Yes truth it is and being myself as advocate since last 30 years of work I believed that there is no proper system against judges for judicial accountability
@@Maddywg-y2c First step should be an exam of all india judicial services , it should be made very tough should have 2 to 3 stages including intreview , after that once candidates are selected but appointed judges in lower court inly to gain experience then after 2 to 3 yrs they should be promoted as high court judges , then after 10 15 yrs they should be appointed as an supreme court judge . Now u will say what i am saying is already done by conducting state judicial exams but no here the ones selected under AIJS will be promoted faster and will be actually the material of high and supreme court only , they will work in lower courts just to gain experience like an PO IPS works as 1 star 2 star 3 star during the inital yrs , but he is not a SI , or SHO , he is an IPS but just to gain experience he is working on that post
@@Maddywg-y2c why will they be appointed through collegium system any person who completes his 10 yrs earlier than other person will be promoted first , collegium has nothing to do in it . Moreover if CJI 'S son was not able to clear AIJS he can not become CJI never
Suddenly everyone is talking about nepotism in the judiciary 🫰 till date their wasn't nepotism , neither the D.Y. C.... Was the son of and grandson of former Chief justice of India 🫰 but suddenly it's about Khanna ji now it's nepotism ! And reason for this Suddenly Wokeness about nepotism is just because his uncle was the only 1 who was against the unconstitutional Things ( Emergency ) and refused to support the then Congress Govt or I.G ! Where as all other Supreme Court judges' supported it including the Father/Grandfather of D.Y Chandrachud 🫰🤌 Politics everywhere bhut bdiya very very well done INDIANS AND INDIANCITIZENS
What is the alternative? NJAC was a clear message from the executive that they want judiciary under them. That can't happen. A PM can't decide who will be CJI, after all they all are illiterate thugs.
The Indian army (at commissioned officer level) and the Indian judiciary is the biggest symbol of nepotism...... Because judges selecting judges ...... Army selecting armed forces officer level........
This is worse than nepotism in Politics or Bollywood. Finally we are talking about it. Judiciary reform is 2nd most important pillar post education for overall better society.
'कमरैडरी आफ मीडिआक्रिटी' का जीता जागता खेल हो रहा है। हाई कोर्ट और सुप्रीम कोर्ट के प्रत्येक जजमेंट की पब्लिक स्पेस में क्वालिटेटिव समीक्षा होना जरूरी हो गया है।
राधे राधे जी। भारत देेश में बुद्धिमता की कमी नहीं है। किसी भी क्षेत्र में भाई-भतीजा वाद की नीती को समाप्त करना बहुत ही जरुरी है। न्याय प्रणाली में तो इस प्रकार की प्रथा को समाप्त करना अति आवश्यक है। देश के सर्वोच्च न्यायाधीशों और अन्य सभी न्यायाधीशों की नियुक्ति उचित परीक्षा के माध्यम से होनी चाहिए। इस दिशा में परिर्वतन कैसे हो, केंद्र सरकार को उचित व्यवस्था को लाना होगा।
@@chaisma Lower court main, not in high court and supreme court. Promotion is different, it has a Standard operating procedure, sometimes there are departmental exams in other organisations. Understand the gravity of these positions, making their 'promotions' transparent and allowing it to have a SOP, will make the system more citizen friendly otherwise it'll only look as selections and not promotion.
Sir kindly make video on nepotism in lower judiciary As we all see in RJS 2024 Preliminary test - 8 questions deleted Mains exam - no criteria for English essay Interview - person scoring 3 marks in English essay scored 22,24 marks in interview And how 100+ candidates are selected from judiciary background
@@xxxxxxxxx108 People choose what is available, not what they want. Choices are limited. If there was a bar that everyone should have basic education, that would be better.. All judges came by completing LLB, what about ministers?
Yes, I also heard in the news that Justice Madan Lokur expressed displeasure because Justice Pradeep Nandraj Jog and another Chief Justice of a High Court were recommended for elevation to the Supreme Court but were overlooked in favor of two other nominees, including the judge who is set to become the next Chief Justice of India
Don't forget that the Standing Advocates of the High Courts who are close to the ruling dispensation are also frequently made High Court judges,irrespective of their merit. They obviously have inclination towards the Government.
Recruitment of State judicial service should be conducted by UPSC. Like wise appointment of judges of high court and Supreme Court should also be conducted through UPSC. I’m not giving reasons, lest I face contempt. If a space is created for discussion, I’ll gladly participate
It is a clear nepotism and it should be finished. The selection process should be transparent and clean. All elegible advocates should get the opportunity to be judges.
Yes Collegium system has so many prblms and faults but still better than NJAC. NJAC was giving power to government,which impacts independence of judiciary
@@YV-2000 This exam can be at lower level and as many states have but in higher judiciary it can't be possible. As for higher judiciary,it demands experience and mere just passing an exam cannot become eligibility for selection. As even in civil service,you give exam and get posted as lower level officer like and then gets promotion on the basisi of you work
More judges from lower judiciary need to be promoted to HC and SC. Atleast they are serving the nation without being a product of nepotism. As of now most of them never get to set their foot even in HC.
All India judicial service Exam like UPSC for Civil services,should be the selection process of all judges selection. If Medical superspeciality exam can take place,where is the problem?
तो भाई कुछ ज्ञान ले ले ओर तब पता कर की जो प्रक्रिया है वो उचित है कि नहीं इस फालतू वीडियो के चक्कर में ज्ञान मत पेल ओर तुम पड़े होते तो तुम्हे पता होता कि मुख्य न्यायाधीश की नियुक्ति क्यों ऐसे होती है और कब से होती है
Amit shah ji ka beta Rajnath ji ka beta Prem kumar dhumal ji ka beta Rajmata vijya raje scindia ka beta aur pota Ram vilas ji ka ladka There are many leaders in BJP whose son’s are either MP MLA or sitting at key positions of different wealthy institutions of country.. First Pm sahab has to clean his own house before pointing fingers towards others..
All India Judicial Services के माध्यम से Judges की नियुक्ति के लिये Exam होना चाहिए,, जिससे कि सभी उपयुक्त योग्यताधारी को समानता का अधिकार मिल सके,,, लेकिन विडंबना है कि जजों की नियुक्ति में ही संविधान में प्रदत्त मौलिक अधिकारों में से एक समानता का अधिकार से सुयोग्य लोगों को भी वंचित होना पड़ रहा है
It is revealed that judges are appointed through nepotism as per your statistics. But head of CBI, NIA, Election Commission Members etc. are not appointed by collegium like institution. But in spite of that CBI, NIA, Election Commission etc. are also not working impartially. It means that unbiased personality are rare. This the summary.
You must have to visit the high courts in india and watch the argument and practice of this family related advocate and others advocate practice and argument then you will knowhow they elevated or appointed as a justice.
Who are judges Are they rulers or servants who they are....??? This is not only about judges appointment judiciary me clerk se lekr chokidar tk sabhi ke appointment ek close door ke andr ho reh No transparency...
Nepotism is undoubtedly bad. Can't be protected. But is the fact that, someone's family member is sitting as a judge, merely sufficient to disqualify him from becoming judge though he is actually deserving??
But how a candidate who got selected through judical services is product of nepotism...i mean if my father is in army ...and i aslo get selected in army through CDS exam....should this be called nepotism?.....did DYC had the option to nominate some else as CJI...as the practice goes senior most judge should be appointed..so he did that only right?.. correct me if i am wrong
![เป็นไปได้ไหม - WanMai [Performance Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Eh5hItD4Mr0/mqdefault.jpg)
This is high time that this nexus is broken .
@@harpalsinghsangwan6326 high time has already passed by now it’s has destroyed many families lives already.
This is reality. You are absolute right. No body can ignore this reality.
Yes truth it is and being myself as advocate since last 30 years of work I believed that there is no proper system against judges for judicial accountability
The Judiciary System needs of upgradation. All India Judiciary Service much be introduced and UPSC should Conduct their Exam.
lol, UPSC is in way lower position than Judiciary
India has become Banana Republic 🍌 only a Fool will trust court to give justice. Frivolous cases r 90%
A new body should form .. NJSC National judicial service commission....
All India judicial service examination is very important
Unfortunately, PM Modis Words are "JUMLA".
@@Maddywg-y2c First step should be an exam of all india judicial services , it should be made very tough should have 2 to 3 stages including intreview , after that once candidates are selected but appointed judges in lower court inly to gain experience then after 2 to 3 yrs they should be promoted as high court judges , then after 10 15 yrs they should be appointed as an supreme court judge . Now u will say what i am saying is already done by conducting state judicial exams but no here the ones selected under AIJS will be promoted faster and will be actually the material of high and supreme court only , they will work in lower courts just to gain experience like an PO IPS works as 1 star 2 star 3 star during the inital yrs , but he is not a SI , or SHO , he is an IPS but just to gain experience he is working on that post
@@Maddywg-y2c ok , sorry , not 2 to 3 yrs we can take 10 yrs ... So what is the problem in that ..
@@Maddywg-y2c why will they be appointed through collegium system any person who completes his 10 yrs earlier than other person will be promoted first , collegium has nothing to do in it . Moreover if CJI 'S son was not able to clear AIJS he can not become CJI never
😢very dangerous for nation ! Need NJC from our Parliament!!! Thanks for sharing
Nepotism always prevailed in judiciary.Judge's son,daughter,nephew get preference no doubt.
Suddenly everyone is talking about nepotism in the judiciary 🫰 till date their wasn't nepotism , neither the D.Y. C.... Was the son of and grandson of former Chief justice of India 🫰 but suddenly it's about Khanna ji now it's nepotism ! And reason for this Suddenly Wokeness about nepotism is just because his uncle was the only 1 who was against the unconstitutional Things ( Emergency ) and refused to support the then Congress Govt or I.G ! Where as all other Supreme Court judges' supported it including the Father/Grandfather of D.Y Chandrachud 🫰🤌 Politics everywhere bhut bdiya very very well done INDIANS AND INDIANCITIZENS
Let’s start a protest against this nexus!
What is the alternative? NJAC was a clear message from the executive that they want judiciary under them. That can't happen. A PM can't decide who will be CJI, after all they all are illiterate thugs.
I am with you.
Jao protest karo jao , aap danda kao hm aapke sath nhi hai😂😂
@@alokkumar-lk3bj danda woh bhi advocate ko?? Lagta hai bachpan m jhoole se gir gaye the tm😂
@@Aman_k.Jaiswal ho scta ho apko police nhi mare lkin bakeyo ka kya ?
Please go ahead and bring this fact to the knowledge of each citizen.
The Indian army (at commissioned officer level) and the Indian judiciary is the biggest symbol of nepotism...... Because judges selecting judges ...... Army selecting armed forces officer level........
This is worse than nepotism in Politics or Bollywood. Finally we are talking about it. Judiciary reform is 2nd most important pillar post education for overall better society.
Very good great great great information
#nepotism_in_judiciary
हम लोग criticism करते रहेगे वो परिवार कुर्सी का आनंद उठाते रहेगे
कालोजियम व्यवस्था खत्म होना चाहिए।
@@deorajsrivastava4914 nya kya doge
'कमरैडरी आफ मीडिआक्रिटी' का जीता जागता खेल हो रहा है।
हाई कोर्ट और सुप्रीम कोर्ट के प्रत्येक जजमेंट की पब्लिक स्पेस में क्वालिटेटिव समीक्षा होना जरूरी हो गया है।
राधे राधे जी।
भारत देेश में बुद्धिमता की कमी नहीं है। किसी भी क्षेत्र में भाई-भतीजा वाद की नीती को समाप्त करना बहुत ही जरुरी है। न्याय प्रणाली में तो इस प्रकार की प्रथा को समाप्त करना अति आवश्यक है। देश के सर्वोच्च न्यायाधीशों और अन्य सभी न्यायाधीशों की नियुक्ति उचित परीक्षा के माध्यम से होनी चाहिए। इस दिशा में परिर्वतन कैसे हो, केंद्र सरकार को उचित व्यवस्था को लाना होगा।
What about reservation ? In India merit has little value.
There should have an examination like UPSC types.
Then reservation will also be their for selection of judges.
There should be all India judiciary exam
Bhai judge exam se hi bante h,,,promotion hote hote upar phunchte h,,,,,,
@@chaismaFor the high court and supreme court judges there should be exams. Now they are not promoted they are selected.
@@YV-2000 thats i. E. Is promotion🤣🤣🤣
@@chaisma Lower court main, not in high court and supreme court.
Promotion is different, it has a Standard operating procedure, sometimes there are departmental exams in other organisations.
Understand the gravity of these positions, making their 'promotions' transparent and allowing it to have a SOP, will make the system more citizen friendly otherwise it'll only look as selections and not promotion.
@@YV-2000 are bat vhi h ,,bhai curruption chlta h,,vo ek hi bat bn chuki h
Great Content
AMAZING content madam
Sir kindly make video on nepotism in lower judiciary
As we all see in RJS 2024
Preliminary test - 8 questions deleted
Mains exam - no criteria for English essay
Interview - person scoring 3 marks in English essay scored 22,24 marks in interview
And how 100+ candidates are selected from judiciary background
You are 100% right.
Only 100 families are running judges not 300. We have seen this you cannot outrun this. Kiren rijuju tries to change this but fails.
At least they all had done LLB, what about our legislators bro?
@@Vasudeva777 people choose them what can we do.
@@xxxxxxxxx108 People choose what is available, not what they want. Choices are limited. If there was a bar that everyone should have basic education, that would be better.. All judges came by completing LLB, what about ministers?
@@Vasudeva777 aptly true sometimes whom people chose same chose the corruption. But despite being judges have a llb degree they choose injustice too.
@@xxxxxxxxx108 because they create no option although we know they are bad
15:00 The sarcastic advice to UPSC was wonderful 😂😂
Sir, Appointments of judges should be transparent & like other All India Services should be through UPSC only,
It's crystal clear 😧
Brilliant Eye opening...
👌 video
Good analysis
Yes, I also heard in the news that Justice Madan Lokur expressed displeasure because Justice Pradeep Nandraj Jog and another Chief Justice of a High Court were recommended for elevation to the Supreme Court but were overlooked in favor of two other nominees, including the judge who is set to become the next Chief Justice of India
Sir judiciary में backdoor से बहुत काम होता है
Thanks for this vedio sir 🙏
Collegium is biggest nepotism 😡😠😠
Nice presentation
Absolutely correct..
Ruling Govt wants Judges should favour Govt as Govt is the largest litigant.
Bhai magar yaha to cureent government kohi sbse jyada issue lgta hai isse😂
BJP government had tried to end " Collegium system. Bill was also passed in Parliament but it was rejected by Supreme Court.
In every segments of institutions and society there is always nepotism.
Parivarvaad malaiwalas good going God bless you
Congratulations.
One day we'll reach on TOP.
Good idea
Very nice presentation sir, constitutional institutions have lost their credibility, sattadhari, briman neta iske jimmedar
All derserced and aspirant people 😊should get the opportunity rather than limited families.
thank you sir
Don't forget that the Standing Advocates of the High Courts who are close to the ruling dispensation are also frequently made High Court judges,irrespective of their merit. They obviously have inclination towards the Government.
Bravo 👏 👏 👏
Very important and informative information !
Recruitment of State judicial service should be conducted by UPSC. Like wise appointment of judges of high court and Supreme Court should also be conducted through UPSC. I’m not giving reasons, lest I face contempt. If a space is created for discussion, I’ll gladly participate
Congratulation to be ammend.As per constitution judges of Supreme Court and HighCourts to be selected from bar.
Exam is best process 😮
Only these families are talented 😂😂😂😂
Yes, UPSC should also learn and adopt collegium system of SC judges selection.
I like your TANA 😅😅😅😅
Bravo 👏
Public at Large is the criteria, not the qualification but the quality of judgement delivered
It is a clear nepotism and it should be finished. The selection process should be transparent and clean. All elegible advocates should get the opportunity to be judges.
Amazing Video 😮
Yes Collegium system has so many prblms and faults but still better than NJAC.
NJAC was giving power to government,which impacts independence of judiciary
There should be All India Judicial service like civil service. At least those who study will become judges in higher positions.
@@YV-2000 This exam can be at lower level and as many states have but in higher judiciary it can't be possible.
As for higher judiciary,it demands experience and mere just passing an exam cannot become eligibility for selection.
As even in civil service,you give exam and get posted as lower level officer like and then gets promotion on the basisi of you work
@@Gaurav-wo7itu r wrong
It can be possible with 5 yr experience and transparent written exam, and no interview otherwise still nepotism will happen
EVM and Collegium
Made written rules for all appointments of judge
Nepotism is everywhere. You can broadly see it in case of other sectors like bollywood, recruitment of officers in armed forces etc.
Nepotism in DNA🤣🤣🤣
It's a family Affairs
AIJS is required
More judges from lower judiciary need to be promoted to HC and SC.
Atleast they are serving the nation without being a product of nepotism.
As of now most of them never get to set their foot even in HC.
CJI Chandrajud father was also CJI .Is ex.CJI Justice's son is likely to to be selected justice.
All India judicial service Exam like UPSC for Civil services,should be the selection process of all judges selection. If Medical superspeciality exam can take place,where is the problem?
Through exam like UPSC
Judge's may be appointed on merit basis by conducting written test.
Voting by judi cials should come for election of CJI
The proposal of NJAC is a good thing, but I think, its proposed formation should be restructured to a great extent.
National judicial. Only eminent personalities of countries from different spheres should vote and select.
So true
It's not only judiciary that needs improvements. The political system needs also reforms and improvements.
भारत का ये दुर्भाग्य है कि हम एक बार ज्ञान को उच्चतम स्थान देते थे और अब केवल परिवार वाद को स्थान देते है,ये ही भारत का अध्पतन है
तो भाई कुछ ज्ञान ले ले ओर तब पता कर की जो प्रक्रिया है वो उचित है कि नहीं इस फालतू वीडियो के चक्कर में ज्ञान मत पेल ओर तुम पड़े होते तो तुम्हे पता होता कि मुख्य न्यायाधीश की नियुक्ति क्यों ऐसे होती है और कब से होती है
Not only justice Khanna, several judges who were not CJ of any HC have been elevated.
High Court judges should be appointed through exam like IAS etc.Indian Judiciary services should be started for becoming high Court judges
This is give and take policy.
Written examination should be conducted for promotion of advocates and judges. No interview and recommendations
These judges have their image in the general public by doing so.
Amit shah ji ka beta
Rajnath ji ka beta
Prem kumar dhumal ji ka beta
Rajmata vijya raje scindia ka beta aur pota
Ram vilas ji ka ladka
There are many leaders in BJP whose son’s are either MP MLA or sitting at key positions of different wealthy institutions of country..
First Pm sahab has to clean his own house before pointing fingers towards others..
All India Judicial Services के माध्यम से Judges की नियुक्ति के लिये Exam होना चाहिए,, जिससे कि सभी उपयुक्त योग्यताधारी को समानता का अधिकार मिल सके,,, लेकिन विडंबना है कि जजों की नियुक्ति में ही संविधान में प्रदत्त मौलिक अधिकारों में से एक समानता का अधिकार से सुयोग्य लोगों को भी वंचित होना पड़ रहा है
What justice can you expect from these judges.
It is revealed that judges are appointed through nepotism as per your statistics. But head of CBI, NIA, Election Commission Members etc. are not appointed by collegium like institution. But in spite of that CBI, NIA, Election Commission etc. are also not working impartially. It means that unbiased personality are rare. This the summary.
Ranganath mishra is not father of Deepak mishra. But , From same family.
Similar Nepotism is present in corporate and IT companies too
You must have to visit the high courts in india and watch the argument and practice of this family related advocate and others advocate practice and argument then you will knowhow they elevated or appointed as a justice.
An unconstitutional collegium had declared a constitutional NJAC unconstitutional. Speaks volumes for the state of law and order, isn't it?
Least interested in the judiciary, no trust as well. Out and out compromised. Quitting, waste of time.
Judiciary reform is much delayed and it needs immediate action by govt.
really
Who are judges
Are they rulers or servants who they are....???
This is not only about judges appointment judiciary me clerk se lekr chokidar tk sabhi ke appointment ek close door ke andr ho reh
No transparency...
Oooooooooooooiiiiii🎉🎉
कोलेजियम सिस्टम ख़त्म होने चाहिए
Ssayad isi karan HC/SC ke verdict nyayke. Mutabik nahi ho raha jiske chalte NKACka maang utha hai.
Indian judiciary system having full nepotism and it can be seen in their decision which is always favour ruling party.
Many Justices are being selected on the basis of their relatives. For fair selection UPSC can conduct exam.
Jai Sanvidhan
Nepotism is undoubtedly bad. Can't be protected.
But is the fact that, someone's family member is sitting as a judge, merely sufficient to disqualify him from becoming judge though he is actually deserving??
Why is the government not creating Indian Judicial Service
🙏🙏🙏
Yehi chalta rahega..
But how a candidate who got selected through judical services is product of nepotism...i mean if my father is in army ...and i aslo get selected in army through CDS exam....should this be called nepotism?.....did DYC had the option to nominate some else as CJI...as the practice goes senior most judge should be appointed..so he did that only right?.. correct me if i am wrong
Judiciary
As per Article 312 of the Constitution of India All India Judicial Service