West Ham fan... Very honest appraisal. We were as surprised as you with the performance. I was expecting a 4 0 loss. You're a great side and wish you luck.
Overrated side they either work together or play as if they’ve never played together last night was awful to watch even if you’re beat it’s the effort and not much especially second half
Who the fuck do Newcastle think they are honestly they haven't won anything in years all we need is a decent coach and you'll see a completely different westham we shouldn't fear teams like Newcastle they are no bigger than westham
As a hammer like a lot of us like to see the toon do well great club great fans and always a good game, we didn’t expect this result as many didn’t but I think your right the international break really helped us more than you plus other factors like us under pressure, we got away with a few tonight I think the ref was poor for both teams, cracking game to watch hard fought good luck for the season 👍⚒️
Where's he's aggression on the ball gone... he's becoming Mr nice guy and the edge is gone... I want him to be the player no one likes again. Its like he achieved his England goal and feels like he owes nothing now
Miguel Almiron is is far superior. Anthony Gordon just had a purple patch last season. He doesn't track back and has no left foot. Gordon gets away with it because of his nationality
as a west ham fan i was stunned by our performance, our best by a country mile this season... newcastle are a good side and will bounce back.. good luck for the rest of the season..
I thought tonali was poor when he came on - he doesn’t seem to be someone who puts his foot on the ball and forces control of midfield in the same way Bruno does. Bruno is everything you want from a centre midfielder but tonali seems like a bit of a luxury player. Jury’s out for me a bit I must be honest.
Eddy has reached his limit, we will plod along win a game lose a game until the penny drops with the ownership that Eddie needs replacing for an elite coach. Just a matter of time, I mean some of his decisions tonight were terrible from the starting line up (dropping tonali and barnes, how can Sean Longstaf be keeping an Italian international, Seria A winning star out the team???) to the subs, I mean Lewis hall in center mid at the end just summed up that the players had no clue what they were doing and where they were supposed to be. We have been a poor/average team for over a season now, this year we have no got the usual excuses of injuries and fixture congestion.
Apparently Wan-Bissaka has scored 3 goals in his career and 2 were against us. His other goal was a stunning hit for manure in the 4-1 defeat behind closed doors.
Honest assessment of the game Keith. It is the first time we have clicked this season. The 119km distance covered is streets ahead of where we have been so far this season. It is no coincidence. Had Isak had opened the scoring early on and we had gone behind I think it could have been a totally different outcome. Good luck for the rest of your season
This is why English managers can never be elite, Longstaff and Willock should never be starting over Tonali and Barnes. This type of man management makes good players turn into bad players.
The trouble is that Tonali hasn’t really looked the business in any game he’s played. Longstaff by contrast hasn’t been in a losing side this season until this game. And even in this game he’s not one of the ones you would point the finger at whereas Bruno, Gordon, Isak and Kelly were all very poor
I’m having a pop at Howe - you bring Wilson on and then Murphy - he can’t put a decent cross into the box to save his life - and Barnes prefers to cut in for a shot rather than cross the ball - that performance was fire - the players need to use their wages to pay the fans back for watching that dross - taking nothing away from WHU by far the better team right across the pitch and Bowen was outstanding- good luck to the hammers - great turn out of away fans for a Monday night game - your team didn’t let you down.
What major silverware have you won since the fairs in 69 / 70 season. Aside from that your last cup win was the F.A CUP 55 / 56. Had finals yes, but always a bridesmaid. I like Eddie Howe, but you will win nothing under him.
Now we have lost with Sean in the team can we start Tonali, ask him that. poor night all round, only Hall was decent. Tonali has to be playing those games, where we have majority of the ball. Sean for games where we don't and need his energy,but we cannot leave him on the bench! Kelly had a bad game, missed BDB. Bruno off pace, should have been rested given he played midweek. They look tired. Jetlag? Bad game management from Eddie today, needs to learn from it. Still backing him to fix it.
@graeme66 The final CL game against Milan done it for me. Was furious after that. All we had to do was not lose and we still had Europe, Win and we finished second! I've got at least 5 more examples of his in game mismanagement and contradictory behaviour
Newcastle only really function when they are underdogs, teams we are expected to beat come to defend in depth and are organised and we struggle to overcome this. We really miss Wilson in such games as I think he is more confident than Isak in these games. If we score first we seem to cope but when we concede first it’s a struggle.
The players are fed up,u can see it,howe has run them into the ground,exactl what he did at Bournemouth, he has to go before January, s window,,we cannot let him sign any more second raters.
As a Hammer I'd like to say what a sportsman you are. None of us were expecting that from West Ham. Take solace from the fact that you live in the best city in the world.
Should have started Tonali instead of Willock. Howe needs to be more aware that most teams will sit back against us at home and we need quality players to unlock that deep block. Very poor after the second goal. Kelly was poor but he doesn't play consistently
Bugger, we just looked flat everywhere. I thought Hall had a good game but I struggle to name another performance. Our ability to cross with any accuracy is appalling. I can honestly see Isaac bailing if we cant get him better ball. I hate all these breaks, it looked like we were on holiday. OMG we better play much better the next home game.
@johnadair8850 Yeah, Howe should be managing in a league with predominantly British players. He's just signed his friends who are Championship players. Lloyd Kelly is absolutely useless and he's getting paid £150k per week. It's a joke
Very poor final ball. Poor decision making. For about 30 min in 2nd half we lost every single second ball. Bruno outplayed by Paqueta. We really miss Burn vs physical forwards like Antonio. But for half a yard we should have gone 1 nil up at 5 min in and it would be different game. Wilson should have had penalty too. Score that and 1-2 with 15 min to go it could have been interesting. Liveramento was limited and Joelinton and Gordon well off the pace.
We are a bad team that occasionally plays well. We are awful infront of goal. This season a top half finish maybe beyond us. Just enjoy watching our better players because this is definitely their final season with us.
West Ham fan: would have put money on 4-0 to you boys. Shocked at our midfield rearrangement, movement and tactics. He hasn't done that all season. Finally we clicked. Still taking stock of what I saw ,TBH. You lot are a proper club - hope you break into the top 6. Cheers.
Still trying to fit players into a team ...willock confidence player like Dyer . Never turned up . Midfield not covering ground and leaving holes . Up front ... didn't pass or run off the ball particularly well . Complacent Toon . Subs were odd . Kelly not a first teamer
We are so boring, predictable and inconsistent. No accountability. Players wages too high on bad performance. No stadium, no players. No contact between players, howe and fans sadly.
Good objective report again Keith. Its a mystery ... West Ham a solid team. NUFC dont seem to know their best 11. Is Tonali or Longstaff better in midfield? Who knows ....
How long do you give Eddie howe, he has ran out of ideas and isn’t a trophy winning manager or have a mindset were they want to win every game and believe that they can do it. Time for a change of manager and changes on the pitch as it’s not working out for me. • Gordon is over rated • Isak is totally out of form • our midfield isn’t working • our centre backs are not good enough • we have no talent on the right wing
It’s scary how bad Kelly is. Just an awful player. 5 years of him on a massive contract and I’d happily never see him anywhere near the pitch again. He’s cash leak for half a decade to come and that’s not great in a PSR world.
@@skysportskeith I feel I was a bit reactive in the aftermath of last night but I also wasn’t as enamoured with him after the cup game as others seemed to be. I thought he was alright but not spectacular. And that was a very poor showing last night. I haven’t been as disappointed and angry after a match since Liverpool at the start of last season. It just feels like a wasted opportunity. They didn’t have to be particularly good to beat us comfortably. I still think we beat most teams in the league if 2 or 3 of Gordon, Bruno and Isak play well but this season, we’ve rarely had more than one of them putting a shift in at a time.
Playing anything but Pope, Tino, Schar, Burn (Botman when hes back) Hall, Tonali, Bruno, Joelinton, Barnes, Gordon and Isak is fucking insane. Kelly should be a last resort back, Longstaff, Murphy and Willock should be injury cover or at best late subs. Howe had a lot of praise and support prior to the international break but hes making it hard to back him with these shit team selections.
Last nights game, and Newcastle's loss needs to be analyzed. Yes, of course you can't take anything away from West Ham, they played well, and took their chances. Newcastle's passing was disjointed, with attacks breaking down. Also, poor defending for the first goal. Tactical changes badly needed by Eddie Howe.
Absolute garbage. We’re a midtable club despite being capable of much more. Howe needs to get some tougher questions from you lot about his baffling decisions and continued problems with set pieces
They filled the midfield , Paquetta (who West ham supporters wanted dropped ) deserved mom. Whilst Bruno was not in the game although Joe was. Poor first goal to concede (yet again) second goal in off post whereas Gordon’s shot (Gordon not at the races) goes past the post. Was it a pen, yes but end of the day it wasn’t our night it was West Ham’s .
We haven’t improved the squad in two windows. Eddie has always said he wanted competition for all places but we are nowhere near that, so a lot of players are complacent. Key players were made promises which are nowhere near being made - from the training ground to European competition. Mitchell has been an unsettling addition who, so far, has added nothing positive. Still, I’ve lived through worse and were in a better place now than we were for best part of 15 years.
What angered me the most was Howe saying post match “mixed night for us” Nothing about this was mixed, he needs to start being a bit more honest. This was dreadful.
Tonali first team ac milan and italian international player yet howe thinks willock and longstaff are better and these two are no where near being picked for the england team i have no idea why we signed tonali and harvey barnes also kelly is no where near a top 10 team player too.
I think the team needs improvement and we haven’t for two windows and it’s telling the crowd are deflated due to that and I think Players have been promised ambition but this PSR is killing us. Need some thing in January and lacking creativity in midfield. Subs tonight did not perform.
Keith, if you've got a strong team and a strong bench then you get totally outplayed you have to look at the manager and the coaching staff. To be brutally honest, Eddie has turned us into Bournemouth. That is his level. We need a manager who is a bigger personality than the players, a manager who puts the clubs success above all else. That means someone who is ruthless and is a proven winner. In the past only Keegan and Robson have fit the bill and it's no surprise they were the closest to delivering the goods. For me, Jose is the man.
You have to wonder , who in this multimillion pound organisation woke up one morning and said OOPS I think we might of overspent, best thing we can do is off load our two best young investments and keep , Almiron , Wilson and Murphy .
well Keith ..I hate games when everyone we are expected to win 3-4-5 0 ...normally I would say European football out of the question ..but there are 19 inconsistent teams + 1 consist team Liverpool ..if things don't change Liverpool will win the league at a canter ?? anyone thinking we will beat Liverpool ???
Keith who on the gods earth thought it was a good idea to buy LIoyd Kelly and give him a reported £100k a week, it's as if we have Westminster deals going on IE Jobs for mates on top dollar, Kelly is nowhere near a top 6 Premiership defender which is were we are wanting to punch at season after season going forward, as you say some of Howe's decisions this season have had many a strong supporter of his scratching there heads, Tonali on the bench yet again aswell the lad is absolutely class and should be shoe horned into that midefield with Bruno, Long, and Big joe, get rid of this bloody 433 and fill our midfield as other teams are doing exactly against us... If Eddie's not careful he could be gone before we lose Isak as I can't really see many tip teams rushing in for Bruno....
Typical Newcastle flatter to deceive I don't believe the hype. Three wins in a row does not win you anything. Sadly inconsistency is the major DNA made up of this squad of players. If I had to sum up this Newcastle in choosing a movie that best represents this squad of players in 2024 would be The Good The Bad and The Ugly.
Everyone needs to stop pointing the finger at eddie and wake up and guve the players the blame eddie basically played the same team bar kelly that beat arsenal forrest and Chelsea he picked a solid starting 11 that should be more than good enough the players need to step up and start being consistent
I new this so call lineup without tonality will catch up to them we cannot be better without our best players playing from d get go we need batman and a new center back first then a real play maker number ten not just a right winger if u ask me
I cant agree with your summary Keith. A Bad result but not a bad performance - for the first 65 minutes I was impressed but just poor finishing by Newcastle and goals win games. Once you’re 2-0 down and chasing the game then you look open and West Ham had something to hang onto. The hard thing to cope with is how to play against teams who sit back in a low block which is something they’ll face more and more often. I wouldn’t criticise Eddie Howe, it wasn’t Eddie Howe who didn’t pick up the West Ham defender who scored the header and it wasn’t Eddie Howe who missed some gilt edged chances. Positives … I thought Lewis Hall is looking a very good player and the way him and Tino get down the wings and attack is great to see. Isak was very poor tonight. Anthony Gordon struggled against Basaka a bit. Bruno had a decent game. Joe Linton played well without causing damage. West Ham defended very well and ran their socks off. A stat after the game showed they’d ran more than any other team apart from spurs this weekend which tells the story. You can’t win them all, there’s always the next game. Some good signs. Some areas to improve.
Im sorry...But this is the clubs fault Why the hell are they dragging the players away to Saudi during one of the most important international breaks. Yeah some players were away with the International Teams, but the rest of them should have been at Benton and grafting hard in their environment. Yes lets go off to Saudi where its roasting hot, travel all that way and then bring the players back to the coldest, windiest part of the country. It may seem trivial but this squad aint full of worldclass players, its got some decent internationals and then a backlog of mediocre players, some who are running down the clock and they should be focusing on the task at hand instead of trying to drum up a small bit of business. The people of Saudi won't give a monkeys about a team who are losing and uninspiring especially against lower table teams. They looked tired and second best. This is what draws in bad decision making and lack of accuracy. The amount of times, seeing players taking a touch when they can play first time and keep the ball moving quickly is frustrating.
West Ham fan... Very honest appraisal. We were as surprised as you with the performance. I was expecting a 4 0 loss. You're a great side and wish you luck.
Overrated side they either work together or play as if they’ve never played together last night was awful to watch even if you’re beat it’s the effort and not much especially second half
You were the better team by a country mile mate.
You guys deserved the win. We really aren’t a great side, normal service resumed for us, but appreciate the kind words
West ham have had a bad start Newcastle seem to think there better than they are West ham only 3 points below ya
Who the fuck do Newcastle think they are honestly they haven't won anything in years all we need is a decent coach and you'll see a completely different westham we shouldn't fear teams like Newcastle they are no bigger than westham
As a hammer like a lot of us like to see the toon do well great club great fans and always a good game, we didn’t expect this result as many didn’t but I think your right the international break really helped us more than you plus other factors like us under pressure, we got away with a few tonight I think the ref was poor for both teams, cracking game to watch hard fought good luck for the season 👍⚒️
Gordon has been awful all year… people need to start talking about this
Where's he's aggression on the ball gone... he's becoming Mr nice guy and the edge is gone... I want him to be the player no one likes again. Its like he achieved his England goal and feels like he owes nothing now
Miguel Almiron is is far superior. Anthony Gordon just had a purple patch last season. He doesn't track back and has no left foot. Gordon gets away with it because of his nationality
Saint Maximin is also better than Gordon
@DanielCordone9 troll get a life!
@@DanielCordone9This is a troll. No one feed it.
as a west ham fan i was stunned by our performance, our best by a country mile this season... newcastle are a good side and will bounce back.. good luck for the rest of the season..
Tonali needs to play, i don't care what the stats say, he's better than wllock and longstaff put together
I thought tonali was poor when he came on - he doesn’t seem to be someone who puts his foot on the ball and forces control of midfield in the same way Bruno does. Bruno is everything you want from a centre midfielder but tonali seems like a bit of a luxury player. Jury’s out for me a bit I must be honest.
@@deanharding740he had no tactical direction. He played okay, but the entire team were lost in the second half
He's not starting bro
Eddy has reached his limit, we will plod along win a game lose a game until the penny drops with the ownership that Eddie needs replacing for an elite coach. Just a matter of time, I mean some of his decisions tonight were terrible from the starting line up (dropping tonali and barnes, how can Sean Longstaf be keeping an Italian international, Seria A winning star out the team???) to the subs, I mean Lewis hall in center mid at the end just summed up that the players had no clue what they were doing and where they were supposed to be. We have been a poor/average team for over a season now, this year we have no got the usual excuses of injuries and fixture congestion.
Who's your elite coach?
same as last season. as soon as we win a few we then hit a slump. no momentum! spurs of the north
Tottenham are better than us
Apparently Wan-Bissaka has scored 3 goals in his career and 2 were against us. His other goal was a stunning hit for manure in the 4-1 defeat behind closed doors.
Honest assessment of the game Keith. It is the first time we have clicked this season. The 119km distance covered is streets ahead of where we have been so far this season. It is no coincidence. Had Isak had opened the scoring early on and we had gone behind I think it could have been a totally different outcome. Good luck for the rest of your season
Are we going to ask some difficult questions at the press conference. Would make a change
No we won't we will just avoid that and hear excuses!!
This is why English managers can never be elite, Longstaff and Willock should never be starting over Tonali and Barnes. This type of man management makes good players turn into bad players.
Howe has too many favourites and will start them whatever that is why we need to move him on we are now looking like his Bournemouth squad
The trouble is that Tonali hasn’t really looked the business in any game he’s played. Longstaff by contrast hasn’t been in a losing side this season until this game. And even in this game he’s not one of the ones you would point the finger at whereas Bruno, Gordon, Isak and Kelly were all very poor
@@jonathanbailey9075 I’ve never seen anyone so overrated than Bruno just don’t see what all the fuss is around him players like him are ten a penny
I’m having a pop at Howe - you bring Wilson on and then Murphy - he can’t put a decent cross into the box to save his life - and Barnes prefers to cut in for a shot rather than cross the ball - that performance was fire - the players need to use their wages to pay the fans back for watching that dross - taking nothing away from WHU by far the better team right across the pitch and Bowen was outstanding- good luck to the hammers - great turn out of away fans for a Monday night game - your team didn’t let you down.
What major silverware have you won since the fairs in
69 / 70 season.
Aside from that your last cup win was the F.A CUP 55 / 56.
Had finals yes, but always a bridesmaid.
I like Eddie Howe, but you will win nothing under him.
Now we have lost with Sean in the team can we start Tonali, ask him that. poor night all round, only Hall was decent. Tonali has to be playing those games, where we have majority of the ball. Sean for games where we don't and need his energy,but we cannot leave him on the bench! Kelly had a bad game, missed BDB. Bruno off pace, should have been rested given he played midweek. They look tired. Jetlag? Bad game management from Eddie today, needs to learn from it. Still backing him to fix it.
If its not fit in 8,9 weeks sack him!!
No ones ready to talk about Eddie Howe's record for us in pressure/must win games. That's why he's not the man to win us anything.
Exactly said the same last year but I’m a plastic fan some just don’t want to admit it but it’s there for all to see
@graeme66 The final CL game against Milan done it for me. Was furious after that. All we had to do was not lose and we still had Europe, Win and we finished second! I've got at least 5 more examples of his in game mismanagement and contradictory behaviour
@@onestopdoc Yeah that's one of them. Isak on the bench for the biggest game he's ever managed but, it was Pope being suspended why we lost 🤣
@@rupert3868Eddie Howe should’ve been sacked after the Dortmund home game
@@phiIip488 See that one hurt but we missed 2 clear cut chances that game from Wilson and big Joe. I wasn't mad but i was disappointed 😅
I don’t know why we’re obsessed with crossing the ball in the box all the time, I know Isak is tall but he’s better with his feet
Agreed!
If we're not crossing it in, we're trying to walk it in. Frustrating.
Because we have a boring English manager!!!!! Simple!!!
Well said mate telling it like it is💯
Let’s be straight…Isak and Gordon missed sitters.
West Ham could've scored 7
I can’t wrap my head around Isak being compared to Thierry Henry!! He’s nowhere near that level.
So did willock just before West Ham scored
@ Totally agree!
Tonali will be off that’s for sure. He didn’t leave the heights of European football to come here and sit on our bench in games like that
Newcastle only really function when they are underdogs, teams we are expected to beat come to defend in depth and are organised and we struggle to overcome this. We really miss Wilson in such games as I think he is more confident than Isak in these games. If we score first we seem to cope but when we concede first it’s a struggle.
fair play mate good luck for the rest of the season great club great fans Steve
The players are fed up,u can see it,howe has run them into the ground,exactl what he did at Bournemouth, he has to go before January, s window,,we cannot let him sign any more second raters.
Agree and shit we have he won’t sell we are screwed under Eddie Howe
@@onestopdocand continue to blame FFP. ffp hasn't stopped paying lloyd kelly his 100k per week wages has it !
As a Hammer I'd like to say what a sportsman you are. None of us were expecting that from West Ham. Take solace from the fact that you live in the best city in the world.
The best Newcastle can achieve in mid table this season
Should have started Tonali instead of Willock. Howe needs to be more aware that most teams will sit back against us at home and we need quality players to unlock that deep block. Very poor after the second goal. Kelly was poor but he doesn't play consistently
Should've started Almiron instead of Anthony Gordon
Howe is a blind Manager
West Ham didn’t play a deep block ,they out passed Nufc in midfield and attacked really well from wide areas
Bugger, we just looked flat everywhere. I thought Hall had a good game but I struggle to name another performance. Our ability to cross with any accuracy is appalling. I can honestly see Isaac bailing if we cant get him better ball. I hate all these breaks, it looked like we were on holiday. OMG we better play much better the next home game.
Eddie won’t answer questions he’s a mid table manager
We could get relegated. We'll get beat by Ipswich
Championship manager and players so disappointing need change
@johnadair8850 Yeah, Howe should be managing in a league with predominantly British players. He's just signed his friends who are Championship players. Lloyd Kelly is absolutely useless and he's getting paid £150k per week. It's a joke
We seem to have gone backwards in the last 12 months. Not been the same since Amanda and her husband left.
Spot on.
Very poor final ball. Poor decision making. For about 30 min in 2nd half we lost every single second ball. Bruno outplayed by Paqueta. We really miss Burn vs physical forwards like Antonio. But for half a yard we should have gone 1 nil up at 5 min in and it would be different game. Wilson should have had penalty too. Score that and 1-2 with 15 min to go it could have been interesting. Liveramento was limited and Joelinton and Gordon well off the pace.
We are a bad team that occasionally plays well. We are awful infront of goal. This season a top half finish maybe beyond us. Just enjoy watching our better players because this is definitely their final season with us.
Disagree. Still think you finish in Europe
West Ham fan: would have put money on 4-0 to you boys. Shocked at our midfield rearrangement, movement and tactics. He hasn't done that all season. Finally we clicked. Still taking stock of what I saw ,TBH. You lot are a proper club - hope you break into the top 6. Cheers.
Still trying to fit players into a team ...willock confidence player like Dyer . Never turned up . Midfield not covering ground and leaving holes . Up front ... didn't pass or run off the ball particularly well .
Complacent Toon .
Subs were odd .
Kelly not a first teamer
Lloyd Kelly is a Championship player at best. He's awful on the ball and can't defend
We are so boring, predictable and inconsistent. No accountability. Players wages too high on bad performance. No stadium, no players. No contact between players, howe and fans sadly.
This has been happening for 18 month now and it’s all down to Eddie Howe he is not good enough it’s is that simple and he needs to go
Howe is to blame this time
Willock is cack. Murphy is cack. Kelly is cack. Poor managerial in game management. Pope not good enough. Trips has gone from hero to zero.
Good objective report again Keith. Its a mystery ... West Ham a solid team. NUFC dont seem to know their best 11. Is Tonali or Longstaff better in midfield? Who knows ....
How long do you give Eddie howe, he has ran out of ideas and isn’t a trophy winning manager or have a mindset were they want to win every game and believe that they can do it.
Time for a change of manager and changes on the pitch as it’s not working out for me.
• Gordon is over rated
• Isak is totally out of form
• our midfield isn’t working
• our centre backs are not good enough
• we have no talent on the right wing
I agree with Point 1
Jose M
Bruno and Gordon were sat on the bench in 2nd half, coz they were absolutely abysmal whilst on the pitch, not that hard to understand is it
Who the hell are Newcastle these days.
Rich owners but no silverware since the 1969 fairs cup win.
They used to be bigger than West ham, but no longer
PSR
It’s scary how bad Kelly is. Just an awful player. 5 years of him on a massive contract and I’d happily never see him anywhere near the pitch again. He’s cash leak for half a decade to come and that’s not great in a PSR world.
I thought he looked good against Chelsea in the cup game at CB, but agree he was poor in a number of aspects last night
Good ol Eddie Howe signing.
@@skysportskeith I feel I was a bit reactive in the aftermath of last night but I also wasn’t as enamoured with him after the cup game as others seemed to be. I thought he was alright but not spectacular. And that was a very poor showing last night.
I haven’t been as disappointed and angry after a match since Liverpool at the start of last season. It just feels like a wasted opportunity. They didn’t have to be particularly good to beat us comfortably. I still think we beat most teams in the league if 2 or 3 of Gordon, Bruno and Isak play well but this season, we’ve rarely had more than one of them putting a shift in at a time.
Agree that Isak had a poor night. Couldn’t believe Craig Hope gave him a merit mark in his channel.
Playing anything but Pope, Tino, Schar, Burn (Botman when hes back) Hall, Tonali, Bruno, Joelinton, Barnes, Gordon and Isak is fucking insane. Kelly should be a last resort back, Longstaff, Murphy and Willock should be injury cover or at best late subs. Howe had a lot of praise and support prior to the international break but hes making it hard to back him with these shit team selections.
excellent report ...thanks
Last nights game, and Newcastle's loss needs to be analyzed. Yes, of course you can't take anything away from West Ham, they played well, and took their chances. Newcastle's passing was disjointed, with attacks breaking down. Also, poor defending for the first goal. Tactical changes badly needed by Eddie Howe.
Absolute garbage. We’re a midtable club despite being capable of much more. Howe needs to get some tougher questions from you lot about his baffling decisions and continued problems with set pieces
They filled the midfield , Paquetta (who West ham supporters wanted dropped ) deserved mom. Whilst Bruno was not in the game although Joe was. Poor first goal to concede (yet again) second goal in off post whereas Gordon’s shot (Gordon not at the races) goes past the post. Was it a pen, yes but end of the day it wasn’t our night it was West Ham’s .
Agree with that. Quite a few players seem to have their best performances against us or score their token goal. Really poor performance and zero luck
7:20
We haven’t improved the squad in two windows. Eddie has always said he wanted competition for all places but we are nowhere near that, so a lot of players are complacent. Key players were made promises which are nowhere near being made - from the training ground to European competition. Mitchell has been an unsettling addition who, so far, has added nothing positive. Still, I’ve lived through worse and were in a better place now than we were for best part of 15 years.
But we should be way better we should be up there in that 6 Howe hasn’t the balls to make this happen
which leads to the massive display of simulation UN carded to disrupt play- The timing on crosses anticipated a youthful Allan Shearear type threat.
No better than Bruce,s side on that performance
We're shit! What Howe is doing doesn't work... not one player looks happy.
What angered me the most was Howe saying post match “mixed night for us”
Nothing about this was mixed, he needs to start being a bit more honest. This was dreadful.
Painful night
No tactical analysis. Just talk about substitutes which everyone will criticise when a team loses.
Amen brother !
55 minutes of very good football. Fell apart after 2nd goal. Bit of perspective needed.
Tonali first team ac milan and italian international player yet howe thinks willock and longstaff are better and these two are no where near being picked for the england team i have no idea why we signed tonali and harvey barnes also kelly is no where near a top 10 team player too.
I think the team needs improvement and we haven’t for two windows and it’s telling the crowd are deflated due to that and I think Players have been promised ambition but this PSR is killing us.
Need some thing in January and lacking creativity in midfield.
Subs tonight did not perform.
Keith, if you've got a strong team and a strong bench then you get totally outplayed you have to look at the manager and the coaching staff. To be brutally honest, Eddie has turned us into Bournemouth. That is his level.
We need a manager who is a bigger personality than the players, a manager who puts the clubs success above all else. That means someone who is ruthless and is a proven winner. In the past only Keegan and Robson have fit the bill and it's no surprise they were the closest to delivering the goods.
For me, Jose is the man.
I agree time to sack Eddie
Jose is the man
Strong bench by what comparison what bench are you looking at
@EAlexRomeroB just a wannabe fan
@@zahrawillis1070 I saw this lovely one in Ikea for £55. It looked very strong.
Zonal marking has now cost us twice from corners, its rubbish
Poor game management yet again by Howe.
Sack
Why the hell do u bring on Murphy for Gordon Why do u take off Joelington? What a Silly Manager!!
You have to wonder , who in this multimillion pound organisation woke up one morning and said OOPS I think we might of overspent, best thing we can do is off load our two best young investments and keep , Almiron , Wilson and Murphy .
well Keith ..I hate games when everyone we are expected to win 3-4-5 0 ...normally I would say European football out of the question ..but there are 19 inconsistent teams + 1 consist team Liverpool ..if things don't change Liverpool will win the league at a canter ?? anyone thinking we will beat Liverpool ???
Write West Ham off at your peril. When they get in a winless run they always pull off wins like these and surprise everyone.
I’d love to have a rant here but sometimes you just need to say we were beat fair and square!
Keith who on the gods earth thought it was a good idea to buy LIoyd Kelly and give him a reported £100k a week, it's as if we have Westminster deals going on IE Jobs for mates on top dollar, Kelly is nowhere near a top 6 Premiership defender which is were we are wanting to punch at season after season going forward, as you say some of Howe's decisions this season have had many a strong supporter of his scratching there heads, Tonali on the bench yet again aswell the lad is absolutely class and should be shoe horned into that midefield with Bruno, Long, and Big joe, get rid of this bloody 433 and fill our midfield as other teams are doing exactly against us...
If Eddie's not careful he could be gone before we lose Isak as I can't really see many tip teams rushing in for Bruno....
Arrogance brings the best of them down. Live and learn...
Just when you might think we are turning up they kick you in the nuts!
Typical Newcastle flatter to deceive I don't believe the hype. Three wins in a row does not win you anything. Sadly inconsistency is the major DNA made up of this squad of players. If I had to sum up this Newcastle in choosing a movie that best represents this squad of players in 2024 would be
The Good The Bad and The Ugly.
We look a mid table side nothing more
We do not deserve to get in europe this season, sorry.
Shocking , second rate same as our manager
Everyone needs to stop pointing the finger at eddie and wake up and guve the players the blame eddie basically played the same team bar kelly that beat arsenal forrest and Chelsea he picked a solid starting 11 that should be more than good enough the players need to step up and start being consistent
We are getting 2 Bournemouth players Eddie go back to bornmouth
I new this so call lineup without tonality will catch up to them we cannot be better without our best players playing from d get go we need batman and a new center back first then a real play maker number ten not just a right winger if u ask me
That was awful very poor performance all round. Eddie has his work cut out
He’s on borrowed time… Lose to Palace and Liverpool and I think he’s gone.
If Miguel Almiron and Martin Dubravka were starting, we wouldn't have lost
I cant agree with your summary Keith. A Bad result but not a bad performance - for the first 65 minutes I was impressed but just poor finishing by Newcastle and goals win games. Once you’re 2-0 down and chasing the game then you look open and West Ham had something to hang onto. The hard thing to cope with is how to play against teams who sit back in a low block which is something they’ll face more and more often. I wouldn’t criticise Eddie Howe, it wasn’t Eddie Howe who didn’t pick up the West Ham defender who scored the header and it wasn’t Eddie Howe who missed some gilt edged chances. Positives … I thought Lewis Hall is looking a very good player and the way him and Tino get down the wings and attack is great to see. Isak was very poor tonight. Anthony Gordon struggled against Basaka a bit. Bruno had a decent game. Joe Linton played well without causing damage. West Ham defended very well and ran their socks off. A stat after the game showed they’d ran more than any other team apart from spurs this weekend which tells the story. You can’t win them all, there’s always the next game. Some good signs. Some areas to improve.
West Ham were far superior. That Spanish midfielder was fantastic for them. Soler
Lose to Palace and Liverpool and I think Howe’s gone.
Well 😢 maybe if beaten in the cup game coming up,and Ipswich.
West Ham were missing Kudos, Alvarez and Fullkrug. West Ham have a better squad
Gordon was poor....again!!!
A very bad sign.
It's a joke how Miguel Almiron isn't starting. He's way better than Anthony Gordon. Eddie Howe out.
😂😂😂
Eddie Howe out
@@EAlexRomeroBRocking the two accounts? How confusing for you.
This is a troll. No one feed it.
Im sorry...But this is the clubs fault
Why the hell are they dragging the players away to Saudi during one of the most important international breaks. Yeah some players were away with the International Teams, but the rest of them should have been at Benton and grafting hard in their environment. Yes lets go off to Saudi where its roasting hot, travel all that way and then bring the players back to the coldest, windiest part of the country. It may seem trivial but this squad aint full of worldclass players, its got some decent internationals and then a backlog of mediocre players, some who are running down the clock and they should be focusing on the task at hand instead of trying to drum up a small bit of business.
The people of Saudi won't give a monkeys about a team who are losing and uninspiring especially against lower table teams. They looked tired and second best. This is what draws in bad decision making and lack of accuracy. The amount of times, seeing players taking a touch when they can play first time and keep the ball moving quickly is frustrating.
sack howe and hire nuno.
0 shots.... ZERO....
Howe tactics are still like we fight a relegation battle.
Boring and predictable.
Eddie has no clue! Sack him!!
Let's cut straight to the point. Newcastle are most times just rubbish and a pain in the ass.
...was hoping 4 a win, 'at least A DRAW'. Looked at best 'average'. ~am disappointed Keith man. / 🖤🤍 -//- 💚💚🤍🤍🧡🧡 /
Just when you might think we are turning up they kick you in the nuts!