@@Deweygreen1 People are always forgotten over time, I don't worry too much though, because it would be unfair to those forgotten to try to remember as many people as possible.
This song is so sad but beautiful both the title and the lyrics really spoke to me, especially since it raised the question of whether or not Twilight will outlive her friends...but even if she did, Twilight would feel alone most of the time, but deep down she's knows that her friends are always with her not by her side but in her heart, and plus she still has so many wonderful memories of them, and as long as Twilight cherishes those memories she'll never truly be alone.
@@steel-dragon4783 oh yeah, I know the feeling, if you want I can link you to a site where you can download It but it is in portuguese, and has portuguese subtitles :p
Ah yes! Twilight melancholy always brings out the best in you! Chant of Immortality, Lost, Stay, Thought I´d let you know, Hoping, Bound with time, this You truly make the best Twilight songs in the fandom!
As soon as the lyrics started, I guessed the subject matter. Then I paid attention to the picture. And realized, I was right. And I was mad. And sad. And wrestled with whether or not I was emotionally capable to make it all the way through the song. I know the dark side of immortality. And this is why I would never want it. This song is beautiful. Thank you.
It's hard to deal the death of a person you know for a long time either a friend, loved one, a pet or a family relative. They are gone but... they are not forgotten
After hearing that guitar part at the start, and before reading the description, I wanted to comment "very Dire Straits there with that guitar part!", and then I read the description, and this is actually meant as a ponification of Dire Straits' "Brothers In Arms", so no wonder that sounded so similar!! When I read that in the description I applauded IRL because I was so happy. A Dire Straits ponification was the thing I didn't know I needed. So awesome with the perfect tone of the guitar like in the original, and your vocals that do sound more like Mark Knopfler's for this one, but that may also just be my mind haha. It definitely still has your signature, and this ponification is awesome. Along the quotes at the start, very emotional too. We know that Twilight is not outliving her friends, but such alternate fan takes are always appreciated. Love what you did, spreading the love for gold bands of old to newer generations too, that's so awesome! Now I wish for Sultans of Swing and Money For Nothing ponifications hehe :D
This video already has 121 likes (including mine) even before it is gonna premiere. It shows how supportive the brony fandom really is. Can't wait for your new song 4everfreebrony!
I don’t think I’ve cried this fast before listening to one of your songs. Either it’s the lyrics or just the cover art in this but it just makes me tear up for some reason. And that’s amazing.
Twilight: Look over the great valley. Look over to the great kingdom. Years went by in a flash. One minute you here, the next, you're gone. The world we knew will never come back. So may you 5 rest in peace. May you 5 go to the great unknown world above. I'm sorry, I won't be joining you anytime soon. I have to stay here. To watch over this kingdom. Don't worry. I'll keep this land safe in your absence. I won't forget you. Even tho you're gone. You'll always be here, in my heart. So rest. You all earned it. Goodbye, my friends up above. Until we meet again.
Amazing release party! You did an awesome job with this heart-felt parody. The addition of the qoetes are amazing, especially during a hard time like our current circumstances.
This was such a touching and catchy song, but mostly touching... I still don't like the fact that Twilight grew as tall as Celestia, she was cute the way she was.
I'm late to this but I'm glad someone mentioned it. I think it would've been better if they gave her a unique design and didn't just make her a re-color of celestia.
mlp was and sill is apart of my childhood it has taught me so many thing on friendship and so much more im sad it had end but to every end there is a new beging and i hope for generations to come it helps other find friendship and belonging in this world like it has done for me and many others that has watched this show
i heard the beginning, and was like "i heard this before havent i?" then i heard the first lyrics and just knew it was dire straights brothers in arms, and the description confirmed everything. just cool dude.
The first time I heard this piece I cried, just plain broke down and cried. Out of all the songs I've heard few have ever had the power to do that to me. This song is right up there with Hoping and Stay for making me cry like a little child. I commend you 4everfreebrony for making such a wonderful piece that I can't listen to without tearing up. :, ) /)
Man, this song hits hard. Last time, I felt like this was at my father's funeral, and it still feels strange and scary knowing that all things come to an end. But at least I have these songs and fond memories to keep me going despite knowing that all things shall return to dust.
I see so many comments about how many people cried watching this, but my eyes don't even get a little wet. Maybe I've cried so much that I've become numb to sadness? I can't help but feel like something's wrong... I love this song. Maybe I don't cry when I listen to it, but it certainly gives me a heavy heart. Amazing job 4everfree
I just woken up and i see this in my recommendations so i took some time to just prep myself to not cry....sadly i failed tho i have no regrets in crying on this tho it made me a bit nostalgic when i first joined this fandom and when the song ended i remembered the ending to the show itself n it really made me cry a lot TwT
It feels like a worryingly relevant spin on current events but so with a spin on "While my Guitar gently weeps". It's filled with heart and pain, while longing for something long past . I love it. A+ 4everfreebrony. Top Quality.
Wow... This flat out made me cry, won't lie. Felt something on my face and reached up to figure it out since I hadn't noticed it.. Crazy beautiful! And heartbreaking
This is so heart wrenching to see twi all by herself ... worst part is it kind of is proven in the last episode where the rest of the mane 5 are older and shes just taller and slightly aged , that she is either immortal or just has a much bigger life span.. fantastic job on this song btw.
I have cried to many of 4everfreebronies songs such as chant of immortality, thought I’d let you know and this one made cry on first listen to it. He is such a great song writer.
Thank you so much, it's been ages I've been listening to your music and listening this cristalised version after so many years of practice, I hope you'll keep the magic forever, your music is the definition of immortality ❤️
This song hits hard, had tears streaming down my face. Almost like I can envision how Twilight would feel at the very moment in the picture, a hollow and hopeless feeling. I love this song, and it seems night after night I keep coming back to it. My soul aches when I hear this song in a way I can't describe. Honestly, I relate this song to MLP: FiM ending. Good stuff 4everfreebrony . I can't seem to find a single song by you that I don't adore.
I loved this song from the first time I heard it, even if it made me cry. Just this past week I played it in the car during my great grandmothers funeral procession... it made my mom cry. In an odd way... I like how sad it makes me feel.
Good song, hits pretty hard home for me. Works well for the show and as for someone who has lost a lot of family and friends. Love your songs happy and sad in theme, they're of such a great quality.
This song touched me so much that I remembered an old breakup with my childhood friends. I cried as much as possible, I don't know how to describe my words, I'm waiting for the instrumental version!!
I always loved this song. Having it covered here evokes the same feelings of sorrow and cimfort the source material does. The only thing to make it perfect would be to have Mark Knofler playing the gutair.
No matter how many times the show staff says that Twilight will not outlive her friends we ain't buying it. After the time skip she and Spike are the only ones who do not look middle-aged. Although she grew taller she definitely isn't aging like a normal pony would and I'm assuming after she grew that tall her aging process has completely stopped. The staff are denying the obvious not to bring people (mainly their child audience) heartbreak. So what I'm truing to say is... this and many other songs with the same premise are canon, fight me.
Pretty much... same with them not outright wanting to make Fluttershy and Discord a couple and all that. They said they don't really want to push relationships in MLP. I'm surprised they even let Pinkie Pie have a child in the last episode lol
@@CuteAnimeGirl Yeah, but Futtercord wasn't denied by the staff and I think someone on twitter has actually stated Fluttershy has a crush on discord (or was it the other way around?).
@@camthefemalefont9801 Dragons can go for as long as 1500+ years. Celestia ruled for about 1111+ a couple years, so he's be around for all of Twilight's rule if she goes for as long as Celestia
@@camthefemalefont9801 Cam The Female Font well we know hat bu S8 that’s Celestia has been ruling for 1111 years. And in Flash Magnus’s legend we see dragon lord torch already a fully grown adult dragon, and that was when Celestia was just a teen. We know that Torch probably hadn’t grown from dragon greed since he can talk and has enough sense to not only rule but to follow the rules to give up p his throne. So with all that said, if Spike can live for as long as torch he can probably go for as long as Twilight rules. Depending if she does for as long as Celestia.
"Everybody dies twice; once when life ceases and again the last time someone ever remembers you."
That's something I always feared and know it will happen to even the greatest so I worry how long untill I to will have been forgoten
@@Deweygreen1 People are always forgotten over time, I don't worry too much though, because it would be unfair to those forgotten to try to remember as many people as possible.
"If I never have to die, am I alive at all?"
~Aviators
Thought it was fitting here.
I loved Ashes when it came out. ^^
@@4everfreebrony He has many songs that I enjoy, and others i like more. But as far as my feeling upon release, definately one of the more memorable.
Never thaught I'd see the day
Literally used that same line to describe my sad Twilight song - it works so well eh?
Ashes! I love that song!
"We'll never return to
... The world, the way it was"
This song is worryingly relevant.
Agreed
I about cried when I heard that line... feels way too relevant to today.
This song is so sad but beautiful both the title and the lyrics really spoke to me, especially since it raised the question of whether or not Twilight will outlive her friends...but even if she did, Twilight would feel alone most of the time, but deep down she's knows that her friends are always with her not by her side but in her heart, and plus she still has so many wonderful memories of them, and as long as Twilight cherishes those memories she'll never truly be alone.
That's pretty much what the songs talks about, but even so i agree.
I couldn't said it better myself.
And the finale definitely hinted at the possibility.
I'll have to listen to this when falling all the way down in snakes and ladders
You know what, same.
Wastelanders never Forget, Because Friendship, Friendship Never Changes.
FiM is never gonna go, cause it’s always here all the time.
Friendship is always magic.
@Dot Warner Good to see people following its ways
@Dot Warner :3
Friendship is manly
@@Deweygreen1 No pls
Bro I just finished watching season 9 yesterday, and then this, I have the big sad now, poor twilight
is that a canon? maybe i should watch 5-9 seasons now
@@hurh54 well not 100% cannon at least not in an explicit way, won't say more cuase spoilers but you should watch it indeed.
I cant get season 9 for some reason it sucks cuz i dont wana finish season 8 untill i can watch s9 soo im dead in the water
@@steel-dragon4783 oh yeah, I know the feeling, if you want I can link you to a site where you can download It but it is in portuguese, and has portuguese subtitles :p
@@steel-dragon4783 I have a few links if you want ;)
Ah yes! Twilight melancholy always brings out the best in you!
Chant of Immortality, Lost, Stay, Thought I´d let you know, Hoping, Bound with time, this
You truly make the best Twilight songs in the fandom!
As soon as the lyrics started, I guessed the subject matter. Then I paid attention to the picture. And realized, I was right. And I was mad. And sad. And wrestled with whether or not I was emotionally capable to make it all the way through the song. I know the dark side of immortality. And this is why I would never want it. This song is beautiful. Thank you.
It's hard to deal the death of a person you know for a long time either a friend, loved one, a pet or a family relative. They are gone but... they are not forgotten
After hearing that guitar part at the start, and before reading the description, I wanted to comment "very Dire Straits there with that guitar part!", and then I read the description, and this is actually meant as a ponification of Dire Straits' "Brothers In Arms", so no wonder that sounded so similar!! When I read that in the description I applauded IRL because I was so happy. A Dire Straits ponification was the thing I didn't know I needed. So awesome with the perfect tone of the guitar like in the original, and your vocals that do sound more like Mark Knopfler's for this one, but that may also just be my mind haha. It definitely still has your signature, and this ponification is awesome. Along the quotes at the start, very emotional too. We know that Twilight is not outliving her friends, but such alternate fan takes are always appreciated. Love what you did, spreading the love for gold bands of old to newer generations too, that's so awesome! Now I wish for Sultans of Swing and Money For Nothing ponifications hehe :D
She probably will out live her friends, season nine :/
This video already has 121 likes (including mine) even before it is gonna premiere. It shows how supportive the brony fandom really is. Can't wait for your new song 4everfreebrony!
If you not cry hearing this song you can´t have a feeling heart ...
I don’t think I’ve cried this fast before listening to one of your songs. Either it’s the lyrics or just the cover art in this but it just makes me tear up for some reason. And that’s amazing.
Me: [reads opening quotes]
Me: [rereads title]
Me: "Oh, I know where this is going. Prepare to cry, eyes, prepare to cry."
the moon need to hear it now
Couldn't agree more.
Twilight: Look over the great valley. Look over to the great kingdom. Years went by in a flash. One minute you here, the next, you're gone. The world we knew will never come back. So may you 5 rest in peace. May you 5 go to the great unknown world above. I'm sorry, I won't be joining you anytime soon. I have to stay here. To watch over this kingdom. Don't worry. I'll keep this land safe in your absence. I won't forget you. Even tho you're gone. You'll always be here, in my heart. So rest. You all earned it. Goodbye, my friends up above. Until we meet again.
How it's beautiful and sad at the same time! :(
Amazing release party! You did an awesome job with this heart-felt parody. The addition of the qoetes are amazing, especially during a hard time like our current circumstances.
This was such a touching and catchy song, but mostly touching...
I still don't like the fact that Twilight grew as tall as Celestia, she was cute the way she was.
Tall twilight is a cursed horse
@@WearyKirin I wouldn't say it that way but OK.
@@theunidentifiedchangeling9451 I get why they did it, but tiny twi was adorable.
I'm late to this but I'm glad someone mentioned it. I think it would've been better if they gave her a unique design and didn't just make her a re-color of celestia.
@@Doc903 Agreed dearly
mlp was and sill is apart of my childhood it has taught me so many thing on friendship and so much more im sad it had end but to every end there is a new beging and i hope for generations to come it helps other find friendship and belonging in this world like it has done for me and many others that has watched this show
This song helps me remember my friends and father who have passed away recently. Thank you for the beautiful song.
Well now we know that she did return to her friends up above.
Man, this is still the only song that can bring me to tears. I loved this back in April and still do now. Well done! ^~^
i heard the beginning, and was like "i heard this before havent i?" then i heard the first lyrics and just knew it was dire straights brothers in arms, and the description confirmed everything.
just cool dude.
Too beautiful, too, too beautiful.
I could cure Australia of drought with the amount of tears I've shed.
my favourite music ever Brothers in arms...ponified, THANK YOU.
Im already cryng 😭
The first time I heard this piece I cried, just plain broke down and cried. Out of all the songs I've heard few have ever had the power to do that to me. This song is right up there with Hoping and Stay for making me cry like a little child. I commend you 4everfreebrony for making such a wonderful piece that I can't listen to without tearing up. :, ) /)
Man, this song hits hard. Last time, I felt like this was at my father's funeral, and it still feels strange and scary knowing that all things come to an end. But at least I have these songs and fond memories to keep me going despite knowing that all things shall return to dust.
those piano chords are musical honey
I see so many comments about how many people cried watching this, but my eyes don't even get a little wet. Maybe I've cried so much that I've become numb to sadness? I can't help but feel like something's wrong...
I love this song. Maybe I don't cry when I listen to it, but it certainly gives me a heavy heart. Amazing job 4everfree
I just woke up and I remembered about the album release, but when I got here I was 42 minutes late.
But hey, its still here to listen to.
I just woken up and i see this in my recommendations so i took some time to just prep myself to not cry....sadly i failed tho i have no regrets in crying on this tho it made me a bit nostalgic when i first joined this fandom and when the song ended i remembered the ending to the show itself n it really made me cry a lot TwT
It makes me feel cry
aaaah, i want to listen to this forever! so deep, so sad, i love all your work 4everfree!
only you could capture the true depth of Twilight's sorrow in this scenario.
Extremely emotional song, I love it
It feels like a worryingly relevant spin on current events but so with a spin on "While my Guitar gently weeps". It's filled with heart and pain, while longing for something long past .
I love it. A+ 4everfreebrony. Top Quality.
Too many immortal Twi songs for me not to cry.
i have no clue why but the inhales are super relaxing and i love it
This is something absolutely heavy and beautiful... I really like it!
Oh we caint wait for this
Wow... This flat out made me cry, won't lie. Felt something on my face and reached up to figure it out since I hadn't noticed it.. Crazy beautiful! And heartbreaking
I immediately got the Dire Straits vibes. Amazing work, as always. You're an inspiration
This is so heart wrenching to see twi all by herself ... worst part is it kind of is proven in the last episode where the rest of the mane 5 are older and shes just taller and slightly aged , that she is either immortal or just has a much bigger life span.. fantastic job on this song btw.
that lyrics god i have goosebumps
4 years later, still a great experience
I have cried to many of 4everfreebronies songs such as chant of immortality, thought I’d let you know and this one made cry on first listen to it. He is such a great song writer.
what an absolute banger of a song. those feels should stay inside and not out of my eyes you know.
Thank you so much, it's been ages I've been listening to your music and listening this cristalised version after so many years of practice, I hope you'll keep the magic forever, your music is the definition of immortality ❤️
Seriously beautiful and so incredibly touching
And as you said... here we are again.
I just noticed the headstones next to Twilight. How dare you bring these feelings upon me, 4everfree.
How dare you.
Oh man this one hits hard, tears are welling up in my eyes gosh darn it.
gj my man.
Premieres in 41 hours... sounds legit.
I love when you do this type of songs! You are the most inspiring person! Thanks!
This song hits hard, had tears streaming down my face. Almost like I can envision how Twilight would feel at the very moment in the picture, a hollow and hopeless feeling. I love this song, and it seems night after night I keep coming back to it. My soul aches when I hear this song in a way I can't describe. Honestly, I relate this song to MLP: FiM ending. Good stuff 4everfreebrony . I can't seem to find a single song by you that I don't adore.
Oh my no...This is so saddening, yet...so beautiful at the same time. 😢💔
Thank you for such an amazing and touching song 4everfreebrony
i saw the bg and i thought oh cool a new wallpaper
then i saw the graves and i started screaming
I loved this song from the first time I heard it, even if it made me cry. Just this past week I played it in the car during my great grandmothers funeral procession... it made my mom cry. In an odd way... I like how sad it makes me feel.
Fantastic concept
The lyrics almost feel like her train of thought and we for better or worse get to be the fly on the wall. Sad somber Thanks 4EF
Good song, hits pretty hard home for me. Works well for the show and as for someone who has lost a lot of family and friends. Love your songs happy and sad in theme, they're of such a great quality.
Had me tearing up. Beautiful and rocks
This is genuinely really beautiful
Oh... my vision is clouded... Are these tears in my eyes? 😢
This song touched me so much that I remembered an old breakup with my childhood friends. I cried as much as possible, I don't know how to describe my words, I'm waiting for the instrumental version!!
Beautiful song🥺❤️
Thank you, 4evers, for your songs
Ahora que si está muy buena la canción 😎🤘 ¡Eres el mejor!
I have been touched very hard by this, as I can relate somehow... Very amazing song dude :')
/)
brothers in arms by dire straits. but by 4everfreebrony. didn't know I needed this. now I do.
Dang it. You made me sad. Now I gotta hug my plushie for comfort.
A great job.
That was beautiful and heartfelt
This started and im already starting to cry
Yes im in full tears this is the most beautiful song I heard
Why do you have to hit so hard.
After a song like this, I have to check that album O_O
When the time comes I will finally have all the boys with me up above
I always loved this song. Having it covered here evokes the same feelings of sorrow and cimfort the source material does. The only thing to make it perfect would be to have Mark Knofler playing the gutair.
Twilight has been indulging in the royal reserve of 'memberberry wine.
What a beautiful and sad song... I love it! ❤️❤️
Dire Straits is one of my favorite bands. What a nice tribute
The only thing that could possibly make this sadder would be it Pinkie's balloons were deflated.
Beautiful
This song is rilly nice👍
Liked & saved immediately.
No matter how many times the show staff says that Twilight will not outlive her friends we ain't buying it. After the time skip she and Spike are the only ones who do not look middle-aged. Although she grew taller she definitely isn't aging like a normal pony would and I'm assuming after she grew that tall her aging process has completely stopped. The staff are denying the obvious not to bring people (mainly their child audience) heartbreak. So what I'm truing to say is... this and many other songs with the same premise are canon, fight me.
Pretty much... same with them not outright wanting to make Fluttershy and Discord a couple and all that. They said they don't really want to push relationships in MLP. I'm surprised they even let Pinkie Pie have a child in the last episode lol
@@CuteAnimeGirl Yeah, but Futtercord wasn't denied by the staff and I think someone on twitter has actually stated Fluttershy has a crush on discord (or was it the other way around?).
This cover is pretty cool.
I am honestly scared to die .
I must be completely heartless. This song only made me cry the third or fourth time I listened to it.
Love it absolutely Love it❤
Ок, жрем стекло. Это шикарная и очень трогательная песня, которая довела меня до слез.
How do you manage to always make me cry?
It would be a fate worse than death to never be able to die. Especially if your friends aren't immortal as well.
I don't know if anybody mentioned this already but this song is pretty much the opposite energy of Dr. Facillier singing 'Friends on the Other Side'.
Welp, time to cry again
Man this song was so good. Don’t be sad Twilight, you’ll always have Spike
I don't think she'll even have him in the future. I'm pretty sure dragons aren't immortal
@@camthefemalefont9801 Dragons can go for as long as 1500+ years. Celestia ruled for about 1111+ a couple years, so he's be around for all of Twilight's rule if she goes for as long as Celestia
@@spoonlolol2 Can I ask what source you found your information from?
@@camthefemalefont9801 Cam The Female Font well we know hat bu S8 that’s Celestia has been ruling for 1111 years. And in Flash Magnus’s legend we see dragon lord torch already a fully grown adult dragon, and that was when Celestia was just a teen. We know that Torch probably hadn’t grown from dragon greed since he can talk and has enough sense to not only rule but to follow the rules to give up p his throne. So with all that said, if Spike can live for as long as torch he can probably go for as long as Twilight rules. Depending if she does for as long as Celestia.
@@spoonlolol2 Ah. I stand corrected. Thanks for the clarification
0:27 I am really curious about the story! 🤔