing. The reality is a normal barber in Indian tier 3 city has more grasp of reality than these fancy english guys. That's precisely why we don't have a good opposition now and all we have is a culturally rightwing but economically near socialist government running some department flawlessly while some not even praise worthy.
Arfa from Wire is also weeping and here Veer Sanghvi is also weeping on the same topic ! When India under Modi is doing great things by building closer ties with Gulf countries these people are not happy ! Which PM or senior Minister went and met ordinary humble working class Indians in the Gulf and enquired about their well being ?? Only Modi !! Did any elitist liberal journalist ever highlight the problems faced by these working class Indians ??? Just see Hindu Muslim in everything !!
We have to move away from our muslims obsessions. Muslims muslims muslims....tiring And all this melodrama after India was divided for a separate muslim. homeland
8:19 Strength of a community is not just about its numbers. Its more about its the organisational structure, the communal ideology and the mobility. Muslims are the group that has all these. Thats why Kashmiri Pandits were driven out of Kashmir when Majority of Hindus in India could only watch it helplessly
Sir, a few different narratives. 1 Islam invaders entry in Sindh in 712 AD.Qasim was a teenage Arab boy who commanded an essentially persian army.No mention of temple destruction. Large scale conversions,yes. 2.2nd phase of Islamic invasions came from Afghans/Khurasan/ Persian/ Turks I the 1st decade of 11th century.Warlord Ghaznavi was not an Arab. All subsequent invasions up to the Mughal dynasty were from Afghanistan whereas Turks played a major role.
Ha ha ! you are trying to drive a wedge between Modi and his supporters. Only idiot would do this. Muslims is not a religion issue but far greater cultural and social-political issue. I am at wit's end to understand your short sighted and shallow understanding.
Hi Vir Perhaps the phobia and victimhood of Hindus comes from the fact that minority Hindu Kashmiri were killed, raped and driven out of their homes and lands by the majority Muslims ? ( Have the Muslim minorities in other states suffered the same way as the Hindu minorities suffered in Kashmir?) Perhaps the phobia and victimhood comes from the fact that anybody’s property can be claimed by Wakf Board - as the recent example in Karnataka with Wakf Board claiming ancestral lands of Hindu farmers? Surely you can see that?
Even before watching the video I knew bhakts would lose their marbles. Bhakts would find some way justify their victimization even though they hate victim card except when they(bhakts) can play it too🤣🤣
Nothing makes sense in this ….there is a huge difference in the way the ME goes about religion and how it happens here. All the activities..religious ones would not be tolerated there, and I mean the religious activities relating to Islam more that that of the Hindus and Christmas there.
😃, most things you will not find odd , only if you come out of your tunnel vision , which I know for sure you will not and cannot.. it’s pretty cozy for you in there now!😉
SO, how does this video make us wiswr? Improve our lives by one crumb even? Exactly HOW does SUCH journalism help us? Zero help. Modi and RSS and ANY power luster is evil. Totally. Karma will catch them. Also bystandards ... ONLY innovatorrs, visionaries CAN bring change. UNmoral is evil too. Sad fact.
Nobody can match these Modi bhakt trolls and all the hateful divisive negative comments. This episode should have been aired years ago. Hindus whether 75% or 60% is a huge figure 1.4bln ppl Hindu khatre may hai and Jyada bachhe by Modi. Slave labourers in the Gulf Diaspora prop up the GDP of India with their Remittances. Hindus always the victims stop breeding like flies resulting in Poverty open defecation healthcare and absolute economic distress of its citizens.
Congratulations Mr Sanghvi for forging an entirely dubious narrative riding on eloquence and selectivism. Hindu Victimhood is not a mere political slogan and it certainly doesn't spring from the middle East. Firstly, you need to look closer, at Bangladesh and Pakistan, and then much farther west to Australia, Canada, Britain, where hate crimes by Islamist and Khalistani extremists routinely make news. Secondly, The 10 years old Modi government certainly didn't appease muslims, but the reprehensible real politik of Muslim appeasement continues with Congress/Leftist politics that alienated and insulted Hindus in their own land for years. Hindu victimisation needs redressal even today as much as the caste discrimination against Dalits.
Pakistan, Bangladesh and countries like Afghanistan do not exist for him.. bhai what stuff do you smoke... pls mention that in some other video aswell.
Vir Sanghvi should stop writing and start reading articles and watching lectures and discussions of experts of geopolitics in various forums to understand what is going on here. His hackneyed views of Hindu Muslim binaries, secular vs Hindutwa communal rants interspersed with oft repeated examples of Muslim victimhood are too passé, thanks to access to free information educated Indians know a lot more than your antics. India needs strong relationship with the Middle East not only for energy security but also the shifting geopolitical map with withdrawal of the US, weakened Iran, assertive Turkey and Chinese inroads. Religion is the last thing India emphasizes, but seeks increased trade and investments from the rich sovereign wealth funds. Arfa, Vir and the like minded Islamists and Muslim loving secularists are feeling uncomfortable as their old narrative is challenged time and again.
Hello Mr, in those countries non-Muslims don't claim their religion is the only way to salvation.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir expertise in comparing Apples with oranges is astounding. I am simply baffled with your nonsense.
Me Too
If sense means nonsense and vice versa.
Agreed
Vir is focusing on the contradiction in ideologically hindu party celebrating Indians working in arab islamic countries.
This contrast doesn't appear to make sense in the nationalist mindsets, where religion is fully intertwined with politics.
So hindu nationalists see no contradiction in their desire for India to be a hindu nation, similar to how Pak is an Islamic nation.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir Singhviji ….can you please enlighten us with your knowledge on WAQF board
Yeah so, kashmiri pandit exodus also rhetoric
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Dumb analysis mixing everything
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir Ji, it would appear your understanding of History is a wee bit fuzzy.Why would Indian people hold a grudge against Arab Muslims? Arabs never really got anywhere with their invasion of India. They were largely held back. Only Sindh was taken by Arabs. Post that the three major empires in India plus a few chiefs managed to hold back the Arab invasions. The Delhi Sultanates were almost all Turko-Afghan or Central Asian. Our Mughal emperors were also Turko-Mongols. Please understand not all cultures are the same even if they follow the same religion. Arabs had trade relations with India LONG before they accepted Islam. Reducing all cultures to Just their religious identity seems simplistic and intentional. As usual your Maserati Marxist world view and understanding of history hinders you from accepting that Indians largely can differentiate between an Arab or Persian and a Turk or Mongol.
But Islam came from Arabs
@HassanAli-xl8kr Islam did not come from Arabs any more than Gravity came from Jews. Islam is eternal just like Hinduism and Gravity.
@@HassanAli-xl8kr
Christianity emerged from the Semitic world, and Jesus was indeed a Jew. Although British colonial rulers, who were Christians, subjugated India, it does not logically follow that Indians would harbor hatred towards Jews.
So you hate Muslims just diffrent breed of muslims got it.
Vir Shangvi understanding of global politics is shallow. His understanding of India is even more so. Thankfully, good English knowledge is not equated as wisdom anymore. He edited newspapers and that shows the calibre of those media.
Mr Vir is always at odd with anything good for India
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
1. That 85% figure is no longer accurate. The new census should tell us more.
2. Many temples are controlled by state government trusts that mismanage funds and use them for their own agenda.
3. People like Anand Ranganathan have talked about discriminatory laws that do not allow Hindus to run their own institutions. This is the country where the Ramakrishna mission once argued in court that it was not Hindu because it wanted to avoid government control of its schools. Minority run institutions enjoy a much greater degree of autonomy. This is patently unfair and people see this as being so.
4. Demographic change matters - it matters everywhere. There’s a reason why the gulf countries you talk of do not allow residents to get citizenship or even permanent residence. There’s a reason Singapore has such strict laws on gaining nationality. Europeans have been foolish enough to relax their norms and are suffering as a result.
Am Indian migrant too. Indians feel entitled to gain Western citizenship as they think the high tech world needs Indians only who pay taxes nd benefit the West. But the better infrastructure schools hospitals social benefits provided by hosts are also a Right. Vir mentioned Hindu vs Muslim yet go there for a better economic life and Western colonisers/oppressors are filling up with illegals from India, 3rd largest in world migration index.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
Vir, you need to sleep well.. you’re way too young for dementia.. rich Indians are not moving to middle-east.. only poor laborers go to gulf.. rich Indians have much better places to move like USA, Europe, Australia etc with golden visas.
Modi is in middle-east not for this chindigiri but for strategic reasons to counter-balance China.. there I fixed your analysis
I agree that Vir is full of nonsense but rich Indians (not just labourers) also move to the Gulf, especially UAE. Thousands of wealthy Indians drive Lamborghinis and live in gated mansions in Dubai. Modi is in Middle East to secure oil supplies and balance China.
@@Godzillamonstrosityyes but for them it is only holiday destinations or jobs as Businesse level executives in companies there .
👌😂😂😂
Most rich Indians give up Indian passport,mostly to live in west asia, US, europe.
@@xxyz2023 Sadly India is still a third world country with a passport that is unwelcome. Indians are known to Overstay UK and Uncooperative US as GOI doesn't take back its citizens. Why not make India great with toilets roads healthcare education and safety net for every citizen. Why are Christian West secular citizens not seeking asylum outside their countries. We owe our countries for our existence. Perish the thought Indians
We thought the likes of singhvi and Gupta, what they wrote on news papers as gospel truth during our teens, now we know how shallow and agenda driven people these are in the era of social media.
How do you make your living? Just by thinking stuff. Very lucky. I am genuinely curious.
Vir is completely br@inwashed leftist 😂 , no hindu ever blamed middle Eastern countries for hindu prosecution in past , even all bjp suppoters see middle Easten muslim as originals and describes Indian mus!iims as defected piece 😂😂
The original Arab Muslims are comfortable in their identity , and they have excellent and cordial relations with Hindus and Hindu civilisation . Modi recognises this . Hindustan has only had problems with forcibly converted Muslims , whether from Uzbekistan, Afghanistan or Iran or Turkey . These Muslims were forcibly converted, lost their cultural identity and are rootless , hence the chaos
It’s so pleasant to listen from you some praise for Modi 😊
Pleasant or disgusting
Bas yahi bhakti hai.. bhakt to pagal ho hota hai.
Vir is talking all nonsense, to say the least. Which BJP state govt is acting against Muslims? Have Muslims started to look at Middle Eastern countries in the last 10 years or they always looked to Ummah since 1947? What price Indian Muslims are paying anyway? Vir should not talk loose and get away with it!!
This guy is such a joker. He is saying that non-Muslims have more religious freedom in Arabic Islamic countries than non-Hindus in India. Ask him when was the last time, non-Muslims could take out a religious procession in these countries. Yes. non-Muslims have a good life but it is because the overall country is economically rich and country maintains law and order which is not the case in India. India has much more religious freedom but doesn't provide good life to 90% of its population. In fact India might be the only country which has special privileges for minorities.
You want to do jai sri ram chants in front on mosques in arab nations?
Will S.G. tell this guy to carry full series on Pappu on (1) Dual Citizenship and (2) GS Connection!!!!!
Correction: India is only 75 percent Hindu. And 25% Muslim.
As usual talking nonsense connecting different things , in ridiculous fashion . Egregious comparisons and outright lies .
Dear Veer, how long you are u planning to sell this theory of Abdul being a victim? Yes, Turkic, Persian and Arabian invaders did some horrible things to Indian Hindus, but we have moved on from that phase. We don't hold the current Arabs responsible for bad things that was done by the predecessors just like the current Britishers are not responsible for the acts of there predecessors. We don't see any harm in doing business with all these nations who treated us badly in the past. However, we are against those people who glorify these barbarians by making them Heros...
What to say about Kashmir, Assam demographic change and more recently things coming out from Sambhaal. Middle East is totally a different set of political dispensation with authoritarian regimes not a n appeasement based democracy.
And Modi is polar opposite. At least their people do not have to illegally migrate for a better life. Whereas democracy provides Zero social benefits. Best infrastructure and status than Indians. Indians confined to slave labour on their bldg sites with hard hats boots overalls and regular monthly wage unlike their home countries where middlemen take a cut.
Mr Modi wants to stamp his legacy as one of the most consequential prime ministers of all time. He wants to be seen as a pan-india leader cutting cross regional, religious and caste divides. He doesn't want to be solely seen as a hardline champion of one ideology and hugely divisive or polarizing figure. He wants to be seen as an able administrator with a positive record on welfare architecture, tightening security, increasing the penetrating of digitization, rapidly developing infrastructure and rising diplomatic stature in global affairs. Will he succeed or not is another question.
Nupur Sharma never said anything offensive. She spoke the facts. It was Zoo Bear's distorted narrative which went viral and Nupur had to pay the price. BJP has done injustice to her. She will be back in Delhi elections. Wait and watch.
Dear Vir, the irony is that the converted are more radical than the originals. The originals have apparently educated and modernised themselves. Note this nuance.
It concerns me when a pro-Congress writer attempts to balance religion, nationalism, and geopolitics, particularly in how they view Prime Minister Modi. Being a nationalist is not a crime. When Modi engages with Muslim-majority countries in the region, he seeks to build relationships that have been absent for decades. This does not imply that he disregards Indian Muslims. For years, Indian Muslims have been exploited for vote-bank politics, often by Congress, with little regard for their well-being. Indian Muslims must seize the opportunities created by government initiatives. The problem is that Congress established a narrative long before 2014, painting Modi as anti-Muslim. However, he has already done much for a state like Gujarat and remains committed to doing more for the entire country, Bharat.
Done a lot for Gujarat. Yet 3rd largest in the World Migration Index of illegals no wars but Poverty. After Punjabis Gujaratis rank 2nd of people paying Agents for a student or tourist visa to Christian West even Freezing in Canada which no other nationality has done.
@@agnescraig2912 Every mindset is a challenge, we cannot change that thought process when individuals decide or been decisive when they want to migrate. We cannot be just specific why someone migrate - jobs, better life, education etc. There can be many reasons, and things does not change for better overnight it takes time. We are seeing a stepping stairs but we tend to ignore or not seeing it.
Why are these arab countries giving modi such awards? Could you care to answer singhvi ji.
Vir is focusing on the contradiction in ideologically hindu party celebrating Indians working in arab islamic countries.
This contrast doesn't appear to make sense in the nationalist mindsets, where religion is fully intertwined with politics. So are the awards from arab nations to pm.
So hindu nationalists see no contradiction in their desire for India to be a hindu nation, similar to how Pak is an Islamic nation.
He is either morally bankrupt and lacks elementary analytical skills. I wonder how such people make it.
This is one of the masterclass of most poor analysis.
Most of the comments in the column are reasonably and as sharp edge asfar as possible but Vir seems to be very big blunt edge. Blunt in TN we call (mokka),this guy seemto be mokka not sharp.
3:58 to be fair Vir, the remarks were distasteful, but in line with Islamic beliefs. Should we be calling them offensive?
6:15 What you are saying makes me think you are understanding a Modi supporter in binary terms frozen in time. You must mix more with RW
7:00 Again, if we are 1/10th income per capita of another country, 10 yrs of excellent growth can make it may be 1/5 by stretch. we'll still be behind after a few decades. basic arithmetic Vir!
7:30 all communities have been flocking to middle east for decades primarily for economic reasons and good law and order. Additionally the religious situation has eased in recent years, not specific to Modi. in fact many Indian muslims dislike MBS for liberalising. Again you are using extreme arguments leaving no scope for a gray/nuance.
8:30 because Hindus do not "belong" in Arab, they do not have any heritage sites taken over. Imagine if hindus had attacked any muslim religious site in Arab 200 hundred years ago, which they want back and hindus refuse to vacate. Hypothetical but that's the equivalence.
at least say something about hindus of pakistan and bangladesh
As per him it's all rhetoric
Brave piece, spitting out facts!!
5:33 Modi never ever hugged terrorist supporting leaders nor kept warm relations with them... again how miserably you fail to understand these simple facts
This also explains why these Muslim nations are cozy with Israel and America
It's not so much about the muslims as a whole but the opposition parties who tend to make their votebanks based on caste and religion of different areas. For the longest time atleast in North India the regional parties held sway by this method of divide and rule. Even now they can't stop rambling about caste census. The bjp is not that perfect when it comes to other issues like development but there is no hope for that from the opposition parties either.
10 minutes of continuous grumbling without saying anything.
I can understand the extreme pain 😮
And the bad news is , it's not going to end in near future
Sir u must take a posting to Bangladesh for a year or two. They seem to need your words of wisdom more than Indians at this moment.. once you achieve a secular tolerant Bangladesh you can return back. Because your ranting against Modi hasn't worked and let's see if you can bring back some change in Bangladesg
Some sense seems to have dawned on you but much more is needed. What every right thinking Indian knew since 2000, you have realised after 24 years! Quite a tube light.
Modi know not everything is Muslim appeasement
The key point missed here is that the Arab (Sunni) world is changing and modernizing at a rapid pace. The engagement both from the Indian leadership as well as people to people connections need to be analyzed with that context in mind.
The simple explanation is that Arab leaders do not see Modi or his government as being anti-Muslim or anti-Arab despite all the rhetoric by Singhvi and his like minded colleagues.
1 word- oversimplification. Sir there are many sides to evry issue please dont let your personal bias creep in
“He gets Netanyahu to set Pegasus” - Vir knows something that even Supreme Court committee didn’t! That’s such an irresponsible statement for him to say
This guy is very partial - half drunk of a page 3 type writer.
It's mostly concluded that any purchase of Pegasus would involve the Indian govt directly, since Israel's official statement was that they only sell Pegasus through govt to govt.
@@franciscotrinidad8251 😂😂
Vir's rhetoric is amazing....
Your shift to a narrative of anti-BJP and pro-Muslim without any objective basis is surprising and saddening to someone like me who used to follow you in print and on The Print. You need to step back and reflect on your recent output or rather outbursts.
Another brilliant analysis...nobel on the way...
Extremely Dumb analysis.
For a starter:
Indian Right wing doesn't have an issue with Islam or Muslims, its the Islamism or the ideology of Ikhwān al-Muslimīn or the Muslim brotherhood,
Which is the same ideology that the sheikhdoms of middle east also have a lot of issue with.
I don't know why but these guys with extremely polished english and some fancy education, pretend or rather themselves completely believe that they are all knowing.
The reality is a normal barber in Indian tier 3 city has more grasp of reality than these fancy english guys.
That's precisely why we don't have a good opposition now and all we have is a culturally rightwing but economically near socialist government running some department flawlessly while some not even praise worthy.
It sounded like analysis written by an intern using gen AI 😂
Arfa from Wire is also weeping and here Veer Sanghvi is also weeping on the same topic ! When India under Modi is doing great things by building closer ties with Gulf countries these people are not happy ! Which PM or senior Minister went and met ordinary humble working class Indians in the Gulf and enquired about their well being ?? Only Modi !! Did any elitist liberal journalist ever highlight the problems faced by these working class Indians ??? Just see Hindu Muslim in everything !!
People out of 80•s and 90•s politics?
We have to move away from our muslims obsessions.
Muslims muslims muslims....tiring
And all this melodrama after India was divided for a separate muslim. homeland
8:19 Strength of a community is not just about its numbers.
Its more about its the organisational structure, the communal ideology and the mobility.
Muslims are the group that has all these. Thats why Kashmiri Pandits were driven out of Kashmir when Majority of Hindus in India could only watch it helplessly
Great perspective .
Vir is normally very good with his analysis but this is the first time I didn't get the point he is trying to prove.
Sir, a few different narratives.
1 Islam invaders entry in Sindh in 712 AD.Qasim was a teenage Arab boy who commanded an essentially persian army.No mention of temple destruction.
Large scale conversions,yes.
2.2nd phase of Islamic invasions came from Afghans/Khurasan/ Persian/ Turks I the 1st decade of 11th century.Warlord Ghaznavi was not an Arab.
All subsequent invasions up to the Mughal dynasty were from Afghanistan whereas Turks played a major role.
Not 85 .. only 70 now 😮 what about kashmir pandits
Ha ha ! you are trying to drive a wedge between Modi and his supporters. Only idiot would do this. Muslims is not a religion issue but far greater cultural and social-political issue. I am at wit's end to understand your short sighted and shallow understanding.
Abb comments mein sab ronne lagage aur minor incidents ko proof ki tarh dikhayege
Hi Vir
Perhaps the phobia and victimhood of Hindus comes from the fact that minority Hindu Kashmiri were killed, raped and driven out of their homes and lands by the majority Muslims ? ( Have the Muslim minorities in other states suffered the same way as the Hindu minorities suffered in Kashmir?)
Perhaps the phobia and victimhood comes from the fact that anybody’s property can be claimed by Wakf Board - as the recent example in Karnataka with Wakf Board claiming ancestral lands of Hindu farmers?
Surely you can see that?
Even before watching the video I knew bhakts would lose their marbles. Bhakts would find some way justify their victimization even though they hate victim card except when they(bhakts) can play it too🤣🤣
Does he talk about Bangladesh? Good atleast he mentioned regressive M.
Nothing makes sense in this ….there is a huge difference in the way the ME goes about religion and how it happens here. All the activities..religious ones would not be tolerated there, and I mean the religious activities relating to Islam more that that of the Hindus and Christmas there.
😃, most things you will not find odd , only if you come out of your tunnel vision , which I know for sure you will not and cannot.. it’s pretty cozy for you in there now!😉
Didnt expect this bs from.him
How journalism has fallen
SO, how does this video make us wiswr?
Improve our lives by one crumb even?
Exactly HOW does SUCH journalism help us?
Zero help.
Modi and RSS and ANY power luster is evil. Totally. Karma will catch them.
Also bystandards ...
ONLY innovatorrs, visionaries CAN bring change.
UNmoral is evil too. Sad fact.
this guy is just out of his mind to say the least
Nobody can match these Modi bhakt trolls and all the hateful divisive negative comments. This episode should have been aired years ago. Hindus whether 75% or 60% is a huge figure 1.4bln ppl Hindu khatre may hai and Jyada bachhe by Modi. Slave labourers in the Gulf Diaspora prop up the GDP of India with their Remittances. Hindus always the victims stop breeding like flies resulting in Poverty open defecation healthcare and absolute economic distress of its citizens.
Congratulations Mr Sanghvi for forging an entirely dubious narrative riding on eloquence and selectivism. Hindu Victimhood is not a mere political slogan and it certainly doesn't spring from the middle East. Firstly, you need to look closer, at Bangladesh and Pakistan, and then much farther west to Australia, Canada, Britain, where hate crimes by Islamist and Khalistani extremists routinely make news. Secondly, The 10 years old Modi government certainly didn't appease muslims, but the reprehensible real politik of Muslim appeasement continues with Congress/Leftist politics that alienated and insulted Hindus in their own land for years. Hindu victimisation needs redressal even today as much as the caste discrimination against Dalits.
Vir is so anti Modi it's unbelievable. I mean why use sold us Pegasus instead of other more important tech?
Pakistan, Bangladesh and countries like Afghanistan do not exist for him.. bhai what stuff do you smoke... pls mention that in some other video aswell.
10:10 Anyone who reads Quran will understand the hollowness of your arguments. Im pretty sure you haven't tried to hear what Ex-Muslims have to say
He is out of a heart-attack since 2014!!!!! The owner who dances both hands while talking non-sense gives a good company!!!!!!
Vile comment but much better English than You. Stick with Hindi.
God bless Arabs ❤
What, s your thoughts about kashmiri pandit
Seems he got calls ..
Is he sane
BS journalistic twist and diluting core concerns
smart observation
One of the most nonsense and biased views, worst thoughts
🙄
tu khane ka hi review kar
and nobody is opressing muslims too dont appase muslims for youtube views.
Vir Sanghvi should stop writing and start reading articles and watching lectures and discussions of experts of geopolitics in various forums to understand what is going on here. His hackneyed views of Hindu Muslim binaries, secular vs Hindutwa communal rants interspersed with oft repeated examples of Muslim victimhood are too passé, thanks to access to free information educated Indians know a lot more than your antics. India needs strong relationship with the Middle East not only for energy security but also the shifting geopolitical map with withdrawal of the US, weakened Iran, assertive Turkey and Chinese inroads. Religion is the last thing India emphasizes, but seeks increased trade and investments from the rich sovereign wealth funds. Arfa, Vir and the like minded Islamists and Muslim loving secularists are feeling uncomfortable as their old narrative is challenged time and again.