'You're Not Being Honest' Adil Questions Kate Forbes on SNP's Election Manifesto
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 มิ.ย. 2024
- The SNP has set out its vision for Scotland. Their key pledges are Scottish independence, an extra £1.5 billion for the NHS and rejoining the European Union. But the SNP are currently behind in the polls, with Labour predicted to overtake them.
Adil Ray questions Kate Forbes MSP over the SNP's election manifesto.
Broadcast on 20/06/24
Stream Good Morning Britain live, every weekday from 6am on the ITVX 📲 daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
Subscribe now for more! bit.ly/1NbomQa
Like, follow and subscribe to Good Morning Britain!
The Good Morning Britain TH-cam channel delivers you the news that you’re waking up to in the morning. From exclusive interviews with some of the biggest names in politics and showbiz to heartwarming human interest stories and unmissable watch again moments.
Join Susanna Reid, Ed Balls, Kate Garraway, Richard Madeley, Charlotte Hawkins and Sean Fletcher every weekday on ITV from 6am until 9 every weekday!
ITVX: daytimelink.itv.com/WatchGMBYT
Website: bit.ly/1GsZuha
TH-cam: bit.ly/1Ecy0g1
Facebook: on. 1HEDRMb
Twitter: bit.ly/1xdLqU3
www.itv.com
#GMB #snp #scotland #generalelection #eu
Another liar just rolls of the SNP conveyer belt. Time to get Indepence from the SNP, bunch of 🤡
As a scot i hate the SNP can't wait to see the back off them.
Hate is a strong word. Why do you hate them? 🤔
Never trust anyone who moves their thumbs like that.
Grasping at straws again eh??
@@portman8909Clutching*
🤣
Nervous and calculating, not a good combination
Looks like she's praying for a miracle
I'm puzzled. This woman wants a completely independent country from the UK but she also wants her country to be ruled from Europe?
It's a joke, that has been the logic they have been peddling since Brexit, there is no independence, there are no funds, they want to flood Scotland with anyone who wants to come, there is no infrastructure, they want to join the Eu, they will never get the pipe dream, could you imagine the trash that would come into Scotland to get to England.
Ireland are not happy with whats happening there
They need someone to blame.
it's amazing how comments disappear when i mention the big corrupt club in Europe.
Are you suggesting the other countries in the European Union are not independent?... France, Germany, for example?... 🤔
SNP always puts the SNP’s interests first….not that of Scotland.
It's funny how they have more members than all of the other parties put together and the keep being voted into power, even in a fairer Proportional Representation voting system?... 🤔
how many times do we hear this about all the parties they never are totally honest
They’re all lying, every single one of them.
Forbes especially.
@@desgilroy1357 Not especially, they are all at it. Tories are lying about what a great job they have done and Labour lying about how the growth fairy is going to magically appear and save the day.
Desperate to get rid of SNP as they will never chase independence or do anything to achieve it
@@graemeross1998 Vote for them and they'll immediately open talks to start the process of independence. It's in their manifesto.
@@graemeross1998 You had your referendum and lost. Get over it
Scotland cannot "re-join" that which it has never been a member. It was the UNITED KINGDOM that was the member. Scotland has never been a member of the EU.
False ... do your homework kid.
@@PYDPIPER😅😅
@@PYDPIPER Has Scotland actually received anything in writing from the EU to confirm it could be?
Did Ursela von der Leyen not state that "when Scotland becomes an Independent country....they would be accepted to join the EU?"
@@annemonaghan4576 I think you're referring to the following quote:
_"Any European State, which respects and promotes the values of the EU, may apply to become a member of the Union"_
That isn't a guaranteed "yes", it's a "of course they could apply ". Plus, she isn't the President now, so you'd need to ask the current one
You dont hold anyone in your own party accountable never mind anyone else
Yet she actually did
@@chiefgilray who? old dodging a charge Sturgy?
@@boabs-bees yeah she did...
@@chiefgilray Kicking out people who disagree with isn't holding to account.
@@boabs-bees are you for real... If someone is booted out of a party, that's making them accountable as they are being disciplined
SNP are washed... absolutely cooked
Actual criminals. Conspiritors, the whole party.
REFORM UK
Slugs voting for salt 🧂 😅
Ye vote reform then us that can afford the insurance premiums can get healthcare quicker .
What about them?...apart from being awful they are not even gonna get above 5 seats
@@roseanncampbell3168How ungrateful people are to want to stop the erosion of our democracy, to stop our right to speak about mass immigration, the right to be proud of the country they live in, the right to stop are taxes being used on forever wars, the right to live a free and peaceful life. Only people like you are against all of the above because you know best. Good luck with that.
Starmer doesn't know what a woman is yet people think he's fit to be PM? Really?
Snp let male rapists into female prisons. And if they're under 23 they just get to walk free.
So you brought that hook, line, and sinker?
Go hide under your bed if all the trans people out there scare you so much. 😂😂😂😂
@@marty1459 Aww bless. You had to edit your wonderfully insightful comment. I'd do another edit - there is a delete option just so you know.
Reality may not matter to you but I think the person leading the UK should have a grip on it.
I think it's more likely the establishment trying to convince people that the population are wanting Labour. Reality is it's mainly the immigrants that want Labour. The Brits don't like Starmer and his knee benders
Adil talking about honestly😂
A poll in The Telegraph 😂
When were you last in Raigmore Hospital Kate. Your mob have spent the money on SNP glory, and you will lose on the 4th July.
Raigmore is a great little hospital go to Leicester general and see the difference
Big constituency pal, wise up
Google “Barnet consequentials” and educate yourself on how our NHS is funded.
Raigmore is full because Scotland can't control it's own immigration or borders .The sheer volume of old retired English immigrants to the Highlands is dragging the NHS to its knees. And then they moan about the Tory's not controlling borders.
@@chiefgilray Do you know how big the catchment area is for Raigmore ? massive all the way to Wick outer Hebrides Orkney
Can’t afford to keep the lights on since Nicola and her husband took all the money.
SNP do not represent the Scottish true nationals.
They are a fake independence party for sure
So who voted for them or is this just the famous “no true Scotsman” fallacy?😂
@@tatata1543 nah dude served 27years Argyll and Sutherland highlanders...SNP do not reflect Scottish beliefs.
@@graemebuchan8142 They do not represent your beliefs obviously but I have some news for you, you don’t speak for Scotland. Sorry to bring you the bad news.
@@graemebuchan8142 Also, dude? Seriously?😂
Since when do you need to be lectured to by people who read autocues for a living?
True
I remember when the news presented the facts.... now all they do is preach a position.... it used to be impartial and about making up your own mind..
it's just influencers paid by shills
She is a complete amateur
Exactly mate. You should be on there instead.
@@IainFrame😂
Kate wee traitor
If not a good look in a dark empty office 😂😂😂
She looks good regardless
Been empty since the police raided it
@@robcarrol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
What is Adil even doing on a news programme ? Still remember him back in the days when he worked for Asian network!
He used the race card to get that job he only is giving Kate Forbes a hard time because she is a strict Christian woman
SNP are very dodgy....
Which party aren't
The SNP couldn’t run a raffle never mind a country.
They're actually pretty-good at raffles, I've heard.
Nicola won a motor-home on their last one! 😉
@@dftfire 😂
Yet the Scottish people ripe the benefits that the SNP put in place.
Free prescriptions, no bedroom tax, baby box, free bus pass to 60+ n upon 22 n on it goes.
Saor Alba 🏴🏴🏴
@annemonaghan4576 bedroom tax ? How can it be a tax when a large percentage of the people it applies to don't actually pay any tax at all ? I have tried to see how much tax gets collect from this bedroom tax and HMRC say its zero so can anyone explain how these people are paying this tax ?
The important election from an SNP point of view are the Holyrood elections in 2026 by which time Labour will be just about halfway through a parliament and will be deeply unpopular. Starmer isn’t even that popular now and I foresee the shortest honeymoon period ever before his ratings tank.
The last time I checked this was an election not Britain's got talent. We need stability, not a pop band. Did you not learn anything from bojo and co and the chaos he came with?
@@roseanncampbell3168 Whit?😂
The Cons will take Phoneyrude in 2026 and I'm not talking about the mob in power now!
@@desgilroy1357 You don’t half talk some pish.
I hope Reform wins and kicks Scotland out the union.
You honestly believe reform will get rid of the golden goose . Scotland is what keeps angerland afloat .
I'm guessing the GMB is for toddlers. What awful political discussion.
Why does anyone listen to aldi ray? The guy got upset when michael gove did not turn up to be interviewed by gmb when in fact he was probably getting ready to be interviewed by the bbc. On that day michael gove was on bbc about 15 minutes after he apparently failed to turn up for gmb.
Humza would call her too white!!
Jesus wept, love how you people get zapped in by a narrative 😂😂😂
@@chiefgilray doesn't make it less true though
Still a bit white 😅
Scotland must be mad. To vote for SNP, Labour.
Reform..we all pull together.
@@Suve35967 reform... So you want change but in a referendum where change was on the cards, you vote against it?
Well said, Kate. All of our Oil wealth was used to fund Thatcher’s deindustrialisation agenda, Cameron’s austerity😮 has starved public services of funding for years and yet the British establishment media come away with, “oh but, this and that are devolved.” Yes, but in the words of Wes Streeting - all roads lead back to Westminster.
So Scotland is basically broke then?
Vote Reform UK 🇬🇧 and lets get our country back. 😊
Yea, vote wingnut that’ll work 😂
What country ? There are 4 countries here
@@annieaitken6591 It’s reform so it’s England , Scotland wants nothing to do with those nutters or that chancer Farage.
Don't hate Brittany enough to vote reform
No thank you, they are no better than the tories.
All dishonest people
Liars
Lying about what specifically?
@@debbiegilmour6171
It would be quicker and take up less of folks time if you could tell us when the snp told the truth Debs.
Nes pas??
SNP are so obnoxious. We’re so bored of this now, you had your once in a generation vote and lost move on.
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
Unless you live there it's non of your business.
@@jake751 If your British it’s every much your business.
Not the snp pushing, it us proud Scots pushing
@@MrAlexMotoScotrish yes voters are Scotrish only son, mind your own business
Reform
I’m looking forward to a Labour government in Scotland that will stop all those free things being given to them like the child payment free prescriptions baby boxes etc
I've just commented on what your post is saying.
Saor Alba 🏴🏴🏴
Vote SNP for Independence then vote for who you want In an Independent Scotland.
Free things like free oil and gas from Scotland are rich pickings for English nationalists thieving Scotland's resources
Bore off mate, that's a tired old argument
you look forward to a labour government that stop child payments,free prescriptions and baby boxes, really?
What a Tory you are wanting to take child payments and baby boxes from children, shameful!
@@TheGladiator125are you kidding!
Reform is what we need.
Vote for it.
SNP states that it puts Scotland first. However Scotland has a higher rate of income tax and yet is worse than uk in both health and education in spite of extra funding arising from the Barnet formula.
They use the extra cash on vanity projects and bribes for the poor and the illegals to keep voting them in.
Utter nonsense, Scotland has progressive taxation,Scots voted for these tax powers,NHS in Scotland is in a far better shape than that in England.
@@TheGladiator125
Meanwhile on the planet Zonk........
@TheGladiator125 Since the SNP came to power, Scotland is no longer a pround contributor to the union. It is not Westminster that is ar fault but SNP incompetence.
Nonsense absolute nonsense from tv presenters that onow fk all about scotland
I know about Scotland and i know she is a liar, i know that the SNP have destroyed Scotland. I know that Scotland needs to free itself from Nat rule.
And the snp cult know even less.
Depending on the poll you look at, the SNP are between 3 and 5 points behind Labour amd are gaining ground. That hardly constitues being "well behind".
Indeed. Because the Labour vote is primarily based in the Central belt, a shift of 34% up to 36% for the SNP can be the difference between 15 seats and 30 seats.
That Aldi guy is totally inept. Reading off an auto cue in that passive aggressive way is not impresssive.
The SNP claim that the people of Scotland voted for Scotland to remain in the EU. No they didnt. That would of been a totally different vote and I imagine many more wouldve voted if that had been the question
Eu told you that they don't want you
Various SNP figures have said EU officials have said Scotland would be let back in, but oddly not in writing, nor can they ever name who they've spoken to... 🤔
The EU would love to have Scotland back as a way of getting one over the UK for leaving. Hence their strong support of Ireland.
She should shut him up by make him state where he got his facts from as he's obviously a pro Tory like all these media zombies !
She handled them both with ease...I was expecting a grilling based on the preview at the start of the video 😕
£ 17.6 Billion specifically for the NHS was siphoned off from the Barnett monies by the SNP to spend on other undisclosed projects.
SCOTTISH People are absolutely desperate to get rid of this SNP.
These newsy personnel know the future, do they? Another referendum on UK membership is not 'unlikely' to call for remaining in the UK, but more likely to assert the Scottish desire to rejoin the European Union, given Tory misrule of the UK the last 15 years. Talk about bias.
Kate Forbes has got what we used to call in the 1980s a 'Tefal'
😂
If Forbes had been FM instead of the box ticking clown they’d be in an even more powerful position , even with the Sturgeon debacle .
Absolute unionist claptrap , Labour and the Tories are identical twins.
The SNP wanted to put listening devices in people's house and have a state sponsored guardian for every child, George Orwell spinning at speed of sound in grave
Stop lying 🙄
Nuuurse!! He’s out of bed again!!!
You mean like Theresea May when she wanted the Snooper Charter started?
What a load of drivel😂
Interesting fact; the warranty on the engines for the two ferries has run out before they've even turned a wheel.
Vote REFORM save our GREAT BRITAIN the one we had until 14 yrs of the CON’s
Reform doesn't care for Scotland. Never will vote for English nationalists.
the English press never seem to like the SNP i wonder why ? ;)
The majority of us Scots hate the Nats as well.
Cos they're shyte!
@@derekbrown3165 that would explain their majority is so big lol
Just like us Scots
@@derekbrown3165 The SNP never tell anyone if they become independent who will they trade tariff free with. At least in the Uk we trade tariff free with each other. Use each others health service for free aswell. No hard borders.
London gets more funds than anywhere in the UK. You never hear that in the media.
All the time!
Doesn't London also generate almost a 3rd of the entire UK's GDP also?
Perhaps that has something to do with the amount of investment that goes into London compared to other areas of the UK.
@@johnclark5349 Almost if that's why the "City of London" was setup as a private enterprise. Doesn't change the fact the UK's GDP is unfortunately tied to London atm.
They also raise the largest tax revenue, which gets redistributed throughout the whole country. So what's your point?
Vote reform uk only
Slugs voting for salt 🧂😅.....
Slugs voting for salt 🧂 😅
Slugs voting for salt 🧂
Blame it on Westminster, we're tired of that excuse!
Kate Forbes is clearly much smarter than either of the questioners. 🤔
Austerity, BREXIT and Cost of Living not the fault of the SNP.
Brexit was a choice the British people made to leave the EU. The cost of living was caused by all these politicians, did you see the Scottish government is now being sued by Biffa for the deposit return scheme? Or the EU grant that wasnt spent in Scotland and now needs to be returned to the EU, what about the flood money award that the SNP dudnt use to help the flooded community, what about the ferries ? And so much more. SNP are corrupt.
Absolute tripe, Britain is and is expected to outperform all other EU nations until around 2050 at least. Stop lying to yourself it isn't healthy, democracy isn't crying about a decided issue until you get your own way. Remainers = Toddlers, waaa, waaa, waaaaa.
@@boabs-bees Brexit benefits not to be seen until after 50 years. Quoted from Jacob Rees Smugg LOL
@@portman8909 So even better then, were outperforming them already and that's forecast to continue until 2050. So well ahead of the 50 year schedule. You proved my point LOL your SMUGGNESS
God I can’t stand this guy so arrogant
Don't agree with SNP policy, but Kate Forbes does speak well.
typical english media linking independence to the SNP when its about the people the snp are the means to independence
I used to think that she was one of the few competent SNP MSPs but alas no longer. This performance was as poor as the one on Question Time. No clarity, no credible policy and an infinite capacity to twist words and waffle. Once anyone with any cash has been taxed dry or left the country our proud country would be left on its knees.
Was wondering how long she would take to blame Westminster.
What has good morning Britain to do with Scottish politics ?
I assume it is shown in Scotland? 🤔
Geography isn't your strong point then?🤦
You a Sun reader I suspect !!.
Far from it.
Card carrying socialist
You could say what are Scots doing voting on English matters in Westminster.
I don't mind the idea of independence, but I hate the SNP
It will take about 15/20 years to be in a position to join the EU. Vote ALBA
2021 is in the past! Harking back is not relevant!
Another sturgeon look what happened to her😂😂😂
Good grief the lies are tripping out of her mouth.
Kate schooling them. Scotland wealthiest country in Europe/World.
Snp are finished in Scotland end off
Aye right😂
In your dreams mate.
That’s NOT what we’re hearing on the door steps ?🤔🤔🤥🤥🤫🤫😵💫😵💫🤡🤡 LIE after LIE 🤮🤮🤮
She looks nervous and unsure still blaming Westminster how on earth CD she deliver independence
Twiddles her thumbs while trying to think of another lie. We have another two weeks to put things right forget the last seventeen years of mismanagement, incompetence and fraud .
What is that crazy lady personating an MP doing with her hands?!?
All of her anxiety is clearly manifesting in her hands😀. She knows she is blagging it.
I don't think she realised her hands were seen most of the time
@@bernarddodd9788 Yes, thanks
It supposed to be a calming exercise for the nerves but all she’s advising to me at least that she knows her party is in bad shape or that she knows that they can’t deliver on something that is being promised
Will you find the missing ringfenced £33M meant for agriculture and farmers?... or the 2 payments of £750K and £250K Humza Useless made to Gaza?.... that would be a good start.
It will be very hard to get out of the EU once you join. Extremely hard.
So.
Even harder to join, muppets!
Kate Forbes got a big pay rise recently.
Scots have been independent before they were dependent, but its funny how the EU was a tory idea, Ted Heath another Tory took us in all this was doneby tories.
Same old script, we need them out, now.
they have lost my vote
Whatever you think of the SNP plans, they are costed out better than those of the Red Tories or Blue Tories. I wouldn't necessarily say that theirs has been costed really well, just better than the two colours of Tories.
Grow up
Oh what a witty and well informed response. 🙄
@@markc7440 "red tories", "two colour of tories". You're a pure riot mate. We need to get away from this infintile form of politics and get some serious people in govt again. We're all fed up of the SNP and their symbiotic partners in crime the tories.
I've been called a few four letter words in my life but I think that riot is a new one 😂
I'm not sure I'd have SNP and Tories down as bed fellows but at times their parties have had similarly autocratic leaders.
Quite right that we need to get away from infantile politics - eg I get so annoyed at PMQ when no PM bothers to answer the actual question and gives a response of their own.
But re my original point, SNP policies are costed out better than the Tories and Labour, I'm not talking about how good or bad I think those policies are, just the costings.
Tends to be that the parties who best give costed policies are SNP, Plaid Cymru, Greens, parties in Northern Ireland, the Lib Dems, then Tory and Labour. That doesn't necessarily mean that SNP policies are costed out well, just the least worst.
You can tell when she's lying - her lips move.
How many Muslims in Scotland have paid stamp duty or council tax in the last 15 + years , probably none of very few all that money missing fron the treasury that could have been spent on Scotland .
The SNP seems very dodgy, but, that is about right ✅
Labour - tories and all the rest are angels ehhh?
Surely the SNP wouldnt tell lies or embezzle funds ?
We are desperately looking for the snp green's out
You have had 17 years at source????
Kate Forbes, Where was she last month!!! No opposition when, last 1st Minister was sacked??
Was hse saying something? I zoned out
ITV is a privatised company with a business agenda. Scotland is big business for those from The Square Mile invested there.
Adil did not come to play today....😎
Sorry to bring a bit of logic here but if Westminster says there is no mandate when the Scotrish people sent a majority of pro independent MPs to Westminster, voted against a big constitutional change and have a 50% backing for independence when it was at 30% when we won the right rmto have a referendum before 2014 then if Scotland does the opposite for unionist (even though Labour literally have nothing pro union in their manifesto) parties being sejlnt to Westminster as a mandate for staying into the uk.
Dry your eyes Westminster loyalists
Seems to be quite a nice lady but it is a shame that she appears to be living in Cloud Cuckoo land .
Some where in scotland a wendy house is missing its toddler
Have the Greens been on the prowl?
SNP yawn manifesto independence Tories are bad yawn
looks like the camper van will have to go on ebay then !
The woman who abandoned her Christian principles. Shame on her.
Scotland voted NO to breaking up the union IGNORE THE PEOPLE AT YOUR PERIL NO TO INDEPENDENCE.
Vote for the Citizen Independents or The Workers Party of Britain or Reform to end the reign of the Uniparty Criminal Collective on Independents day 4th July 2024!!!