'DELUSIONAL!': Jon Stewart SHREDS Netanyahu | The Kyle Kulinski Show
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 ก.พ. 2024
- Support The Show On Patreon!:
/ seculartalk
Subscribe to Krystal Kyle & Friends On Substack!:
krystalkyleandfriends.substac...
Follow Kyle on Twitter:
/ kylekulinski
"The first time I ever really listened to Kyle Kulinski’s show was in the back of a cab last summer. The driver had his phone hooked up through the stereo and was pumping out an episode through the car speakers - loudly, as if looking to convert a captive audience.
“Do you like Kyle Kulinski?”
The driver, Ahmed, was a recent immigrant and apparently a die-hard fan of Secular Talk, the political talk show that Kulinski broadcasts on TH-cam. I told him, yes, in fact. I do like Kulinski, had come across his show several years ago, and, all things considered, he seemed pretty good.
“He understands what we’re up against,” Ahmed said. “Like Bernie.”
But I was surprised to hear Kulinski’s name mentioned in the same breath as Bernie Sanders, particularly with such adoration. Because what I did remember about Kulinski’s show struck me as mostly capital-P “progressive” takes on the news - the left wing of the Netroots crowd more than the democratic socialism Sanders has popularized.
It’s an impression that wasn’t entirely incorrect.
“I have no time for philosophical, airy bullshit,” Kulinski tells me from his home in Westchester, New York. “I don’t want to hear about Lenin. I don’t want to hear about Marx. I just want a super plainspoken, straightforward agenda with a straightforward way of selling it.”
With over 800,000 subscribers and nearly 670 million total views on TH-cam, selling a progressive agenda is clearly something Kulinski knows how to do - even Democracy Now, the long-standing flagship of progressive media, cannot match his reach on the platform. Chapo Trap House can certainly boast a wildly devoted fan base (and a not insignificant degree of media influence), but their audience is roughly half the size of Kulinski’s.
While Secular Talk might be more likely to be looped in with the progressive networks around Air America and Pacifica alums like Sam Seder than the more resolutely socialist world, Kulinski’s fiery rhetoric, razor-sharp class instincts, and knack for withering takedowns sets him apart from his peers. Judging by his rhetoric alone, he’s closer to a Eugene Debs than a Chris Hayes.
But unlike Hayes, Amy Goodman, or his friend Cenk Uygur of The Young Turks - who began airing Secular Talk on his web network seven years ago - the thirty-two-year-old Kulinski is virtually invisible in the mainstream media. Despite his enormous fan base, his show has never once been mentioned in the obligatory trend pieces on “the Millennial Left” pumped out by the prestige media. Nor has Kulinski’s name ever popped up at all in the New York Times, Vox, the New Yorker, New York Magazine, or the Washington Post, despite his leading role in cofounding Justice Democrats, the organization widely credited with sweeping Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the rest of “the Squad” to power.
Just last week, his Wikipedia page was deleted. The reason? “There is very simply no [reliable source] coverage of this person,” according to one moderator. In new media, he’s king - the Sean Hannity of the Berniecrat left. In old media, he’s nobody.
I suspect there are a few reasons for that. There is nothing “cool” about Kulinski’s show. (As a friend put it, “‘Welcome to Secular Talk’ sounds like something you’d hear on Egyptian radio.”) His no-nonsense social-democratic politics won’t get him much cred with the Full Communism crowd. He records his show not in Brooklyn or Los Angeles, but in a studio he built himself in his modest Westchester home. His hair is too groomed and his taste in clothes too preppy to qualify as “Dirtbag Left.” Nor has he ever attended an n+1 release party. “Not only have I not attended one,” he says, “I have no idea what that means.”
And yet he’s astonishingly plugged-in for a young man in the suburbs. Wondering how Sanders ended up on the Joe Rogan Experience? Kulinski, a frequent guest on Rogan’s wildly popular show, introduced them. “You make the most sense to me,” Rogan told Kulinski on a recent episode. “You’re a normal person.”
Much like Sanders himself, Kulinski’s show has a massive audience that just doesn’t compute with our media’s understanding of “what the kids want” or even “what the left-wing kids want.”
It’s probably for the best - the very woke and very WASP-ish decorum haunting much of the media world is nowhere to be found in Secular Talk. “Corporate Democrats over-focus on identity as a trick to divert you from the issues that unite us all - class issues,” he said on a recent episode.
Read More Here!:
jacobinmag.com/2020/03/kyle-k...
#KyleKulinski #SecularTalk #news #politics #youtube #biden #economics #left #progressive #viral
Saying Netnyahu isn't a war criminal is like calling the IDF the most moral military.
Jesus christ how do you manage to be everywhere all at once
@@bobbysmith9298lts a bot
Moral Military - now that's an oxymoron. Bot or not.
@@botanicalitus4194It's a strange bot lol
lol. But which military is the most moral in your opinion?
I wish John also did a jab at how the US vetoed the UN peace deal 4 times in a row
Yeah, honestly he could’ve hit way harder on Israel with this segment.
The UN is antisemitic
Steward is too much "democrat loyal" to really go all "George Carlin" in your face
Maybe you should both apply to become writers🙄😆
@@jvs333lol Jon has fought the dems in NY on behalf of 9/11 veterans… you call that “democrat loyal”?
Somethings aren’t left and right, it’s moral and immoral, Jon very much does and say what he thinks is moral. He doesn’t have to dramatize every aspect just enough to get the point across to those who are still salvageable
War crimes ??? How about the last 76 YEARS of war crimes???
Who's war crimes though the Israeli or the Palestinian ones? They both aren't exactly jumping for peace with each other
@adia5752 Well only one country have pillaged the other's territory for about 70 years give or take. I don't say that Palestinians are innocent, but in comparison they have the right to fight their occupiers where as the other have no right to maintain the occupation, that is if international laws have any legitimacy. Annexing territory and pillaging, razing and stealing civilians homes also falls within this framework. I would feel very different about things if these people would had facilitated the two-state solution instead of building settlements undermining the whole peace process.
The most crucial aspect of everything is really our support(the Wests) for the whole thing since it undermines everything we have built since WW2... even if we don't expect countries like for example China and Russia to respect international laws, they have no reason to do so if some countries can act as they please without sanctions etc. legal impunity ain't a good thing for anyone of us, all it really benefits is one little upstart nation.
Do you consider kidnapping children from their homes, holding babies hostage acceptable forms of resistance? If that sentiment were to become normal, the world would plunge into darkness, lsrael's response to stopping that is necessary @@magnuscarlsson9969
@@bb_arcadia5752One side has the backing of the most powerful military-industrial complex on the planet. The other side is desperately trying to survive, If you don't wanna be on the wrong side of history then stop siding with the oppressors. And yes, just because we know we have to say it because you idiots can't tell the difference between a terrorist organization and innocent civilians, the oppressors also include hamas
@@bb_arcadia5752What a dishonest scumbag...
Greetings from Ireland .. BDS apartheid Israel .. Free Palestine!
Irish people always out here opposing authoritarian regimes 🙌
Salute also To Ireland as the only (?) European Country that never had Slave colonies elsewhere!!
@lbamusic The Irish were the slaves for a time unfortunately
Salute 🫡 to Ireland 🇮🇪 ❤️🇵🇸 much love
Including my first Irish ancestor in America. Sent to Barbados as a slave by Cromwell.
Jon Stewart hasnt changed at all. The rest of the media has been dragged to the right in the 9 years that hes been gone. Him coming back shows it, and its stark.
The Media leans Right! 🤔😆
@@mr.saturn7833 the whole country does. There is no left in America aside from some angry kids on the Internet.
@@mr.saturn7833 They do.
pretending to care about black people or women sometimes doesn't change that.
they tackle most worldly matters from a right wing perspective.
@@mr.saturn7833Yep. They are totally pro war and pro corporate. Do you listen to Kyle or are you here to troll?
@@Thezuule1 Sure. I mean, aside from a slight majority of the Democratic party voters, about a third of independents, and a handful of disenfranchised former republicans that actually want workers rights.
So ya know, just a few dozen million people, outnumbering MAGA several times over.
I hope Jon talks about Aaron Bushnell and the mainstream media’s shameful misreporting/underreporting of why he self-immolated on next Monday’s show.
Yes!! It’s scandalous how invisible this young man’s death still is - a shocking and heartbreaking self-immolation as a cry for the end of genocide. And mainstream media? Crickets. 😡😡😡
I only heard about it by complete mistake, 2 days after. And I check the news daily.
Yep we are 100% complicit!
You're a terrible person, how dare you.
This is not US first genocide, many took place before and no question many will take place after this as well! US is a PRO War Criminal 🙁free Palestine
@@JassZoigelYou speaking to jakejake or Jon? No matter, you're wrong on both counts.
@@JassZoigel So calling out a country that supplies arms which ----------- 35000 civilians makes HIM terrible? How dare YOU?
If you disagree you either
A don't think he's complicit
B don't think the Palestine war is bad
How can American government be serious about two state solution when they see what is happening and don’t call for a ceasefire.
I agree ...the rage is mounting and I am not even Palestinian
Israel is the boss here! American wanted a two state solution but Israel is not buying it. The US need to stop talking and take action including taking away all aid, stop backing Israel war crimes and get rid of Satanyahoo.
The American government is in for a reckoning with its people
Who said they are interested in two state solution? They probably meant they would ask Israel and 'work' with Israel for a two state solution, and if they reject..well guess what? "Israel is a sovereign country" and "we can't force anyone"...BS excuses
@@muhammadkutty8754 Actually - we (the U.S.) can't force Israel to do anything. BUT - we sure could stop sending Israel millions!!! 😮
"If you have 100 dissidents, and you destroy them all, you are then left with 1000 dissidents"
I'm not sure if Yahoo is delusional or just a bloodthirsty bastard who likes having other people killed by other people.
How they do it to First Nation American tribes?
Bullshit. They're all made to hate.
@@bwelc0076I'm going to move into your house and see how long it takes before you start having a problem with it
@@bwelc0076Stop your Israelis propaganda BS!
"There'v been October 7th every day since October 7th on the palestinians side"
what a profound thing to say.❤
1/5th oct 7th per day
Profound, maybe. Mathematically accurate, no. Also known as a fabrication or hyperbole. Israel has killed 39000 Palestinians (give or take) in ~144 days. That's ~200 dead per day or 1/6 of Oct 7th per day.
So, tragedy upon tragedy but not Oct 7-level tragedy upon Oct 7-level tragedy. It does add up to about 25 or so Oct 7ths altogether though.
And before that date.
@@MrBrock314 Mathematical accuracy is important. But it is never a good idea to compare atrocities. They are all wrong. If you factor in that most of the casualties on one side are women and children, water & food blockade for ~144 days, >70% of civilian structures destroyed (including most homes, and all hospitals, schools, and places of worship), and soldiers posting videos of themselves looting or using civilian dwellings, you enter war crime territory. Under international law, foreign military occupation forces are held to a higher standard than militants from their occupied subjects. Starving civilians, carpet bombing them, collectively punishing them, releasing government statements encouraging their forced displacement or dehumanizing them (e.g., calling them human animals) are all actions that the international community criminalized after the world wars and the era of European colonialism. We're going back in time if we try to justify war crimes against an occupied population at that scale. And as Americans, we should never finance war crimes committed at this scale by a foreign state even if they are allies.
Nonsense, Oct 7th was intentional, the response is not.
The irony is Nutanyahu is trying to get rid Hamas but he's the only person that's going to be gone. Sooner rather than later.
He doesn't care about Hamas. He wants to be in power forever and be a hero
Reaping what he sowed by helping fund Hamas in the first place. Terrible that innocents on both sides are paying the price for zionist hatred
I firmly believe this military surge was just a way to hold power in a time of manufactured crisis. Basically the George Bush Iraq War setting.
75 years of Oct 7s
57 - Israel and Palestine weren't at war (nor occupation) during 1948-1967. Gaza for example was in Egypt's control during that time so Israel certainly wasn't bombing them as they had a truce.
Nakba 1947-48 thousands killed almost a million ethnically cleansed from there land
21% of Israeli population is Arab, they serve on the Knesset, the Supreme Court and the IDF. Show me the comparable in the region. 5 Arab nations declared war on the new state of Israel in 1948, again in 1956, 1967 and 1972. Hamas won an election in Gaza, then threw its Fatah opposition off rooftops in Gaza City. There is no "other side" to negotiate with. Free the hostage, #freeiran.
@@garydixon4290 No, a quarter of million Arabs stayed in the new state of Israel by choice, now number 1.8 million, 21% of the population, serve on the Knesset, the Supreme Court and in the IDF. A million Jews were "ethnically cleansed" from Egypt, North Africa, Iraq and Iran, some coming to the new State. The new state was attacked by 5 Arab countries, the US had banned arms sales to the new State of Israel, and even in 1967 it was the French Mirage Jet which won the war for Israel, not US arms. So much Taqiyya.
Illegal occupation however you slice it.
I’m glad Jon is back
Me three and not me too😂😂
Jon's country needs his leadership.
“Jon’s Country?” How much of America has Jon given back to the First Peoples? How much of America have YOU given back to them?
Anyone living in the U.S. who isn’t of significant Native American lineage who’s screaming about Jews being colonizers of Israel are raging hypocrites and have no comprehension of irony.
He is a media hero
John needs John Fetterman?
Do you seriously think Israel would allow a united Arab army within its borders for any reason? There are no good faith actors on either side so all I see is continued war and death for the foreseeable future. I wish it was not so.
No one has the better ability to put a spotlight on the obvious like Jon Stewart. Pure genius political satire, worthy of a mike drop.
Good to see John Stewart back and willing to say the things others are terrified to say on US TV. From London UK
"terrified", we have entire networks devoted to what he is saying, and the entire city of Dearborn, MI chanting it out. Jurt more Taqiyya.
@@nuqwestr They merely touch the surface, but as a “comedian” he can get away with a lot more under the guise of satire. For many people he used to be their main source for news. Its also why he left Apple TV because there were certain topics that were off limit and he wasn’t willing to do that.
Mans name is Jon.
I died when Jon asked the U.N. "WHY THE F*** DO YOU STILL HAVE A BUILDING??" All talk, little action on just about anything. 😅
True.
As a New Yorker I felt that too
True. Classic Jon 😀
They were helpful in getting George W. Bush’s country into Iraq based on a total lie.
The veto on the UN Security Council is the real problem.
Netanyahu's comment that they will be slowing down in a few weeks, reminds me of when he and the U.S. were telling the public that they would be entering a new phase with less bombings as they were being brought up on Jen-O-Side charges at the ICJ.
No "jen-o-cide", looked for that in Tigray, Ethiopia, sponsored by Turkey, Iran and the UAE.
@@nuqwestr Have you looked in SA, Congo, Iraq, Yemen, Ireland, America, etc.? I can give you more.
@@RyuLongRHOG I'd call that a Marxist dialectical inversion. Why do so many from those countries seek citizenship in America? Nigerians perform better here in the US than immigrant Asians. Your metric is not factual, but political correct within the framework of a political dogma. The population of Gaza has increased dramatically since 1948. That's a funny genocide. In Tigray, Ethiopia, there's actual death from malnutrition, that's not occuring in Gaza. Again, look at the UN definition, I did. How many know the PLO/PA leader Abbas earned his PhD equivalent in Moscow at a Marxist university with a thesis comparing Zionism to Nazism.
@@nuqwestr people who call themselves 'chosen' is thecsame as ub€rm€nsch and these zionists also want l€bensraum at the expense of people they call human animals. So Abbas was not wrong at all.
@@nuqwestrObviously don't know the criteria for genocide of you talking about Palestinian increased population 😂. Just Israeli propaganda
The elephant in the room that can't be ignored is that only Jon Leibowitz can say such truths. Everybody else would pay an immense price and nobody is willing to pay such a price.
I pictured john lovitz while reading that
@@banquetoftheleviathan1404 it STINKS!
Hence those heads of the Ivy League schools - their heads rolled for similar or less.
You’re right, I honestly forgot he is Jewish and I remember when the Fox news reporter was ridiculing him for his grandfather I think changing his last name I am not certain I can’t remember
The criminals need to be stopped and brought to justice. The people need to be saved and compensated for their suffering.
His segment about his dog Dipper passing was pretty emotional, much respect to him for showing that much vulnerability.
Right!
So sad but real
I had a dog from my age 10 to 25
She lived 15 years a very long fair life for a dog
But when she passed I was devastated
Still miss her
Best friends you'll ever have dogs are
My "that dog" passed 3 years ago. I wept with him. I still mourne my girl, I cannot possibly fathom what the palestinians mourne.
He has always been a huge animal lover
I have a rule steer away from people who don't like animals especially the ones who don't like dogs and cats
@@diggerman00007 Meto. I have a similar rule
I love the moans of pleasure Kyle has when Stewart makes a good point lol.
Except of course to the Israel Palestinian discussion lol he said it's "BoTh SiDsEy" when it's a practical discussion on how to move forward and Kyle is upset because he gave both views for the audience to ponder instead of just giving the Palestinian only a mouth piece kyle is a fraud now.
Except of course when it comes to John's segment with an Israeli and a Palestinian he whines because he gave two views for the audience to ponder and because it wasn't a Palestinian fluff job Kyle is a fraud now
Kyle is a fraud now he won't cover johns segment with debate between an Israeli and a Palestinian on how to move forward instead of grandstanding . He said it's "BoTh SiDeSey" because he gave the audience two views to ponder and is whining because its not a Palestinian fluff job 🤣
😂😂😂❤❤KYLE is a living legend❤
There is something quite wrong with you, man!!
Absolutely agree re: the brilliant humanist, Jon Stewart.
US not only complicit, enablers is more correct, as suppliers of arms.
#METO Middle eastern treaty organization - lets get it going ✌️
Love it!!❤
Gamal Abdel Nasser Hussein tried that, it didn't work, and TE Lawrence made it clear why it won't work. "So long as the Arabs fight tribe against tribe, so long will they be a little people, a silly people - greedy, barbarous, and cruel, as you are."
Sure, let's get the Hashemites and the House of Saud together, or the other medieval principalities and tribes together. LOL
Middle Easterners hate each other. Them hating each other is kind of why we are in this situation right now.
@@nuqwestr or we could just act like you and never try anything right? Just never attempt anything positive cuz there's always reasons not to.
@@MadameCasperthe Arab league exists, and it's useless, basically a paper tiger which wags the tails to western interests, I see no way the Arabs are gonna form a middle East treaty organisation unless they break free from foreign control and finally act as United
Been railing at all the 'hosts' who have been too cowardly, to even allude to this slaughter of Palestinians, for months, and insisting that Jon Stewart would have had the gonads. He didn't let me down. BTW, Huge respect to John Oliver, for speaking out so early. I'd like to see him revisit the topic.
Cue John Stewart being called anti-semitic in 3...2...1
And of course “self hating Jew” as well. They have no morals or qualms demonizing their own if they dare step out of line and stand for justice or truth.
Ben Shapiro, the "pope of Jews" as Sam Seder puts it
@@soulshine8531 and who would 'they' be?
Zionists @@ink1775
This is significant from Jon Stewart because it's a show that's being watched by millions of millions audience, they maybe laughing but they are also being informed. Satire has always been the enemy of truth, it's harder for the enemy to get angry with such a thing because of its comedic, playful nature. Voltaire used this too as his main weapon.
Which Voltaire writing have you read?🙄
Voltaire held no power.
@@nuqwestr The OP is clearly trying to appear smarter and it didn’t work 🙄😆
Thanks for explaining how satire works, professor. No one knew that
Nowadays you find more truth in satire than the mainstream news media. Sad but true
Jon Stewart for Prez.
Too bad he's already said no thanks.
Hes too smart to want the job
JON STEWERT LOVES WARS THO.. HE SUPPORTS THE MILITARY HARDCORE
@@jonlee580 you should support the military
Jon Stewart is a national American treasure
God bless you, Jon!!!!!
I hate this world.
Stop watching the news mdude. No need to harm yourself, it doesn't help anything.
This world hates itself!!!
@@JassZoigelNow why didn't I think about that solution. Oh right, BECAUSE IT IS NOT A SOLUTION YOU DUMMY!!!
hate the assholes in this world. Not the world.
Stewart's timing of return and gravitas is actually going to move the needle and I think he knows it now
Thats what I love about Stewart. He knows he will be called a self hating Jew and he just doesn't give a flying FUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Gotta admire the guy even if you don't like him.
Even if hamas released the hostages there would still be thousands of Palestinians, including women and children, in Israeli prisons with no charges which is probably why there are hostages in the first place.
False, Taqiyya
@@nuqwestr
It's true. Even Israeli newspapers have reported on the huge amount of minors being detained. Rejecting this fact because it is inconvenient to you is despicable.
@@fluidthought42 Minors are under a certain age. The USA also "detains" minors, as does Europe. In the USA minors may be tried in court as an adult depending on the crime. Are you saying Israel should be held to a different standard? I never said minors were not detained, but ask what ages?
In 2000, voters in California passed what is known as Proposition 21 or The Juvenile Justice Initiative. The initiative was meant to curb the high incidents of juvenile crimes, especially related to gang activities. Under the law, a prosecutor can decide to try you as an adult even if you are under 18.
@@nuqwestr
Israel's detention of minors, women, et al. without prosecution and charges and with accompanying abuse and inhumane conditions cannot be tolerated. Those conditions cannot be tolerated no matter how widespread they are, no one is entitled to commit injustice.
Also, you're lost if you think this audience is one that is sympathetic to the policies of mass incarceration like that 2000 California Prop. We are consistently opposed to it no matter where it is being committed (and we are aware that the US is a major perpetrator for the practice of mass incarceration). So uh, switch up your style if you want to propagandize better, bud.
@@fluidthought42 Understood, you have a universal belief in a social justice dogma and don't single out Israel. Glad to hear it.
Insane how entitled the US has made Israel.
Not to veto would also be a great idea.
Agreed, it would be a good start. USA racking up a huge amount of worldwide resentment which no amount of aid (bribes?) will wash away.
Other step: empower ICJ, and international law, by eliminating veto vote from world powers.
Based
Jon is the only person who talks about the Palestinian “RIGHTS”
Not Steven Cobbler,
Not fallen,
Not Seth Meyer
Not kimmo
Not main media ABC, CBS n NBC
Shame, Shame, shame
As a Muslim Texan, I absolutely respect and value this show which I recently made aware of. Stay sharp.
On point. Many Thanks for that & your courage. In these times it has become very hard to be human and to uphold basic values.
Is there any clear evidence that the US actually said anything to Israel leadership directly about limiting civilian casualties? If so, did they say it like they meant it or was there a wink and a nod while they said stop the killing of women and children.
Loved it. Nobody is fair or even humane in the US media.
Your correct that Jon’s coverage was both sidey but saying that it’s at least better then the mainstream corporate news coverage, is a low bar you must admit Kyle!😐
At the moment I live in Cairns Australia; with Israel being more careful and surgical we have begun taping our windows and preparing an evacuation plan.
This is a very powerful video. 💪
Thank you!
I was once asked what I thought of Netanyahu?
I said, "I was sorry that he was dead".
They said, "No, he is not dead"!
I replied, "He should be"!
I enjoyed the Rosenberg and Hussain interview. These guys work together, literally to end the hate and violence in the Middle East. Sometimes a ‘both sides’ interview is not the worst thing to watch
Jesus Christ, thank you! Kyle doesn’t want to hear any side except for Palestine side. He cherry picked John Stewart, segment showing how Hamas is it interested in peace either.
The point about the Arab League not being ideal mediators was a good point, but the conversation talked around the idea of UN intervention and framed the ides of US occupation TO PREVENT GENOCIDE as unworkable. People wanted to pull out of Afghanistan because there were no achievable goals and the methods used towards them were abhorrent (like NYT covered about the vets who were disciplined for trying to speak out about). I don't care if it's a US mandate, UN mandate or a mix thereof: the current Israeli and Gazan governments have proven unable to function without resorting to mass violence. Outside intervention was needed a long, long time ago.
“Weeks away from completion” said Putin before invading Ukraine
Putin might be right (God forbid) unless the USA and NATO up their game appreciably.
I appreciate all you do Kyle!!!
The man on one hand brings sorrow, this isnt a laughing matter. On the other hand, he very well points out not only the ludicrous nature of the conflict. But offers SANE solutions. The greatest method is mockery. Narcissists ( Netanyahu ) detest being humiliated, mocked, embarassed. So. Thank you for your efforts to correct the record. God Bless Gaza.
"Don't massacre seven people with that (weapons) could you keep it to three!" You nailed that point to the wall!
Greetings from Scotland .. BDS apartheid Israel .. Free Palestine!
The truth of our politics lies in the risks we refuse to accept.
We don't deem war intolerable.
The US needs to stop giving Israel 3 billion a year.
Easier said than done. Well done, Mr. Know it all!
A few observations:
1. Netanyahu is not delusional. Hamas is. This is why. When you benefit from your delusions it is very most likely political strategic thinking geared towards self advantage and highly calculated rather than something out of your own control. When Netanyahu said the mission is only weeks within reach not months he is buying time. Hamas is delusional because their way of thinking is doing massive damage to themselves and their own people. There is nothing strategic and intelligent about this. If they are not acting against their own interest then the bare minimum is they are acting against their own people's interest. Netanyahu is not acting against his interest or his own people's interest. Why? He is winning and the cost on his side is very low at least in the immediate and short term but that's the best you can do as nobody has a crystal ball.
2. 7:49 "Israel stops bombing, Hamas releases the hostages". Wrong order. Hamas releases the hostages, Israel stops bombing. Hamas surrenders unconditionally, the war ends immediately. Fixed it for ya John!
3. It is delusional or at the very least a fantasy anyone thinking the government of Israel should be tried for war crimes. Not even Hamas' leaders will be tried for war crimes. The international system including international law is Mickey Mouse law. That's why more often than not states resort to what is called "self-help". Let's be realistic!
4. It is delusional to call it a genocide. The population of the Gaza Strip is nearly two and a half million people. The Hamas figures for the casualty of what the IDF is doing now, with an impartial observer being very generous accepting such figures, is around 40,000 deaths (made a lot worse by Hamas using civilians as human shields) with a very substantial number of that figure includes the death of Hamas terrorists and their accomplices. Israel is doing a very bad job if that is their attempt at genocide. Everyone knows they can do a much better job if they want to but the willingness to be genocidal is not there (i.e wiping out all Gazans or at the very least to kill as many as humanly possible). That ratio, while on its own is horrific, relative to other major conflicts in the past such as WWI, WWII, Vietnam War, Iraq War etc. the human toll in Gaza in terms of ratio to the entire population and military targets struck is less terrifying. If Hamas releases all hostages as well as unconditionally surrenders and then Israel continues the bombings and killings of innocent civilians then that would be a much much better argument for genocide.
5. The parallels with the war in Ukraine is misguided if not foolish. Ukraine is a war between two sovereign nations members of the UN. You can negotiate to end this war. Hamas is not a nation let alone a sovereign one. It is a terror organisation and October 7 made it conclusive. It is also not simply a terror network like the IRA where the British government negotiated with. Hamas is a religious terror network in the same vein as ISIS, Al Qaeda, Boko Haram etc. This means you cannot negotiate with Hamas as any political pundit knows negotiating with terror organisations give them political legitimacy. At the bare minimum you cannot formally negotiate with them even if the inevitable hypocrisy in politics mean you can or may have to do so informally behind closed doors. The bombings give Israel in this type of negotiations leverage such as they'll say "we will stop bombing but you gotta release all hostages" or else there are no bargaining chips to play on the negotiating table.
6. Hamas is a religious terror network that means it's political aspirations are intertwined with religious motives. The ostenstible political aspirations may be territorial but its inevitable religious motives like any other religious organisations are global as mandated by their sacred texts. Either Israel do the dirty work now dealing and eradicating them or the West and the rest of the world would have to do so later in the future if this malignant tumor is not removed now.
7. October 7 atrocities were unique in its barbarity as no civlised power would commit such atrocities in that manner. They were planned, highly calculated as well as executed with intentionally sadistic horrifying deeply personal evil of the medieval type. Not your average collateral civilians death in any conventional war or armed conflict. What was done to defenceless babies, children, women, the elderly and the like such as genital and private parts mutilation, beheadings, rape in front of loved ones, burnings of people alive, necrophilia, the taking of hostages of children, women and the elderly etc are proof of a wicked enemy of a particular religious type.
8. They hate us anyway regardless of what Israel or the West does or doesn't do. So why bother being nice without very significant trade offs such as the release of all the hostages and unconditional surrender. Give them an inch and they'll take a mile. Only those with delusions think being nice to them means them being nice to us. That was the mindset of the Jimmy Carter administration and Carter was taken for granted and taken for a ride.
Most of the 'facts' you give is just plain wrong. But refuting all......this...... is just too much labour, so I'm not gonna bother. Just the same ol' Hasbro word-vomit talking-points, even though most of it has already been debunked.
Hamas is evil, pathetic inhumane and demonic, but you seem to suggesting that IDF can push upto 99% of what Hamas is doing and are self-righteous defenders of their people. Isreal has every right to defend itself from Hamas but that does not mean they get a free pass to conduct destruction on Palestinians. Their response doesn't make them any less vile than Hamas. Hamas is a fundamentalist terrorist group they cause destruction and should be stopped, everybody can also agree on this, but Isreal is a sovereign "democratic" country they are expected to act rationally and morally with care for human life what they're doing is not close to the best possible response. Isreal has failed to destroy Hamas or even considerably deal any damage that too with shockingly high "collateral damage". The disregard to life of Palestinians leads to people calling it a genocide. If they hold human shields and you shoot at them indiscriminately how does that make you any better than them shooting at civilian Israelis. Where do draw the line? Do you want to match your attack to that of a terrorist group?
Just like Israeli children died at the hands of Hamas, Palestinian children have died at the hands of IDF.
The main problem with how Israel is grossly responding itself and the justifications for the said response not with the right of Israel to defend itself. Most people cry for Israeli as well as Palestinian children, women, men and elderly who have been claimed as collateral damage for this war which isn't yielding any good. You can read all the comments here, except for a negligible retard few, are sympathizing for Palestinians and NOT Hamas.
Israeli lives matter, similarly Palestinian lives matter. Hamas does not have a reason or right to hurt civilians, similarly neither does Isreal.
Israel propaganda. Nothing more. Not worth reading
Imagine putting so much energy into defending a genocide. History will not judge you well.
@@dijikstra8 I will win. It is written in the Book. Their own Holy Book admits the children of Israel has right to the land forever granted by their God. Now I wonder which land that is that they mentioned in their own sacred text that is the homeland of the children of Israel? LOL That's what happens when religious nuts are selective in which verses they use. Tonnes of verses either expressly or implicitly accept the land belongs of the children of Israel but of course they never quote it as it destroys their narrative the Jews stole their land in 1948. Go Google "children of Israel" in their Book. It might or might not change your view but facts don't care about people's feelings!
1) Haifa Massacre 1937
2) Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3) Haifa Massacre 1938
4) Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5) Haifa Massacre 1939
6) Haifa Massacre 1947
7) Abbasiya Massacre 1947
8) Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
9) Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
10) Jerusalem Massacre 1947
11) Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
12) Jaffa Massacre 1948
13) Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
14) Jerusalem Massacre 1967
15) Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
16) Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
17) Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
18) Jenin Refugee Camp April 2002
19) Gaza Massacre 2008-09
20) Gaza Massacre 2012
21) Gaza Massacre 2014
22) Gaza Massacre 2018-19
21) Gaza Massacre 2021
22) Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing. There were 21 documented oct7’s done to the Palestinians, leading up to “oct7”
israel should be dissolved, or moved to Uganda. Sorry Uganda, you probably don’t want any more genocidal maniacs living inside your borders 🙏🏼
I don’t blame you!
Thank You
Thank you so much for this
Correction, it has been October 7 for the Palestinians for about 70 years.
Good attempt at what needs to happen Kyle - More discussion and debate needed on this.
In the face of horror, i needed a laugh. Thank you Jon ❤
Thank for all your work towards peace in the Levant
Don't forget Turkey's support for Gen-0-cide in Ethiopia.
They say honesty is the key to great comedy. Jon Stewart is a gem.
Im jealous of Jon : Smart, attractive,funny, good moral compass, witty as fuck, rich. How can you luck out like that ?
I loved watching Jon Stewart's signature form of political and social satire. So nice to have him back ... Mondays.
Great reporting!
Thank God for you guys!!
This is so sad . The killing of women and children. Calling the killers victims is also sad..
I'm a first time subscriber. Glad you popped up on my feed 👍
This is a fight to the death.
Geat observation Sir, I salute 🫡 you
Thank you
If your journalism is eliciting outrage from the elite then you're doing your job.
Thanks!
I watched the original video on there yt page، But you made many points clear. It is good that the video appeared to me when I was researching the topic
good job. keep up the good work brother with your videos
METO is catchy…
Brilliant presentation
6:00 It’s like Hilliary Clinton telling Wall Street “ Hey! Cut it out!”.
Bengavotrich sounds like a lovecraftian shambling horror
Bravo. Thank you🎉
Well done
Stewart is a hero. How about hos Congressional hearings about 9/11 victims. I've got to see him live. Kyle I'd love for you to sit in or join in in his shows. Please
I have always said that the Saudis and Kuwaitis, etc. to step in to help the Palestinians, but the fact is that they don't care about the Palestinians.
Thank you Kyle 👍
I hope Stewart will get Bassem Youseff on the show. He's incredible, especially on the Palestine issue!
So great!❤
He does everything that you claim, but you forgot to mention, he makes us laugh!❤
You s good man, keep up the good work
kyle has offered the best solution to end this crisis , you are really a good man and you have such a great analysis always , thank you so much for your voice and your efforts
Video title or explanation?
@@JassZoigel he gave his opinion about what to do in the end of the video and i agree with him
@stephanmoris2515 I didn't hear a solution, I heard another condemnation of Israel and the US should isolate them. He also misunderstands loac, every member of hamas who operates around civilization clears Israel of War crimes, while also making themselves guilty of them, so there would be far more hamas being charged.
@@JassZoigel what are you talking about israel = nazi germany we all know that
@@JassZoigelthey keep deleting my comments
I watched the original, before this so I could concentrate on Kyle and I loved his reaction. Both Jon Stewart and Kyle Kulinski are so very reasonable about this.
Agree. Was pleasantly surprised that Jon was even allowed to say that. Talk about totalitarianism!
🥰 John Stewart! 🥰 you, too! You’re doing a great job! Appreciate your relevance.
Perfectly said, peace through justice.
Good show.. 🙌🏾🇿🇦
So glad that you're back to The Daily Show. Your talent in exposing social injustices through humor is food for the soul! Thank you!
Brilliant 👏 thanks
God bless you for showing compassion for the underdogs