TIMESTAMPS: Intro + Disclaimer 0:00 10th place 0:13 9th place 1:07 8th place 1:54 7th place 2:57 6th place 4:20 5th place 5:54 4th place 7:22 3rd place 🥉 9:15 2nd place 🥈10:53 1st place 🥇 12:38
Thank you for your comments. But to alot of voters they can't see what are criterias that make an idol. They vote according to favourites, looks, patriotism or follow the crowd. Actually their latest ranking some shouldn't be there. While some should be there aren't there. 😅😂😢
I’ve waited so long to watch this video, because I was afraid that I’d violently disagree with the majority of your takes (sorry, my prejudice is based on previous experience lol) but I’m pleasantly surprised, and agree with almost everything! Thanks!
I actually didn't notice Doha atfirst maybe because of lack of screen time and he kinda introverted person but onstage he is a beast he transform into a great performer his raspy voice Wow shocked me. Again and Again performance not being biased but most of my picks are on that team but like what you said they have different charms that people will captivate their performance. From the intro guy (Hangyul) to the first line member (Lingqi) to the voice style of Donghwa argggg though Zai rap was unstable but Hong Sungmin served it powerfuly and Ziheng visual arrgg. All of them individually are eye catching members. Anyway SungMin and Lingqi biased plus F4, plus Minjae and Doha + Hikari. Woah too many talented that makes me hard to vote....
Thank you so much for sharing this. I like how you give as fair of a review as possible, and review them with the standard of an idol rather than trainees, as that is what we are looking for! (Ahem some voters…)❤❤ look forward to your review for the 2nd stage! I agree for a lot of this video especially your comments for the top 2!! For me though, a 3rd place ranking for the How You Like That stage was too high. I do agree with what you said, but in my opinion the girlypop vibe was CRUCIAL for the delivery of that stage, and that was totally out of the window… This is just my opinion though😂 I have also began to notice people like jeongwoo and yoojun who are truly so skilled, but the only problem for me was that I couldn’t remember their faces 😭 I guess for me nothing in particular abt them really stood out (like their face??). To be fair I didn’t even notice lingqi the first few times I watched the Again & Again stage (i am now obsessed) until I noticed the high note and I was like WTH how could I miss this!? 😭 anyway maybe some other trainees that aren’t as noticeable now will grow on me,, so thank you for pointing them out here 🙏 There are a few other trainees that I feel like have much more potential than shown in these stages so I hope to see in the next stage. Again thanks for sharing your review ❤ ~
It def has something to do with the screen time distribution. Iqiyi is obviously pushing some members and jeongwoo,lingqi(in recent eps, maybe), yoojun are not pushed as much as other trainees like sunjiayang, yoo gwanwoo, and shao ziheng
@@yodatea8073 Happy you are able to see and evaluate those boys talent. Examples like Ling Qi. But the present ranking of Ling Qi is pretty bad way down. We worry we may loose him a talented young man.
ok but like we had the same thoughts for Again & Again and boom boom bass being 1st but if I said that I would get dragged for saying it. But I think most of the reason why it was better was because like you said both teams are really good in terms of skills but as an idol there should be more to bring to the table and I think everyone in Again and Again really embodied that. It seemed like they know exactly how to catch the audience’s attention. To be honest if this whole team + Junhyuk debut I wouldn’t be mad lol. They really suit this concept that now I kind of want the debut team to have a mature concept which is appropriate bc they’re not relatively young. I’m curious on your thoughts on what concept you want the debut team to have.
Although i love noise music i feel like its getting rlly redundant recently, im hoping for a more mature group that has less repetitive lyrics. Would love to see more suits/formal wear kind of concept in kpop.
I’m start watching the show by Hangyul and then I got jump by Yang Donghwa on this stage (I’m glade he changing the hairstyle. It’s even look like different person for me) The only regret I have is the moment when Zai made a mistake, because I truly believe this performance had the potential to become legendary stage. Many people (myself included) would have rewatched it hundreds of times and revisited it for at least the next 4-5 years [on the same level as iconic performances like Sorry Sorry, Sangnamja (SS2) Boss, Love Shot (PDX) Kill This Love, and Love Me Right (BP)]. Unfortunately, everyone will likely keep noticing Zai’s mistake over “AGAIN AND AGAIN”, which is such a shame because this performance was so close to being perfect. But, it’s not a big deal, because while other teams delivered performances at 100%, the Again and Again team delivered at 200%. Even if you deduct 50 of their score due to Zai’s mistake, this team would still be Top ahead of the others. So, their 1st place finish is absolutely well-deserved!
I’ve been avoiding this video for ages because I was worried it would disagree with me and I’d get mad. But this is literally what I think about everything down to Sun yinghao’s vocals and Shao ziheng’s lacklustre performance. I’m so happy someone agrees with me about Han Jeongwoo I’m so worried for him T_T
was it really necessary to rank junho that low just for his facial expressions tho? and btw onsite recordings audio quality are way worse because its recorded by a worse device so pointing that out for donghwa was a little unnecessary as well tbh
how was junho ranked low? I have nothing against him i thought everyone above minjae did better(which ofc u can disagree). I just mentioned his facial expressions bc it was pretty much his only flaw( very big one in terms of stage presence tbh).
Also, for the onsite rec thing, Ill admit i criticized the wrong part abt yangdonghwa, it wasnt that specific adlib(although it still couldve been better) there was another line where his delivery was flat and was fixed for the broadcast. i still ranked him pretty high bc ik he can sing and i personally liked his performance anyways. ps. idk who cant differentiate bad audio quality and bad singing but its not me
TIMESTAMPS:
Intro + Disclaimer 0:00
10th place 0:13
9th place 1:07
8th place 1:54
7th place 2:57
6th place 4:20
5th place 5:54
4th place 7:22
3rd place 🥉 9:15
2nd place 🥈10:53
1st place 🥇 12:38
THIS VID IS SO FR bro namson and lingqi r so underated they both ate that up. PLEASE VOTE FOR THEM!!!
Yes please continue to vote for them especially Ling Qi. His present ranking is too low below and sad 😔.Thank you 😊❤
I FW WITH THIS VID SO MUCH RN
agree with literally everything u said esp abt doha
king was slaying the whole time
Thank you for your comments. But to alot of voters they can't see what are criterias that make an idol. They vote according to favourites, looks, patriotism or follow the crowd. Actually their latest ranking some shouldn't be there. While some should be there aren't there. 😅😂😢
oh you ate so bad with this vid i fear. your opinion is so valid
This was actually super funny & enjoyed watching this! Pls make more starlight boys vids like this LOL 😂❤️
Completely agree with the ranking and why again and again was my fave even with the mistakes
finally someone noticed ivan cooking
this was a really good video i enjoyed it a lot
ok now i need the next mission ((bcause i love ur video))
i love lingqi sm
Crazy in the ending of each rank explanation goes so hard
I’ve waited so long to watch this video, because I was afraid that I’d violently disagree with the majority of your takes (sorry, my prejudice is based on previous experience lol) but I’m pleasantly surprised, and agree with almost everything! Thanks!
DOHA MENTION
Doha supremacy
Margarine instead of Butter 😅
Main vocalist not vocalling 😅
And now where cooked
I love your humor
I actually didn't notice Doha atfirst maybe because of lack of screen time and he kinda introverted person but onstage he is a beast he transform into a great performer his raspy voice Wow shocked me.
Again and Again performance not being biased but most of my picks are on that team but like what you said they have different charms that people will captivate their performance. From the intro guy (Hangyul) to the first line member (Lingqi) to the voice style of Donghwa argggg though Zai rap was unstable but Hong Sungmin served it powerfuly and Ziheng visual arrgg. All of them individually are eye catching members.
Anyway SungMin and Lingqi biased plus F4, plus Minjae and Doha + Hikari. Woah too many talented that makes me hard to vote....
@@Romyjohn14 at present example like Ling Qi's ranking is very bad. Worry we may loose a talented young man in this debut.
Thank you so much for sharing this. I like how you give as fair of a review as possible, and review them with the standard of an idol rather than trainees, as that is what we are looking for! (Ahem some voters…)❤❤ look forward to your review for the 2nd stage!
I agree for a lot of this video especially your comments for the top 2!! For me though, a 3rd place ranking for the How You Like That stage was too high. I do agree with what you said, but in my opinion the girlypop vibe was CRUCIAL for the delivery of that stage, and that was totally out of the window… This is just my opinion though😂
I have also began to notice people like jeongwoo and yoojun who are truly so skilled, but the only problem for me was that I couldn’t remember their faces 😭 I guess for me nothing in particular abt them really stood out (like their face??). To be fair I didn’t even notice lingqi the first few times I watched the Again & Again stage (i am now obsessed) until I noticed the high note and I was like WTH how could I miss this!? 😭 anyway maybe some other trainees that aren’t as noticeable now will grow on me,, so thank you for pointing them out here 🙏
There are a few other trainees that I feel like have much more potential than shown in these stages so I hope to see in the next stage. Again thanks for sharing your review ❤ ~
It def has something to do with the screen time distribution. Iqiyi is obviously pushing some members and jeongwoo,lingqi(in recent eps, maybe), yoojun are not pushed as much as other trainees like sunjiayang, yoo gwanwoo, and shao ziheng
@@yodatea8073 Happy you are able to see and evaluate those boys talent. Examples like Ling Qi. But the present ranking of Ling Qi is pretty bad way down. We worry we may loose him a talented young man.
3:27 ivan made such an amazing decision for the 2nd mission
Glad I’m not the only one noticing Gunwoo’s talent. Sad that K-netizens care more abt visuals (not that he is ugly or anything)
13:40 Sungmin was really amazing here, I love his rap parts
Again and again will always be first like theres no debate i fear
Bro must make a part for position battle to after ep 8
PLEASE RANK 2ND MISSIONS STAGES WHEN THEY ALL COME OUT I LOVED THIS VIDEO
pentor and eden carried SO HARD
3:00 I always get goosebumps when I hear this intro
honestly, after this performance I really fell in love with XingXing’s vocals ❤️
ok but like we had the same thoughts for Again & Again and boom boom bass being 1st but if I said that I would get dragged for saying it. But I think most of the reason why it was better was because like you said both teams are really good in terms of skills but as an idol there should be more to bring to the table and I think everyone in Again and Again really embodied that. It seemed like they know exactly how to catch the audience’s attention.
To be honest if this whole team + Junhyuk debut I wouldn’t be mad lol. They really suit this concept that now I kind of want the debut team to have a mature concept which is appropriate bc they’re not relatively young. I’m curious on your thoughts on what concept you want the debut team to have.
Although i love noise music i feel like its getting rlly redundant recently, im hoping for a more mature group that has less repetitive lyrics. Would love to see more suits/formal wear kind of concept in kpop.
I agree but swap Sheesh with How u like that + BBB with again&again and thats my ranking
do more i actually enjoyed this
I’m start watching the show by Hangyul and then I got jump by Yang Donghwa on this stage (I’m glade he changing the hairstyle. It’s even look like different person for me)
The only regret I have is the moment when Zai made a mistake, because I truly believe this performance had the potential to become legendary stage. Many people (myself included) would have rewatched it hundreds of times and revisited it for at least the next 4-5 years [on the same level as iconic performances like Sorry Sorry, Sangnamja (SS2) Boss, Love Shot (PDX) Kill This Love, and Love Me Right (BP)]. Unfortunately, everyone will likely keep noticing Zai’s mistake over “AGAIN AND AGAIN”, which is such a shame because this performance was so close to being perfect.
But, it’s not a big deal, because while other teams delivered performances at 100%, the Again and Again team delivered at 200%. Even if you deduct 50 of their score due to Zai’s mistake, this team would still be Top ahead of the others. So, their 1st place finish is absolutely well-deserved!
I’ve been avoiding this video for ages because I was worried it would disagree with me and I’d get mad. But this is literally what I think about everything down to Sun yinghao’s vocals and Shao ziheng’s lacklustre performance. I’m so happy someone agrees with me about Han Jeongwoo I’m so worried for him T_T
ur video was fun and enternaining! love it! 😂😂
Subbed in case you make a part 2 for the next mission 😳😳
9:25 😂soooo true
ziheng forgot to sing part of his rap onsite too but they fixed it for brodcast
oh i didnt even realize that 😭 ig he must be a producer pick then
10:16 exacttttlllyyyy😂😂
Nam son se salvó!!!
I was literally overjoyed
do ha is not getting populer when he shouldddd
Perdimos a Yoshi 😢😢
wish he couldve stayed for longer😔
@DoodyC0rn4T3 same :(
15:21 what was that?
Hwanwoong? All of a sudden?😭
Tell me are you Oneus fan!!!!!!???
OMG FELLOW TOMOON??
@DoodyC0rn4T3 YASSSS!!!! Who's your bias? Do you have any channel about them or something? Let me follow you
@@JannatulFerdous-xg8pm bias is Hwanwoong and bias wrecker is Xion. I dont have a channel i jst started youtube this my first vid 😅
@@DoodyC0rn4T3 Good luck then
If you make videos regularly, make some about Oneus too and let me subscribe you.🥰
13:32 LMAOOO
Where did you find the HYLT onsite fancam?
it was doha's fancam
was it really necessary to rank junho that low just for his facial expressions tho? and btw onsite recordings audio quality are way worse because its recorded by a worse device so pointing that out for donghwa was a little unnecessary as well tbh
how was junho ranked low? I have nothing against him i thought everyone above minjae did better(which ofc u can disagree). I just mentioned his facial expressions bc it was pretty much his only flaw( very big one in terms of stage presence tbh).
Also, for the onsite rec thing, Ill admit i criticized the wrong part abt yangdonghwa, it wasnt that specific adlib(although it still couldve been better) there was another line where his delivery was flat and was fixed for the broadcast. i still ranked him pretty high bc ik he can sing and i personally liked his performance anyways.
ps. idk who cant differentiate bad audio quality and bad singing but its not me