Pat Benatar - Wuthering Height's | *Better than Kate Bush?* | First Time Reacting
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ส.ค. 2024
- Thanks everyone for clicking on the video. In today's video, we react to Pat Benatar's cover of wuthering heights. Let us know what you think!
........................................................................................................................................
You can find us outside of youtube, on Istagram: 'koreviewsmusic'
...........................................................................................................................................
Don't forget to Like, subscribe and Comment any thoughts or suggestions you have down below! We regulaly see the comments, so am hoping to listen to what songs you have to suggest for us.
Hope you have a great day!
..............................................................................................................................................
Disclaimer : No Copyright Infringement Intended. All Visuals, Audio Belong To Their Proper Owner/s.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
LOVE Benatar’s version.
One of her most underrated performances for sure
Pat benatar was classically trained in opera before she decided to switch to rock music in the late 1970's. Her vocal range is astonishing.
Finally someone who's reacted to Pat Benatar's version. IMO her version blew Kate Bush's away.
Yes!!!! Kate is shrill and winey . I don't understand the appeal.😅
Kate is shrill and winey sounding. 😮😅
Every hair onmy body stood out when I first heard it. And it still does.
I love both Pat Benatar's voice is astonishing as is Kate's. I could listen to both versions a million times.
Both are great. Partial to Pat's version but Kate is the originator and is such an influential artist.
In the liner notes of the box set, Pat Benatar said this song was very difficult to sing. She also felt like she didn't do the song justice. It's different from KB's version for sure, but I love them both for very different reasons.
As a teen I listened to Pat's version on a loop so many times and have been telling people about it ever since as not many people even know that she covered it. There are some live videos of Pat singing it, unfortunately the sound is not great but you can clearly hear how beautifully she delivers the song.
Thanks so much for the video!
Pats cover is amazing and introduced me to Kate bush they are both so different but I love Benatars which’s is so powerful
Always loved this cover. Haunting and poweful.
I definitely prefer Pat Benetar's version. She would be the modern Cathy. I just love her voice.
I prefer Pat Benatar's version. Her voice is pristine(check out her live versions of it).
I first heard this song when Crimes of Passion first came out. I was 15 and babysitting for my older sister (she's 8 years older than me). I was listening to her records and I noticed that one of the songs on Crimes of Passion was a song called Wuthering Heights. I had just read the book by Emily Bronte and was haunted by the story (beautifully written book that reads like a long poem). I'd not heard Kate Bush's original version. I loved this version and felt it captured the haunting emotion of Bronte's classic gothic novel. I've since heard Kate's original version and like it too. She wrote it at age 18 within a few hours! Very emotive and theatrical but I consider it more performance art than radio friendly. Prefer Pat's rockier sound and equally haunting vocals which introduced the song to a wider audience.
I’m biased, but I think this is the BEST version of the song, but it all comes down to taste, really. I think this may be Pat’s most underrated song. If it isn’t, it would be Don’t Let it show, from her first album. Anyway, I am partial to Hard Rock and Metal, and not only do I feel that NO ONE, touches Pat in the Rock genre, but, she is one of the best voices, period. I have only found one person who is even close to her as a frontwoman of a Hard Rock/Metal band, and that would be Amy Lee of Evanescence. Amy can’t match Pat’s range, but neither does Pat play piano like Amy. But Amy has a similar presence to Pat, as a frontwoman.
Agree with most of the guys here, I too prefer Pat's version, the range , the power and the metal edge to it !
I like both. I was surprised by PBs voice so close to KBs. Super cool. You guys should check out Post Modern Jukebox if you want quality covers of songs. Maybe you've already listened to em.
Thanks for checking out the video and the suggestion! 🎶
Love that you did this one! I was just listening to the album and had to see if anyone did a reaction to this 🙌❤️I was a kid in the 90s hearing this and thinking, damn it’s almost as if Pink Floyd played backing to Pat, no disrespect to Neil! ❤️
I actually first heard this sung by Benatar and had no it was a cover. I loved it and I love it still. I also prefer it, but can't say one of the versions is better than the other as they're so different. I like them both and understand what Kate Bush was trying to do with the song. Benatar manages to capture some of the eeriness with her voice (in spots) and the band also captures the eeriness with some of the instrumentation. Benatar's voice adds such a depth though. I can tell so much work had to go into making their arrangement of this song.
Love both.
I like this version because I can actually sing along with it since it's in my vocal range and Pat's voice is phenomenal but I prefer to listen to and like Kate's version better because it's artistically sublime. There is no other sound like it. You really get into the ethereal and gothic vibe of what Kate is portraying. It's so outlandish and weird but in all the right ways. Perfectly portays the mood of the lyrics. Pat's version is amazing too, it's just that i feel all of the lyrics with the original. Pat's is vocally better but Kate's is artistically better and has a lot more depth to it... I mean she did write and produce it, lol.
I got to it in a roundabout way after listening to Moroder's "Metropolis soundtrack album" which features her track "Here's my Heart on it".. Then Spotty followed it up with this out of the blue... I like this better specially the outro to Kate's which is on that 1st album is sung in her trademark very high key.
Both artist are amazing, Kate of course the original and she wrote and produced it in 1978, but. Pat, of course shes my fav singer ever!!! She just added the Rock!! Version, with her amazing band of course amazing Neil Geraldo amazing guitarist!!❤❤❤
"Angra" did an amazing cover of this song. Full on power metal but still beautiful.
God that's good
Benatar
I like this version better but not because of the voice. It’s because Pat turned it into a awesome classic rock song aha
It would be fun to hear them do a duet of the song. For another amazing cover, Anne and Nancy Wson's version of Stairway to Heaven at the Kennedy Center Honors for Led Zepplin with the surviving members in attendance and Jason Bonham on drums. Or Prince's cover of While My Guitar Gently Weeps at the George Harrison Memorial concert shows why he is a great guitarists.
Pat Benatar sings this really well. I don't think that you can compare this with Kate Bush's version.The main difference is the key in which it is sung (Kate sings it in A and this is in F - I think!) I remember Kate Bush stating that the high key helped to identify with the fact that Cathy is a ghost, and she achieves that amazing, high-pitched sound which Kate felt sounded ghost-like. Also Kate's artistic interpretation is iconic, and her choreography, which I don't think Pat Benatar does..
Yea it’s pretty much impossible to say one is better than the other! Even though they’re so similar in ways they’re both very different songs. This is just a rocking classic kinda ballad where as kates version is a haunting masterpiece. Both amazing regardless though!
I don’t understand this comparison?
Pats version is amazing.
No disrespect but Kate Bush sounds like a munchkin. I don’t like it at all.
Just my opinion. 😂
@@aks4204 Ya know, my Wife hates the Doors. She can't stand a second. When I asked her why, she said it just sounded like the Munsters music to her.
@@littlejimmy7402 LoL 😂
That’s funny!
@@littlejimmy7402
P.S.
I forgot to say, I’m not a fan of the Doors either. LoL Now I need to listen & see if it’s because they remind me of The Munsters!😂
💌💌💌💌💌
Yes I prefer Pats version too
I definately prefer the original by Kate Bush. The emotion in her voice, especially when she says 'Let me grab your soul away' - gives me goosebumps every time.
Myron Grombacher...JAYSUS CROIST
Pat Bentar's version is alot better. I can understand the lyrics better and i love how she tells the story. I watched the movie wuthering heights whenever it come on tv and my husband doesn't understand the story
Pats is much better
Not even close.
I much prefer Pat Benatar's version of this song as her voice sounds so pretty, pure, and pleasant to the ear. I don't like the shrillness of Kate Bush's voice.
I greatly prefer Pat Benatar's version. I like a lot of Kate Bush, but I find her rendition of Wuthering Heights insufferably shrill and annoying, so much that I truly cannot bear to listen to it. Pat Benatar's version is beautiful, and near operatic. Kate's version comes off like a squeaky weirdo. Sorry.
Mnn im a Brit so i love kate's version as its meant to be the voice of a tortured ghost, Pats sounds too Hollywood glossy ! good, but not for me ! Sorry ! Kate Rules !! XXX
Pat's Voice is beautiful but that's all. When Kate sings this, she IS Cathy.
Great great cover but not like Kate Bush the original Is the Best
It's ok, but there is no real passion or vulnerability in her voice which helps make the original so outstanding. You believe every word when Kate Bush sings it. Not heard of this version before though Ollie, so thank you for reviewing.
Yeah I hadn't realised Pat did a cover of the song, so was interesting hearing an alternate version!
@@KOReviewsMusic Check out Pat's version of Crying
I think the thing with this version that a lot of people like isn’t so much to do with the passion of her voice as it is to the vibe of this version! To me it makes me feel like I’m listening to some amazing 70s classic rock song when I hear this version. They’re both great in their own way