I commented on the WIP version but i forgot to on the finished version. This is really cool! I love how you interpreted the quirks of the older Peanuts animations in your take. We definitely had more trouble making Charlie and Lucy work as their artstyle was harder to replicate and also make look clean and vibrant. I think this take will satisfy people who were hoping for something sketchier like the old shorts/comics. Thanks again for doing this and congrats on 30k views!
Minor details and stuff 1. 0:24 Was my favorite shot to animate I loved doing the bomb transition 2. Was considering animating Cartman in his show’s style for the final scene but I figured I should get more practice with that style first 3. Speaking of that style, Kanye West is the first ever South Park character I’ve animated (he flips the camera off but the blur transition kinda hides it) 4. I used as much traditional smear framing I could 5. Cartman gets angrier throughout the entire video, he wouldn’t just stand there after being fat shamed and called out for his actions! 6. Charlie fidgets with his fingers when talking about racism, because I feel like that would be a sensitive topic for him 7: Charlie was originally supposed to kick the Muhammad Censor like a football but I didn’t want to reveal Lucy before her verse 8: Feel free to ask more questions in the replies! I’d love to hear critiques or other such things
I definitely like this animation alot better, the ball transitioning into a bomb to represent the line was really good! I just wished the part at 0:37 was animated as well but I suppose it's fair
@IyeDeeKay Fair enough, I just felt like alot could've been done with that bit so it was slightly disappointing, but overall I love the work and I can't wait to see more from you! ^-^
@@myguitarisinmymind that’s exactly why I remade the animation! No disrespect to the animator but it wasn’t as accurate to the source material as the Eric segments
I like this one better. The OG did this weird thing with the mouths and I’m glad you fixed it. I also like all the details you added like Charlie going to kick the football
I commented on the WIP version but i forgot to on the finished version. This is really cool! I love how you interpreted the quirks of the older Peanuts animations in your take. We definitely had more trouble making Charlie and Lucy work as their artstyle was harder to replicate and also make look clean and vibrant. I think this take will satisfy people who were hoping for something sketchier like the old shorts/comics. Thanks again for doing this and congrats on 30k views!
Thank you so much! It truly is an honor to hear such kind words from you!
here before any other replies
Same@@urlocalsonicfanlol
@badlydrawnsonic yep
@badlydrawnsonic yes it is
to me, this is better just because the side profiles and arms appear like they did in the original shows and comics
@@BudHud thanks!
Yeah, as much as I love the original the side profiles did look kinda weird
@@thefeintnetwork5429he also had long sleeves in some parts for some reason
The Line "You're So Insecure That You Need Blanket Statements" Will Always Hit Different
I love how theres less movement in this version, accurate to how classic peanuts specials are animated
Glad you caught on to that! Believe it or not this was intentional!
Minor details and stuff
1.
0:24 Was my favorite shot to animate
I loved doing the bomb transition
2.
Was considering animating Cartman in his show’s style for the final scene but I figured I should get more practice with that style first
3.
Speaking of that style, Kanye West is the first ever South Park character I’ve animated (he flips the camera off but the blur transition kinda hides it)
4. I used as much traditional smear framing I could
5. Cartman gets angrier throughout the entire video, he wouldn’t just stand there after being fat shamed and called out for his actions!
6. Charlie fidgets with his fingers when talking about racism, because I feel like that would be a sensitive topic for him
7: Charlie was originally supposed to kick the Muhammad Censor like a football but I didn’t want to reveal Lucy before her verse
8: Feel free to ask more questions in the replies! I’d love to hear critiques or other such things
Are you gonna Make a Lucy animation?
@@griffgrig yes! But it will take a while!
@@IyeDeeKay take all the time you need
@IyueDeeKay u cant rush art
The best part is the fact that snow day is referenced is something I wish was in the original
The artstyle actually looks like charlie brown, good job!
Just an idea for Lucy’s verse I think that at some point she should make cartman do the, classic football trick
The animation is generally so smooth dude, you did a great job!! Hope this blows up! 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥
Same! And TYSM!
This is great. I’ve seen a lot of the peanuts cartoon and this seems very reminiscent to the original design. Nicely done.
Omg yes! this looks so much better
This is awesome
You got the art style spot on!!
The original animation is great but this captures the Peanuts style so well
This is amazing ngl
Sometimes, this feels a Bit Stiff, But It’s Still pretty good!
I definitely like this animation alot better, the ball transitioning into a bomb to represent the line was really good! I just wished the part at 0:37 was animated as well but I suppose it's fair
@@YippeeYah Yeah, that critique is fair, I got a little lazy at the end. Trust me, I’m gonna try harder with Lucy’s verse
@IyeDeeKay Fair enough, I just felt like alot could've been done with that bit so it was slightly disappointing, but overall I love the work and I can't wait to see more from you! ^-^
Nice animation!
this is awesome!! the way they did the side profiles in the original made me angry lol
agreed like im sorry to the artist that did the charlie segments but oh my god
@@myguitarisinmymind that’s exactly why I remade the animation! No disrespect to the animator but it wasn’t as accurate to the source material as the Eric segments
This is so beautiful bro never stop animating. Subscribed
BRO COOKED EVEN BETTER THEN CARTMAN COOKING HIS DAD🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
Im your 100th sub and i was actually gonna animate some parts of Cartman cool stuff bro
This is so good!
That video was out for only 2 weeks, this is awesome
This is actually smooth af bro, and it looks alot more like the original peanuts style!
You deserve more views than this, this is cool!!
@@sonictheSPINDASHER2022 thank you!
Dude this is a masterpiece
I like this one better. The OG did this weird thing with the mouths and I’m glad you fixed it. I also like all the details you added like Charlie going to kick the football
@@allison122477 thank you!
This is awesome!!!
THIS IS SO GOOD
11/10, one thing tho; I recommend making cartman eyes black instead of white for next animation (love the animation)
AMAZING
BEAUTIFUL!!!
damn your good at drawing charlie brown
@@urlocalsonicfanlol :3
This Is so cool!
I was so disappointed with the way they animated Charlie Brown in the original. But this is PERFECT 💯
Thank u!
Accidently clicked
Did not regret
Amazing
Epic
Why is the start fire all ready
really cool
Muy bien está perfecto 👌 😊
Most underrated animator ever
@@DinoboyProductions865 TYSM!
Dude I love this part 0:22 this is better than the og
Underrated
Cool
eddie gotta see this shit on god
PORQUE NO ESTA EN TENDENCIAS!
This is better
LET THEM COOK
Minnesota Rap!
Where's the color?
@@ZayvellBoissiere-xv7vh It’s unlikely that I’ll give this animation color, but I could try
@IyeDeeKay please try, or I'm un-subscribing 🟥🟧🟨🟩🟦🟪
Hol up let h cook
The original one sucked so this is good
I think the original was still pretty good!
CHARLIE BE SPITTIN BARS! (I haven't watched the full video yet)
this is awesome!!!