When I first saw this as a kid in the cinema, I was depressed that all those Narnians were slaughtered at the gate. Watching this now, I hear their cries not for their deaths but for Peter to be safe. They believed in him and the siblings to very end, willing to give their lives for their home and the freedom of their people, knowing that they will avenge them
Me too and so proud and glad we avenged them after the final battle indeed and the Narnians have there home back after over a Millennium time and that's a miracle relief wasn't it right guys but still at least the Narnians have got there kingdom back and they've got the best High High High High King of there's of all time right after Aslan yep His High High High Majesty King Caspian X really has done very well after defeating the Talmerines hasn't he right guys he's done super indeed!
Difference is that, there was a part of me that believed Aslan resurrects. (And my gut was right). The Narnians however, died tragically, and there was no other way to reverse it.
2:34 this scene is so tragic not just because Glenstorms son is left behind with the other Narnians, but because the look in Peter’s face screams “What have I done” so hard.
En ese castillo aunque no se aprecie bien, según un análisis que hice sobre la batalla de Beruna y las palabras de Nikabrik hacia Caspian después de la Batalla en el Castillo de Miraz, este dice lo siguiente: "Medio Ejército a Muerto" y "Al otro Medio le falta Poco". Es decir, que en la batalla de Beruna cuando Miraz llaga con su Ejército, este tenía 16.000 telmarinos bajo su Mando y Peter a unos 3.000 Narnianos a su lado. Eso significa, que 3.000 Narnianos perdieron la vida en el Castillo de Miraz, y dado a la inmensidad de bajas que tuvieron los telmarinos en el Ataque al Castillo de Miraz, significa que aquella noche en el castillo, tuvieron que perder entre 9.000 y 10.000 hombres. Mientras que en Beruna, batalla donde murió Miraz, de 16.000 telmarinos, 10.000 perdieron la vida y los Narnianos, sólo unos pocos 100, debido a la estrategia que tuvieron y la ayuda de Aslan con los árboles.
@@dakotalange2858 Mostly yeah, but Peter is also responsible for letting his pride cloud his judgment. It was a losing battle when they failed to truly catch them by surprise, but Peter was just too stubborn to admit this was a total failure. Meaning when he does realize it, he loses more than he would’ve.
The first movie made me dislike the Minotaurs because they served under the White Witch but seeing this absolute unit of a Minotaur, holding the gate just so the others can escape made me sad and love them
@@itfigurescomics6704 It's actually 1500 years since the first battle of Beruna and the defeat of the White Witch and considering Peter reaction the first time they crossed a minotaur in the second movie, i don't think the minotaurs were accepted among the Narnians under the Pevensies reign.
The first movie made me love minotaurs, even if they were serving the White Witch. This movie made me love them even more, the fact that they were on the heroes side was so good to see
I love how the brief scenes with the Minotaurs are a complete and deep story arc: 1st movie: A minotaur is the one commanding the White Witch's forces 2nd movie: A minotaur is the one sacrificing himself to allow other Narnians to escape Miraz's castle 3rd movie: A minotaur is the one commanding the Dawn Treader ship along with Caspian.
The chivalry and nobility in this scene…despite it being an absolute failure of a fight, the sadness and nobility of Peter staying with his troops to the last second…man you don’t see that everyday
Oh yes… it’s a shame this franchise never developed. Prince Caspian was never my favourite as a kid,I always loved the first one. It was too saddening.
@@jwill5892True, notice that not just Minotaurs, but also Satyrs, dark dwarves, wolves, other beast and other creepers are under Aslan's rule after the war.
they don't make soundtracks like this anymore!! I remember watching this on theaters as a kid and I cried so hard when the minotaur held the gate, such a powerful scene
The nod between the two centaurs is quite depressing in a way, but also shows a strong family bond at the same time. It is basically like the father is telling his son to "die well", cause as soon as they have this moment the one trapped turns around and heads back into the courtyard to die fighting.
I don't think Glenstorm would've left his son to die if it was possible to go back. But giving how risky it was, he had to let him die, and his son knew it.
0:30 I literally get super emotional everytime I see this Minotaur sacrifice his life so the pevensies and his friends could escape knowing full well he would die. He even lifted the gate higher before the end.
Of all the films I've seen, I can't think of any force of men die with such bravery. All of them telling King Peter and the others to live and fight another day.
If Disney treat Narnia seriously, they had lot of potential to be succes franchise like Lord of the Rings and Game of Thrones. Narnia had a lot of lore and history to dive deep in the story and if Disney+ make a series for this a lot of people gonna watch it, only if they choose the right Director and Writer Edit: Great news! Narnia will have a new movie coming and Greta Gerwig is the director. Huge win! 🙌🏻
Not in this political and woke era this woudnt be a success no matter who take s on the role because of all the things Disney has being doing even netflix now that has taken the rights more because CW Lewis was a cristian and i doubt they would respect his characters as he wrote the story and took alot of stuff from the bible
@@crow_g1639Narian's by far one of the best depictions of Christian allegories that we have in media, its not preachy! It's got great fights when you're younger and even after growing up they're still pretty brutal here and there. Its the quintessential example of Christianity made fun for kids.
Why is nobody talking about how strong the Minotaur was, so the others could escape? Everyone should talk about the others, not just talk about the leaders.😢
There's a reason he was 'The magnificent', Peter was willing to give his life and help the ones that were trapped, but he understood that some sacrifices must be made
Only half of the narnian soldiers escaped the castle and the rest inside of the castle got struck by a hail of arrows after the Minotaur got struck by 4-5 arrows since he couldn’t hold the gate for much longer… so sad😭🤧 but at least half of the Narnians made it out of the castle alive but still suffering the loss of their fallen comrades!
Most of them ended up dying in the final battle anyways. If you look at the amount of narnians that are alive at the end of the film you can see that like 1/4 of those who fought in the final battle survived
Watching this the first time I always thought the Narnians stuck inside were crying for help. After watching it again later in life, realizing they were telling those who made it out to save themselves brought on all the feels.
What makes it so tragic, is that not only does half the narnian forces sent in die, all while they cheer for King Peter and such and believe in them until the end, but also the telmarine forces.It's why the commanding guy is so hesitant to give the order, something Miraz has no qualms, is the minute the gate drops all the men will die.And you literally see a few telmarine men die by their own mens hands.
There’s something else to Asterius’ death and his will to sacrifice himself. When Trumpkin fell he landed on a Telmarine soldier who was about to stab Asterius from behind and he noticed only when Trumpkin was on the ground. Perhaps one of the reasons he stayed to the end was because he realized that he was already supposed to be dead due to that Telmarine soldier but he was saved by very unlikely circumstances so he gave it his all to let others save themselves.
Peter’s plan was always going to fail. His only strategy was to either attack and hope the castle would fall, or wait for the enemy to come to them. And pray the Narnians could hold them off. It would have been much better if they had stayed in the forest and used guerrilla tactics to slow down the talmarin army. Even destroy the bridge they were building. Would have taken away their advantage of their siege weapons. And even the odds for the final confrontation.
@@garlikbred5170 Not really. Because even if they took the castle and killed the lord, the other lords would have just taken his place and laid siege to the castle. The narnians would have been trapped behind enemy lines with no escape. Victory would have only been temporary.
@@garlikbred5170 No it wouldn't. Neither Peter nor the Narnians knew the layout of the castle or how to even siege it properly. His plan was literally "kill everyone". Caspian blatantly told Peter that nobody had ever taken the castle, it was built to withstand sieges for near 1000 years since the Telmarines invaded Narnia. If you watch the movie again Peter is clearly shown to be way too hot headed. Even Susan told him to abandon the mission after Caspian's failed attempt to kill Miraz which costed them. But he didn't and look what happened. Caspian isn't solely to blame here
@@snoshio6043 No it wouldn't. Neither Peter nor the Narnians knew the layout of the castle or how to even siege it properly. His plan was literally "kill everyone". Caspian blatantly told Peter that nobody had ever taken the castle, it was built to withstand sieges for near 1000 years since the Telmarines invaded Narnia. If you watch the movie again Peter is clearly shown to be way too hot headed. Even Susan told him to abandon the mission after Caspian's failed attempt to kill Miraz which costed them. But he didn't and look what happened. Caspian isn't solely to blame here
Героїзм і смерть цього мінотавра викликають в мене більше емоцій і смутку, ніж смерть будь якого злодія чи героя Марвел. Абсолютно досконала сцена, яка в дитинстві змушувала плакати і битися в конвульсіях декілька днів, а потім ще місяць бути в депресії. Спи спокійно герой, безіменний Мінотавр, сподіваюся ти знайшов свій мінотяврячий рай.
Я спершу подумав, що це ютуб автоматично переклав коментар, доки не придивився уважніше. Приємно все-таки зустрічати співвітчизників серед англомовної аудиторії, ще й під таким фільмом
This was so sad he sacrificed himself and so did all the others yelling save themselves but really they all knew as soon as they were trapped they were going to die and then Edmund’s fly over
God damn these were underrated movies, that cgi is absolutely golden holy, not to mention that werewolf gave me nightmares as a child, and the desperation on jadis' face as her window is closing is really eerie-like an animal starving for something to devour, didn't catch that as a kid
I'm 23 years old, and my heart still aches 💔 for all those Narnians getting trapped, getting left behind, and getting shot 🏹 😢😭. Believe me man, I know how you feel to one Narnia fan to another.
How amazing the new threat of former enemies has brought together. However, it is a frequent historical tradition to unite in front of a common enemy. Subsequently, this had a positive effect on the peoples of the Minotaurs and they perfectly settled into the new political system.
A lot of these comments seem like D%D type people. Never really been a fan of playing, but I love listening to your stories and your imaginative ideas. I’m definitely built more like a jock and I love sports, but I’m open minded. I’m the biggest fan of smiles and winning, and being the best you and loving you, and if this what makes you happy then if it were to ever come down to it then let me be “The Minotaur at the gate” to grant all of you my Kings and Queens safe passage back to the kingdom! ❤🔥
I know Peter was kinda an ass in this one but he really wasn’t terrible here. Tried to end Miraz and when that failed he tried to get all of his troops out and was the last one that made it out.
While I love this as a battle scene, and absolutely adore the sacrifice and courage of the Narnians, I have mixed feelings about this as it never actually happened in the books and seems like it was added to the movies just so Peter could learn a hard, unnecessary lesson. However, that Minotaur is literally the definition of sacrifice, and let’s be honest, those fighting scenes are incredible. Also, as a HUGE Edmund fan, the Edmund scenes in this were gold 💖💖💖
Yes and no, i think the problem is just there isn't any director who have that passion anymore especially the success of guys like the Russos who are overrated and no talent, proven by Cherry and the Gray Man. They are hiring just yes man thanks god the strike helped now
Troy needs to be the one who always returns in this universe. That stab wound did nothing! Maybe he is some kind of superhuman that ends up being the key to a cure because of his regenerative abilities? I want to see a redemption arc! My favorite fear character! ❤
We can talk about whose to blame, but the Wikipedia plot says it failed because of Peter's recklessness; as soon as the bells went off Peter should have just called the plan off
Okay, there's one thing I don't get. At 2:26, when that Minotaur kept holding up that gate, and got shot. Granted that was the most heroic, honorable, and noble sacrifice he made. But I'll get right to the point, when the gate fell at that moment why couldn't another Minotaur lift it up? I mean, it's not like the gate was bolted down or it was unliftable, there were still time left to escape. I mean a Minotaur or two could have lifted up the gate easily, and let several other Narnians to escape. I don't get it, Minotaurs are known for their brute strength. They could have lifted up the gate easily, but they didn't. Do any of you out there totally agree with me on that? I mean, ever since I first saw it in theaters that scene when those Narnians got trapped and got left behind it broke my heart. To this day it still gets me, I mean it can break anyone's heart or even crack a tear ask anyone. Also, all those Minotaurs and including the one who was holding up the gate has truly made up from fighting along side with the White Witch 1300 years ago. Wouldn't you also agree with me on that too?
It's a lot harder to lift something up than to keep it up. The first minotaur was able to use his whole body to keep it lifted as well. I think a few minotaur may be able to lift it back up, but it's definitely a lot harder to do and while everyone is getting shot at
Oh dear Peter you should have called off the attack when the Alarm was raised but now trying to take back your former kingdom when you failed the Narnians too welly all the way and now thanks to his hypocrite and stubborn reckless half the Narnia army of King Caspian X is dead now because of you indeed right guys!
That's because this battle never happened in the book. Most of the battles in the book were near Aslan's How, where Caspian and the Narnians had bunkered down. And at least, they kinda had to skirmish with the Telmarines a number of times in the book, as they had been followed and basically besieged by the Telmarines. I also don't think they brought all the Narnians in this night "raid" in the movie, but probably just a hand-picked strike force.
@@garlikbred5170 Because the film needed more drama apparently. In the books, this battle doesn't even happen. Instead, they are bunkered down in Aslan's How, and would sally out from time to time to skirmish with the Telmarine Army.
When the gate shuts why do they act like half an army of Minotaur and centaurs and fauns etc… can’t simply relift the gate again when it only took 1 Minotaur
Because you can't get your hands under a gate that heavy when it has fallen fully shut. It's possible to stop it while it is still falling but not when it's shut
If they had only killed Miras and retreated the mission would have been sucessfull, as some collegues here mentioned and with reasoning: even if they took the castle they would never be able to hold it.
You know there was more minotaur there. Sure they was getting shower with arrows, but i felt like they could of lift it up just a few more sec to get more out.
This movie is a little weak in some areas, which is what makes the movie not quite as good as the first one, but it sure has some powerful scenes. The battle scenes are all second to none and are on par with lord of the rings. One thing that both movie series do so well is get you to care about not just the main characters, but supporting ones as well.
Its sad that these trilogy Was ended. Part 1 and 2 was amazing but the thirth Part was absolute boring and then they have stopped the continue. Sry for my bad english. I am still learning :)
@@itfigurescomics6704 Maybe! Disney has already Star wars destroyed. Im not so hopeful that they have learned to be better in their job. When I was a child I was a big disney movie fan. Today you see only wokeing and boring character and simple storys.
1. I don't think that was the whole Narnian army, but a selected strike force. 2. Castle Battle DIDN'T happen in the book. INSTEAD, Caspian and the Narnians had fled, and bunkered in Aslan's How, where they fought several skirmishes against the Telmarines that had followed them. I guess though, that having multiple battles in the same location would've been "boring" in a movie.
@@nemo0036 it wasn't the entire army, though half of them did die. Nikabrik tells Caspian that half of his army is dead after this. Doesn't really end up mattering that much though, since most of them end up dying in the final battle anyway. About 1/4 of them survive
When I first saw this as a kid in the cinema, I was depressed that all those Narnians were slaughtered at the gate. Watching this now, I hear their cries not for their deaths but for Peter to be safe. They believed in him and the siblings to very end, willing to give their lives for their home and the freedom of their people, knowing that they will avenge them
This scene was too brutal as a kid. I was a but depressed as well because the first movie wasn't as dark as this one.
That part always makes me cry
Those Narnians died bravely.
Bro i was depressed because all other narnians from part 1 are dead😖
Me too and so proud and glad we avenged them after the final battle indeed and the Narnians have there home back after over a Millennium time and that's a miracle relief wasn't it right guys but still at least the Narnians have got there kingdom back and they've got the best High High High High King of there's of all time right after Aslan yep His High High High Majesty King Caspian X really has done very well after defeating the Talmerines hasn't he right guys he's done super indeed!
Saddest scene in whole of the series this. I know Aslan dying was awful, but this just really tore your heart.
Aslan surely knew that he would survive, and they surely knew that they would die.
Difference is that, there was a part of me that believed Aslan resurrects. (And my gut was right).
The Narnians however, died tragically, and there was no other way to reverse it.
Not enough people talk about the absolute unit that minotaur was, holding a metal sliding gate for more than a minute so the others could escape
Hearing his cry in pain when he firstly feels the weight of the medal gates always breaks my heart
Not even a word of fucking thanks as they all rode past him, and no one said anything “I’ll avenge you all” to those still trapped within.. disgusting
Legend 👏 💯
AND being shot at, to boot--this is one of the reasons why I play Minotaurs in D&D, they can be loyal to those they value till the end! DX
@@BoomPunchPear yo his death crushed me the most🥺 I thought this would’ve been a victory
2:34 this scene is so tragic not just because Glenstorms son is left behind with the other Narnians, but because the look in Peter’s face screams “What have I done” so hard.
En ese castillo aunque no se aprecie bien, según un análisis que hice sobre la batalla de Beruna y las palabras de Nikabrik hacia Caspian después de la Batalla en el Castillo de Miraz, este dice lo siguiente: "Medio Ejército a Muerto" y "Al otro Medio le falta Poco". Es decir, que en la batalla de Beruna cuando Miraz llaga con su Ejército, este tenía 16.000 telmarinos bajo su Mando y Peter a unos 3.000 Narnianos a su lado. Eso significa, que 3.000 Narnianos perdieron la vida en el Castillo de Miraz, y dado a la inmensidad de bajas que tuvieron los telmarinos en el Ataque al Castillo de Miraz, significa que aquella noche en el castillo, tuvieron que perder entre 9.000 y 10.000 hombres. Mientras que en Beruna, batalla donde murió Miraz, de 16.000 telmarinos, 10.000 perdieron la vida y los Narnianos, sólo unos pocos 100, debido a la estrategia que tuvieron y la ayuda de Aslan con los árboles.
It was caspians fault
@@dakotalange2858 Mostly yeah, but Peter is also responsible for letting his pride cloud his judgment. It was a losing battle when they failed to truly catch them by surprise, but Peter was just too stubborn to admit this was a total failure. Meaning when he does realize it, he loses more than he would’ve.
@thanosmarioorgana2501 They’re both at fault in different ways.
The first movie made me dislike the Minotaurs because they served under the White Witch but seeing this absolute unit of a Minotaur, holding the gate just so the others can escape made me sad and love them
If one act could have redeemed them this 💯 was it.
100 years of peace and mercy can change a Race after the War for Narnia
@@itfigurescomics6704 It's actually 1500 years since the first battle of Beruna and the defeat of the White Witch and considering Peter reaction the first time they crossed a minotaur in the second movie, i don't think the minotaurs were accepted among the Narnians under the Pevensies reign.
The first movie made me love minotaurs, even if they were serving the White Witch. This movie made me love them even more, the fact that they were on the heroes side was so good to see
His name was Asterius.
I love how the brief scenes with the Minotaurs are a complete and deep story arc:
1st movie: A minotaur is the one commanding the White Witch's forces
2nd movie: A minotaur is the one sacrificing himself to allow other Narnians to escape Miraz's castle
3rd movie: A minotaur is the one commanding the Dawn Treader ship along with Caspian.
I noticed that too. Thought it was great
Brothers advanced in society, true chads
Yes the Minotaurs were my favorites in these movies
This absolute legend holding up the gate 🔥 0:29
He will be remembered... 😔
I would have given him the Medal of Honor!
RIP Asterius.
🫡
Edmund took “fall back” to a whole nother level 😂
Literally made me laugh out loud 😂😂😂
The chivalry and nobility in this scene…despite it being an absolute failure of a fight, the sadness and nobility of Peter staying with his troops to the last second…man you don’t see that everyday
He is High King it's his duty...1st to charge last to retreat
This was my Red Wedding when I was a kid.
"Red Wedding"?
@@itfigurescomics6704 game of thrones i forgot what episode though
Oh yes… it’s a shame this franchise never developed. Prince Caspian was never my favourite as a kid,I always loved the first one. It was too saddening.
@@firewarmicecold2954 Season 3 episode 9
I'm 25yrs old grown man
I cry like a baby each time I see minotaur's death.
Asterius was his name.
The main centaur dude and his son is distantly related to Oreius even after hundreds of years his family still fights for Narnia
"The main centaur dude" 😂😂😂
His name is Glenstorm by the way but how you called him it's also good. 😂😂😂
To think, the Minotaurs once fought along side the White Witch. That one holding up the gate sure showed them!
I can see em holding up the gate so the white witch can escape
@@FPSDAVE23 This one would stomp on her face
Groups of people can change given more than 200 years lol
@@jwill58921300 years, but yeah. I see your point
@@jwill5892True, notice that not just Minotaurs, but also Satyrs, dark dwarves, wolves, other beast and other creepers are under Aslan's rule after the war.
The part were one of the Narnians yelled save yourself leave us made me cry
they don't make soundtracks like this anymore!! I remember watching this on theaters as a kid and I cried so hard when the minotaur held the gate, such a powerful scene
Those left behind didnt even cried for help. Instead they urged the others to run to safety.😢😢😢
The nod between the two centaurs is quite depressing in a way, but also shows a strong family bond at the same time. It is basically like the father is telling his son to "die well", cause as soon as they have this moment the one trapped turns around and heads back into the courtyard to die fighting.
I don't think Glenstorm would've left his son to die if it was possible to go back. But giving how risky it was, he had to let him die, and his son knew it.
0:30 I literally get super emotional everytime I see this Minotaur sacrifice his life so the pevensies and his friends could escape knowing full well he would die. He even lifted the gate higher before the end.
As the gate goes up you can hear someone say, “avenge us.”
No, he said "in the name of Aslan" as the gate goes up
Of all the films I've seen, I can't think of any force of men die with such bravery. All of them telling King Peter and the others to live and fight another day.
If Disney treat Narnia seriously, they had lot of potential to be succes franchise like Lord of the Rings and Game of Thrones. Narnia had a lot of lore and history to dive deep in the story and if Disney+ make a series for this a lot of people gonna watch it, only if they choose the right Director and Writer
Edit: Great news! Narnia will have a new movie coming and Greta Gerwig is the director. Huge win! 🙌🏻
Yeah--but who? 0w0
Not in this political and woke era this woudnt be a success no matter who take s on the role because of all the things Disney has being doing even netflix now that has taken the rights more because CW Lewis was a cristian and i doubt they would respect his characters as he wrote the story and took alot of stuff from the bible
@@crow_g1639Narian's by far one of the best depictions of Christian allegories that we have in media, its not preachy! It's got great fights when you're younger and even after growing up they're still pretty brutal here and there.
Its the quintessential example of Christianity made fun for kids.
Just imagine old BBC series made today...
@@crow_g1639Keep whining about woke shit and I'll make Glenstorm and Oreius bisexual
Why is nobody talking about how strong the Minotaur was, so the others could escape? Everyone should talk about the others, not just talk about the leaders.😢
Yeah, that guy was an absolute unit AND a good solider till the end... 😢
There's a reason he was 'The magnificent', Peter was willing to give his life and help the ones that were trapped, but he understood that some sacrifices must be made
That was brutal, no wonder why despite only seeing this scene as a child, I still remember this massacre.
Only half of the narnian soldiers escaped the castle and the rest inside of the castle got struck by a hail of arrows after the Minotaur got struck by 4-5 arrows since he couldn’t hold the gate for much longer… so sad😭🤧 but at least half of the Narnians made it out of the castle alive but still suffering the loss of their fallen comrades!
Most of them ended up dying in the final battle anyways. If you look at the amount of narnians that are alive at the end of the film you can see that like 1/4 of those who fought in the final battle survived
It's a good job I'm blind, otherwise this comment would be useless.
Watching this the first time I always thought the Narnians stuck inside were crying for help. After watching it again later in life, realizing they were telling those who made it out to save themselves brought on all the feels.
What makes it so tragic, is that not only does half the narnian forces sent in die, all while they cheer for King Peter and such and believe in them until the end, but also the telmarine forces.It's why the commanding guy is so hesitant to give the order, something Miraz has no qualms, is the minute the gate drops all the men will die.And you literally see a few telmarine men die by their own mens hands.
I can never get over the part one of the Narnians says run for your lives save your self !
I get teary eyed every time I see this.😢
Man, that Minotaur was awesome--holding up the gate while being shot at... 😢
There’s something else to Asterius’ death and his will to sacrifice himself. When Trumpkin fell he landed on a Telmarine soldier who was about to stab Asterius from behind and he noticed only when Trumpkin was on the ground. Perhaps one of the reasons he stayed to the end was because he realized that he was already supposed to be dead due to that Telmarine soldier but he was saved by very unlikely circumstances so he gave it his all to let others save themselves.
This movie was never my favorite in the series but I'll admit, this scene still gets me. Truly a work of art.
Peter’s plan was always going to fail. His only strategy was to either attack and hope the castle would fall, or wait for the enemy to come to them. And pray the Narnians could hold them off.
It would have been much better if they had stayed in the forest and used guerrilla tactics to slow down the talmarin army. Even destroy the bridge they were building. Would have taken away their advantage of their siege weapons. And even the odds for the final confrontation.
Nah everything would of worked if caspian had followed orders
It wud have been fine if caspian followed his orders
@@garlikbred5170 Not really. Because even if they took the castle and killed the lord, the other lords would have just taken his place and laid siege to the castle. The narnians would have been trapped behind enemy lines with no escape. Victory would have only been temporary.
@@garlikbred5170 No it wouldn't. Neither Peter nor the Narnians knew the layout of the castle or how to even siege it properly. His plan was literally "kill everyone". Caspian blatantly told Peter that nobody had ever taken the castle, it was built to withstand sieges for near 1000 years since the Telmarines invaded Narnia. If you watch the movie again Peter is clearly shown to be way too hot headed. Even Susan told him to abandon the mission after Caspian's failed attempt to kill Miraz which costed them. But he didn't and look what happened.
Caspian isn't solely to blame here
@@snoshio6043 No it wouldn't. Neither Peter nor the Narnians knew the layout of the castle or how to even siege it properly. His plan was literally "kill everyone". Caspian blatantly told Peter that nobody had ever taken the castle, it was built to withstand sieges for near 1000 years since the Telmarines invaded Narnia. If you watch the movie again Peter is clearly shown to be way too hot headed. Even Susan told him to abandon the mission after Caspian's failed attempt to kill Miraz which costed them. But he didn't and look what happened.
Caspian isn't solely to blame here
1:03 i love this szene! She's really cute and way too underrated in my opinion
Just hearing that last words "Avenge Us" Just made me feel so sad for the ones left Behind.
Героїзм і смерть цього мінотавра викликають в мене більше емоцій і смутку, ніж смерть будь якого злодія чи героя Марвел. Абсолютно досконала сцена, яка в дитинстві змушувала плакати і битися в конвульсіях декілька днів, а потім ще місяць бути в депресії.
Спи спокійно герой, безіменний Мінотавр, сподіваюся ти знайшов свій мінотяврячий рай.
Этого минотавра зовут Астериус.
@@АндрейЕнинков дякую, буду знати ім'я героя.
Я спершу подумав, що це ютуб автоматично переклав коментар, доки не придивився уважніше. Приємно все-таки зустрічати співвітчизників серед англомовної аудиторії, ще й під таким фільмом
@@Buddy_Jesus факт і для мене це приємна зустріч. А фільми шедеври і завжди в серці.
Ultrachad minotaur deserved more screentime
Love that moment when Edmund flies by Peter on his griffin and Peter looks back to check on his brother
This was so sad he sacrificed himself and so did all the others yelling save themselves but really they all knew as soon as they were trapped they were going to die and then Edmund’s fly over
“In the name of Aslan!” 😭😭😭
God damn these were underrated movies, that cgi is absolutely golden holy, not to mention that werewolf gave me nightmares as a child, and the desperation on jadis' face as her window is closing is really eerie-like an animal starving for something to devour, didn't catch that as a kid
It was so heartbreaking to see they sacrifice themselves for the good of Narnia and they were avenged
I am 26 years old and I get tears in my eyes when I watch that gate trap the troops inside waiting to get shot
I'm 23 years old, and my heart still aches 💔 for all those Narnians getting trapped, getting left behind, and getting shot 🏹 😢😭. Believe me man, I know how you feel to one Narnia fan to another.
omg a minotour can be seen carrrying an injured faun trying get out while it is also injured at 1:55 :(
Good Eye!
How amazing the new threat of former enemies has brought together. However, it is a frequent historical tradition to unite in front of a common enemy. Subsequently, this had a positive effect on the peoples of the Minotaurs and they perfectly settled into the new political system.
Frick, dude--100 years after the War really can change a Race... 🥲
Also, where? o.o
@@itfigurescomics6704 bottom left behind peter
im a 26yr old and this dam sad scene STILL gets me everytime.. it holds up to the emotional roller coaster to this day :'>
This movie and book are the my favorite of the series. This book was so dark.
A lot of these comments seem like D%D type people. Never really been a fan of playing, but I love listening to your stories and your imaginative ideas. I’m definitely built more like a jock and I love sports, but I’m open minded. I’m the biggest fan of smiles and winning, and being the best you and loving you, and if this what makes you happy then if it were to ever come down to it then let me be “The Minotaur at the gate” to grant all of you my Kings and Queens safe passage back to the kingdom! ❤🔥
God bless everyone because of this video 999 trillion times more.
Hardest scene in this movie 💔😔
I know Peter was kinda an ass in this one but he really wasn’t terrible here. Tried to end Miraz and when that failed he tried to get all of his troops out and was the last one that made it out.
Peter learned a true burden of leading an army "In Peace Sons bury their Fathers and in War Fathers Bury their sons"
While I love this as a battle scene, and absolutely adore the sacrifice and courage of the Narnians, I have mixed feelings about this as it never actually happened in the books and seems like it was added to the movies just so Peter could learn a hard, unnecessary lesson. However, that Minotaur is literally the definition of sacrifice, and let’s be honest, those fighting scenes are incredible. Also, as a HUGE Edmund fan, the Edmund scenes in this were gold 💖💖💖
✝️🤍😇🔯🧄🐑🕊️🌠🪐🌎🌏🌍🌲🦅🇺🇸🍀Holy Psalm 91 Jesus and KathrynMiller say Thankyou for sharing ✝️🤍✝️🤍✝️🦅🇺🇸🍀🍀🍀
Hearing Peter desperately calling the Narnians to retreat while the Minotaur is struggling at the gate is bone chilling
That minotaur was MVP 💯
Disney these days wouldn't dare put a scene like this in one of their movies.
Yes and no, i think the problem is just there isn't any director who have that passion anymore especially the success of guys like the Russos who are overrated and no talent, proven by Cherry and the Gray Man. They are hiring just yes man thanks god the strike helped now
Troy needs to be the one who always returns in this universe. That stab wound did nothing! Maybe he is some kind of superhuman that ends up being the key to a cure because of his regenerative abilities? I want to see a redemption arc! My favorite fear character! ❤
Круто прикрасно❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
We can talk about whose to blame, but the Wikipedia plot says it failed because of Peter's recklessness; as soon as the bells went off Peter should have just called the plan off
As sad as this scene is, I always loved how the rats pass through so easily, even after the Minotaur (rip king) collapses.
Since some of the good guys died in battle I'm still sure it was honorable
Qapla to that ❤
Peter's face at the end 😭💔
Okay, there's one thing I don't get. At 2:26, when that Minotaur kept holding up that gate, and got shot. Granted that was the most heroic, honorable, and noble sacrifice he made. But I'll get right to the point, when the gate fell at that moment why couldn't another Minotaur lift it up? I mean, it's not like the gate was bolted down or it was unliftable, there were still time left to escape. I mean a Minotaur or two could have lifted up the gate easily, and let several other Narnians to escape. I don't get it, Minotaurs are known for their brute strength. They could have lifted up the gate easily, but they didn't. Do any of you out there totally agree with me on that?
I mean, ever since I first saw it in theaters that scene when those Narnians got trapped and got left behind it broke my heart. To this day it still gets me, I mean it can break anyone's heart or even crack a tear ask anyone. Also, all those Minotaurs and including the one who was holding up the gate has truly made up from fighting along side with the White Witch 1300 years ago. Wouldn't you also agree with me on that too?
It's a lot harder to lift something up than to keep it up. The first minotaur was able to use his whole body to keep it lifted as well. I think a few minotaur may be able to lift it back up, but it's definitely a lot harder to do and while everyone is getting shot at
Giant can also hold the bridge gate for enough time for the soldiers to escape from the castle that could have been a backup
plan.
I love prince caspian
Dont mean to be ignorant but why didnt the other Minotaurs try to lift the gate together so more could escape?
I know it’s late but they could also bring the logs and use it as support pillars to keep the gate open
give the order , my men are still down there
Soo heartbreaking scene:/
Oh dear Peter you should have called off the attack when the Alarm was raised but now trying to take back your former kingdom when you failed the Narnians too welly all the way and now thanks to his hypocrite and stubborn reckless half the Narnia army of King Caspian X is dead now because of you indeed right guys!
That's because this battle never happened in the book. Most of the battles in the book were near Aslan's How, where Caspian and the Narnians had bunkered down. And at least, they kinda had to skirmish with the Telmarines a number of times in the book, as they had been followed and basically besieged by the Telmarines.
I also don't think they brought all the Narnians in this night "raid" in the movie, but probably just a hand-picked strike force.
Caspian was the one that ruined the plan tho
@@garlikbred5170 Because the film needed more drama apparently.
In the books, this battle doesn't even happen. Instead, they are bunkered down in Aslan's How, and would sally out from time to time to skirmish with the Telmarine Army.
@@nemo0036 caspian should have sticked to the plan
@@nemo0036 this battle scores a point for the movies. It was awesome
I feel sorry for all the Satyr, Minotaurs, talking animals, and Glenstorm's son getting killed there.
Why didn’t they just send the griffins to get the people with the crossbows…you had aerial support they could’ve used it 😭
Feel like the Fairy Godmother should have been singing I Need A Hero here.
I cried cus they were crying out “go save yourself!” Broke me in two
Why did Susan call Caspian
She calls Peter name alot in the movie
Simple solution...After the minotaur collapses, why cant the others lift up the gate? There were minotaurs and other stronger creatures present
I have always wondered
They would be cut down and the person who would most likely to try to lift the gate would be the centre of the archers' attention
@@CrabDougnut Maybe so but it’s still worth trying don’t you think? If it meant one more soul escaped it was worth it right?
They maybe wanted to be a distraction so that Peter and the others could escape. It was a lost cause, someone(s) had to die
Maybe 'cause if other would hold the gate, it won't be enough space for the others to escape.
The Minotaur general carried the battle literally
Excelente película 😂
1:30 GERONIMO!!!!
Lovee this films so much, such a shame the rest werent adapted in sequence
Happy time
What is
Natanpo
When the gate shuts why do they act like half an army of Minotaur and centaurs and fauns etc… can’t simply relift the gate again when it only took 1 Minotaur
holding it is one thing but relifting a solid metal gate is another thing beside dude that one minotaur was a strong mf
Because you can't get your hands under a gate that heavy when it has fallen fully shut. It's possible to stop it while it is still falling but not when it's shut
Natanbo
@@idajohansson6921 but it wasn't fully shut as it fell on top of the poor Minotaur holding it and is big enough for Reepicheep to go under
Even if they managed to lift the gate, there was no way for them to lower the bridge
If they had only killed Miras and retreated the mission would have been sucessfull, as some collegues here mentioned and with reasoning: even if they took the castle they would never be able to hold it.
I knew miraz is a tyrant, but letting his soldiers die by ordering to shoot..?
miraz could have wait until the minotaur falled down
prince caspian
Just a thought, if 1 cow man in a enough to hold the gate. I'm supposed to believe a bunch of other animals man can't work together and lift it up.
Who is here in 2024 and too think,god damn how strong a single minoraur is and why he was able to hold the gate for that much time ?
Is it just me, or do the tigers and leopards and such seem a bit on the smaller side?
You know there was more minotaur there. Sure they was getting shower with arrows, but i felt like they could of lift it up just a few more sec to get more out.
This video is so sad😢😢😢😧😧😣
2:21 1 Minotaur
2:35 but why they can't lifted it up again?
This movie is a little weak in some areas, which is what makes the movie not quite as good as the first one, but it sure has some powerful scenes. The battle scenes are all second to none and are on par with lord of the rings. One thing that both movie series do so well is get you to care about not just the main characters, but supporting ones as well.
Its sad that these trilogy Was ended. Part 1 and 2 was amazing but the thirth Part was absolute boring and then they have stopped the continue.
Sry for my bad english. I am still learning :)
the only thing that was great was the dragon the rest was boring
I get it--maybe Disney+ can try again
@@spellsnare You are right. And the only one good character was Aslan and Prince Kaspian.
@@itfigurescomics6704 Maybe! Disney has already Star wars destroyed. Im not so hopeful that they have learned to be better in their job. When I was a child I was a big disney movie fan. Today you see only wokeing and boring character and simple storys.
@@lukas.kreuch the mandolorian was great and also obi-wan kenobi was fun to watch
They should have never attack the castle lost half their army should have let them come to there stronghold
The plan was good. It was Casian who ruined everything.
1. I don't think that was the whole Narnian army, but a selected strike force.
2. Castle Battle DIDN'T happen in the book. INSTEAD, Caspian and the Narnians had fled, and bunkered in Aslan's How, where they fought several skirmishes against the Telmarines that had followed them.
I guess though, that having multiple battles in the same location would've been "boring" in a movie.
@@nemo0036 it wasn't the entire army, though half of them did die. Nikabrik tells Caspian that half of his army is dead after this. Doesn't really end up mattering that much though, since most of them end up dying in the final battle anyway. About 1/4 of them survive
Based Minotaur
More movies need to do moments of absolute silence. Or at least moments with absolutely no musical score.
Where were the griffins???
I’m joining peter army
What is a hero that Minotaur