‘Absolutely disgraceful’: ‘Gag order’ on residents over renewables slammed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- The Australian’s Contributing Economics Editor Judith Sloan has slammed the “absolutely disgraceful” gag order given to residents who agree to have a renewable installation in their area.
“You have to sign a gag order - so basically, you have to talk favourably about renewable energy and say that you love the turbines,” she told Sky News Australia.
“But here’s the point that if you violate that gag order, they reserve the right to withdraw the monetary compensation - it is absolutely disgraceful.”
Should be a Labor sorry day, for all the muppetts that voted for them. 😅
The morons who did are now saying they didn't.
I want a sorry day & an apology from the people that Voted for Daniel Andrews & Albo
Me too
Can we administer the rattan before they apologise?? Can we? Pleeeeeeease?
@@ideaphile your comment didnt make sense to me. Autocorrect?
Mr Morrison signed us up for the economically destructive delusional insanity of Net Zero.
The feckless ALP then doubled down upon this economic and environmental vandalism.
They frequently indulge in Jetsetting around the world at taxpayers expense, however they are oblivious to the consequences of the same triple popular delusion based energy policy in Germany.
@@davefoord1259 Sorry - now corrected!
Where's the EPA on these grubs, oh that's right, Every Project Approved. 🤔
Many thousands of submissions have been put to the EPA against hundreds of renewables projects. There is a great deal of knowledge and expertise amongst those submissions and all of this information is ignored. Of course the issues around wind turbines, solar panels and backup batteries are exactly the same for every project yet we are expected to submit submissions for each and every project. The numerous risks and fact based objections have to be presented over and over and even when the EPA refers some issues back to the developer they take the word of the developer every time. We are so sick of the lies being told.
We have more than 50 projects in the pipeline for our beautiful region alone. It's hard to get the numbers for the submissions with small populations and we received notification on a recent project that as the number of submissions received totalled 49 it will automatically be approved. It goes before a panel if you can get more than 50 submissions but you only get five minutes to present your case. It is so humiliating trying to present all that you know in just five minutes. It's pretty much a waste of time anyway, their eyes glaze over and they don't seem to be listening.
There needs to be a Royal Commission into renewable energy. What is happening out here in the regions is devastating.
Yes, some people never leave the suburbs and don't see how bad this really is. Fancy relying on a Government who doesn't care less about you.
One has thought bubble.
About Environmentalist Activists renting Air Conditioned Office Space in Metropolitan Business Districts, and taking flight in Luxury Private Aircraft.
We need a sorry day for free speech.
Turbines and large scale panels should be banned.
Not large scale all of them sould be banned.
Oh poor Leonardo, did somebody spoil your view ?
.
VOTE ALL LABOR OUT, SIMPLE.
Vote ONE NATION!
It was the LNP who under Howard/Anderson in 2002 brought in the Renewable Energy Act.
This act created a honeypot subsidy environment where those companies’ building turbines are paid between $600K - $900K per turbine per annum to companies wanting to build wind turbines, in just this subsidy alone which taypayers money is sent offshore and funnelled into shelf companies leaving farmers with a massive bill if anything happens to them like catching on fire.
This subsidy is reaming $40B per year out of the Australian economy and is paid by ALL Australians via our power bills.
Yes.. but
Not so 'simple'
There are quite a few woke Liberals as well
Judith is spot on, we need more of her wisdom on your show.
Go with the cheapest and most reliable, COAL!
Cheapest form of energy on the planet.
We will all be sorry everyday when we lose everything and own nothing living in a 15 minute city with a social credit and carbon score.
Free we will be no more.
Thats when other countries exert themselves over ours and force their cultures on us.
Note that a lot of these wind farms are Italian/ French/ Singaporean /Chinese !
you think you've ever been free?
@@andyman8630 years ago things were definitely better. No phones, cars didn’t tell you how to drive, one wage could run an entire household with a mortgage.
Your question is more philosophical than a serious question and I am sure you know what I mean.
@@paulgraham5790
we were still slaves to the system, money and govt decades ago - just wasn't so "in your face"
The amount of money shovelled to Ukraine by the Gubberment, we could have built two Nuclear Plants.
So you think Russia is doing the right thing, invading a country??
Next step for Dutton is a statement that all govt. funded or guaranteed intermittent energy projects will be stopped in their tracks by Libs. at least until a proper assessment of ALL associated costs is considered.
We simply need to withdraw from the ridiculous Paris agreement and use the most economical energy resources available.
I don't feel any confidence in Dutton after he SUPPORTED Labors IDIOTIC Digital I.D. and the anti-free speech, e-Safety Commissar. He's become "Labor Light".
We need a “Sorry Day” for all Labor government past and present. Everything from power bills, mining approvals, tax increases, NDIS Funding, AUKUS agreement, immigration, bills against free speech, cover up’s in the senate, ridiculous government pay rises, Labor influence on the ABC/CSIRO/ASIC, the renewable energy scam, KATY GALLAGHER… the list goes on and on.
✔
funny thing is the Aboriginals are OK with this mass destruction.
Have they been asked ?
Same as most people
Because they know Albo is going to pay them billions in compensation for building all this rubbish
abo.s only care about linning their own pockets
@@stewatparkpark2933 probably not.
DO NOT OBEY ,SPEAK YOUR MIND ,dont be told to stay silent ,,and never be sorry for some other buggers history not lived
'SORRY" is a swear word for politicians. It indicates they were wrong. On the other hand 'LIE' is a necessity.
I know i speak for all cattle, sheep and humans out there that we hate windmills, panels and transmission lines. I can even extend that to all my marine life friends in the sea.
Exactly, so-called "renewables' in their current form are not environmentally friendly in the traditional meaning - protect flora and fauna and ecosystems
A sorry day from Labor to the Australian people for the Albenese government and the destruction they caused to the economy and Australian values!!😢
I’m 🇦🇺🇦🇺I say sorry to no one,,very easy to fix vote them out ,that easy ,use what we sell coal and gas
Ugly sight. Poor Birds 🐦🕊️
I'l be gone to a much better place before the full penalty for he renewal madness becomes apparent, but I really care about those who are following my generation. Gag orders? Disgusting and outrageous, to put it gently.
Labour must go!
" Wake up Australia"
From my back door l can count around 100 , short drive across the paddock and its 200. Can only hope the teals view of the harbour never has to change..
What happened to Freedom of speech????
Personally have never asked any politician to say a SORRY for me on behalf of indigenous people
Down the American way. We don’t need anymore sorry days. Time to move on and stop the rot. The city people have no idea of our land being destroyed by Labor and the greens
It's only recently that Scotland's S.N.P. admitted that 15 MILLION trees were destroyed in the establishment of their wind turbine, "environment friendly", generation grid. They also admitted that they had to install turbines gas heaters to "unfreeze" the turbines, due to freezing weather before, they could get them to operate. Just a sample of the coverup there, and Australia in years to come will hear the truth, when it is all too late, and the Political proponents are sitting back on huge taxpayer funded superannuation benefits.
Idot politicians need a gag order
Judith is correct on all she said. Great informative again Rowan, Rita and James.
The Directors and CEO and major shareholders of these renewable companies should be made to pay to repair all the land broken through the renewables development.
Isn’t that blackmail?
No it's bullshit
@@longway1 It's bullshit because it's blackmail.
I think the issue with Matt is that once again this job is a total waste of taxpayers' money for zero performance that will make zero difference to the outcome of climate change, zero difference to the CO2 level, zero difference to the protection of the environment and most likely taxpayer money totally wasted to make the energy transition worst, to increase debt, and the create a bigger mess that needs to be fixed down the track with more taxpayers' money. No wonder we are going broke.
Will we ever get a politician in this country that cares????????
Gutless government - the truth can't come out. Expected when you have the world's most gutless PM.
You can't control the narrative if you have people running around telling th truth.
The Albanese government should be made to pay first nations and regional people $1000 for each bird strike, every cancer attributable to the problems caused by destroyed panels and towers. This money should be paid by the elected members who voted for them, both the Labor greens and purple people.
Judith Sloan you should be in Politics Nations or Liberals would love to have a sensible person like you, people would listen to you
Thats if we outlive the starvation thats planned for our dismal future.
J SLOAN...SPOT ON, LET THE PEOPLE LEARN THE TRUTH.....
I agree but can’t we stop the destruction now 😮
So None of this Shit is Going On, Sacred Sites ? Funny That !
The largely useless and exorbitantly expensive rubbish will soon end in landfill and the hapless taxpayers will be left with bad debts that will take generations to pay off.
or rare birds.
I dont want an Apology Day. I want several years of 365 days of REVENGE.
The ALP wouldn't want the truth to come out now would they.
Albo hush money.
Make companies give a 100 year no questions asked guarantee on every aspect of the panels or wind turbines or million dollar fines per panel not repaired.
Almost time to get out of Australia it’s becoming a country of no chance of getting ahead and the leadership is the worst in history. Unless you’re a politician, refugee, criminal, businessman, OF account owner or a so called celebrity on radio or TV the rest of us are screwed.
You can can't drive very far in Western Victoria without seeing bird mincers aka wind turbines.
Should do an article about selling all our coal and gas overseas.
Indeed, our energy policy is ludicrous. Out government is misappropriating colossal amounts of taxpayers money and resources into uneconomical and unreliable renewable energy projects whilst simultaneously exporting our coal, gas and uranium to other countries which use them for cheap reliable electricity generation.
We need to withdraw from the Paris Agreement and use the most economical energy resources available.
I did a paid survey about renewable, it was in three parts. I got through two parts but spoke my mind in answering the questions and said that it will fail and that I hope I'm around when it all fails. They didn't like that and I received a message saying that I had completed they survey and didn't need to continue onto part three, they still paid me but I wasn't saying what they wanted to hear.
DROVE PAST SOME OF THOSE WINDMILLS WHAT AN EYESORE THEY ARE AN CONSIDERING HOW WINDY IT WAS THEY WERN'T DOING FUCK ALL
what the actual fck, bring on regulations for gag orders they just slapping them on things everyone should know ugh
It makes sense for CCP investors to put a gag order on Labor too. Listening to them talk in the house of representatives... They sure sound like they're under a gag order regarding renewable energy.
They skirt a question, praise renewables, self advertise, & repeat. There's almost no point in having question time because they consistently give the same response. Cheap AI would do a better job.
Do these sorry days really make any difference or are they just to make a few people feel better .
Judith is a keeper 💪🏻💪🏻💪🏻
How in hell does Labor party not know nuclear is excellerating in usage all over the rest of the world.
they know, they don't have personal investments in it like they do with the windmills and solar.
I'll be glad to see Australia go nuclear, then Tasmania can have some of it's Hydro power back for our own use, instead sending a lot of it across Bass Straight.. Tasmanian industry once had cheap Hydro power.. Now we have little industry and our power costs more, in order to pay for the Bass link cables?
The clean up of all the renewables
I want a sorry day for the disgusting treatment we got during Covid. The entire farce was ludicrous. They will need a sorry day for insisting on renewables at all (very great to the average person) costs. It is a recipe for disaster. But...we can all feel good while sitting with candles and blankets in Winter, that we will have a sorry day! Yay!
Nuclear is the obvious solution to our power needs well into the future, but what happened to Hot rock power generation ?
It proved to be uneconomical!
@@stevehewitt1151 I guess so, but not much more uneconomical than short lived wind farms & vast solar farms, Nuclear all the way I say !
@@chrisdickinson7949 I absolutely agree with you - I believe that geothermal does have some future part to play! On the other hand, I believe wind and solar are gigantic white elephants - remove the subsidies and watch it collapse!
I'm a whitie Australian, What day do i have to apologize for being alive?
Yes. It should also be a day of no confidence in our government 🤟😎💚🇦🇺
Sorry day for the white man for having common sense.
How about a 'Sorry Day' for the hundred thousand babies murdered in Abortion EVEY YEAR.
Oh tell it to the marines!! It's a woman's choice ,
@@RoyBennett-dz2cq Yes. It ain't the baby's choice, that's for sure.
Seeing that huge array of solar panels made me cry a little bit. Horrible.
1/2 of them are out of service and the rest are leaking oil or have damage blades and gears.
if I owned a property I would never allow them to put it on my land
The Government has taken the discussion out of where this destruction occurs. Green Energy has the authority to put wind and solar wherever without consultation.
I'd like to know exactly what tax payer funded subsidies are going where and exactly what the cost is and for exactly how long he's signed us all up to pay for this roart.
Sorry day for the Australia economy,
Labor needs a Sorry Day for being a failure.
I’m not even allowed to make a comment about what the damage is. Investor protection maybe?
protection racket
@@andyman8630in a word, yes.
@@andyman8630the single word reply just vanished.
The renewable energy projects only exist due to massive taxpayer funded subsidies. They are a malinvestment of taxpayers money and resources.
In Western Australia the farmers are paid $30 000 per year per wind mill for each one on their farm
Anyone saying anything about this and how will these things ever be profitable with all these ongoing yearly costs
The same thing happened in Germany. Wind has a low energy density and wind power is centuries out of date. The wind farms only exist due to massive taxpayer funded subsidies. They make no economic sense.
They are a colossal waste of taxpayers money and resources (including coal, oil and copper).
The useless renewable energy equipment will soon end up in landfill.
These fools in labor, haven't assessed the reflective heat from the solar panels back to the atmosphere. ❤😂🎉😊
yes the solar farms can create there own weather systems.
Why the fukc should the panels be anywhere that there is green grass. Those obviously are areas of high rainfall and thats detrimental for sun shine.
We got huge areas of low rainfall and most constant sunshine of any areas
Indeed. In Northern Europe vast numbers of solar panels are frequently covered in snow in winter. There is widespread inappropriate uneconomical use of solar panels in many parts of the world. Taxpayers money should not be squandered on this.
@@johngeier8692 right good point. I wonder when it was that some clever money men worked out this scam and started putting it in motion
I always was lead to believe that the Greens were about the environment SO WHAT HAPPENED???????.
CLICK BAIT,
Discuss the subject, stop running your mouth about everything except the subject!
communism.
Farmers have access to Ammonia Nitrate and diesel fuel, so the problem is the farmers unwillingness to use their resources in the proper manner.
Why?????
Albo stuff the people, gag the non woke people. Sorry Albo just blames the opposition
Circus Aus.
There is huge amounts of copper in these remote solar farms and wind turbines, that’s a lot of money just sitting around lol……… just saying…….
All ways to manufacture electricity have its downside. Top of the list is Hydro. The most destructive method used to produce electricity.
What's there to be sorry about. You do not own vista. Owned land is being compensated.
An official sorry from government in this respect would require either an absolute conservative majority (in which case there’s indeed very dark days ahead before we reach that), or the political left would be required to display a level of contrition we could only dream of. 🤔
Go Green, go lean.
Go Woke, go broke.
Labour under Labor.
Wind turbines subsidies are $7.5 million each for thousands of them.
Fuck the sorry days, and the welcome to wherever recognising the elders past and present. Enough if the woke bullshit is enough. If we gonna say sorry for everything our corporate government does in our name, it will be every other day is sorry day.
An apology is meaningless. All people who made millions promoting this short term fix should pay for cleaning up the mess they created.
Native birds and bats love those turbines so much they gather by the thousands at their base to celebrate the final joy of knowing we are saving the planet. Mitch, Australia.
Our Politicians have always been 20 years behind the 8 ball.
Wasn’t there clean coal technology for power production ?
Australia is sometimes very backward in regard to getting things done. Nuclear is the cheapest and cleanest form of energy, and the spent rods if they have energy left in them they can be recycled.
where are the aboriginals kicking up a storm about destrution of their so called lands
I don't won't a Sorry Day, I want to see prison sentences for crimes against the environment.
Duck mistaking them for ponds and crash landing
Welcome to Australian communistic party
Follow the money,just watch who gets jobs in this sector when they get voted out.
This is new china / communist labour/ greens
How long does it take for a wind turbine to pay for itself just on the footprint of land, it is on?
Some think they look horrible, some sexy.
Does a Turbine even "offset" itself ffs?
If farmers agree to turbines or solar panels on their land, they are more a vandal than an inner-city luvvie who at least doesn't have a clue about what is happening on the land.
They are paid large amounts of taxpayers money as “rent “ to keep them quiet.