yeah, but I accidentally saw on the other show, I think it is the SBS gayo daejun, his severe bald spots at the back of his head are still there, you can see it even clearly now that he grows his hair back. but I do see that it's getting better, I hope that he can fully recover this year coz him recovering means he's getting less stressed and that to us would be a great news ^_^
Only got allowed to have 25 melodies in the audience but fan chants are still on point... THANK U BTOB AND MELODIES FOR 2017 Cant wait for us to be more in love in 2018.
IM YHUMI Back injury.. he's temporarily halting promotion with the rest which in a way, I think, is a good thing since he's been so busy that he should/needs some sort of break
Omg guys, was it just me, who literally felt every lyrics fit maybe the unspoken message of Sungjae for Joy? 😭😭 because it felt that way tho. Esp Minhyuk's rap part. I'm crying rn with feels
i'm a gay for Park Soo Young and I love it your username is me, and girl yesss! That’s how I feel too and my sungjoy heart can’t take it 😭 I feel that way about so many of their songs :(
Although I don't stan BTOB, I actually really love this song and when I saw the lyrics I teared up a little. It made my heart warm when I saw the other groups singing and clapping with them😢❤
how i miss listen to ilhoon's rap in every btob song. each voice of the members complete the song. that is why btob's song have a unique and distinct vibe.
even when Eunkwang wasn't there, Changsub and Hyunsik had hard-carried the whole Movie song for him, singing all of his part Hyunsik ver : th-cam.com/video/StcgesC5kfw/w-d-xo.html Changsub ver : th-cam.com/video/Lr7KYBL9Mck/w-d-xo.html
Although I disagree with the "best vocals in kpop," (that's your opinion and it's totally fine), I would say, they have the best members. No blackhole. Anybody can fill anyone's parts easily. For the vocals, I'd say, they're one of the best. For me, there are some better vocalists, but BTOB's vocal line together is just too powerful. They compliment each other perfectly.
I really like this in BTOB , when a member is absent it is very easy to fill his place ! what a great group with a great vocal rang. but you can feel that sungjae aura is missing :(
i will always like this performance even though sungjae was not here. and when ilhoon cover sungjae's line? wow his voice, there's texture and color. i know ilhoon's the one who's singing it, around 3:04 because that's his voice. minhyuk's only the second voice that time. it's just so sad that he's not in btob anymore.
Peuni's pineapple head is the cutest! He looked more more handsome with that hairstyle i loooove it so much! Mochi's ankle finally healed. I hope it really healed and he didn't forced it. And it would be perfect if Sungjae's there. But it's okay. Let our maknae rest well and heal completely. I think our boys were super busy at the end of the year with concert, personal schedules, and year-ends performances. Hope there's no more injury/sick again after this. Please be healthy and happy, boys! Yejiapsa 💙
Can We Appreciate At 3:26 What Changsub Did there. he Sang Sungjae 's Strong part and Then Sang His Own Soft Part. Wow. It took me Over A Month to Notice That Awesome Thing. I need To Get My All Senses To watch BTOB Videos from Next time.
This is what you called Live..BTOB always sing live hoping for the other groups too..Its unfair that some groups can't sing live..They slayed again without Sungjae hyungsik and eunkwang coverd Sungjae parts.. Look how the other groups claps for them... Anyway Minhyuk how could you be that so handsome..
Not a fan of BTOB, but i love this song so much. N the vocals r on point. What captured me most is that they involved the audience (who mostly are the artists) to sing along with them as if it were their concert arena. BRAVO, BTOB. Love this performance 😍😍😍😍😍
Brings me that moment where they said: BTOB sell emotions not albums..😭😭 im crying.. Makes me emotional when, aside from melodies , other people are singing along with them...
i just heard this song yesterday AND OMG I HAVE BEEN SLEEPING ON BTOB ALL THESE WHILE. this song is GOLD omg and their vocals are on point. btob will go far im sure
BTOB is one of the few groups that can perform missing a member but no one would notice because everyone can adjust very well. The power of having almost everyone as vocal and rapper. Not to mention the trying hard rappers Sungjae and Eunkwang.
![[C.C.] Is CHANGSUB finally getting married?! #BTOB #CHANGSUB](/img/n.gif)
Minhyuk all of a sudden singing vocal 😍😍😍
he's technically part of the official vocal line, he's just not part of the vocal unit
aisyah #그리워하다 ???? I thought we all know that Minhyuk is btob hidden vocal? I just didnt expect him to be singing here too.
It so soothing ❤️
I expect him to take over sungjae part tbh Even in previous comeback, he always took over Sungjae part when Sungjae was absent
minhyuk is also vocalist since debut
Can we just, Peniel’s hair grew so much and it makes me so happy to know that he’s getting better!!!
yeah, but I accidentally saw on the other show, I think it is the SBS gayo daejun, his severe bald spots at the back of his head are still there, you can see it even clearly now that he grows his hair back. but I do see that it's getting better, I hope that he can fully recover this year coz him recovering means he's getting less stressed and that to us would be a great news ^_^
He should go to that hair treatment company Bosley. The commercials I've seen seem legit but I could be wrong...
아이돌 중에 젤 노래 잘함.. ㄹㅇ 라이브란게 말이 안 돼
인정이요 실력으로 내가수 깔사람 없어 ㅜㅜ
ㄹㅇ..
BtoB does not need props, just a mic and their voice and it still made you cry.
And Peniel hair is the cutest thing I ever seen😍🤗.
Which one is him ?
@@hobiworld2.030 the one who raps at 1:57
@@ephxphany2346 Ohokay thank u ❣️
Only got allowed to have 25 melodies in the audience but fan chants are still on point... THANK U BTOB AND MELODIES FOR 2017
Cant wait for us to be more in love in 2018.
hanafrei R u serious? Like seriously? Why?
what?? 25???seriously??? bt fanchanting was best..💙💙💙💙 melodies jjang 🙋🙋🙋🙆🙆🙆🙆🙆
hanafrei o my Really 🙄🙄??They had 2 performances still why only 25???
the place is smaller this time, but looks like they still have Melodies, audiences and other idols singing for them at the main part
That's crazy. How can a venue dictate how many fans for a group can come? That's crazy that u can put a number on it
가수이자 아이돌이자 아티스트라고 칭할 수 있는 거의 유일한 그룹
3:04 that's my rapper's vocals right there 😇
Its sungjae part right?
@@LINASHIN_ ilhoon sings his part here, since Sungjae was absent at that time
I was looking for this hahahahahaha
@@LINASHIN_ isn't it the bridge part where everyone harmonizes together? even the crowd always sing that part
I wish Sungjae was able to perform with them too but health comes first. I wish they could perform Movie too.
heyheyhey what happened to sungjae?
IM YHUMI Back injury.. he's temporarily halting promotion with the rest which in a way, I think, is a good thing since he's been so busy that he should/needs some sort of break
Seeing other idols singing along with BTOB 💙💙💙
Missing You is a masterpiece I tell you.
CJ Owseven indeed
진짜 비투비를 좋아한 지 얼마 되지는 않았지만 입덕한 게 제일 잘 된 선택이었다 노래로 깔 사람은 없다 진짜 까는 사람이면 사람이 아닐 정도임 진심...
Hyunsik's power never dissapoint me. BTOB is the real king of live performance💙
lol its exo
@@qingshanxuen7231 Nope, Both of them(BTOB & EXO) is Kings of Live performance❤
Fuu Namikaze lol get lost this abt btob . No hate i love exo too but your attitude a bit off
@@qingshanxuen7231 imagine going to btob's comment section to talk about exo. exo's not bad, but this is poor behaviour
역시 믿고 듣는 비투비
네
3:05 YAS MINHYUK FINALLY I CAN HEAR YOUR LOVELY VOICE
mcqel I can only hear ilhoon tho.
try listening to Minhyuk's recently produced song CHILDLIKE. You can hear his voice @ 2:34 ♥
mcqel isnt that ilhoon?
ilhoon first then minhyuk little
I thought it was ilhoon's and when i go over the vid again, its really minhyuk has the louder one than ilhoon's..
우리 창섭이 성재 몫까지 열심히 하네 ㅠㅠ 진짜 멋져
성재어디간거에요? 이때가 허리 다쳤을때인건가요?
@bigboss11y15y 허리 다쳤을때인 것 같아여
I love when other idols are singing together 😭😭😭 BTOB UNITE ALL FANDOMS~~\
Familyship it is 😭😭😭
One of the wonderful comment I've seen...
minhyuk just standing there with his hand on his waist, showing that veins while rapping is so so cool ~~
1. BTOB nailed by beautifully singing this song live.
2. I'm happy to see Peniel's hair :")
3. Seventeen singing along #heartexploded
라이브 레전드인 날 보고싶을때마다 본다ㅜ 이때 성재 없었던거 아쉽..
Omo Joy sing too💕 BTOVELVET forever!!
sadly Sungjae wasn't there
So sad.. finally after so many years rv & btob get to reunite.. but Sungjae isnt there
Omg guys, was it just me, who literally felt every lyrics fit maybe the unspoken message of Sungjae for Joy? 😭😭 because it felt that way tho. Esp Minhyuk's rap part. I'm crying rn with feels
i'm a gay for Park Soo Young and I love it your username is me, and girl yesss! That’s how I feel too and my sungjoy heart can’t take it 😭 I feel that way about so many of their songs :(
@@NazifaAnjum96 i think im the only one XD
3:06 -3:09 is the killing part!!!
Lee Minhyuk A rapper who has a golden voice. OMG he could be a guest in king of Masked singer.
Sungjae ya get well soon my baby BTOB OT7 forever ♥
letsbe rich BTOB what happened to him?
what happened to him?/2
He's injured
Restu Fitria S.A.W
He's resting for now because of a waist/back injury
Although I don't stan BTOB, I actually really love this song and when I saw the lyrics I teared up a little. It made my heart warm when I saw the other groups singing and clapping with them😢❤
BTOB always daebak when live perform, yook sungjae get well soon baby, we are missing you 😘😘😘
You’re Average Twice Fan 😂😂
how i miss listen to ilhoon's rap in every btob song. each voice of the members complete the song. that is why btob's song have a unique and distinct vibe.
I am out of breathe everytime Minhyuk sing 😍 💙💙 Kinikilig me 🙈
Get well soon baby maknae Sungjae ya 😘
Happy New Year BTOB and Melodies 💙💙
JOY WAS THERE TO WATCH THE PERFORMANCE, BUT SADLY SUNGJAE WASN’T THERE :”(
MBC always know how to slaying Bbyu shippers ❤️ Joy was singing Missing You, sadly Sungjae wasn't there. #GetWellSoonYookSungjae
Jul Julia exactly :( I'm sure they are also both missing each other ^_^ and we are missing BTOVELVET interactions :(
What happened to him back then? New melody here hehe
@@ellasegura6874 Sungjae was injured at the time
What happened to Sungjae ...he's not there
@@ariapark2095 He has back injury that's why he was not able to perform.
프니엘 개귀엽네ㅠㅠ 처음에 웃음참는거 ㅋㅋ ㅠㅠ
Minhyunk's rap part always make me go weak...😢😍
bb0mi ppang always
Yeah his voice I cant
Manager: Oh no. What to do, who will sing Sungjae part?
BtoB: Don't worry. Anyone will do. We are all vocals.
even when Eunkwang wasn't there, Changsub and Hyunsik had hard-carried the whole Movie song for him, singing all of his part
Hyunsik ver : th-cam.com/video/StcgesC5kfw/w-d-xo.html
Changsub ver : th-cam.com/video/Lr7KYBL9Mck/w-d-xo.html
Why was sungjae absent?
@@watch1394 may be shooting a drama
@@favellarafa9027 I see .. thanks for the info ☺️
@@watch1394 Sungjae was injured at the time
KINGS OF LIVE PERFORMANCE
Minhyuk oppa's voice ughhh 😍😍😍
btob is no doubt the king of vocals. *STAN TALENT STAN BTOB* 💙
They have the best vocals in kpop boy groups in my opinion.. Chang sub is just amazing vocals
True.
Although I disagree with the "best vocals in kpop," (that's your opinion and it's totally fine), I would say, they have the best members. No blackhole. Anybody can fill anyone's parts easily. For the vocals, I'd say, they're one of the best. For me, there are some better vocalists, but BTOB's vocal line together is just too powerful. They compliment each other perfectly.
Beautiful. Thank you Changsub Hyunsik for covering Sungjae 💙 Chimchim singing to 그리워하다 is refreshing!
I really like this in BTOB , when a member is absent it is very easy to fill his place !
what a great group with a great vocal rang. but you can feel that sungjae aura is missing :(
yeah.. Hope he'll get well soon.. Hope btob will take good care of themselves.. Amd wont stress out. They complete me...
btob: sorry we never learned how to lipsync or even use in ears :( hahahaha
hannahthecritter omo I just saw that they're not using in ears! Damn kings!!
if they wear it, it's fake because I believe they never turn it on
hannahthecritter no they used it once,,,, for every 1st performance
they use in ears but they take it off most of the time hahahaha
Sungjae even took off his in ear while singing for joy
다시봐도 인이어 안 끼는 거 너무 대박이야...
Everybody singing along BTOB made me emotional 😢
Most of The Other Idols were Crying In the End...reason may be anything but Missing you Impact was surely Deep. BTOB Kings 👑
minhyuk the hidden vocal of btob❤️ 7rappers 7vocals❤️😘
I miss him every time I listen to Missing you 😢. I miss our angel so much 😭😭😭😭
I can listen 1000 times without getting bored 😻😻😻😻😻
same lmao i really cant get tired of this song XD
Me too
Same 😍
jimin at 3:16 omoooo 💙💙💙 minhyuk's vocaaal is always the best 💙😭
Get well soon, Sungjae. Look how great your hyungs are. ♥
anabet ipsagel I am sure He Knows very Well 😀😀
what happened to sungjae?
Loriani93 hi is injured,,, hi was confined on 27 due to back pain 2 to 3 weeks of treatment,,,
i will always like this performance even though sungjae was not here. and when ilhoon cover sungjae's line? wow his voice, there's texture and color. i know ilhoon's the one who's singing it, around 3:04 because that's his voice. minhyuk's only the second voice that time. it's just so sad that he's not in btob anymore.
no, i think thats minhyuk at 3:04
@@jimired maybe but listen to the tone of that voice. Its like ilhoon's.
BTOB KING OF LIVE VOCALS!!!
Get well soon baby Sungjae.
Jungkook opened his mouth throughout this performance maybe because he was amazed on how brave Btob are to sing a song with choreography in a live..
Sungjae get well soon okay!
What happened to Sungjae?
Aurora Knutsen he suffered waist injury
Joyii Virus Sungjae got injury?
Joyii Virus how?
boy btob, winner and mamamoo saved this show by showing what live really is
hidden main vocal lee minhyuk forced to take things in charge during sungjae's absence lmao
CHANGnosia no,,, actually 3 of them replace sungjae's part
you must be fun at parties
said by someone who has an anime dp lmao
what's with toxicity in the replies? are you all melody?
Yasss
I don't know what I love more; BTOB? Melody? or BTOB and Melody? //hearteu
changsub singing sungjae's part i'm so soft
Seeing other idols clapping and singing with BTOB's Missing You is my favorite thing!!! This is one my reasons why i love kpop. ❤
no group can beat btob when it comes to live
rino rolo absolutely correct
BTOB are kings....
Agree at 100%
노래 너무 좋고요!! 잔잔하게 춤 조금씩 보여주는거 너무 좋네요!! 비투비 화이팅!!
Get well soon sungjae...changsubiee i am in love with your voice... BTOB fighting!!!
Peuni's pineapple head is the cutest! He looked more more handsome with that hairstyle i loooove it so much!
Mochi's ankle finally healed. I hope it really healed and he didn't forced it.
And it would be perfect if Sungjae's there. But it's okay. Let our maknae rest well and heal completely.
I think our boys were super busy at the end of the year with concert, personal schedules, and year-ends performances. Hope there's no more injury/sick again after this. Please be healthy and happy, boys! Yejiapsa 💙
Their comeback literally saved 2k17
ilhoon is so talented 😭 i keep sabotaging myself everytime im reminded he aint with btob anymore 💔
chanyeol face at the end "im shook"
Can We Appreciate At 3:26 What Changsub Did there. he Sang Sungjae 's Strong part and Then Sang His Own Soft Part. Wow. It took me Over A Month to Notice That Awesome Thing. I need To Get My All Senses To watch BTOB Videos from Next time.
This is what you called Live..BTOB always sing live hoping for the other groups too..Its unfair that some groups can't sing live..They slayed again without Sungjae hyungsik and eunkwang coverd Sungjae parts.. Look how the other groups claps for them... Anyway Minhyuk how could you be that so handsome..
Changsub too
Andreas Widjaja ah yeah changsub also.. Sorry thank u for correcting me
*hyunsik
Btob is always standing with their vocal love them so much, actually the group without lip sync is btob and mamamoo. Their vocal no hesitant
My life is incomplete
It’s Missing you SUNGJAE
I miss ilhoon 💙💙💙💙💙💙💙
Not a fan of BTOB, but i love this song so much. N the vocals r on point.
What captured me most is that they involved the audience (who mostly are the artists) to sing along with them as if it were their concert arena. BRAVO, BTOB.
Love this performance 😍😍😍😍😍
that's the concept of this album : singing together
that's why they named the album Brother Act, taken from Sister Act film
Helda Helda thanks, we Melodys are always happy when non fans notice BtoB vocals And charms
U should watch their concerts lol.. its like a choir since the fans sing the whole songs too especially when missing you and its okay is performed.
Brings me that moment where they said: BTOB sell emotions not albums..😭😭 im crying.. Makes me emotional when, aside from melodies , other people are singing along with them...
hanafrei i really wish i could...but i'm just into kpop, n i found these boys are so good. N this song is my fave...❤❤❤
first grup that i saw didnt wearing an earpiece.. daebak! they r singing live !! love btob !
they seldom wear it, if they wear it I think it is turned off
BTOB slayed as usual my kings. Happy new year BTOB & Melody ♥
minhyuk slaying 😍😍😍
sungjae😭
Its just so nice seeing other idols singing along💓 who says missing you doesnt deserve to be the song of the year?
This really their song of the year
Minhyuk sweet v0ice😘
THIS IS REAL TALENT
Sumpah ya amaze banget sama vocal btob. Dan baru tau ga pada pake earpiece. Gilaakkk kece
HERE'S TO GREAT 2018 FOR BTOB
i just heard this song yesterday AND OMG I HAVE BEEN SLEEPING ON BTOB ALL THESE WHILE. this song is GOLD omg and their vocals are on point. btob will go far im sure
its look like joy are singing for sungjae behalf
Lee MinHyuk haha ikr ! BtobVelvet
워매 라이브 실화냐
The fanchant. Their vocals. Other idols sang with them.
Wow! you guys made all melodies proud! 😄💙💙💙
섭이는 이날 미모 좡난아니었네요..유난히 더 뽀얘가지고 ㅎㅎ 라이브는 진심 오지구요~~
Gws sungjae .. and hyunsik covering part of sungjae so beautiful ♡ 😍😍😍😍
Putri handayani sorry nanya.
Sungjae sakit ? Atau apa
kina han iya.. cedera punggung.. dan musti istirahat 2-3 minggu kata nya 😔
Putri handayani ya ampun 😢😢
Gws sungjae😘
Makasih infonya putri
kina han moga sungjae bsa kembali sehat..gangguin abang2nya lagi.. huhu 😍
Sama sama..hehehe
Putri handayani iya.semoga secepatnya sembuh.
Hahaha iya kangen sama jail nya ,usilnya 😄😄😄
These young men look so stunning in black suit, their live vocals sounds so fantastic, especially Changsub's, his voice is just heavenly.
omg vocals are sooo on point!!! penile grwing his hair! im happy!! and, changsub looks so handsome in this
BTOB is one of the few groups that can perform missing a member but no one would notice because everyone can adjust very well. The power of having almost everyone as vocal and rapper. Not to mention the trying hard rappers Sungjae and Eunkwang.
ilhoon is also a trying hard vocal hahahahaha
Shayne Matsuda And Minhyuk Certified As Vocalist 😊😎😎
3:05 Minhyuk sing, so great!
Minhyuk's visual and vocal OMGG 😍
*BTOVELVET.*
JungKeulleeo sungjoy 😁
I wish sungjae was here.. Joyiahhh is watching
Hey! FM and joy was singing with them toooo 😍😍
Btob is one of those groups in which their voice change live but only to sound even more gorgeous ,I love their performances so badly 😍❤️
thank you seventeen supporting btob 💓
melody, myday & universe seventeen is like the biggest idol fanboys of btob out there!!lol
echan meikam I was going to say 😊😊
Ezabella Love 😄😄😄 especially mr.boo hahahaha
3:10 ?? that guy is nice, I remembered he was the first person who congratulated Eunkwang after BtoB first win
Andreas Widjaja yup those guys in white are seventeen! They adore btob so much!
Imagine making all other idol groups sing along with you, only BTOB
2:43 I was attacked by veins.
i am always attacked by minhyuk at that part but yesssss today we were attacked by veins 😂
Faiza yass my bias💕
My bias
Why???? I cant see
Lmfao
Peniels laughing cause eunkwang told him his mic was a little too tall kukukuku cute 0:15
Minhyuk looks really good there 💞💕
nureen salimee he always really good
He looks really good everywhere. :')
Peniel's hair!!! ♡
They performed so amazingly as always!
The real live performance. And the real art. Thank you btob. Thank you MBC.
성재야 보고싶다ㅠㅜ 푹 쉬고 빨리 나아서 와❤
AJSLSLQAJ I SPY WITH MY LITTLE EYE A PINEAPPLE NAMED PENIEL
Faiza LMAO
this made me think of taeyang's famous mohawk back in the days...it can be peniel's signature hairstyle now while he grows it out 😂
penielpple ?
Yuzu Gummy I love it 😂
Yuzu Gummy omg yasss
they have such boyfriendly-vibe voices i can't explain it