29. Why don’t the Shia fold their arms in prayer? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 พ.ค. 2024
- 29. Why don’t the Shia fold their arms in prayer? | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani
------------------------
Subscribe to Sayed Ammar’s official online platform, consisting of bespoke courses, exclusive content, brand new podcasts & more!
www.sayedammar.com
Please continue this series, as a revert i cannot expresss how helpful these have been. Alhamdulillah
As a sunni I love watching your videos
😂😂 you are a shiaa brother l, why are you lying
@@ashrafulalam4281not all suuniz are ignorant some know that sunnis and Shias are brothers like it or not
why are you doing taqqiya just for likes on a youtube video
I’m a revert. I’m here to learn about Shia may Allah direct me to the right path
This man is misguided and a deviant. Go learn about their beliefs from their scholars.
Thank you for the knowledge. You’ve only made me more and more Shia after every video Hamdillah.
Keep them coming Sayedna. I know there is so much more to uncover and to expose. Todays one was more about just looking at how hypocritical Ahlul Sunnah can be sometimes towards the Shia.
Can I ask you a question as a Muslim?
@@omarazmery Sure brother
@@A.A471 who was the first shia ?
@@omarazmery do you want first Shia of the Prophet SAW or the first Shia of Imam Ali A.S ?
@@omarazmery Or I can even give you verses of the Shia of prophets if you want ?
Early gang here! Thank you brother for being here with us.
Alhamdullillah to have you in our lives. May Allah continue to bless with more wisdom and understanding
I feel proud to have scholars like you May Allah bless you
Thank you Sayed Ammar ❤❤❤
Thank you Dr Sayed Ammar.
Thank you for making this series. Even though the videos are long - they can be used as reference for discussion with different schools of thought
Allahu Akbar!
Thank you ❤
Mashallah God bless you Sayed .
May Allah SWT bless and protect you 🤲🏻💙
The last hadith was absolutely phenomenal 😓🤲
Am really proud of you Sayed
Thank you
Finally mr ammar
I love you brother
Assalamualaikum wa rahmantullahi wa barakatuh to all My Bright Faced People #Twelve #AllahuAkbar #AllahuAkbar #AllahuAkbar 🖤💚🤲🏾🕋☪️
Wa aleikum assalaam brother ❤
I am a Shia Revert and I try to explain this is why I find Shia Islam as most authentic and reliable because Sunni practices are not even unified in there teachings of our 5 daily prayers no disrespect to Sunnis because I know we are all Muslims. But if they can’t agree on basics of prayer I can’t imagine how they stay consistent and unified in all major teachings as well
Masya Allah, keep on giving lecture on the true way of Islam.
allahumma barikk laku fikk
It’s very concerning how even within the Sunni religion they dont agree upon a simple matter which is the way they pray, and claim WE as Shia are the wrong
and you as shia cant agree on who the imams are, the Ismailis have one imam, the twelvers have one imam, the zaydis have another, all claim to be the right shia
@@WaqasAli-ct7lythe same way there are multiple sects within sunni islam that claim to be the right one. respectfully, the same words you use against shias can be used against you
@@farahs2204right 😂
Thanks Syed
Just shock how I barely know this information. ❤.
Assalamu alaikum brother ammar,
Can you please do more quran tafseer videis with english translation of the suras which you havent done on your channel.
Mashallah
Link to all the hadiths you mentioned please I want to buy some so I can study for myself
Salaam Brother Ammar, jazaak-Allah khair for your thorough and well-researched speeches. MashAllah, you dive deep into all the literature that you can possibly find, may Allah SWT bless you and your team for bringing us such knowledge.
A quick question please, how do we convince some people we know who are very stubborn and unacceptable of the Shia sect and enable them to start listening to the reasons behind our beliefs? Jazaak-Allah khair 🙏🙏🙏
Please, sir, can you activate the translation mode into Arabic, especially in your videos in which you discuss dialogue with people?
من اي دولة؟@@user-maraym
Jzk❤
The Muslims in yesteryears had 3 groups Sunnis who accept the 4 Rashidun Sahabi Khalifas, the Kharijis who accepted only the first 2 Rashiduns (Abu Bakr and Omar) and the Shias who accept only on one as Rashid calling him Imam (Ali).
Interestingly Imam Malik used to pray his Fardh/Wajib prayers using SADL (hands by side) in Madinah. Shias pray using Sadl. And, most Interesting is the Kharijis who believe that Othman and Ali AS erred (now only one prominent group called Abadis of Oman) pray using Sadl.
Qabd near sadr (heart) is done by jews whereas the Xoroastrians and the early Byzantines prayed to their Kings and Gods with hands below their navel.
My opinion is that this innovation of Qabd is a biddah.
I was born into a Deobandi-Barelwi (the two sects of Subcontinental Hanafis, who call each other Kafir) family and I have spent a lot of my time with Khanqahis (Sufis), Barelwis, Deobandis (especially Tablighi Jamat), Jamaat-e-Islami of Maududi, Shabban-e-Ahle-Hadeeth (Najdi-Wahabis, the descendants of Maslama kidhdhab), Quranists.
Now I call myself only muslim like Ibraheem AS, and believe Ali as Wali and Wasi because sunni books are full of ahadeeth regarding Ali of being Maula. But I don't belong to any sect of Shias/Sunnis/any other group.
I think Shias (Athna-Asharis) are closer to the Qur’ān but the Shiism of Zakereens puts me off because of their Nusayri/Alawi beliefs.
Since last 5 years I pray hands by my side and end my prayers with Allahu-Akbar and post that I say Assalamoalaikum, because I believe there is nothing wrong in giving blessings of peace to those praying to my left and right.
Sahl ibn Sad was a prominent shia of Imam Ali. He must have said (the people were ordered by Omar) but like 10 and 6 from Hadrat Ayesha's age 10 was omitted, (by Omar) was also omitted by Muhaddetheen to make it ambiguous as if it was ordered by Prophet Muhammad SAW himself.
Each one of them claims to have seen our prophet Muhammad(saw) to have prayed in a certain way, I have also heard of a hadith, (if I'm not wrong) That when our prophet (saw) was praying, "when reciting a long Surah he will place his hands by his sides to rest his arms, regardless if you put your hands over your chest or buy your sides you are still standing in front of Allah and praying your Salah
but I have never personally heard a Sunni call a Shia a kafir for that purpose, I personally put my hands on my chest, Not because I follow such and auch but this is what I've learnt in a book called Islamic studies plus this is comfortable for me to place my hands on my chest (Heart)
23:36 And if someone wants to call me a kafir for that purpose then that is your problem, personally I will never call anyone that says la ilaha illallah Muhammad rasulullah a kafir, anyone that calls another Muslim a kafir has committed kufur him self
Al hamdillah, you will not find any of our shia people to call anyone who puts his hands on his chest a kafir, but there are certain groups that teach their followers to call us (shia) kafir.
We are brothers in faith. We both come to different conclusions as what the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet (saws) is and at the end it is Allah (swt) who will judge our differences.
Knowledge is power. Salam brother.
You literally said you would never call another Muslim a kafir and in the very next sentence you accused Muslims of Kufr.
@joshrentos216 No, sorry, what I meant was A man does not call another as fasiq or kafir, except that he will be the apostate if the other is actually not” & they are not my own words, I'm sure you know what I mean,
But it's clear now that regardless of whatever I say, I am an enemy to you because I am from ahl al sunah, I would just like to ad that the majority of my friends are from Ahl al Shia & we are like Brothers,
Please don't be a hater. I have nothing against you regardless if you're Muslim or Not
@@joshrentos216 are you even Muslim
@sadikkadom9566 Brother, the ones you're referring to also call some of us kafir as well if we have even 1% difference this is extremism at another level,
Well the introduction proves what I've said just about all along.... What do you call a person who follows five atheists his whole life.. he never does one halal Salat or one halal wudu?.. imagine they go their whole lives and never ever ever do one real wudu.... Mind-blowing
Praying with your hands on your side for Sunnis it’s not haram. The whole where to place your Arms in salah goes as far as Sunnah not further. You can’t takfir someone because of their hand/arm placement in salah (that’s what wahabis/salafis do Not Sunnis) and Sunnis don’t believe it’s wajib to wrap your arms in salah.
While true you will get the most disgusting looks if you don’t fold your hands and be kicked out of any Sunni mosque
Brother can u please make a video explaining Sunan ibn majah 106, many sunnis contradict us on this.
Dang it was simple and short
Sayed can you please also address this question of many ? Why our prophet Mohammad had so many wives ? The historical and political reasons behind these marriages even though all wives were not as pious as should have been ?
❤❤❤
سلام
نمیدانم زبان من را متوجه خواهید شد یا نه ولی یک سوال دارم
استاد قرآن من برای ما گفته بود نماز اول وقت به علاوه بهتر بودنش به این دلیل هم مهم است چون امام زمان علیه السلام هم و همه مؤمنین نماز اول وقت میخوانن و این خود نوعی جماعت غیبی میباشد حالا سوال من این است منم دوست دارم به همین دلیل نمازم را اول وفت بخوانم تا به امامت امام زمانم باشد اما ساعت هر کشور اسلامی فرق دارد مثلا من اهل افغانستان هستم عراق با ما یک ونیم ساعت فرق دارد پس این موضوع چگونه است واقعا؟
Can you please show me one single Sunni who has ever made takfir of a Shia ONLY because they have their arms by their side. Show me literally one single Sunni
11:20 name me ONE SINGLE BOOK which makes takfir of people SIMPLY because of how they pray. Otherwise you’re a liar
Who was first Shia? Please don’t say Ali. RA. Still waiting? Any shia want to defend Shiasim?
Which shia are you referring to? Shia just means followers. So followers of whom? It's not like Imam Ali a.s. was when the word came to be. It's in the Qur'an, so please clarify.
@@nourahrmumeenslave let me say it clearly who was the first Shia? An answer would clear up this question. If you asked me who the first human was, I would say, Adam. If you would’ve asked me who was the first Muslim, I would say, Adam. So now I’m asking a shia. Who was first Shia ?
@@omarazmeryAdam is not the first Muslims, Adam was the first human, as a Catholic Christian I disagree, Adam is not the first Muslims nowhere did church history or cathecism says so. My pope will not say it tho. Salafism only came in 18th century.
@@omarazmery shia of what? Shia of Musa? shia of Ibrahim? shia of Shaytan? To Which Shia are you referring? Stop trying to add more to the word Shia than it is...in English then, to which "followers" are you referring? "And most surely Abraham was among the Shi’a of him (i.e., Noah)”(Qur’an 37:83) so which shia?
@@nourahrmumeenslave I see how your shia mentality makes you can’t answer a basic question. So sad how you Shias call yourself Muslim but can not even be honest. Shia belief goes against all prophets peace be upon them.
I will test your honesty do you know who first person to turn shia belief into a religion and start taking some people away from Islam?
Shia religion?? Lol what's that
They have big shirk and innovation you talk about folding arms what a waste of time
God bless you Sayyed Ammar 🙏