I agree... Unfortunately, the U S. is so full of weaklings, and h8ters of Israel... Even J's are so lefty they accuse Israel of "genocide"... Utter madness...
@@judymiller1490 no Israel needs to go back to Germany and take their land but the cowards won't do that but they should the Germans love Israel now their cousins would be glad to have them
This is Biden screwing things up. Hamas is meeting Trump's deadline but working with weak Biden because they know they will get the best deal for Hamas and Iran and Gaza through Biden. Trump is not President and cannot make any official deal until he is in office. This is all Biden and the usual fake news propaganda reporting against Trump.
Like VDH said, let's see if in fact this is what will take place. In Hegseths confirmation he flat out said that he wants all Hamas dead. Marco Rubio is the most knowledgeable person on the planet regarding world politics and Huckabee is well aware of the Israel dilemma. If this is not handled correctly president Trump will lose major support in America.
Amen!!! Thank You Caroline for having Mr. Hanson on. You both are national treasures!!! I'm stand for Isreal, IDF etc but especially the hostages and their families!!! Much Love from Salisbury, NC & Lower East Side NYC!! Shalom and Maranatha to Ya'll ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ 54:18
Abandoned by the world !! Are you nuts !! The world stood by and watched, while the US handed Israel 2000 pound bombs to drop on the children of Gaza! Europe and the US gave diplomatic cover to Isreal for 2 years! Israel murdered 250 000 Palestinians and destroyed EVERYTHING in Gaza and you say the world has abandoned Genocidal Israel!! The world abandoned the people of Gaza!! Shame on you scumbags!!
This has Biden's inept, bungling fingerprints all over it! Trump is not in office yet, and unfortunately, Biden is still President until Jan. 20th. He can screw up many things until then.
Not enough is being told about this ' DEAL '. BUT EVERY HOSTAGE & CORPSE SHOULD BE RELEASED OR. NO CONCESSIONS. CASE CLOSED!!!! ALL....OR... NOTHING!!!!
I share your perspective, Sandra. - Not enough is being released about this "deal", but I am pretty sure it is like you said: ALL OR NOTHING. We have a saying in Portugal "Deus escreve direito em linhas tortas". It means divine justice. I put my fate in a big win for Israel. Shalom, from Lisbon.
It’s really just a ceasefire. The Islamists will break it no doubt! I don’t care who rockers its the way it is! The one and only ceasefire was done about two months after Haas attacked Israel. It was Pres Biden who got 101 hostages released. People seem to gloss over that. It’s sickening to me! Biden at heart is much more loyal to Israel then Trump ever was or will be. You can trust him as far as you could throw him.
Israel must not just become a footnote to Trump's foreign policy record. The issues at stake are too important for that. It is the very survival of the Jewish people and the long term future of Israel. Those must be the priorities for both Israel, the Jewish people, and friends and allies. Trump will be gone in four years. The Jewish State must have a far longer view, indeed to the end of the world.
This deal was negotiated under biden admin & biden negotiators (I use this word loosely). We dont know yet what influence Trump negotiators had, if any. Trump said hostages are to be released by 20 Jan 2025. That is not the agreement in this deal. We will see. There are some of us Americans who want the best for Israel & have been disgusted with the treatment of Israel by present admin. Am Yisrael Chai.
@@zmarssojourner7435 I think you mistake us. For our time, a large portion of the American population will do what it can to make sure you survive, in your own land. There will come a day when that ends I think. But not today.
You are right, unfortunately Bibi is not a strong leader with a long-term vision. He's a weak leader with one priority: his political survival. Very sad that most Israelis are so stupid not to realise that in the last year.
Trump is being advised by anti Israel advisors. This is the most horrible impact on Israel, and the people are not very realistic. Most often it is better to sacrifice the blood of a few to save the many. Do not rely on trump as he has a huge ego bigger than the size of the earth. Trump do not apply his promises but more interested of financial deal to benefit him and his family. We must not forget that he lost a lot through the tears, trust and personal interest and reputation - my own opinion. STAND ALONE AND STRONG ISRAEL AND RESPECT PRIME MINISTER NETANYAHU AND THE IDF SOLDIERS WHO FOUGHT A LOT FOR YOUR COUNTRY. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽♥️♥️♥️
God IS and will always be in full control...NOTHING happens which HE doesn't allow...ultimately it's all about Scripture being fulfilled...DJT is an instrument, nothing more
You can stay out of this. My people getting out of the tunnels is more important than your feelings. Even if it means just one of them is coming back. We will take whom we can get. We did not start this mess. The hostages didn't start this mess.
You may want to learn to disagree in a respectful way. No need to vomit your frustrations and attack a well meaning empathetic stranger. Self regulation is an important life skill.@@zmarssojourner7435
@@zmarssojourner7435 Of course not, Israel did not start this mess...Gaza terrurests did. This deal is so bad bc it empowers these terreorists to do this again, even stronger. It allows them time & money to do it again! There was a peace agreement in effect when the invasion took place. How well did that work? This will result in more Israeli lives lost, more hostages taken, more IDF lives lost, as history with these people has proven. This is not a Trump deal it is an Obiden deal made by Obiden negotiators on Obiden's watch. DJT basically has no power to negotiate any deal UNTIL he is sworn in as pres, 20 Jan. NO I do not have to "stay Out" as you suggest. I too have suffered loss of loved ones in WWI, WWII & VN. The pain of ALL Israelis is palpable & I am so sorry. I cant help but wonder if you have the welfare of the land of Israel & Israeli citizens in mind. Are you even whom you seem to be? Am Yisrael Chai.
@@zmarssojourner7435your people will not be getting out! Most of the hostages are dead. Only 23 live hostages are to be released in part 1 of the deal. Will be amazed if the 23 are released as they will be released 3 or 4 per wk with plenty of time for hamas to change the terms. Last hostage deal ended without all the hostages to be released as hamas changed the terms in the middle insisting on releasing dead instead of live hostages. Those hostages not in the list for 1st part of 33 hostages will never get released as nothing can be trusted with hamas and terms arent decided for their release
There's no way Trump can compare this deal with Hamas in January 2025 with Ronald Reagan's deal with Iran in January 1981. Regan scared Iran, they capitulated, and the U.S. gave up nothing. In today's case, Israel is giving up way too much, and it will cost dearly. 1981 - Good. 2025 - Bad.
Seems like a South African early 90's scenario is being forced & playing out on Israel here !! Trumps first 2 - 3 weeks will tell if this treachery is his or Bidens as VD Hanson is saying .... either way Israel is the sacrificial lamb if you read how VD Hanson hesitates every now & then in this interveiw !!
It is Trump is all about himself you think America cares about us you’re insane I know there are Americans who do however there all Jewish and I don’t mean that in a bad way at all I respect my brothers and sisters across the globe however fighting in this war has gotten me no where not a single victory has even been allowed by the Americans and we could’ve won if our government wasn’t afraid to say no
Well, he said that hostages will be released by inauguration. Obviously there was a tremendous pressure on Israel to except the deal . Trump needed it. Perhaps he promised something in return, like turning blind eye if israel will attack Iran, or promising American help as well. Will see in the near future if there was another side of the coin. Let’s hope that Netanyahu government will survive this .
German Catholic here: I was shocked about this deal, but as VDH says: Let´s wait a week or so. I think or hope things will look much better for Israel. God bless.
German Catholic Church always makes me think of German Chocolate Cake. So I love you already 😂 We stand with you and with Israel and that’s why we fought so hard against all odds to get Trump reelected. Praise God. I think soon we give Israel a lot of room to run!
Dear Caroline I take my hat off, you are admirable and a true and wise Israelite ❤ keep it up ☝️ fight the good fight of Faith... one more time gorgeous journalist with all due respect 🎩I side with you 100 percent!at your service Manny 🥊
Trump should do what he thinks is best for America and Netanyahu should do what he thinks is best for Israel not how it is now where America is imposing on us what they want for us to accept and our spineless government accepts that no questions asked
Trump is the only reason why the deal was signed, why would he distance? He does not care about what his deal will lead to in 3 years, he only cares about his glory.
@@zmarssojourner7435 do you want us to stay out of it? I will spread that around that in Israeli in Israel wants us to stay out of it as the US will get our people back and you’re on your own.
My guess is they are releasing a bunch of lower risk prisoners to buy time until Trump is thoroughly in control of DC and by end of February Israel will have a lot more latitude to conduct their policy. I can’t wait. God help them!! 🙏🏽
Truly appreciated this episode of your show, Caroline. Love Victor. He is always so informative and truthful. No prisoners release without all the hostages - alive and deceased - returned to Israel. Please let a wrench be thrown in the middle of the ceasefire agreement. The agreement needs to be implemented with President Trump in office not anyone in the O’Biden administration having any part in the future of Israel dealings with Hamas. Israel must be in charge of its destiny.
Sinwar was himself released as part of the insane deal that Israel made for its soldier Gilad Shalit. These types of deals lead to catastrophe and more dead Jews.
What a treat to listen to two of my favorite commentators! I’m really horrified at this terrible deal. Truly hope there are things behind the scenes the make this not as bad.
Of course Israel has its divine fate. God-Jesus Christ personally and through the Prophets and Apostles tell us so all through the 66 Books of the Bible. Israel ultimately comes to belief in Jesus Christ and win in the end. But before that time, there’s still lots of distress and tribulation for Israel. 🇮🇱
I find the reporting of this deal to be suspect....my impression is that this is propaganda...I certainly hope this deal was not the plan offered and "insisted" on by Trump. This deal is NOT acceptable to me as a supporter of Israel and Trump. If it is true.....there MUST be other plans we do not yet know of.
@djtner6232 My thoughts exactly. This deal does not come close to what DJT insisted on. This deal could be an "all or nothing last ditch effort" by the failing Obiden admin. This deal is disgusting! We will see 20 Jan 2025. Am Yisrael Chai.
something is not right with this deal , Israel needs to be very careful and stay wide awake , you are dealing with americans and muslims what can go wrong ?????????
I commented in one of your prodcasts in the past that i hoped Trump wouldn't let Israel down 😟. I pray the safety of Israel and for the release of all the hostages.
Basically this is Israel's defeat and it means all those IDF soldiers were killed in vain since Hamas will stay in power and while the IDF leaves the hamas will be busy making it even more dangerous for the IDF to return or fight
Keep Gaza under the control of Israel. Keep southern Lebanon! Keep the Syrian border protection under Israeli control. Spoils of war is terrioritory! The hell with Oslo agreement.
@sgabig The biblical geographic limit is a lot bigger than what it is, because Israel has been making concessions like this terrorist release deals. So insane, since 1948.
Well believe it. Steve Whitkoff forced Netanyahu to accept the deal he previously didn’t accept. Funny that the ‘Hell in the Middle East ‘ threat included Israel right
They know full well. But do you really know what the deep state wants? We can’t look at their words only see what they do. Their actions are what they really want.
Don't say: "US"; rather say: "US Government", "US Public", "US Congress", etc. What you MEAN to say, however, is "Trump". He sees, he knows more than you think. And as much as I love Trump, he was wrong to force Bibi to accept this shitty deal.
Of course Israel has a choice. It can take and hold territory and refuse any agreement that doesn’t include the unconditional surrender of Hamas. Israel also must hold strategic positions like Rafah on the Egyptian border to prevent cash and weapons form coming into Gaza and allowing Hamas to rearm. As Netanyahu said, you cannot put out three quarters of a fire. It will just start up again in a few years and Israel will have lost all of its soldiers’ lives in vain. No concession to Hamas.
Thank you Ms Glick. This has been a brilliant conversation. In the fog of war it becomes difficult to see the difference between friend and foe. Israel must remember who the real enemy is. Shia or Sunni, the dogma of Islam remains the same. Other nations who act like the turtle will get stung by the scorpion. Whatever "it" promise NOT to do, " it" WILL do. They should remember the nature of the beast. ❤🇮🇱❤ May Hashem keep His hand of protection over His people and His land. May Adonai Elohim comfort those who mourn. Heal those wounded in body, soul, and spirit. Give strength to the brave warriors of Israel. Counsel the government under the leadership of Mr Netanyahu. Amen🙏 Hallelujah , the Lord God Almighty reigns. Jahweh is His Name. 🙌
Absolutely. Donald Trump, as much as he has been a friend to Jews and a friend to Israel, is a weak reed to rely on. Only the Almighty can be depended upon to be in our corner. Israelis have to rely on each other and on the Creator.
Caroline, I love you and Israel. I’m not Jewish, but I lived in Israel and went to graduate school there. I speak, read, and write Hebrew, and have taught it and Jewish history. However, most American Jews I deal with and highly assimilated. So much so that their Judaism looks more Presbyterian to me than Jewish. Consequently, they are liberal Democrats. Israel Is not the most important issue on their radar.
so true! ... I am an American (secular) Jew who is SUPER MAGA ... but hard as I tried ... my two JEWISH sisters having swallowed the democrat Koolaid for so long ... they still vote democrat as if this was the democrat party of JFK and LBJ
Heartbreaking, yet nonetheless entirely true. I personally, as a traditional Jew, coined the term "Plastic Jews" in reference to those confused souls, as their association to the collective is tethered solely by the thin thread of motherly technicality.
Yes, she knows this better than you, but thanks for the reinforcement. By the way, we Jews on the Right have a name for secular (and even a very few observant) Jews who vote for Democrats: "Yidiots". Additionally, we tell this joke since 2016: Q: What's the difference between Trump and a typical American Jew? A: Trump has Jewish grandchildren
Will the Palestinian prisoners released be deported into another country or released back into Gaza? Phase 2 states, "Security for Palestinian returnees". What does that mean?
How can a deal be announced before the final details are agreed. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said they will issue an official statement regarding the hostage deal "only after the completion of the final details of the agreement". According to Netanyahu the details are currently being worked on.
Be disappointed with Netanyahu he’s the idiot who allows himself to get forced into signing shitty deals stop pointing fingers at America the only thing we can do is start protesting American influence over our country trumps gonna do what’s best for him not what’s best for Israel or the American Israeli relationship
Trump doesn't show his hand before he takes action. He never gives the enemy his plans in advance. He did say release of all hostages before 1/20/25. We have a few days to see how this actually plays out.
President Trump forced Israel to sign a terrible deal! There is nothing to be happy or proud about! In 42 days, we will see if his guarantees that we can go back to fight Hamas are real. Praying for the people of Israel 🇮🇱 🙏♥️
We should pray for Caroline and Victor that God would give them an encumbered mind and share their knowledge with President Trump. Pray that God will guide them all! Amen and Amen
Any ceasefire at this juncture must have an indefinite permanent peace for Israel . This ceasefire does not guarantee any peace. It is sad , but what I see is a decession to support an egoist element to fulfill what was said in the election campaign. It is best to view this cease fire as temporary pause . Hamas will never relinquish its vendetta as long it is given a chance to live another day.
Releasing terrorists is also part of this deal? What are they thinking? Not good. I feel sorry for Israel. I'm very worried. 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇱🏴🏴 Praying for Israel.🙏🙏
It would not be surprising to learn that Trump and Bibi came to an understanding that once this deal is successfully completed in all phases (and that’s a big “if”), that there would be an all out effort to neuter Iran. If true, Hamas’s lifeline would be effectively cut off and Hamas as a viable entity would come to an end. Couple this with extending the Abraham Accords to Saudi Arabia, the dynamics in Gaza, among other places, would dramatically change. This is the broader context that the deal could only make sense. But all this is speculation; we really don’t know. And so we will have to wait and see.
I’m submitting a request to President Donald John Trump that he would consider both of you to sit among his most trusted advisors. I will also forward directly to his inbox this conversation. May God continue to richly bless you both.
I am very disappointed in the deal. This weakens Israel's security. Over 800 Israeli soldiers died for what? Hamas will start over, and Israel will be compromised. I understand the hostage families concern. This deal does not bode well for Israel. 😢😢😢
WIKI: "Steven Charles Witkoff is an American attorney, real estate investor and developer, philanthropist, and founder of the Witkoff Group. He practiced as a real estate attorney for the first few years of his career, then pivoted to become a real estate investor and developer."
Caroline, I can't believe that Trump would abandon Israel but I understand your anxiety. I think that one approach to creating lasting peace in the Middle East will be by way of business and I am sure parts of it will not look good at the first glance. The thing about strategy is that you can't reveal it ahead of time. I also think that US citizens will stand behind Israel.
This is small point, but as a Canadian I just have to say that Trump can take no credit for Trudeau's exit. We have been working hard for years, to oust the dictator.......remember the freedom Convoy? People have been unjustly imprisoned , we have been protesting continually, Pierre Poilievre has been traversing the country relentlessly, in short, Trump can crow all he wants about it, but it's as stupid as crowing that the disaster of a deal in Israel is 'epic' as he put it. I can't be more disappointed in Trump and I have been an ardent supporter for years. I am nauseated and sick at heart. God bless Israel.
Among the things I fail to understand include why Hamas is still being allowed to exist and why this compromised hostage-release deal is viewed as acceptable. What are the true roles of Qatar and Turkey? It's not just "the hostages" who are being held hostage ...
VDH is a Wise man, Trust the Lord, And Trust the Guy that recognized Jerusalem as the Eternal Capital of the Jewish Kingdom, and the Golan as part of Israel 🇮🇱 No one in over 3500 years has done that. God is not sleeping, and He does not slumber. Caroline, The Fear you have is the from the God of your enemies. Like my mother told me, “It’s your Goat, Don’t let them have it”. Take out what we all know to be the tool of the left, Fear. Praying for You, VDH and all the One and Always Jewish people.
I think we need to stop attributing to Trump-whom I certainly appreciate-military genius and judgment he simply does not have. Whether you’re a Christian or a Jew, he is not the Messiah, and we have to start interpreting his shortcomings as just that, not potentially genius feints.
If the Knesset gives the green light for this hostage deal, they are also green lighting the two-state solution. The only possible reason for allowing the survival of Hamas is so that they can form a Palestinian state along with the Palestinian Authority.
Israel absolutly needs to stay in Gaza.
I agree...
Unfortunately, the U S. is so full of weaklings, and h8ters of Israel...
Even J's are so lefty they accuse Israel of "genocide"...
Utter madness...
I agree...
No, Israel needs to not exist.
Trump is for Himself.
@@judymiller1490 no Israel needs to go back to Germany and take their land but the cowards won't do that but they should the Germans love Israel now their cousins would be glad to have them
Many Americans are very shocked and disappointed with this so-called Hostage Deal. Our ❤ and prayers are with you.
lmfao cry some more
Amen!
This is Biden screwing things up. Hamas is meeting Trump's deadline but working with weak Biden because they know they will get the best deal for Hamas and Iran and Gaza through Biden. Trump is not President and cannot make any official deal until he is in office. This is all Biden and the usual fake news propaganda reporting against Trump.
Thank you. Amen!!
@ Free Palestine!
I am furious with this deal
Furious with Trump
You wouldn't be if u were the one trapped in a Gaza tunnel
Stupidity
Like VDH said, let's see if in fact this is what will take place. In Hegseths confirmation he flat out said that he wants all Hamas dead. Marco Rubio is the most knowledgeable person on the planet regarding world politics and Huckabee is well aware of the Israel dilemma. If this is not handled correctly president Trump will lose major support in America.
@@levarcheatham9586I see this point
My heart goes out to you ISRAEL. It looks like you are abandoned by the world.BUT GOD is surely with you for such a time as this.❤❤❤❤
Amen!!! Thank You Caroline for having Mr. Hanson on. You both are national treasures!!! I'm stand for Isreal, IDF etc but especially the hostages and their families!!! Much Love from Salisbury, NC & Lower East Side NYC!! Shalom and Maranatha to Ya'll ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ 54:18
If god lets israel fall, then we know god does not exist
I feel the same. We can depend on the dependability of the God of Israel. He will have the final say.
Abandoned by the world !! Are you nuts !! The world stood by and watched, while the US handed Israel 2000 pound bombs to drop on the children of Gaza! Europe and the US gave diplomatic cover to Isreal for 2 years! Israel murdered 250 000 Palestinians and destroyed EVERYTHING in Gaza and you say the world has abandoned Genocidal Israel!!
The world abandoned the people of Gaza!! Shame on you scumbags!!
Thank you ❤❤❤
That is the worst for Israel! I am very sad for Israel!🇺🇸🇺🇸
Lmfao stay sad
@Ffhjjkkkbdssrthb We can worry about both, Especially us Christians
@FfhjjkkkbdssrthbThat is worrying about America israel is the stabilizer in middle east.
This has Biden's inept, bungling fingerprints all over it! Trump is not in office yet, and unfortunately, Biden is still President until Jan. 20th. He can screw up many things until then.
@Ffhjjkkkbdssrthb Bible land IS my Land. Something you will never understand without Jesus/Yeshua.
Not enough is being told about this ' DEAL '. BUT EVERY HOSTAGE & CORPSE SHOULD BE RELEASED OR. NO CONCESSIONS. CASE CLOSED!!!! ALL....OR... NOTHING!!!!
I share your perspective, Sandra. - Not enough is being released about this "deal", but I am pretty sure it is like you said: ALL OR NOTHING.
We have a saying in Portugal "Deus escreve direito em linhas tortas". It means divine justice.
I put my fate in a big win for Israel.
Shalom, from Lisbon.
@@sandratankersley8470 Agreed!!
It’s really just a ceasefire. The Islamists will break it no doubt! I don’t care who rockers its the way it is! The one and only ceasefire was done about two months after Haas attacked Israel. It was Pres Biden who got 101 hostages released. People seem to gloss over that. It’s sickening to me! Biden at heart is much more loyal to Israel then Trump ever was or will be. You can trust him as far as you could throw him.
Great episode Carolyn, I’m a big VDH fan. As a Christian I’m always praying for Israel 🇮🇱 and the peace of Jerusalem.
🙏💖
I love VDH.
America First!
Stop giving American taxpayer money to Israel!
VDH fan as well...
Thanks for a voice of reason.
How is this a voice of reason? It is a lullaby to keep you calm, in my opinion
Israel must not just become a footnote to Trump's foreign policy record. The issues at stake are too important for that. It is the very survival of the Jewish people and the long term future of Israel. Those must be the priorities for both Israel, the Jewish people, and friends and allies. Trump will be gone in four years. The Jewish State must have a far longer view, indeed to the end of the world.
We Jews will survive, no matter what administration is in power. We ain't going nowhere; regardless of what u think or hope.
This deal was negotiated under biden admin & biden negotiators (I use this word loosely). We dont know yet what influence Trump negotiators had, if any. Trump said hostages are to be released by 20 Jan 2025. That is not the agreement in this deal. We will see. There are some of us Americans who want the best for Israel & have been disgusted with the treatment of Israel by present admin. Am Yisrael Chai.
@@zmarssojourner7435
I think you mistake us. For our time, a large portion of the American population will do what it can to make sure you survive, in your own land. There will come a day when that ends I think. But not today.
You are right, unfortunately Bibi is not a strong leader with a long-term vision. He's a weak leader with one priority: his political survival. Very sad that most Israelis are so stupid not to realise that in the last year.
Oh please there are Jews all over the world and will be with or without an Israel state
This ceasefire deal is poison.
Trump is being advised by anti Israel advisors. This is the most horrible impact on Israel, and the people are not very realistic. Most often it is better to sacrifice the blood of a few to save the many. Do not rely on trump as he has a huge ego bigger than the size of the earth. Trump do not apply his promises but more interested of financial deal to benefit him and his family. We must not forget that he lost a lot through the tears, trust and personal interest and reputation - my own opinion. STAND ALONE AND STRONG ISRAEL AND RESPECT PRIME MINISTER NETANYAHU AND THE IDF SOLDIERS WHO FOUGHT A LOT FOR YOUR COUNTRY. 🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽♥️♥️♥️
Pure poison.
Lol
@@jpk3692how.? Hostages are being freed back to their families. America first 🇺🇸
XD Trump did a 180
I’m sickened by this deal smells
Stinks
Reeks to heaven high.
Ceasfire today January 15 big mistake
Big one: Rafah under Egypt
As has happened since 2005, Hamas will have free pass
Infuriating!
Astute analysis as usual. And so articulate.
Victor Davis Hanson is one of our exceptional political analysts.
Glad he’s one of Caroline’s regulars.
Love you Caroline💙
Same! Excellent conversation as always.
Pray that this goes from Victor Hanson's lips to God's ears.
Just what my husband said when we both heard this
God IS and will always be in full control...NOTHING happens which HE doesn't allow...ultimately it's all about Scripture being fulfilled...DJT is an instrument, nothing more
@@janiceplotz3339 Ah, will you stop with the incantations!
This is a terrible deal. I sm a huge MAGA Christian American and i am terribly disappointed in this deal.
You can stay out of this. My people getting out of the tunnels is more important than your feelings. Even if it means just one of them is coming back. We will take whom we can get. We did not start this mess. The hostages didn't start this mess.
You may want to learn to disagree in a respectful way. No need to vomit your frustrations and attack a well meaning empathetic stranger. Self regulation is an important life skill.@@zmarssojourner7435
@@zmarssojourner7435 Of course not, Israel did not start this mess...Gaza terrurests did. This deal is so bad bc it empowers these terreorists to do this again, even stronger. It allows them time & money to do it again! There was a peace agreement in effect when the invasion took place. How well did that work? This will result in more Israeli lives lost, more hostages taken, more IDF lives lost, as history with these people has proven. This is not a Trump deal it is an Obiden deal made by Obiden negotiators on Obiden's watch. DJT basically has no power to negotiate any deal UNTIL he is sworn in as pres, 20 Jan. NO I do not have to "stay Out" as you suggest. I too have suffered loss of loved ones in WWI, WWII & VN. The pain of ALL Israelis is palpable & I am so sorry. I cant help but wonder if you have the welfare of the land of Israel & Israeli citizens in mind. Are you even whom you seem to be? Am Yisrael Chai.
@@zmarssojourner7435your people will not be getting out! Most of the hostages are dead.
Only 23 live hostages are to be released in part 1 of the deal. Will be amazed if the 23 are released as they will be released 3 or 4 per wk with plenty of time for hamas to change the terms.
Last hostage deal ended without all the hostages to be released as hamas changed the terms in the middle insisting on releasing dead instead of live hostages.
Those hostages not in the list for 1st part of 33 hostages will never get released as nothing can be trusted with hamas and terms arent decided for their release
@@zmarssojourner7435 The weak-minded overly emotional is why Sinwar got out of prison to organize 10/7/23.
You are the problem.
Thank you Professor Davis Hanson!
There's no way Trump can compare this deal with Hamas in January 2025 with Ronald Reagan's deal with Iran in January 1981. Regan scared Iran, they capitulated, and the U.S. gave up nothing. In today's case, Israel is giving up way too much, and it will cost dearly.
1981 - Good.
2025 - Bad.
Seems like a South African early 90's scenario is being forced & playing out on Israel here !! Trumps first 2 - 3 weeks will tell if this treachery is his or Bidens as VD Hanson is saying .... either way Israel is the sacrificial lamb if you read how VD Hanson hesitates every now & then in this interveiw !!
Israel is the actual offended. It should be required to give up nothing. Nothing.
@@CatouMilou That's what I meant too. I think you missed my point.
Huge mistake to allow all those convicted terrorists to walk free. Yahya Sinwar is a cautionary tale!😢
Terrible deal. Hope that's not what Trump really wants. ☹️
🙏 🇮🇱 💙
It looks like yet more poisoning by Biden
It is Trump is all about himself you think America cares about us you’re insane I know there are Americans who do however there all Jewish and I don’t mean that in a bad way at all I respect my brothers and sisters across the globe however fighting in this war has gotten me no where not a single victory has even been allowed by the Americans and we could’ve won if our government wasn’t afraid to say no
Well, he said that hostages will be released by inauguration. Obviously there was a tremendous pressure on Israel to except the deal . Trump needed it. Perhaps he promised something in return, like turning blind eye if israel will attack Iran, or promising American help as well. Will see in the near future if there was another side of the coin. Let’s hope that Netanyahu government will survive this .
Trump is very smart. And that’s the most important thing. Smart people do smart things
What your favourite Trump really wants is Canada and Greenland.
Love the two of these folks
German Catholic here: I was shocked about this deal, but as VDH says: Let´s wait a week or so. I think or hope things will look much better for Israel. God bless.
The innocent Palestinian people are paying the price of Germany's holocaust of jews during WW2.
Exactly!
Bulls..t! Now you see what US deep state plan is and nobody can stop what they want
German Catholic Church always makes me think of German Chocolate Cake. So I love you already 😂 We stand with you and with Israel and that’s why we fought so hard against all odds to get Trump reelected. Praise God. I think soon we give Israel a lot of room to run!
Dear Caroline I take my hat off, you are admirable and a true and wise Israelite ❤ keep it up ☝️ fight the good fight of Faith... one more time gorgeous journalist with all due respect 🎩I side with you 100 percent!at your service Manny 🥊
Its a terrible deal that Israel will regret,Trump needs to check himself and distance himself from this deal!
Trump should do what he thinks is best for America and Netanyahu should do what he thinks is best for Israel not how it is now where America is imposing on us what they want for us to accept and our spineless government accepts that no questions asked
Trump is the only reason why the deal was signed, why would he distance? He does not care about what his deal will lead to in 3 years, he only cares about his glory.
You can stay out of this.
@@zmarssojourner7435 do you want us to stay out of it? I will spread that around that in Israeli in Israel wants us to stay out of it as the US will get our people back and you’re on your own.
Very dissaponting Trumpm & Biden same Side of the coin.
This is outrageous. Imagine asking for 3000 terrorists to be released.
Crazy as....
My guess is they are releasing a bunch of lower risk prisoners to buy time until Trump is thoroughly in control of DC and by end of February Israel will have a lot more latitude to conduct their policy. I can’t wait. God help them!! 🙏🏽
Truly appreciated this episode of your show, Caroline. Love Victor. He is always so informative and truthful.
No prisoners release without all the hostages - alive and deceased - returned to Israel. Please let a wrench be thrown in the middle of the ceasefire agreement. The agreement needs to be implemented with President Trump in office not anyone in the O’Biden administration having any part in the future of Israel dealings with Hamas. Israel must be in charge of its destiny.
No Terrorist Release!
No negotiating with terrorists.
This was so helpful! Many thanks to both erudite commentators. Let's bring this concern to the Lord God of Israel in sustained prayer.
Call for a national fast. And prayer
@@debrayoung7501 An 8-hour fast like the super-silly pro-Hamas students?
adore your commentary always C. Glick ! Genuine female reporter, without screaming t.y. !
Why specify 'female'? How is it a criterion?
Sinwar was himself released as part of the insane deal that Israel made for its soldier Gilad Shalit. These types of deals lead to catastrophe and more dead Jews.
Yep.
What a treat to listen to two of my favorite commentators! I’m really horrified at this terrible deal. Truly hope there are things behind the scenes the make this not as bad.
And Biden has taken credit for it.
@@marycull3607 That's fine. He should take credit for all his bad deals.
Caroline, I agree with Victor that Israel has Divine fate. Love your show, you and Israel. ❤️
Of course Israel has its divine fate. God-Jesus Christ personally and through the Prophets and Apostles tell us so all through the 66 Books of the Bible. Israel ultimately comes to belief in Jesus Christ and win in the end. But before that time, there’s still lots of distress and tribulation for Israel. 🇮🇱
I find the reporting of this deal to be suspect....my impression is that this is propaganda...I certainly hope this deal was not the plan offered and "insisted" on by Trump.
This deal is NOT acceptable to me as a supporter of Israel and Trump.
If it is true.....there MUST be other plans we do not yet know of.
Why? Do you want the hostages to endure more suffering?
@djtner6232 My thoughts exactly. This deal does not come close to what DJT insisted on. This deal could be an "all or nothing last ditch effort" by the failing Obiden admin. This deal is disgusting! We will see 20 Jan 2025. Am Yisrael Chai.
There is. A Palestinian state and peace in the middle east. Trump will make it happen.
Something about it just doesn't add up.
@@StrollmanxThey say what we want to hear and do what the deep state wants
something is not right with this deal , Israel needs to be very careful and stay wide awake , you are dealing with americans and muslims what can go wrong ?????????
They're dealing with liars..turn coats and Muslims..smiling faces tells lies..
Praying for Israel!
Thank you. Amen.
Just starting watching. Love the warmth, mutual respect and fondness of the two towards each other in the first minute.
I commented in one of your prodcasts in the past that i hoped Trump wouldn't let Israel down 😟. I pray the safety of Israel and for the release of all the hostages.
Basically this is Israel's defeat and it means all those IDF soldiers were killed in vain since Hamas will stay in power and while the IDF leaves the hamas will be busy making it even more dangerous for the IDF to return or fight
No.
💯
Yeah,Iran should put an end to it!
Keep Gaza under the control of Israel. Keep southern Lebanon! Keep the Syrian border protection under Israeli control. Spoils of war is terrioritory! The hell with Oslo agreement.
What is the geographic limits of Israel?🇮🇱
Hezekiel 47,13-23
How is the Oslo Agreement still valid if the other side did not respect it?
@@sgabig Plenty of documentation on this on the Internet. Look it up.
@sgabig The biblical geographic limit is a lot bigger than what it is, because Israel has been making concessions like this terrorist release deals. So insane, since 1948.
i can't believe Trump will settle for this deal.
Trump is not President yet
Well believe it. Steve Whitkoff forced Netanyahu to accept the deal he previously didn’t accept. Funny that the ‘Hell in the Middle East ‘ threat included Israel right
@@chenal7445that is a possibility
@ nope. hamass will break the agreement because they are stupid. then it's bye-bye gaza.
Trump did not mention prisoners. He talked about the hostages.
How can the US not see what Israel needs.
We don't care about Israel y'all have your own prime minister to worry about y'all problems trump is our president and Americans come first
The US doesn't care about what Israel needs. We're just Jews, expendable.
They know full well. But do you really know what the deep state wants? We can’t look at their words only see what they do. Their actions are what they really want.
Don't say: "US"; rather say: "US Government", "US Public", "US Congress", etc. What you MEAN to say, however, is "Trump". He sees, he knows more than you think. And as much as I love Trump, he was wrong to force Bibi to accept this shitty deal.
@@s.marcus3669 Trump lied and betrayed us, the Israeli people.
Stellar guest! No deal until Trump is in.
This is gut punch by Trump
@@happycamper47 both- Biden I expected
Releasing terrorists in exchange for hostages is what brought us Sinwar and October 7th. Enough is enough. Hasn't this government learnt its lesson?
They don’t have a choice
Not "this" government ! The Left in Israel are "too nice"!!!!
Why?@@nancywilkinson7281
Of course Israel has a choice. It can take and hold territory and refuse any agreement that doesn’t include the unconditional surrender of Hamas. Israel also must hold strategic positions like Rafah on the Egyptian border to prevent cash and weapons form coming into Gaza and allowing Hamas to rearm. As Netanyahu said, you cannot put out three quarters of a fire. It will just start up again in a few years and Israel will have lost all of its soldiers’ lives in vain. No concession to Hamas.
@yehoshuabenavraham9706 AMEN The best way to end a war is to win it. I think Trump pressured Netanyahu to take it, which I do not like.
Thank you Ms Glick. This has been a brilliant conversation. In the fog of war it becomes difficult to see the difference between friend and foe. Israel must remember who the real enemy is. Shia or Sunni, the dogma of Islam remains the same. Other nations who act like the turtle will get stung by the scorpion. Whatever "it" promise NOT to do, " it" WILL do. They should remember the nature of the beast. ❤🇮🇱❤ May Hashem keep His hand of protection over His people and His land. May Adonai Elohim comfort those who mourn. Heal those wounded in body, soul, and spirit. Give strength to the brave warriors of Israel. Counsel the government under the leadership of Mr Netanyahu. Amen🙏 Hallelujah , the Lord God Almighty reigns. Jahweh is His Name. 🙌
Only in God should Israel trust.
Absolutely. Donald Trump, as much as he has been a friend to Jews and a friend to Israel, is a weak reed to rely on. Only the Almighty can be depended upon to be in our corner. Israelis have to rely on each other and on the Creator.
Zionist don't believe in god
Great show Caroline!!!
HE SAID "ALL HOSTAGES" BEFORE INAUGURATION. NOT SOME HOSTAGES. DON'T GIVE TRUMP CREDIT YET, AND FORGET THE REST!!!
Biden has taken credit for it. Why when he was leaving the W.H.?
I’m starting to wonder if he really meant only the hostages with US passports 😢
Caroline, I love you and Israel. I’m not Jewish, but I lived in Israel and went to graduate school there. I speak, read, and write Hebrew, and have taught it and Jewish history. However, most American Jews I deal with and highly assimilated. So much so that their Judaism looks more Presbyterian to me than Jewish. Consequently, they are liberal Democrats. Israel
Is not the most important issue on their radar.
Trump knows EXACTLY what that the REAL JEWS want, including his daughter and son in-law, who are Orthodox Jews. Hanson keeps evading her questions!
so true! ... I am an American (secular) Jew who is SUPER MAGA ... but hard as I tried ... my two JEWISH sisters having swallowed the democrat Koolaid for so long ... they still vote democrat as if this was the democrat party of JFK and LBJ
Heartbreaking, yet nonetheless entirely true. I personally, as a traditional Jew, coined the term "Plastic Jews" in reference to those confused souls, as their association to the collective is tethered solely by the thin thread of motherly technicality.
Yes, she knows this better than you, but thanks for the reinforcement. By the way, we Jews on the Right have a name for secular (and even a very few observant) Jews who vote for Democrats: "Yidiots".
Additionally, we tell this joke since 2016:
Q: What's the difference between Trump and a typical American Jew?
A: Trump has Jewish grandchildren
Oh I loveee Victor! Keep up the great work Caroline. 💙
And again Israel must to feed and supply enemy. Why????
Were they not getting out of that foolishness? If not, it has to end. Completely.
Caroline glick and victor davis hanson,, two of my favorite people
Yep. Titans
Will the Palestinian prisoners released be deported into another country or released back into Gaza? Phase 2 states, "Security for Palestinian returnees". What does that mean?
They will go back to their families
It’s probably legal word for they get free rain over Jews again
Thank you very much Sir for supporting Israel!
Thank you for Victor Davis Hanson. There is nothing double minded about him. Thank you Caroline and Mr. Hanson
Thanks Caroline for your update 🙏
How can a deal be announced before the final details are agreed.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said they will issue an official statement regarding the hostage deal "only after the completion of the final details of the agreement".
According to Netanyahu the details are currently being worked on.
I'm so disappointed with Trump.
Be disappointed with Netanyahu he’s the idiot who allows himself to get forced into signing shitty deals stop pointing fingers at America the only thing we can do is start protesting American influence over our country trumps gonna do what’s best for him not what’s best for Israel or the American Israeli relationship
@deborahfreedman333 This is an Obiden deal not Trump's. Trump said all hostages released by 20 Jan or else. We are not at 20 Jan!
Maybe they are buying time...?
Hope so🤓
1978 I get my citizenship I know the band time😢⚕️🇨🇭🧾🗺️🇮🇱🇺🇲🙏🔊 we the people😅
I am very very disappointed with Trump. He talks a lot but sadly he’s doing the opposite.
Give him time ...Israel need peace as well as Palestine.
You don't know that.
@@marianlynch4829 "Palestine"????
Trump doesn't show his hand before he takes action. He never gives the enemy his plans in advance. He did say release of all hostages before 1/20/25. We have a few days to see how this actually plays out.
@@SharonFried-k4p Jordan is Palestine
looking forward to hear Caroline's take, esp. w/VDH.
President Trump forced Israel to sign a terrible deal!
There is nothing to be happy or proud about!
In 42 days, we will see if his guarantees that we can go back to fight Hamas are real.
Praying for the people of Israel 🇮🇱 🙏♥️
Biden fingers are all over this Trump is not in yet Trump will help Israel
Just a great interview with someone I have total respect for Victor Hanson
Both Victor Davis Hanson and Caroline Glick are esteemed thinkers and commentators.
Thank Caroline and Victor! Great podcast, not very encouraging news( hopefully just for now)!
We should pray for Caroline and Victor that God would give them an encumbered mind and share their knowledge with President Trump. Pray that God will guide them all!
Amen and Amen
Israel has to do what have to do, it is your people, pray!. Nobody wants a hot potato from others, you know your enemies, God be with you.
I've not seen Trump comment on this...
This is Obama's deal. We will not really know what Trump really can do about it until next week.
💯 AGREED 👍🏻👍🏻
Facts…
Am Israel chai from Costa Rica 🇨🇷
Any ceasefire at this juncture must have an indefinite permanent peace for Israel . This ceasefire does not guarantee any peace. It is sad , but what I see is a decession to support an egoist element to fulfill what was said in the election campaign. It is best to view this cease fire as temporary pause . Hamas will never relinquish its vendetta as long it is given a chance to live another day.
Trump ego
Releasing terrorists is also part of this deal? What are they thinking? Not good. I feel sorry for Israel. I'm very worried. 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇮🇱🇮🇱🏴🏴 Praying for Israel.🙏🙏
With this deal, Israel is in danger.
This deal is to say the least sickening just sickening can't believe it,it's just shocking
Welcome back Victor D Hanson? One of the great ones recognizes Caroline Glick, good to see
I agree
Why did this deal happen?
PM Netanyahu was pressured and threatened both by Biden (with a UN resolution the US wouldn't veto) and pressured by Trump's special envoy Witcoff
It would not be surprising to learn that Trump and Bibi came to an understanding that once this deal is successfully completed in all phases (and that’s a big “if”), that there would be an all out effort to neuter Iran. If true, Hamas’s lifeline would be effectively cut off and Hamas as a viable entity would come to an end. Couple this with extending the Abraham Accords to Saudi Arabia, the dynamics in Gaza, among other places, would dramatically change. This is the broader context that the deal could only make sense. But all this is speculation; we really don’t know. And so we will have to wait and see.
Accurate.
I’m submitting a request to President Donald John Trump that he would consider both of you to sit among his most trusted advisors. I will also forward directly to his inbox this conversation. May God continue to richly bless you both.
How do we let him know about our highly concerns
Thanks!
Thanks for your support!!
I do agree that Mr Hanson would be an asset on the president's cabinet as a Historic Advisor.
This is a disastrous ceasefire ever
I am very disappointed in the deal. This weakens Israel's security. Over 800 Israeli soldiers died for what? Hamas will start over, and Israel will be compromised. I understand the hostage families concern. This deal does not bode well for Israel.
😢😢😢
WIKI:
"Steven Charles Witkoff is an American attorney, real estate investor and developer, philanthropist, and founder of the Witkoff Group. He practiced as a real estate attorney for the first few years of his career, then pivoted to become a real estate investor and developer."
30:00 Victor Davis Hanson fitting pronunciation: Erdo-yawn (Erodgan) and Gutter (Quatar).
Incredible detail in your reporting. Truth.
They could give all the prisoners released a pager 🙄
Hamas won't be able to keep the ceasefire.
I think they are planning on it otherwise they would give up all the hostages
Exactly
Follow up Carolina glick 🕎 🇮🇱 I told him he was bigger than your think my side l l el 😅🙏
Thanks Victor and Caroline
Brighten the swamp that's the first mistake 🇺🇲🇮🇱🕎⚕️🇨🇭🧾🗺️🚑🧫✍️😅📡🎖️
Caroline, I can't believe that Trump would abandon Israel but I understand your anxiety. I think that one approach to creating lasting peace in the Middle East will be by way of business and I am sure parts of it will not look good at the first glance. The thing about strategy is that you can't reveal it ahead of time. I also think that US citizens will stand behind Israel.
I sure hope US citizens will stand behind Israel! Let them remember the origins of their deepest beliefs.
This is small point, but as a Canadian I just have to say that Trump can take no credit for Trudeau's exit. We have been working hard for years, to oust the dictator.......remember the freedom Convoy? People have been unjustly imprisoned , we have been protesting continually, Pierre Poilievre has been traversing the country relentlessly, in short, Trump can crow all he wants about it, but it's as stupid as crowing that the disaster of a deal in Israel is 'epic' as he put it. I can't be more disappointed in Trump and I have been an ardent supporter for years. I am nauseated and sick at heart. God bless Israel.
Excellent! Thank you 🙏🏻
EDUCATE YOUR PEOPLE!! Concerning WHICH NEWS AGENCYS to freely talk to;& which news agencys to WALK AWAY FROM!!
Among the things I fail to understand include why Hamas is still being allowed to exist and why this compromised hostage-release deal is viewed as acceptable. What are the true roles of Qatar and Turkey? It's not just "the hostages" who are being held hostage ...
VDH is a Wise man, Trust the Lord, And Trust the Guy that recognized Jerusalem as the Eternal Capital of the Jewish Kingdom, and the Golan as part of Israel 🇮🇱
No one in over 3500 years has done that.
God is not sleeping, and He does not slumber.
Caroline, The Fear you have is the from the God of your enemies. Like my mother told me, “It’s your Goat, Don’t let them have it”. Take out what we all know to be the tool of the left, Fear.
Praying for You, VDH and all the One and Always Jewish people.
❤❤❤❤ Great analysis! I Love Israel and I stand with Israel!
SOMETHING ODD.....
Don’t jump to conclusions; especially don’t buy any second- third- fourth-hand propaganda.
Is it possible that Trump wanted to free as many hostages as possible before they destroy HAMAS
I pray that is the plan. I am certainly disappointed with the deal being reported.
I think we need to stop attributing to Trump-whom I certainly appreciate-military genius and judgment he simply does not have. Whether you’re a Christian or a Jew, he is not the Messiah, and we have to start interpreting his shortcomings as just that, not potentially genius feints.
Possibly
@@edoboleyn Yep.. Like with any politician, expect great disappointment...then maybe it won't be too bad...
@@edoboleyn Definitely...He's got a big ego that's for sure...
If the Knesset gives the green light for this hostage deal, they are also green lighting the two-state solution. The only possible reason for allowing the survival of Hamas is so that they can form a Palestinian state along with the Palestinian Authority.
A murderous enemy state beyond the fence with Israel?