Mariah has been a great singer in the 90s but now she lost a lot of her vocal abilities and she just doesn't sound always great. She just hasn't been able to maintain the same vocal control through her 30s and 40s. On the other hand Celine has just gotten better and better over time
It’s not about who can sing the loudest. It’s the technical aspect too. Both have strengths and weaknesses in different areas but outshine each other in unique ways
Apparently, most of the time you're really honest to give your unreasonable criticism, nitpicking, prejudice and subjective dislikes on Celine's vocal and singing.
I love this comment cause you're RIGHT!!!! She's just a Mariah fan and now Im surprised she took time to play Celine videos cause she always negative about it. She's a vocal coach but her perspective is most likely from what she's fan of from the reality!! She always dislike Celine cause Mariah can't even have Celine's rich voice
Jean Cortes Actor it's annoying because she did it with Demi Lovato too. She had a video of Demi vs Ariana and I love both of the girls, but some of the things she was saying was completely unfair. The Demi videos were bad quality, but this girl said that the person who made it was biased towards Demi. Vocal coach reactions shouldn't be based on not liking a singer, it should be based on their technique
Mariah doesn’t oversing. When she uses her runs, she does to compliment the style of the song. And it’s pleasant. Celine doesn’t have half the amount of musicality that Mariah has plus Mariah sounds better overall.
Mariah has the gift of musicality. She uses runs as embellishments, to fill in gaps, to keep the listener's attention, wow factor ect. Her doing runs in every song is not oversinging. Celine belt's every single song but I don't see you saying anything about that? Celine's belts are her wow factor and Mariah's whistles runs and riffs are her wow factors. I wouldn't say either overusing. They're just highlighting their strengths.
I literally don't know what she's saying! No idea! Well, she was speaking French so. Celine doesn't show off every time. I Can't Help Falling In Love With You isn't her song. She didn't want to do Elvis. Elvis has already done it. Celine's version is in its own realm: one of the best vocal runs ever.
I like most of your reactions but this reaction was extremely biased. Celine is one of the best singers to ever grace and you didnt seem to give her that respect. You have a weird dislike for runs and growling which is fine but it shouldnt effect your reaction of the quality of her singing.
@@AlmedaRen how dare you to say that...yes Celine is not good like the two cause Celine is up them, your so delsusional,,,where's your whitney?,,,Did Mariah can slay?,,,no....only Celine is the remaining star out of the Trinity
Honest technical analysis: Insane resonance and natural reverberation. Amazing control of her dynamics. Perfect control of her vibrato's speed. Perfect transition between her registers. Incredible power. Her diction is really great (and she's not even a native English speaker - Ariana, if you hear me...). Slight rasp sometimes on her belts which adds a more dramatic / out of this world effect. Even though she wasn't particularly mean on the technical aspect (how can she, as a vocal coach and knows damn well Celine has a crazy technique with a very unique sound), her lack of enthusiasm is quite telling
Can't help falling in love was not over riffed. You would need to watch the full performance to see that. She has just integrated her style to it. This video you watched is about vocals that 'had me shook' . you are supposed to be analyzing the vocals. You have not watched the whole performance of it so you cannot judge it the way you just did. Im just so confused. Nevertheless nice video . What do you mean you don't know why she's ' holding all the notes'? These aren't full performance clips. Its supposed to be a few seconds of vocals that are amazing. Of course she is either going to sustain notes with amazing resonance or she is going to riff something. What were you expecting? Same goes for that Phelps video you mentioned. Of course he would hold notes. Thats literally the title of the video? resonant high notes... ufffff
Albert Samuel no that’s just an expression. ‘She can SING!!’ Like she has something special in other words. Obviously they were not saying she couldn’t sing before they were just saying ‘she’s the real deal’. ❤️
I think the fact that you look 100% bored out your mind whenever you react to Celine Dion speaks volumes about your opinion of her. She's obviously not one of your favorite singers/performers, just put your Lady Gaga reaction next to any Celine reaction and you'll see what I mean. How you're not in complete awe of what this woman can do vocally is bizarre.
also dont like when you said her accent "improved" thats pretty insensitive. Her accent didnt improve because its less strong. Strong accents are beautiful, you have one!!! So please less bias. Thanks
@@HonestVocalCoach please dont feel like im attacking you. I really enjoy your videos. Its nothing personal just ways to further improve your reactions. Thanks for so many great videos. Thanks!
If your accent comes through whenever speaking another language to the point where it is difficult to understand for a local speaker..that is not "beautiful" but just poor command. Celine's English early on was dreadful and I have no doubt she'd be the first to say so. To say it has improved is a compliment and no doubt Celine would be gratified to hear it. There are many who start out where Celine started and never improve.
@@reddragonready shut up! Diversity is a good thing. Having an accent is common for non native english speaker. I would like to hear you speaking chinese with fluent accent
I realize these reviews are subjective. As you often say it’s your personal choice. However when it comes to technique I have to question your credibility. And by the way, I’m absolutely sure that the songs and words that you could not understand were in French. Or are you bilingual? If so my apologies.
Omfg when Celine Dion sung i can't help falling in love with you ...it is her accent!!! The way she sings i don't think she was over singing the emotion in it beautiful
@@ondyandraandra5346 i mean she say "i don´t like her melissmas bue her technique is very well" so?? she is givin us a rewiew like public not like a vocal coach!
ondy andra andra: the objective one, not the same subjective "preferences". she calls herself a coach so should act like one, not acting like she's an audience who are more subjective.
the cant help falling in love one is like one of her greatest performances...imo. You probably need to watch the whole thing to appreciate that bit at the end. But its amazing that run. I think the person that put that vid together tho thinks that holding a note = being shook haha.
I’m actually questioning you ability as a coach. Where do you look at chest and head voice which are where she pulls her “power from and that endless air control” Tell me where those are? Celines french-Quebec and her accent will always be present...just like your accent it’s....tryna isn’t a word though I know you are saying “trying too”. And nippy picking on je sais pas which means I don’t know....sits well in this review from you ;-)
@@schneevongestern9898coz Georgina said that on the last clips...Celine's pulled it back and it's not.....She is laughing at Celines moves and have an insulting face coz she really jealous that Celine hits that highest note that never exist in the history...coz her Mariah Can't do that............Celine mixed her head and chest voice and that's why she makes a high notes like it was out of this world
and at first when she said at least she now have better accent in other language that she sing, she said that while she was singing in french. She don't have an accent in french, that's how she speak. -_- To not know that Celine is a french canadian when you talk about how she speak her own language... lol!
What really pisses me off is that she is acting like it's a random good performance - nothing too special while Celine is belting notes that nobody else Is able to hit on this planet. And she is acting like it's just a normal singer with a good voice.
..... Celine is over riffed but Mariah is not??? R U SERIOUS???? I bet u listen to Mariah "best song" The Holy Night, is that over riffed for u indeed? Ha?
11:24 When Celine “didn’t quite hit the note” but still had me shook... saving then sustaining a mixed A5 at age 49 like the living legend that she is!
CELINE IS QUEEN SHES BEST SINGER IN THE WORLD BEEN VOTED THIS ASWELL.. ADELE IS THE BRITISH VERSION OF CELINE HOW CAN CELINE BE JUDGED ON BAD VOCALS EVERY SONG SHE SINGS IS PERFECT
Me Luis I know that. She doesn’t like her. And i think a vocal coach should know that if the sound quality is bad. She should not react on that since it will be automatically a bad reaction. Mostly Céline’s video in the 90’s looks like it was taken from a VHS that’s why the quality looks bad of course the sound will be the same like it’s a mono. That’s why I want her to react “The Resonance of Celine Dion Part 2” since it has better performances and better sound quality
Me Luis what i’ve noticed about her is that she likes a wide stereo sounds like clear like mimi’s clips. A fancam would be great since it has wider sounds and arena reverb. She loves that.
You’re more subjective than objective ......................for my liking , oversinging isn’t a bad thing it depends of your emotions of the moment ......
robert monthe yeah the “I can’t help falling in love with you” with the gritty G5 and runs, it’s like essential to the song like so raw and emotional, I hate when people pretend that subjective and negative opinions are them just being “honest” like labelling yourself as the honest vocal coach and being so subjective and personal preference based, isn’t ‘honesty’, it’s opinionated
The riffinf in falling in love with you didnt work for you maybe but it worked for the rest of the world! Your comments sometimes makes me question your authenticity as a vocal coach and also sometimes come off as jelous or envious cause you cant hit the samenotes or are as technical as the singers you are reviewing! IT seems you only give good feedback on singers or styles that you like and can do for yourself! If the style is out of your repertoire or singing range or genre than you automatically dislike it! The run celine did in falling in love is worldwide extremely famous and known and then you go and say you didnt like itè You are all alone in this satement! And bytw you need to learn to keep your own personal feelings to yourself as vocal coach! People come to ypou for proff advice and technique not singing tastes!!!!!! You should be giving as objective as possible adivce and feedback! You seem to dsilikeanything that is pwoerful, belted, high or whistle or long notes or passionate growling! You only like lower or mid range songs!
The runs is technically great. But I don't like it on that song. That's what Georgina said too and I agree with her. She's not alone on this one because you can just look at the comments (troll comments aside) on the original video - many do think she was doing too much; technically proficient, but isn't needed for that song.
She doesn’t do too much on that song at all. She only really let’s it rip at the end of the song. The way she sang it was just perfect. That said, some people are just more conservative than others when it comes to vocals. Don’t worry most people I’ve seen in the comments other videos love what she did. In fact this is the first time I’ve heard anyone say they didn’t like it. So you guys are clearly in the minority.
I'm sorry, but HONEST vocal coach, please sing at least one song of these performances. I want to hear this. The opinion is absolutely not objective. The song "I cant help falling in love" was performed incredibly, powerfully! The high notes are fantastic! Long notes are insane! Celine Dion is one of the best singers in the world and your reaction is more than strangely...
And I hope you understand that music is universal, instead of pausing and making faces when she sings in French, u should appreciate different languages and emotions
Georgina, I really like your videos but I would find it beneficial if you struck everything in terms of vocal analysis. I feel (for a vocal coach and as making videos analyzing vocals) that you're being too subjective and only giving singers who's style you prefer a 'passing grade'. This was very apparent while I was watching a video where you reacted to Sohyang and couldn't acknowledge her technique. I just think you should prioritize objectivity over personal preference. You can still give your opinion but we want to hear what your opinion is on the technique.
I’ve seen that before too. This is personal preference and not applied to vocal ability. She did the same in her “review” of the trinity - she personally loved mariahs over singing and unsupported belts....but the supported belts from Whitney and Celine were not amongst her personal likings.... Well - it’s her channel and she can do what she wants. I’m not viewing it again
Poor reaction..we know that you don't like Celine Because Mariah is your favorite And in your latest reaction in the vocal battle of Celine,Mariah,and Whitney You picked Mariah because we know she is your favorite Goodbye!!!
Terrible in so many ways. Your reaction and the clips were out of sync. You are reacting to "Vocals that had me shook" and talking about over singing and showing off too much? Really? Half of the clips you watched were in French. What accent improvement are you talking about? You didn't understand "Je sais pas"? I don't even speak French but that was crystal clear. You completely missed a lot of technically savage moments. Why? What's the point of the reaction then? To show your expressionless face? Edit: OMG! I just listened to your version of "This is me". Even though you ditched all the high parts you were still pitchy and anything that went out of your speaking range caused problems for you. And that was a prerecorded track you thought was good to record a video to! Unbelievable!
@@HonestVocalCoach Honesty? Your vowel modification is bad, your mouth shape and placement is poor. You don't know how to access your head voice. If I had to guess what's going on in your mouth, your soft palette isn't lifted, your tongue is placed back in your throat. That's because you keep spreading instead of dropping your jaw to produce artificial brightness like you encourage others to do in your "smile" video, and like I've seen multiple videos of your students do. This results in dulled flat tones, even if you are close to the pitch. It removes access to your natural resonators and over amplifies higher frequency tones at the cost of mid and low frequencies. This removes a lot of the natural depth and projection power from notes. You tend to wobble your jaw when you use vibrato, but I've never seen you use vibrato above your first bridge. This is likely because you have a poor mix. You need to work on your head voice. You need to work on your breath support(you tend to push from the throat to get more sound, but that dulls the tone and removes a lot of freedom-so no vibrato-and control of your voice), because you have limited vocal dynamics. Pick exercises that strengthen your diaphragm and that strengthen your head voice, and then work on mixing head and chest dynamically in your mid range(F4-F5 most likely). That should clear your tone, give you *natural* brightness and lightness, give you much more dynamic control, and deepen your resonance. Start with vowel/mouth shape (Ah, Eh, Ee, Oh, Oo) practice on a scale like they teach for basics, and go from there. Best of Luck.
The problem with this video react of yours, Madam, is not about wether you like her or not as a performer. The problem with it is the offensive and judgemental funny faces you make when you think She is oversinging. Aren't you supposed to react to her singing ability as a performer not judging her based on what you find disgusting or not? Imagine if I sent you my singing video and you make those faces, I'd never sing again my whole life believing I'm a terrible singer. I believe you should call yourself 'Judgemental Coach' So unsubscribing.
i don't know anything about music, nor that much, but you disliked Celine for when she over sang, which is riffing (as for looking at the comments) and then like 1 minute later you said that "you don't know why she held the note for so long". Idk that seems hypocritical, if i'm wrong then someone in the comments please correct me lol.
Guys she's biased. She definitely prefers Mariah to Celine, it's obvious from other videos. And apparently she doesn't speak French, that's why she didn't understand Celine's singing in the third clip.
Dear " honest" vocal coach, i just wanted to tell you, that it's obvious that you don't like Celine, who is clearly and obviously one of the greatest if not the BEST voices in the history of music, but i just don't think that you have the right and the knowledge of criticizing such an artist . So please, just stay DOWN at your own level and don't mess with the big names in this industry !!!!
Thank you for attempting a reaction video and listening to my suggestion, much appreciated!! I was a bit confused though... you know she is originally from Quebec (which speaks french) right? That is why you couldn't understand it so don't assume it's 'wrong english'. To pretty much all of your subscribers, she is still a true singer that we love regardless of your poor judgement.
Her accent is what makes her stand out and what we've known her for. The video title is "vocals that had me shook" not the "subtle intrinsic profoundly understated and subdued emotional lick that had me sob and gasp for air".... Its all about vocal show-off... Having said that I do agree that there are far better examples. But to say that she didn't really land on the note in a crazy crescendo performing live in her fifties after 35 years of active career is a bit of a nit picking don't you think? It's ok, she obviously is not your cup of tea, I get it. Really...it is not my intention to sound belittling or derogatory in any way but your recordings really don't sound all that vocally stern... I mean its all rather pitch accurate and dynamically cohesive, but still, rather vanilla... Simply ok. But nothing more. I advise that you lead by example and have your performances vocally criticized by a peer vocal coach? How about that? I think it's a wonderful idea. If you are interested I have a couple of very good and objective coaches to suggest. Keep up there! Best, Nihad.
Did she not say several times that these are definitely not Celine's best vocal clips? Her stating that shows an obvious defense and respect for Celine as an artist and vocalist. Subjectively she did just say if you're picking a song to show off on, pick a song that is made for vocal gymnastics and go all the way with it. If you're going to do a woeful ballad, do a woeful ballad. Don't half ass it. Sorry, but if I'm going to show off my vocals I'm not going to pick " The itsy bitsy spider " , pick something that fits.
@@iTeacupPanda Yes, you're defending the coach now. I disagree in that these are merely the climaxes of songs that otherwise simply build up to them... Its not as if the entire songs are revamped and desecrated only to serve the purpose of demonstrating vocal abilities... You can surely dislike the tonal quality and even musicality to an extent of an artistic preference... But such an underwhelming review of someone who can surely sing rather superbly and who nurtured their craft and an instrument is somehow meh... I wonder how come that her reviews of Mariah's performances, even the recent ones, are so favorable even when it's painfully obvious that thee voice is gone... I'm just saying that it doesn't seem professional to sound that much biased. Am I subjective? Sure... But then, I do not call myself a vocal coach who claims to be doing professional unbiased reviews of vocal performances... Or maybe it's just that her bar is set quite high for Celine as opposed to the other artists... :) Nah.... Not buying it :)
I swear, I get so angry when I watch your videos because their is being honest and then there is being rude. Celine dion is a vocal goddess and everyone knows that, all other vocal coaches on TH-cam said nice things about this video but you were just negative. It's not about personal opinion, it's about technique and Celine dion well and truly has it.
I think you should also know that the low quality sound has a huge effect to the voice we’re hearing on this video. Like it sounded so mono. By watching you react. I think you like the wider sound like in “Je Sais Pas 2008” part where it was shot by a fancam the sounds were more open/wide which we can hear more resonance because of the arena reverb effect. A vocal coach should react to the sound quality if it's bad don't react to that performance (vocal coaches should know that) because.... Bad sound quality = bad reaction
I think that what people fail to notice is that singers don't only sing, but they also PERFORM, they tell a story. It's a wonderful blessing to have strong vocals and be able to hold a long note, but all that must be used to serve the storytelling, to deliver an emotion, not only have it done cause you can...
I think one of my comments was deleted so I will post it again.. I actually do like your reactions.. you're not afraid to call something out when you find it not on par. But I do feel you let your tastes sometimes decide what is good instead of focusing on what they are doing right. I never heard you mention Celine's agility, power, pitch-perfect way to hold and sustain notes without a wobble.. Maybe you don't like that but other people do so you can always give your view but also bring the technical side of what she is doing right... I can't help falling in love that's up to taste... I understand what you're saying as it is a very sweet song... But for the version, she made a bluesier rock version the runs etc where great... But I understand your point.. just keep reacting.
Hmm...so Celine is "showing off" when she does certain techniques and skill but Mariah Carey doesn't? They are both great singers with great technique and obviously great skill and God given gifts, so how is that "showing off"? Everyone knows that Celine puts a TON of emotion and heart into her songs and isn't the "show off" type of artist. Wow I can now see why all the comments in here are hating on this video. Maybe should just stick to Mariah Carey vids and not Celine because you obviously think she's "showing off."
people come to you to hear your professional singing tech, not your music taste dahling, so I think you better not say that comments in falling in love with you, As I know, a lot of people like it.
@@reddragonready I agree with the OP, this isn't supposed to be an opinion type video it's a technique video by a vocal coach. She should base her findings on that and not her tastes in music or really her opinion because all that is subjective.
The videos you couldn’t understand, is because Celine was singing French... her first language. Whenever she sings English, her French accent has never really shown that much, although I’d say her accent is more evident 2015-present more than ever when she sings her English songs. But especially in the 90s, most people couldn’t tell she’s French.
I always felt Celine was whitney's true equal .They could sing each others songs only difference is the diction.Whitney was American so she could pronounce the hell of the lyrics but those two had the most powerful prettiest clear voices.Their vocal clarity is unreal.
Celine is legendary. I'm not a fan, but I can appreciate and acknowlegde her work. She sounds amazing I wonder if you can give an honest opinion on Brandy's (live) vocals. She used to be mentored by Whitney and she's one of the most influental R&B singers. She might not be relevant anymore, but she definitely left an impact in the '90s and early '00s. And I really think she grew vocally a lot from 14 years until now 38 years. She's also called the vocal bible among her fans and peers.
Watched her for the first time when she reviewed and scored the "Vocal Trinity", Celine, Mariah and Whitney. Although all 3 of these ladies are my fav all time singers i was surprised at tue scoring of some of the notes. Some notes where Celine lost out to Mariah and Whitney and vice-a -versa. I found it odd as on some of those notes i would have either given it to Celine but it went to one of the other 2. Now watching THIS review, i am convinced that her findings are subjective and she just does not like Celine's singing style, compared to maybe Whitney or Mariah. But its okay. Celine is not sweating it! Still selling out sold out shows accross the world....
I'm not necessarily in love with Celine, but this reaction was (maybe) a bit biased... The singer slew everything and you can't find any major flaw or fault in any of these performances, c'mon. I was quite surprised to see that this reaction video took such a turn :(
if you don't understand french, how will you know what she's saying? btw, the song she is singing is called "I don't know" at 3:53 in french. which is quite fitting to you i would say.
“ It’s about the feel”, I hope you remember the video title is 10 Times Celine’s Vocal had me SHOOK, so the uploader picks her incredible vocal showoff moments. And, u didn’t comment on anything about resonance.... Yes, I see honest reaction but nothing about music knowledge
This was a really questionable reaction video. You found Celine's amazing moments as over singing, however, you enjoy even more riffs, runs, melisma when it comes to your favorites, such as Mariah to name one. Don't get me wrong. I am a huge of Mariah but there is no question that you cannot be objective about Celine's vocal ability or for that matter any vocalist. Celine is one the best vocalists on the planet. PS: I don't like Jessie J's style or voice. But I can't deny that she is a very good singer. That is being objective.
You cant judge a full song by only listening to the peak of the song. Celine is the Goddess of Ballades because she puts meaning and effort in all her songs and most of her songs has got low mellow starts and high ends . Also, pick one vocalist who can pull off what Celine does and then compare. The only thing I can fault Celine on is the fact that she makes it all look easy, try singing her songs holding all notes properly and changing between head voice and chest voice when she does, then judge. BTW your face when Celine belted out the note in "where does my heart beat now" is priceless.
Thank you for this reaction! For more emotional and touching Celine performances I can recommend: Calling you (Live a Paris 1995), Water from the Moon Live/En public, and The Colour Of My Love (Live The Colour of My Love concert) 💕. Other performances from Colour of My Love and Live a Paris concerts also excellent! I’ll be happy with any Celine reactions though 😄
Celine dion is the MOST SUCCESFUL TOURING ARTIST OF ALL TIME.. 1.5 BILLION grossed from ticket sales. How much money did you make from your talent COACH????
I just realized that during the performance of ‘Imagine’ you gave a nod of approval ‘Now that’s better’ you said. In one of your previous reaction videos that same clip was shown and you definitively claimed that autotune ( I think that was the phrase you used ).
Thank U Vocal Coach 4 that vid :) Celine Dion is incredibly talented, but what is the most important and what today's young people who take part in talent shows could learn is humility and such a life wisdom. Celine shows that the talent will defend itself. Hi from Portsmouth
Dont mean to be rude I mean its your opinion, but i feel like tbis women just doesnt really vibe with celine dion or appreciates her vocals the way we do we like the extra stuff she does it give u more soul more feels, shes a goddess at singing right along with Whitney Houston! I honestly think singing shouldn't be judged its here fot entertainment that's all and its a beautiful thing. Celine will go down as one of the hardest most talented female singers in HISTORY.
To all the celine fans if you go back and watch her previous videos she never really seems to enjoy celine dions performances. She definitely always prefers Mariah. I personally love celine dion and believe she’s the best singer because I love clarity and power... I have never really enjoyed Mariah’s voice because she has no clarity. I can never hear her lyrics clearly and she’s always just humming along to the song..
That is the worse reaction you didn’t even give Celine a chance you had a premeditated judgment what would make your day is if people sent you just Mariah or Beyoncé I can’t believe this you have a premeditated sound and stuff and if they don’t hit it then you are Offended
I've read some comments and I like how people are so passionate about an artist. I mean get so upset about what someone thinks, likes or dislikes about the artist they're passionate about. People talk about nitpicking, isn't that what differs the pro's to the amateurs. So to find faults in Celines voice or technique by nitpicking, I only see that as a compliment to her. To me a reaction video is always subjective no matter what. BTW the video was entertaining to me!
Je Sais Pas..this was her Taking Chances tour in 2008. I saw her in Winnipeg and she was so, so sick that she passed out when she got offstage. But you could not hear it in her voice when she was singing. She did absolutely amazing. She hit every note..she's a consummate professional. I clicked on this video because I honestly wanted to see if you could actually critique her. She's trained through the wazoo and has perfect pitch!
Another thing is that on ALL of the french and some english songs, she has a slightly closed mouth because ALL FRENCH PEOPLE DON'T OVER EXAGGERATE mouth movement and facial expressions like the English
I agree with you when you say it's not the best choice if clips. As a massive Celine Dion fan, I've seen that there are definitely better performances, at least in my opinion.
I'm a big Celine Dion fan and I didn't find anything bad about this reaction. You are always honest and I appreciate it Georgina. (I only have to say that the clip you didn't understand is because it's in French) but great reaction.
@@alejandroromanoff6183 "Honey"..her credentials are a lot more solid than most socalled vocal coaches AND they can be checked. These are reaction videos..that means she reacts how she reacts. They are not educational videos.
That '91 clip she was definitely showing she could do runs like another hot new singer that was out at the time, that is an icon, Mariah Carey. By '94 Celine had come into her own brand beautifully. She is amazing.
You went on about the vocal gymnastics...meanwhile you love Mariah? Please. Celine’s resonance, power, and control are incredible. You just lost credibility.
You obviously don’t like Celine, and you lose credibility by unjustly criticizing her so much. Well, Celine, her fans and her over 200 million albums sold ..don’t care what you think of her
8:55 good thing that's your opinion and not an actual fact. You may disagree with this, but there is no "correct" way to interpret a song. Singing is a natural function. People do it how they do it. It's not a math problem with 1 unique solution, or a set number of solutions. If people like a singer's interpretation of song, they like it. If people don't, then they don't. Evidently you don't like this interpretation, and that's OK, but don't critique her interpretation as if your opinion is so correct. Céline is successful regardless of what The Honest Vocal Coach on TH-cam thinks.
You know what ?? First of all, you should have noticed the YEAR that the performances have been recorded : some are from her early years as a singer....Of course she was not as "good" as now !! Also, you talk and talk and again ! about her accent ! She, and I, could say the same about you!! You say that she sings better in French than in English : OF COURSE !! she's a FRENCH CANADIAN !!! born in the Province of Quebec, which is 90% French speaking !! At LEAST...SHE can sing in ENGLISH as well as in FRENCH :: YOU can't even (understand !) say a word in French !! All these "clips" are parts of SHOWS (not albums !) ....and to you, a SHOW sould be as "clean" and "plain" as a "Studio recording session" !!! Have YOU ever performed in front of an audience of more than 100 people? If so, did people ENJOYED and STAYED 'TILL THE END ?? You talk as if you were the BEST singer (vocal coach !?!) ......however, I never heard about you.... GET DOWN TO EARTH "MRS. CALLAS" 😒
Elle parlait de l'accent qui s'était amélioré avec les années dans une chanson en français -_- C'est pas un accent, c'est comme ça qu'elle parle lol. J'étais comme : Wtf are you saying? lol. Frenchement. Je ne suis pas vraiment une fan de Céline, mais ce vidéo n'est pas non plus l'opinion d'un coach vocal.
![ALLY - OH MY! [ REACTION ] 'Amarin Nitibhon' #ALLY_OHMY #ALLY #allynitibhon #แอลลี่](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/nX9qpHjVfbQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I dont think Mariah can outsing Celine if live and thats a fact! She has the range maybe but Celine definitely has the pipes period.
When I was young, my mother used to tell me Celine had 4 lungs, which I honestly believed for 2 years
Mariah has been a great singer in the 90s but now she lost a lot of her vocal abilities and she just doesn't sound always great. She just hasn't been able to maintain the same vocal control through her 30s and 40s. On the other hand Celine has just gotten better and better over time
And by the way I'm not saying that Mariah can't sing anymore, she's just gotten worst after 1998
It’s not about who can sing the loudest. It’s the technical aspect too. Both have strengths and weaknesses in different areas but outshine each other in unique ways
divas live showed us a lot that mariah was just a studio-kid lol
Apparently, most of the time you're really honest to give your unreasonable criticism, nitpicking, prejudice and subjective dislikes on Celine's vocal and singing.
Henry Choong thank you Celine is a extraordinarily singer she is just a huge Mariah fan
To be fair for someone’s of Celine level any form of criticism is considered nitpicking, but they might not be invalid
I also noticed how honest she is 😂😂
I love this comment cause you're RIGHT!!!! She's just a Mariah fan and now Im surprised she took time to play Celine videos cause she always negative about it.
She's a vocal coach but her perspective is most likely from what she's fan of from the reality!! She always dislike Celine cause Mariah can't even have Celine's rich voice
Jean Cortes Actor it's annoying because she did it with Demi Lovato too. She had a video of Demi vs Ariana and I love both of the girls, but some of the things she was saying was completely unfair. The Demi videos were bad quality, but this girl said that the person who made it was biased towards Demi. Vocal coach reactions shouldn't be based on not liking a singer, it should be based on their technique
It’s honestly kind of weird that you find her over singing yet you clearly just adore Mariah who is constantly doing runs in every. single. song.
Thank you or tori kelly, jessie j, etc. If this is over singing then they beyond oversing
Mariah doesn’t oversing. When she uses her runs, she does to compliment the style of the song. And it’s pleasant. Celine doesn’t have half the amount of musicality that Mariah has plus Mariah sounds better overall.
@simplegateaux I am strongly AGREE 💯💕
Idk I found both of them good to listen. So far for me their "oversinging" are good on the musics
Mariah has the gift of musicality. She uses runs as embellishments, to fill in gaps, to keep the listener's attention, wow factor ect. Her doing runs in every song is not oversinging. Celine belt's every single song but I don't see you saying anything about that? Celine's belts are her wow factor and Mariah's whistles runs and riffs are her wow factors. I wouldn't say either overusing. They're just highlighting their strengths.
I literally don't know what she's saying! No idea! Well, she was speaking French so. Celine doesn't show off every time. I Can't Help Falling In Love With You isn't her song. She didn't want to do Elvis. Elvis has already done it. Celine's version is in its own realm: one of the best vocal runs ever.
exactly
I like most of your reactions but this reaction was extremely biased. Celine is one of the best singers to ever grace and you didnt seem to give her that respect. You have a weird dislike for runs and growling which is fine but it shouldnt effect your reaction of the quality of her singing.
Exactly. And Celine is the one to have been able to preserve her voice for the longest time in the vocal trinity.
@@mcmohitchauhan21 Celine also wasn’t as good as Mariah or Whitney. Lol
@@AlmedaRen how dare you to say that...yes Celine is not good like the two cause Celine is up them, your so delsusional,,,where's your whitney?,,,Did Mariah can slay?,,,no....only Celine is the remaining star out of the Trinity
@@AlmedaRen Celine was way better than Whitney, she has always had more range and a better technique.
She doesn’t like growls/distortions cos long term they can hurt the singers
Honest technical analysis: Insane resonance and natural reverberation. Amazing control of her dynamics. Perfect control of her vibrato's speed. Perfect transition between her registers. Incredible power. Her diction is really great (and she's not even a native English speaker - Ariana, if you hear me...). Slight rasp sometimes on her belts which adds a more dramatic / out of this world effect. Even though she wasn't particularly mean on the technical aspect (how can she, as a vocal coach and knows damn well Celine has a crazy technique with a very unique sound), her lack of enthusiasm is quite telling
The lack of enthusiasm is very interesting, wonder what’s driving that?
She is the only person I've seen that doesn't like the can't help falling in love clip🤦🏻♂️
Adonis Macris it’s obvious she doesn’t like Celine ,I hate that faces when can’t help falling in love start
~Well, then she is the first. She has a different taste, we all have.
😘
Me too
Can't help falling in love was not over riffed. You would need to watch the full performance to see that. She has just integrated her style to it. This video you watched is about vocals that 'had me shook' . you are supposed to be analyzing the vocals. You have not watched the whole performance of it so you cannot judge it the way you just did. Im just so confused. Nevertheless nice video .
What do you mean you don't know why she's ' holding all the notes'? These aren't full performance clips. Its supposed to be a few seconds of vocals that are amazing. Of course she is either going to sustain notes with amazing resonance or she is going to riff something. What were you expecting? Same goes for that Phelps video you mentioned. Of course he would hold notes. Thats literally the title of the video? resonant high notes... ufffff
This woman is very ignorant. That’s why I never subscribed to her, and hardly visit unless she’s doing someone I’m very interested in.
Saw one with the Trinity’s
Over signing was a thing for her with Mariah and that was praised.
@@dennispedersen7460 I strongly agree
Shes incredible how can she be Critisized shes the best singer in the world period
Exactly. She chose video about vocals.and didn't wanted to see the vocal lol
Damn, this title should've been... "Vocal Coach envies Celine Dion's vocals for 13 Minutes!"
Pure salt and green envie
Hallelujah! I'm glad someone said it in this comments section. Green-eyed monster syndrome!
I really like Celine Dion. Have been to a few concerts and she can sing!
She can sing? So you think she can't sing before? Sh is a legendary singer... The best singer in the world
Albert Samuel no that’s just an expression. ‘She can SING!!’ Like she has something special in other words. Obviously they were not saying she couldn’t sing before they were just saying ‘she’s the real deal’. ❤️
No she can't sing SHE CAN SANG SHE IS LEGENDARY VOCALIST AND ONE OF THE BEST VOICES IN THE WORLD....
I think the fact that you look 100% bored out your mind whenever you react to Celine Dion speaks volumes about your opinion of her. She's obviously not one of your favorite singers/performers, just put your Lady Gaga reaction next to any Celine reaction and you'll see what I mean. How you're not in complete awe of what this woman can do vocally is bizarre.
ikr but she loves mariah
Totally agree, curious about what drives that?
@RowenMyBoat Envy maybe?
the 3rd song is french.. so its normal that you cannot know what she is saying..
It's probably something about Surrendering.
@@iTeacupPanda Nope
Maxine Caulfield Je sais pas is I don't know, so it's I don't know if I can handle it.
I think she cut the moment
Some clips are cut
also dont like when you said her accent "improved" thats pretty insensitive. Her accent didnt improve because its less strong. Strong accents are beautiful, you have one!!! So please less bias. Thanks
@@HonestVocalCoach please dont feel like im attacking you. I really enjoy your videos. Its nothing personal just ways to further improve your reactions. Thanks for so many great videos. Thanks!
Actually british english isn't an accent... american english is an accent.
If your accent comes through whenever speaking another language to the point where it is difficult to understand for a local speaker..that is not "beautiful" but just poor command. Celine's English early on was dreadful and I have no doubt she'd be the first to say so. To say it has improved is a compliment and no doubt Celine would be gratified to hear it. There are many who start out where Celine started and never improve.
Gabriella Svensson it’s an accent to other countries so be quiet
@@reddragonready shut up! Diversity is a good thing. Having an accent is common for non native english speaker. I would like to hear you speaking chinese with fluent accent
I realize these reviews are subjective. As you often say it’s your personal choice. However when it comes to technique I have to question your credibility. And by the way, I’m absolutely sure that the songs and words that you could not understand were in French. Or are you bilingual? If so my apologies.
I’ve never heard her say anything useful about anyone’s technique. I guess that’s why she fills up the time with her subjective opinions.
It's the most annoying thing ever
I love that you're reacting to Celine Dion, she's my favorite out of the Trinity!
Omfg when Celine Dion sung i can't help falling in love with you ...it is her accent!!! The way she sings i don't think she was over singing
the emotion in it beautiful
all is about your music preference not a vocal technique... really?
Alejandro Romanoff i definitely agree!
What kind technique u wanna hear?
@@ondyandraandra5346 i mean she say "i don´t like her melissmas bue her technique is very well" so?? she is givin us a rewiew like public not like a vocal coach!
ondy andra andra: the objective one, not the same subjective "preferences". she calls herself a coach so should act like one, not acting like she's an audience who are more subjective.
I absolutely agree. She absolutely doesn't honor Celines outstanding talent. But that was the case already in few other videos.
the cant help falling in love one is like one of her greatest performances...imo. You probably need to watch the whole thing to appreciate that bit at the end. But its amazing that run. I think the person that put that vid together tho thinks that holding a note = being shook haha.
I’m actually questioning you ability as a coach.
Where do you look at chest and head voice which are where she pulls her “power from and that endless air control”
Tell me where those are?
Celines french-Quebec and her accent will always be present...just like your accent it’s....tryna isn’t a word though I know you are saying “trying too”. And nippy picking on je sais pas which means I don’t know....sits well in this review from you ;-)
@@HonestVocalCoach bitch
@@tedypermana9552 wtf is wrong with you? Georgina is so sweet and you just offend her.
@@schneevongestern9898coz Georgina said that on the last clips...Celine's pulled it back and it's not.....She is laughing at Celines moves and have an insulting face coz she really jealous that Celine hits that highest note that never exist in the history...coz her Mariah Can't do that............Celine mixed her head and chest voice and that's why she makes a high notes like it was out of this world
Yeah this woman is terrible...watch the other coach...she's great. Tara Simon Studios
best coment she is so negative about celine. why not of course her mariah can not do like celine i'm pretty sure this is the reason.
3:57 You can't understand the words she singing.Do you speak French actually??
kepala gundul well seeing as she said she doesn’t understand the words, I think it’s safe to assume she doesn’t speak French
and at first when she said at least she now have better accent in other language that she sing, she said that while she was singing in french. She don't have an accent in french, that's how she speak. -_- To not know that Celine is a french canadian when you talk about how she speak her own language... lol!
What really pisses me off is that she is acting like it's a random good performance - nothing too special while Celine is belting notes that nobody else Is able to hit on this planet. And she is acting like it's just a normal singer with a good voice.
If you have a biased opinion about someone, positive or negative, you shouldn't be giving a 'Honest Vocal Coach' review
hahahaha the one you didn’t understand was actually french!!!
La Filouterie thanks for clearing that one up.
Right. It literally says the song name is "Je sais pas", unless she didn't see the name when she was making the video.
..... Celine is over riffed but Mariah is not??? R U SERIOUS???? I bet u listen to Mariah "best song" The Holy Night, is that over riffed for u indeed? Ha?
Lol you were already wrong when you think that The Holy Night is Mariah’s ‘best song’
Hugo Boss didn’t u see me using the quotation mark here?? :)
She is jealous. That’s all.
Celine can STILL blow the roof of Mariah.
“ it’s cute though”. Hahaha😂
11:24 When Celine “didn’t quite hit the note” but still had me shook... saving then sustaining a mixed A5 at age 49 like the living legend that she is!
It was even flat haha
@@speedycomet1692 She's the only one who can do that note...who is your idol then tell him to do that...
It’s like she took great pleasure in pointing that out. Interesting.
@@RowenMyBoatThe gleeful nature was palpable. Maybe some envy?
What a good vocalist she is. The way she's holding her notes.
i died laughing when I heard this
CELINE IS QUEEN SHES BEST SINGER IN THE WORLD BEEN VOTED THIS ASWELL.. ADELE IS THE BRITISH VERSION OF CELINE HOW CAN CELINE BE JUDGED ON BAD VOCALS EVERY SONG SHE SINGS IS PERFECT
I think you should react to “The Resonance of Celine Dion Part 2” for better performances
Me Luis I know that. She doesn’t like her. And i think a vocal coach should know that if the sound quality is bad. She should not react on that since it will be automatically a bad reaction. Mostly Céline’s video in the 90’s looks like it was taken from a VHS that’s why the quality looks bad of course the sound will be the same like it’s a mono.
That’s why I want her to react “The Resonance of Celine Dion Part 2” since it has better performances and better sound quality
Me Luis what i’ve noticed about her is that she likes a wide stereo sounds like clear like mimi’s clips. A fancam would be great since it has wider sounds and arena reverb. She loves that.
You’re more subjective than objective ......................for my liking , oversinging isn’t a bad thing it depends of your emotions of the moment ......
robert monthe yeah the “I can’t help falling in love with you” with the gritty G5 and runs, it’s like essential to the song like so raw and emotional, I hate when people pretend that subjective and negative opinions are them just being “honest” like labelling yourself as the honest vocal coach and being so subjective and personal preference based, isn’t ‘honesty’, it’s opinionated
Yay! My favourite singer!!!! Even though I hold her responsible for damaging my voice as years of trying to mimic her was not possible for me!
"Honest vocal coach"
Unless it's a Céline video... Hahaha
The riffinf in falling in love with you didnt work for you maybe but it worked for the rest of the world! Your comments sometimes makes me question your authenticity as a vocal coach and also sometimes come off as jelous or envious cause you cant hit the samenotes or are as technical as the singers you are reviewing! IT seems you only give good feedback on singers or styles that you like and can do for yourself! If the style is out of your repertoire or singing range or genre than you automatically dislike it! The run celine did in falling in love is worldwide extremely famous and known and then you go and say you didnt like itè You are all alone in this satement! And bytw you need to learn to keep your own personal feelings to yourself as vocal coach! People come to ypou for proff advice and technique not singing tastes!!!!!! You should be giving as objective as possible adivce and feedback! You seem to dsilikeanything that is pwoerful, belted, high or whistle or long notes or passionate growling! You only like lower or mid range songs!
Richard That is so true, I have noticed that too👍
I didn't like the runs on "I can't help falling in love with you" too.
The runs is technically great. But I don't like it on that song. That's what Georgina said too and I agree with her. She's not alone on this one because you can just look at the comments (troll comments aside) on the original video - many do think she was doing too much; technically proficient, but isn't needed for that song.
The runs is like she is singing a national anthem. Not suitable. But I like her vocal
She doesn’t do too much on that song at all. She only really let’s it rip at the end of the song. The way she sang it was just perfect. That said, some people are just more conservative than others when it comes to vocals. Don’t worry most people I’ve seen in the comments other videos love what she did. In fact this is the first time I’ve heard anyone say they didn’t like it. So you guys are clearly in the minority.
I'm sorry, but HONEST vocal coach, please sing at least one song of these performances. I want to hear this. The opinion is absolutely not objective. The song "I cant help falling in love" was performed incredibly, powerfully! The high notes are fantastic! Long notes are insane! Celine Dion is one of the best singers in the world and your reaction is more than strangely...
And I hope you understand that music is universal, instead of pausing and making faces when she sings in French, u should appreciate different languages and emotions
Georgina, I really like your videos but I would find it beneficial if you struck everything in terms of vocal analysis. I feel (for a vocal coach and as making videos analyzing vocals) that you're being too subjective and only giving singers who's style you prefer a 'passing grade'. This was very apparent while I was watching a video where you reacted to Sohyang and couldn't acknowledge her technique. I just think you should prioritize objectivity over personal preference. You can still give your opinion but we want to hear what your opinion is on the technique.
I totally agree with you
I’ve seen that before too. This is personal preference and not applied to vocal ability. She did the same in her “review” of the trinity - she personally loved mariahs over singing and unsupported belts....but the supported belts from Whitney and Celine were not amongst her personal likings....
Well - it’s her channel and she can do what she wants. I’m not viewing it again
Poor reaction..we know that you don't like Celine Because Mariah is your favorite And in your latest reaction in the vocal battle of Celine,Mariah,and Whitney You picked Mariah because we know she is your favorite
Goodbye!!!
Mariah is better than Celine, bye
Like idk why you people don’t understand that
no celine is better than mariah bye😒😒😒
@@AlmedaRen Celine is better than Mariah byebye poor sheep
@@AlmedaRen Celine is better
When Celine sings
"Baaaaaaaaby no no no no" is Bloody Brilliant
Terrible in so many ways. Your reaction and the clips were out of sync. You are reacting to "Vocals that had me shook" and talking about over singing and showing off too much? Really?
Half of the clips you watched were in French. What accent improvement are you talking about? You didn't understand "Je sais pas"? I don't even speak French but that was crystal clear.
You completely missed a lot of technically savage moments. Why? What's the point of the reaction then? To show your expressionless face?
Edit: OMG! I just listened to your version of "This is me". Even though you ditched all the high parts you were still pitchy and anything that went out of your speaking range caused problems for you. And that was a prerecorded track you thought was good to record a video to! Unbelievable!
@@HonestVocalCoach I don't have any advice for you. You lack knowledge, skill and understanding of the things you try to talk about.
@@HonestVocalCoach Honesty? Your vowel modification is bad, your mouth shape and placement is poor. You don't know how to access your head voice. If I had to guess what's going on in your mouth, your soft palette isn't lifted, your tongue is placed back in your throat.
That's because you keep spreading instead of dropping your jaw to produce artificial brightness like you encourage others to do in your "smile" video, and like I've seen multiple videos of your students do.
This results in dulled flat tones, even if you are close to the pitch. It removes access to your natural resonators and over amplifies higher frequency tones at the cost of mid and low frequencies. This removes a lot of the natural depth and projection power from notes.
You tend to wobble your jaw when you use vibrato, but I've never seen you use vibrato above your first bridge. This is likely because you have a poor mix. You need to work on your head voice. You need to work on your breath support(you tend to push from the throat to get more sound, but that dulls the tone and removes a lot of freedom-so no vibrato-and control of your voice), because you have limited vocal dynamics.
Pick exercises that strengthen your diaphragm and that strengthen your head voice, and then work on mixing head and chest dynamically in your mid range(F4-F5 most likely). That should clear your tone, give you *natural* brightness and lightness, give you much more dynamic control, and deepen your resonance.
Start with vowel/mouth shape (Ah, Eh, Ee, Oh, Oo) practice on a scale like they teach for basics, and go from there.
Best of Luck.
are you speak french? you reaction is subjetive not objetive dahling!
Alejandro Romanoff thank you she seems like she just doesn’t care
@@djjames2324 and i don´t care your comment dahling!
lmao funniest dialogue ever
Alejandro Romanoff he's agreeing with you lol. You need to learn a bit more English since you can't even tell when someone is agreeing with you.
You criticise the vocal couch about her opinions and yet you can't spell. It's "darling" "do you speak French?"
The problem with this video react of yours, Madam, is not about wether you like her or not as a performer.
The problem with it is the offensive and judgemental funny faces you make when you think She is oversinging.
Aren't you supposed to react to her singing ability as a performer not judging her based on what you find disgusting or not?
Imagine if I sent you my singing video and you make those faces, I'd never sing again my whole life believing I'm a terrible singer.
I believe you should call yourself 'Judgemental Coach'
So unsubscribing.
i don't know anything about music, nor that much, but you disliked Celine for when she over sang, which is riffing (as for looking at the comments) and then like 1 minute later you said that "you don't know why she held the note for so long". Idk that seems hypocritical, if i'm wrong then someone in the comments please correct me lol.
Guys she's biased. She definitely prefers Mariah to Celine, it's obvious from other videos.
And apparently she doesn't speak French, that's why she didn't understand Celine's singing in the third clip.
Dear " honest" vocal coach, i just wanted to tell you, that it's obvious that you don't like Celine, who is clearly and obviously one of the greatest if not the BEST voices in the history of music, but i just don't think that you have the right and the knowledge of criticizing such an artist . So please, just stay DOWN at your own level and don't mess with the big names in this industry !!!!
Thank you for attempting a reaction video and listening to my suggestion, much appreciated!! I was a bit confused though... you know she is originally from Quebec (which speaks french) right? That is why you couldn't understand it so don't assume it's 'wrong english'. To pretty much all of your subscribers, she is still a true singer that we love regardless of your poor judgement.
Her accent is what makes her stand out and what we've known her for. The video title is "vocals that had me shook" not the "subtle intrinsic profoundly understated and subdued emotional lick that had me sob and gasp for air".... Its all about vocal show-off... Having said that I do agree that there are far better examples. But to say that she didn't really land on the note in a crazy crescendo performing live in her fifties after 35 years of active career is a bit of a nit picking don't you think? It's ok, she obviously is not your cup of tea, I get it. Really...it is not my intention to sound belittling or derogatory in any way but your recordings really don't sound all that vocally stern... I mean its all rather pitch accurate and dynamically cohesive, but still, rather vanilla... Simply ok. But nothing more. I advise that you lead by example and have your performances vocally criticized by a peer vocal coach? How about that? I think it's a wonderful idea. If you are interested I have a couple of very good and objective coaches to suggest. Keep up there! Best, Nihad.
Did she not say several times that these are definitely not Celine's best vocal clips? Her stating that shows an obvious defense and respect for Celine as an artist and vocalist. Subjectively she did just say if you're picking a song to show off on, pick a song that is made for vocal gymnastics and go all the way with it. If you're going to do a woeful ballad, do a woeful ballad. Don't half ass it.
Sorry, but if I'm going to show off my vocals I'm not going to pick " The itsy bitsy spider " , pick something that fits.
@@iTeacupPanda Yes, you're defending the coach now. I disagree in that these are merely the climaxes of songs that otherwise simply build up to them... Its not as if the entire songs are revamped and desecrated only to serve the purpose of demonstrating vocal abilities... You can surely dislike the tonal quality and even musicality to an extent of an artistic preference... But such an underwhelming review of someone who can surely sing rather superbly and who nurtured their craft and an instrument is somehow meh... I wonder how come that her reviews of Mariah's performances, even the recent ones, are so favorable even when it's painfully obvious that thee voice is gone... I'm just saying that it doesn't seem professional to sound that much biased. Am I subjective? Sure... But then, I do not call myself a vocal coach who claims to be doing professional unbiased reviews of vocal performances... Or maybe it's just that her bar is set quite high for Celine as opposed to the other artists... :) Nah.... Not buying it :)
@@iTeacupPanda Most of the clips are def some of her most impressive belts and runs though.
I swear, I get so angry when I watch your videos because their is being honest and then there is being rude. Celine dion is a vocal goddess and everyone knows that, all other vocal coaches on TH-cam said nice things about this video but you were just negative. It's not about personal opinion, it's about technique and Celine dion well and truly has it.
Celine is on a totally different planet when it comes to vocals and doesn’t need approval or critique from anyone so this video is pointless
I think you should also know that the low quality sound has a huge effect to the voice we’re hearing on this video. Like it sounded so mono. By watching you react. I think you like the wider sound like in “Je Sais Pas 2008” part where it was shot by a fancam the sounds were more open/wide which we can hear more resonance because of the arena reverb effect.
A vocal coach should react to the sound quality if it's bad don't react to that performance (vocal coaches should know that) because....
Bad sound quality = bad reaction
I think that what people fail to notice is that singers don't only sing, but they also PERFORM, they tell a story.
It's a wonderful blessing to have strong vocals and be able to hold a long note, but all that must be used to serve the storytelling, to deliver an emotion, not only have it done cause you can...
I think one of my comments was deleted so I will post it again.. I actually do like your reactions.. you're not afraid to call something out when you find it not on par. But I do feel you let your tastes sometimes decide what is good instead of focusing on what they are doing right. I never heard you mention Celine's agility, power, pitch-perfect way to hold and sustain notes without a wobble.. Maybe you don't like that but other people do so you can always give your view but also bring the technical side of what she is doing right... I can't help falling in love that's up to taste... I understand what you're saying as it is a very sweet song... But for the version, she made a bluesier rock version the runs etc where great... But I understand your point.. just keep reacting.
Hmm...so Celine is "showing off" when she does certain techniques and skill but Mariah Carey doesn't? They are both great singers with great technique and obviously great skill and God given gifts, so how is that "showing off"? Everyone knows that Celine puts a TON of emotion and heart into her songs and isn't the "show off" type of artist. Wow I can now see why all the comments in here are hating on this video. Maybe should just stick to Mariah Carey vids and not Celine because you obviously think she's "showing off."
It went out of sync the video and your reaction LMFAOOOOO
Yes this vocal coach is weird
people come to you to hear your professional singing tech, not your music taste dahling, so I think you better not say that comments in falling in love with you, As I know, a lot of people like it.
Well "people" need to get a parrot instead, if they just come to get confirmation of their views and opinions.
@@reddragonready I agree with the OP, this isn't supposed to be an opinion type video it's a technique video by a vocal coach. She should base her findings on that and not her tastes in music or really her opinion because all that is subjective.
The videos you couldn’t understand, is because Celine was singing French... her first language. Whenever she sings English, her French accent has never really shown that much, although I’d say her accent is more evident 2015-present more than ever when she sings her English songs. But especially in the 90s, most people couldn’t tell she’s French.
She's not French^^
I always felt Celine was whitney's true equal .They could sing each others songs only difference is the diction.Whitney was American so she could pronounce the hell of the lyrics but those two had the most powerful prettiest clear voices.Their vocal clarity is unreal.
Celine is legendary.
I'm not a fan, but I can appreciate and acknowlegde her work. She sounds amazing
I wonder if you can give an honest opinion on Brandy's (live) vocals. She used to be mentored by Whitney and she's one of the most influental R&B singers. She might not be relevant anymore, but she definitely left an impact in the '90s and early '00s. And I really think she grew vocally a lot from 14 years until now 38 years. She's also called the vocal bible among her fans and peers.
Watched her for the first time when she reviewed and scored the "Vocal Trinity", Celine, Mariah and Whitney. Although all 3 of these ladies are my fav all time singers i was surprised at tue scoring of some of the notes.
Some notes where Celine lost out to Mariah and Whitney and vice-a -versa. I found it odd as on some of those notes i would have either given it to Celine but it went to one of the other 2.
Now watching THIS review, i am convinced that her findings are subjective and she just does not like Celine's singing style, compared to maybe Whitney or Mariah.
But its okay. Celine is not sweating it! Still selling out sold out shows accross the world....
exactly
I think this woman is a francophobe..
Many Brits can be that way
I saw that video. A couple of moments where she didn't wait to hear Céline before deciding.
I love celine dion!😍
I'm not necessarily in love with Celine, but this reaction was (maybe) a bit biased... The singer slew everything and you can't find any major flaw or fault in any of these performances, c'mon. I was quite surprised to see that this reaction video took such a turn :(
if you don't understand french, how will you know what she's saying? btw, the song she is singing is called "I don't know" at 3:53 in french. which is quite fitting to you i would say.
“ It’s about the feel”, I hope you remember the video title is 10 Times Celine’s Vocal had me SHOOK, so the uploader picks her incredible vocal showoff moments. And, u didn’t comment on anything about resonance....
Yes, I see honest reaction but nothing about music knowledge
This was a really questionable reaction video. You found Celine's amazing moments as over singing, however, you enjoy even more riffs, runs, melisma when it comes to your favorites, such as Mariah to name one. Don't get me wrong. I am a huge of Mariah but there is no question that you cannot be objective about Celine's vocal ability or for that matter any vocalist. Celine is one the best vocalists on the planet.
PS: I don't like Jessie J's style or voice. But I can't deny that she is a very good singer. That is being objective.
big THUMBS DOWN for the reaction of this so-called "VOCAL COACH"#yawn
You cant judge a full song by only listening to the peak of the song. Celine is the Goddess of Ballades because she puts meaning and effort in all her songs and most of her songs has got low mellow starts and high ends . Also, pick one vocalist who can pull off what Celine does and then compare. The only thing I can fault Celine on is the fact that she makes it all look easy, try singing her songs holding all notes properly and changing between head voice and chest voice when she does, then judge.
BTW your face when Celine belted out the note in "where does my heart beat now" is priceless.
Thank you for this reaction! For more emotional and touching Celine performances I can recommend: Calling you (Live a Paris 1995), Water from the Moon Live/En public, and The Colour Of My Love (Live The Colour of My Love concert) 💕. Other performances from Colour of My Love and Live a Paris concerts also excellent! I’ll be happy with any Celine reactions though 😄
Celine dion is the MOST SUCCESFUL TOURING ARTIST OF ALL TIME..
1.5 BILLION grossed from ticket sales. How much money did you make from your talent COACH????
I just realized that during the performance of ‘Imagine’ you gave a nod of approval
‘Now that’s better’ you said.
In one of your previous reaction videos that same clip was shown and you definitively claimed that autotune
( I think that was the phrase you used ).
Mike Alward she mentioned that that note was probably pitched-corrected.
@@Suijiro99 as if live pitch correction was even prevalent in the early 90s. I don’t even know if it was possible at that point, much less prevalent.
It’s all about being bright and open... lol
singing isnt only about one way of singing
Don't disrespect the queen.PERIODT.
You are an honest lamb
Thank U Vocal Coach 4 that vid :) Celine Dion is incredibly talented, but what is the most important and what today's young people who take part in talent shows could learn is humility and such a life wisdom. Celine shows that the talent will defend itself. Hi from Portsmouth
Céline Dion Is a LIVING LEGEND and ICON of World Music in History of all Times!!! So UNBELIEVABLE!!!....
Celine isn’t showing off! She’s giving the audience what they paid for! Celine is just being Celine.
Dont mean to be rude I mean its your opinion, but i feel like tbis women just doesnt really vibe with celine dion or appreciates her vocals the way we do we like the extra stuff she does it give u more soul more feels, shes a goddess at singing right along with Whitney Houston! I honestly think singing shouldn't be judged its here fot entertainment that's all and its a beautiful thing. Celine will go down as one of the hardest most talented female singers in HISTORY.
I didn't get what accent you are talking about in the beginning, Quebec?
Celine had a very strong french accent early on in her career. She sang in English but hardly spoke it at the time.
I wouldnt say celine 'over does' anything. She can just do far more than most artist..give her credit where it due, the woman is phenomenal
Celine Dion is a legend. She is th best singer in the world
To all the celine fans if you go back and watch her previous videos she never really seems to enjoy celine dions performances. She definitely always prefers Mariah.
I personally love celine dion and believe she’s the best singer because I love clarity and power... I have never really enjoyed Mariah’s voice because she has no clarity. I can never hear her lyrics clearly and she’s always just humming along to the song..
That is the worse reaction you didn’t even give Celine a chance you had a premeditated judgment what would make your day is if people sent you just Mariah or Beyoncé I can’t believe this you have a premeditated sound and stuff and if they don’t hit it then you are Offended
But a vocal coach is to do technical opinion or personal preferences? The Celine's voice and technical are great, fact.
André yes I am agree with you ;she only do personal opinion ;I think she don’t Celine
I've read some comments and I like how people are so passionate about an artist. I mean get so upset about what someone thinks, likes or dislikes about the artist they're passionate about.
People talk about nitpicking, isn't that what differs the pro's to the amateurs. So to find faults in Celines voice or technique by nitpicking, I only see that as a compliment to her.
To me a reaction video is always subjective no matter what.
BTW the video was entertaining to me!
You better don't reacting on Celine's performances anymore, you're so rude, it makes me don't believe about your JOB as vocal coach
Je Sais Pas..this was her Taking Chances tour in 2008. I saw her in Winnipeg and she was so, so sick that she passed out when she got offstage. But you could not hear it in her voice when she was singing. She did absolutely amazing. She hit every note..she's a consummate professional. I clicked on this video because I honestly wanted to see if you could actually critique her. She's trained through the wazoo and has perfect pitch!
OMG I just re watched this and at 9:49 you went 'ooooh hear that high note at the end? Effortless!' when all celine did was scream 'YES'
Another thing is that on ALL of the french and some english songs, she has a slightly closed mouth because ALL FRENCH PEOPLE DON'T OVER EXAGGERATE mouth movement and facial expressions like the English
not the best clips???? wtf these are amazing and one of the best i've seen from her
She has far better and most of them are very recent. Her billboard performance of " My Heart Will Go On " is gorgeous.
@@iTeacupPanda that was lip synched.
I believe my ingorance about music allows me to enjoy more of it than you do.
I agree with you when you say it's not the best choice if clips. As a massive Celine Dion fan, I've seen that there are definitely better performances, at least in my opinion.
I'm a big Celine Dion fan and I didn't find anything bad about this reaction. You are always honest and I appreciate it Georgina. (I only have to say that the clip you didn't understand is because it's in French) but great reaction.
Honey she is a "vocal coach" and she react like one? Hell no! She react like a public.
@@alejandroromanoff6183 "Honey"..her credentials are a lot more solid than most socalled vocal coaches AND they can be checked. These are reaction videos..that means she reacts how she reacts. They are not educational videos.
That '91 clip she was definitely showing she could do runs like another hot new singer that was out at the time, that is an icon, Mariah Carey.
By '94 Celine had come into her own brand beautifully.
She is amazing.
I personally liked how she over sung 'I can't help falling in love with you' :P
You went on about the vocal gymnastics...meanwhile you love Mariah? Please. Celine’s resonance, power, and control are incredible. You just lost credibility.
Your ears need to be checked.. she did well? 😂 I guess that's why front row tickets to her 2020 concert ( Tampa, FL) are over $4000
Celines voice is life🥇🙌🙌
😘
Now Whitney was my fav of the vocal trinity. But YOU HAVE TO ADMIT CELINE KEPT HET VOICE IN TACT. You ma’am are very biased
Céline : blowing everything away
Coach: hehe cute lip thing she did
anybody who tries to critic celine dion looks crazy
You obviously don’t like Celine, and you lose credibility by unjustly criticizing her so much. Well, Celine, her fans and her over 200 million albums sold ..don’t care what you think of her
8:55 good thing that's your opinion and not an actual fact. You may disagree with this, but there is no "correct" way to interpret a song. Singing is a natural function. People do it how they do it. It's not a math problem with 1 unique solution, or a set number of solutions. If people like a singer's interpretation of song, they like it. If people don't, then they don't. Evidently you don't like this interpretation, and that's OK, but don't critique her interpretation as if your opinion is so correct. Céline is successful regardless of what The Honest Vocal Coach on TH-cam thinks.
You know what ??
First of all, you should have noticed the YEAR that the performances have been recorded : some are from her early years as a singer....Of course she was not as "good" as now !!
Also, you talk and talk and again ! about her accent ! She, and I, could say the same about you!!
You say that she sings better in French than in English : OF COURSE !!
she's a FRENCH CANADIAN !!! born in the Province of Quebec, which is 90% French speaking !!
At LEAST...SHE can sing in ENGLISH as well as in FRENCH :: YOU can't even (understand !) say a word in French !!
All these "clips" are parts of SHOWS (not albums !) ....and to you, a SHOW sould be as "clean" and "plain" as a "Studio recording session" !!!
Have YOU ever performed in front of an audience of more than 100 people? If so, did people ENJOYED and STAYED 'TILL THE END ??
You talk as if you were the BEST singer (vocal coach !?!) ......however, I never heard about you....
GET DOWN TO EARTH "MRS. CALLAS" 😒
Elle parlait de l'accent qui s'était amélioré avec les années dans une chanson en français -_-
C'est pas un accent, c'est comme ça qu'elle parle lol. J'étais comme : Wtf are you saying? lol. Frenchement. Je ne suis pas vraiment une fan de Céline, mais ce vidéo n'est pas non plus l'opinion d'un coach vocal.
React to part two and 15 times Celine silenced her haters.